The wolf he chose ||
CHAPTER 12 ||
VALARR TARGARYEN X FEM!STARK!READER
□ summary: With Valarr's confession still weighing on your heart, you find yourself caught between the feelings you cannot deny and the promises you made long ago. As the question of the betrothal forces you to confront what you truly want, the words of those closest to you leave you with a choice you never expected to make.
□ word count: 5k
□ tropes: slow burn, he fell first and harder, hurt-comfort, No use of y/n, no physical description of reader, reader is a badass and can fight, reader and valarr are adults.
□ warnings: afab reader, slight misogny, violence, death, cursing, mentions of blood and slight gore, reader has a direwolf, no beta read.
□ a/n: i am sooooo sorry for the delay again, to make up for it chapter 13 will be uploaded on the 18th, i have it written, and it just needs polishing and some additions :). Life just keep kicking my ass in one way or another. I got into a masters uni and had to move to a new city for it. It got chaotic real quick. Thank you for reading, enjoy 🫶🏼
Chapter 11
Series Masterlist
Discover my other works here
Valarr sat in his chambers with his head buried in his hands, the fire crackling softly in the hearth as he tried to calm his rapidly beating heart. His face was still flushed, his ears burning, and no matter how many times he took a deep breath, the heat refused to leave him. The reality of everything he had said to you in the corridor was finally settling in, piece by piece, and with every passing moment he felt more horrified with himself.
The way he had pinned you against the wall. The way you had let him get so close to you. The way he had poured every thought and feeling he had been keeping buried into words without even stopping to think. Gods, you were more than capable of hurting him. He had seen you fight. He had watched you cut down a knight twice your size without hesitation, yet when he had pinned you in that corridor, you had not struck him. You had simply stood there and listened while he made a complete fool of himself.
"Oh gods," Valarr groaned, squeezing his eyes shut as his own words came rushing back to him. "I am an idiot. A complete idiot. The Targaryen madness has definitely caught up with me."
He dropped his hands onto his lap and stared blankly at the fire.
He had prepared an entire speech for you. Something proper. Something befitting a prince. He had planned to explain why the match made sense politically, why you would be an excellent wife for him, how he would respect your duties and your family and never ask you to become someone you were not. He had rehearsed it in his head more times than he cared to admit.
But the moment you had looked at him with tears in your eyes and told him that what happened in the Godswood had been a mistake, all of it had vanished.
He had not thought, he had only seen you slipping away from him. The one thing his heart had desired, the one thing he had finally allowed himself to reach for, had suddenly been taken from his grasp. And something inside him had simply snapped.
So he had confessed everything.
Every foolish thought, every longing, every feeling he had been too frightened to even name to himself.
"What must she think of me?" he muttered, rubbing both hands over his face.
He sounded like some lovesick bard singing beneath a maiden's window, not Prince Valarr Targaryen, heir to the heir of the Iron Throne. He had spoken of fate and hearts and souls as though he had spent his entire life composing love songs instead of studying histories and laws.
His eyes burned. He blinked rapidly, refusing to let the tears fall.
He was a prince, an adult man. He had faced council meetings, political negotiations and the expectations of an entire kingdom without breaking down.
Yet the thought of losing you made his chest ache in a way no council ever had.
A knock on the door startled him. Valarr immediately wiped his eyes with the back of his sleeve and straightened himself in the chair. He took a slow breath, then another, desperately trying to make sure his voice would not betray him.
"What is it?" he called, forcing as much strength into his voice as he could.
The door opened, revealing his father. Valarr rose immediately as Prince Baelor entered the chambers and closed the door behind him.
"Father, you should sent for me."
He gave a slight nod, and Baelor returned it before looking at him properly. A small crease appeared between his father's brows.
"I heard you were unwell. Ser Donnel said he saw you practically running through the corridors of Winterfell. He also said you looked rather pale...and flushed." Baelor gestured towards his son's face. "Is everything well?"
Valarr cleared his throat and swallowed. "It is nothing. Just the Northern winds."
His father hummed, though the look in his eyes made it clear he did not believe him. He walked further into the room and glanced around before settling his gaze back on Valarr. The room settled into silence for a few moments.
"It is not easy to win a person's affection," Baelor said quietly as Valarr's head lifted. "Especially a woman who places duty and family above everything else."
Valarr immediately knew what his father was referring to.
"Father, I-"
"I understand your restlessness, son." Baelor walked towards the table and poured himself a cup of wine from the pitcher resting there. He took a slow sip before continuing. "But rushing things will not lead you anywhere. If anything, it will only push her further away."
Valarr lowered his gaze. He wondered if his father knew. If he had somehow seen what happened in the corridor. If someone had told him. If the entire castle already knew that he had confessed his heart to you like a fool.
"Sometimes," Baelor continued, "it is better to allow things to happen in their own time. Give the other person the chance to understand what they feel. Let them think without the cloud of shock and anger hanging over them."
He placed a hand on Valarr's shoulder and gave it an affectionate squeeze. Valarr looked up at him, if only his father knew how badly he had already ruined everything.
"I'm worried, Father." The words came out before he could stop them, and Baelor's expression softened.
"What if it all falls apart?" Valarr asked, his voice growing quieter. "What if that cloud of anger never disappears?"
His eyes burned again, and he quickly ran a hand through his hair, trying to steady himself.
"Valarr." Baelor straightened and gave his shoulder another reassuring pat. "It will not fall apart. If your heart is honest and your intentions are pure, anger will fade eventually. No matter how heavy the cloud may seem."
Valarr nodded, though he was not certain he believed it. He rubbed at his eyes before looking towards the fire again.
Baelor gave him a small smile and straightened his doublet. "Now, if you have gathered yourself, you must follow me to my solar. Bloodraven has sent word that some Blackfyre loyalists have been seen travelling towards Dorne. We need to discuss the matter with your uncle Maekar. It will take your mind off the things for awhile."
Valarr nodded and quickly followed his father out of the chambers, though his mind remained far behind in the corridor where he had last seen you.
By the time they reached the solar, Valarr was still trying to push the thoughts from his head when he stopped abruptly.
You were standing outside his father's chambers with Berena. His father stopped a few paces ahead of him, and Valarr remained beside him, staring.
He immediately noticed your hands were trembling and your eyes were red. You had been crying. The thought made his breath catch in his throat.
The instinct to cross the distance between you and comfort you was almost impossible to resist. He wanted to ask what had happened. He wanted to wipe away the tears from your cheeks and tell you that everything would be alright, even though he was not sure it would.
Instead, he stood frozen. Berena said something to you that he could not hear before taking hold of your wrist and pulling you away.
Valarr caught the confusion and hurt in your eyes before you disappeared around the corner with your sister.
His heart sank.
Had his selfishness ruined everything?
He looked towards his father, who appeared just as confused as he was. Baelor watched the corridor for a moment before sighing quietly.
"Whatever is happening," he said, "I think it best that we do not involve ourselves in the matters of Lord Stark's family."
Valarr nodded slowly. But as he followed his father into the solar, he wondered what had happened between you and Berena.
If his selfishness has ruined things between you and your sister.
Your breath came out ragged as Berena dragged you through the corridors of Winterfell towards your chambers. Her grip around your wrist was firm, almost painfully so, and every step she took seemed to carry another ounce of anger with it. You could feel the fury rolling off her, but beneath it was something else, something that made your own heart ache.
After Valarr's confession, you had wanted to be selfish. For a few fleeting moments, you had allowed yourself to imagine what it would be like to have him. To accept his love instead of running from it. Because deep down, beneath all the guilt and fear and duty, you knew the truth now.
You liked him.
Gods, you loved him.
His confession had been nothing but sincerity. You could still see the way his eyes had watered as he poured his heart out to you, the way his voice had trembled when he spoke of you as if you were the only thing in the world worth wanting. For those few selfish moments, you had imagined what it would be like if Valarr were yours and you were his.
Then you had remembered Berena's face as she left the Great Hall. Her watery eyes. The way she had refused to look at you. The tightness of her hand around yours before she had left.
And you had decided that you would fix everything. If Valarr would not tell his father, then you would. Prince Baelor seemed like a reasonable man. Surely, if you explained that the betrothal was a mistake, that you were not the right woman to become Queen and that Berena was far better suited for it, he would understand.
Everything could still be put right.
You had barely reached Prince Baelor's temporary solar when Berena had appeared before you and asked what you were doing. You had smiled at your sweet little sister and told her that you were going to fix everything, that everything would be as it was supposed to be.
Instead of looking relieved, Berena's eyes had flashed with anger. She had grabbed your wrist and practically dragged you away. If you wanted to, you could have easily overpowered her. You were stronger, faster and far more experienced with a sword than your sister. But how could you possibly fight her when she looked so heartbroken, when she had practically commanded you to come with her?
"Berena, please," you called, your lips trembling, but she did not listen.
She reached your chambers, pushed the door open and shoved you inside before following you in herself. Sara, who had been fixing the bedsheets, looked startled at the sight of the two of you. Berena merely dismissed her with a nod, and Sara quickly dipped into a curtsy before leaving, closing the door behind her.
"Berena-"
"What were you doing there!?" she screamed, and you flinched.
Her eyes were filled with fury, but there were tears gathering in them too, and something inside your chest twisted painfully. You quickly stepped towards her, cupping her cheeks in your hands. You had always hated seeing your younger siblings cry. No matter how old they grew, a part of you still saw them as the children who had once followed you through the corridors of Winterfell.
"Sweetling, I told you. I'm going to fix everything. Believe me-"
Berena slapped your hands away from her face. You flinched at the motion, watching as her breathing grew quicker.
"Fix what?"
"Berena-"
"Fix what?" she repeated, her voice breaking as she took a step towards you. "Fix the fact that the prince does not love me? Fix the fact that he looks at you like you hung the stars and the moon?"
"Sweet girl, please-"
"Fix the fact that both he and the Lord Hand think that you are better suited for the crown? Fix the fact that they right about it?"
She was standing directly in front of you now, glaring at you. But the anger had begun to disappear from her eyes, replaced by something far worse, disappointment.
Your hands trembled, and you swallowed hard, trying to force the words out through the lump in your throat. "I swear I will fix it. You have to believe me, I didn't mean-"
"Do you think so little of me, sister, that I would want a man who so clearly loves my sister?"
You choked on your breath. Berena shook her head, tears spilling down her cheeks as she gave you a bitter little smile.
"Gods, anyone with eyes can see that Prince Valarr loves you. And anyone who knows you well can clearly see that you love him too."
"No, Berena." You stepped towards her, clutching her shoulders. "I swear, this is all just a misunderstanding-"
"Do not lie to me!"
Her voice cracked through the room and you froze. Her face had crumpled into something close to despair, and your own heart began beating wildly in your chest.
"I have seen the way you look at him," she continued, her voice trembling. "The way you smile when he speaks to you. The way your eyes follow him when you think nobody is looking."
"That is not the-"
"Tell me, sister, do you truly believe that I would marry a man after knowing I had crushed my own sister's happiness?"
Your breathing came out ragged as you stared at her, unable to find an answer.
"I thought you knew me," she whispered. "I thought you understood me." Tears were falling freely now. Berena clutched the ends of your cloak as a broken sob escaped her, and your hands instinctively moved to cup her cheeks again, wiping away the tears with your thumbs.
"No, sweet girl. Of course I know you. You are my sweet, sweet sister. I would never-"
"I have envied you since the day I was born."
You fell silent. Berena smiled faintly, but there was no happiness in it. Her eyes remained fixed on yours as your hands trembled against her cheeks.
"There is nothing to envy, Berena. I am but a-"
She shook her head and continued before you could finish. "Gods know how much I have envied you. Whenever I watched you train with Donner and William, I wondered if I could do the same. I wondered what it would be like to have people look at me and see something more than Lord Stark's daughter." Her voice grew softer as she looked down. "But I wasn't born with a talent for swordsmanship like you. Or perhaps I simply did not have the determination for it that you did."
She gave a small, humourless laugh.
"So I decided to become the lady everyone expected me to be. I learned embroidery. I learned how to speak politely, how to smile at the right time, how to dance, how to sit quietly and listen. You name it, I did it. All so the North would look at me the way they looked at you."
Her grip tightened around your cloak. "But it never worked."
You felt tears beginning to gather in your own eyes.
"My identity, my worth, my use started and ended with being Lord Stark's daughter. Just like it does for every other woman in this realm." Berena looked up at you.
"But you were different. They looked at you as you. Your opinions were your own. Your accomplishments were your own. Every lord in the North admired you for something. Some admired your swordsmanship, some your mind, some your courage. But they admired you."
Her voice had softened into quiet sobs now. "So when Mother said that I must marry Prince Valarr, I thought perhaps this was how I could finally be of use to Father."
"Oh, my sister." You pressed your forehead against hers, your own tears slipping down your cheeks. "Your presence alone is enough for all of us. Everyone in the North loves you. You never needed to be useful to anyone. You are my sister. That is enough."
Berena let out a small chuckle and shook her head. "I know. I know that." She reached up and placed her hands over yours. "This isn't about that. It is just..." She took a shaky breath. "I don't want you to refuse the betrothal because you pity me."
You opened your mouth, but she shook her head. "I'm not blind, sister. I think some part of me always knew the prince liked you. Especially after Ethan appeared. That day, his eyes were practically glued to you, even I could tell something was happening."
You swallowed and looked away.
"And then came the trial." A small smile tugged at her lips despite the tears still wet on her cheeks. "Gods, he was so obvious. The way he stared at you...he looked more like a maiden watching a knight at a tourney than a prince."
A laugh escaped her, and you could not help but look at her.
You could still see Valarr standing on that balcony, his eyes fixed solely on you.
"And it isn't shocking that he fell for you," Berena continued. "You are quite the catch, if I say so myself." Her eyes crinkled in the same way Donner's used to when he was teasing you. "The southern ladies certainly made that quite clear."
You groaned at the memory, and Berena giggled. She took your hands from her cheeks and brought them down, holding them against her chest.
"I wasn't sad when the Lord Hand asked for your hand. I was just..." She shrugged. "Taken aback. That is all. And besides, he isn't my type anyway."
You stared at her.
"So do not pity me."
Your eyes watered again. Gods, you had cried more in the past day than you had in years.
"For once, I want you to chase your own happiness. Donner would want that."
The mention of your brother broke something inside you. A sob escaped your lips before you could stop it, and Berena immediately stepped forward, wrapping her arms around you.
"If you truly like the prince, then I want you to marry him," she whispered, rubbing your back. "I want you to be happy."
You buried your face against her shoulder, your arms slowly wrapping around her.
"And say no only if you do not like him. Not because you pity me. Not because you think someone else is more suited for the crown." Her arms tightened around you. "But because you do not like him."
You held her tighter, your tears soaking into her gown as you finally managed to whisper, "Okay."
The two of you remained like that for a while, holding each other as the anger that had filled the room slowly faded away. You wondered when all your siblings had grown so much. It seemed only yesterday that Berena had been small enough to sneak into the kitchens with you, and now she was standing before you, telling you to chase a happiness you had spent your entire life denying yourself.
Eventually, Berena pulled away. You were certain your eyes were red from crying, but you still rubbed at them with the back of your hand.
"I must go see William now," she said, fixing her gown. "He has been freaking out since the announcement. All my siblings seem to be stupid like that."
A small smile tugged at your lips. Berena reached for the door before looking back at you.
"Promise me you will think about it?"
You raised an eyebrow. "About what?"
"Prince Valarr." The warmth immediately returned to your cheeks. Berena smiled knowingly. "Promise me you will make the decision for yourself. Not for me, but yourself."
You stared at her for a moment, Valarr's face flashing through your mind. His mismatched eyes, his smile, his freckled face. The way his voice had trembled when he told you that he loved you. The warmth of his hand against your cheek and the softness of his lips against your forehead.
"I will..." You swallowed, your heart beginning to beat faster. "I will think about it. I promise."
Berena smiled and nodded before opening the door.
"Good."
She stepped out, leaving you alone in the quiet of your chambers. You stood there for a moment, staring at the closed door, your sister's words echoing through your mind.
It was well past dinner when Meera came to ask if you would join the rest of the family in the Great Hall. You had declined, telling her that you would eat in your chambers instead. She had looked worried, but thankfully she had not pressed you any further.
Now you sat on your bed with your knees pulled against your chest, staring blankly at the flames burning in the hearth. The room was quiet, save for the occasional crackle of the wood, but your mind was anything but.
Your thoughts kept wandering back to the kiss you shared with Valarr in the Godswood. To Valarr's confession in the corridors today.
You buried your face in your hands as your heart began beating rapidly again. The red rising to your ears. You did not know what you wanted.
On one side, there was Valarr. His confession had been sincere, you knew that. There had been no calculation in his words, no political ambition hidden beneath them. He had looked at you as though you were the only thing in the world he wanted, and the memory of his lips against yours was still fresh enough to make your stomach flutter.
But then there was the promise you had made to yourself when Donner died.
You had promised that you would never marry. That you would remain for your family, that you would care for your siblings and protect the North in whatever way you could. You had built your entire life around that promise. Berena had told you to chase your own happiness, but it was easier said than done.
This was not simply about what your heart wanted. It was about your honour. Your family. Your promise to Donner. The memory of the brother you had lost and the life you had promised yourself you would live in his absence.
And then there was Valarr himself. He was a good man, you knew that much. He had done nothing wrong, not truly. If anything, he had been painfully honest with you.
But being betrothed to him would mean far more than simply marrying a man you loved. He was the heir to the heir. One day, he would sit the Iron Throne. And if you became his wife, you would become Queen.
You had never once imagined yourself wearing a crown. You had spent your entire life preparing to be a Stark, not a queen.
There were too many things to consider, too many lives that would be affected by one decision.
You sighed and rubbed a hand over your face, trying to make sense of the thoughts swirling inside your head.
A knock on the door startled you.
"Come in," you called, your voice quieter than you intended.
The door opened and your father stepped inside. You immediately moved to get off the bed, but he waved a hand.
"Stay."
He crossed the room and settled into the chair beside your bed, his eyes studying you carefully.
"Father, you should have sent for me," you said, managing a small smile.
He hummed, his own smile faint. "Meera tells me you have not been feeling well."
"I am fine." You looked down at your hands. "It has simply been a long day."
"That it has."
Silence settled between you. For a while, neither of you spoke. You found yourself picking at the edge of your bedsheet, pulling at a loose thread until your father finally broke the silence.
"Your mother thinks it is a good match although it was not the one we expected."
You closed your eyes briefly and took a slow breath. "I expected her to say that."
Your father nodded. "William has been on edge all day, though even he admits it is a decent proposal. And Berena..." A small smile tugged at his lips. "She seems surprisingly happy about it."
You looked down at the furs of your blanket, biting your lip. "And you?"
Your father leaned back in his chair, studying you for a long moment before answering. "I think it is a good match. The prince seems like a good man. In the time he has spent here, he has shown nothing but respect to our family. More importantly..." His eyes softened. "He seems to admire your strength rather than finding it something that needs to be softened. That matters to me."
Your father's hand came to rest over yours, which was still absentmindedly plucking at the fur of your blanket. He gave it a firm squeeze.
"But what I think does not matter."
You looked up at him.
"Nor does what your mother thinks. Nor what the council thinks. Nor what the prince thinks." His thumb brushed over the back of your hand. "The only thing that matters is what you want."
Your lips parted, but for a moment, no words came.
"I don't know what I want." The admission came quietly. "There is just so much happening in my head. It isn't even only about Valarr. I don't know if I want to leave the North. I don't know if I want to be Queen. I don't even know if I could be a good Queen."
Your father smiled sadly. "Matters of the heart and matters of honour are rarely simple, my little wolf." He squeezed your hand again. "Take your time. These decisions should not be made hastily. I have already told the Lord Hand that we will need a few days before giving him an answer, and he has generously agreed."
You nodded, leaning back against the headboard as you let out a slow breath. For a moment, you thought the conversation was over. Then your father spoke again.
"But I agree with Prince Baelor."
You looked at him, raising an eyebrow.
"You would make an excellent Queen."
A small laugh escaped you.
"You are biased."
"Perhaps." He smiled. "But I have watched you grow up. I have watched you sit through council meetings when you were far too young to understand half of what was being discussed. I have watched you learn the laws of the North, learn the ways of our people, learn how to command men twice your age."
His expression softened. "And I have always regretted not naming you my heir."
Your smile disappeared. "Father, you shouldn't say that. It was the right decision."
"It wasn't."
You stared at him, he rarely spoke so firmly.
"No matter the circumstances, I should have waited for you to heal and then asked you what you wanted. Instead, I made the decision for you."
"Father-"
"I let grief make the decision that should have been yours." His voice had grown quieter. "And I will die with that regret. Not only because I undermined my own daughter's abilities, but because my decision drove a wedge between me and my son."
"William does not hate you." Your father gave you a tired smile. "And neither do I think you undermined my abilities." You squeezed his hand. "The North needed an heir beside you during those difficult years. I was drowning in my own grief. I could barely get out of bed some days, let alone stand beside you and rule the North. You made the decision you thought was best for the North."
"But that does not make it right."
You looked at him quietly, his words made your throat tighten.
"I should have fought harder for you. I should have told the council that being wounded did not make you incapable. That grief did not make you weak. I should have reminded them that you were my daughter before you were anything else and that ruling the North was your birthright."
Your eyes began to burn, "Father..."
He gave your hand another squeeze. "And that is why I want you to make this decision yourself." He straightened in his chair, his gaze never leaving yours. "I do not want you to think about what happens to the North if you leave. I do not want you to think about what your siblings need. I do not want you to think about what I need."
His voice softened.
"You have spent enough of your life thinking about everyone else. Your destiny may be here in the North. Or it may be beyond these walls. Perhaps it is beside Prince Valarr, perhaps it is not. But whatever it is, it should be your choice."
You stared at him, your eyes filling with tears.
"If you want him, then I will gladly agree to this betrothal."
A shaky breath escaped you. "And if I said no?"
Your father laughed softly and reached up to pat your head the way he used to when you were a child.
"Then we say no."
"But wouldn't the royal family be offended?" you asked, a small pout forming on your lips despite yourself. "What if they declare it treason?"
"I do not think Prince Baelor is an unreasonable man." He paused, his smile widening. "But if refusing his son's hand is enough to offend him, then I have no doubt the entirety of the North would rally behind you."
You laughed softly, though your eyes remained wet as your father stood. But before he could take another step, you lurched forward and wrapped your arms around his waist. He froze for half a second before his hand came down to rest against your head, gently stroking your hair.
"Do what your heart desires," he murmured. "That is all I want from you. Your happiness will always be my first priority."
You pressed your face against him, and the tears you had been holding back finally spilled over. You let out a quiet sob, your fingers tightening around his tunic.
The decision was yours. And somewhere beneath all the fear and guilt, you already knew what your heart wanted.
Chapter 13 [18th August]
Taglist: @snowwythegloww @supermanshand @rakiroad @cassandra-reborn-anew @bloomballet @bubblegupyy @darling-darling3 @targaryenamour @boundandbrews @onlyrealjoy @qardasngan @rather-melodramatic @appalost @writingshae @uixhzzzi @ch3ska0 @lasylady @jjubilee-fluff @noilusionsblr @062292 @kiszexo-blog @arutsumu @bloomfaery @febru4rystars @secretf1lms @lilybear1-2 @bobostark @whydoshe2308 @Older-bro @madisonosidam @icebearcucumber @ky-3102 @mikariell95 @galactict3a @topsecretgoatt @beelinesblog @lucycarlisleswife @idfkgabby @starlitflora @scuderiapng @madszoca @nice-nice-dazey @mols832
Please let me know if you want to be added to the taglist 🫶🏼🫶🏼

















