Eloise Sundal

Sunshine on Leith tells the story of two soldiers, Ally and Davy, returning home to Edinburgh after a tour of duty in Afghanistan.

The social aspects of "Sunshine on Leith" are mirrored perfectly by the film's soundtrack, which consists mainly of songs by “The Proclaimers.” Some of the principal themes that we can see being explored in the movie are community, relationships, social class and identity, and the songs play a huge role in telling the stories. For example, “I’m gonna be (500 miles)” highlights the relationships, communal, familial, and romantic, between the characters. The flash-mob scene in Edinburgh's Princess Street reflects the importance of community and support networks while the cut to the other two scenes offers a much more intimate perspective on the struggles of having a loved one far away from home and/or being the person who returned home and finding a community and identity after living through such a traumatic experience. Similarly, “Letter from America”, speaks to feelings of longing, home, belonging, and the comfort found in familiar places. It underlines the importance of their hometown as a source of not only instability and solitude but also solace and familiarity—ironically.

The established history of The Proclaimers' songs adds another layer of meaning to "Sunshine on Leith" for audiences familiar with the band's earlier work, but it can reframe the audience's understanding of the songs, which are delivered in a much less punchy/rock style than their original versions. For instance, "Sunshine on Leith," a song traditionally played at funerals, adds depth to the emotional impact of the film. It is not played during a particular important scene but it is often playing softly during a scene of reflection or longing for home. On the other hand, a song like "Letter from America," written about long-distance relationships in general, becomes more poignant when applied to the specific context of war and separation  after Jean and Liz’s intimate conversation in the film. 

The music that drives the score of "Sunshine on Leith'' can be classified as a combination of folk rock and pub rock. The latter is a genre associated with The Proclaimers' music, which forms the backbone of the film's soundtrack. It often features acoustic guitars, sing-along choruses, and lyrics that deal with issues of the social realm, working-class experiences, and everyday life, which are elements that perfectly capture the film’s essence and the social fabric of it. On the other hand, while the film might not have full-blown pub scenes, the pub rock elements we find in the songs add a sense of vibrancy and camaraderie to the story. 

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs? 

"Mamma Mia!" is set on a Greek island and reflects the cultural and societal aspects of Mediterranean life. The film portrays a close-knit community where traditions, family ties, and local customs play a significant role. Its setting embodies a sense of escapism and freedom, which resonates with the carefree and joyous spirit of many of ABBA's songs.

Additionally, the film's narrative touches upon themes of family values, female empowerment, and the evolving roles of women. Donna is portrayed as a strong and independent woman who raised her daughter Sophie on her own. This portrayal aligns with the changing societal attitudes towards women's independence and empowerment during the time the film was made and set.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers? 

ABBA's songs, deeply rooted in the 1970s and 1980s, reflect the cultural and societal attitudes of their time. In "Mamma Mia!", the film's late 20th-century setting and characters' experiences resonate with these themes. For instance, "Money, Money, Money" aptly captures the economic struggles faced by Donna as she tries to make ends meet running her tavern on the Greek island. The song's lyrics about financial hardship align with Donna's determination to provide for herself and Sophie. Additionally, "Dancing Queen" encapsulates the youthful spirit of Sophie and her friends as they prepare for the wedding. The song's celebration of youth, joy, and freedom mirrors Sophie's excitement and anticipation for her big day. These songs enrich the film's narrative by adding emotional depth to the characters' experiences and enhancing the audience's engagement with their stories.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

The pop music genre in "Mamma Mia!" complements the film's portrayal of a Mediterranean island community in the late 20th century. ABBA's upbeat and catchy songs, such as "Waterloo" and "Voulez-Vous," encapsulate the energy and optimism of that era.

Unlike traditional musicals with original scores, "Mamma Mia!" uses pre-existing songs to tell its story, making it distinctively vibrant and accessible to audiences familiar with ABBA's music. This approach not only celebrates the timeless appeal of ABBA's songs but also creates a nostalgic and engaging musical experience that resonates with fans and new audiences alike.

Idlewild is a musical drama film released in 2006, directed by Bryan Barber and starring the hip-hop duo OutKast, which consists of André 3000 (André Benjamin) and Big Boi (Antwan Patton). The film is set in the Prohibition-era South and blends elements of music, drama, and crime with a jazz and hip-hop-infused soundtrack.

This was a beautiful film and very aesthetic. I have not seen another musical quite like this one and it’s for a reason. Here's why...

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs? 

The characters in "Idlewild" demonstrate resilience in the face of adversity, a theme echoed in the film's music.  Many songs highlight the characters' determination to overcome obstacles and fight for their dreams, reflecting the broader struggle for justice and equality.

The film's love songs align with these themes, expressing the joy, passion, and challenges of love.

Rooster's involvement in the criminal underworld is depicted through intense and energetic musical numbers that convey the danger and excitement of his lifestyle.

The film's songs reflect their desires for a better life and their struggles to achieve their dreams. Percival's introspective ballads, for instance, convey his longing to break free from his small-town life and pursue his passion for music.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers? 

Most of the songs in Idlewild had already been featured on the OutKast albums Big Boi and Dre Present...OutKast and Speakerboxxx/The Love Below, essentially making it a jukebox musical. Seven of the songs from the film, along with several unreleased songs, were released by LaFace Records as an OutKast album entitled Idlewild at the time of the film's release.

This is such an interesting question for my film considering all the film’s score was performed and produced by the lead actors, Andre 300 and Big Boi, with a few credited features in the film. Obviously it isn’t just circumstance that the leads were a famous Hip-Hop duo, so it isn’t hard to assume that the actors/artists were chosen specifically to star in this film for their transformative and notable music style and sound. Without their unique sound and talent for performing, the film could not, and would not be what it is. 

The historiography of this film is unique in the way that the character actors are also the creators of the featured soundtrack. On one hand, the audiences may feel more compelled to the characters and their narrative because they are in support of their music exclusive to the film, as well as some of their originals. In general though, I think historiographies definitely inform the audience’s relationship to a narrative. It can make you more engaged with the characters and their conflicts if you personally feel the music is fitting, or on the other hand, it can make you understand and better comprehend the narrative you're following because you may be familiar with the meaning and significance of the music. I also think about people’s ability to see artists they like and songs they love being performed in a different medium. In a way, your brain might see the visuals from the first time they heard it; or maybe the song originally had a music video. It’s up to directors to build the narrative strongly around the music.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical? 

The hip-hop, funk, and soul stylings of the song score are intentionally anachronistic, a choice made to complement the film being set in 1935. Elements of 1930s-era blues and jazz music are, however, featured prominently in many of the musical numbers. The film's dance numbers, choreographed by Hinton Battle, also feature many period dances, primarily the jitterbug and showgirl moves, like featured in the above video.

The film does a lot of blending hip-hop with jazz, blues, and gospel influences.

Idlewild is known for its visually stylized and innovative approach to storytelling, incorporating musical numbers, fantasy sequences, and animation. 

The film defines itself by taking place in the 1930s, in addition to casting vetted performers and songwriters as your leads. The musical simply wouldn't have the same storytelling element had anyone else written the soundtrack, whether prior to the film or not.

Jersey Boys, directed by Clint Eastwood, follows the story of the 1960s rock 'n roll group The Four Seasons comprised of Frankie Valli, Bob Gaudio, Tommy DeVito, and Nick Massi. The film focuses on their rise to fame and the challenges they faced along the way.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

Jersey Boys aligns its musical selections with key social aspects of its narrative, each song underscoring elements of the personal and communal evolution of the characters. Set against a backdrop of the 1960s—a time of cultural upheaval and musical revolution—the film focuses on the personal struggles and successes of The Four Seasons. For instance, songs like "Sherry" and "Big Girls Don't Cry" resonate with the youthful exuberance and working-class ambitions of the band members, reflecting their hopes and the societal push towards a new musical era that merged pop with personal storytelling. The track "My Eyes Adored You" reflects Frankie Valli's personal losses and his perseverance amidst family tragedies, portraying a deeper social context of personal resilience and commitment, a common theme of the era's socio-cultural fabric. Thus, the film’s songs not only enrich the narrative but also mirror the complex interplay between personal identity and broader societal shifts.

Mira discusses this narrative integration as a staple of successful musicals, highlighting how songs in traditional musicals often serve to express unspoken thoughts or pivotal emotional moments. Though Mira doesn't mention this directly, I find this tactic of musicals to be extremely efficient in advancing timelines without having to explicitly inform the audience of the jump. Similarly, a musical number can encapsulate a wide variety of emotions and plot information, similar to a montage. Jersey Boys employs this technique effectively during sequences like Frankie Valli's rendition of "Can't Take My Eyes Off You," which encapsulates his feelings of triumph and personal turmoil.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers?

The historiography of The Four Seasons' songs plays a crucial role in Jersey Boys by creating a bridge between the audience and the narrative, enhancing the authenticity and emotional engagement. Songs like "Walk Like a Man" and "December, 1963 (Oh, What a Night)" carry with them a historical weight that informs and deepens the audience's understanding of the times and trials the characters endure. These songs, embedded in the cultural memory of many viewers, evoke nostalgia and a sense of realism, making the historical context of the film more relatable and vivid. The familiarity of the music invites the audience into a shared experience, transcending the screen to tap into collective memories and emotions, thereby strengthening the connection to the film's portrayal of the characters and their journey.

Furthermore, the film's narrative structure diverges from the typical linear progression of many musicals. It employs a documentary-style format with characters breaking the fourth wall to address the audience directly which contributes to the historiography. The idea is to include the audience in the storytelling as both makers and viewers reflect on the monumental rise of a beloved American music group. This method adds a layer of meta-narrative commentary, reflecting on the construction of musical mythos itself, which Mira notes as a modernist touch in contemporary musicals.

[SEE 4TH WALL BREAK IN TRAILER ABOVE]

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

Jersey Boys is driven predominantly by the crooner, Doo-Wop, and Rock 'n' Roll styles that characterized the 1960s music scene, particularly influencing the American pop music landscape. This genre choice not only serves to set the period context but also redefines the musical film by integrating biographical and historical realism with the traditional elements of musical theatre. The use of genuine songs from The Four Seasons' catalog, performed in contexts that closely mirror the real-life circumstances under which they were popular, adds a layer of authenticity that is sometimes absent in more stylized musical films. This approach allows Jersey Boys to maintain a foot in the conventional musical genre while also exploring more nuanced, character-driven storytelling, emphasizing the impact of time, place, and societal change on personal and professional lives.

The blend of traditional and innovative elements in Jersey Boys suggests a potential path forward for the Hollywood musical genre, one that respects its roots while evolving to meet contemporary tastes. Mira argues that for musicals to stay relevant, they must adapt by incorporating new styles and addressing modern audiences' expectations, which are more attuned to realism and complexity. I largely agree. I think there is room for the more traditional whimsy of the Hollywood musical if it is housed within more complex themes such as the possibilities we covered in class (humor, delusion, hallucination, satire, etc.).

Jersey Boys demonstrates that the musical genre can successfully incorporate realistic storytelling and complex character development without sacrificing the emotive power of musical performances. The film's ability to appeal to both fans of traditional musicals and new audiences suggests a versatile blueprint for future projects within the genre. The successful integration of music and story, along with a modern narrative approach, may well encourage more filmmakers to explore and innovate within the musical genre, ensuring its survival and relevance in the modern cinematic landscape.

This approach, rooted in the dual adherence to tradition and innovation, not only honors the genre's history but also paves the way for its continued evolution, as discussed by Mira in the broader context of Hollywood musicals adapting to cultural shifts.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

The film explores many social aspects throughout the course of the narrative, and they play extremely significant roles in the story and in providing context for the story. It explores themes of love, sin, societal norms, freedom, forbidden love, love, and ambition. I included forbidden love as being separate to love in this case because while love is an overarching theme, the narrative is as tragic as it is because the love is forbidden.

For example, to set the stage for the film contextually, we have three songs performed at the nightclub, Moulin Rouge, by Satine (Nicole Kidman) and an ensemble of the other nightclub performers. They perform "Lady Marmalade" which talks about the performer's sense of independence as women doing what they have to do provide for themselves. One of the lines in the song is "We independent women, some mistake us for whores/I'm sayin', 'Why spend mine when I can spend yours?'" The next song, "Sparkling Diamonds" performed by Satine also contributes to this idea of freedom and ambition. "Sparkling Diamonds" has a catchy line, "Diamonds are a girl's best friend...'cause we are living in a material world/and I am a material girl". This provides context to our story, and the kind of life that the female protagonist leads, as her character is driven by her ambition to become a "real actress" with no time for love.

Also during this ensemble musical number at the nightclub, the men dance around singing lyrics to Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit", "Here we are now, entertain us", suggesting that the women are there solely for their pleasure, and that they are entitled to the power they hold in that dynamic.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers? 

Seeing as this movie was released in 2001, the songs used in it are from an era that now in 2024 evokes much nostalgia. Now, the film samples a lot of existing songs, and combines them to make new songs. Some of the songs with historiographies that carry the most weight are "Come What May", "Roxanne" by The Police in "El Tango de Roxanne", "Your Song" by Elton John, "One Day I'll Fly Away" by Randy Crawford, "Diamonds Are a Girl's best Friend" by June Stone and Leo Robins, and "Smells Like Teen Spirit" by Nirvana. However, I will only talk about a few of them.

What's interesting about "Come What May"--as it is actually an original song for the film--is that it was originally intended for Luhrmann's Romeo + Juliet. We are all familiar with Romeo and Juliet, their story synonymous with tragedy. Knowing this, we can get a better understanding of the doomed relationship between Christian (Ewan McGreggor) and Satine (Nicole Kidman).

Now "Roxanne" by The Police is a song about a man who falls in love with a prostitute. The song as is used n the film is meant to convey the futility of Christian and Satine's efforts to maintain their relationship. In fact, it comes at a pivotal time in the film when Christian must confront his jealousy.

The song "One Day I'll Fly Away" by Randy Crawford is actually a very telling number as it foreshadows what is to come. It is performed by Satine after her first encounter with Christian, and after having passed out on stage earlier that night where we learn that she is very sick. Though within the context of the film, it sounds like flying away means achieving her dream of becoming an actress, but this is not the case. The song's meaning is that one day we'll be able to "fly away" and go to heaven. For Satine, this is very much the case as we learn at the beginning of the film that she passes away soon after falling in love with Christian due to her sickness.

The last song I'll talk about is "Diamond's Are a Girl's best Friend". This song is about women accepting the cruel ways in which the world operates, and learning to take advantage of it. It talks about not relying on men for anything beyond his material value. This song is sung whilst Harold Zidler (Jim Broadbent), the nightclub's owner tells Satine that he has arranged for her to meet The Duke (Richard Roxburgh) so that she can seduce him and convince him to fund their next show so that she may have a better chance of becoming an actress. Just as the song says not to rely on men for anything beyond their money, Satine must secure The Duke's funding by pretending that she is in love with him.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

The Blues Brothers establishes the group of Nazi’s that follows them around as a central villain and point of ridicule throughout the film. Policing in general and law enforcement are also another social aspect within the narrative as both Jake and Elwood are running from the law. The film pokes fun at the extreme lengths law enforcement takes to arrest the Blues Brothers and their failure to do so. The film has several car chases with one spanning over 20 minutes, and a record of one hundred and four cars destroyed during filming. These ridiculous stunts constantly reaffirm that the Blues Brothers are on the other side of law enforcement. This type of narrative–music as rebellion and performance as protest–is bolstered by the film’s Rock and Roll and R&B soundtrack. 

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers?

The historiographies of these previously recorded songs are what make this film special. The audience already has strong ties to the iconic performers and their songs, so any decontextualization for narrative continuity is minor. That is to say, this film doesn’t attempt to disguise performers like Aretha Franklin, Ray Charles, and Cab Calloway. It embraces their presence and the influence they hold as musicians. For example, “Think” by Aretha Franklin was released during the civil rights movement. When she performs it in The Blues Brothers, the narrative shifts the song's original meaning. Her character Mrs. Murphy asks her husband to think before he leaves to go off with the band. Despite this shift, the song’s original context is still very attached to the performance.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

Soul and R&B drive the film’s score with performances like “Think” performed by Aretha Franklin, “Minnie the Moocher” performed by Cab Calloway, and “Shake A Tail Feather” by Ray Charles. I think this choice of genre defines The Blues Brothers unique feel and makes the dry humor and slapstick comedy so successful. Despite being set in 1980, the film pays homage to iconic performers of the late 50s and 60s. Elwood and Jake are even made fun of for their black hats, sunglasses, and suits, but they maintain their signature “old-school” style throughout. The film's commitment to incredible performers is just one of the reasons it has become a classic.

Walking on Sunshine is a 2014 British jukebox musical romantic comedy-drama film directed by Max Giwa and Dania Pasquini. The film features popular hit songs from the 1980s and is often compared to Mamma Mia!. The plot of Walking on Sunshine revolves around a young woman who travels to a beautiful coastal village in Italy to attend her sister's impromptu wedding. She soon discovers that the groom is her ex-boyfriend whom she’s still in love with. The story unfolds with a backdrop of sunny beaches and features plenty of singing and dancing to iconic 80s hits. The film is known for its energetic musical numbers and vibrant settings, even though it received mixed reviews for its storyline and character development.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs? 

In Walking on Sunshine, the use of vibrant 1980s pop songs directly correlates with the film’s themes of love, joy, and summer romance. Each song is chosen to enhance the film's emotional landscape and reinforce the relationships and conflicts between characters. For instance, the title track "Walking on Sunshine" by Katrina and The Waves is emblematic of the film's overall atmosphere of celebratory love and carefree spirit. The social context here is a nostalgic callback to the 1980s, a time perceived as colorful and full of energy, which mirrors the scenic, lively Italian wedding setting in the film.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers? 

The songs selected for Walking on Sunshine carry with them decades of history and individual memories, which help to establish a deeper connection between the audience and the narrative. The film's remix/rendition of "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" and "Wild Boys" are pivotal in invoking a specific emotional and cultural recall from the audience. "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun," a feminist anthem of self-expression and independence, resonates with the film’s portrayal of strong, independent women navigating love and personal desires. This rendition allows the audience to connect with the characters' journeys through a familiar lens of empowerment and youthful rebellion. This song is interwoven with "Wild Boys" by Duran Duran. With its wild and energetic vibes, "Wild Boys" is used to underline themes of unruly passion and the tumultuous relationships among the characters. The use of these songs (as well as the costume choices in these scenes) not only enhances the narrative but also activates the audience's personal and collective memories, influencing their reception of the film's events and character arcs.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical? 

Walking on Sunshine leverages the pop genre, particularly hits from the 1980s, as its driving musical force. Unlike traditional musicals that might rely on Broadway-style numbers, this film’s score is composed entirely of pre-existing pop songs. This choice significantly redefines the film’s classification within the musical genre by merging pop culture with cinematic storytelling. The upbeat and synthesizer-heavy music typical of the 1980s not only supports the film's energetic dance sequences and vibrant aesthetics but also modernizes the musical genre for an audience that might not connect with traditional musical theater. This redefinition makes the genre more accessible and relatable to a broader, possibly younger audience.

Directed by Emile Ardolino in 1992, Sister Act is a comedy film starring Whoopi Goldberg as Deloris Van Cartier, a lounge singer who witnesses a murder and is placed in protective custody in a convent. Disguised as a nun, Deloris clashes with the strict Mother Superior (played by Maggie Smith) but ultimately helps transform the struggling choir into a musical sensation. Along the way, Deloris finds redemption, friendship, and a sense of purpose. The film combines humor, music, and themes of empowerment and sisterhood to deliver an uplifting and entertaining story.

Deloris' backstory in Sister Act reveals a poignant journey from her childhood in a Catholic school to her adult life as a singer in Reno. As a child, Deloris attended a Catholic school, presumably imbued with the teachings and traditions of the Church. However, for reasons undisclosed in the film, she ultimately departed from that environment, symbolizing a rupture in her connection to her faith and the Church.

Years later, Deloris finds herself pursuing a career as a singer in Reno, embodying a lifestyle far removed from her religious upbringing. Her departure from the Church as a child and her subsequent immersion in secular pursuits represent a thematic departure from spiritual values and community ties. However, the narrative arc of Sister Act intricately weaves Deloris' return to the Church into its storyline. When Deloris becomes a witness to a crime and is placed in protective custody in a convent, she is forced to confront her past and reconcile with her roots. Through her experiences within the convent, particularly her involvement in revitalizing the choir, Deloris undergoes a profound personal and spiritual transformation.

The film eloquently explores Deloris' initial apprehension towards convent life, juxtaposed against the urban landscape of San Francisco. This juxtaposition serves as a metaphorical reflection of societal disarray, wherein the Church stands as a beacon of hope amidst urban decay. Deloris' transformative impact on the choir symbolizes the catalytic force of individual agency within communities undergoing profound change. Through the medium of music, both Deloris' internal pilgrimage and the city's socio-cultural metamorphosis converge, highlighting the transcendent power of artistic expression to inspire collective renewal and redemption.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs? 

The social aspects within the film's narrative align with the film's songs in several ways. 1. Empowerment and Self-Discovery: Many of the songs in the film convey themes of empowerment and self-discovery, mirroring Deloris' journey as she finds her voice and purpose within the convent. Songs like "I Will Follow Him" and "My God (My Guy)" reflect Deloris' transformation from a self-absorbed performer to a woman who finds fulfillment in helping others and embracing her newfound community. 2. Unity and Sisterhood: The film's songs often emphasize themes of unity and sisterhood, echoing the bonds formed among the nuns despite their differences. Songs like "Hail Holy Queen" and "Just a Touch of Love" celebrate the camaraderie and support found within the convent, highlighting the importance of solidarity in overcoming challenges. 3. Redemption and Forgiveness: Through songs like "Bless Our Show" and "If You Wanna Be Somebody," the film explores themes of redemption and forgiveness, emphasizing Deloris' journey towards redemption as she confronts her past and seeks forgiveness from both herself and others.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers? 

As for the historiographies of previously recorded songs, they inform audience relationships with the musical's narrative and performers by adding layers of familiarity and nostalgia. Many of the songs featured in Sister Act are well-known hits from the 1960s and 1970s, such as "I Will Follow Him" by Little Peggy March and "My Guy" by Mary Wells. These songs evoke memories and associations from the past, connecting audiences to the film's setting and characters on a deeper level. Additionally, the use of familiar songs allows the film to play with audience expectations and reinterpret these songs within the context of the narrative, in this case changing love songs into songs praising God, creating moments of surprise and delight.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical? 

The musical genre/style that drives the film's score is primarily gospel, with elements of soul and R&B. This genre/style redefines the film as a musical by infusing it with a vibrant energy and spiritual resonance that complements the themes of redemption and sisterhood. The use of gospel music not only adds authenticity to the setting of a convent but also elevates the emotional impact of key moments in the narrative. Furthermore, the incorporation of soul and R&B elements reflects the diverse backgrounds of the characters and contributes to the film's infectious sense of joy and celebration. Overall, the fusion of gospel, soul, and R&B genres in the film's score creates a dynamic musical experience that enhances the storytelling and leaves a lasting impression on audiences.

Deloris' journey of rediscovery and reconciliation mirrors the larger theme of redemption and the cyclical nature of faith. Deloris' return to the Church symbolizes not only her individual reconciliation but also a broader exploration of forgiveness, belonging, and the enduring power of faith to guide one back to their true self. In essence, her departure from and eventual return to the Church serve as a narrative framework through which the film explores themes of identity, redemption, and the enduring journey towards spiritual fulfillment.

Meet Me in St. Louis follows the Smith family living in St. Louis the year before the 1904 World’s Fair. Esther Smith, played by Judy Garland, is the middle “child” of five siblings but is notably the most outgoing, and thus the lead, of her entire family of eight. Garland sings most of the featured songs, including those original to this film:  "The Trolley Song", "The Boy Next Door", and "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas”. Most of the remaining songs we popular during the time of the World’s Fair.

Social Context for Musical Relevance

This film straddles two remarkably different eras of US history. The beginning of the 20th century (when the film is set) marked great changes in industrialization and first-wave feminism, while the 1940s (when the film was made) can be largely characterized by WWII and FDR’s final term. Two songs - “The Boy Next Door” and “Over the Bannister” balance these two times while mostly serving to satisfy the 1940s audience. “The Boy Next Door” follows a conversation between Esther and her older sister, Rose, who leaves her sister with the sentence “My dear when you get to be my age you’ll learn that there are more important things in life than boys”. The first few scenes of the film cover the fact that Rose, despite her “spinster” age, is not yet married. While this isn’t necessarily problematized it is heavily emphasized. Instead of following in her sister’s footsteps, Esther yearns for love and attention but seeks it out on her terms. Her relationship with the boy next door, John Truett, begins with these two songs. Last week we discussed Altman’s “inevitable couplings”: this pairing, despite falling into the heteronormative framework and finality of so many other musicals, does require effort and initiation from Esther’s character specifically. When John first kisses Esther, long after the performance of these songs, she hesitates. While this relationship is a goal for Esther, she prioritizes her family and personal needs. Rose and Esther’s overall characters and personalities are reminiscent of the feminist movement they harken from, but their ultimate decisions to settle down with comfortably wealthy men aim to please an audience engulfed in war, loss, and instability.

The Cultivation of Christmas Cheer and Nostalgia

Though half the songs are original to the score, the pieces that make this a jukebox musical serve mainly to cultivate nostalgia and joy. Again, the films release during WWII shaped the messaging required or desired by audiences. “Skip to Ma Lou” is sung to the tune of “Yankee Doodle” and other short ditties popular in the late 19th and early 20th centuries but likely still familiar to adult audiences in 1944. This party scene as a whole evokes normalcy, making the plot and characters more desirable and relatable. Other songs included in the score are “auld lang syne” and “the first noel”, some of the oldest Christmas songs that maintain their relevance to this day. Meet Me in St. Louis is often categorized as a Christmas movie despite only the last 20 or so minutes being set during the holiday season. Including these familiar songs in the score sends clear messages about the persistence of peace and being in communion with one another. These songs don’t necessarily have specific or relevant histories but they do have age-old recognition.

Melodrama Meets Musical

Meet Me in St. Louis combines opera, show tunes, and classical music to create a sound that effortlessly blends into the diegesis of the film. Erin Blakemore notes how the film lacks large, spontaneous musical numbers despite all the crowd scenes and possibilities for such fanfare. Rather, the creators integrated music into the Smith family’s regular routines: their parties and goodbyes, moments of comfort and joy. The rest of the score is used more like it would be in a non-musical drama as a sort of choral, background send-off. This movie is undoubtedly still a musical, but it's more “natural”, and perhaps more aligned with the folk musical, than the others we’ve analyzed.

Richard Whorf's Till the Clouds Roll By is a 1946 biopic of American Broadway pioneer Jerome Kern. It features renditions of Kern's famous songs from his musical plays performed by contemporary stage artists. The film follows Kern's journey from his early days as a struggling songwriter to his rise as one of the most influential figures in American musical theater.

Jerome Kern was an American composer whose breakthrough came with the musical Show Boat (1927). Throughout his career, Kern composed numerous hit songs that became standards of the American songbook. Kern's influence extended beyond Broadway, as he also composed music for Hollywood films. He received multiple Academy Award nominations for his film work, including for the score of "Swing Time" (1936), which featured the classic song "The Way You Look Tonight."

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs? 

In Till the Clouds Roll By, every song serves as a snapshot from one of Jerome Kern's musicals. Each of his musicals has various themes that are reflected in these performances. For instance, the film delves into the pursuit of artistic success and recognition within the competitive world of musical theater, as seen in the song "Make Believe" from Showboat. Performances of songs like "Can't Help Lovin' Dat Man" and "The Folks Who Live on the Hill" create sentiments of longing, desire, and devotion, mirroring the characters' experiences of love and heartache against the backdrop of their personal and professional lives.

Through these performances, audiences are transported into the intimate moments of the characters' lives, witnessing the highs and lows of their relationships unfold on screen. The emotional depth and vulnerability conveyed through these songs resonate with audiences on a profound level, inviting them to reflect on their own experiences of love and longing.

2. How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical's narrative and performers?

By incorporating these well-known songs into the film, Till the Clouds Roll By establishes a connection with audiences who may be familiar with the original recordings. The historiographies of these songs evoke a sense of nostalgia and recognition, inviting audiences to engage with Kern's work on a deeper level. As audiences listen to familiar tunes reinterpreted within the context of the film, they are reminded of past performances and experiences, enriching their understanding and appreciation of the narrative unfolding on screen. Each performance is set against the backdrop of theatrical stages that include similar set designs and costumes to those of Kern's musical plays.

A notable example of this homage is Caleb Peterson's rendition of "Ol' Man River" from Kern's seminal work, Show Boat. In the film, we see the character Joe, a Black dock worker grappling with the struggles faced by African Americans along the Mississippi River. Peterson's performance captures the essence of Kern's vision for the film. He is dressed in attire similar to Joe's character and surrounded by a stage design reminiscent of the riverfront setting.

However, the film takes an unexpected turn with Frank Sinatra's rendition of "Ol' Man River" towards the end. Sinatra's performance, set against the backdrop of a grand orchestra and adorned in an all-white suit, exudes an air of glamour and sophistication that diverges from the raw authenticity of Peterson's portrayal.

While Peterson's rendition authentically captures the struggles of marginalized communities and serves as a powerful commentary on racial inequality, Sinatra's interpretation risks overshadowing this narrative depth. The contrast between Peterson's portrayal of a Black dock worker and Sinatra's performance tinged with privilege and sophistication, may inadvertently dilute the real meaning behind the song, shifting the focus away from the authentic representation of racial struggle.

3. What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

Alberto Mira's "Introduction: The Hollywood Musical is Dead. Long Live the Hollywood Musical!" provides valuable insights into the evolution and significance of the Hollywood musical genre, which can be applied to understanding Till The Clouds Roll By. Mira's discussion of the Hollywood musical's cultural significance underscores the importance of the genre as a reflection of societal values and aspirations. Till the Clouds Roll By embodies this aspect by exploring themes of ambition, love, and social justice through its musical performances and narrative arcs. The film serves as a testament to the enduring appeal of the Hollywood musical genre and its ability to resonate with audiences across generations.

The film Tommy (1975), directed by Ken Russell, is a musical fantasy drama that follows a boy named Tommy after he watches his step father kill his father. After this incident, Tommy goes psychosomatically deaf, dumb, and blind. After Tommy discovers his great talent for playing the pinball machine, he accumulates a cult following that take his skills as divine powers. Eventually, Tommy regains his senses and attempts to sell cheap gimmicky products that he claims will give his followers his powers. Tommy is played by the harmonica player of the band The Who. The entire film is based on Tommy, the album by the who released in 1969.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

During the 70s, society was characterized around large crowds of rock and roll fans flocking to prominent bands. Tommy accumulates a cult following because of his sensational pinball skills, and the music for the film comes directly from the album Tommy, by The Who, that were a prominent rock band in the 60s and 70s. In fact, the whole film is based on the album. During the 60s and 70s, it was not uncommon for rock and roll bands to be worshipped like they were profits or gods. One band could take over the world. In this film, Tommy is portrayed as the second coming of Jesus, granting abilities to his followers which come in the thousands. The song Pinball Wizard is the pinnacle song in the album that is also the main song in the film which Elton John performs. It is the main song that fills in the narrative of the film.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers?

The previously recorded songs being from the album Tommy, by The Who, engage the viewer with the musicals narratives of a rock and roll story. Tommy's story is one of great success and then tragedy as his own fans murder his mother and step father. The band The Who has a similar tragic past. The Who concert disaster of 1979 is evidence of how many rock and roll bands are involved in tragic accidents or downfalls. Even though the incident occurred after the making of this film, the concept still applies. A rock and roll band wanted to make a film, so they made it a tragic, yet epic musical - one which reflects their own careers.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

This film is a rock musical, starring a rock artist, using a narrative from a rock song, and other rock music from that specific band. This style of music makes the whole film a rollercoaster of fantasy surrealism. From one scene to the next there is emotional tensions, to violent conflict, to perfect calm. These ups and downs in such fantastical ways represent a rock and roll song, or even the life of a rock and roll artist. Watching the film, don't know what's coming next, and it's the same with a band like The Who. As Alberto Mira states: "pop musical, like many established cycles, ends up being about pop music, pop stardom, and their legacies" (32).

Rock of Ages

Rock of Ages is a 2012 jukebox musical styled as a comedic film involving the interweaving storylines of several artists trying to make it big in the rock music scene. The film is built around 1980s rock featuring songs from bands like Styx, Journey, Bon Jovi, Europe, and more.

What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

The film is set in 1987 Los Angeles. As mentioned in the text "rock and roll, the first new wave of pop music, appeared then as a label which certainly seemed to be new to the mainstream, but its success has to be understood along social lines: white appropriation of Black music, marketing youth lifestyles, and encouraging teen consumerism" (7).

This wave of pop music was categorized by the social base it addressed. In Rock of Ages a small town girl Sherrie Christian (Julianne Hough) meets city boy Drew Boley (Diego Boneta) on the Sunset Strip as they try to launch their musical careers. The entire soundtrack utilizes rock from the 80s which was an extremely controversial period of music for its time leaving audiences heavily divided. This disparity between supporters and haters of the music is depicted in the film pinning rock listeners and churchgoers against each other.

Building up to the 80s and lasting throughout the decade, rock was criticized for explicit lyrics, themes of rebellion, and references to drugs use, violence, and sexual content. This created widespread paranoia among parents, religious groups, and conservative organizations about the impact of listening to this music. There were certain bands like Black Sabbath and Iron Maiden that raised concerns for a spread of Satanism. Rock, more so than anything, was known for challenging traditional social norms and values like gender roles and sexual morals. Artists like Prince and Madonna are known for these kinds of provocative lyrics and performances.

The songs within the film are emblematic of a period of rebellion, a genre dedicated to challenging norms and establishing its own realm of music. Songs like "I love Rock and Roll," "Wanted Dead or Alive," "I Want to Know What Love is," and "Hit Me With Your Best Shot" are all emblematic of societal reflections imposed onto the characters within the narrative. Catherine Zeta-Jones' character Patricia Whitmore is the film's main antagonist in her disdain for rock music. But quickly, through seduction of a famous musician, she is quickly swayed away from hatred and into a total state of enamor.

The music also serves to explore the faults of the rock industry as well by exploring all avenues of glitz, glamor, and obstacles.

How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers?

As aforementioned, the history of rock not only permeates the soundtrack but the narrative as well. Though paranoia surrounding rock music came from conservative and religious groups fearing and overtaking of Satanists, many famous rock musicians and bands struggled with substance abuse. The star of the film, Stacee Jaxx (Tom Cruise) is a mirror into the lives of former rock stars struggling with the weight of their fame. Throughout the film he goes in and out of sobriety, though for the most part he remains absurdly intoxicated especially while performing.

The text discusses how music integrates itself with culture by influencing attitudes, fantasies, politics, and listening communities (7) and that it was much "easier to describe rock's style negatively - to describe what it wasn't" (8). Because rock was new, it was perceived to be threatening, especially because it was powerful. In the film specifically the characters revolve their lives around the music as if their existence depended on it.

Each character has their own relationship to the industry which are uniquely expressed through different rock artists and bands. Whilst picketing Stacee Jaxx and rock music in general, Patricia Whitmore (Zeta-Jones) tells the rock fans to hit her with their best shot, superbly vocalizing Pat Benatar's epic 1980 single.

When Sherrie struggles to make it big she lands herself a job in a strip club where she and the rest of the dancers harmonize alongside Mary J. Blige for a version of "Anyway You Want It."

But even those who fear the music at the beginning of the film learn to love it by the end.

What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

Rock music is the SOUL of this film. It is the only music included which I think really defines the heart of the narrative and the power behind the battle of fighting for the music, as well as everyone's individual career. This influence is in the HAIR, their CLOTHES, their MAKEUP, and their connection to each other.

In order to examine the genre of the film that is inspired by the music, I want to just showcase what these artists looked like and how they performed their art.

Jon Bonjovi.

The vision herself, Pat Benatar:

Whitesnake:

Def Leppard at their first concert:

To really capture this energy wouldn't have been possible for the film for what it intended to be as the songs have a bit more of a pop influence for the film, which I would argue makes the music more digestible in order to reach a larger audience. However, I believe keeping the songs in the same style would have created a more realistic tone for the film.

Question 1: What are the social aspects within the film’s narrative that align with the film’s songs?

The narrative of “All That Jazz” explores the dark side of entertainment. In the opening number, “On Broadway”, the audience is introduced to the allure of show business while being shown the grueling audition process.

The upbeat R&B song, performed by George Benson and popularized by The Drifters in 1963, complements the energized dancers and fast moving tryout. The lyrics of the song express longing and escapism, with the narrator dreaming of making it big on Broadway. However, beneath the glittering lights and promising opportunities lies a darker reality. The director, Joe Gideon, uses his artistic prowess and influence over the production to lead casting decisions based on who he wants to sleep with rather than talent.

He begins a sexual relationship with one of the dancers he chooses from the sequence, Veronica, and in a future scene he essentially breaks her down to tears in order to get the performance he wants out of her. To bring it back to “On Broadway”, the tension between the glamorous facade and the seedy underbelly of show business reflects another tension in the film which is a broader dichotomy in the entertainment world, where personal ambition often beats out artistic and personal integrity.

The scene between Veronica and Joe.

Another social aspect explored within the film’s narrative through song is the cyclical nature of life and art in “Everything Old is New Again”. The song was originally by Peter Allen in his 1974 album “Continental American”. As Joe grapples with his morality and attempts to reinvent himself creatively, the song serves as an important reminder of the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth, suggesting that trends and fashions often repeat over time. During the 1970s a large number of traditional values were being challenged and individuals sought to redefine themselves in the ever-changing and evolving world. Joe is able to find comfort and define himself with the comfort of the cyclical nature of art and life.

Question 2: How do the historiographies of previously recorded songs inform audience relationships with the musical’s narrative and performers?

The use of previously recorded songs in “All That Jazz” seeks to add layers of meaning to a specific audience familiar with their original contexts, an audience of Broadway and the style of bygone eras. For example, “Some of These Days”, a song associated with vaudeville performer Sophie Tucker, is used in a scene where Joe faces his mortality. Audiences familiar with Tucker’s career may interpret the song as a nod to the past, invoking a sense of nostalgia and paying homage to the rich history of stage productions and entertainment that predate Joe Gideon’s era which is inspired by Bob Fosse’s life.

Sophie Tucker

Similarly, “Bye Bye Love” originally by The Everly Brothers is used in a scene where Joe grapples with the dissolution of his relationships. The lyrics of the song become more significant in this context, reflecting Joe’s sense of loss and longing.

Question 3: What musical genre/style drives the film’s score, and how does the genre/style (re)define the film as a musical?

The music of “All That Jazz” encompasses a wide range of musical genres and styles including, jazz, pop, classic R&B, and traditional Broadway music. The eclectic mix reflect the diverse taste and influences of its director, Bob Fosse. By mixing the different genres, the film defies categorization and helps to redefine the musical genre. 

Bob Fosse in a situation similar to one we see Joe in many times during the film.

Unlike some jukebox musicals which adhere to a singular style or formula the film embraces experimentation and innovation. The film uses non-linear storytelling, surreal imagery, and unconventional musical numbers to challenge audience expectations. It doesn't feel like what one might think of as a musical, it feels more like a prolonged fever dream of a performance.

Across the Universe transforms thirty-three popular songs by The Beatles into a wacky musical odyssey that explores the highs and lows of youth counterculture movements in 1960s US and Britain. With major characters named Jude, Lucy, and Prudence who all have obvious namesakes from within the Beatles' discography, the lyrics and perspective of the bands' music informs the characters' attitudes and circumstances throughout the film. Though it's unclear whether the Beatles exist in the films' universe, which seems to be an imagined caricature of the 60s, its certain that Taymor believes their music captures the essence of the sixties, as the (mostly white and well-off) characters sorrowfully sing their way through the turmoil of the Vietnam War and the Civil Rights movement....

At times, this film relies on cinematic narrative expectations, and at others, the film feels like a two-hour long Beatles music video. Some creative risks are taken, such as an LSD-sequence or a highly choreographed interpretation of the military drafting process during the Vietnam War. Though the film is fun when it indulges in its wackiness, I found that it was stuck between following a narrative structure and subverting it, causing it to feel unsatisfying, disjointed and generally underdeveloped.

With this in mind, there's a lot of small characters and storylines that make the film a bit difficult to summarize. Here's a synopsis from Google:

When young British worker Jude (Jim Sturgess) sets sail for the United States in search of his father, he ends up meeting carefree college student Max (Joe Anderson) and his lovely sister, Lucy (Evan Rachel Wood), along with a cast of eccentric characters. As Jude and Lucy fall for each other, their relationship is threatened by the social upheaval that accompanies the Vietnam War.

Social Aspects Through Song

The "social aspects" of Across the Universe are conveyed through the films' songs in a way that is incredibly on-the-nose and un-subtle. In fact, nothing about this film is subtle. For instance, when unemployed artist Jude is upset with his booked and busy girlfriend for being too involved in the anti-war movement, he shows up at the nonprofit and starts singing "You say you want a revolution..." In another sequence, Max prepares to be screened for military service, and giant Uncle Sam posters come to life and start singing "I want you."

With such un-nuanced recreations of political events, I am unsure of what exactly this film is trying to say about the 1960s' political and social revolutions from a 2007 vantage point. On the contrary, perhaps the film is attempting to create an "objective" yet campy and fun retelling of 60s history with a focus on the youth, without deliberately trying to "say" anything new at all. With this non-argumentative lens, the film seems blissfully unaware of its own shortcomings, such as the unresolved sexism of its two male leads, or the surface-level characterization of Lucy and the heavily apparent absence of the second-wave feminist movement.

Perhaps the most questionable of this films missteps, though, is its treatment of race through song. The film's secondary cast features a queer Vietnamese female character, Prudence, who randomly disappears from the film a third of the way in. Then there is Jo-Jo. When it is revealed to the characters that Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated, the film cuts to Jo-Jo, a Black man, singing at a bar, only to reveal that his sad song is actually about Sadie, the woman who left him. While social issues of race clearly loom over the characters' heads, the film employs the powers of the Beatles' "All You Need is Love" rhetoric to wash over any nuance pertaining to the topic. This is especially interesting since this rhetoric within actual hippie circles in the 1960s proved to be a clear failure.

Musical Memories and Genre-bending

On the changing force of pop music within the movie musical format, Mira writes: "In assessing what pop songs bring to the musical, we must consider, firstly, that a song's meaning is conveyed not only through melody, rhythm, and lyrics: engaging with an audience's memories, viewpoints, and personal background can be powerful in unleashing meaning as well" (24). In this sense, I think Across the Universe transforms its musical source material and plays with audience's familiarity with its songs in a really fun and effective way.

The film's opening is a really great example of how it blends the audiences' diverging associations of a classic Hollywood musical versus a classic rock music video. These two juxtaposing numbers comprise the opening:

Within this introduction, we are already hit with three different musical styles: the Beatles' contemplative ballads through Jude, a more intense female rock voice, and a more classical "musical theatre" style through Lucy. However, all of the songs sung are by the same artist. In this way, the film often plays around with the melodies, keys, tempos, etc. of the original Beatles' songs in order to suit which character is singing a given song. I think this is a really clever way of making similar-sounding music feel dynamic enough to remain interesting for the span of a two-hour film while also serving practical narrative functions. The songs of the Beatles are also transformed to song like other artists or sub-genres of 60s rock and roll. For example, the character Sadie's songs are reminiscent of rock stars like Stevie Nicks or Janis Joplin, while Jo-Jo's skilled guitar playing is inspired by the likes of Jimi Hendrix. In this way, the film pays homage to several icons of the era, despite only using actual music created by one band of the time.

Victorious follows Tori Vega, an unassuming teenager who lands a coveted spot at Hollywood Arts High School, a prestigious performing arts school, after taking her older sister's place in a showcase. Surrounded by her talented classmates like Andre, Robbie, Jade, and Beck, Tori navigates the challenges of high school life with a focus on music, performance, and the ups and downs of artistic pursuits. The show utilizes humor, musical numbers, and a dual-focus narrative that explores not just romantic relationships, but also friendships, mentorship, and collaboration as Tori gains confidence and embraces her newfound passion for performing. 

How does the series use dual-focus narrative as a strategic storytelling tool beyond heteronormative romantic pairings? 

Victorious is more of a coming of age show. I think the central focus of this dual-focus narrative is mainly navigating highschool in a very competitive performing arts world, while juggling with the drama and complexities of being a teenager. 

Trina and Tori’s dynamic is a prime example of this. While often played for laughs, they offer a unique dual focus on sibling rivalry and eventual support. Episodes explore the challenges of living in each other's shadows while ultimately showcasing a bond of care, even if expressed in a quirky way.

Cat and Jade’s friendship is another example. Their contrasting personalities - Cat's bubbly, seemingly innocent and dumb, and Jade's dry wit - create a dynamic that focuses on loyalty, acceptance, and navigating the intricacies of female friendship and girlhood.

Often, the show adopts a "group focus" narrative, touching on themes of teamwork, navigating high school and the “que serás” of life after graduation. Victories at competitions, overcoming obstacles thrown their way by Sikowitz, or simply hanging out are all depicted with a group focus, fostering a sense of community and shared journey. Sikowitz, the eccentric yet insightful teacher, becomes a mentor figure for each character. The dual focus here explores themes of artistic growth, following one's passion, and overcoming self-doubt, with each character's journey receiving dedicated focus.

What are the “inevitable” couplings within the series and how are they accentuated through “cinematic” similarities and contrasts? 

Beck and Jade’s love story is a classic "opposites attract" with cinematic parallels. Beck, the carefree charmer, is often contrasted with Jade's fierce and sarcastic personality. They use slow-motion moments, lingering glances, and dramatic lighting to emphasize their inevitable connection. Their contrasting personalities often lead to humorous conflicts. Jade's sharp wit clashes with Beck's laid-back demeanor, resulting in playful banter and witty exchanges. These comedic moments keep the relationship dynamic and prevent it from becoming overly sentimental. While slow-motion highlights their connection, their body language in everyday interactions can show their contrasting comfort levels. Beck might have a more open posture, while Jade might have crossed arms or a guarded stance, hinting at their underlying feelings and insecurities. Although, somehow, they seem to not be able to stay away from each other!

How does the series use musical numbers within and beyond the narrative world to replicate fairy tale, backstage, or folk musicals? 

Diegetic musical numbers like "Freak the Freak Out" blur the lines between reality and the fictional performance. The song takes place during a moment in which Tori wants to prove herself and others that she is talented, in some way, it showcases her anxieties and at the same time, her confidence as she performs for the karaoke bar's crowd. On the contrary, Acoustic numbers like "You Don't Know Me" performed by Jade mirror the folk musical style, emphasizing personal growth and self-discovery. This stripped-down style allows for a more intimate portrayal of her character’s emotions and vulnerabilities, as she is often only portrayed as the punk, emo teenager with no feelings.