Foodsy #436: Challah Bread French Toast
https://www.thekitchn.com/challah-french-toast-264194
🥖 French Toast Notes — Inspired by The Kitchn
I followed The Kitchn’s recipe for classic French toast, using challah bread. I especially liked their tip about using the oven method to dry out the bread — it’s a lifesaver when you’re short on time. Still, I’d like to try Keith’s method next time: simply unwrapping the challah and leaving it out for a day or two to naturally stale. It might produce a better texture and deeper flavor.
I realized I didn’t whisk the custard thoroughly enough. The eggs weren’t fully integrated, which made the texture a bit uneven. Next time:
Use a hand mixer or stand mixer for a smoother, more uniform custard.
Mix longer than I think I need to — aim for a silky, fully blended mixture.
Cooking Technique & Heat Control
The All-Clad frying pans heat up fast, and my first batch burned slightly even when following the “medium-high” recommendation. Going forward:
Try a lower heat (medium to low) setting.
Don’t adjust both heat and time simultaneously — test one variable first.
Watch for that golden brown stage carefully to avoid blackening.
Finding the right balance between soaking and sogginess is key. I plan to:
Use Âľ-inch to 1-inch thick slices of challah for ideal structure.
Soak each slice just long enough to absorb custard without falling apart.
After soaking, place the bread on a wire rack (so it’s elevated and can dry slightly before frying). I’ll check with Brady about which of our racks works best.
A few flavor ideas came up while making this:
Try adding a splash of sherry or Chambord (Brady’s dad’s method vs. Brady’s preference) for depth or a hint of berry flavor.
Experiment with fruit syrups made from jam — a great way to use up jam jars and introduce subtle sweetness and complexity.
âś… Let challah dry naturally next time
âś… Whisk custard more thoroughly (use hand mixer)
âś… Lower the pan heat slightly
âś… Watch cooking time closely
âś… Use wire rack post-soak
âś… Test jam syrups for topping