ykw this was half joking but like im serious, bc not only did the demographics change, but the content of my dashboard changed. i used to go out of my way to see more world news and social justice and intersectional politics. it used to be that tumblr was the main place I trusted to get that stuff from bc I knew it was probably at least coming from other marginalized ppl and more likely to be analyzed thru an intersectional lens. it was more likely for me to find local as well as global politics here, posts about the anti-trans legislation being pushed everywhere, and posts countering that with GOOD world news, places where we are making progress.
I didnt really change who i follow. I rarely follow someone new. I will here and there, a handful over the last few years, but a lot of who I follow are also other marginalized people who talk about this stuff. I go out of my way for this. This is how I have curated my dashboard since I was in high school. This blog is old enough to go to college btw. I have had this same blog since 2009.
But ONLY NOW am I seeing less and less and less of current events. Less protests. Less anti-capitalism, less ACAB sentiment.
I get more of that stuff from THREADS now. Do you hear me, Tumblr? Facebook is outpacing you when it comes to POLITICS, now. The website that admitted outright that it was manipulating you, lying to you, and experimenting on you just to see how much they could get you to click, just to see how much they could get into your head. The website that is fully transparent about how much it suppresses Mutual Aid requests and discussions of real world issues and current injustices. Fucking ZUCK'S website is doing better than tumblr right now? at the ONE THING we were known for, other than BEING GAY? Where the fuck am I???
And like yeah I just cant see it as "correlated but coincidence" that around the time I stopped seeing this stuff on tumblr, my following also got eerily quiet. No more anons, not even mean ones (even though I leave it on constantly). People respond to my OPs on occasion, but its much more rare than it used to be. NOBODY has given a bite on any ask games I have reblogged for SIX YEARS. Not a single response.
No I dont miss The Discourse(tm) but part of what made Tumblr a place that was WORTH coming back to for 17 fucking years is that it WAS a community. I survived off mutual aid and app referralls from my blog for years when I stopped being able to work, while I struggled to figure out why i was so sick. I used to have easily a dozen mutuals who logged on regularly and sent me asks, replies, etc. I used to log on every single day and see world and US news and current events, updates about Stop Cop City and other anti-imperialist efforts.
And yes, like, shit changed afte the porn ban. It did. This place was a ghost town for like, a year after that. But those of us who stayed kept it going and built it back up. I felt like there was a bit of a resurgence back in 2020/2021...
And ykw, specifically around the time that Renee Good and Alex Pretti were killed, that was when I started seeing a REMARKABLE amount of Fucking Nothing on this website. I BARELY even saw those two mentioned. Meanwhie, shit was POPPING OFF on Threads. People were fucking organizing over there, ON FACEBOOK, while the people on Tumblr posted about fandom shit.
It wasnt immediately after the porn ban that i saw this shift. It was recent. Until the last 6-9 months, I COULD still come to my dashboard and see all the stuff I worked so hard to curate here. I COULD count on coming to tumblr and seeing news about things like Minneapolis or events in Gaza here, first, before anywhere else. I could see videos of Bisan without having to go to Instagram.
Suddenly, I cant anymore.
So yeah I dont think its the porn ban demographic shift actually, I think tumblr is making a much more concentrated effort to either ban or suppress posts like this, and people who are likely to post them (yes! trans women and TPOC!!)... and to boost posts/blogs that post sheer vapid entertainment only.
Its like theyre trying REALLY hard to lean back into Tumblr being "the fandom website" and trying specifically to erase the kind of discourse and "SJW vibes" it used to be known for.
They are rebranding and trying to make Tumblr more palatable to normies, while normies on the fucking Zuck website are doing a better job of posting about politics.
This is so ass backwards idek what my point of this post is, its just wild to have been here this long and watched it change like this