Erin Hunter Give Us A Darktail Plush Please I Beg

Link to a tierlist of all the books

Please it would be so funny

harestar isn’t ancient and as far as we know, he has only lost one life from his fight with lionblaze. as far as we know.

even if it isn’t harestar, i think it’d be great for a main series to reintroduce tunneling to windclan, whether from old legends passed down or by reinstating the practice. in the same way that nightcloud was believed to have gone missing in the tunnels w the stoats, i think a windclan leader going into the tunnels only to never be seen again would be great.

another idea is that there’s a section of windclan’s existing tunnel system that also acts as a portal to another time, maybe back to fallen leaves’s time. i can imagine a cat straying deeper into tunnels and slowly feeling the air change around them. new scents filling their nostrils, new sounds greeting their ears. when they come out on the other side, they see the lake, but something is much different.

These ideas are great!

Like, after Darktail killed Dudley. She just cracks, she loves Darktail with all her heart, but she can’t bring herself to continue on. Not when everything is falling apart.

So, whilst Darktail is currently waiting for her on the other side of the thunder path & a monster is coming down to take her out, she stops dead in her tracks, silently wishing her son well as the monster hits her dead on.

He lives in the forest while she & a majority of WarriorClan aside from the cats the hoarding situation return to their twolegs at night.

That’s such a fun AU, one I could see happening. Question is, would he be an innocent roleplayer or Scourge 2?

We know DOTC at earliest can only really take place in the 1960s so the timeline seems reasonable. And therefore it can’t be any time earlier and still reasonably and realistically fit into the timeline.

Let me be clear that I know the authors intended none of this at all. They clearly just wanted and eclipse in their po3 book, and for yellow diggers to turn up in dotc time, and for flatscreen tvs to be in StormClan’s Folly, and clearly all these things were done without thinking about the real world timelines of such things.

And then they are just not there the next morning. No one saw them leave. The rain has washed away any scent, there’s no sign of a struggle. They’re just. Gone.