Zutara rebuttals to irrelevant/irritating Kataang arguments I hear much too often part 3
Guys I just saw this article and read through the entire thing.
https://screenrant.com/avatar-last-airbender-katara-aang-not-zuko-relationship/
This is a piece of crap, I'm pretty sure all of the arguments here were thoroughly debunked before but I just HAVE to address them because I can't stand by and watch them twist things into something they're not.
Because MAN does this author even know what what talking about???
"They were enemies in season 1"
Bro. Exactly. Season 1. What does this have to do with them ending up together in season 3?
Like, seriously you kataangers got to stop using that argument. Being enemies at the beginning is literally the point of enemies to lovers arcs. Arguing that they shouldn't be together because it(meaning: being together) fits their arc is like arguing you should give a child a knife because it might hurt itself.
Then again, while I do understand why people say Kataro hated Zuko (she very much did in season 1), I have to point out that Zuko's feelings about Katara aren't exactly straightforward. While there might be annoyance at the fact that she prevents him from getting his honor aka the avatar, there are little things that suggest he didn't hate her. For example the fact that he puts his hand on her back to prevent her from sliding form the searshu.
Or the fact that when he catches her in 'The Waterbending Scroll' he doesn't torture her like Zhao or 90% of respective Fire Nation generals would, he just ties her up to a tree and tries to bribe her. For the record, I'm not saying Kataro should have ended up with him because he didn't torture her when he had the chance to. I'm pointing out this shows respect.
A respect I'd argue is mutual, because Katara, for all the hatred we see, never disrespects him. I have to point out that Katara doesn't hate Zuko as an individual so much as what he represents (canonically confirmed in the crystal catacombs). Example: you never see Katara calling him names or flexing the fact that she and Sokka and Aang escaped like e.g. Sokka sometimes does. The hatred is there, but so is respect.
Here, I have to point out that the author downplays Zutara to 'just friends bonding over shared trauma' which has been addressed so many times I won't even bother doing it again.
Zuko and Kataraâs relationship may have been too toxic to evolve into a healthy romantic relationship, especially given the fact that Avatar: The Last Airbenderâs target audience when it aired on Nickelodeon was for children age 9 to 14.
Excuse me? Toxic? Zuko and Katara? How? I already addressed 'The Waterbending Scroll' drama, I won't do that again, as well as the whole 'they were enemies' rant.
Also, excuse me, the crystal catacombs betrayal is crucial to both Zuko and Katara's individual arcs as well as their joined arc. The fact that Zuko was mature enough to apologize for it and ask for forgiveness without forcing anything and that Katara was able to truly, thoroughly forgive him that is the reason why people ship them and shows true maturity. Canon Zutara validation would be the ultimate true forgiveness force power which isn't toxic at all unlike Katara 'forgiving' Aang for something that is literally a textbook case of sexual harassment/assault (you guessed it right, the ember island players kiss) which is literally toxic masculinity validation.
I get why people say their bond in seasons one and two first half of season 3 is based on mutual respect and understanding, but Bryke thoroughly messed this up in the second half when they made Aang go from a smitten teen to an insecure asshole and abuser. Like damn, he forced two kisses! One of them crossed boundaries Katara set literally a few second earlier and met with a definitely negative response, the other one was so uncomfortable for Katara and the face she made after suggests she wasn't into it even then. I don't even know how to start with why Kataang isn't a relationship based on respect.
About them encouraging each other to work on their waterbending techniques, I have to point out Katara was the one encouraging Aang to work on it 90% of the time. And this does not equal a romantic relationship. I don't get why the author used that argument.
About Aang 'giving up his training with Master Pakku', how is that a sign of respect towards Katara? Like, she was pissed at Pakku' for being sexist. And that comment Aang made before the duel?
Aang: You don't need to do this, I can find another teacher.
Like bro thinks the world revolves around him, that's main character syndrome which is also what ruined this ship for me.
About the Kataang 'good line of communication', I already said this has been so thoroughly destroyed in second half of season 3 that it is literally an argument why Katara and Aang are better off as friends. Their communication works when Aang stays friendzoned.
Katara and Zukoâs friendship allowed them to grow as people in a way that couldnât have been achieved had they become a couple
Impressive. This argument is literally the opposite of what would have happened. Like yes, their friendship allowed them to grow as people. And no, a romantic relationship wouldn't have stopped that process. It would have sped it up and made it even more efficient.
The 'friendly' life saving jump in fron of Azula's lightning was such blatant ship baiting that you have to be literally blind not to notice that. The familial love goal would have been achieved with Sokka becoming practically a brother to him and do I have to mention the sibling dynamic between Zuko and Toph?
The regaining of Zukos honor would have been even more emphasized if Zukos jumped in front of a lightning to save the love of his life because the old Zuko would have let Katara take the lightning and use that moment to beat Azula instead. The fact that he chose to save Katara and trust that she'll have it in her to beat his psychotic sister despite knowing she might fail says everything about his honor and moral compass that we need to know.
Katara's kind and nurturing nature makes her the perfect person for Zuko because she'd love him with all her heart and help him through rough times instead of giving vague statements like Mai did. And Zuko, for all his flaws would do the same thing for Katara which would be the ultimate validation of his redemption arc.
Also, I find it weird how the author said they both grow as people without pointing out Katara's growth. Maybe that's because she grows as a person in 'The Southern Raiders' and that episode alone contains so much pro-Zutara and anti-Kataang ammunition that this episode alone would overthrow every single argument made in this article LOL.