Steve Harrigton needs a date to his cousin's wedding and unfortunately for you, you owe your sister a favour.
pairing: steve harrington x mayfield!reader
words: 8.5k
contains: fluff, frenemies to lovers, (sort of) fake date, mention of precious king!steve behaviour, steve’s dad being a little awful, grief, guilt, mention of death of a sibling, female reader, no use of y/n, she/her pronouns for reader.
author's note: ah so this one was so fun to write! i have never written a wedding guest fic before and oh, i just loved it! please enjoy
taglist | masterlist | 3k special masterlist | requests page
Steve Harrington could not believe his luck—or lack thereof.
The day before cousin’s wedding, Juliet had called Family Video to cancel on him and so, Steve had naturally begun to panic.
He knew how much the wedding was costing his aunt Edith—the only family member who he actually really liked—and so he knew how a last minute cancellation like this would stress her and his cousin Daisy out. Especially as he had already begged his aunt to allow him to bring Juliet with him in the first place.
He had called Robin but she was unfortunately sick with the flu. He had called his last ten dates but they were all either busy or flatly refused to go out with him again. He had even debated asking Nancy but shook the thought, she was his ex-girlfriend after all.
“Wow,” Max Mayfield grins in mild amusement as Steve rattles off the list of girls he had asked to be his emergency plus one. “You really need to find a hobby.”
Dustin—who had stumbled into Family Video over half an hour ago alongside Max to try and convince Steve into letting them rent an R rated horror for the party’s weekly movie night—laughs loudly, causing Steve to groan into his hands before resting his head against the cool countertop in defeat.
“I’ll just go alone,” Steve grumbles against his arm. “I’ll just look like a sad, sad loser going to alone to a wedding and—”
“What about Max’s sister?”
Steve can’t help it. He lets out a snort of disbelief before standing up straight.
He doesn’t miss the look of annoyance Max shoots his way.
“What’s wrong with my sister, Harrington?” She asks pointedly and Steve’s ears turn red.
Of course, there was nothing wrong with you per se. In fact, Steve had very briefly considered asking you the moment that he had gotten off the phone with Juliet. But there was just one small problem—
“Nothing!” Steve says quickly, holding his hands up in surrender. “Absolutely nothing! She just—”
“Hates his guts?” Dustin offers.
Max rolls her eyes in exasperation, folding her arms across her chest as she looks from Dustin to Steve.
“She doesn’t hate you,” Max insists. “She just—she just thinks you’re an asshole and would prefer not to be in the same room as you.”
Steve swallows. Something that felt like shame swirls in his gut. Of course, you had every reason to dislike him and Steve would be the first to put his hands up and say he probably deserved it. You two had very much gotten off on the wrong foot after you had overheard him call Billy’s family—and by extension your family—’trash’. It had been in the heat of the moment and he had only said it because Billy had been pushing his buttons all day. The moment he had realised that you were within earshoot, he had regretted saying it. But because he was stubborn and, at that point in time, cared more about what others thought of him than doing the right thing, and so he didn’t take them back. He didn’t apologise.
He later tried, after the first dance with the Upside Down together, after you had stopped Billy from almost killing him in Byers’ home with a syringe but you had scoffed and walked away like you didn’t buy it. You had made it very clear that you didn’t want to accept his apology, that you had made your mind up about him despite the fact your sister could not care less about the comment. He understood why—you were her big sister and you were protecting your family. Especially after Starcourt, especially after Billy died.
And so, Steve wasn’t exactly convinced by Max’s insistence that you didn’t hate him.
“There is no way she’ll go with me,” Steve says with a shake of his head, arms folded across his chest. “She hates—”
“—she will,” Max says with a knowing smile. “She owes me a favour.”
Steve blinks, looking from Max to Dustin and back again, as if waiting for one of them to shout ‘April Fools!’.
When neither of them does, Steve raises a brow at Max.
“What for?”
“She broke my skateboard,” Max explains. “I was gonna make her buy me a new one but making her go to a wedding with you sounds more interesting.”
Dustin laughs and the corner of Max’s mouth twitches but Steve looks thoroughly unconvinced.
“Gee, thanks Max,” Steve mutters, eyes shifting down to the pile of tapes stacked in front of him that he was meant to be rewinding. “But I really don’t think she’ll agree.”
And so, Steve spends the rest of his shift rehearsing exactly what he was going to say to his aunt when he called her to tell him he would be attending the wedding tomorrow, minus his plus one.
Five minutes before his shift was due to end, Steve was carefully rearranging the candy selection just as the bell above the door sounded. He couldn’t help but roll his eyes.
Of course—it was just his luck that a customer had decided to waltz in five minutes before his shift ended. He would put money on the fact it was a group of teenagers who would refuse to leave, teenagers who would mess up the horror display he had spent forty five minutes rearranging, teenagers who pick up the tape for Body Heat to try and convince Steve that they weren’t fourteen.
“We’re closing in—”
“—in five minutes. I know. I can read a clock, Harrington.”
Steve’s stomach turns at the sound of your voice. His head whips around so quickly it was a wonder he didn’t hurt himself. He certainly dropped all of the bars of candy that he had been holding.
“Wh-what are you doing here?” Steve asks, blinking as he watches you approach the counter with a schooled expression. “Robin has the flu if that’s what you—”
“—I’m here to see you,” you interrupt, eyes flicking down to the peanut butter bopper still clutched in Steve’s hand before you look back up at his face. “Max told me about your—your plus one situation.”
“Oh,” Steve says, the tips of his ears reddening as he looks down at all the candy bars he had dropped, the ones he had been lovingly arranging for the past ten minutes. “Yeah um, that Juliet cancelled on me. She’s cat sitting or something so can’t um, make it.”
You quirk a brow and Steve can tell by the look on your face that you want nothing more than to make a comment, to crack a joke, perhaps even tell him that he had very clearly been stood up, that there was no way Juliet had actually cancelled on him to cat sit. But you don’t, instead you seem to take a deep breath before you say. “I’ll do it.”
The bopper in Steve’s hand falls to the floor. He scrambles to pick it up before looking back ar you.
“Seriously?” He asks, his eyes wide as he tries his best not to look too hopeful. “You—you’re not—this isn’t a prank, right?”
You frown slightly. “Why would I do that?”
Steve blinks before he shakes his head because really, he knew you would never do anything like that to him.
“I—I dunno—I just—you know this is a wedding, right?” Steve asks you. “Like I’ll be in a suit and you’d wear—”
“—a dress,” you finish. “I know, Max told me. I have a dress if that’s what you’re worried about.”
Steve swallows, the bopper that was back in his grip starting to melt in his sweaty grasp. “I’m not worried about that, it's just—are you sure? Like, are you sure about coming to this wedding—with me?”
You exhale, looking away from Steve momentarily to look around the store, almost as though you were bracing yourself for something big.
“Yes, Harrington,” you say finally. “As a favour to Max, I’ll go to this wedding with you.”
Steve looks back at you for a long, long moment, as if to make sure he wasn’t dreaming or that you weren’t going to tell him you were joking. When he realises that this wasn’t a dream and you say nothing, he starts to smile.
“Thank you,” he breathes. “Thank you so much. This means a lot. My family are—yeah—this is just, it’s really great of you to—”
“—but I’m not dancing with you,” you cut in quickly, fiddling with your hands as you look away from him. “Or doing anything remotely touchy feely. I’m just your plus one. That’s it. That’s all I’ll be.”
“That’s fine!” Steve says quickly, wiping his clammy hands over his jeans before setting down the bopper onto the countertop beside him, the wrapper crumpled and the chocolate inside a little gooey. “Makes sense. Yeah. Um, totally. No dancing. Limited touching. Ju—just my plus one.”
You look at him for a beat before finally, you nod. “Good. Glad we got that covered,” you say before you lean down to pick up one of the candy bars he had dropped and tear open the wrapper.
“You know you need to pay for th—”
“See you tomorrow, Harrington,” you say, smiling before taking a large bite from the chocolate bar and walking straight out of Family Video.
“Could you sit still? Just for two minutes?”
“Is this really necessary?”
Max looked back at you blankly in the mirror before shaking her head, returning her attention to your hair, ignoring you.
You huff but you don’t question her further.
You didn’t want to admit it to yourself but as it drew nearer to ten in the morning—the time that you agreed to be ready by with Steve late last night when he had called you in a slight panic, having forgotten to tell that the wedding was over an hour away—you found that you were starting to feel nervous.
The pale green satin dress you were wearing—the one you had been saving for Max’s graduation—hugged your body in a way that you weren’t used to. Max and your mom insisted that you looked beautiful but you didn’t exactly know how to feel about that. Especially knowing you’d be spending the day and most of the evening on the arm of Steve Harrington.
“Is it too late to back out now?” You ask Max hopefully, setting down the blusher you had been applying while she was focused on your hair. “I mean—I could say I got the flu from Robin or—”
“—absolutely not,” Max snaps at you. “Just give him a chance? Alright? He’s not the asshole he was in high school.”
You hum in acknowledgement at her words but you don’t respond. You had heard that sentiment plenty of times before, you just couldn’t allow yourself to believe it.
By some miracle, you were ready just before ten o’clock. After slipping on some silver kitten heels, you stand up straight and catch a glimpse of yourself in the mirror next to your bed. It was hard not to smile at how pretty you felt.
“Still wanna back out?” You hear Max ask from the door of your shared bedroom, one of your mom’s nice silver purses she only used for special occasions clutched in her hands.
You look over your shoulder at Max before your eyes flicker back to your reflection, at the hair Max had lovingly styled and the makeup you had delicately applied but mostly at the dress that gave you a fluttery feeling in your stomach.
“No,” you say with a small shake of your head before you turn to look at your sister. “I made a promise so I should stick to it.”
Max looks at you before she smiles. “You look really pretty, by the way.”
Your face warms a little at the compliment but you try to hide it, walking over to Max to take your mom’s purse from her hands. “Not bad for a last minute wedding.”
The corner of Max’s mouth twitches before she walks over to you to carefully adjust one of your hair clips. “You promise to be nice to Steve? Give him a chance to prove himself?”
“Max—”
Max cuts you off with your name and you look back at her carefully. “I’m serious. I want you two to get along. You’re important to me, he’s important to me.”
You feel yourself soften, just a little. Because if something mattered to your little sister, it mattered to you too.
“Just don’t—don’t tell him I said that,” Max adds.
You fight back a smile. “I won’t.”
It was five minutes later when there was a knock at the front door. Your stomach turned nervously as Max ran to answer it.
“You look great,” your mom smiles reassuringly. You smile back—not entirely knowing why you felt so nervous. This was just Steve. Just Steve—the guy who just last week you had yelled at for breathing too loud. Just Steve—the guy you were now going to a damn wedding with.
You take a deep breath before bidding your mom goodbye and following the voices of Max and Steve out of your room.
“—is the tie the right colour?” You hear Steve ask Max, a nervous edge to his voice. “‘Pale green’ was right of vague, I had to—”
“—you don’t need to match with her dress, it’s not prom, Steve—”
“—but I thought—”
You walk into the open plan living room and suddenly, Steve stops talking.
In fact, Steve Harrington seems to stop breathing as he looks at you.
He was looking at you in a way that took your breath away for a few short seconds before you remember just how infuriating you thought he was. But for a brief moment, you allow yourself to look at Steve—really look at him—and admire just how nice he looked. He had always been good looking, even you could admit that, but right now with his wide hazel eyes, parted lips and the suit he was wearing—the tie of which almost perfectly matched your dress—he looked stupidly handsome. The kind of handsome that made your stomach tighten.
The moment the thought enters your mind, heat spreads throughout your body. You determinedly ignore it.
“You’re late,” you say by way of a hello, hoping your voice doesn’t give any indication that you felt nothing but apathy for the man in front of you. “You know it’s rude to show up after the bride?”
Steve blinks, seeming to snap out of whatever momentary trance you had sent him in so that he could frown at your words.
“It was the tie! And there was some construction near the—”
“—still. You’re late.”
Steve seems to bite his tongue with whatever retort he had ready to go, his eyes flickering over to match who Max watches the exchange, thoroughly entertained.
“Ready to go?” Steve asks you, choosing to ignore your remark as he steps towards the door.
You nod, opening your mom’s purse to check you had your lip gloss and some extra hair clips before looking back at Steve. “Yeah. Ready to—”
“—wait!” Max exclaims and you know what was coming before she even opens her mouth. “Let me just go grab the camera. I want this moment framed.”
Neither of you stop yourself from groaning loudly at that.
The drive to the wedding venue took a little over an hour and the car ride with Steve was almost completely silent, save for the radio that seemed to be the saving grace of the journey.
It dawned on you that you hadn’t ever really spent one on one time with Steve before. Sure, you two had been through a lot together when it came to the upside down, but you had never hung out, not really. But now—you face the prospect of spending the entire day together. At a wedding, no less.
One thing you quickly learned about Steve was that he hummed while listening to music. A lot. Like it was beginning to grate on you kind of a lot.
“Do you have to hum while listening to music?” You ask him in a terse voice after almost thirty minutes of biting your tongue.
You watch Steve stiffen slightly out of the corner of your eye, watch the way his knuckles tighten around his steering wheel and you register the instant ceasing of his humming.
“It’s my car,” Steve points out. “I can hum in my car if I want.”
You open your mouth to snap at him, to tell him that his humming was incredibly annoying and to tell him to stop. But then you thought of Max, you thought of your promise to her that you’d try to be nice to Steve, that you would give him a chance. You find yourself pursing your lips, carefully considering your options before you decide to let this minor annoyance slip.
Baby steps.
But when Steve pulls his Beamer into a church car park that was swarming with pastel coloured dresses, fascinators and expensive suits, it felt more like diving headfirst into cold water than tentative baby steps.
“Are you ready for this?” Steve asks you gently, sensing your apprehension as you make no move to leave the safety of his car.
You swallow nervously, soothing down your dress as you nod because suddenly, you were acutely aware of the fact that your dress cost less than thirty dollars and that your heels were scuffed, owing to the fact you had bought them secondhand from a thrift store.
“Yeah,” you lie because Hawkins was over an hour away and both you and Max had put too much effort in your appearance to turn back now. But as Steve’s hand moves to open the door, you add, “it’s just—I’m not—I’m not great with family.”
Steve’s hand stops mid-air, inches away from the door handle as he looks over at you carefully before the corners of his mouth lift into something akin to a smile. “That makes two of us,” Steve tells you. “So don’t worry. My parents hate everyone. Just don’t take it personally and you’ll be fine.”
You almost laugh. Almost.
To his credit, the moment that you finally stepped out of his car, Steve was right by your side. His hand, though tentative, rests on the small of your back as you walk towards the church, gravel crunching beneath your shoes. You were already regretting the heels.
As you walk by throngs of Steve’s relatives, he gives you a very quick run down of who’s who while you try to keep up.”
“That’s my uncle Simon,” Steve tells you, nodding to a man in a suit that looked so expensive that you briefly wondered if you were even allowed to look at it. “Been married like three times. Doesn’t seem to understand what monogamy is.”
You bit back a laugh.
“That’s my great aunt Sara—”
“—great aunt?” You repeat, looking at the women Steve had subtly pointed to who did not look old enough to even be considered a great aunt. “Are you sure she’s—”
“—she had a face lift,” Steve explains and you nod slowly. “Well, we all suspect she’s had a face lift. She’s never actually said. She just keeps saying it’s because slathers herself in honey or egg whites every morning.”
Another laugh you had to fight back.
Steve was just telling you about some falling out between his grandmother and cousin as someone calls his name. Steve stops talking mid-sentence to look over at who had called out his name and smiles.
“And this,” he murmurs to you as a woman with a kind, heart shaped face and bright smile approaches. “Is my aunt Edith. She’s a bit much but—”
“Stevie! Oh, look at you!”
You watch in fascination as Steve Harrington—the guy who had been known as King Steve, the guy who had once held a keg stand record for almost three years—turns bright red.
“Edith—”
“—what?” Edith beams at the sight of Steve, carefully adjusting his blazer and fusing over his tie. “Is it a crime now to say hello to my favourite nephew?”
Steve doesn’t respond as even the tips of his ears turn red but his aunt doesn’t tease him any further, instead her soft eyes shift over to you.
“And who is this beautiful young lady?” Edith asks, her gaze so warm and friendly that you couldn’t help but smile at her. “Steve, is this your—”
“—friend,” Steve says quickly and with a quick glance over at you. “Just a friend.”
In any other circumstances, you would have corrected Steve if he referred to you as a friend but you let it slide. Baby steps.
“And a friendship is a beautiful foundation for a relationship,” Edith says to a blushing Steve before she looks back at you. “I’m only teasing him, honey. Don’t look so worried.”
You let out a breathy laugh before shaking your head. “No, go ahead. Tease away. I didn’t know he could turn that shade of red.”
Edith laughs and despite Steve rolling his eyes, he lets out a reluctant chuckle.
“Oh, I like her already.”
The corner of Steve’s mouth twitches before he tells Edith your name and you can’t help but notice the flash of recognition in her eyes when she hears Steve reel off your last name. You can’t blame her. The surname Mayfield and the names of your family had been splashed all over the newspapers after Starcourt, Billy's death.
But Edith doesn’t say anything, which you appreciate.
“You two should probably head inside,” Edith tells you with a nod towards the church. “Or you might be in danger of being run over by the bride.”
You let Steve guide you inside, his hand still on your back as you enter the church.
“Sorry about Edith,” Steve says as you walk towards the church pews. “She’s really—”
“—she was lovely,” you tell Steve. “Really. She wasn’t too much at all.”
Steve nods but you can see the look of quiet gratitude in his eyes.
You sit down in the pews beside Steve, becoming acutely aware of his thigh pressing against yours, of the way he was tapping his finger rhythmically against his thigh as his eyes darted around the church. You knew without asking that he was looking for his parents.
“By the way,” Steve murmurs after a moment, his eyes shifting back to you. “I forgot to say earlier but you look—”
But Steve was cut off by a sudden swell of music that signalled the arrival of the bride and whatever he was about to say dies on his tongue.
As Daisy met her soon to be husband at the altar and the ceremony began, you tried your very best to remain present. But as your eyes flickered around the church, something swirled in your gut. The realisation that the last time you had been in a church—albiet, nowhere near as extravagant as this—had been at Billy’s funeral.
Despite the fact you hadn’t been very close with Billy nor had you even remotely liked your step-brother, Billy’s death had affected you more than you cared to admit. It wasn’t just because of what had happened to your family in the immediate aftermath of Billy’s death, when your step-dad had left Hawkins and took every bit of stability you had left with him. It was also the immense guilt and complicated things that you found yourself feeling that had made Billy’s death difficult to navigate, guilt that you felt for surviving Starcourt when Billy didn’t, guilt for also feeling so much resentment towards Billy when he had been alive for making your and Max’s life miserable but deep down, desperately things had been different for him.
But most of all, the thing that had been the most difficult about Billy’s death? It was seeing how it had affected Max and the crushing realisation that came the moment you had heard her scream out Billy’s name—was that, try as you might, you couldn’t protect Max from everything.
And so, as you sat beside Steve Harrington in the pews you were barely listening to Daisy and her soon to be husband Dale exchange their vows. And you even miss Steve sniffling quietly beside you.
After the ceremony—of which, you remember very little—you and Steve make the short journey to the reception which would be held at a magnificent farmhouse outside of which there was a beautiful rose garden. You would have thought it a truly breathtaking sight if you still weren’t so in your own head, still thinking about Billy, of the funeral and Max.
Though he wasn’t saying anything, Steve could tell something was wrong. The small rapport you had built before the ceremony had vanished, you didn’t even complain when he had ordered you the wrong drink by accident.
“Okay,” Steve sighs, looking at your expression carefully after pulling you to the side of the bar. “You gonna tell me what’s up? Did I do something or—”
You blink, looking at Steve as though only just seeing him properly for the first time.
“I haven’t—I haven’t been in a church since—” you stop yourself, averting your eyes in favour of watching a few of Steve’s smaller cousins running around to distract yourself from the slight burn you were feeling behind your eyes.
You miss how Steve’s eyes soften, how his expression shifts and how he half raises his hand as though he had to stop himself from reaching for you.
“Oh,” he says softly, so softly that you barely recognise his voice and you have to look at him just to be sure it was really Steve. “I didn’t—I didn’t even think. I’m sorry. I—”
“—it’s okay,” you say quickly, forcing a smile onto your face as you look back at Steve. “I’m okay. It was a really beautiful ceremony.”
Steve looks at you and there was a brief moment where you thought that he was just going to drop it. That he wasn’t going to push you to talk but he said your name in that new, soft voice and you knew you weren’t going to get away that easily.
“—I know I’m not your favourite person in the world but you know you can talk to me about—”
“—Steven! We’ve been looking everywhere for you!”
You watch as Steve’s face almost completely drains of colour.
“Fuck,” Steve mutters to you as your peer over his shoulder to see a couple—who were undoubtedly his parents—striding towards to two of you. “Okay. It’s just my parent’s. It’s just my—”
“—oh, you must be Steven’s girlfriend!” Steve’s mother exclaims happily as both she and his father approach. You were so taken aback by the hug she pulled you into that you don’t even try to correct her on the fact you were not Steve’s girlfriend and Steve makes no attempt to correct her. Instead, his face reddens and he shoots you an apologetic smile.
That son of a—
“He had told us you were pretty but I don’t think you’d be—”
“—mom,” Steve mutters, his face now burning as he avoids direct eye contact with you, clearly not wanting to give away the fact that you definitely were not his girlfriend. But you didn’t care about it that much anymore, not when you had just learned that Steve Harrington had told his parents that you were pretty.
Steve introduces you to both his parents and, like Edith, you see the flash of recognition across their faces at your surname but unlike Edith, Steve’s parents didn’t let your name pass without acknowledgement.
“Oh dear,” his moms says kindly, placing a gentle hand on your arm that makes your stomach churn uncomfortably. “I thought I recognised your face. Billy Hagrove was your step-brother, right?”
You don’t trust yourself to talk and nor do you look at Steve as you nod.
“We’re terribly sorry for your loss,” his father says to you solemnly, though his expression does not change in the slightest. “Awful accident.”
You smile in acknowledgement but you aren’t quite sure what to say. Thank you? Everything you knew you should say when someone offered their condolences would sound insincere. Unnatural, even. But fortunately—or unfortunately—for you, Steve’s father continues talking.
“And for his father to leave the way he did, leaving your family, a single mother to struggle and live in a trailer park of all places—it must really be awful for your family. Being amongst drug dealers and god knows what else in that park!”
You swallow. It had been awful but you didn’t think much of Danny Harrington’s tone—of the fact he sounded more sorry that your family were living in a trailer park than grieving. You still had Max and your mom—even if she had started drinking to cope—and a roof over your heads. It was all you needed.
But before you could tell Steve’s father any of this, before you could even consider politely standing up for yourself, Steve Harrington got there first.
“Dad, let’s not—let’s not go there, okay?” Steve says, placing a hand on your back as if ready to steer you away from the conversation.
Danny Harrington, for a very brief moment, looks taken aback by his son’s words but had enough sense to understand the topic of Billy Hagrove and the Mayfield family was off limits.
“Very well,” he says with a small nod and a tight lipped smile. “Enjoy the evening, both of you.”
The moment his parents leave you and Steve standing at the side of the bar, you feel immense relief.
You breathe a sigh of relief, not even noticing how tense you had felt for the past two minutes as you turn towards Steve. “That was—”
“—I’m really sorry,” Steve cuts in, his hand leaving your back in order to scrub over his face. Before you could even ask what he was sorry for, he continues. “For making them think that you’re my girlfriend. I panicked a little and didn’t know what to say—”
“—Steve, it’s—”
“—and I’m sorry for butting in like that. I know you can stand up for yourself and you didn’t need me to—you know. I just—my dad he just—I couldn’t—I couldn’t just let him talk to you like that. Like he—”
“—Harrington.”
Steve swallows, looking back at you as though he was bracing himself, ready for you to yell at him for doing something for you that you were perfectly capable of doing yourself. But to his utter surprise, you start to smile at him.
“It’s okay,” you tell him gently. “I—I appreciate it. Really. It’s fine, don’t worry about it.”
Steve looks at you as if to make sure that you weren’t lying, his eyes on you making your stomach turn in a way that you weren’t used to around him.
“Okay,” Steve says with a grateful smile. “Okay. That—that’s good. I thought you were going to lose your shit at me for a second.”
“No,” you say, stopping yourself from smiling back at him. “But the girlfriend thing though, still undecided about that.”
Steve can’t help it, his face flushes a warm pink and before he knows it, he was laughing and you find yourself joining in.
Baby steps.
He says your name then and you look at him, the expression on his face as he looks at you makes the world around you feel a little fussy, makes your stomach flip and your cheeks grow hot.
“Yeah?” you reply in a voice that you hope doesn’t give away just how slightly flustered you were feeling.
“I wanted to—I forgot to say this earlier,” he begins, scratching the back of his neck as though he was nervous, despite the fact you didn’t think it at all possible for Steve Harrington to be nervous. “I think—you just—you look beautiful, Mayfield.”
You weren’t entirely sure why those words had such a monumental effect on you, but they did. Your breath hitches, your face feels ten times hotter and you were almost positive that Steve could hear your heart beating out of your chest because of those words.
“You look pretty good yourself, Steve,” you say with a small, barely there smile.
Steve blinks and then—
“You just called me Steve,” he says, the corners of his mouth lifting.
You shrug, you pretend it wasn’t a big deal.
Baby steps.
It was hard not to smile watching Steve twirl not one but two of his little cousins around, especially when their laughter was full of unbridled joy as they begged him for just one more spin around the dancefloor.
You sat at the table you and Steve had been convening at for the past few hours. The table where you had sat for the reception dinner with a handful of his cousins, where you had struggled to hold back tears at the speech by the father of the bride and Steve had placed a warm, comforting hand on your arm. Your skin was still tingling from his touch.
“Please Steve!” the youngest of his cousins, maybe five or six, pouted up at him. “Just one more!”
“Later,” Steve promises with a quick glance over at you. “Later, I promise!”
You were fighting back yet another smile at their whines of protest, at Steve ruffling their hair to make them squeal before walking back over to your table.
“What are you smiling at?” He asks, sitting down in the chair beside yours before taking a long swig of his beer.
“Nothing,” you say, hoping he doesn’t notice the warmth of your cheeks. “Just—you’re really good with kids.”
Even the colourful disco lights couldn’t conceal the impressive shade of red that Steve had turned at your words.
“Yeah, well, I’ve had a lot of practice,” Steve murmurs. “Kids are much easier when there’s no Upside Down involved.”
You laugh, which over a few courses of dinner had become something of a common occurrence with Steve. He had made you laugh a lot, more than you wanted to admit. You were beginning to think that Max was right, that perhaps you had been a little too harsh on Steve over the past few years and you even started to feel bad for not giving him a chance sooner. Not that you would ever admit that.
It’s quiet between the two of you then. You watch Steve’s fingers gently drum against the beer bottle in his hands and as he glances over at the dancefloor. You can’t help but look over too, remembering that you had told him no dancing. You found yourself suddenly regretting that part of the deal.
“You want another drink?” Steve asks you, setting down his now empty bottle of beer. “I can get you another—”
“—do you want to dance?”
The words slip out before you could second guess them and you feel your stomach tighten in apprehension. If Steve said no then you would surely have to move far, far away and—
“Yes,” Steve says quietly and with a nod. “I’d love to.”
You look at him to see he was smiling at you and you hate the fact his smile makes your stomach feel a little fussy inside.
“Just keep your hands to yourself,” you tell him with a faint smile as you stand up from your chair, Steve mirroring your action only a few seconds later.
“I’ll be a gentleman,” Steve tells you with a smile that makes you wonder why you had ever disliked him in the first place. “Promise.”
The moment you and Steve were finally on the dancefloor together, the rest of the wedding faded into nothing. From Cyndi Lauper, to a-ha to Elton John, you and Steve Harrington danced until your feet began to hurt. He spun you around, he laughed when you stumbled over your heels and you laughed when a drunken uncle of his had spilled whiskey all over his blazer. Your laughter quickly died when Steve had thrown his blazer aside, leaving him in his white shirt that he had unbuttoned while loosening his tie, giving you a peak at the hair that adorned his chest. Your throat felt a little try at the sight.
“Do my eyes deceive me,” Steve begins, smiling at you as Heaven Is A Place On Earth fades into Come On Eileen, “or are you checking me out, Miss Mayfield?”
You laugh like it was funny despite the fact you definitely had been checking him out.
“No,” you deny it with a laugh that causes the corners of Steve’s mouth to twitch. “Course not, Harrington.”
“Oh? Are we back to Harrington, now?” Steve asks in a teasing voice that makes you feel so hot it feels as though your stomach was suddenly made from molten lava. “What did I do? I’ve been nothing but a gentleman to you, Mayfield.”
It took you a moment to realise that he was flirting with you and as soon as you did the heat in your gut began to burn.
“Just keeping you on your toes,” you tell him, your eyes seeming to sparkle in the light as you look back at him.
Steve hums, unable to stop the smile from spreading over his face as he looks at you. “Misson accomplished.”
There was something in his eyes that seemed to hold you captive, you couldn’t move, could barely breathe and in that second, his eyes dip down to your lips.
“Mayfield, I—”
“—Steve!”
It was the voice of his younger cousins’, the ones he had promised another dance with. You watch as he has to force himself to look away from you, his eyes flickering back for a brief moment to apologise.
“It’s okay,” you tell him with a smile, ignoring the pang of disappointment that had taken refuge in your gut. “I’ll um, I’ll go get another drink while you—”
You gesture towards his younger cousins’ who were both tugging on his arms impatiently, demanding Steve’s attention. He shoots you one last apologetic look before he bends down to pick both squealing girls up with one only arm. You couldn’t deny the way your heart doubled in size at the sight.
You make your way over to the bar, passing by his parents who you avoid eye contact with while you order yourself another glass of wine and Steve another beer. You tap your nails against the wooden top of the bar, your eyes finding Steve dancing with his younger cousins’ easily.
“He’s always been great like that with kids.”
The sound of Steve’s Aunt Edith’s voice makes you jump, very nearly spilling Steve’s beer.
“Sorry honey,” she chortles, steading the bottle as you look away from Steve and over at her.
“It’s okay,” you say with a genuine smile because unlike Steve’s parents, Aunt Edith didn’t make you feel even remotely nervous. “Just took me by surprise, that’s all.”
“Becuase you were too busy staring at my nephew?” She offers with a wry smile.
Your face warms but you don’t even try to deny it.
“You know, I’ve seen my nephew with a fair few women over the years but I don’t think I’ve ever seen any who could make him blush like you have over the course of the evening,” she tells you.
You couldn’t stop the look of shock from passing over your face, your body buzzing with something you couldn’t quite put your finger on.
“I’m just saying,” she continues when you say nothing, your fingers still tapping nervously against the table, “that I think, as his favourite auntie, that you’d be pretty grear together.”
You weren’t quite sure what to say and perhaps Edith knew that because she smiled at you kindly before walking away.
Edith’s words play on your mind as you continue to watch Steve and his cousins. You couldn’t lie to yourself, couldn’t deny that the evening had made you see Steve in an entirely different light. It had also made you rethink the Steve you had been so rude to over the past few years; the Steve that always dropped Max back home without a second thought, the Steve that never drove off without ensuring she was safely back inside the trailer, the Steve that had some sort of stupid handshake with Dustin Henderson, the Steve that had brought you tea and made Max lumpy tomato soup after Billy’s funeral. Something inside you twisted as you remembered that fact you had never said thank you to him for doing that.
“You’re looking awfully pensive over here, Mayfield.”
The sound of Steve’s voice pulls you out of your thoughts but his presence does nothing to the swirl of emotions you were feeling.
“Just thinking,” you say finally, turning to face him with a small smile. “Here’s another beer, by the way.”
“Thank you,” Steve grins, taking the bottle from you. Your fingers brush against his and your body feels alive with something you had never had thought you would feel around Steve. “Need it after running around with those kids, I’m too old for this shit.”
You laugh and shake your head in amused disbelief. “You’re twenty one, Steve.”
“Twenty one going on seventy.”
You can barely contain your laughter at that and soon both you and Steve were laughing. You miss the way his eyes flicker down to your lips as you laugh, the way his cheeks flush a shade or so darker when you look over at him as the beginning notes of Heaven by Bryan Adams starts to play.
“I know you just got us some drinks,” Steve begins, setting his bottle down onto the bar and gently prying your own glass of wine from your hands. “But I really want to dance with my date.”
The way he said it, the look in his eyes, it was almost too much.
“Plus one,” you correct him, biting back a smile.
“Synmatics,” he says softly, smiling at you before he holds out a hand, palm up, for you to take. “Dance with me, Mayfield.”
There was no other answer but yes.
You let Steve pull you towards the dancefloor, the fluttering in your stomach making you feel almost dizzy as he wraps his arms around your waist while your arms loop around his neck. It was the closest you had ever been to Steve and all you could think about was how incredible he smelled, how you wanted to trace each and every mole that kissed his skin, how truly gorgeous he looked and how alive you suddenly felt in his presence.
“Ever thought that you’d be slow dancing with me?” He asks with a smile that very nearly takes your breath away.
“Not even in my wildest dreams,” you tell him, trying to cover up the fact your heart was beating so loud you were beginning to suspect it was trying to escape from its home in your chest. “But—I think today may have helped me change my mind about you.”
“Yeah?” He asks with a hopeful smile. “Or maybe you just finally realised how irresistible I am?”
You laugh and Steve smiles so hard that you were surprised that it didn’t hurt.
“Something like that.”
You and Steve didn’t leave the dancefloor for a long time after that. Even when the song changed to something more upbeat, you didn’t leave Steve’s arms. You slow danced to Madonna, Bruce Springsteen and Prince as guests left the wedding in their droves—the bride and groom sneaking away hours ago.
“You wanna head back?” Steve murmurs against your hair as you sway to Fleetwood Mac, the dancefloor around you significantly less busy as you pull back to look at him.
“Not really,” you admit quietly, trying to ignore how one of his large hands was resting on your lower back, how his touch had set your skin aflame. “But I think we’re about five minutes away from being kicked off the dancefloor.”
Steve chuckles, looking away from you for a moment to glance at the last few stranglers remaining with you two on the dancefloor. They were all incredibly drunk and you can see the amusement in Steve’s eyes as he looks back at you.
“C’mon,” he murmurs before he pulls himself away from you, though his hand remains on your back. “Let’s go for a walk.”
You follow him without hesitation, walking out of the farmhouse with Steve’s hand still on your back and your heart nearly beating out of your chest.
“I really thought you weren’t going to say yes, by the way,” Steve tells you as you walk over the path, between the red and yellow roses that were illuminated by the glittering lights strung up ahead. “To be my plus one, I mean.”
“I owed Max a favour,” you tell him. “Broke her skateboard. By accident.”
“She mentioned that,” Steve smiles fondly. “I think she thought going to a wedding with me was more tortuous for you.”
You shake your head as you stop in front of the soft pink roses to face him. “Twenty four hours ago, I might have agreed with her but, tonight—I have to admit, it’s been pretty good.”
“Just good?” Steve asks, head tilting to the side as he looks back at you with a smile.
“No, much better than pretty good,” you say. “Maybe something closer to…pretty incredible.”
“What? Me or the wedding?” Steve asks with a hopeful look back at you.
“Undecided,” you tell with a whisper of a smile.
Silence falls as you continue through the rose garden, the colourful flowers catching your eye as you pass by. But Steve’s eyes remain on you, thought you don’t see it—on the dress that he was sure to dream about, of just how fucking beautiful you looked and how glad he was that you had broken Max’s skateboard.
“For the record, I’m really glad you said yes,” Steve tells you, the hand on your back dipping lower for just a moment and making your insides turn to goo.
“Me too,” you admit. “I um—it made me realise how silly I was—for um, not giving you a chance before. And for you know, not being all that friendly with you.”
Steve says your name and you know by the look on his face that he wanted to tell you that it was okay, that it didn’t matter but you continued talking before he could do so.
“I think I’ve realised that Max may have been right when she said you really were a good guy. I just—I’m her big sister, you know? And—I get my back up a little when people talk bad about my family and I just—I struggled to let go of what you said.”
“Because it was cruel what I said,” Steve begins, slowing down until he stops walking completely, his hand on your back making you do that same. “It was cruel and stupid and I’m sorry. Like, really fucking sorry.”
“I know and—”
“—and if after this you want us to go back to normal then I totally understand and—”
“—Steve!”
“Yeah?”
You smile, shake your head and say, “I don’t want to go back to ‘normal’ after this.”
“Then what do you want?” He asks, hazel eyes twinkling beneath the lights.
You tilt your head to the side, considering him before you say, “another dance?”
Despite the fact there was no music, despite the fact you were in the middle of a rose garden and it was fast approaching midnight, Steve does not deny your request. Instead, he pulls you into his arms like he had on the dancefloor, his body so close to yours that there was barely an inch of space between you and you were very aware of his hand resting on your lower back.
“Did I tell you how beautiful you look?” Steve asks in a voice so soft and gentle that you had to lean in to hear him.
“You did,” you whisper back with a barely contained smile.
“Well, I wanna tell you again. You look fucking beautiful, Mayfield. The moment I saw you I thought—fuck, this wedding is gonna be torture.”
Your face warms and you laugh, leaning into Steve so you could feel his heart thumping loudly in his chest.
“Because I’m annoying?” You offer with a teasing smile.
“No,” Steve says quietly, one of his hands reaching up to tuck a strand of hair behind your ear carefully. “Because I’ve been wanting to kiss you all day, Mayfield. That’s why.”
Everything seems to slow around you. Time, the roses gently dancing in the wind beside you. You can barely believe the words coming out of Steve’s mouth but the way he was looking at you told you that this wasn’t a dream—that Steve Harrington had really admitted to wanting to kiss you.
And it was crazy because twenty four hours ago, you were tossing and turning in your sleep over the idea of today, of the prospect of spending an entire day with Steve at a wedding. And now, you were desperate to feel his lips against yours.
“Then kiss me, before I change my mind.”
Steve blinks, as if to make sure that he had heard you correctly before he pulls you even closer with one arm around your waist. The proximity to Steve makes you feel almost lightheaded, his woodsy, vanillary scent filling your lungs and the hand now cupping your cheek making your body thrum with need.
“As you wish,” he murmurs before he leans in and presses his lips against yours. That first brush of his lips against yours was so inviting, so intoxicating that you felt almost every nerve in your body come alive from the feeling. His mouth was warm, his lips soft and he was kissing like there was nowhere else he would rather be than right here in the rose garden with you.
You kiss him back with no hesitation, warmth seeping through your veins as he gently tilts your head back, coaxing your lips apart with his tongue and making you forget how to breathe. You could have kissed him all night, until the early hours of the morning if you could. Especially when his tongue brushed against yours, making you whine against his lips and tug him even closer.
“Fuck,” Steve murmurs against your lips, your mouths moving together in an almost desperate sort of way as your fingers curl into his shirt. “You’re gonna ruin me, Mayfield.”
You don’t know how long you stayed there, making out with Steve Harrington in the rose garden but all you knew as you finally pulled away from each other was that your lips were bee stung and his were wet and covered in your lip gloss. He had never looked so good.
“So much for keeping my hands to myself,” Steve grins as he reaches up to swipe his thumb across your swollen bottom lip. You roll your eyes and can’t help yourself—you pull him into another kiss that makes him groan against your mouth. The sound makes you feel incredibly glad that you had broken your sister’s skateboard.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
pluto and its sun | steve harrington
part one: the perpetual orbit
pairing: steve harrington x reader
word count: 15.6k
warnings: cursing and using alcohol as a coping mechanism
includes: heavy angst, self sabotaging!reader, yearner!steve, yearner!reader, eventual second chance romance, friends to lovers to exes to lovers, the world's most depressing wedding, maxsteve sibling moment for those who care.
summary: all you've ever known how to do is orbit steve harrington. all he's ever known is to love you. eventually hundreds of miles separate the two of you and yet your orbit never faulters. but a wedding and a flask filled with whiskey just might be the two things that implode your sun. loosely based off of the song 'parachute' by hayley williams
a/n: okay this was originally supposed to be one big one shot... but i decided to split it into two. this is depressing so sorry in advance. also shoutout to my wonderful lid!! @tinfoileddd for helping me with the title and letting me brainstorm ideas with her <3 i hope you all enjoy!
masterlist
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
There was a time in your life where the center of your universe was a five foot eleven hazel eyed boy from Hawkins. In the beginning you two were just kids who grew up in the same circles. Which meant you had mutual friends, were in the same homecoming group, and even sat at the same lunch table sometimes, but all of that meant nothing when Steve Harrington was the Sun and you were Pluto.
You were there, he knew you existed, but there were so many other planets that revolved around him. Ones that he gladly gave attention to, and because all you’ve ever known how to do was orbit Steve, you continue to sit at the lunch table and give him a pencil during Algebra only wishing you could be more like Mercury, wishing to be so close to him that it burned.
And you had become accustomed to that for so long that you had convinced yourself that this was all you were ever going to get from Steve. Fingertips that brushed as you passed him a pencil. The smell of his cologne as you stood next to him in front of Lisa Keller’s house for homecoming pictures with his hands on Mercury’s waist. His laughter at the lunch table, that brief moment of eye contact when he catches you laughing too, and the smile he shoots your way that makes your heart do a traitorous thing.
You think how lucky Mercury must be to have him like that all the time and you wonder if maybe one day once you’re out of Hawkins and no longer confined by his gravitational pull, that you’ll find a new star to orbit. One that would love you even if you are Pluto.
That all changes though on a chilly November night in 1983 when Will Byers goes missing and you find out that Hawkins is not what it seems and that your orbit is not as far away from the sun as you thought.
As the months and years pass and with each new battle Hawkins seems to find itself in Steve and you only grow closer. So close in fact that you don’t know where he ends and you begin and it becomes obvious that you’ve lost your original orbit. The thing about your orbit was that it kept you steady, kept you from becoming all consumed, but god if you didn’t love the feeling of hurling through space.
For the longest time you’d imagined what it would be like– to be Steve’s. In December of 1985 during a closing shift at Family Video he let’s you know he also wonders what it would be like to be yours.
It’s a Tuesday night, an hour before closing, and the bell that hangs above the entrance hasn’t chimed in the last two hours. There’s still a substantial amount of snow blanketing the ground and roads from the storm that rolled through Sunday and that only added to your usual lack of business after the sun set in the winter time. If it was up to you this place would close at eight, but you weren’t the boss, and admittingly you did like having the alone time with Steve. Even if you were sorting through old tapes and reshelving the horror section per Keith’s request.
“Maybe horror for our movie night this week?” you suggest, holding up a copy of Amityville.
Fifteen year old you would have died knowing that only three years later you’d be having weekly movie nights with Steve. That the King Steve, whose fall from grace was anything but graceful, was your person. Granted King Steve had been long gone for some time now and sometimes it’s hard to believe that the boy who stands in front of you with a green Family Video vest and a crooked name tag adorned on the front of it is the same untouchable boy from those years ago.
Steve looks up from the stack he’d been kind of going through on the cart and flashes you that smile that still makes you feel like you're that fifteen year old girl. “If you want to cuddle with me you don’t have to use the excuse of some lame horror movie to do it.”
That teasing, flirting, the sly smirk on his face, it’s times like now where you realize his old habits do die hard and that there are parts of King Steve that still live in him, but it’s the good parts. The parts that make you giddy and the butterflies in your stomach to kick with such force you feel your stomach flip. The boy that stands in front of you is the same person as the older version you knew of him, but just more himself in the best way possible. And everyday you thank your lucky stars that you’re able to have Steve in your life like this.
“Right so when I have to turn on the lamp again because you thought you saw something in the corner of the room I’ll be sure to hold you extra tight,” you tease, slotting the movie into its correct place onto the shelf.
“It was one time!”
Your soft laughter eventually dies down until all that fills the void is the buzz from the overhead lights and the ticking of the clock on the wall. The two of you work in silence, wanting to actually get this done before you have to leave, not wanting to hear Keith complaining about you two being lazy while he’s got cheese ball dust caked under his fingernails.
The clock ticks louder on the wall, like a constant reminder that your time with Steve for the day is running out, and you think that you’ll never get enough of Steve. That he could crawl under your skin and live there and you’d still want more of him. Especially when you can feel his eyes flickering over at you every so often, lingering long enough for you to feel it, but not long enough for you to catch him in the act. It’s embarrassing to say that it’s making you blush slightly, but you quite literally used to look forward to Steve asking you for a pencil during class just so you could feel the slight brush of his fingers against yours and then savored that feeling until the next time. So, blushing over him playing eye tag with you was not the most embarrassing thing you’ve done when it came to Steve.
About ten minutes before close Steve mumbles something about being right back. When the bell above the entrance rings you know exactly what he’s doing and a few seconds later you hear your car start out front. You focus on transferring the last few tapes from the cart and back onto the shelves, trying to ignore how the blush on your cheeks has now spread throughout your body.
The bell rings again and you can feel the cold air rush in just as fast as him, like he doesn’t want you to know what he’s done, doesn’t want to make a big deal out of it. Steve just does things like that so effortlessly– without a second thought. You notice very early on in whatever you want to call your relationship with him that he only does stuff like that for you. Even in school when you hyperfocused on every little thing he did with Mercury he was never as attentive with her as he is with you and it makes your head spin.
Eventually the clock strikes eleven and the neon light in the window fades to black as Steve locks the doors behind you. The cold winter air bites at the apples of your cheeks and the snow crunches beneath your feet as you walk at what could be considered a snail’s pace to your car, with Steve alongside you of course. He was adamant about walking you to your car when you two closed together, even though you two literally parked not even ten feet away from the store. You clearly didn’t mind it, greedily taking advantage of every second you could get with him.
“You know you don’t have to do this for me,” you say softly as the two of you linger by your car.
“Do what?” Steve questions with that sly smirk on his face that you love more than you should.
“Oh right sorry– I keep forgetting that my car magically starts on its own.”
“That’s a real fancy car you got. Don’t know how you can afford it on $3.25 an hour.”
You roll your eyes at him, but there’s no real malice behind it, if anything it’s fondness. “Thank you Steve– for real.”
He shrugs his shoulders, his hands stuffed in the pockets of his coat. “It’s no big deal, but you’re welcome.”
On any other night this would be the moment that you would tell him that you’d see him tomorrow, get in your car, and drive home. Your hand is already on the door handle, the cold metal doing nothing to help your already freezing fingers, but something in you is telling you to stay for another minute. To turn around and stay out in the cold for just a little bit longer. Maybe it’s a sign from above protecting you from a horrible car wreck or maybe it’s the feeling of Steve’s eyes burning into the back of your head, like he’s trying to tell you to stay without really saying it, but either way you turn on your heel, the snow crunching underneath your sneakers, and come face to face with Steve.
Wind whips through the barren parking lot making the cold settle deeper into your bones and you can see that it's already turned the tip of Steve’s nose and the tops of his cheeks red. He lets out a long exhale once the two of you make eye contact, like he’d been waiting for you to turn around, hoping that you wouldn’t get in your car and leave him standing here.
Steve can’t believe he’s about ready to ask you this in the middle of the Family Video parking lot, but you've turned around and willed his thoughts to come true, so now he has to follow through with it. He’s chickened out one too many times before and god help him if this was where he was supposed to finally work up the courage to ask you, then so be it.
He’s rehearsed this a million times, thought about it at night until his alarm clock read an obscenely late time, and now that the time has come everything he’s wanted to say goes right out the window and is reduced to six words.
“Have you ever thought about us?”
His question hits you like a tidal wave and the sound of your heartbeat in your ears makes you feel like you’re caught in that wave, constantly being held under by the rip current, your chest burning from having to hold your breath. The feeling sits there for an uncomfortable amount of time and it’s not until you see Steve start to turn in on himself, embarrassment written all over his face at your lack of reply, that your head finally breaks through to the surface gasping for air.
“Have you?”
You’re turning the question back on him, but you can’t help it. Even though you know Steve isn’t the same golden boy you shamelessly fawned over for years, the boy who you never thought would give you the time of day, there is still that part of you that fears this is all too good to be true. That there’s no way Steve could ever feel the same way you do about him. So, instead of making a fool of yourself when it turns out his words didn’t hold the same meaning you thought they did– you force him to answer first.
“Yes,” he answers simply and then with an airy laugh continues. “All the time actually. Can’t get you out of my head.”
You find yourself leaning against your car, not trusting yourself to be able to stand on your own. At fifteen you had convinced yourself that you were fine with admiring Steve from a distance, that as long as you could have those small interactions with him you were content. At sixteen you convinced yourself that you were fine with just being best friends with Steve, that as long as you could have him close you didn’t need to actually have him to be happy. Now at seventeen you’re trying to convince yourself that Steve Harrington does in fact feel the same way you do about him and when you continue your questionnaire everything you thought you knew blows up in your face.
“How long?” you ask quietly, like you two are in a crowded room and not in the middle of an empty parking lot. “How long Steve?”
“Are you asking how long you’ve been consuming my mind? Or are you asking how long I’ve thought about what it would be like to be yours?”
He asks it so casually, like this confession isn’t changing things forever between the two of you.
“Both.”
He inches closer to you, close enough that he can reach out and take his warm hand in your freezing one. The feeling of his hand in yours, the way his big hazel eyes seemingly stare straight into your soul– it makes your head spin.
“I’ve always noticed you Y/N. I’ve always thought you were so pretty and funny in a way not many people appreciated. That day your freshman year when Heather invited you to sit at our lunch table was a day I’ll never forget. And everyday since then when I would I catch your eye or heard your laugh it put such a funny feeling in my chest.”
Steve shakes his head, pausing for a moment as laughs to himself slightly, like he can’t believe that he’s admitting all of this right now.
You sure as hell can’t believe he’s admitting it either.
He takes a deep breath, squeezes your hands in his again and then continues.
“I mean fuck did you really think I didn’t have a pencil on me almost every single Algebra class for that year? I was just using it as an excuse to have any little bit of interaction with you, but I never specifically seeked you out because I didn’t think you were interested in me. Didn’t think you’d like the kind of guy I was back then. But then all the shit with the Upside Down happened and we got thrown into the mess together and now I can’t imagine my life without you in it. If I thought my thoughts about you before were all consuming then I don’t even want to know what they’d be considered now.”
Steve realizes he’s rambling and reels himself back in with a sheepish smile.
“I just– what I’m trying to say is that I’m an idiot who’s had feelings for you for way too long and I’m finally admitting it because I can’t stand to just have you as a best friend when I want you as something much more than that.”
It’s not just the cold air that you’re breathing in that is making your lungs burn– it’s you realizing that you never needed to be more like Mercury. The Sun saw you even when you felt like you were the furthest you could be from him.
“I was going through an astronomical amount of pencils that year, but I’d say it was worth it,” you reply with a big grin stretching across your face.
Steve mirrors your expression, the weight on his chest lifting when he sees you smiling. “Yeah?”
“The amount of times I went into Melvalds for pencils was a little concerning. At one point Joyce asked me why I was going through so many and I lied and told her I was writing a novel.”
The laughter that ripples through Steve’s chest is like music to your ears and a little part of you still wants to pinch yourself to see if this is real.
“Is that so?” Steve questions.
“I couldn’t let her know that I was buying them out of pencils because the boy I had a massive crush on would ask for one like every day and I never wanted to not have an extra on me.”
Steve’s heart swells and he wants to punch himself for waiting so long to do this.
“Well how could I ever repay you for all those pencils?” his tone is slightly teasing as his hands rest on your hips, gently caging you against your car.
“Hmmm. I think I might have an idea.”
You kiss Steve Harrington for the first time in the middle of the Family Video parking lot. There’s snow on the ground and your fingertips are freezing, but the fire that ignites in you when you feel his lips on yours has you feeling like it's the middle of July.
And you realize that this is what it finally feels like to be close to the Sun.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
Being with Steve is everything you could have imagined and more. He’s attentive and caring and honestly everything you could have ever asked for in a boyfriend. He makes life easier and when shit hits the fan again in Hawkins he’s right there beside you the whole time.
And you don’t know if it’s because you two are faced with what is the most challenging fight you’ve had yet or the fact that Steve suffered his worst injury and you’re both a little scared that maybe you won’t make it out of this one alive. But the topic of your future together gets brought up and when Steve mentions something about having a brood of children the idea doesn’t scare you. Alright, maybe his idea of six is a little extreme, but you could see yourself in the future having little versions of him and you running around. You in a white dress with a shiny ring on your finger, the people you love most bearing witness to such a sacred ceremony of true love.
In a stolen RV on the way to what might be your inevitable death you come to the conclusion that doing those things with Steve– getting married and having kids. It is something you would want with him.
But then Hawkins gets put in lockdown and well your future is stuck in limbo. College is put on hold for the foreseeable future and you think that maybe it was a blessing in disguise because even though you had been accepted into Indiana University and had plans of getting into their school of medicine– those plans were never really yours. It’s always what your parents had wanted for you and you’d never been one to really know what you wanted in life, so you went along with it, wanting to make them happy. But as the years in high school passed and the idea of what you were getting yourself into became more of a reality, well you felt like a rat in a cage. The lockdown helped ease the panic for a little bit, but the thing about a caged rat is that it never stops feeling caged and the walls built around Hawkins weren’t big enough for what you realized you wanted for yourself.
The crawls, smuggling in contraband, relaying secret messages through the radio station that Steve and you seemed to live at– this wasn’t how you imagined your early adulthood to look like. Sure you loved playing apocalyptic house with Steve and in the grand scheme of things you two had only grown closer over those eight months, to the point where once all of this was over he’d thought about just renting that RV he talked about and getting a head start on your future together.
But when it’s all said and done and Vecna and the Upside Down are gone and real life quickly funnels its way back in you realize that Steve and you are in two very different stages of life.
It starts as pillow talk and before you know it there’s tears streaming down your face and a horrible feeling in your gut that maybe what you thought would be forever with Steve would only turn out to be a chapter. When you tell him that in six months you’re planning on going to NYU instead of IU you should have known he wouldn’t take it very well, in fact you knew he wouldn’t take it well, and you’d prepared yourself for it. You just hadn’t prepared yourself for the inevitable realization that your orbit around the sun might have swung too far out and there’s nothing there to pull you back in.
All you’ve ever known is Hawkins and for the longest time all you’ve ever known is Steve. He’s your safe space, the person you love and trust the most. You two have been through hell and back multiple times and you think maybe that’s why this hurts more than it would if it was some other boy you met in high school. Because you two have a bond that goes deeper than anyone could imagine.
At the end of the day it’s put in front of you very clearly.
You want to find out who you are outside of Hawkins, want to make a life for yourself that isn’t your parents dream, and you still love Steve.
Steve hates the idea of leaving Hawkins permanently because it’s all he’s ever known, he’s more than content with living the life he’s imagined for himself (and you) in the fixer upper on the corner of Sycamore and Vine that he’s been eyeing since December, and he still loves you.
And because Steve loves you he’s never going to hold you back from doing what you want to do. So, you two try to make long distance work. It’s hard, even with your parents funding your flights home the distance takes its toll, and when you come home for Christmas break you two break up.
You saw it coming, knew it was inevitable, and honestly it wasn’t just the miles between you that contributed to the breakup, it was feeling like you two were on different paths, and maybe some other things you weren’t ready to address yet internally. It hurt more than you could ever describe because even if you two didn’t want the same things– you still loved him.
You’ll never not love Steve Harrington.
And even when Pluto is casted out as a dwarf planet and no longer considered a major planet– she still orbits the sun anyways.
That following spring you don’t come home for the kid’s graduation and when your Mom calls you that following morning to check in like she always does on Sundays she of course lets it slip that she ran into Steve at graduation. She claimed he was doing well and that he even got a job at the school. You tell her that’s great through gritted teeth and a searing pain through the still fresh wound on your heart. She asks when you’ll be home, you say you don’t know and that’s the whole conversation. You put the phone back on the receiver and wish that the universe in your heart would be swallowed by a black hole.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
On August 3rd, 1993 Steve walks to his mailbox like he does every morning and retrieves his mail. He mindlessly sorts through it– junk mail, his outrageous electric bill, his neighbors water bill, coupons for Bradley’s, and then his eyes land on a crisp white envelope. He nearly does a double take, confused as to who is sending him something so official and fancy.
Mr. Steven Harrington
465 Park Street
Hawkins, IN 46952
There’s no return address, but something in him already knows who this is from, and part of him has the nerve to not even open it and just throw it in the trash. He doesn’t though, he slowly walks back up his driveway, back into his house, and it’s not until he’s safely sat at the kitchen table that he opens the envelope.
PLEASE JOIN US IN CELEBRATING THE WEDDING OF
CHRISTOPHER CARTER
&
Y/N Y/L/N
Saturday October 17th, 1993
At 3 o’clock
Laurel Hill
5395 Emerson Way
Indianapolis, IN 46226
There’s a ringing in Steve’s ears that resembles all the times he’d taken a particularly hard blow to the head during his years of trying to save Hawkins, but he thinks another beating from Billy Hargrove would hurt less than how he feels right now. The news shouldn’t come as a surprise to him, he’d heard from Robin a couple years ago that you were seeing someone and then that you were engaged and well that was a rough pill to swallow. And of course in true Robin fashion she always gave out more information than Steve would have cared to know.
This guy– he’s everything your parents would have wanted for you and more. Comes from money, majored in political science at Columbia, also from Indiana which explains the wedding being back home, and to top it all off Robin claimed he was really nice. Which made Steve feel even worse because Robin just didn’t go around saying that about every person she met.
The fact that everyone else in your ragtag group of friends had met and apparently approved of this Chris didn’t help the ache in Steve’s chest either. Robin, Nancy, Jonathan, and you all being a couple hours from each other kept you all close, while Steve felt like the outcast of the group back in Hawkins. And yes he knows life happens, people move on and grow up, but the fact that all four of you still kept in touch and the only one he talked to was Robin hurt more than he’d like to admit.
In fact Steve hasn’t talked to you in five years.
Five years of failed relationships, meaningless hookups, and looking for you in every girl he sees. You’d left such a lasting mark on him that it was starting to get pathetic and you’d clearly moved on– so why couldn’t he?
The proof of your heart belonging to another man was in his shaking hands and he still couldn’t help but think about what life could have been like if he hadn’t let you go, if he tried to make things work when you came home that Christmas.
He’d like to think it would be his name next to yours on that invitation, but that’s a dream that’s already been tarnished.
The clock on the wall reads 10:02 a.m.
Robin picks up the phone at 10:03 a.m.
“I need you to tell me this isn’t real. Tell me she’s not getting married.”
It’s real. He knows it is. He knew you were engaged, but holy fuck if he wasn’t holding on to the smallest bit of hope that it would fall through.
“Steve….”
“Robin.”
There’s static on her end, a sigh, and then. “It’s real Steve. She’s getting married to Chris. I’m sorry.”
The old wooden dining chair creaks under Steve as he slumps against the back of it, the invitation still gripped tightly in his other hand. “Why did she invite me?”
“Believe it or not she still cares about you. Still asks how you’re doing from time to time. When she asked me whether or not she should invite you– I told her yes.”
“And why the hell would you do that?” he bites back at her.
“You don’t have to come, but I honestly think she’d like to see you. It’s been five years Steve.”
It’s been five years but Steve swears sometimes it feels like it was just yesterday.
His eyes glance back down at the invitation in his hand as his finger traces the embossed lettering of your name. All he ever wanted was for you to be happy and he always thought he’d be a part of that happiness, but he’d let you go. He let you go find yourself and in the process you found someone else that made you feel the same way he used to.
“Does he make her happy?”
Robin doesn’t respond for what starts to be an uncomfortable amount of time and then finally with a sigh she tells Steve what he does and doesn’t want to hear.
“Yeah he does. He makes her happy.”
Something twists in Steve’s chest– sharp and painful. The invitation gets tossed onto the table with the rest of the mail and he gets up from the creaking chair with an urgency he hasn’t had since he was fighting demogorgons.
“Glad to hear. I’ll talk to you later. Gotta get to work.”
It’s August 3rd. School doesn’t start for another couple weeks and it’s also ten in the morning meaning Steve would have been extremely late for work. All things Robin knows but doesn’t get the chance to comment on because Steve’s slamming the phone back on the receiver so hard that it nearly comes off the kitchen wall.
Steve’s not mad. He's upset. He’s got five years of unresolved feelings bubbling to the surface over a fancily addressed envelope and seeing your name next to another man’s– inviting him to come bare witness to your eternal love.
His hands haven’t stopped shaking and he finds himself rummaging through the cabinet for that dark amber liquid that could numb the feelings he didn’t have the capacity to handle right now. He doesn’t even bother grabbing a glass. If he was going to drink at ten in the morning then he might as well be as uncouth as he can– choosing to bring the bottle straight to his lips and letting his chosen vice begin to work its magic.
Steve eventually finds himself in his room. One hand still has an iron grip on the neck of the whiskey bottle while the other haphazardly shuffles through the clothes once neatly hung in his closet. He lets out something that resembles more of a grunt than a hum once he finds what he’s looking for and then tosses it onto his bed.
The formal suit stares back at him, taunting him in ways only he could understand. He isn’t drunk enough to talk back to it yet. So, he brings the bottle back up to his lips and takes a long swig while his eyes are still locked onto the article of clothing.
He mumbles something incoherent at it, something he isn’t even sure he understands, and then sits down on the bed next to it. Which is where he spends the rest of his day drowning his sorrows.
The next morning he mails back the RSVP with a splitting headache.
Please Respond
RSVP by September 1st, 1993
Steven Harrington
accepts with pleasure declines with regret
Plus one? YES NO
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
It was easier to blame the pit in your stomach and the crushing weight sitting on your chest on the flower fiasco (because the florist arriving with red roses instead of white would ruin everything at least in your Mom’s eyes) instead of addressing the real reasons.
Today was your big day. The day that you’d been planning meticulously for the last year– the color of the napkins, if you should have chicken or fish, red velvet or vanilla cake, what font should be used on the name placards and if they should coincide with the color of the table cloths they will sit on.
Everything was planned out down to the tiniest detail and save for the flowers, which were not the massive deal your Mom had made it out to be, everything else had gone off without a hitch. It looked beautiful, like something you could only dream of.
And that should help calm your nerves at least a little.
Right?
You were marrying a good man. Chris made you happy, your friends liked him, and your parents loved him. He made you feel safe and a future with someone like him was something girls were more than envious of.
So the fact that you were on the verge of a breakdown with less than an hour left until you were set to walk down the aisle was a little concerning.
Your dress– the one that had been hand designed by some French lady who flew into New York courtesy of Chris’s Mom– felt like it was two sizes too small and every time you tried to take a breath it kept getting tighter. Your bridesmaids had left you alone in the dressing room not even ten minutes ago and in those minutes you’d worked yourself up into a panic attack.
These feelings though hadn’t just popped up suddenly. They’d been bubbling under the surface for weeks now— ever since you got a certain RSVP back in the mail. You thought that inviting him might tie up some loose ends you still have internally, but receiving his response had only unraveled them. It had been five years since you spoke to Steve and now the first time you were going to see him since you had broken up was going to be on your wedding day.
The day you’d once hoped to share with him.
No. You can’t think about that right now. You can’t think about how you’ve only ever imagined marrying one man and that it wasn’t the one on the opposite end of the building getting ready right now.
You smooth the front of your dress with your sweaty palms for the hundredth time and try to take a deep breath, try to talk yourself off this very dangerous ledge to be dangling from right now. You don’t dare catch a glimpse of yourself in the mirror, knowing the moment you see yourself trying to keep it together, the less than thrilled look on your face on what is supposed to be the happiest day of your life, it will break the dam of tears you’ve so tactfully held back.
This was something every bride went through, it was just a little bit of cold feet, at least that’s what you keep telling yourself.
There’s a soft knock on the door and it makes you freeze, your breath catching in your throat. You didn’t want anyone to see you like this, but then you see your Mom peek her head in and the breath you’ve been holding in shakily comes out.
“Hi honey,” she says softly as she closes the door behind her. “How’s my girl? Feeling a little nervous?”
You were far from nervous. The incessant pounding of your heart against your ribcage and the heavy feeling of impending regret that floods your nervous system was not just you feeling nervous.
“Mom I don’t–”
Your dress is suffocating you and you’re to the point where you reach behind you and start clawing at the corset Robin had so expertly laced up earlier. Your perfectly manicured fingers slip past the silk each time you grab at it, unable to free yourself from the rib crushing material.
It’s a sight to see– you panicking like a rat stuck in a hot cage whose only way out is to dig through your metaphorical stomach while your Mom stands there watching you.
A cry of defeat slips past your lips once you finally give up, your arms aching and sweat beading at your brow.
“Mom,” your voice cracks something awful and the realization hits you like a ton of bricks. “I can’t do this. I can’t marry him.”
“Yes you can,” her reply is instant and sure, like there’s no other option that could have crossed her mind. “This is all just some wedding day jitters. You just need to take a deep breath, maybe have a little drink. You want some wine? I can get you a glass of wine and it will take the edge off real quick.”
She’s already turning back towards the door and it makes you even more manic.
“I don’t want wine!”
If you needed alcohol to get you through what is supposed to be the happiest day of your life, well then that’s a sign right there that you shouldn’t be doing this.
She stops dead in her tracks at the sharpness of your voice, but doesn’t turn back towards you yet, she’s waiting for the other shoe to drop.
“I want to take this dress off. I need to take this dress off because I’m not getting married today.”
You watch as she turns toward you slowly and the look in her eye is something you’ve seen one too many times before. It makes your already rolling stomach flip in ways you’ve never felt and her gentle touch on your arms does nothing to bring you back from the ledge.
“Honey, you’re going to get married today. You’re going to take some deep breaths, have a little wine, and I promise you’ll feel so much better.”
You can feel your bottom lip starting to tremble as you shake your head in defiance at her.
“You love him Y/N. I’ve never seen you happier than when you’re with him. He’s good to you and he can provide for you. I’m not going to let you regret ruining your future again over such a rash decision– over feeling a little nervous. This is what you’ve been planning for the past year, what you’ve been looking forward to, what Chris has been looking forward to.”
Her hands fidget with your hair for a moment, always making sure you look your best, before they intertwine with yours. “Trust me baby,” she squeezes your hands like she’s really trying to get you to listen to her. “You want this–you just have to get out of your head.”
The first tear falls from your eye and drags a path through your once flawless makeup.
This was never what you wanted. This was what she wanted– what your parents wanted.
For someone who had left all they’ve ever known to escape the crushing weight of feeling like you needed to live the life your parents had planned for you. It’s quite ironic that you’ve landed yourself back under their thumb. You guess moving seven hundred miles away will never get rid of the little girl who always wanted to make them happy, who wanted to trust that they always had her best interest in mind.
It’s funny that you’d thought you were a rat in a cage all those years ago back in Hawkins, because that was a cardboard box compared to how you feel now.
This wasn’t college, this was a commitment to another person, and as lovely as Chris was– you could not spend the rest of your life with him. As horrible as it sounds, you don’t think you’ve ever really loved him. Not in the way you should. Chris was good to you, really good to you, he was the kind of guy that would rent out the fanciest restaurant in New York on a Friday night for your one year anniversary kind of good. The let’s fly out to Paris for the weekend kind of good and the you’ll never have to work another day for the rest of your life kind of good.
The lavishness of everything was amazing, but you’d found yourself getting wrapped up in it, choosing to forget that marrying a man like Chris came with obligations. Ones that you know would slowly wear you down until you were a shell of a human, a ghost of your prior self. Chris may have been born in Indiana, but he hadn’t grown up the way you had, barely spent three years of his life in the Hoosier state before moving to New York, and sometimes it’s glaringly obvious that you two come from very different worlds.
Yet even with your differences Chris had never given you a reason to doubt his love for you and his family was so welcoming, claiming they were glad Chris had settled down with a girl like you. Even going as far as paying for the wedding and your dress wanting your special day to be everything you could have ever dreamed of.
Except this is nothing you’ve dreamed of.
When you accepted Chris’s proposal you’d thought that maybe this was the moment that you’d stop orbiting the sun. That the part of your heart that was still reserved for that hazel eyed boy who you fell in love with all those years ago would unlock itself and let Chris fully in– let him be the new sun you’d orbit– and for the longest time you’d convinced yourself that it had happened. You hadn’t seen Steve since you two broke up– five years to be exact. So, finally fully moving on, creating this life with Chris should have been the final nail in the coffin for whatever you felt towards Steve right?
Wrong.
If anything, getting engaged to Chris had only made you think more about Steve.
You’d thought more about Steve during this past year of being engaged than you had the first year after your breakup. He always seemed to be in the back of your mind and you’d find yourself asking Robin about how he was doing, breaking the cycle of Robin being the one to mention him every time you asked how things were at home because even after all these years you still associated him with home and Robin could always tell when you were homesick.
You thought about Steve when Chris’s Mom was helping you decide if you wanted a live string quartet or when his sister helped you pick out the Swarovski toasting flutes that cost more than you could ever imagine something you drink out of costing. It was all so out of your depth and fancy and all you could think of when you were choosing between one extravagant thing or another was that this was not what you’d ever imagined your wedding looking like.
In fact you know if Steve was still in your life he would have been poking fun at you, telling you that this wasn’t anything close to what you wanted– that it wasn’t you. And he would have been right because you never wanted anything extravagant. A late night pillow talk session back when your future was up in the air had revealed that all you had ever wanted was a simple wedding, one where your love was the main attraction and not an ice sculpture of a swan.
It makes your stomach twist to think that you’d left Hawkins– left Steve– for the sole purpose of wanting to find out who you were outside of all you’ve ever known and in the end you’d found yourself living a life that half the time didn’t feel like yours.
Like you were an imposter– living the life of some NYC socialite when all you were at your core was a girl from Indiana that loved sunsets and driving backroads in a maroon BMW with the only boy you’ve ever truly loved.
The same boy you’d invited to your wedding. Telling yourself that he more than likely won’t come as you drop his invitation off at the post office, but you should have known that Steve of all people would be one to attend. Because he’d only ever wanted you to be happy and what better display of happiness could be shown than marrying someone? You tell yourself that it doesn’t mean anything, that it had been five years, he’s surely moved on, but the NO that he’d marked on his RSVP for a plus one made your heart do a traitorous thing.
You’re marrying another man and yet your orbit still hasn’t strayed from your sun. It may have been weaker over the years, but the proof of your eternal love for Steve Harrington was here on your wedding day, wishing he’d show up after five years of no contact and tell you that you didn’t have to do this.
“Mom, I don't want this. Chris is a good guy, but this isn’t the life I want for myself. Please don’t make me do this.”
You’re pleading, tears streaming down your face as your Mom stares back at you with such a stoic expression that it makes you panic even more. There’s no remorse or motherly love staring back at you, just a face that tells you exactly what’s going to happen and it’s not what you want.
It’s sad that even at twenty five you still feel like you have no control over your life– that you can’t work up the nerve to walk out that door yourself. The part of you that your parents have tainted with the idea that this is your only option and that you’ll never live a life better than this tries to reason with the other part of you when you realize that the one person that was supposed to protect you is not on your side in this.
It’s a back and forth battle in your brain and you know that if you do walk out of this venue right now that you’ll be on your own. Your parents will cut you off and you’ll probably end up sleeping on Robin’s couch, which isn’t the worst thing ever, but it’s also not just you that will be affected by this choice.
Chris will be too.
He didn’t deserve this, his family didn’t deserve this, especially after the astronomical amount of money they’d spent on everything. You know you wouldn’t want to be left at the altar on your wedding day, but you also don’t want to marry a man you know you don’t love like you should. It’s a double edged sword and unfortunately your hands are gripped tightly onto it.
“This feeling will pass. A couple months from now you’re gonna be able to look back on this and laugh, knowing that you were just overreacting. You’re going to be living the life that woman would die for darling, be greatful, especially since you’re getting it with such a handsome and nice man like Chris.”
Her touch is cold as she wipes away your tears and you know she’s thinking of what excuse she can tell everyone as to why you’re going to be late walking down the aisle, you can see the gears turning in her head. It’s all methodical with her, always has been, and when she presses a chaste kiss to your forehead you know you’re marrying Chris today whether you want to or not.
“I’ll be right back,” she whispers before quickly turning on her heel and exiting your dressing room with urgency.
The door clicks shut behind her and you absolutely lose it.
You stumble into the little bathroom, your hands gripping the sides of the porcelain sink with such fierceness that you feel like you could rip it right off the wall. The first glimpse you get of yourself in the mirror is terrifying, your mascara is streaked down your cheeks, your eyes are bloodshot, and your chest is red and splotchy– borderline breaking out into stress hives.
There was no way you could make it down the aisle and look presentable in an hour– yet you knew it was going to have to happen.
You try to talk yourself down from off this metaphorical ledge that you’ve been walking with one foot dangling off the side of ever since you woke up this morning, but it’s easier said than done. You tell yourself that maybe you could learn to love Chris like you should. That maybe once you go back to New York and settle into your new life that you’ll look back on this and laugh like your Mom had said, but you shouldn’t have to learn how to love someone. It should come naturally and while you do have love for Chris it isn’t the eternal kind.
You’ve only ever had that with one person and you threw it away for what? A life you don’t even want? To be sobbing on your wedding day? To be right back under your parents thumb?
You guess you were always meant to be a rat in a cage.
The door opens, you can hear the clicking of your Mom’s heels across the wooden floor, the sound of what is undoubtedly a glass of wine being sat down at the vanity, and then her voice echoing through the room.
“I’m going to go get Robin. You’ll get all fixed up and then everything will go as planned.”
You don’t respond, you just wait for the sound of the door closing again before slowly exiting the bathroom. You find the wine glass sitting next to your favorite blush as you sit down at the lit up vanity and the girl that stares back at you in the mirror is unrecognizable. It’s a girl with no back bone– a chronic people pleaser. A girl who wishes that her knight and shining armor would come and save her, but this isn’t a fairytale and Chris isn’t an ogre. So the only thing you needed saving from was yourself.
You sit there and stare at yourself for a long time until you eventually start wiping away the remnants of your makeup, your silent tears aiding you in the process, but nothing can remove the stain on your heart.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
The second Steve pulls up to this place in his pickup truck he knows this is way out of his comfort zone. He may be in formal attire, but this is something you’d see in the movies or on the cover of some celebrity magazine at the doctor's office. He knew this Chris guy came from money, but not this kind of money, and Steve feels like the smallest guy on Earth, feeling like a fool for ever thinking that he could provide for you back then. He still could barely afford to pay his light bill on time some months and here you were marrying Mr. Money Bags.
A gentle knock on his window startles him enough that he’s cursing under his breath and his hand shakes an unnecessary amount as he cranks the window down.
“Sorry to startle you sir, just the valet,” a guy probably around his age states, who is also dressed in formal attire.
Valet. Right. Because that’s the type of wedding he’s attending where you can’t even park your own vehicle.
Steve puts the truck in park, takes the ticket from the worker, and slowly gets out of the vehicle. The trek up the stairs to the entrance is lined with extravagant flowers and Steve finds himself having to remember how to walk, having to take one step at a time. There’s a lady with a clipboard standing at the top of the stairs by the front entrance that watches him the whole time, how his hand grips the railing like he’s an eighty year old man who’s taken on too many tumbles.
“Hello! Name please?” The lady asks with a little too much enthusiasm once Steve finally makes it up the stairs.
“Um– Steve,” he replies. “Steven Harrington.”
The lady’s eyes scan the clipboard and then with a smile on her face she makes a little check by what he can only assume is his name. “Ah yes. Mr. Harrington!” She then looks back up at Steve with that same smile. “The Carters are very happy that you could attend.”
Steve forces a smile back at her and tries to act like her referring to you as Carter before it was even official didn’t make his chest ache.
As soon as he passes through the threshold he feels like he’s been transported into another dimension. He’s never been to anything this fancy before in his life, the excessive amount of flowers, the crystal chandelier, the live string quartet. If this was just the ceremony he could only imagine what the reception would be like.
It’s so in your face and reeks of wealth and Steve can’t help but scoff because this is so not you. You two would have made fun of a wedding like this, claiming that anyone who felt the need to do something so extravagant was over compensating for an already failing relationship.
But that was back then and Steve hasn’t talked to you in five years so hell for all he knows this is something you wanted. Maybe this was who you were now and it makes his stomach twist to think about how there’s a whole nother version of you that he doesn’t know a single thing about.
There’s so many people here that Steve is actually kind of grateful for it, he can blend in and not feel like the obvious sore thumb he is– the ex at the wedding. Granted he’s not sure how many people here actually know who he is besides the handful of people from home, which is more than enough for him. He keeps asking himself why he ever thought it was a good idea for him to come as he tucks himself in a corner, sneaking sips from the flask he’d hidden in the breast pocket in his suit jacket.
He thinks he might be a masochist– wanting to torture himself by watching the only girl he’s ever loved marry a man he could never measure up to. He doesn’t know why he’s throwing himself a pity party, he’d let you go, thought he was doing the right thing all those years ago, and sometimes late at night when he’s had a little too much to drink he wonders why his love wasn’t enough for you to want to stay.
He knows you two wanted different things back then, that making long distance work was harder than either of you could have imagined, but he swears if you’d asked him to move to New York with you when you came home that Christmas he would have. Instead you’d broken up and Steve hates himself for not fighting harder for you, for rolling over onto his back and exposing his belly for you to carve into. He knows things were hard for you and maybe you felt like you didn’t have the capacity to love him and figure out who you were, but Steve didn’t really know who he was back then either and still doesn’t if he’s being honest. But it had never wavered his love for you because if there was one thing Steve was certain about it was how he felt about you.
Steve’s eyes catch sight of your Mom hurriedly walking through the crowd of people and up the grand staircase– a glass of wine perched in her hand. She still has that same methodical ambiance about her, carries herself with such perfectionism and control that Steve understands why you moved to the other side of the country.
“Look what the cat dragged in.”
The familiar voice rips his eyes away from the older woman who disappears somewhere upstairs and onto the one person who he’d only ever seen wear a dress one other time, back when the tight feeling in his chest was from an alternate dimension entity murdering teenagers and not from attending a wedding.
“You look nice Robs.”
He really means it, but he can tell she doesn’t care to hear his compliments.
“Yeah– the things we do for Y/N,” Robin states with a soft sigh as she looks out into the crowd of people and then as if she realizes what she’s implied her eyes shoot back towards Steve. He’s already looking at her with an expression that says tell me about it, but he doesn’t say anything. He just slips his flask out of his pocket again and takes another swig, fully knowing Robin might judge him, but not caring anymore.
If this was any other setting Robin would have said something to him, but over the years Robin had learned the importance of time and place, and as long as Steve didn’t get sloppy sad drunk before the ceremony even started, she’d let him be. She also feels partly guilty about Steve’s current mental state, she should have never told you to invite him, should have never told him that you wanted to see him, because no matter how much she wanted you two to get back together it would never be that easy. This wasn’t like the romantic comedies that Nancy would make her watch, this was real life, two real people with real feelings.
Although Robin has a feeling that Steve would have shown up anyways without her telling him that. Steve would push down every horrid heartbroken feeling he had if it meant you got to be happy, if he got to see you be happy, because to Steve the happiness and safety of the ones he loved meant more than his own well being. It’s something she learned very quickly that summer she slung ice cream for a living with him. When their 4th of July was spent thousands of miles underground and how at only age nineteen Steve had taken the brunt of the horrors they experienced down there just so there wasn’t a scratch on her.
Robin knows Steve has experienced so much hurt in his life for only being twenty seven and yet she knows him watching you get married to someone else will undoubtedly be the worst pain he’s experienced.
She wonders if maybe in some twisted way this is closure for him.
In the same twisted way she hopes it’s not– for either of you.
“Did I tell you I’m walking down the aisle with the son of the man who invented Pop-Tarts?” Robin rambles, trying to make conversation, which is something she never has to force with Steve, but she guesses there is a first time for everything.
It gets a slight smirk out of Steve though and so she’ll take it as a win. “Let me guess Michael Jackson is officiating the wedding isn’t he?”
“Well now you’ve ruined the surprise!”
Steve can feel himself falling back into the familiar back and forth riffing he does with Robin and for a split second a real smile graces itself onto his face, but it’s gone as fast as it appears.
“Robin! There you are. I’ve been looking for you.”
Your Mom suddenly appears next to Robin and Steve swears her presence alone causes a change in the air pressure. Her eyes lock onto his for a second, gives him a tight lipped smile, and then focuses her attention back on Robin.
It wasn’t that your Mom didn’t like Steve. In fact your parents loved him as a person, but they didn’t love the fact that he hadn’t gone to college and that he was working at Family Video as a full time job when you two had started dating. Your parents would never come out and say that they wanted better for you back then or at least their terms of better, especially considering your parents were friends with Steve’s, but when you two had broken up it was obvious that your parents weren’t the least bit sad.
“Honey I need you to go help Y/N. She had a little mishap with her makeup and I need to let everyone know we might have to push the start of the ceremony back just a teensy bit.”
She says it so casually like it’s no big deal and Robin and Steve share a concerned look.
“Is she okay?” Steve asks immediately, surprising both himself and the two women who stand in front of him.
Your Mom gives him a small smile, already halfway out of this conversation and onto the next task at hand. “Oh she’s just got a little wedding day jitters. She’ll be all good by the time she needs to walk down the aisle.”
She’s gone before Robin or him can ask anymore questions and something settles deep in Steve’s gut. Something he can’t ignore and maybe it’s the liquid courage that he’s been nursing ever since he arrived or maybe it’s just pure concern, but he finds himself doing something he knows he shouldn’t.
As soon as your Mom had left Robin was brought into another conversation by one of the groomsmen asking if you’d be mad if one of their ties might be a slightly darker shade than the rest of the guys and Robin wants to say ‘how the fuck could they be a different shade you all went and got them together’ but she doesn’t. She tells him it will be fine because frankly she has bigger fish to fry and that fish is you who she knows is undoubtedly a mess up in your dressing room.
You’d been off for months now, but this morning while she was helping you get ready she could tell right away that your demeanor was not one of someone with wedding day jitters. She’d tried mentioning it in a not so obvious way, asking if this was something you still wanted, but you were always so quick to shoot her down. Your thousand yard stare quickly turning into a smile, reassuring her that this was what you wanted, but she could see the lack of sparkle in your eyes, and she hated that you felt like you had no way out of this.
Once the groomsmen is shooed away Robin turns back towards Steve to tell him that she probably won’t see him till after the ceremony, but his corner is no longer occupied. Her head whips around in every direction, eyebrows drawn together in confusion and a little bit of annoyance because if she knew being a maid of honor meant putting out this many fires she would have never accepted the role.
(Yes she would have because she loves you, but future Robin will take this day into consideration if anyone ever asks her again. Unless of course there’s a wedding in the future that might include her two favorite people and well then maybe she’d officiate it instead because how could she be both the maid of honor and the best man?)
Her eyes finally lock on to someone with shaggy brown hair ascending the grand staircase and she just stands there– watching him. She makes no effort to stop him and when she sees him disappear down the hall she turns on her heel and heads to the other side of the building.
This tie fiasco could ruin the wedding and Robin surely doesn’t want that.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
Steve’s legs seemingly carry him down the hall, the same legs that have carried him through the tunnels under Hawkins and through the Upside Down multiple times, but the trek down this marbled hallway feels far more scary than his times spent in alternate dimensions.
He knows he shouldn’t be doing this, knows it’s only going to make things worse for him, but god dammit he needed to make sure you were alright. It doesn’t matter how long it’s been since Steve’s seen you, if you haven’t been his for five years, or if you were about ready to get married to another guy– he was always going to care about you.
And he shamelessly wanted to see you. Even if he knew it would absolutely tear his heart to shreds, he wanted to see you one last time, because after today Steve was going to have to let you go.
At least that’s what he keeps telling himself, but how is he supposed to let go of the girl who was and probably always will be the center of his universe?
The once amplified sound of what seemed like hundreds of people talking and music playing has now settled into a muffled buzz in the distance as Steve stands in front of a double solid dark oak door. He can see his distorted face reflecting back at him in the golden door knobs and the Mrs. Carter sprawled across the center of the door on some sign that probably cost more than what he makes in a week teaching middle schoolers about puberty makes him want to reach back into his breast pocket for that security blanket once more.
He runs his hand through his hair, takes a very shaky deep breath, and then with a whispered fuck it– he knocks on the door.
“Robs?”
Steve’s heart embarrassingly skips a beat over just hearing your voice. It had been five years since he’d heard it, the first time he’s heard it since you looked at him with tears streaming down your face telling him that you’re always going to love him before ending what was the best thing that had ever happened to him.
The fact that he can tell you’ve been crying– even through the door. God it makes his head spin because you never truly forget what it sounds like when the woman you love is hurting. He knows you may very well tell him to fuck off and to get out, but it’s a risk he’s willing to take if it meant seeing you.
His hand shakes as it hovers over the door knob and before he can seem to lose the courage he wraps his large hand around the cool metal.
On the other side of the door you’re oblivious that it’s anyone other than your best friend coming to help you and you don’t think of the implications of what you’re saying or the fact that it could be someone else– you just desperately call out to her as the door creaks open.
“Robin, I need you. I don’t know what to do.”
Your face is hidden in your hands, still sitting at the vanity, not knowing how the hell you’re supposed to walk down the aisle in less than an hour and marry Chris. All you do know is that you need your best friend to talk you down off this ledge and maybe possibly help you figure out how to get out of this.
“Robin?” you question once you realize the door had opened, but she hadn’t made her presence known.
As you’re lifting your head up Steve finally peaks his head in from around the corner and when you two make eye contact in the mirror you swear it feels like Pluto has flown off its orbit and collided directly into the sun– imploding itself and the entire solar system.
A buzzing silence fills the room and you stare back at him in the mirror for the longest time, waiting for him to disappear, thinking that you’ve had a psychotic break and you were hallucinating him being here. You slowly turn in your chair and with unsteady legs you get up to face him, your hands gripping the back of the chair for support.
“Steve?”
It comes out so broken, but what should you expect when you’re broken yourself?
Steve feels his knees go weak under him and he tries to casually lean against the table to his right, like his knuckles aren’t turning white from how he’s have to hold himself up. It’s embarrassing and his cheeks flush over how his knees had nearly buckled under him at the sound of your voice.
Over the sound of you saying his name.
“Hi angel.”
The old pet name slips off Steve’s tongue with such ease no one would have ever guessed it had been five years since you two had been together. Steve doesn’t even register that he’s said it, he’s too mesmerized by how beautiful you look. How you’re standing there in front of him looking like a real life angel in the white dress that he’d imagined you in so many times. It takes his breath away in such a heartbreaking way because all those dreams were never going to become a reality and the proof was right in front of him.
Your heart does a traitorous thing when you hear him call you angel and it does nothing to help ease the ache in your chest, if anything it makes it worse. Your hand still grips the back of the chair like a lifeline as you stand there staring at him, taking in the man you haven’t seen in years. He’s changed so much yet not all in that time and your stomach churns over the fact that you once knew every single thing about him, but now there’s half a decade of Steve that you know nothing about.
When you’d left him he still had some of his boyish features, but now at twenty seven he’d grown into himself. His hair wasn’t as long as it was back in high school, but it was still long enough in that classic Steve way. There were crinkles around those all too familiar hazel eyes and you remember Robin telling you he coaches little league and you wonder if they’re from him being out in the sun. You could also tell that he’d gained some weight, filling out his suit in a way that had your eyes trailing all over his body. The slight pudge that made its presence known over his belt. It looked good on him and it didn't slip past you the way the fabric on the arm of his suit jacket strained when he lifted his arm to run his hand through his hair.
He looked good.
He looked too good.
And you shouldn’t be thinking that about someone else on your wedding day.
Steve could tell from your tone of voice through the door that you had been crying, but if he hadn’t been able to, well he could definitely tell now. Your mascara was still smudged slightly around your bloodshot eyes and your skin was red and splotchy– a tell tale sign that you were stressed and or upset.
“What are you doing here?” you ask softly, not trusting your voice enough to not crack again.
A little smile tugs at his lips, like he’s trying to make things less awkward, “Well I was invited…full government name and everything.”
You give him a look– a look that he still knows very well and knows that now is not the time for jokes.
Steve glances down at the floor, his bottom lip tucked securely between his teeth. The idea of admitting that he was coming to check on you, that he wanted to see you, made his stomach twist. Because he knows he doesn’t really have the right to do those things, feel those things, with you anymore.
He hasn’t for a long time, but old habits die hard.
He moves closer to you, just enough that it’s noticeable, but not enough that you’d feel inclined to step back– not that you would anyways.
“I heard your Mom say the start of the ceremony was being pushed back and I wanted to make sure everything was alright.”
His eyes wander up from the floor to you and the way you’re looking at him, eyes all round and lashes still damp from your tears, it makes Steve throw all his restraint out the window.
“And I wanted to see you,” he states, like it doesn’t crack something deep in his chest. “I wanted to see you one last time.”
Your fingernails dig into your palms, trying to stop yourself from breaking again, to stop your already watery eyes from leaking again. It’s funny that you thought inviting him would somehow make things easier for you, to close off that chapter in your life once and for all. You should have known it wouldn’t work like that, should have known that the moment you saw him again everything would come rushing back tenfold, that your orbit around your sun could never be severed.
When you don’t respond Steve finds himself taking a deep breath, trying to not let your silence over him wanting to see you again bruise his already very fragile heart. He knew it was a little forward, but what did he have to lose? You were already standing in front of him wearing a wedding dress that another man was going to help you out of later.
The smell hits you instantly. As soon as the air leaves his pretty pink lips you’re met with the overwhelming smell of alcohol. There wasn't any alcohol available to anyone until the reception, which means Steve either snuck some in, or drank before he got here. It’s then that you really take in how glassy his eyes are and how messy his hair really is, he was always one to constantly run his fingers through it when he was tipsy, never knowing what to do with his hands.
His speech wasn’t slurred yet, but you could imagine if he’d found you any later he’d be on the cusp of it.
“Why have you been drinking?” you ask abruptly.
Steve wants to say– because I can’t get through watching you marry another man sober.
Because ever since I got that invitation in the mail I’ve been drinking to cope.
Because I’ve looked for you in every woman I’ve been with since you left. (which isn’t a lot)
Because I know after today I’m going to have to let you go, even when I haven’t had you for years.
Because I don’t know if I can ever move on from you even if I tell myself to let you go.
Because it’s been five years and my Mom has been starting to ask when I’m going to find someone to settle down with.
Because I’m hoping that maybe you still feel the same and maybe this won’t end with me at a bar tonight.
Because I still love you.
Instead, he turns the conversation back on you, not wanting to dive into his own personal issues, and asks. “Why have you been crying?”
You narrow your eyes at him, annoyed that he’s trying to avoid your question by bringing up the obvious elephant in the room. There’s so many things you want to tell him, so many things that would ultimately determine if you were going to be walking down the aisle shortly, and you wonder if you asked Steve to sneak you out the back if he would.
He would without a second thought.
Do you tell him the truth? Do you tell him all the reasons that have been swirling around in your brain as you stand here in your custom made wedding dress staring into the glassy eyes of the man who would light the world on fire if you asked him to.
You could tell him your red rimmed eyes and smeared mascara is just because of nerves.
But what you really want to say is – it’s because my special day is nothing like I ever expected it to be.
Because I feel like an imposter.
Because the man that will be standing across from me at the altar isn’t a five foot eleven hazel eyed boy from Hawkins.
Because my parents want this marriage to happen more than anything in the world, even at the expense of their own daughter’s well being.
Because I realized that moving away and leaving you was never going to fix me and that I was never trapped in Hawkins. I was running from something much bigger than myself.
Because seeing you here is killing me and knowing you’ve been drinking is making it even worse.
Because you’re always going to be my sun and my orbit around you still hasn’t strayed even after all these years.
Because I’ve thought about you showing up like this a million times and now that you’re here I can’t work up the nerve to ask you the one thing I need you to do for me.
Because I wonder if you still love me even after I left you like I did.
Because I still love you.
But none of that comes out of your mouth– you lie straight to his face instead.
“I’m just nervous,” you respond. “I think every woman cries a little bit on her wedding day if we’re being honest. I mean there’s a lot of people out there. What if I trip walking down the aisle? Or what if I forget my vows?”
It’s all bullshit and you can tell as Steve’s eyes flicker across your face, taking in your wrecked features for the millionth time since he stepped foot into this room, that he knows it too. He’d always been able to tell when you were lying, when something much bigger was bothering you than you’d let on, and it’s times like this when you realize he probably knew about you wanting to leave Hawkins way before you did.
He doesn’t say anything right away and lets your response linger in the air. He isn’t really sure what to say, he’d heard you crying out for Robin through the door, can clearly see the stress hives on your chest, this wasn’t just a little wedding day nerves. This was you freaking out and Steve doesn’t know if it’s because of your Mom or if it’s something else.
He selfishly hopes it’s the something else, but if it was, how would that even play out? You’re supposed to be marrying Chris in less than an hour and what if this is all just nerves? Does he risk making a fool of himself by insinuating what he thinks is going on with you? What he hopes is going on? He doesn’t really have much to lose if he does, but there’s still something holding Steve back.
It’s been five years since he’s seen you and in that time, not only has he changed, but so have you. Say he does put everything out on the table, asks you if you really want to marry Chris or just straight up tells you not to marry Chris. Who says you’d even want to be with him? Or if things would even work out. In a month you could regret ever leaving him today and Steve would be painted the fool. Hell, he doesn't even know if you still have feelings for him. The irrational side of him though, the side that still holds on to what you told him when you left years ago, tells him it’s a possibility.
The rational side– it tells him to let you go.
You’re both not teenagers anymore, fighting demogorgons and saving your podunk town for years on end. You’re adults with real life responsibilities, and jobs, and 401k’s that Steve still isn’t really sure he understands. Things are so different from what they used to be and Steve can’t help but think about how when things got real– when all the adrenaline from years of being on edge had finally worn off– you left. And maybe that’s a sign that you two weren’t meant to be together in the real world, facing normal people problems that now seemed much harder than defeating Vecna ever was.
His irrational side takes over long enough for him to break his already fragile heart.
“Do you love him?” Steve asks, his throat constricting as the words come tumbling out.
His question steals the air from your lungs and you swear you can feel the corset backing on your dress tightening again. This is what you had wanted, you’d wanted him to question things, wanted him to come save you, and you can’t get yourself to say the words you need to.
“I–”
Tell me not to do it Steve.
“I love him,” you reply with what is the most uncertain tone coming from a woman who’s about to marry said man. “I love him enough.”
Tell me not to marry him.
“You love him enough?” An ugly feeling settles deep in Steve’s chest as he wrestles with the realization that your love for him was clearly never enough for you to stay in Hawkins, but you apparently love Chris just enough to marry him.
The tears you’ve been holding back finally break past their barrier and then they come down harder when you realize that the man who’d wipe them away as soon as the first one fell wasn’t even moving an inch towards you.
“I–no–Steve–” your words come out wet and broken and you have no fucking clue to what even say anymore. “That came out wrong–” it came out exactly like you wanted it to. “I’ve just got a lot going on in my head right now.”
Say anything. Say anything at all and I won’t marry him.
Steve can feel his emotions starting to get the better of him and he knows he should just leave the conversation at this because the longer he stands here and watches you cry the worse it’s going to get for him, but he’s got to get one last thing off his chest.
“Do you remember what you told me when we broke up?” Steve asks, holding out hope that you’d held on to the same thing as him after all these years.
You sheepishly shake your head no at him, there was a lot of things you’d rambled to him that night, and maybe if you’re brain wasn’t fucked up beyond belief right now you’d be able to decipher what he was alluding to.
Steve tries to swallow down the giant lump in his throat, he should have known you wouldn’t remember, should have known every question he would throw your way would only hurt him, but fuck it he’s got a little bit of whiskey left in his flask, so he might as well continue.
“You’d told me that you’d always love me,” he can see the broken realization on your face, but he continues. “And for the longest time I held on to that, hoping that you’d come back to me, and you never did. Which I should have expected, but I showed up to your wedding, came into this room, with the idea that maybe you still loved me even just half as much as I still love you.”
He shakes his head, eyes flickering back down to the floor in an act of selfpreservation.
“I don’t know what I was expecting to happen. I don’t even know why I’m telling you all of this right now, but I’d held on to those words for so long that there was part of me that had hoped you’d see me and everything would go back to how it used to be, but I know this isn’t a fairytale. This is real life and you’re marrying another man and I have to accept that.”
This is where you tell him that you still love him. This is where everything changes and you can feel like yourself again– with the only person who ever really understood you. This is where relief should be flooding your nervous system.
Instead you stand there with tears streaming down your face and paralyzed vocal chords.
You can see the first few tears cascade down Steve’s cheeks and you want to reach out and wipe them away, remember how his skin feels under your touch, but you can’t.
Steve wipes away his own tears and looks back up at you, clearing his throat before continuing to break not only his own heart, but yours too. “I’m choosing to believe that what’s going on with you is just nerves because if it was something else you would have told me. And I’m sorry for springing this on you but I couldn’t–” his voice cracks and he stops, shaking his head in annoyance at himself. “I’m happy for you and Chris seems like a great guy. I think maybe being nervous is a good thing, yeah? Just shows that you want your special day to be everything you imagined.”
“Steve,” you finally choke out. There’s so much you want to say to him, so much you need to say to him, but you can’t get it out. You don’t have time to get it out. Because as much as you want him to run away with you, as much as you’re looking at him with pleading eyes, trying to get him to just take your hand and run out the back.
It’s not going to happen.
He’s too good of a man to do it and you’re too chicken shit to tell him.
How you’re even standing right now is beyond you– you’ve got no backbone. Never have. Probably never will. Hopefully in the plethora of gifts that your Mom was boasting about earlier– someone has given you one.
It’s clear that you’ll marry Chris because he’s good to you and because it will make your parents happy. You’ll also let Steve walk out of this room and hope that maybe the universe would give you a third chance in the future, because even if you’re married, even if this is Steve’s way of letting you go.
How can Pluto ever stop orbiting its sun?
His hand reaches out and you let him intertwine his fingers with yours, relishing in the feeling of his skin on yours for the first time in years. Electricity travels up your arm and directly into your chest– blooming something achingly familiar in your heart. You don’t want to let him go, don’t want to have to forget the way it feels to do something as simple as holding his hand or hear him call you angel again.
You squeeze his hand as you look into those doe eyes of his and for a split second you feel like you’re seventeen again in the Family Video parking lot. The frigid winter air nipped at your skin back then as you leaned against your car, but you never even felt the effects of it because you had your sun right in front of you. Which is how you feel now, even for just a minute, having him here in front of you, it dulls the ache in your heart.
Steve takes a shaky deep breath and you know this is the end, this is where he’s going to let you go, and you wonder if this is how he felt when you left him standing in his bedroom that Christmas. You feel his grip loosen just a tad, but you hold on tighter, not letting him leave before he’s said goodbye.
He reaches up with his other hand and cradles the side of your face, his thumb gently wiping away your tears. It makes your breath hitch in your throat and the tears fall even harder, but you shamelessly lean into his touch, your eyes fluttering shut, trying to savor this fleeting moment.
Even after everything, this was still your Steve standing in front of you. Still the same caring boy who’d put himself between you and too many life threatening situations to count, who would always bring you over free ice cream that summer he worked at Scoops and you worked at the Gap, who threw you a graduation party when Hawkins going into lockdown had ruined everything about the end of your senior year. Five years had passed and he’d fallen back into old habits like nothing had happened, like both of you weren’t hurting.
“I'll always love you Y/N, but I’ve got to let you go.”
His words hit you square in the chest, like you’ve gotten the wind knocked out of you, and to make matters worse you feel his touch evade you. Clearly drawing the line in the sand with not only his words but his actions. As you slowly blink open your eyes you’re praying that this has all been a bad dream and you’d be back in your bed in New York, but luck has never been on your side, and Steve stands before you with round wet eyes that will haunt your dreams tonight.
Steve wants to tell you a million other things, wants to stay holed up in this dressing room with you for eternity, but he knows he can’t. Hell he’s surprised your Mom hasn’t busted down the door wondering why you weren’t ready to walk down the aisle by now, but either way he knows his time with you is limited.
He’d seen you, told you his feelings, and now he was going to watch you marry another man.
“You know,” Steve shuffles back a bit from you, starting his exit plan. “I always thought you’d make a beautiful bride and it’s nice to know I was right.”
He finds himself biting the inside of his cheek, trying to not let himself cry again as he walks backwards towards the door.
You open your mouth to say anything to get him to stick around, but nothing comes out, and you’re internally screaming, pleading for him to not leave you.
It seems to play out in slow motion as you watch his hand grip the door knob, the sound of the door opening ricochets off the walls, and then in a split second your sun leaves you and takes every bit of warmth with him. Silent tears stream down your face and when Robin walks in seconds later you’re none the wiser to the fact that she’d been eavesdropping in the hallway to hear at least the worst bits.
She guides you to sit down at the vanity while she grabs some things from the bathroom. Time doesn’t seem to exist to you right now, and you don’t even realize she’s exited the bathroom until you feel her pressing a cold washcloth to the back of your neck and chest, trying to get you to calm down. She doesn’t say anything to you, which you’re eternally grateful for, but when you make eye contact with her in the mirror as she stands behind you, you know she knows.
She knows you’re back in the Family Video parking lot, except you’ve locked your keys inside your car, and Steve is nowhere to be found.
Forty-five minutes later and only a half an hour past the ceremony start time, Robin and you exit the dressing room hand in hand, leaving behind your conversation with Steve and an empty wine glass.
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ───
The moment the live string quartet starts playing Canon in D and everyone stands Steve wishes the floor would swallow him whole. As soon as the giant double doors open he hears a gasp from the crowd and he wants to punch himself for sitting in an aisle seat. He wonders if it’s too late to ask Lucas to switch seats, but then he locks eyes with you as you start coming down the aisle and whatever he was thinking goes out the window. It was one thing to see you in your dressing room, but this was different, this was real, and he feels his chest crack wide open. You looked like an angel, so breathtaking, and he’d imagined this day so many times before, what you’d look like as you walked down the aisle towards him, he just never thought he’d be in the crowd and not at the altar.
He doesn't have Robin to lean on right now, just a very judgemental yet caring Max next to him that can definitely smell the whiskey on him, but doesn’t say anything. Mainly because Max is just observant at twenty-two as she was at fifteen and she knows that Steve Harrington is still very much in love with you. She knows he’s been struggling, knows this has to be the worst day of his life and she’s surprised he even came, but he was here and that has to count for something.
Max feels a slight pang in her chest as she looks up at the man that has saved her life more times than she can count. He looks broken, far from the bat-slinging teenage boy she once knew, and she finds herself reaching out for his hand hanging idle at his side. Without a second thought she wraps her hand around his and gives him a reassuring squeeze, letting him know that she’s here and when he turns his head towards her and gives her a smile that says thank you, she gives him one back. She gently bumps his shoulder with hers like she’s telling him you know it’s no big deal, and he squeezes her hand back.
Their hands stay intertwined the whole ceremony and when the officiant says those famous six words, Max feels Steve grip her hand to the point where it hurts, but she knows that twenty seconds of pain is nothing compared to what Steve is feeling right now.
The guests cheer and holler and clap, but all Steve can hear is a constant ringing in his head, like he’d rung his bell too hard again. He watches as Chris and you walk back down the aisle hand in hand with big smiles on your faces. It makes Steve’s chest burn with such fierceness that he can’t catch his breath. The groomsmen and bridesmaids follow in tow of the newly married couple and he doesn’t miss the sympathetic look Robin shoots his way, it makes him feel even worse, like he’s the pathetic ex that showed up to the wedding just to ruin the vibe.
The crowd eventually trickles out of the room and he hears Max and Lucas asking him something from behind him, but he doesn’t answer, doesn’t follow the crowd into the ball room. He just keeps going straight and lets the entrance doors slam behind him as fresh air finally fills his burning lungs.
summary: Spencer Reid spends six months flirting. You spend six months not realizing he's flirting. The BAU spends six months losing money in Rossi's betting pool.
word count: ~2.5k
authors note: should I be sleeping? yes. will i be late for work tomorrow? yes. do I care? Not really.
just light rom com spencer x reader. not proof read.
masterlist
~♡~
The thing about Spencer Reid was that he was terrible at being subtle, at least according to everyone else.
You, unfortunately, were completely immune to recognizing romantic interest when it was directed at you.
Which was why, six months after joining the BAU, you still hadn't figured out that Spencer was hopelessly, ridiculously in love with you.
The betting pool started because of a Tuesday.
Not a dramatic or life-changing Tuesday.
Just an ordinary Tuesday when you mentioned, in passing, that you hadn't slept well.
That was it. One sentence.
The next morning there was coffee waiting on your desk.
The morning after that there was coffee again.
And the morning after that.
Three weeks later Spencer was still showing up with coffee, exactly how you liked it.
No one mentioned it. At least not to either of you.
But Rossi quietly slid twenty dollars toward Emily. Emily accepted it without question. Across the room Luke raised an eyebrow. Garcia looked delighted.
Spencer remained completely unaware. You remained completely unaware. Everyone else was suffering.
The thing about Spencer was that he remembered everything. Most people found that impressive, however you found it comforting. You could mention something once and Spencer would remember it months later.
A favorite author.
A movie you loved as a kid.
A food allergy.
A random story from college.
It all stayed somewhere inside his mind. One afternoon you were searching your desk.
Spencer looked up from a file.
"What are you looking for?"
"My charger."
"It's in conference room B."
You blinked.
"What?"
"You left it there after the briefing."
"How do you know that?"
"You forgot it."
"As opposed to?"
"You forgetting it somewhere else."
You laughed, what made Spencer smile. The room collectively watched. Then looked away before either of you noticed.
A month later the team was flying home from a case. You fell asleep halfway through the flight. Nothing unusual.
The unusual part happened afterward, when the jet landed. You woke up covered with Spencer's suit jacket. Garcia nearly bit through her lip trying not to smile. Luke immediately looked toward Rossi. Rossi silently updated the betting pool.
You simply handed the jacket back.
"Thanks."
Spencer looked almost embarrassed.
"Of course."
Like covering you with his jacket was the most natural thing in the world. Which, to him, it was.
The problem wasn't that Spencer was subtle.
The problem was that he treated you differently in a hundred tiny ways, that only became obvious when people paid attention.
He always sat beside you during briefings, partnered with you when possible, saved you a seat on the jet, noticed when you were tired or stressed, or hungry, or upset.
The rest of the team noticed.
You didn't.
One afternoon Emily walked into the bullpen and stopped. Spencer was talking and you were laughing. Neither of you seemed aware that everyone else had stopped working. Your eyes blurry with tears, Spencer vividly gesticulating as he was telling you an old story about prank war he had with Derek, years ago.
Luke slowly slid into the chair beside Emily.
"How long do you think?"
Emily sighed.
"At this rate?"
"Yeah."
"Six months."
Luke nodded thoughtfully.
"Optimistic."
Across the room Garcia was already adding notes to the betting spreadsheet.
The funniest part was that Spencer thought he was hiding it.
Everyone knew. Everyone. Including suspects, witnesses, local police.
Once, during a case, a detective looked between you and Spencer and casually asked how long you'd been together.
You nearly choked. Spencer looked like he forgot how talking worked.
The detective immediately apologized.
The team spent three days making fun of him. Spencer never recovered.
The jealousy started by accident.
At least that's what Spencer told himself.
The team was interviewing witnesses at a local bar. You were speaking with one of them. A very attractive witness. A witness who was clearly more interested in you than helping with the case.
Spencer was trying not to stare.
He failed. Spectacularly.
The witness leaned closer, what made Spencer hate him immediately.
The witness said something and your smile vanished.
"Oh no," Luke muttered beside Spencer.
"What?"
"The poor idiot crossed a line."
Sure enough, you folded your arms.
"What exactly do you mean by that?"
The witness smirked. Spencer couldn't hear his response. Whatever it was, he didn't need to.
Your eyebrow lifted.
Three minutes later the witness looked like he'd lost an argument with a lawyer, a professor, and a disappointed mother all at once.
He practically fled.
You walked back toward the team.
"What happened?" JJ asked.
"He told me I'd be prettier if I smiled more."
Emily winced.
"Oof."
"He also suggested women usually aren't greatat this job."
Luke barked out a laugh.
"Well, he deserved whatever you said."
You shrugged.
"I simply informed him his confidence was unsupported by evidence. And that if he thinks me smiling more would help finding the killer, I'm glad his job is cleaning tables."
Rossi laughed into his coffee.
Spencer tried to hide his grin and failed. You caught it immediately.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"You look pleased."
Spencer shrugged.
"I enjoy watching arrogant people get embarrassed."
Your smile widened and Spencer forgot how breathing worked.
The breaking point came another two months later. The team was flying home after a case. Everyone was exhausted. Luke was asleep with his head tilted back. Garcia was scrolling through her phone. Emily and JJ were discussing paperwork. Rossi had somehow fallen asleep the second the jet left the ground.
You sat across from Reid.
He sat with a book open in his lap. Supposedly reading. You knew he was reading because he always read.
What you didn't know was that he'd been staring at the same page for fifteen minutes. Because you were sitting directly across from him. And because he was trying very hard not to think about how good you looked. He was failing miserably at that.
You sighed and stretched.
"Can I ask you something?"
Spencer glanced up.
"Of course."
"Why don't you date?"
A few seats away, Emily immediately looked interested. Luke cracked one eye open.
Spencer tried to focus back on the book.
"That's a broad question."
"I mean, you're smart."
He turned a page. The wrong page.
"Kind."
Another page. Still not reading.
"Funny."
The book lowered slightly.
"And ridiculously attractive."
Reid nearly dropped it.
Across the aisle, Luke looked ready to choke.
You continued obliviously.
"Anyone would be happy to be with you."
Spencer stared at the page, not reading a single word. Then he said, almost casually:
"Well, you don't seem interested."
You blinked.
"What?"
The words came out before he could stop them. His eyes widened slightly. The entire jet suddenly felt very quiet.
You stared.
Spencer stared at his book, very intensely.
Like maybe if he focused hard enough he could disappear into it.
"What do you mean?"
He swallowed, slowly lowered the book and looked at you.
"I mean..." He hesitated.
For once, Spencer Reid seemed completely unsure of himself. Then he gave a tiny shrug.
"You don't seem interested in dating me."
The silence was immediate. Absolute.
Across the jet, Luke's eyes snapped fully open. Garcia looked up from her phone. Emily stopped pretending not to listen. JJ pressed her lips together. Rossi looked awake all of a sudden.
You simply stared. Because surely you hadn't heard that correctly.
Spencer realized exactly what he'd just admitted. A faint blush spread across his face.
"Oh."
He looked away.
"That wasn't how I intended to say that."
You were still staring. Because suddenly everything made sense.
The coffee.
The jacket.
The attention to detail.
The jealousy.
The way he always found you first.
"Oh my God."
Spencer let out a quiet laugh.
"Yeah."
"Oh my God."
"I know."
You pointed at him. Completely horrified.
"You're flirting with me?"
Luke physically buried his face in his hands. Garcia made a noise somewhere between a scream and a laugh.
Spencer finally smiled.
Warm.
Fond.
A little smug.
He tilted his head.
"For like... two months now, thank you for noticing."
"Two months?"
Emily snorted.
"Try six."
Spencer groaned.
"Emily."
"What? She deserve the truth.
You looked confused.
"You knew about it?" You looked at everyone, trying to figure out what exactly is happening.
"Technically Rossi had the betting pool."
"I financed the betting pool," Rossi corrected.
You looked back at Spencer, furrowed brows, thinking. Analysing.
"You really like me?"
Spencer's expression softened immediately. Like the answer was obvious.
"Considering I haven't stopped thinking about you for almost a year?"
Your heart completely stopped.
"A year?"
Spencer closed his eyes.
"Please stop repeating that."
"A year?"
Luke laughed so hard he nearly fell out of his seat.
Garcia was openly crying.
And Spencer looked like he wanted the jet door to open so he could jump out.
"Yea" he admitted quietly. You smiled, not taking his eyes off of him.
"That's good" you said eventually and that made him curiously look at you.
"Good?"
"Yea. Because I like you too. For quite some time" you admitted, smiling fully now.
"You do?"
"Yes. Thank you for noticing" you couldn't help but mock him, as you intertwined your fingers on the small table inbetween you.
Garcia already started planning your wedding. JJ and Emily exchanged looks, knowing smirks. Luke just silently handed Rossi fifty bucks, mutting something that sounded like "one week too soon".
summary: When choosing a female agent to send back in time to gain young Sergeant Barnes's trust, everyone's in agreement that it should be Sharon. Until Bucky, the man that you barely get along with, speaks up and lets everyone know that it could only be you.
warnings: angst, smut, profanity, pet names (only sweetheart & baby), mutual pining of sorts, enemies to lovers (kinda), jealous!Bucky, possessive!Bucky, one bed trope, teasing, masturbation (male & female), brief thigh riding, dry humping, nausea/vomiting (not graphically described and not a major part of the story, apologies to my emetophobic girlies), oral sex (female receiving), fingering, unprotected sex, MINORS DNI, 18+.
word count: 43.2k
a/n: Thanks again to @littlemiss-yeehaw for reading all of my shit and listening to my unhinged ramblings when I write, and for her amazing artwork. Thanks to @flowersforbucky for also reading my shit and for taking the time to tell me that it isn't as shitty as I think. Without them, this fic would be unreachable in the depths of my laptop's trash bin. Pics included in the title image for this fic are not representative of reader, location, etc.
Insufferable. Is that really the right word? Can someone be insufferable when all they do is mope around in silence, giving you looks of disdain? Maybe insufferable is a word better suited to describe someone who says more than five words at a time. And yet, you still feel that Bucky Barnes is insufferable.
Raindrops patter rhythmically against the roof of the car, making the all-too-quiet stakeout a little more bearable. You shift in the passenger seat, letting your eyes fall closed for a moment as you press your head against the leather headrest behind you. You’ve been sitting here for two hours. That’s two hours of listening to nothing more than the sound of your own breathing, Bucky’s occasional annoyed sighs, and the shitty audio feed of the abandoned storefront just up the street. You’re contemplating giving in and taking a nap when you hear the sound of gravel crunching beneath tires somewhere outside of your parked car, and your eyes shoot open. You catch a glimpse of the flashing yellow lights of a security vehicle in the rearview mirror and Bucky groans, quickly powering down the surveillance equipment and dropping it down to the floor at his feet.
“Just what we needed.” Bucky says sarcastically, with frustration edging his tone as the security guard pulls in closer and closer. He’s about twenty meters behind the car now, moving slowly. You’re sure he’s taking down the make and model of the car, the license plate, and noting the fact that it’s currently turned off. It looks suspicious as hell, you have no doubt. Your mind is moving a million miles a minute as you start shrugging your jacket off of your shoulders and mussing up your hair. “What are you doing?” Bucky asks, raising a brow in your direction.
“Getting us out of this.” You mumble, glancing back in the rearview mirror one last time. You see the security vehicle coming to a stop a few meters behind, so you move a little quicker. You’re climbing over the center console in a flash, placing your knees on either side of Bucky’s hips as you come to straddle his lap. You hover over him, with your ass pressing against the steering wheel so hard that it’s a wonder you aren’t honking the horn. “Move your seat back.” You whisper harshly, gripping his shoulders with both hands as you stare down at him. Bucky swallows hard and narrows his eyes at you as if he wants to throw you right back into your own seat, but he reaches down with his vibranium hand and starts sliding the driver’s seat backward.
Bucky can’t stand you. As you lower yourself down to sit on his lap, he keeps his hands stiff, with one resting along the driver’s side door and the other resting over the center console. His hands curl into fists when you lean in and press your lips against his neck. It’s soft and hesitant at first, as if you’re not really sure that it’s an acceptable thing to do. Bucky’s chin tilts upward and to the side instinctively, giving you more access and a clear go-ahead that has your second kiss coming in a little more desperate and firm against the column of his throat. Bucky tenses beneath you but the barely audible groan that slips past his lips has you wondering if he hates this as much as he’s trying to portray. You glance over his shoulder and see the security guard approaching the car now, his eyes scanning the rear windshield as he speaks lowly into a handheld radio.
“Barnes, I swear to god if you don’t put your hands on me and make this believable…” Your threatening tone has a roguish smile tugging at the corners of Bucky’s mouth, but he refuses to let it take full form. His hands move quickly now, grabbing onto your hips and tugging them downward. He realizes as he basically grinds your clothed center over the semi-hard front of his jeans that he probably shouldn’t have done that. When you feel his partial erection pressing against you, you falter for a moment, your lips stilling against his neck and your breath hitching in your throat. “And here I thought you couldn’t stand me.” You whisper against his skin.
“I can’t.” He responds dryly, sliding his hands up the sides of your waist and letting his fingers splay out over your ribs.
“Are you sure about that?” You ask teasingly, swirling your hips in a circle as you press down on his lap. He grunts and lets his right hand glide up your back, moving higher and higher until it’s tangled in the hair at the crown of your head.
“Pretty damn sure.” Bucky rasps as he uses his hold on your hair to tug your head back. He takes the opportunity he’s given himself to attach his lips to your neck, sucking a nice little red mark right below your ear before smoothing over it with his tongue. The whimper that leaves your lips at the feel of his tongue against your skin is enough to turn his semi-hard cock into a raging hard-on. The bright ray of a flashlight shining through the driver’s window catches your attention, and you feign surprise as the security guard taps on the window with his knuckles one, two, three times. Bucky’s letting go of your waist and hair and pushing the door open as a sly chuckle climbs up his throat.
“I told her we shouldn’t do this here.” Bucky says smugly, shaking his head as you place your hands on his chest and lean back, glaring down at him. “I can’t keep her off of me.”
“Could you uh, dismount? Ma’am?” The officer requests. You turn your head and take in the short, balding man. Blush colors his cheeks a deep shade of red and you wonder if this is the most action he’s seen all year. Moving off of Bucky’s lap, you come to stand just outside of the car, crossing your arms over your chest as the cool night air hits you. You regret taking your jacket off earlier.
“I’m so sorry.” You say ashamedly, hoping you look as faux-embarrassed as you’ve made your voice sound. The man offers you a shy smile, his eyes wrinkling around the corners as Bucky climbs out of the car next. You smirk at the way Bucky tugs his jeans down and adjusts himself, trying his best to disguise the tent beneath the fabric. He glances in your direction, his eyes briefly flitting down to where your arms are crossed over your chest, before shrugging off his leather jacket and tossing it to you. You’re still for a moment, until you realize that it would probably look questionable if you refused the kind gesture in front of the security guard, so you drape the jacket over shoulders and wrap it around your upper body. Your little act was so believable that Bucky only has to spend about one minute chatting back and forth with the security guard before he lets you both off with a warning. He didn’t even ask to see your IDs. Bucky’s pretty good at bullshitting, you’ll give him that.
Infuriating. As Bucky stands beneath the steady stream of hot water, letting it soak his hair and drip over the curves of his shoulders, it’s the only word on his mind. You’re fucking infuriating. How he continues to end up on missions with you is beyond him. He never thought he would miss the days of having Sam as his partner, but god, he misses them. He might even take Walker on as a partner if it means getting the hell away from you. Actually, he’d rather put up with you than with Walker. But anyone else? He’d happily work with anyone else out in the field.
Bucky’s just beginning to rinse the shampoo out of his hair when the sound of his bedroom door flying open registers in his mind. He freezes, both hands hovering at the sides of his head as you angrily rush through his room. The bathroom door is thrown open next, and he feels a whoosh of cold air floating over the top of his glass shower door.
“A hickey?” Your voice is laced with malice. The fiery rage inside of you is stoked by the sound of Bucky laughing behind the fogged-up glass. “Are you sixteen?”
“You made a pretty little sound when I gave it to you.” He points out, continuing to work the shampoo into his brown locks.
“I was playing the part.” You argue. You take a moment to glance around his bathroom, noting the way it looks exactly like yours except it’s devoid of any personality. He has dark gray rugs on the floor, a matching dark gray towel hanging over the shower door, and even a dark gray toothbrush sitting in a little white cup beside the sink. Is he allergic to every other color?
“The security guard couldn’t hear anything inside the car, you don’t have to lie to me. You liked it.” Bucky says coolly. He rinses the suds out of his hair and even with his eyes closed, he’s sure you’re standing there with your arms crossed. It’s your signature pose in his presence.
“I have shit to do tomorrow, Barnes. Now I have to worry about covering this up.” You complain. You snatch his towel off of the shower door and use it to wipe at the fogged-up mirror over the sink. You’re studying the sizable red mark below your ear in the reflection when Bucky turns off the running water.
“You have three seconds to put my towel back before I walk out of here without it.” His voice is low and threatening now. You roll your eyes before tossing the towel back up and over the shower door, he grabs it immediately. When he steps out a moment later, he has the towel wrapped firmly around his waist. As he steps into the view of the mirror, your eyes roam over his wet, toned body in the reflection. Your gaze follows a few drops of water as they drip from his hair and trail down the side of his neck. You stand still in front of the mirror, unmoving as Bucky meets your gaze and narrows his eyes, taking a few steps forward to close the space between you. He comes to a stop with his bare chest nearly brushing against your clothed back, and then he moves his hands to grip the edge of the countertop on either side of your hips. Leaning forward the tiniest bit, his lips graze the shell of your ear and every single muscle in your body tenses up. “Why cover it? You don’t want people to know that you like being marked up?”
“I can’t stand you.” You spit coldly, crossing your arms over your chest and glaring at him in the reflection. Bucky chuckles lowly before letting go of the edge of the countertop and turning away from you, leaving you alone in his steamy bathroom.
“I can’t stand you either.” He calls back to you.
When you stomp through his bedroom a moment later, he watches out of the corner of his eye as you disappear out into the hall and let his door fall shut behind you. He knows that on some level, you’re both liars. There are so many things that you can’t stand about each other, and yet, there’s an undeniable force that seems to keep you both coming back. You could simply stay away from each other when you’re in the tower. You live across the hall from each other but the place is so damn big that you could easily avoid each other anytime you’re not working together in the field. He’s sure that somewhere beneath the haze of false hatred and tension, you can feel that incessant pull just as much as he can. That’s why he can’t stand you. That’s precisely the reason why he finds you so infuriating. Because you act like you can’t feel it.
The Howling Commandos files have taken up nearly every waking second of your time for the past three days. You’ve read every word, combed through every grainy black and white picture, and taken enough notes to fill nearly twenty pages of the little notebook that currently sits open in front of you. And yet, you haven’t been able to formulate a solid plan. That’s why the conference room is packed full of people with varying skillsets and thought processes. Fury sits at the head of the table, leaning back comfortably in his chair as he twirls a black pen in his right. Sam sits to his left, staring down at the same files you’ve studied for hours. Beside him is Sharon, who looks equal parts bored and entirely over the situation at hand. Knowing the things that she’s been up to lately, she probably has more important places to be right now. A few people are littered around the room, leaning against walls and quietly conversing with each other as they try to come up with the best course of action to solve the present issue. You’re seated at the far end of the table, opposite of Fury, tracing the lines of your left palm with your right thumb.
Bucky stands near the door, with his back pressed against the smooth wall and his arms crossed over his broad chest. He wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t labeled a mandatory meeting. Hell, even with it being labeled mandatory, he considered skipping it. He doesn’t particularly enjoy watching everyone read up on his past life, even if it was the era that he considers his glory days. Being a part of the Howling Commandos was one of the few good things he ever did, but letting himself think about that time only leads him down a darker path. He thinks about how each Howling Commandos mission that he was a part of brought him closer and closer to getting captured, to losing his arm, to losing himself. Shaking his head, Bucky pushes away from the wall and stands straight, he wonders if anyone will notice him slipping out the door.
“I don’t like time travel.” Fury says evenly, keeping his eyes on the pen in his hand as he twirls it around just above the surface of the conference room table. Bucky freezes, his eyes narrowing as he looks to Fury. Everyone in the room halts, all eyes moving in the same direction to follow the commanding voice. “I don’t like time travel at all. It’s risky and it tends to fuck things up in the long run.” Fury takes a moment to cast his eyes around the room, taking in each and every person present. After making the first round, he turns his head to the right and focuses on Bucky. “Unfortunately, I think this situation calls for something risky.”
Goosebumps spread over the surface of your skin and you tense in your seat. You follow Fury’s gaze and your eyes land on Bucky, who stands tall beside the door. His arms hang still at his sides, and for once, his vibranium arm isn’t hidden behind a long shirt sleeve or leather jacket. The black and gold glints in the fluorescent lighting of the room, drawing attention like a bright red flower draws bees.
“The intel that we need from a currently non-existent HYDRA base doesn’t exist. The Howling Commandos weren’t tasked with collecting evidence or documenting what they found at each base.” Fury continues. Bucky swallows hard but maintains eye contact. He already doesn’t like where this is going. “So, we send someone back in time to get what we need.”
As tension rises in the room and the air begins to feel like its crackling with anticipation, Fury lays out the only two potential plans he can think of. The first plan is automatically a no, because of how risky it is to send a full team back in time. The first plan would’ve been to send someone back in time to infiltrate a specific HYDRA base moments before the Howling Commandos take it out, so the intel can be gathered and brought back to the present. But the second plan is the one that has discussion raging around the conference room.
“Steve wouldn’t trust someone he’s just met, we’d need to get through to Peggy first, then she can sway him and the rest of the Howling Commandos.” Sharon argues, leaning forward and clasping her hands together over the table. Your eyes flit over to her as her blonde hair falls over one shoulder and obscures the side of her face. She’s right, 1940s Steve Rogers wouldn’t even come close to trusting a new person in the midst of a war, let alone one who’s so obviously from the wrong time period. You see Sam laughing to himself further down the table and you’re sure he’s remembering the story Steve used to tell of his past self attempting to kick his present self’s ass during his time travel stint.
“Peggy wouldn’t be wholly trusting either.” Fury points out, barely looking up from the surface of the table before him. “We need to get Peggy and at least one of the Howling Commandos on our side for this to work. The rest will follow.”
“What if we go at this from a slightly different angle?” Torres asks. He stands a few feet behind your seat, leaning against the wall as his thumbs rapid-fire away at the phone in clutched in his hands. Everyone turns their attention to him and he finally looks up, blinking once before clicking the phone off and sliding it into the back pocket of his jeans.
“We’re listening.” Fury says, his interest clearly piqued.
“We pick someone that Peggy could relate to, someone she would like, maybe become fast friends with.” He starts slowly, letting his gaze roam over each person in the room as he speaks. His eyes stop when he reaches Bucky, and you don’t have to look over your shoulder to know that Bucky’s staring right back at him. “And that same person needs to be someone Bucky would like, someone he’d be drawn to. Steve would trust Bucky’s judgement, and at least by choosing to make Bucky the center of this, we have the advantage of having him right here.”
It’s silent for a beat as the idea is mulled over. You turn around and look back to Fury, watching as his face shifts from a blank, almost bored expression to a thoughtful one. He nods slowly before tucking the pen he’s been twirling around into the pocket of his jacket.
“Sergeant Barnes…” Fury’s eyes shift to his right, landing on the stiff super soldier who looks like he’d rather be anywhere but here right now. “Does that sound like a feasible plan?” It feels as though everyone is collectively holding in a breath as Bucky remains silent. You can tell he’s thinking, you can almost see the gears turning behind his blue eyes as he zeroes in on Fury. A small nod from him is all it takes to get the conversation churning around the room again. He's in.
“I can be in and out and have this whole thing finished within just a few seconds of passing time here, I need maybe two days in the past.” Sharon says calmly, leaning back in her seat as she tucks a stray lock of blonde hair behind one ear. You really don’t even know why the discussion is still ongoing at this point. Out of everyone left in the conference room, the majority is most definitely in favor of sending Sharon back in time for the mission. It’s not like there were many other options. You didn’t exactly volunteer yourself and as of right now, you and Sharon are the only women on the team. Sure, Fury could’ve shopped around the agency a bit and found a few other suitable agents to screen for the task at hand, but Sharon seems pretty set on handling it herself.
“Okay, say you gain Peggy’s trust easily. What about Bucky? What’s your plan for getting him on your side?” Sam asks with a raised brow. The room grows quiet and all eyes land on Sharon as she filters through the possible methods she could use. Your eyes flit over to where Bucky is still leaning against the wall by the door, looking slightly less disinterested in the conversation than he was earlier. He’s studying Sharon with an unreadable expression painted on his face. Instinctively, your hand lifts up to the healing hickey that’s hidden beneath a layer of concealer and foundation right below your ear. For the briefest moment, he turns his head and tracks your movement, his eyes roaming down to the tips of your fingers as they brush over the skin of your neck. You drop your hand in an instant and his blue eyes meet yours. You can feel the arrogance radiating off of him and you roll your eyes before looking back to Sharon. You swear you hear Bucky chuckle under his breath, but when you glance around the room, no one else seems to have heard a thing.
“I just put on a pretty outfit and dance with him. It can’t be that hard to woo a soldier in his bachelor phase.” Sharon laughs out. A few softer laughs ring out around the table, but Torres’s next question quiets everyone.
“Bucky, what kind of girl would you have asked to dance back in the forties?”
You think it must be Bucky’s lack of an immediate response that sucks the air out of the room. It’s so quiet you can hear the sound of your own heart beating in your ears, even though it’s beating at a normal rate and rhythm. You steal a look at Bucky once again, who’s face is cast downward at the floor. He seems to find his shoes overly interesting all of a sudden. Everyone’s staring at him.
Bucky’s mind is churning, running through all of the girls he ever shared a moment with back in his golden days. He has a type in more ways than one. It’s not just a physical type. He’s always been drawn to women with certain personality traits, women with certain ways of carrying themselves, certain ways they flirt. One wouldn’t think he was picky with the number of girls he found himself in the company of back in the day, but he damn sure was. And he still is. That’s why his heart beats a little harder, vibrating against his ribcage as he lets out a deep breath and finally looks up. He can feel everyone’s eyes on him, but he focuses in on the one person that he’s sure his younger self will trust. Bucky’s staring right at you.
“It needs to be you.” He says firmly, fixing his gaze on your face as the color drains from it. If the air hadn’t been sucked out of the room when Torres first asked a question, it sure as hell would’ve been now. Your breath is hitched in your throat and the skin over your hidden hickey suddenly feels like it’s on fire. No, scratch that. Every inch of your skin feels like it’s on fire. Color returns to your cheeks as quickly as it first disappeared, and suddenly, you’re flushed pink.
“Me?” The word leaves your lips as an unintended whisper, but you can’t be bothered to clear your throat and try again. You know he heard you. He nods slightly, looking quite sure of himself, but his expression is still unreadable and it’s driving you mad.
“Her?” Sharon questions, narrowing her eyes at you and pursing her lips. She’s looking at you in disbelief, but not because it’s questionable that you’d be someone’s type. She’s looking at you like that because she knows, like everyone knows, that you and Bucky are at each other’s throats more often than not. Why would that be any different with a younger version of himself? The last thing the team needs is you getting sent back in time to argue with yet another version of Bucky Barnes.
“Her.” Bucky shrugs, shooting Sharon a look that easily shuts her up. She leans back in her seat once more and crosses her arms over her chest, indicating that she doesn’t like where this is going.
“Are you sure?” Sam asks with a raised brow, his eyes flitting between you and Bucky. Bucky pushes himself away from the wall and turns to face the door that leads out into the hall. As his flesh hand wraps around the door handle, he finds himself biting down on the inside of his cheek. He’s sure that his younger self will be drawn to you, that he’ll trust you, yeah. Is he sure that this is a good idea? Hell no.
“It’s her.” Bucky confirms. Then, he walks out of the conference room as if he didn’t just drop a fucking bomb in the middle of the goddamn gunmetal table. What the hell does he mean it’s you?
Your silence is unsettling. Bucky thought you might come storming into the gym during his evening workout, ready to give him a violently worded piece of your mind after he left the conference room earlier, but you never did. Then, while a mix of sweat and suds spilled down the drain of his shower, he listened intently for the sound of his bedroom door flying open, but it never came. He sits on the side of his bed in the dim light of a lamp, thumbing through the little red notebook that once belonged to Steve. He isn’t digesting its contents. Really, he isn’t even skimming over the words that are written in pencil before him. He’s zoned out as he strains his ears to listen for you across the hall. He knows you’re in your room. It’s late, just a bit past midnight now, and you’re always tucked away in there by ten. But you’re not asleep, that’s for damn certain. He can hear the occasional sound of your footsteps against the soft rug you have spread over your bedroom floor. Every few minutes, he hears an uncharacteristic scuffling sound, following by a thud. What the hell are you doing over there?
He waits a moment longer before his curiosity and impatience get the best of him, and then he’s tossing the notebook onto his bed and taking long strides toward the hall. If you won’t come to him to argue about today’s conference room situation, about what’s now lingering on the horizon, then he’ll go to you. Arguing about it will be far better than sitting around while you do whatever the hell sort of noisy thing it is you’re doing over there right now, Bucky thinks.
In retrospect, he should’ve knocked. By the time he’s throwing your unlocked door open and taking the first step into your room, he’s already sporting a half-hard cock beneath the all-too-thin fabric of his sweats and boxers. The dog tags hanging against his bare chest give away the increased rate of his breaths as his eyes skate over you. You’re on your hands and knees in the center of the room, with your cheeks flushed pink and your oversized t-shirt making it look like you’re not wearing anything else. As you stare up at Bucky, both of you frozen in place, you’re acutely aware of the compromising position he’s found you in. You sit back on your knees quickly, dropping the last few stray rings into the small jewelry tray in your left hand.
“What the hell, Bucky?” You look up at him with a mix of confusion and annoyance in your eyes as the rings clink against the ceramic tray. Bucky swallows hard as he stares down at you, trying to figure out what the fuck you’re doing in the middle of the floor. His gaze lands on one single golden ring glinting in the low light of your room and your eyes follow his.
“You missed one.” He says lowly. You reach out and pick it up with your thumb and index finger before setting it on the small tray along with the rest. “What are you doing?”
“Rearranging.” You respond dryly. You stand carefully, making sure not to dump all of your rings out a second time, before crossing the room and setting the tray on your recently moved vanity. Bucky’s only been in your room once or twice before, but he notices the changes immediately. You’ve moved your vanity from the right side of the room to the left. The chair you used to have sitting near the window now sits in a corner near the bed. A few other small pieces of furniture are strewn about haphazardly, as if you haven’t quite decided where you want them yet.
“At midnight?” Bucky raises a brow, catching your eyes as you turn to face him once more.
“What are you doing in my room, Bucky?” In his peripheral vision, he sees the slight reflection of light in one last piece of jewelry on the floor. It’s just a foot in front of him, so he steps further into the room, letting the door fall shut behind him as he bends down and scoops the rose gold ring up in his palm.
“You haven’t said anything since the team meeting earlier today.” He points out. He studies the small ring in his hand, realizing for the first time just how much smaller your hands are than his. You don’t make a move to take it from him, so he continues fiddling with it as he stands in the middle of your room.
“You walked out.” You remind him. You turn your back to him and begin straightening up a few things on your vanity. It’s weird to have him in your room like this. Your skin feels warm while the air in the room feels cold. Your oversized t-shirt feels too small while his presence feels much too large.
“I didn’t have anything else to say.” Bucky takes a few more steps forward and turns, bending at the knees to sit on the foot of your nicely made bed. You watch him in the reflection of your vanity mirror, wondering why the hell he seems so comfortable in your room.
“And I should? What do you want me to say?”
“Anything.” His single-word response makes the air in the room feel even icier, and suddenly, you’re wishing you’d put on sweats tonight. A deep breath rattles in your chest before you turn around to face him.
“It’s not me.” You say evenly. You cross your arms over your chest and focus on his face as he stares back at you. He’s still fiddling with the ring, running the pad of his thumb back and forth over it mindlessly.
“It’s you.” He sighs. He almost seems tired with the conversation, which is frustrating considering he’s the one who came in here and started it.
“It’s not, and having me deal with two of you is a recipe for disaster. I can barely handle one Bucky Barnes in this century. Sharon’s the better choice.”
“It’s not Sharon.”
“Bucky—”
“It’s you. I don’t know what you need me to say or do to convince you, but it’s you. The sooner you accept it, the sooner we can start making a plan and preparing for the mission.”
His words swirl around in your head, bouncing off of the walls of your mind like it’s a fucking pinball machine. It’s not you. You’re pretty damn sure that what 1940s Bucky Barnes needs is anything but you. Maybe Bucky’s so far removed from his younger self that he just doesn’t realize how wrong you are for this mission. He’s gotten too used to working with you in the field lately and he doesn’t want to figure things out in the field with a new partner. Whatever his reasoning is, you need him to figure his shit out before you’re sent back in time to fuck up the op.
“You can’t convince me.” You reply stubbornly, narrowing your eyes at him. “Sharon is right for this mission and everyone sees that but you.” When he glances up at you this time, his eyes settle on the light pink mark beneath your ear. His mark.
“You’re my type.” The words slip past his lips before he can stop them, and he’s gripping the ring tightly in his flesh fist.
“What?”
“I’m not saying it again.” He decides, pushing himself up to stand. You’re frozen in stunned silence, your eyes wide. You’re sure you’re about to watch him walk out the door after dropping his second bomb of the day, but he turns to face you. He’s moving forward before you have a chance to do or say a damn thing. Bucky doesn’t stop until your arms are dropping down to your sides and his hands are resting on your hips. He walks you backward one, two steps, until your ass hits the edge of the vanity and a gasp parts your lips.
“There was this bar in London, the Whip and Fiddle. I went there with Steve and the guys a few times.” Bucky starts. His tone is low and gravelly and his lips are so close to yours that they nearly touch with every word he speaks. He’s looking down into your eyes with an intense look, a look that keeps you firmly in place, along with his hold on your hips and his muscular frame pressed partially against your front. A shiver runs down your spine, but you stay silent, waiting for him to continue. Bucky’s right hand glides upward, following the curve of your body until his fingertips are ghosting over the side of your neck. He presses his thumb against your healing hickey lightly, feeling you tense against him at the touch. “If younger me saw you walk into that bar, even with all of the noise and the low lights, he’d fucking swoon. It would all be over. The chasing girls around, only ever learning first names and hometowns, the bachelor shit. It would be over. He’d follow you anywhere.”
“Bucky—”
“It’s you. Not Sharon, not anyone else damn it, it’s you.” His vibranium hand tightens over your hip and his right hand slides further back behind your head. His fingers tangle in your hair but it’s a gentle, careful act. You tilt your head up and take in his serious expression. His brows are furrowed and his gaze heats your face as he stares down at you. He isn’t fucking with you. He isn’t trying to get in your head or manipulate you into being a part of this mission. He means every word of what he’s saying right now and it scares the shit out of you. You move quick, drawing your arms up between the two of you and pressing your palms flat against his bare chest. You shove him back hard, forcing him to take one big step away from you. He doesn’t look surprised at all, and his expression never shifts, the seriousness never leaves his face.
“You can’t stand me.” You remind him, though the words feel empty as you say them. You’re questioning the notion, as if he hasn’t said those words himself a hundred times before.
“I can’t.” He agrees, nodding slowly. You take a deep, shaky breath in and let it out through your teeth. “But for some reason, it’s still you.”
You stand still, with the edge of the vanity still digging into your ass and your chest heaving as Bucky turns his back to you and heads for the foot of your bed. You watch through narrowed eyes as he leans over and scoops up the ring he left sitting there. He straightens up and looks down at the small shiny object held precariously between his thumb and forefinger.
“Do you know how to dance?” The question rolls off of his tongue so casually that for a moment, you wonder if anything that just happened really happened. Did he not have you pushed up against the vanity only seconds ago? Was he not touching you and leaning in close like you meant something to him after months of acting like you’re nothing more than his shit-giving coworker?
“What?” You nearly choke on the word. Your throat is so dry after seemingly forgetting to swallow at all in his presence.
“Do you know how to dance?” He repeats, craning his neck to the side to look at you.
“What the hell does—”
“He’s going to ask you to dance, and you’ll have to say yes.” Bucky says matter-of-factly. You find it a little odd that he refers to his younger self as if he’s someone else, but you don’t comment on it. “I can teach you.”
“Fine.” Bucky freezes at your quick and unexpected caving. He raises an eyebrow at you, still fiddling with the ring between his fingers. “Help me move my dresser.” Your eyes dart over to the large piece of furniture across the room and Bucky’s gaze follows. He looks at it for a second as the realization dawns that you’re really asking for manual labor in exchange for agreeing to go back in time for this mission. The fact that you’re going to do it, that you’re going to be the one who does this with him, leaves an unfamiliar calmness settling inside of him and he lets out a deep breath.
The sounds of furniture scuffling around the room and soft thuds carry on for the next half hour as Bucky uses the serum in his veins to set your room up just how you want it. When everything is finished and you seem satisfied, he walks over to your vanity and drops the last ring into the ceramic tray. Your eyes rake over his bare back, taking in the way there isn’t even the slightest sheen of sweat present on his smooth skin. You should’ve asked him to move your furniture two hours ago when you first started doing it yourself. If you’d known it was so damn easy for him, you might’ve even said please.
“You should probably lock your door at night.” Bucky says as he heads toward it. He wraps his hand around the door handle and you watch as the muscles of his flesh arm ripple slightly.
“Why? Are you going to keep barging in?”
“You’ve done that a lot more than I have.” He points out, tugging the door open to reveal the darkened hallway beyond.
“So, start locking yours then.” You retort. He can hear you rolling your eyes. A small smile plays on his lips as he steps out into the hall and runs a hand through his messy hair, keeping his back to you.
“My door’s always open for you, sweetheart.”
“Fuck you, Barnes.” You say coldly, just as the door clicks shut between the two of you.
You can’t stand him.
Sam doesn’t let things go easily. Sure, if he was really pushing Bucky’s buttons, he might back off a bit, but he hasn’t gone too far yet. Yet.
“I just want to know how you can go from barely getting along with the woman to demanding that she’s the one for your little forties self.” Sam says through a smirk. He falls into step next to Bucky as the two of them jog through the heavily wooded trails behind the tower.
“If you’re going to keep talking about this, you can finish the run alone.” Bucky threatens, shooting Sam a deathly sideways glare.
“I’ve been telling you for months that there was something between the two of you, and you shot it down every time. I don’t get to gloat now?”
“There’s nothing to gloat about. There isn’t anything between us besides this mission. You’re reading too far into shit, Sam.”
“That super soldier serum didn’t teach you how to be a convincing liar, huh?”
“I’ll see you back at the tower.” Bucky says flatly, immediately picking up his pace to an ungodly speed and leaving Sam behind in literal dust.
Bucky’s ears are filled with the sounds of his feet pounding against the dry dirt path below and his own steady, even breaths as he speeds along the trail. The mission is the only thing between you, he tells himself. There isn’t anything else. As much as he wants there to be, as much as he feels something there, you fight against the tension like it suffocates you. You fight against it tooth and nail, pushing Bucky away every time you think he might be getting a little closer to you. Is it just him? If it was someone else running dangerous ops with you, saving your ass regularly, and sitting through stake-outs with you late at night, would you push them away just as hard? Or is it just because that guy is Bucky?
Thunder rumbles in the distance, tearing Bucky away from his troubling train of thought momentarily. He glances up through the crowded tree branches and catches sight of the gray sky above. He can smell rain in the air, so he picks up the pace a little more, intent on beating it.
He can still feel the curve of your hip against his vibranium hand and the way every muscle in your body tensed up when he pressed his thumb against the mark on your neck last night. Fuck. Bucky feels beads of sweat forming around his hairline, and it’s not from the hellish pace he’s bent on keeping. His mind falls even further back to that last stakeout. The memory of you moving over the center console of the car and seating yourself on his lap so effortlessly plays out in front of him like a movie. He doesn’t even realize how fast he’s running until the tower comes into view a whole lot sooner than he expected it to. With sweat dripping down the back of his neck, he tugs his shirt off and scans his palm at the back entrance to the gym.
He can feel the weight of your body settling over him, feel your thighs pressing against either of his hips as you straddle his lap. Bucky bites down on his bottom lip as he tugs the door open and glances over his shoulder for any sign of Sam. He lets the door fall closed behind him when he realizes that he’s probably still a couple of miles back in the woods. Lifting the t-shirt that’s hanging from his right hand, Bucky uses it to wipe the sweat from his brow and neck. Fuck you. Fuck you for acting like you’re oblivious to whatever the hell has been brewing between the two of you for months now. It’s right in front of your face and yet you act like you can’t see a damn thing, like you don’t feel a damn thing. Fuck you for giving Bucky just enough of you to fantasize about but not enough to feel satisfied. He heads straight for the locker room, shoving the door open hard as he uses one hand to untie the drawstring of his shorts.
He won’t let himself do what he needs to do. He comes to stand in front of the mirror, placing his hands on the edge of the sink as he drops his head and sucks in a deep breath. He won’t do it. Bucky lifts his head a bit, looking his reflection in the eye for a moment before flicking the faucet on and splashing a handful of cold water against his flushed face.
Fuck. He’s going to do it. He’s rushing for one of the showers within the next second, turning the hot water on just before he shoves his shorts and boxers down. He steps out of them, already mentally chastising himself for what he’s about to do.
He’s only been in the shower for a minute when heat begins to spread down his spine, sending a warmth over the surface of his skin and pushing him to lean forward. He rests his forehead against the cold tile wall of the shower, telling himself that this is pathetic. His flesh hand works quickly, moving back and forth while staying wrapped tightly around the shaft of his cock. A shaky breath snakes past his lips as his eyes flutter closed and his hips piston forward once, twice, three times. He fucks his hand roughly, letting out a low groan when the pad of his thumb brushes against the sensitive spot on the underside of the head of his cock. He hates that this is what he’s resorted to. Never once has he left himself do this with you on his mind. It feels shameful, even offensive. You’d kick his ass if you ever found out, he’s fucking sure of that. Still, he continues on, working himself up until he’s teetering on the edge of bliss. It’s the memory of you on his lap in that damn care, letting him tug on your hair and tilt your head back so he could suck on your neck, that almost finishes him. His movements grow sloppy and his breaths come out a little more ragged. He replays the sweet little sound you made when he left that hickey on your skin, when he left his mark on you.
“Shit.” Bucky groans, scrunching his eyes shut even tighter and stroking his cock a little harder. A shudder races through him and he bangs his vibranium fist against the shower wall just as his climax hits. He opens his eyes and watches as ropes of cum paint the tiles. The steamy shower water washes it all away and carries it down the drain within seconds. What a waste.
You’ve been lying on your stomach in bed ever since you woke up, watching every video you can find that depicts anything remotely close to dancing in the forties. It’s stressing you the hell out. How long do you have to learn this shit? Does Bucky even remember how to do this? You can’t picture him doing something so…lighthearted.
You roll over onto your back, tossing your phone to the opposite side of the bed before pressing the heels of your hands into your eyes and letting out a frustrated groan. Why the hell did you agree to this? Oh, right. The memory of last night starts playing in your mind on a loop. Bucky barged into your room like he had every right to. He sat on your bed. He pushed you up against the vanity and…and did absolutely nothing. So, why does your heart race merely at the memory? If it was nothing, why did it feel like something? You let out a louder groan and run your hands through your messy hair, tugging at it a little and feeling the slight stretch of your scalp. You’re thinking about pulling the covers over your face and going back to sleep for the rest of the rainy morning, but your train of thought shifts over to the contents of the communal fridge in the kitchen down the hall.
Bucky’s chosen to avoid you today. If what he did in the shower half an hour ago is any indication of the dangerous territory that he’s put himself in, he knows he needs to pump the brakes now. So, he stands in the kitchen, leaning against the edge of the countertop as he sips on a glass of orange juice in near-silence. The sounds of rolling thunder and heavy rain are all he can hear as he tries to ignore the guilt eating away at him. He really fucked his hand simply at the memory of being close to you last night. He’s in way too fucking deep and he needs to get a grip before this mission really starts. Maybe he should’ve just let it be Sharon. She probably could’ve pulled it off. Younger Bucky wasn’t really all that picky if he’d had a few drinks, and Sharon could’ve easily been coached to put on a personality that Bucky would’ve been drawn to. But no, he had to make sure it was you. God, he’s kicking himself for it all now.
He stiffens when he hears your door open down the hall, fighting against the urge to make a dash for the elevator just to avoid you. He glances at the time displayed over the stovetop. It’s still too early to get ready and rush off for his therapy session, but maybe if he drives really slowly Dr. Raynor won’t have to question why he’s there an hour and a half ahead of time. Bucky lets out a heavy sigh as your footsteps patter down the hall in the distance. He’s being dramatic. He knows that. He had a moment of weakness in the shower this morning and it was his own fault. He shouldn’t have let his thoughts carry him that far and he sure as hell shouldn’t have been in your room doing and saying the things he did and said last night.
When you appear in the main living area, you’re still wearing that damn oversized t-shirt and distinct lack of pants that you were last night, and Bucky stifles a frustrated groan. His eyes roam over your body so quickly that you don’t even notice the look as you enter the kitchen and give him a small nod. You tug the fridge open and rummage around for a few seconds as your mind races. Your heart is beating wildly in your chest, you can feel warmth creeping into your cheeks, coloring them pink. You hate this. Why the hell did he decide to flip a switch this week? You were fine barely getting along, just giving each other shit in the field and then coming home after missions and going your separate ways for the most part. Why did he have to say all of that shit about it being you that his younger self would want?
Your appetite dissipates more and more with each passing second, until suddenly you’re shutting the fridge and taking a step back. You see Bucky out of the corner of your eye, sipping on an almost empty glass of orange juice as he studies you.
“You’re manipulative.” You say lowly, crossing your arms over your chest as you turn to face him. He raises a brow at you and takes another sip from his glass, but says nothing in response. “What you did last night wasn’t fair.”
“Moving your furniture around?” He questions, keeping that one brow raised. You can tell by the look in his eyes that he’s being facetious and it pisses you off. Your tongue presses against the inside of your cheek as you look him over. He’s clearly fresh out of the shower with messy, damp hair. He’s dressed in dark gray sweats and a navy blue t-shirt that hugs the muscles of his upper body a little too snugly for your liking.
You could just respond to his question with a verbal answer, you know that. You could just open your mouth and remind him about what it was that he did last night that you’re referring to as being unfair and manipulative. But your feet carry you forward. You move slowly, giving him a multitude of opportunities to step around you and leave the kitchen unscathed. Bucky remains planted there, leaning against the kitchen counter with the glass in his hand. When you’re only a foot away from him, you reach out with your right hand and take hold of the glass. He watches you carefully, with his head slightly cocked to the side as your grip tightens and his loosens. When he lets you fully take the glass from his hand, you lift it to your lips and swallow the last sip of orange juice. Bucky’s cock twitches beneath the fabric of his sweats as he watches your lips retreat from the exact spot that his once pressed against the glass. He bites down on the inside of his cheek in an attempt to dissuade the hardening of his already tired cock.
“Do you really think I’m talking about you moving my furniture around?” You ask in a whisper, taking one more step forward until your chest is nearly brushing against his. You reach past him with your right arm and set the glass on the countertop behind him, holding your breath as your bottom lip comes within a centimeter of his chin. You keep your head tilted up, watching his eyes as the distance between you diminishes. “I couldn’t possibly be talking about you pushing me up against the vanity and putting your hands on me, right?” His eyes flutter closed and you smirk, feeling satisfied with the effect that you’re clearly having on him. You let both of your hands rest against the edge of the countertop on either side of him and suddenly you’re close enough that when you stop tilting your head upward, the tip of your nose is threatening to brush against the column of his throat.
“Did that do something for you?” His words come out slightly raspy and it sends an unfamiliar warmth surging low in your stomach. You pull your head back a couple of inches and look up at him through your lashes, tilting your head to the side.
“Not a damn thing.” You lie. He chuckles darkly and lets out a breath that fans across your face. A smug smile takes over his features and you feel your confidence wavering.
“Right.” He says absently, as his flesh hand begins to move. You can feel your heart rate doubling as you anticipate his touch, and it infuriates you. Since when does he get this kind of physiological reaction from your body? As his fingertips make light contact with the side of your neck, you inhale sharply and let your eyes fall closed. You want so badly to remain stoic, to look as unbothered as ever as his fingers ghost over the now mostly invisible hickey that he left days ago, but you fail.
Bucky knows that when he presses his thumb against that spot, just like he did last night, your body will tense up. Even with the alarm bells going off inside his head, with that little voice inside of him screaming for him to run, to do anything but the stupid thing he’s about to do, he can’t help himself. His wraps his vibranium around your waist and presses his cool metal palm against the small of your back before tugging you forward. The moment your chest collides with his, he pushes the pad of his thumb against that spot beneath your ear and revels in the feeling of your body tensing against his. Fuck. He’s in deep, but he wishes he was in so much deeper.
“Not a damn thing, hm?” He teases, looking down at you as your eyes flutter open.
“I really can’t stand you.” You retort, but you make no move to get out of his hold. You’re sure that he can feel the dangerously high rate that your heart’s beating at, but still, you stay there against him.
“I know.” He smirks. He lets his thumb trail down the side of your neck until it reaches your collarbone, and then he moves it right back up to the spot where he first marked you. “But you agreed to be a part of the mission anyway, so you’re stuck with me for now.”
“I still think it’s a bad idea.” You point out. You’re coming to your senses now, realizing just how compromising of a position you’re both in right now and how beyond stupid and careless this is. What are you thinking? You pull your hands up between your two bodies and place your palms against the soft blue fabric of his shirt, getting ready to push yourself away from him. He knows what you’re about to do so he tightens his vibranium arm around your waist and slides his flesh hand back to tangle in your hair.
“I didn’t convince you last night?” He asks roughly, narrowing his eyes at you as if he’s slightly annoyed. You shake your head and push lightly against his chest, not putting any real effort behind your movement. He holds you impossibly tighter against his chest before dipping his head down toward your neck.
“Bucky.” You breathe his name out softly, with no other words coming to your mind.
He’s feral. He’s fucking feral. He’s fighting with every ounce of restraint that he possesses to keep from leaving five more marks on the skin of your neck, just to replace the one that’s now faded from there. It’s as if he didn’t fuck his hand to completion less than an hour ago, because his cock sure seems to have forgotten. He bites down on his bottom lip before nudging the tip of his nose against the column of your throat. God, he wants to fucking taste you.
“You know where to find me if you need more convincing.” He says lowly, nipping at your neck one single time before releasing you from his grip and pushing past you. He needs to get the fuck out of here.
You spend the rest of Saturday morning in bed, just like you’d planned, though you didn’t get much sleep. You laid there under the covers, lazily scrolling through your phone, until you heard Bucky’s door opening, closing, and then locking right before he headed for the elevator down the hall. With him out of the tower, you finally felt like you could breathe. So, that’s what you did. You laid in bed and breathed. You took a nice, deep breath in as you rolled over onto your back and let your hand snake down beneath the waistband of your panties. You let a long breath out as you ran your fingertips through the wetness that had gathered along your folds. Then, you drew a shaky breath in as you circled your middle and ring fingers over your clit, using your own arousal as lube. You don’t feel good about what you did to yourself the moment Bucky was out of earshot. You don’t feel good about pretending that your hand was really his. You really don’t feel good about his name being on the tip of your tongue as an orgasm shook you to your core. But you feel good about the fact that you didn’t actually say his name out loud. That’s something, right?
As you put the final finishing touches on your makeup look for the night, you force yourself to push Bucky Barnes far out of reach of your mind. You know that you’ll have to deal with him enough come Monday, when there’s another team meeting about the mission, but for now, you tell yourself that he’s off limits. He’s off limits and you get to spend the night thinking about anyone and anything else. Maybe that’s exactly what you should do. Think about anyone else.
The bar that Sharon chose for tonight is dimly lit and overly full of patrons. You feel like you touch a minimum of three people every time you try to take a step in any direction, so you settle into a cramped booth with your drink and good company, hoping you can get away with sitting there for at least the next hour while the crowd thins out.
“You could’ve picked a busier place.” Maria remarks sarcastically, shooting Sharon an annoyed look as they both slide into their seats across from you. You take a long sip of your drink before setting it down on the wooden surface of the table and double-checking that nothing was swiped from your clutch on your way through the bustling bar.
“You need to get used to being around normal people, Maria.” Sharon wiggles her eyebrows. “No gods or mutants or super soldiers, just good old fashioned normal men.”
“I came here under the impression that this was going to be a girls night.” Maria says as she lifts her drink up to her lips. A mischievous look takes over Sharon’s face and her eyes glimmer as she looks between you both.
“A girls night where all the girls go home with a plus one.”
“Oh, fuck off, Sharon.” Maria scoffs, shoving her shoulder playfully. Sharon snorts and casts her gaze around the crowded bar, seemingly browsing the vast menu of eligible men. As you follow her line of sight, you notice that there are significantly more men than women here. Including the three of you, you count maybe a total of ten women versus at least fifty men.
“Sharon…” You start, narrowing your eyes as you face her.
“Maybe I chose a bar that’s currently having their weekly guys night.” Knowing that both you and Maria are ready to start in on her, Sharon raises a hand and closes her eyes. “But I did it with a good heart. You both need to get laid.”
As much as you want to kick her from underneath the table, you know she’s right. You shake your head as you take another long sip from your drink, and wonder just how many of these you might need before you agree to go home with one of the strangers in this bar.
“I don’t think I’m the one that needs to get laid tonight.” Maria says quietly, casting a pointed look in your direction. Your eyes widen at her insinuation.
“Why are you looking at me when you say that?”
“You’re about to spend a whole lot of time with not one, but two Bucky Barnes.” She responds. Sharon nods eagerly, suddenly leaning forward and resting her elbows on the table as she joins Sharon in staring you down.
“You need to fuck someone and clear your system before this mission takes off. Make sure you’re going into it with an empty tank, you know?” You’re sure that Sharon’s mostly joking, but there’s still an air of seriousness to her words.
“You both think that I’d be tempted by him?” You raise an eyebrow at both of the women before you. They share an indecipherable look between themselves before all eyes are back on you.
“Aren’t we all?”
Bucky doesn’t usually pick whiskey. Nowadays he’s more of a beer kind of guy. Especially when he wants to drink a lot and reminisce about the times when he could get drunk. The feel of a cold glass bottle in his hand and the lip of it pressing against his mouth with each sip reminds him of a time when just a few of those would do him in. But tonight, he’s drinking Four Roses.
As he swirls the amber liquid around in his glass, he scans the packed bar. The crowd is thick, with men heavily outnumbering and swarming the few women that are milling about.
“I didn’t take you three for the guy’s night type.” Maria’s familiar voice sounds from behind Bucky’s left shoulder. He turns in unison with Sam and Torres. When their backs are to the bar, they all come face to face with Maria Hill. Bucky gives her a subtle up-and-down look, feeling a bit odd seeing her in an outfit that doesn’t resemble anything tactical for once.
“I wouldn’t have taken you for the guy’s night type either.” Sam laughs out before taking a sip of his beer.
“Trust me, I’m not.” Maria responds with a slight grimace, casting a glance over her shoulder in the general direction of where she came from. Bucky follows her gaze and spots a few booths off to a side wall, but it’s too dim for him to tell which one she might be looking to. He focuses back on her as she pushes between him and Sam to get to the bar. She orders three different drinks in quick succession, but only the last one catches Bucky’s attention. It’s your drink. “Is that you guys that I feel staring or is it the rest of the sleazy men in this place?” Maria asks jokingly, looking over her shoulder again. Sam and Torres both laugh, but Bucky’s barely paying any attention. He’s scanning the room again, studying each face with a watchful eye as he searches for you. “They’re in the third booth against the far left wall.” Maria says reluctantly, when she catches the look in Bucky’s eye. She may find him attractive as hell, like everyone else does, but she knows he’s essentially off the market. He may hide it well with the constant bickering and brooding façade, but he’s so fucking into you. Maria knows it as well as anybody else. Well, anybody but you. Sometimes she wonders if Bucky himself even knows it.
Bucky shoots Maria a sideways look and she shakes her head.
“They won’t be happy that you guys are crashing girls’ night.” She clicks her tongue disapprovingly, just as the bartender starts working on her drinks.
“Oh, come on. They’ll be thrilled.” Sam jokes, immediately heading off in the direction of the booth Maria described. Torres stays with her, but Bucky follows Sam closely. He should be running in the opposite direction. He knows it’d be in his best interest to down the rest of his whiskey and run right out the door. And yet, his feet carry him forward like his entire goal since this morning hasn’t been to avoid you.
You were having a half-decent night before you laid eyes on Bucky Barnes. When he comes into view, wearing one of his signature leather jackets and dark gloves, your heart skips a beat. You’re sure it’s skipping a beat out of protest rather than anything more meaningful, but still, it skips a damn beat. You don’t even hear Sam’s initial greeting, or the immediate banter that he and Sharon get into the moment he’s within earshot of the table. In fact, every single sound in the bar seems muffled all of a sudden. He’s staring at you. Bucky’s looking right into your eyes as he hovers near the end of the table, with his expression as bored and unreadable as ever.
The intense eye contact is only broken when Maria and Torres appear, and she uses her shoulder to nudge Bucky out of the way so she can set the three drinks down. As soon as she slides the small glass in front of you, the din of the bar is loud again and you’re itching for a higher blood-alcohol level. You down the fresh drink in one long gulp, ignoring the burning in your throat as all eyes fall on you.
“I think I need something a little stronger.” You say flatly, after clearing your throat and setting your empty glass down on the table. Sharon raises an eyebrow at you but within a second, she re-engages with Sam. Maria and Torres are quick to take your side of the booth the moment you rise to your feet, and Sam slides in next to Sharon. As you saunter off toward the bar, you can hear the sound of Bucky dragging a chair over to the edge of the table to give himself somewhere to sit.
Bucky can’t seem to tear his eyes away from you as you make your way to the bar. You’re wearing a little black dress that hugs your curves and accentuates every part of you that he’s been trying not to think about all goddamn day. The heels you chose are surely killing your feet with every step you take, but god, they keep drawing his gaze down your legs and then the dress drags him right back up again. The front of Bucky’s jeans have started to feel a bit too tight and his mind is reeling. He wants to pour his glass of whiskey into his eyes. It may be the only way he can stop fucking staring at you.
Though you feel Bucky’s eyes burning a hole in the back of your head, you refuse to look back. He can stare all he wants, but you’ve decided not to give a shit. He messed with your head last night and manipulated you into being a part of next week’s mission. Then, he messed with your head again this morning, telling you to come find him if you need anymore convincing. What the hell did he mean by that? You swallow hard as you reach the bar, reaching out and grabbing onto the edge of it to steady yourself. You’re two drinks in now and starting to feel a little buzzed, but you sure as hell won’t be stopping if the guys are sticking around. You order something significantly stronger than your last two drinks and then start fiddling with a stray lock of hair that’s hanging over your shoulder as you try to look unapproachable. This place feels like a testosterone festival and although Bucky’s stare was the only one you felt at first, you’re acutely aware of quite a few more pairs of eyes on you now.
Bucky’s aware as well, so fucking aware. He watches with veiled frustration as you become the center of attention over at the bar. He can tell you don’t even want the attention simply by your body language, but that doesn’t stop men from ogling shamelessly. He knows you can handle yourself, so he bites down on his bottom lip and tries to return his attention to the table, choosing to pick his battles wisely. He tunes into a semi-heated conversation about who’s worse at holding their liquor amongst everyone at the table, but every now and then, his gaze flits back over to you.
Two minutes go by before Sam notices the tension seemingly rolling off of Bucky’s broad shoulders. The brooding super soldier sits stiffly in the wooden chair at the end of the table, gripping his whiskey glass so tightly in one gloved hand that Sam’s surprised it hasn’t shattered under the pressure. When he follows Bucky’s gaze across the room, he finds the source of all of that angsty tension. There you are, looking undeniably gorgeous in that little black dress of yours with a fresh drink in hand as some tall, charismatic guy tries his best to win you over. Sam chuckles under his breath and watches for a moment, noting the way the guy continues getting closer to you every time you lean away from him. He sees the fake smile painted on your face and the way you keep nodding your head in the direction of the table as you speak in short sentences, probably letting the guy know that you have a group waiting for you.
“Go get your girl, Bucky.” Sam finally says, lifting his half-empty beer bottle in your direction. “Haven’t you two been a fake couple at least a hundred times by now? Pretend to be her man and get her out of that.” Bucky winces at the idea. Conversation at the table dies down as everyone starts shifting to get a look at you.
“What do you want me to do?” Bucky asks dryly, taking a long sip of his whiskey as he analyzes Sam’s expression over the rim of the glass. “She can get out of that herself if she wants to.”
“Yeah, or you could make it easy for her.” Sam points out. Bucky turns his head to look at you again and he doesn’t like what he sees. The man takes one step closer to you, nearly closing the gap between your bodies entirely. He makes it seem as though he was pushed into you, which you seem to buy given how crowded the bar area still is. You let out a stiff but polite laugh, and then the man rests his right hand on your hip as he leans down and whispers something in your ear. That’s enough, Bucky decides. He downs the last of his whiskey before standing up and setting the empty glass on the edge of the table. He’s moving toward the bar before he has a moment to tell himself to stop. In an instant, his gloves are being tugged off one at a time and shoved into the pocket of his leather jacket.
Bucky could just shove the guy away from you. He could throw a punch and start a good old-fashioned bar fight, maybe get himself kicked out into the street along the way. He could even waltz up and call you some sweet little pet name, because maybe, just maybe, the guy would be respectful enough to ditch the moment he thinks you’re spoken for.
But as Bucky’s flesh hand tangles in the hair at the crown of your head and he tugs you back harshly, every other possible way to handle the situation is trampled under his feet. His movements are rough but calculated as he separates you from the guy and places his own body between you. Your lips part and you nearly spill your drink as Bucky uses his hold on your hair to tilt your head up so you’re looking right into his blue eyes.
“Bucky, what—” The. Fuck.
With his right hand still fisting your hair and his left moving to wrap around your waist, he pulls you flush against his chest and leans in. You don’t realize it, but even in your shocked state, you lean in to meet him. He tilts his head to the side and sucks your bottom lip in between his teeth instantly, barely even kissing you before he’s biting down on it hard enough to draw a gasp from you. He takes the opportunity to slide his tongue between your parted lips and taste you. Fuck. He didn’t mean to do it. He didn’t mean to put his tongue in your mouth, but now that it’s there? Fuck, he’s ruined. Bucky kisses you so intensely, so fucking passionately that for a moment, you’re convinced it’s real. It isn’t until his grip on your hip falters and he has to pull back to take a breath that you realize why he did it, that you realize it most definitely wasn’t real. You’re fighting to catch your breath as he lets you go and glances over his shoulder, making sure the guy is gone. When he looks back at you, you’re pressing your fingertips to your lips lightly, while clutching your drink in your other hand. Your eyes are wide and your hair messy from his touch. His eyes skate over your face, taking in the way your cheeks and nose are rosy and your pupils are dilated as you stare at him. Bucky runs a hand through his own hair and bites down on his bottom lip. Wait, is he…flustered?
“Stop looking at me like that.” He says lowly. As much as you want to give him hell for that stupid stunt, your brain only seems to be able to focus on one thing.
“You taste like honey.” Your voice comes out soft but raspy, and your fingertips still ghost over your lips as you speak. Bucky looks taken aback by your response, and he stills for a moment as he looks down at you, his eyes narrowing.
“You taste like strawberries.” His gaze darts down to your lips, but then quickly back up to your eyes. Shaking your head to snap yourself out of whatever trance you’ve found yourself in, you brush past Bucky, making a break for the table.
Bucky needs a fucking minute. With your scent swirling around him and the ghost of your mouth on his, he needs a minute to adjust the raging hard-on he’s sporting and gather himself. What the fuck did he do that for? He’s gritting his teeth as he turns on his heel and heads for the bathrooms off to the side of the bar. When he steps foot in the men’s room, he scans the floor of each stall quickly, making sure he’s completely alone before locking the door to the entire bathroom and moving to stand in front of the large mirror displayed across the wall of sinks. Strawberries. Bucky stares down at the ceramic sink in front of him as his hands move to grip onto the edge of it. He fights the urge to break it into a million little pieces as he licks his lips, picking up a hint of your taste. Lifting his head and catching his own gaze in his reflection, he bites down on his bottom lip nearly hard enough to draw blood. The twinge of pain is enough to snap him out of whatever the hell kind of haze he’s in, and he flicks the sink on with his flesh hand. After washing his hands, he splashes a bit of cold water on his face before drying up with a few paper towels. He doesn’t leave the bathroom without adjusting his cock, tucking the head of it beneath the waistband of his boxers and pants to ensure his unchecked arousal won’t be noticed by anyone.
With lively conversation passing back and forth across the table, no one seems to notice the thick tension brewing between you and Bucky. You haven’t glanced at him once since he came back from the men’s room looking utterly unbothered by the display of public deception that he’d put on just moments earlier.
Bucky steals looks at you throughout the evening as you go through three of your usual drinks and two shots of vodka with Maria and Sharon. He notices that you smile a lot more when you have some alcohol in your system. You also look at him a hell of a lot less, and he hates that. He can’t seem to go more than a minute or two without searching you out, while you don’t even seem to notice that he’s still in the bar. He watches with a knotted stomach as two other guys attempt to move in on you when you’re up at the bar with the girls, but the knot unties itself when he sees you quickly turn them both down. Why hadn’t you done that with the first guy earlier tonight? A weird sensation bubbles up in his chest as he wonders if maybe you’d actually been attracted to the man you were talking to before Bucky stormed over and stuck his tongue in your mouth. Did you only turn the last two men down because you were worried that Bucky would try to kiss you again?
As much as you would’ve liked to avoid looking at Bucky all night, your plan is thwarted when Sharon ends up a little past tipsy and Maria decides to Uber back to her apartment early. Not wanting to wrangle a semi-drunk Sharon in an Uber by yourself, you accept Sam’s offer for a ride. With Sam driving and Torres immediately sliding into the passenger seat, you push Sharon into the backseat on the passenger’s side and shut her door. You watch with a small smile playing on your lips as she promptly leans against the door and closes her eyes. You’re sure she’ll be asleep before Sam ever pulls up to her apartment complex.
You cross around the backside of the car to find Bucky standing, holding the other back door open for you. You glance inside, noting the small middle seat and shake your head.
“I’m not sitting in the middle.” You say stubbornly, crossing your arms over your chest. A small shiver wracks through your body as the chilly night air blows over your exposed skin. Bucky’s shrugging his jacket off before he even realizes it. When he holds it out to you, you look at it warily, but another cold breeze wafts by and you reach out and grab it. Draping it over your shoulders, you narrow your eyes at him. “I’m still not sitting in the middle.”
“Yes, you are.” He responds roughly, resting his left forearm on top of the open door as his right hand moves to rest on his hip.
“No, I’m not.” You’re aware of the fact that you sound like two children arguing over something so trivial, but still, you maintain your stance. Bucky bites the inside of his cheek before stepping back and pushing the door shut. You hear Sam shout something out of confusion, probably wondering what the hell you two are doing out there in the cold delaying the ride home, but you both ignore him.
“You kissed me back.” He says in a low, raspy voice, making sure no one in the car could possibly make out his words. Your eyes widen and you pull his leather jacket tighter around your shoulders, trying to ignore the way his scent is rolling off of it and surrounding you.
“You put your tongue in my mouth.” You respond stiffly, glancing over your shoulder at the car.
“I’d do it again if it would shut you up and make you get in the car.”
“Sounds like you’re looking for an excuse.” You say, letting out a fake laugh. Bucky rolls his eyes, clearly unimpressed with your accusation.
“You really think I’d look for an excuse to do that again?” Bucky asks, taking a step toward you and reaching past your body for the door handle. When he’s close enough to you that his lips are nearly grazing against the shell of your ear, your eyes flutter closed. “I think we both know I wouldn’t need one.”
Bucky tugs the door open just as you open your eyes and look into his.
“Get in the damn car.” He says authoritatively, holding the door open as you glare at him. You want to dig in your heels and stand on the curb until the sun rises in the morning, but with how cold you are and how late it is, you know you’re fighting a losing battle. You give Bucky a look that could kill as you slide into the middle seat and let out a frustrated sigh. You use his jacket to cover your legs and maintain what little body heat you have left. When Bucky slides in after you and pulls the door shut, Sam’s driving off before either of you have buckled your seatbelts. Bucky fastens his own before noticing that you’re not making a move to buckle yours, so he takes matters into his own hands. He leans over you and grasps the seatbelt in his flesh hand as he brings his lips close to your ear again, lowering his voice to a whisper. “Always so fucking stubborn.”
With every little curve and bump in the road, Bucky’s leg brushes against yours and you tense up each time. You’re always quick to pull your leg away and back toward the middle of the floorboard, until you start to notice that he never pulls his away. You stare out of the windshield ahead as Sam weaves through the city, heading toward Sharon’s downtown apartment. When you turn your head and glance over at her, she’s sound asleep with her mouth wide open as her head rests against the door beside her. Another bump jostles the car and Bucky’s leg collides with yours, but instead of pulling away this time, you stay still. As the heat of his leg permeates the thick fabric of his jeans and warms your bare knee, you find yourself relaxing a little. It really is way too cold to be wearing such a tiny dress.
Bucky’s gaze is fixed outside of his window, but he can feel you letting your head fall back to rest against the headrest behind. He tries not to move too much, sensing that you’re somewhat thankful for his body heat warming your leg and side. It’s cold as shit tonight and you picked what has to be the thinnest dress in your wardrobe. If he didn’t love it on you so much, he’d have told you that you were fucking stupid for risking hypothermia by wearing it.
You let your eyes fall closed as goosebumps prickle across the skin of your arms and you lean back against the headrest. Sharon’s apartment is just another ten minutes away, and then the tower will be an extra thirty on top of that. If you clear your head and pretend like the man beside you is merely a stranger in a shared Uber, and not someone whose tongue was in your mouth only an hour ago, you might be able to get a little sleep before you’re home. But Bucky’s leather jacket sits heavy over your thighs, and his intoxicating scent swirls around the backseat, begging to be inhaled. He’s not a stranger. He’s a fucking coworker who left a hickey on your neck and what feels like a black hole in your gut after offering up some kind of half-baked confession of attraction a couple of days ago. Younger me would fucking swoon. Who the hell says something like that to a girl who thought she was the last person he’d ever be into? Does he get off on looks of confusion and bewilderment?
The car tires screech against asphalt as Sam slams on the brakes and the car struggles to meet his demand. You’re lurching forward in an instant, the seatbelt pulling coarsely across your chest as it locks and holds you in your seat. But it isn’t the sudden unexpected stop that has everything moving in slow motion. It’s Bucky’s hand gripping your mid-thigh tightly over the fabric of his leather jacket. As your back thumps against the seat and your eyes dart out toward the windshield ahead, you see that Sam narrowly avoided running a red light with a traffic camera posted on the street corner. He mumbles something about refusing to get another citation, but your ears are ringing as you cast your gaze downward. Bucky’s hand is still right there, his knuckles nearly turning white with how hard his fingers are digging into your leg. For a moment, a fleeting moment, you let yourself think about how nice his touch feels. You can feel the warmth of his palm even through the leather jacket covering your legs and the chill in your body begins to dissipate. In reality, he’s only been holding onto your thigh for two seconds, but it feels like it’s been two minutes. You let out a shaky breath as the stoplight turns green and Sam starts driving past it. Bucky’s grip loosens and he starts to withdraw his hand, but something within you stops him. You’re reaching out and grabbing his hand in yours, tugging it back to your thigh and resting it atop the leather jacket again. Neither one of you turns to look at the other. You both stare straight ahead, silently letting the moment play out.
It feels as though a fire’s been ignited deep in Bucky’s chest. As you move your hand away from his, he has to turn his head and look out the window to keep from looking down at where he’s touching you. If he gets a glimpse of where his hand is at right now, he won’t be able to scrub the image from his mind no matter how hard he tries. And his hand is only on your damn thigh. He takes even breaths through his nose as he watches the city lights dance around outside. He estimates that Sharon’s apartment complex is less than ten minutes away. What happens after those ten minutes? Will you push his hand away and pretend like the moment never happened?
Each passing minute feels longer and longer as Bucky’s hand remains heavy on your thigh. Two minutes go by before he starts alternating between squeezing your leg and letting his hand rest loosely atop the jacket across your lap. When you reach the third minute, your cheeks are flushed pink and sparks are igniting throughout your body at the slightest touch. There aren’t many thoughts floating around in your head now, which is probably why it’s so easy for you to slide your hand over his and quietly guide it beneath the fabric of the jacket. He doesn’t resist. He doesn’t pull his hand away or fight your movement, and when you feel the warmth of his palm pressing against the bare skin of your thigh, you withdraw your own hand and cover his with the jacket carefully. Bucky’s clenching his teeth as he grips your leg and scrapes his trimmed, blunt nails along the inside of your thigh. He feels you shudder against his touch, but then you seem to press into him a little closer and he can’t fucking breathe. The backseat of this car is suddenly feeling too damn small for either of you, and he wants nothing more than to drag you out at the next red light and find the nearest alley with a brick wall he can back you into.
She’s just cold. Bucky keeps reminding himself that that’s why you’re letting him do this, that that’s why you’re encouraging him to touch you this way. But are you really that cold? Your skin feels almost overheated beneath his hand. He grips your leg again and then starts drawing lazy circles with his fingertips along your inner thigh. He never once tries to move his hand any higher or lower than the exact spot that you placed it in. You’re having a hard time figuring out if that excites you or disappoints you, especially when all you can do is focus on keeping your breathing unnoticeable and eyeing the three other people in the car to make sure no one is the wiser.
The tension in the backseat of the car is so thick that you could cut it with a knife by the time Sam’s pulling into a parking spot in front of Sharon’s building. Bucky’s fingertips dig into the skin of your thigh one last time before he drags his hand out from underneath the jacket and back to his own lap. You start to unbuckle so you can help Sharon out of the car and up to her apartment, but Sam shakes his head at you in the rearview mirror and pushes his own door open quickly.
“We’re not going to make you walk her all the way up there when you’re in heels.” Sam tsks, signaling for Torres to hop out as well. “We’ll take her up and get her settled, just stay in the car.”
“Are you sure? I could do it, she can probably walk fine, she’s just sleepy.” You say softly, glancing over at Sharon as she begins to stir. She shoots you a sideways smile and starts unbuckling her seatbelt with sloppy movements.
“Don’t say that, let them carry me.” Sharon jokes, slurring nearly every single word she speaks. You laugh lightly before pushing a bit of her blonde hair away from her face and leaning over her to open the door on her side.
“Fine, but don’t give them too much trouble.” You concede, watching as Torres takes both of her hands and helps her out of the car. You find your heart racing as she straightens herself up and takes just enough steps forward for Torres to shut the door again, leaving you and Bucky alone in the dark car. You let out a shaky breath as you watch Sam, Torres, and Sharon all move further and further away from the car. You don’t move a muscle. You stay seated right there in the middle of the backseat, painfully aware of how your left side is still brushing against Bucky’s right side.
Bucky’s sitting stiffly in his seat, wondering if you can hear how hard his heart is thumping against his ribcage right now. His eyes flit downward to where his leather jacket has shifted off of your lap a bit and the skin of the thigh that he was just toying with is now exposed. Gritting his teeth, he reaches over slowly and pinches the edge of the jacket with his fingertips before dragging it back up to cover your lap entirely. Your head moves quickly, tilting downward to watch what he’s doing. You swallow thickly as thoughts start swirling around in your head. It’s a mixture of sane, rational thoughts about thanking him for the jacket and dirty, irrational thoughts about putting his hand back where it was before the car stopped here. Even as your mind is formulating a coherent sentence to spit out, you know you should sit here quietly and act like nothing happened. You know so much better than to speak when tensions are running this high, and yet…
“I did kiss you back.” The words roll off of your tongue so quietly that you fear Bucky might not even have heard them. But when he stops staring out his window and drops his gaze down to where his hands rest in his lap, you know he heard you.
“You did.” He says just as quietly, shifting in his seat a bit. You let out a soft sigh and glance over at the empty seat beside you. You know it’ll look a bit odd to Sam and Torres when they get back to the car and see you still sitting in the middle of the backseat. You’re thinking about sliding over and buckling yourself in when movement catches your eye. Bucky’s flesh hand reaches over slowly, and his fingertips take hold of the edge of his jacket just like they did a moment ago, but instead of making sure the fabric covers your thighs, his moves it further down your legs this time. Your breath hitches in your throat as he pushes it down just an inch, revealing the hem of your short dress and the tiniest bit of skin across the tops of your thighs. Goosebumps prickle across your skin, but it has little to do with the fact that you’re still a bit cold. “I put my tongue in your mouth.” He rasps. You’re frozen in place as he starts tracing the hem of your dress with the tip of his index finger. His words hang in the air, swirling around with the thick tension like a heavy fog early in the morning. Bucky leans in as you stare down at his hand. He leans in until his forehead is nearly touching the side of your face and his lips are ghosting around the shell of your ear. “Would I need an excuse to do it again?”
As your eyes flutter closed and you suck in a deep breath, Bucky can only think of one thing. He can only think about how fucking perfect it felt to have you kissing him back, to push his tongue past your lips and really taste you for the first time. Of all the times he’s kissed you for undercover missions, it was never like that. He never dared to let his tongue get involved, not until tonight. Now he fears he might be ruined.
You’re thinking about the same damn thing. You’re thinking about how he tasted like honey and citrus and vanilla all jumbled together. You’re replaying the feeling of him fisting his hand in your hair and pulling you toward him in a way that should’ve done nothing other than piss you off.
Neither of you realizes that you’re both glancing toward the apartment building entrance at the same time, both checking to see if Sam and Torres are anywhere nearby. Are you really about to do this? You finally turn your head to face Bucky, and find him already staring at you intensely. His blue eyes reflect the tiniest bit of light from a street lamp in the distance, and you swear you can see something akin to flames dancing around in his gaze. He stares back at you for one, two, three seconds before the tension hanging in the air between you both shatters. In a flash, you’re shoving the leather jacket onto the floor and moving toward Bucky just as he’s grabbing you by the waist and tugging you toward him. Your lips meet before your bodies do and you’re kissing him so desperately that you almost feel a bit of shame. You’re acting like a horny teenager having her first bit of alone time with a guy on prom night, but as your dress hikes even higher up your hips and Bucky settles you not over his lap, but over his right thigh, every trace of shame disappears. You’re straddling the toned muscles of his thigh as he curls his fingertips against your scalp and takes a handful of your hair in his fist.
“You like when I do this, don’t you?” He asks lowly, nipping at your jawline as he pulls on your hair just enough to tilt your head back. A soft whimper escapes you and you grind down on his thigh, feeling just the right amount of friction as the fabric of your panties meets his jeans. He falters for a second and looks down, his grip on your hair loosening as you grind against his leg again. “Fuck, don’t do that.” He growls, squeezing your hip with his vibranium hand to make sure you’ll be still.
“But it feels so fucking good.” You whisper, fighting against his vibranium hand and dragging your clothed cunt against his thigh again. A guttural sound crawls up his throat and he pulls you in for a kiss, sliding his tongue past your lips instantly. There’s that honey taste again. He doesn’t try to stop you this time when you grind down, so you keep doing it over and over again for a few seconds, giving your clit exactly enough friction to elicit a sense of pleasure. If his side of the backseat was bigger, you’d settle yourself over his lap and grind on the bulge that you know is hiding behind the zipper of his jeans, but you’ll take what you can get.
“Is that enough for you?” Bucky asks roughly, the second he pulls away from your lips and glances down at where you’re grinding on his thigh once again.
“They’ll be back any minute.” You whisper. You place your hands on his shoulders as you crane your neck to glance back at the apartment building again, ensuring Sam and Torres are still out of sight.
“Say it isn’t enough.”
“Bucky—” Both of his hands move down your back and he cups your bare ass beneath the fabric of your dress, squeezing hard enough to leave red fingerprints in your skin. He leans in and presses an open-mouthed kiss to your neck before dragging the tip of his tongue up toward your ear and biting down on your earlobe softly. “It isn’t enough.” You moan out as your back arches and your chest presses against his. Bucky lets out a groan before reaching down with one hand and unbuckling his seatbelt. The thin strap moves between your two bodies quickly before clicking against the door, and then Bucky’s wrapping one arm around your lower back and moving to lay you down in the backseat. He hovers over you as your legs spread a bit to accommodate him, and then he sinks down on top of you. There’s something about feeling the full weight of a man over you that makes it hard to think rationally. That’s why when you feel the outline of his hard cock press against your damp panties, your back arches and his name leaves your lips in such a desperate, sultry moan. That’s why you let him grind and rut against you relentlessly for at least thirty seconds, listening to the sounds of his grunts and heavy breaths as he buries his face in your neck and moves his hips rhythmically. That’s why you let yourself get so dangerously close to an orgasm that you’re circling your own hips against his. It’s because you’re not thinking rationally, not one tiny bit.
You don’t hear it, but Bucky does. He hears the distant click as the door to Sharon’s apartment building swings open. He knows he only has a few seconds left before Sam and Torres will be close enough to see the car, so he presses his hips into you one last time, making sure you feel the entirety of his hard length against your clothed cunt before he looks down into your eyes and memorizes the look of pleasure on your face. He kisses you one last time, savoring the taste of your lips and letting his tongue dance with yours for one fleeting moment. Then, he’s pulling himself away from you and grabbing your hands to pull you back into a sitting position beside him. You’re in a daze as he leans down and scoops his leather jacket up off of the floor. The sound of Sam and Torres’ voices ring out in the distance and you move yourself to the seat Sharon had previously occupied, quickly smoothing out your dress and hair before buckling yourself in. Bucky holds the jacket out to you just as Sam and Torres are nearing the car, and you take it, draping it over your lap carefully.
Sam and Torres’ incessant small talk is the only sound to be heard as the car carries you all back to the compound. You’re keeping your legs tightly crossed and your hands folded neatly in your lap as you stare out your window and try to avoid thinking about what just happened. Adrenaline is still surging through your veins, almost cancelling out the alcohol in your system. On top of that, the sexual frustration that you feel from having not finished what you and Bucky so recklessly started in the backseat is giving you a bit of an attitude. You chew on the inside of your cheek as the damp panties trapped between your thighs begin to feel uncomfortable and the gravity of what you just did, what you would’ve done if Sam and Torres hadn’t showed up when they did, begins to set in. You’re compromising not just the upcoming mission, but your entire working relationship with a damn good partner. And for what? Not even an orgasm. He didn’t even give you that. You have no doubt that he would have if you’d had the time for it. Hell, you were pretty damn close to one with him grinding against you like that and those sounds he was making. Your mind starts to float back into dangerous territory and you bite the inside of your cheek a little harder, nearly drawing blood. You shudder at the sensation of pain, but continue staring out the window, wishing Sam would drive just a little bit faster.
He could cum right now. Bucky could actually cum in his jeans right now, and it’s been a solid ten minutes since he even looked in your direction. His cock is still painfully hard and fighting against the front of his jeans, threatening to pop the zipper if he doesn’t free it soon. He glances around Sam’s headrest to see that he’s already doing five over the speed limit. Still, it’s not fast enough. Not when you just did what you did, and you’re sitting only a foot away with Bucky’s scent all over you. Actually, that’s not even the worst of it. The worst of it all is the fact that you left wet spots on his thigh and over the crotch of his jeans, both of which hold the scent of your arousal. Bucky lets out a heavy sigh and shifts uncomfortably in his seat, adjusting the seatbelt over his lap so it won’t restrict his cock any more than it needs to. He catches you turning your head in his direction out of the corner of his eye, but he doesn’t dare look back at you. Screwing his eyes shut, he pinches the bridge of his nose with his flesh index finger and thumb as he presses his head back against the headrest. He can survive the last twenty minutes left in this car ride, but as soon as the car pulls up to the tower, he’s getting the fuck out of here.
Sam, ever the courteous and thoughtful designated driver, let you, Bucky, and Torres all out of the car right at the front entrance to the tower before heading off to park the car in the underground garage. Bucky almost decided to stay in the car and take the ride down to the garage with Sam, just to keep from being stuck in the elevator with you. However, it turns out that Torres is pretty damn good at icing over the fiery tension in a small space. Bucky is leaned against the back wall of the elevator, staring at the leather jacket hanging off of your shoulders as you stand a few feet in front of him. You’re so close to the metal doors that if you stuck your tongue out, you’d probably be licking them. Torres stands oblivious off to one side, scrolling through his phone absentmindedly as the elevator carries the three of you closer and closer to the main living quarters.
“Have you two gotten started on the dancing lessons yet?” He asks casually, without looking up from his phone. You say nothing. You stay still, staring at the metal in front of your face as the elevator continues on. Bucky clears his throat lightly and you hear him shift somewhere behind you.
“Tomorrow.” Bucky replies stiffly, offering no more than that single word. You turn your head the tiniest bit to see Torres nod, still looking down at the device in his hands.
“Saving it for the last minute?” He jokes. Your eyes dart upward and you see that you’re only a few floors away from the living quarters. “Fury wants you guys back in the past within the next two days.” You swallow hard at the reminder as an uneasy feeling settles in your gut.
“There isn’t going to be much to teach.” Bucky’s tone is flat, but still somewhat polite. You see Torres nod in your peripheral vision, and then the elevator is dinging and it’s slowing to a stop. You’re hurrying out the second the doors begin sliding open. You hear Torres’ phone ring and he mumbles something about taking the call down in the conference room, but you’re already halfway through the main living area. Your heels click against the hard floor as you make your way toward the dark hall, refusing to look back at the super soldier who can only be a few yards behind you.
“You don’t have to walk so damn fast.” Bucky mutters, watching you storm ahead. You’re still about ten feet from your door when you slow down and turn on your heel. Now you’re standing there looking at him as he continues walking toward his own door at a normal pace. You stand there and stare at the man you didn’t want to look at for another second tonight. He’s nothing but danger and bad decisions and you’re learning not to trust yourself around him anywhere but in the field.
“My feet hurt.” You say matter-of-factly, narrowing your eyes at him. You watch as he comes within a couple of feet of you and turns left to face his door that’s right across from yours. “I want to take off these heels and this dress and shower and just…” Your voice trails off and you catch Bucky looking over his shoulder at you with a raised brow. “And just sleep this off.” You finish, making it clear that you’re talking about whatever it is that’s between you right now. He turns to face you right as you’re turning your back to him and reaching for your own door handle.
“Sleep it off, huh?” He scoffs, noting that you’re still keeping his leather jacket draped over your shoulders. “Whatever this is, it’ll just be gone in the morning?” You keep your hand on the downturned door handle but you pause, not yet pushing the door open fully. You shrug your shoulders and Bucky watches as his jacket moves up and down once around your frame. “Kinda hard to forget what happened tonight if you wake up and see my leather jacket beside your bed in the morning.” You snort out an amused laugh before casting a glare at Bucky over your shoulder.
“Maybe you should take your jacket back then.” You respond calmly. As you’re facing your door, letting your head turn forward once again, you hear Bucky shuffling behind you slowly. A chill spreads beneath the surface of your skin as he grows closer and closer, until his body heat is enveloping you and his proximity has your hand faltering on the door handle. When he comes to a stop right behind you, so close that one deep breath from you would have your back pressing against his chest, he braces himself against your doorframe. Both of his arms are outstretched, his hands grasping the doorframe on either side of you as he leans in close to your ear, just as he’s done so many times tonight.
“But it looks so damn good on you.” He coos, taking a chance to inhale your sweet scent after he speaks. His breath tickles the side of your face as the wetness in your panties suddenly feels a little less uncomfortable and a little more exciting. You’d like to say your body is beyond your control when you draw in a deep breath and let go of the door handle. When you let your palms glide over the surface of your door and arch your back just enough to push your ass against the front of Bucky’s jeans. You’re met with the same hard-on he was rubbing all over your clothed cunt in the car just a little while ago and warmth pools low in your stomach. Bucky’s hips lean in, pressing himself against your ass a little harder as his flesh knuckles turn white and his vibranium hand whirs with exertion against the doorframe. He gives you a chance to open the door and disappear for the rest of the night, but when you circle your hips back against him a second time, his hands quickly move down to your hips and he pushes your front into the door firmly. He crowds in behind you, dragging his lips over the skin of your neck as you tilt your head to the side. He makes sure your bodies never part as he kisses down the column of your throat and bites down lightly on your collarbone. You grind your ass into him one more time and his control starts slipping.
“Keep that up and I’ll fuck you against this goddamn door.” Bucky rasps against your neck, tightening his hold on your hips to keep you from grinding anymore. You wriggle in his grasp, but he only curls his fingers against your dress even more, before dragging his lips back up toward your ear. “You’ll wake up tomorrow wondering why the fuck you can’t walk.”
“I’d blame the heels.” You whisper, surprising yourself at the fact that you’re going along with this. But everything he’s saying, everything he’s doing makes it hard for you to think straight. Bucky lets out a surprisingly gentle, genuine laugh before letting go of your hips and tugging his jacket off of your shoulders. He steps back suddenly, leaving you a bit cold and wanting for his touch. You turn around to watch as he walks over to his own door and pushes it open. “That’s it? You just walk away after that?”
“You can’t stand me, remember?” He replies. You can hear his smirk showing through his tone. “Should be easy for you to sleep it off.”
With that last line, Bucky’s shutting his door and you’re left in the dark hallway alone. You have half a mind to kick his door in and ruin your pretty heels, but the other half of you knows he’s doing the right thing. What did you really want him to do? If you’d invited him in and spent the night with him, you have no doubt that your professional life would’ve gone to shit before the end of the week. If he’d invited you in, or even worse, fucked you against right there in the hall like he’d said, the outcome would’ve been the same. You can’t mix work and play. You know that all too well. But why is it turning out to be so damn fun to blur the lines with him?
You take your time peeling off your dress and heels, soaking in a long, hot shower, and then getting ready for bed. By the time you’re flicking off the bathroom lights and pulling back the plush covers on your bed, it’s already a bit past one in the morning and the aching between your legs hasn’t ceased. You refuse to indulge your fantasies after having already made yourself orgasm once within the last twenty-four hours at the mere thought of the man across the hall. Twice would be too much, way too much when you’re actively trying to tell yourself that you need to start keeping things strictly professional with him. You choose to lie in bed and scroll through your phone for a bit, but still, Bucky remains at the forefront of your mind.
Bucky vows not to touch his cock in the shower ever again. Tonight was the last time. As he towels himself dry and avoids looking at his reflection in the bathroom mirror, he’s surprised at the fact that he doesn’t feel so much shame this time. He has a feeling you might’ve even been flattered by just how much cum ended up being washed down the drain after he thought of nothing but you as he stroked himself. Okay, maybe that’s wishful thinking. But seriously, with the things you did to him…with him tonight, he knows that you wouldn’t have kicked his ass for what he had to do in the shower. He has a feeling you might’ve even been tempted to do something like that for yourself after you parted ways.
One text. That’s all you need to send to give yourself a little peace of mind and maybe set things back on the right track with Bucky. It’s why you’re staring at the typed out message on your phone screen and your thumb is hovering over the send button. It’s late. Maybe too late to be sending him a text. But you feel like you have to do it. You’ll clear things up now and tomorrow everything will go back to normal, or as normal as things can be before a mission like this. When you hit send, let out a deep breath and let your head fall back on your pillow a bit dramatically.
When Bucky’s phone vibrates on his nightstand, he’s rolling over and grasping it in one hand almost instantly. Holding it over his face and quickly dimming the brightness of his lock screen, he sees your name at the top of the notification and he narrows his eyes. How many times have you texted him since you’ve started working together? Once? Maybe twice? His heart thumps a little harder than it previously had been as he unlocks his phone and reads your message. You don’t need any more convincing? His tongue darts out and wets his lips as he sends his overly simple response through.
Two question marks. That’s all you see as you stare at his text. Heaving a sigh, you type out a slightly longer message, making sure you’re abundantly clear. You need to make sure that he knows he doesn’t have to keep going with whatever act this is that he’s been putting on the last couple of days. If he’s only been fucking around with you to convince you that you’re the one his 40s self would approach in a bar, he doesn’t have to keep doing it. You’re thoroughly convinced. It’s only a few seconds after you’ve sent your message that you see the little gray typing bubbles pop up on his end of the message window.
You watch those three little dots with bated breath as your thumbs hover over your phone screen. When his final text comes through, your heart rate nearly doubles and warmth rushes up to color your cheeks a soft shade of pink.
Shit. You exhale noisily, before clicking your phone off and setting it on your nightstand. Your mind starts rushing back to all of the missions you’ve worked together, all of the times you bantered back and forth or argued and yet, every mission was carried out seamlessly. Was the tension between you two something that you’ve been misreading up until now? Had you been mistaking it for the type of tension felt between two people who don’t really get along, when all of this time it was that kind of thick, suffocating tension that you only find between two people who are oblivious as to how right for each other they really are?
You wrap yourself up in your bedsheets and let the darkness of your room envelope you. No fucking way. You do not have feelings for James Bucky Barnes. And even more than that, he most definitely does not have feelings for you. There’s simply no way.
When you finally drift off to sleep, what happened in the car on the way back from the bar replays in your dreams on a loop, growing slightly filthier with each rerun. You wake up three hours in with a pillow wedged between your legs and your hips instinctively grinding down into it in search of friction. You wake up a second time just before sunrise and you almost can’t take the ache between your legs.
If you really couldn’t stand him, if this was really nothing, you would’ve been able to sleep it off. And that scares the shit out of you.
Glimmers of early morning sunlight peek through your curtains, casting your room in a hazy yellow glow. Stretching out your legs beneath the covers, you rub the sleep from your eyes and blink a few times. Your gaze settles on the white ceiling above and you notice a slight twinge of pain behind your eyes as a headache begins to set in.
The night before replays in your mind, almost like a highlight reel, as you push the covers back and move to sit up on the side of your bed. You see yourself being pulled away from that stranger in the bar, being pulled to Bucky’s chest as he kissed you like you belonged to him and no one else. You squeeze your eyes shut and massage your temples with the middle and index fingers of your right hand. You see Bucky’s hand on your thigh in the car, and then him lying you down in the back seat before crawling on top of you and…fuck.
Tonight had nothing to do with convincing you. His last text to you from just a few hours ago is displayed across a billboard in the forefront of your mind. You rush through pulling on an outfit for the gym, settling on a lazy hairstyle and light makeup to hide the dark circles under your eyes from the poor sleep you got last night. It might be Sunday and you might not have much to do today, but you know good and well that sitting here in your room is only going to send you straight into a spiral of thoughts you don’t need to be dwelling on right now.
You listen carefully through your door, straining to detect any sounds that might let you know someone else is up and about this early. When you’re sure the coast is clear, you make a dash for the elevator and ride it all the way down to the gym.
Sam’s sitting in the conference room with Fury and a very hungover Sharon just a little past eight. He’d probably be laughing if she didn’t look so miserable. Her blonde hair is pulled back into a messy ponytail and the dark circles under her eyes are aging her by about five years. He can tell her head must be throbbing by the way she keeps squinting at the bright lights overhead and glancing over at the light switch across the room. Maybe he should’ve made an effort to end the fun a little earlier last night, but in his defense, none of you really made an effort to do that. Besides, he had no idea Fury would want to see them first thing on a Sunday morning.
“We’ll be sending you in tomorrow to bring Peggy Carter up to speed and establish a safehouse for the mission.” Fury explains slowly, eyeing Sharon as he speaks. She nods along, keeping her hands folded in her lap beneath the table. “You’ll have one day to get it done.”
“It won’t be a problem.” Sharon affirms confidently, letting her eyes shift between Fury and Sam. “One day is plenty of time. What stipulations do you have for the safehouse?”
“As long as they have a place to sleep and a door to lock at night, I don’t care. Whatever Peggy can help you find is going to have to do. They’ll only be there for two nights.” Fury responds. His phone chimes and he quickly stands up from the table, pushing his chair in gently. He casts Sam and sideways glance as he heads for the door.
“Maybe don’t take her out drinking tonight.” Fury advises, letting out a half-hearted laugh as he reaches for the door handle. “And let me know how those dance lessons go later. If those two can’t get along long enough to make it through one song, I have half a mind to scrap the whole damn mission.”
“They got along pretty well last night.” Sam snorts, remembering the way Bucky kissed you in the bar. Sure, he was the one that encouraged him to do it, but Sam knows for damn certain that it was anything but fake. He wonders for a moment just how complicated this mission might end up being with the two of you being thrust into the past without backup readily available. You’ve always worked well on missions before, but this is so different. This is the kind of mission that’ll make or break a partnership, and he’s very much aware that your partnership is somewhere on a tightrope between being rock solid and completely falling apart at the seams. If he had to place a bet, he’d say neither of you come back from this one the same as when you went in. Something’s going to change.
It doesn’t feel real. As you stand on a platform that looks like something straight out of a sci-fi movie, wearing a quantum suit in the darkest shade of black you’ve ever seen, you feel a bit like an imposter. It should be Sharon in your position right now. You know she was just in this same spot yesterday, heading back in time to establish a safehouse and make the first contact with Peggy Carter, but still. Who the hell decided that you’re qualified not only to run ops in this century, but to send you back to the last one to run an op as well?
“Hey.” Bucky says quietly, drawing you out of your spiraling thoughts. You turn your head to the right and take in the sight of him as he takes the few steps up onto the platform. He moves to stand directly in front of you, taking in the apprehension written all over your face. You tuck a stray lock of hair behind your ear and let out a shaky breath as you meet his gaze. “Just another mission.” He assures you, keeping his voice low so only you can hear it. You nod, but you’re sorely unconvinced. This is not just another mission. You know it and he knows it.
“It should’ve been Sharon.” You mumble, averting your gaze and choosing to watch Bruce, Scott, and Torres as they work seamlessly behind a table of screens and electronic devices. Bucky shakes his head and narrows his eyes at you, but you refuse to look at him again.
“Okay, let me hit a few main points before we do this.” Bruce says suddenly, clapping his oversized, green hands together as he approaches the edge of the platform. “You have one roundtrip each, please make every effort to come back from this together. You can come back earlier if you have to but for the love of all things scientific, don’t come back later than planned. What feels like five minutes to you might be fifteen years here.”
“Bucky, you’ll keep your watch on at all times in the past. Take that thing off and lose it and you’re stuck in the forties, which I get might not be all that unappealing to a man who’s over a hundred years old, but still…keep it on.” Scott says pointedly. You glance down at your own time-space GPS device. While Bucky’s does resemble a normal wrist watch, yours was made to look more like an inconspicuous necklace so you could continue wearing it in the forties and still be dressed for the time period. “Don’t let anyone take that off of you.” Scott directs his warning at you. You nod curtly, reaching up and running your fingers along the dainty device lightly.
“Try not to go changing the past.” Bruce takes over again, but he’s backing away from the platform now and moving back toward the table of screens and devices. “Stick to the mission. Get in with the Howling Commandos, get what you need from the HYDRA base, and then get the hell out of there on time. Are we all on the same page?” Both you and Bucky nod in unison, and you finally face forward to meet his piercing stare.
“It could only be you.” Bucky whispers across the short distance between the two of you. Warmth floods your chest and you barely hear the sound of Bruce beginning to count backwards from twenty.
“I told you I didn’t need any more convincing.” You remind him, matching his low volume. “I’m here, I’m doing this. I just think Sharon would’ve been the smarter choice.” Bucky shakes his head at you almost disappointingly as Bruce reaches the ten second mark. You see something flash in Bucky’s eyes, something passionate and intense as you ready yourself to activate the helmet and face mask on your suit. When Bruce calls out eight seconds left, Bucky rushes forward, taking two steps before grasping the sides of your face firmly in his hands.
His lips are soft and gentle when they meet yours, but in less than a second he’s kissing you like it’s the last time he’ll ever get the chance to. It sucks the air right out of your lungs and sets a fluttering sensation off deep in your stomach, but then he’s pulling away and stepping back. You activate your helmets and face masks at the same time, right as Bruce is nearing the end of his count.
“Three, two, one…”
With a flash of light and an unusual feeling that the gravity beneath your feet has just increased by a hundred-fold, you’re being dragged through time and space, hurtling toward a period of time that you’re sure you don’t belong in.
Rain pours down heavily on the roof of the car as Peggy drums her fingertips along the top of the steering wheel. She glances down at the coordinates scrawled on a small scrap of paper for the fifth time, even though she knows she’s exactly where she’s supposed to be. She can’t help but feel a little on edge. The street light perched above her car gives off just enough light for her to lean over in front of the rearview mirror and reapply her red lipstick one last time. It’s a bit of a nervous habit really, because it’s not like she has much reason for her makeup to look perfect with the role she’s about to play. A glorified cab driver. That’s what she is tonight. A flash of light in the distance catches her attention, and it isn’t lightning. She turns the key in the ignition and watches as her headlights suddenly illuminate the alley ahead.
She isn’t quite sure what she expected the two of you to look like. She should’ve assumed that Sergeant Barnes would age well, but the fact that he’s barely aged has her raising a brow as she studies him from a distance. She notes the fact that he seems taller and much more muscular than the Sergeant Barnes she’s come to know through Steve and the Howling Commandos.
“Welcome to London.” Bucky mutters under his breath, as he raises a hand to shield his eyes from the bright headlights ahead. He squints slightly and catches sight of Peggy’s characteristic red lip and brown curls through the windshield of a dark Morris eight. You cut your eyes to the side and take in the sight of him, with his hair already soaked through and rainwater dripping down the side of his face. Before you have a chance to say anything back, he’s moving to stand behind you and placing a hand against the middle of your back, lightly guiding you toward the car.
The rain sends a chill racing from your head to your toes as Bucky reaches past you, tugs the front passenger door open and ushers you into the seat. He leans down before closing the door, letting his scent invade your space as he looks past you to Peggy.
“Peggy Carter.” He says with a soft smile, looking at her as if he’s seeing an old friend after so long apart. You’re stuck staring at him. You’ve never seen this look on his face before and it lets you see him in a slightly different light.
“Sergeant Barnes.” Peggy’s British accent is almost musical in a way. You finally turn your head and get a good look at her. She looks perfectly put together and polished with her bright red lipstick, styled hair, and navy blue pantsuit. “If you’d like to hop in and allow your partner here to close her door, we just might make it to your safehouse before you’re both thoroughly soaked.” A laugh slips past Bucky’s lips, but he listens to her and steps away from the door, closing it for you gently. Once he’s settled in the backseat, Peggy shoots a sideways smile in your direction before putting the car into reverse. “Does he always listen that well?”
“Not at all.” You respond honestly.
Peggy guides the car backwards out of the alley and onto the very sleepy, rainy streets of London. It’s an odd feeling to be in such a major city but see so little traffic or nightlife. You’re taking everything in with widened eyes, noting all of the little differences between the forties and the time period that you come from. Bucky’s soaking it in as well, but instead of exciting him, it relaxes him. He sinks into the backseat and lets out a deep breath, watching as the old buildings and signs roll past his window. He almost feels at home here.
The drive to the safehouse on the outskirts of the city doesn’t take anywhere near as long as it would’ve taken in the modern world. When Peggy turns into the long driveway of one of Howard Stark’s many homes, you’re starting to feel the effects of time travel. Your head feels a little fuzzy and you have a sensation almost similar to that of motion sickness. Peggy says something about the house being a bit small for two people, mentioning it being one of Stark’s occasional residences for when he travels alone.
“Everything you need will be inside. Clothes, food, a few choice weapons for the mission at hand. Please let me know if I missed anything, but I think I was rather thorough.” Peggy says cordially as she leads the way up the paved driveway toward the front door. You take a few steps away from the car but stop short, scrunching your eyes shut as a heavy wave of nausea hits. Bucky’s behind you in an instant, letting his palm press against your lower back as he stands at your side and leans over to look at your face.
“What’s going on?” He asks in a hushed tone with concern lacing his words.
“I’m good, it’s just the time travel thing.” Bruce made you both read an obscene amount of research on the potential physiological effects of time travel, but assured you that you probably wouldn’t experience any of them. Yet, here you are, experiencing a bout of time sickness before you’ve even made it into the safehouse. Bucky scrutinizes your expression, searching your eyes for any sign that you’re downplaying whatever’s going on with you. You wave a dismissive hand at him as rain begins to come down a little heavier.
“Are you two coming?” Peggy asks from the door up ahead, looking at you both with a raised brow. Bucky turns his head for a second to glance at her, but quickly looks back at you as his hand falls away from your back. He watches you carefully as you put on an unbothered expression and take a couple of steps forward. Shit. The nausea increases ten-fold and suddenly you’re rushing over to the edge of the driveway and leaning over with your hands on the knees of your quantum suit, losing the contents of your stomach all in one go. Bucky’s beside you within a second, gathering your hair up in both of his hands and holding it back behind your shoulders.
“Don’t say it.” Bucky warns as you turn your head to look up at him, wiping your mouth with the back of your hand.
“It should’ve been Sharon.” You groan, straightening up and tugging your hair away from his grasp. He shakes his head at you and you can already see an argument gearing up in his head, so you brush past him, feeling significantly better now that you’re completely empty.
Peggy can’t seem to stop herself from reading into the way you and Bucky interact. When she met Sharon just yesterday, it was made abundantly clear that you and Sergeant Barnes are partners but don’t always play nice with each other. From what she’s seeing now, Bucky wants nothing more than to play nice with you. She has to wonder if the bickering and constant tension that Sharon talked about is a façade, a thick wool blanket over what’s really at the core of your partnership.
You feel fine just long enough to run your fingertips over the green and cream floral wallpaper that covers the kitchen walls and admire the pristine white oven that anyone’s great grandmother would love. But the moment you turn your attention to the living area just a few steps outside of the kitchen, a fresh wave of nausea begins taking up residence in the pit of your stomach and you breathe in deeply through your nose. Bucky watches you apprehensively from the foyer, waiting to see what you’ll do. He can tell you feel miserable. He can tell you want to get a good look at the safehouse and settle yourself in, but you’re looking a little green and fatigued as you move toward a large dark green couch in the living room.
You sink into the couch and let your head fall back against the cushion behind you. As you reach up and wrap your fingers around your necklace, your quantum suit deactivates and you’re left in leggings and a black pull-over. Bucky glances around the house, noting the short hallway that leads to the master bedroom and what looks to be French doors leading to a study off to one side. He takes a few steps forward until he’s moving around the couch, and then seats himself in a dainty looking floral-patterned lounge chair that’s angled toward you across from a coffee table.
“Is this really just a time travel thing?” Bucky finally speaks. Your eyes flutter open and you take in the sight of him in that lounge chair. If you didn’t feel so shitty you might laugh at how out of place he looks in such a pretty little chair.
“What else would it be?” You ask. Bucky watches closely as you run your fingers through your damp hair and stare right back at him. He narrows his eyes at you and cocks his head to the side and you immediately know what he’s thinking. What is it with men always thinking that a woman is pregnant if she pukes? You just fucking time traveled and he still feels the need to rule it out?
“I’m not pregnant.” You sigh, letting your eyes fall closed again as you kick your shoes off and draw your knees up toward your chest. “I can’t be.”
“Can’t be?”
“I haven’t done the thing that you need to do in order to be pregnant in a long time.” Bucky finds relief in your words. He didn’t really think you were pregnant, but he sure as hell likes knowing that you haven’t slept with anyone recently. He leans back in his chair and lets his gaze float around the comfortable space. The homey kitchen makes him think of his mom. The wooden floor boards make him think of how carefully he’d have to tiptoe around his childhood home to keep from letting his parents know that he was awake past his bedtime. The slight chill in the air guides his eyes over to the fireplace that spreads across one wall of the living room. If it gets any colder he’ll have to start a fire.
“I kissed you.” He says evenly, turning his head back to you. You open your eyes and give him a hard stare, trying to read his indecipherable expression as his blue eyes zero in on your face.
“Yeah, you keep doing that.” Your nausea worsens and you draw your knees up even tighter against your chest before dropping your head down to rest on them. Bucky pushes himself out of his chair and heads for the kitchen. You listen as he opens and closes a few drawers, rummaging around for something. A few seconds later you hear the kitchen sink running and then it cuts off. Bucky stands there, wringing out a wet cloth as he purses his lips.
“You haven’t stopped me.” He points out. He turns on his heel and carries the wet cloth in your direction. When you feel his weight sink into the couch cushion beside you, you lift your head from your knees and find yourself face to face with him. He lifts the wet cloth to the side of your neck and dabs at it gently, watching as your eyes close and you take a deep breath in.
“I’ll make sure it doesn’t happen again.” Sarcasm drips from every word. Bucky slides the cloth to the back of your neck and holds it there for a moment.
“He’s going to try to kiss you tomorrow.” Bucky seems almost annoyed with his own statement and you steal a sideways glance at him as he moves the wet cloth to your forehead. He seems to almost resent the way his younger self behaved.
“He moves that fast?” Bucky nods, chewing on the inside of his cheek as he contemplates how much to tell you.
“You’ll meet and he’ll ask you to dance. You’ll dance and he’ll ask if you want to leave the bar. He’ll take you out into the city, try to show you a good time.” Bucky slides the wet cloth down the side of your face until it’s right below your chin. You look into his eyes, watching as his gaze darts down to your lips for the most fleeting moment. “He moves fast.”
“I can handle it.” You assure him, but your words come out a lot quieter than you intended. Bucky pulls his hand and the cloth away from your chin and dabs your neck with it again.
“I know.”
“Then why does it seem like you’re worried?” Bucky shrugs his shoulders as he focuses in on the skin of your neck. He’s staring at the spot he once marked with his own lips, dragging the cool cloth over it slowly.
“I don’t like the thought of him touching you.”
“Bucky…” Your stomach churns violently and you’re rushing off of the couch at lightning speed. Your feet carry you down the hall, into the master bedroom, and into the bathroom quickly. You’re lucky you make it in time to drop to your knees in front of the toilet before the last remnants inside of you start to come out. You hear Bucky step into the bathroom only a second later and he’s tugging your hair back just like he did in the driveway earlier. “Don’t say shit like that.” You groan, grasping the wet cloth that Bucky’s holding out beside your head. You wipe at your lips and reach up to flush the toilet as you stay in place, not trusting that your gut is finished betraying you.
“Like what?”
“You shouldn’t care if someone else touches me. We’re partners. We can’t keep blurring the lines like this.” You explain. Bucky’s hands stay firmly in your hair as he waits to see if you’ll get sick a third time.
“The lines have been blurred for a long time.”
“Doesn’t mean we should keep blurring them.” You assert. Though you don’t peer over your shoulder to look at Bucky, you can sense the look of frustration that’s written all over his face. He lets out a weighted sigh before moving away from you and reaching over to turn on the shower. As the sound of running water fills the room, you gauge the heaviness in your stomach and decide that you definitely feel better. You remember Bruce’s little pamphlets saying that the first hour after moving through timelines is when you experience the most side effects, and you’re nearing the forty-five-minute mark now. You lean away from the toilet and drop the lid down before pushing yourself up to stand. Though you feel a tiny bit wobbly on your feet, the nausea is mostly gone and the steam from the shower is making you feel a little less chilly.
“I’ll go grab you some clothes.” Bucky says quietly as he brushes past you and heads back into the bedroom. You take the free moment to search the contents of the bathroom drawers until you find a new toothbrush and some toothpaste. Bucky comes back in when you’re brushing your teeth in front of the fogged-up mirror. “I get the feeling you aren’t going to wear these.” He says with a smirk, dropping a deep red set of folded pajamas beside the sink. You give him a wary side-eye, tucking the toothbrush into the side of your cheek before reaching for the pile of fabric. As soon as you unfold the top, you realize it’s a long sleeve button down shirt with matching pants. It looks like the kind of pajamas you see families wear on Christmas day in lifestyle magazines. Shaking your head, you fold the top and set it back on the countertop. Bucky crosses his arms over his chest and leans against the doorframe as you bend over the sink and spit out a mouthful of water and toothpaste.
“That’s all there is?” You rinse off the toothbrush and set it along the side of the sink before reaching down and gripping the bottom of your shirt. You already have it pulled over your head by the time you realize what you’re doing. Bucky stands frozen in the doorway, staring at you with narrowed eyes as you drop the shirt to the floor at your feet. He tilts his head to the side, never letting his eyes stray from your face even as you stand before him in a bra.
“How is this not blurring the lines?” He questions, jutting his chin out at you. You narrow your eyes back at him and cross your arms over your chest, matching his stance. There’s a palpable heat in the air, and it’s not just from the steamy shower. As you and Bucky stand there staring each other down, each of you refusing to break first, tensions soar and you find yourself itching to push him out of the bathroom and shut the door. He can see the idea forming in your head so he speaks up before you actually have a chance to go through with it. “There was a floor-length nightgown if you’d rather wear that.” He says with another signature smirk. You shake your head firmly.
“Were t-shirts not a thing in the forties?”
“You’re going to wear a t-shirt when there’s only one bed?” Bucky asks, raising a brow. A genuine laugh erupts from your chest as you uncross your arms and run your fingers through your damp hair.
“The bed’s all yours, Bucky.” You say, raising your hands up in a gesture that makes it clear you don’t want the bed for yourself. “I’m taking the couch.” Bucky scoffs as he reaches over for the folded pajamas beside the sink. As he steps out of the bathroom, he gives you a look you can’t quite read. It’s something between longing and frustration and it makes your cheeks feel warm. He pulls the door shut behind him, leaving you alone in the steamy bathroom. As you strip your clothes off and step under the stream of water, so many things are stuck in your head. The way Bucky rushed over and held your hair back not only the first time you puked, but the second time as well. He cares. You know he cares. He cares and it scares the shit out of you. The way he pressed a wet cloth to your neck and sat with you on the couch, even if he was using the moment to warn you about his younger self and reveal a little hint of how he feels about you. I don’t like the thought of him touching you. Bucky’s confession may not have surprised you, but it wasn’t what you were expecting him to say. What did he think was going to happen when he insisted you be a part of this mission? He could’ve let Sharon handle it and he never would’ve had to deal with the jealousy or possessiveness or whatever it is that’s coursing through him right now. But no, it had to be you. It could only be you. As you scrub a sweet-smelling soap into your skin, your mind wanders back to that moment on the platform earlier today. He kissed you. He kissed you in front of some of your coworkers without a care in the world. The lines are so fucking blurred that you wonder if he even knows where they are anymore, or if he cares. You look down as soapy suds circle around the drain near your feet. Do you know where they are? Do you care?
Bucky rummages around in the bedroom until he finds a plain white t-shirt that he’s sure Peggy meant to be for him. It looks like it’ll probably be a bit oversized on you, so he tosses it onto the bed and stands still for a moment, listening to the sound of the shower running through the wall. He knows you feel the same thing he feels. Every time he’s kissed you, he’s reminded that you feel it. Do you try to deny it because you don’t want to feel it? Sometimes he just wants to grab you and ask what it is that keeps you from being real with him.
Bucky shakes his head, trying his best to clear all thoughts of you from his mind, before tugging his shirt over his head and dropping it on the bed. He leaves his tactical pants on as he moves through the house, searching for an extra pillow and blanket. He sure as hell isn’t going to let you take the couch, especially not a couch made eighty years before the couches you’re used to sitting on. You’ll wake up in the morning with a stiff neck and aching back. He’ll take the couch and leave you the bed.
It’s just a few minutes later that you’re stepping out of the bathroom, wrapped tightly in a towel as you pad across the bedroom floor quietly. You glance around but see no sign of Bucky. Eyeing the crisp white t-shirt on the bed, you can tell he left it for you. You run your fingers over it while clutching the towel around your chest with one hand.
“Is that what you wanted?” Bucky’s voice is low and gravelly as he speaks from the bedroom doorway behind you. Clutching the towel a little tighter, you turn to face him with the white shirt fisted in one hand. Your eyes roam over the expanse of his bare chest, coasting down to the ripples of his abs and the v-line that so prominently drags your gaze even further down to the front of his tactical pants. He smirks at the way you’re ogling him, but he doesn’t mention it. When you finally tear your eyes away from him, the dresser beside the doorway catches your eye. You move closer to it and rummage around in one of the top drawers until you find a pair of simple black panties. Bucky’s eyes follow your movements carefully. He leans against the doorframe just like he did in the bathroom earlier, keeping his gaze trained on your face as you lean over and guide the panties up your legs beneath the towel. You’re just careful enough to make sure not to flash Bucky, but you wonder if his eyes would even stray from your face if you flashed him.
“It’s fine.” You say, referring to the t-shirt. “Are you gonna shower?” You ask, trying to keep your gaze from drifting down his torso again. You turn away from the dresser and head back for the foot of the bed, dropping the shirt onto the mattress before peeling the towel away from your body.
Bucky stiffens in the doorway as you let your towel fall to your feet. He’s never seen you this way. As you stand there with your back exposed, wearing nothing but a pair of black panties, he has to bite down on his bottom lip to keep from saying something stupid. Who’s blurring the lines now? He wants to point out your hypocrisy, to make it blatantly obvious, but he stays quiet as you tug the t-shirt over your head and slide your arms through the short sleeves.
“Did you want to keep staring or were you going to shower?” Your voice rings out playfully as you cut your eyes at Bucky over your shoulder. He tamps down a groan at the way you look at him through your lashes, but then he’s moving toward the bathroom door.
“If I find you on the couch when I get out, I’m moving you myself.” He threatens, not daring to steal another look at you as he nears the bathroom.
“I already called it.” You shrug, bending over to scoop your damp towel off the floor.
“Take the bed, unless you want me joining you on that damn couch and blurring the lines even more.”
As you settle into the bed, letting go of your signature stubborn nature for the time being, Bucky’s all you can think about. It’s not the fact that he looked undeniably attractive standing there in the doorway without a shirt on. It’s not the fact that he insisted you take the bed and leave him with the surely uncomfortable couch. It’s every little thing he’s said and done in between that has your heart racing and your mind reeling. What if, just this once, you let yourself explore the tension? What if instead of waiting for the tension to snap like a twig, instead of waiting for him to lay you down in the backseat of someone else’s car in the heat of the moment, you took the initiative and tried to figure out what the hell this is between the two of you? He was right when he said that the lines have been blurred for a long time. Maybe instead of trying to tiptoe around and avoid blurring them, you should just shift them. Shift the lines and see if things end up crashing down in flames. If everything goes horribly, it’s not like you had anything to lose. But if things go well? A shiver runs down your spine and you tuck yourself in underneath the covers of the oversized bed. You sink into the pillow behind your head and let your eyes fall closed as you imagine a moment where your field partner becomes something more. You imagine a moment where all the stolen kisses and touches lately stop being so stolen, and instead are given and taken freely. You imagine what it might feel like to stop running and fighting against this thing that you feel so strongly. Warmth spreads through your body and you relax against the mattress.
When Bucky steps out of the bathroom a few minutes later and catches sight of you curled up in bed with your eyes closed and the covers pulled up to your shoulders, he lets out a quiet sigh of relief. He really thought you’d try to tough it out and sleep on the couch. He stands in the doorway between the bathroom and bedroom, fiddling with the dog tags around his neck and wondering if he should look for some pajamas of his own instead of crashing on the couch in just a pair of black boxers. When he glances over at you again and sees the peaceful look on your face, he can’t bring himself to go digging through the dresser or closet and risk waking you. Though it’s chilly in the house, he could make it through the night just fine by starting a fire in the living room fireplace and using the spare blanket he set out on the couch while you showered. As he starts moving forward, his dog tags clink against his bare chest and the wooden floor creaks under his feet on the second step. He stills and holds his breath, not even moving to look over his shoulder and see if he’s woken you with those little sounds. After waiting a second, takes another cautious step forward and the floor creaks a little louder. Fuck it. He makes it to the door quickly, with only a few more creaks of wood beneath his feet, but as he exits the doorway into the hall, he hears you stir behind him.
“Bucky?” Your soft sleepy voice stops him in his tracks. He exhales deeply, feeling a bit guilty about waking you but loving the way you sound when you’ve just woken up. He turns around in the doorway and faces you. You’re propped up on one elbow, squinting at him through the dark room.
“If I knew the floors were so loud I would’ve just slept in the shower.” He says halfheartedly, speaking quietly to match the sleepy mood of the house.
“I wasn’t really asleep.” You whisper back. Your eyes follow the curve of his vibranium arm down until you’re studying the black and gold fingertips that hang at his side. Bucky raises a brow at you.
“You were asleep.” He murmurs, cocking his head to the right. He glances over at the empty side of the bed, noting how little space you take up even when you have your legs stretched out.
“I was just thinking.”
“About what?” Bucky wonders aloud. He takes a step forward and leans against the doorframe like he’s done multiple times tonight. He crosses his arms over his chest as you let your head fall away from your hand and lay back on your pillow again. You stare up at the ceiling as nervousness begins to swell up in your chest. You bite down on your bottom lip and screw your eyes shut, holding your breath for a second before deciding to speak again.
“Blurring the lines.” As you lay there in the dark, refusing to prop yourself back up to look at Bucky, your heart starts beating wildly against your ribcage. He’s silent for a second too long and it has you regretting opening your mouth. When you hear the wood floor creak, you force yourself to open your eyes. Pushing yourself up on your elbows, you see Bucky moving toward the bed slowly. His dog tags swing with each step, clanging against his chest a couple of times before he reaches your side of the bed. You watch with bated breath as he nudges your legs through the covers. Getting the hint, you sit up and pull your legs in closer, drawing your knees to your chest. Bucky sits down on the side of the bed but keeps his face cast downward at the floor.
“That night you tried to sleep it off…” His voice trails off as he leans over and rests his elbows on his knees. He looks down at his hands as he presses his palms together. “Did it work?” You swallow hard but don’t hesitate to shake your head. You know he catches the act in his peripheral vision, so you don’t say a word. Bucky nods slowly, studying his hands as if he’s memorizing every detail of them. Your eyes drift to his shoulders as he takes steady, even breaths. They rise and fall rhythmically as moonlight from the window across the room filters in through the curtains and highlights them.
Bucky wants to say more, to ask you more. He can tell that you’re open to talking right now, probably more open than you’ve ever been before, but he has this sinking feeling that you’ll say something that’ll break him. He doesn’t know if he can handle hearing you say out loud just how one-sided you think this thing between you really is. Even though he’s sure it’s not actually one-sided, hearing you say that it is might really break him. He won’t give you the chance to do that yet. He wants to hold out hope a little longer. So, Bucky rises from the side of the bed and exhales deeply. When he turns to head for the door again, intent on settling into that stiff green couch in the living room for the night, every sensory receptor in his body fires at once at the feeling of your hand reaching out and grasping his flesh one. He drops his gaze quickly and sees exactly what he feels: your palm sliding against his and your fingers intertwining with his softly. His throat feels dry and every thought leaves his mind as you tighten your grasp and tug on his hand slightly.
“Lay with me.” You whisper. Your tone is so meek that he can tell exactly what’s going through your mind right now. You’re afraid he’ll say no. You’re afraid that he’ll reject you and continue on to sleep on the couch, leaving you here alone, feeling vulnerable and stunted. The tone of your whisper puts the tiniest crack in his hard exterior.
Bucky’s silent as you drop his hand and scoot closer to the middle of the bed, pulling back the covers for him. He moves slow as he settles into the warm spot you’d been occupying, inhaling your sweet scent as he pulls the covers over his body and rolls onto his side to face you. You’re just a few inches away, lying on your folded arm since he moved the second pillow to the couch earlier. He could get up and go grab the pillow. He’d only be gone for a few seconds. But he fears the moment he leaves your sight, you’ll change your mind about having him here and he’ll have ruined everything. That’s why he tugs the pillow out from under his head and moves it toward you, watching with a softened gaze as you accept it and slide it beneath your own head.
You’re falling asleep right in front of his eyes a few minutes later, when suddenly your eyes flutter open and you reach out for him beneath the covers. Your warm palm lands on his side, skating around to his back before you pull him toward you. He moves in carefully, apprehensively, until his chest is nearly pressed against yours. He watches as you drag the pillow until it’s in the shared space between you and both of your heads fall to rest on it evenly. With Bucky’s body heat keeping you warm and the light patter of rain on the bedroom window lulling you to sleep, your eyes are closed only a few minutes later and Bucky finds himself missing the heat of your stare until he too drifts off into an unusually peaceful slumber.
You awake in a tangle of limbs with lightning flashing through the curtains and illuminating the room with a ghostly glow. Everything looks a little scarier in an antique house at three in the morning. Thunder rumbles loudly just above the house, shaking the roof and rattling the glass window. As you fully come to your senses, you figure out just where your limbs are in relation to Bucky’s and your heart rate picks up quickly. He’s asleep directly in front of you, with his face looking more relaxed than you’ve ever seen it. But his legs and arms…
A shaky breath flows out through your nose as you close your eyes and try not to move. Bucky has one thigh wedged snugly between yours and an arm thrown lazily over your waist. You can tell that your t-shirt has ridden up above your hips and ass, with his forearm resting against the hem of it on your waist. Blurred lines. So fucking blurred.
You close your eyes tightly as a loud crack of thunder reverberates through the house. Bucky’s instantly awoken as the thunder rolls and you tense up against him. He focuses on your face, on your tightly closed eyes and the way you’re holding your breath. He moves the arm that’s draped over your waist slowly until his hand is ghosting over your hip. His fingertips just barely graze the hem of your t-shirt as thunder sounds again. You look into his eyes right as you move your left hand to clamp down over his, forcing his palm to press flat against your hip and his fingers to curl against your skin. As you stare into each other’s eyes and the storm rages on just outside, the tension rising between you feels just like it did in the car outside of Sharon’s apartment that night.
“I don’t want to keep blurring the lines.” Bucky rasps as he squeezes your hip once. Your eyes trail down to his lips as he speaks only inches from your face. He leans in slowly until he’s so close that one little shift of your head would have you kissing him. He lets the tip of his nose brush against yours gently before moving down and pressing his lips to your jawline. He leaves kisses in a row all the way back to your ear, moving at a torturously slow pace until he’s nipping at your neck in that way that always drives you crazy.
“Then what do you want?” You ask breathlessly. Bucky pushes the knee that’s trapped between your legs upward until he’s applying the tiniest bit of pressure against your clothed cunt. A soft moan escapes your lips as you squeeze your thighs around his and focus on the feel of skin against skin.
“I want to cross them.” He whispers against your neck. You tilt your head back to give him more access as his tongue swirls against the column of your throat. “I want to lay you down on the line and just…” Bucky tugs the neck of your shirt to the side and bites down on your collarbone lightly. “Fuck you on it.”
“Bucky…” His name is a whimper that floats from your lips and fills the space around you both. Moving his hand back down to your hip, Bucky curls his fingertips into it and pulls you down, making your grind against the firm muscle of his thigh. This time a sultry moan slips out and your back arches slightly, causing your chest to press against his.
“How am I supposed to keep my hands off of you when you say my name like that?” Wetness pools between your thighs and begins to dampen the fabric of your panties as he pushes his thigh upward again, at the same time that he pulls your hip down and applies pressure to your clit just right. You know you should have better sense than to lay here and let him do unspeakable things to you. You should remind him that you’re partners, that you’d be risking things professionally if you let things go on this way. You should remind him that you’re technically on a mission right now, but his name just falls from your lips again. You’re actively emptying your mind of any thought that would have you push him away when he attaches his lips to your neck again and pulls you in against his chest. You try to push his shoulders and force him onto his back so you can move on top of him, but he fights against you, rolling on top of you instead. He pins your arms down on either side of your head and lets his nose brush against yours a second time. He lowers his hips down slowly as your legs spread on their own accord, giving him the space to press his clothed erection against your wet panties.
“How do we keep ending up like this?” You whisper against his lips, staring up into his blue eyes as your question hangs in the air. Bucky presses his lips to yours in a short, shallow kiss. “I keep telling myself this can’t happen and we keep ending up here.”
“Let me have you.” He begs, dropping his forehead to yours. You look at him through your lashes as your breath hitches in your throat. “Let me have you just this once.”
“Just this once? That’s all you’re asking for?” The words come out airy and light as you struggle to take in a full breath. Bucky grinds against you, circling his hips slowly while he keeps your arms pinned to the mattress.
“I’d ask you for a lifetime if I didn’t think it would scare the shit out of you.” Goosebumps prickle across your skin and you bite down on your bottom lip hard enough to draw blood.
“We can’t fuck.” You say decidedly. The surety of your voice surprises you, with how malleable you feel having Bucky grind against you like this. You fear that if he really asked you for something specific, you’d say yes in a heartbeat. He circles his hips into yours impossibly harder and shakes his head above you.
“I wasn’t asking if I could fuck you.” Bucky takes in the confused look on your face and he can’t help but to lean in and kiss you. He envisions what he really wants to do to you. He pictures the way he wants to push your legs apart and eat you out like your pussy is his last meal. Then he kisses you like that’s exactly what he’s doing. His tongue delves into your mouth relentlessly, leaving you gasping for air when he finally pulls back. He lets go of your forearms and pushes the covers away from his back as he shimmies down. He kisses your neck, then your chest through the t-shirt. He leaves soft, gentle kisses all the way down until he’s settling himself between your legs and pressing his lips against the waistband of your panties. You look down at him through your lashes, wanting nothing more than to tangle your fingers in his hair and pull his face closer to where you need it. “I was asking if I could taste you.”
“You say you want to lay me down on the metaphorical line and fuck me, and then you get between my legs and ask if you can just taste me?”
“I’m not fucking you until I know I can do it without you running off and pretending like it meant nothing to you.” He plants an open-mouthed kiss right over your clothed clit. The warmth of his tongue seeps through the fabric, sending a jolt of pleasure dancing up your spine and a knot tightening low in your stomach. “When I fuck you, you’re not going to get all in your head about how you shouldn’t have let it happen. You’re not going to have regrets and feel like we ruined everything we had.” Bucky hooks a finger in your panties and gently pulls them to the side, but he never looks down. He maintains eye contact as he starts pressing the pad of his thumb against your now exposed clit. Him finding your clit instantly without even looking, without having your anatomy perfectly memorized, almost ruins you. “When I fuck you, you’re going to realize that you were just delaying the inevitable.”
“You keep saying when.” You point out between heavy pants. You can’t resist the urge to tangle your fingers in his hair any longer, not when he’s toying with your clit this way and looking at you so intensely. You reach down with both hands, carding your fingers through his hair and tugging on it lightly.
“Inevitable, sweetheart. Tell me what that word means.” He finally lets his eyes angle downward and settle on your wet cunt. You watch as his pupils dilate and his tongue darts out to dampen his lips as he admires you from just a couple of inches away. He starts circling your clit with his thumb, applying just enough pressure to have your back arching off of the bed and your fingers curling in his brown hair. Bucky inches closer to your pussy and you feel his tongue press against your entrance firmly, before he’s dragging it upwards and using it to replace his thumb. He pulls back abruptly, leaving you whining out in frustration. “If something’s inevitable, it’s certain. It’s unavoidable, it was bound to happen.” His warm breath fans over your pussy as he speaks in a low voice. Bucky sucks on your clit roughly before pulling back again. “When I fuck you, when the inevitable happens, you won’t be able to pretend like there’s nothing between us anymore.”
You’re torn between wanting to argue with him and wanting to clamp your thighs around his head and grind against his tongue. Bucky smirks up at you and you tug on his hair a little harder out of spite.
“It’s already happening, isn’t it?” He asks just before flattening his tongue against your clit and letting your circle your hips against him. Your eyes flutter closed as that knot in your stomach tightens more and more. “It’s getting harder to pretend.”
“Fuck you.” You moan out the insult, but it’s useless as he slides down and pushes his tongue inside of you. His thumb takes over stimulating your clit once again as he starts eating you out like he’s dreamt of doing it since he’s known you. His tongue works you up higher and higher, closer and closer to the edge of the cliff as a sweat breaks out across your forehead and you struggle to keep your ass on the bed.
“You’re getting close.” He groans against you. You whimper as he drags his thumb away from your clit and switches to rubbing it with his middle and ring fingers. He moves slow now, sliding those fingertips away from your clit and toward your entrance.
“Bucky…” You say his name in warning. You know what he’s about to do. He plunges both fingers into you, stopping when they’re halfway in and your back is arched inches off of the bed. Your fingertips scrape against his scalp as you hold in a moan that would’ve been damn near pornographic if you’d let it out. Bucky lets out a frustrated sigh before dragging his fingers out and then pushing them back in all the way. As he holds them inside of you knuckle-deep, you cry out loudly. It’s been so long since you’ve let anyone do something like this to you and he isn’t giving you much time to adjust, but god, it feels so fucking good.
“Breathe, baby.” He says as he presses a soft kiss to the inside of your thigh. He starts fucking you with his fingers slowly, almost gently. In and out they go, first just halfway each time, but then he starts thrusting them deeper and going a little faster with it. “I would’ve gone a little easier on you if you hadn’t held in that pretty little sound.”
“Just…fuck, Bucky.” You moan, hooking your legs over his shoulders as a loud crack of thunder sends the window rattling again. “I’m close.”
“Trust me, I know.” He groans, pressing a sloppier kiss to the inside of your thigh as he curls his fingers inside of you. You cry out again, but this time your hands leave his hair and go to grip the sheets on either side of your head. “Are you going to imagine you’re cumming on my cock when this orgasm hits?”
“No.” You say defiantly, shaking your head as he curls his fingers again. He laughs darkly, clearly calling your bluff.
“You know you squeeze the hell out of my fingers when you lie?”
“I do not.”
“That’s it, baby.” Bucky coos. He positions himself to attach his lips to your clit as he continues his ministrations with his hand. “Keep tightening around my fingers until you fucking cum.”
Some part of you wants to keep defying him. You want to be stubborn and refuse to give him this piece of you, refuse to give him one of your orgasms. It feels like if you let go and give it to him, you’re going to tumble right over the edge of a cliff and into the unknown. But why does it feel so damn good as you stand on the edge of that cliff? When you stop resisting and let your orgasm wash over you, when Bucky watches as your face contorts with bliss and your knuckles turn white against the bed sheets, he’s just as far gone as you are. You’re cumming around his fingers while he laps at your clit, and he’s cumming in his boxers without even having realized just how close he was to doing it.
There’s an odd feeling brewing in his chest as he puts your panties back in place and collapses beside you in bed. He can’t quite figure out what it is. When you catch your breath and look over at him, taking in the sight of Bucky Barnes with your arousal painted over his lips and chin, you feel your heart skip a beat. Bucky looks back at you, but he only gets a second to see your dilated pupils and flushed cheeks before you’re leaning in and swiping your tongue across his bottom lip.
As your lips move against his in a gentle, familiar way, his lungs burn and his heart is pounding in his ears. Because he knows what this is. He knows what that unusual feeling in his chest really is. Love. He’s in love with the girl who lives to ignore her feelings.
You’re in too deep. You can’t even try to reason with yourself. As you lie in a tangle of sheets, listening to the mixed water sounds of Bucky showering and rain falling lightly just outside the bedroom window, you feel utterly fucked. And not just because Bucky fucked you with his mouth last night. You let out a frustrated groan before rolling onto your back and fisting your hands in your messy hair. You can’t tell yourself to be professional because you’re so far past professional now that it’d be insulting to you both if you tried to revert. You can’t tell yourself to stop crossing lines with him because you know just how good it feels every time you do it. Bucky was onto something last night when he asked you if it was getting harder for you to pretend that there’s nothing between the two of you.
Your eyes float over to the partially closed bathroom door and you watch for a moment as steam floats through the space between it and the doorframe. Is it steam from the hot shower or is it just radiating off of the man that said your pussy gets tighter when you lie? Blush creeps into your cheeks at the memory of him saying such a filthy thing while his fingers were inside of you.
Bucky tenses up in the shower when he hears the bathroom door creak open the tiniest bit. When your bare feet lightly tap along the cold floor and he hears them stop in front of the sink, a small smile plays on his lips.
“You’re not coming in?” Bucky’s smirk is evident in his tone and you’re biting on the inside of your cheek as you reach for your toothbrush.
“You remember me saying we can’t fuck, right?” You ask, though even as you say it, it feels like a weak statement.
“Do you remember me saying it’s inevitable?” He retorts playfully. You should tell him to fuck off, but you only find yourself tempted to actually join him in the shower. As you spread a bit of toothpaste along the bristles of your toothbrush, you shake your head to yourself.
“I’m brushing my teeth in the kitchen.”
“That’s fine.” Bucky replies nonchalantly, seemingly unfazed by your slight rejection. He spends the next ten minutes lathering and rinsing for the second time in less than twelve hours. He isn’t normally someone who takes a shower both in the morning and at night, but after he came in his boxers last night, he fell asleep next to you and didn’t take the time to clean himself up. He woke up feeling like he’d had a wet dream.
Peggy sits on the foot of the bed, waiting patiently as you try on a third dress.
“Are you alright in there?” Peggy calls out politely, uncrossing her legs and readying to rise from the bed if need be. You laugh softly from inside the walk-in closet before pulling the door open and revealing the deep blue dress she picked for you to try a few minutes ago. It has cap sleeves, a high neckline, and an A-line style skirt. “I think that one looks wonderful on you, don’t you like it?” She asks, pushing herself up and coming to stand in front of you. She catches the pinched look on your face before you’ve even formulated a response. You didn’t quite like the first two dresses either, and at this point there are only a handful left to try. She has to wonder if maybe it’s the dissonance between forties-style dresses and modern dresses that’s throwing you off. “Sergeant Barnes.” Peggy calls for him loudly.
Bucky’s rising from the couch and heading down the hall as soon as he’s been invited into the bedroom. He was kicked out pretty much the moment he finished up his morning shower, with Peggy showing up and saying she just had to get started on your look for tonight. He was a bit skeptical about how much time it’d really take, but after hearing you try on three dresses and dislike every single one, he sees why she came so early.
“What do we need him for?” Confusion is written all over your face as you smooth down the blue dress and raise a brow at Peggy.
“He’s the one that needs to like the dress, isn’t he?” She questions, motioning for Bucky to come in. He takes a few steps into the room and rubs the back of his neck awkwardly as his eyes coast over the dress. It’s pretty, it’s definitely very forties-esque, but it’s not you. It’s not you and it’s definitely not for him. “Help her pick a dress for tonight.” Bucky stares at her for a long moment before she starts moving toward the door. She pats his shoulder as she passes him, leaning in to whisper in his ear just as you’re disappearing back into the closet. “She needs you for this.”
You feel Bucky’s presence in the closet without having to turn around and look at him. He stops just a few inches behind you, looking over your shoulder at the row of dresses that you have to choose from.
“It’s a little different than your closet back home.” He says softly, watching as your fingertips dance across the fabric of each hanging dress.
“You haven’t seen my closet back home.” You point out, tugging on the side of a dark navy dress. As soon as you see the front of it, you let it go. Your fingers continue on, looking for another dark fabric.
“If you’re looking for something like that little black dress you wore last weekend, you won’t find it in here.” Bucky replies. Thinking about that little black dress sends your mind back to the night in the bar, when Bucky kissed you in front of everyone. Then your mind wanders to what happened in the car after, and you have to shake the thought of it from your head. Your fingers brush along a bright red dress and you don’t even consider checking it out. Bucky steps up close behind you, so close that you feel his body heat permeating your skin through the blue dress you’re wearing. He reaches around you with his right arm and grasps the edge of the only black fabric amongst all of the dresses hanging there.
“Peggy said something colorful would be best.” You murmur as he removes the dress from the hanging rack and holds it out in front of you both.
“He won’t be paying much attention to the dress.” Bucky assures you. He leans in close to your ear before whispering his next words. “And you look good in black.” A chill runs through you but you reach out and grasp the hanger quickly before turning around and pressing a hand against Bucky’s chest.
“Let me change.” You push against his chest gently and he takes a few steps backward until he’s out of the closet. As he moves across the room to sit on the foot of the bed where Peggy previously was, he hears the sound of your blue dress unzipping but not the sound of the closet door closing. He takes a cautious look as he sinks down onto the edge of the mattress. There you are, slipping out of that deep blue fabric while giving Bucky an almost clear view of you in forties-style black lingerie. His cock is awake instantly and is hardening within the already sort of tight-fitting sweats he took from Stark’s dresser earlier this morning. Bucky leans forward and rests his elbows on his knees as he drops his line of sight to the floor.
You walk out only a moment later in the dress he chose. It’s all black, with off the shoulder sleeves and a fairly low-cut neckline. It hugs your body tightly. It’s quite similar to the shape of the red dress that Peggy wore when he first saw her in the Whip and Fiddle.
“Don’t look at me like that.” You say lightly, watching as Bucky’s eyes glide up and down your figure multiple times. He clears his throat and sits up straight before motioning with his flesh hand for you to come closer. You move forward until you’re a couple of feet in front of him, but then your eyes drop to his lap and you see his erection pressed against his sweats. Confidence rolls off of you in waves as you stop thinking and take a few more steps toward him. You don’t stop until you’re standing between his legs and he’s looking up at you. You let your hands rest on his shoulders as his move to ghost along the outsides of your thighs.
“Don’t go too far with him tonight.” Bucky’s tone is almost pleading as he searches your eyes, but his expression is unreadable.
“How far is too far?” You swallow thickly after asking your question. Bucky curls his fingers into your hips and draws in a deep breath.
“I don’t know.” He admits, but he does know. He knows that he doesn’t even want you to let this younger version of himself dance with you. He doesn’t want to let him lean in and whisper in your ear, he doesn’t want him to even get the chance to consider kissing you.
“You told me he moves fast, and we need him and Steve to be on board for this mission tomorrow. I can’t reject him.” You explain quietly, glancing over your shoulder to make sure Peggy’s still in the living room. When you turn your head forward again and look down at Bucky, he’s leaning in closer to you. You watch with your breath hitched in your throat as he lets the tip of his nose brush against your dress, just below your breasts. He moves slow, dragging his nose upward and letting his lips follow in their wake until he’s halfway up your chest. Your hands slide up the sides of his neck and tangle in his hair, tugging him back to look at you again.
“Why did you ask me to lay with you last night?” Bucky finally asks the question that’s been on his mind since he woke up this morning. You exhale slowly, absentmindedly massaging your fingers into his scalp while his thumbs rub circles against the front of your hips. He watches as you chew on the inside of your cheek, trying your best to come up with a safe answer.
“I wanted to know what it would feel like…to stop pretending.” You whisper.
“How did it feel?” His eyes stray from your face, taking in the swell of your breasts over the low neckline of the dress. Filthy memories of last night flood your brain and you clench your thighs together slightly. It wasn’t slightly enough, because Bucky catches on instantly and he tugs his bottom lip between his teeth. While you’re remembering the feel of his kisses against your inner thigh and his tongue on your clit, he’s remembering the sweet taste of your cunt and the pretty sounds you made just for him.
“Good.” Your whisper is even quieter now, and your nerves are rising knowing Peggy’s just down the hall in the living room.
“Just good?” Bucky fishes for more. He tests the waters, letting his hands slide down your thighs, closer to the hem of the dress. You don’t move away, you don’t swat at his hands or tell him to stop.
“Just good, Bucky.” You answer. But as his fingers hook beneath the hem of your dress and he starts guiding it higher and higher up your legs, you know your resolve and will to pretend is crumbling.
“I think you’re lying.” He says calmly, staring up at you with those blue eyes as the hem of the dress nears the middle of your thighs. You squeeze his shoulders as he lets his flesh thumb graze the lace edge of your panties, close to where your thigh meets your center.
“Peggy’s here.” You whisper the reminder, but make no effort to break away from him. In fact, you find yourself leaning into his touch. Bucky’s quick as he slips one finger into your panties and drags it along the length of your folds, gathering the slick arousal that’s started collecting between them.
“Shh, I just want to see if you’re lying to me.” Bucky hushes you just as his gaze is dropping to your lower body and he’s nudging your feet apart with his right foot. You don’t stop him. You don’t do anything but close your eyes and dig your fingertips into his shoulders as he dips a finger inside of you. Your mouth falls open and you inhale sharply as he curls it against your walls. “How did it feel last night? To stop pretending for a little while?” He gazes up at you with what you think is a look of lust, but he knows is all fucking love. “Just good?”
“Bucky…fuck.” He pulls his finger out before plunging it in deeper than before, and then he curls it again.
“That’s not an answer.”
“It felt good…it felt, shit, Bucky.” He starts thrusting his finger in and out of you at a medium pace as you try to piece together your answer. “It felt right.” He slows to a stop as you say that last word. Though you’re tight as fuck, just like you were last night, he doesn’t feel that characteristic clenching when you give your answer. You’re telling the truth. Maybe that’s a stupid way to interrogate you, but his theory is proving true so far. He pulls his finger out of you and brings it to his lips, sucking it into his mouth and savoring your taste. You look down just as he's pulling it away from his lips and tugging your dress back into place.
“Black heels.” He says lightly, patting the side of your thigh as you step away from him. He rises in front of you and moves a stray lock of hair behind your ear with the same finger that was just inside you. “The third ones from the closet door.”
Bucky’s waltzing out of the room, tucking his hard-on into the waistband of his sweats as you’re left standing there dazed. Dazed and beyond aroused. Part of you wants to grab him by the back of his shirt and drag him back into the room, telling him to finish what he started. The other part of you knows better than to give him the satisfaction. So, you grab that pair of black heels from the closet and keep your mouth shut.
You feel uncharacteristically nervous for what should just be another mission on your long list of undercover ops. Maybe it’s because you have one version of Bucky Barnes listening through the in-ear monitor you’re sporting, while you’re moments away from meeting another version of the same man. Or maybe it’s because you’re trying to walk the very fine line between hating Bucky Barnes and loving him. Whatever it is, you’re nervous and it’s showing.
Peggy walks close to your side, leading the way down the busy street in her red dress and matching heels. You can hear the watch on her left wrist ticking away as you approach the Whip and Fiddle.
“You seem worried.” Peggy voices her observation softly as she slows her pace a bit and casts you a sideways glance. You let out a stiff laugh before pushing a curl over your shoulder. She did your hair and makeup in a way that has you feeling like something fresh out of a forties fashion catalog. “Is it the mission itself or the man involved?” You swallow thickly, knowing Bucky can hear the entire conversation through your in-ear monitor. You could reach up and turn it off, have a quick girls chat with Peggy while leaving Bucky in the dark. But you’re sure Peggy would instantly realize that you’re on comms and you don’t know how she’d feel about not being let in on it sooner.
“I’m fine, just not used to life in the forties I guess.” You respond curtly.
“Well, that wasn’t very convincing.” She huffs. When she slows to a stop beside you, you know it’s futile to keep walking toward the bar, so you stop and turn to face her. “He looks at you like he would’ve given you the world and his last name in any timeline.”
“Peggy—”
“Now you have to spend an evening flirting with a younger version of him when you don’t even know how you feel about your version of him. You don’t have to lie to me just because he’s listening in, he knows that you’re conflicted.” Your eyes widen as she lets you in on exactly how perceptive she is. You hear Bucky clear his throat through your ear piece and pink begins to color your cheeks, you’re sure it’s even showing through the blush Peggy applied for you earlier.
“I’ll be fine.” You assure her, though the words don’t come out sounding quite as convincing as you’d hoped.
“I’m sure you will be. Sergeant Barnes will show you an exceptionally great time tonight, but it won’t make your problem any easier to figure out.”
“My problem?”
“You’re in love with your partner and you don’t know how to handle it.”
“You just met us last night and you’ve already decided that?” You ask incredulously, crossing your arms over your chest as Peggy glances over at the door to the Whip and Fiddle. You see a few soldiers spilling out of the place with varying degrees of unstable gaits and boisterous laughs. You don’t recognize any of them as Steve or Bucky, so you turn your attention back to her.
“It doesn’t matter when I met you, I look at you and I see me.” That’s how Peggy sees your situation so clearly. She’s in the same one. She’s in love with Steve Rogers and she doesn’t know what to do about it. She doesn’t know how to handle it yet. You let out a deep sigh and let your arms fall to your sides. Bucky’s staying quiet on the other end of comms, so quiet that you can’t even hear him breathe. “I want to ask you how things end for me in the future…how things end for us, but I won’t.” You know that she’s referring to herself and Steve and your heart breaks a little for her. “Don’t let fear get in the way of the rest of your life. You could live a wonderful life with a man that feels what he feels for you, but you can lose it all by being too afraid to give him a chance.”
Your black heels are frozen to the sidewalk as Peggy’s words echo in your mind. When she turns and starts heading for the entrance to the bar, you stay still and quiet.
“They end up together.” Bucky’s voice plays in your ear so quietly that you think you’ve made it up for a moment.
“How do you know?” You finally ask, speaking under your breath as you start moving in Peggy’s direction slowly. Bucky lets out a long sigh, like he’s dwelling on a memory.
“It’s the only reason Steve would’ve stayed behind like he did.” Bucky listens to the slow, steady clicking of your heels against the pavement as he grows closer and closer to losing you to his younger self. He wants to say so much more. He wants to point out that you didn’t deny it when Peggy said you were in love with him. He wants to ask if you’re really afraid, if she was right about that. But it’s not the time. It’ll probably never be the time.
He leans back into the couch as he listens to the distant din of the Whip and Fiddle. The in-ear monitor won’t pick up much background noise, but he hears the sound of a bell chiming as the door opens for you and the sound of way too many soldiers clamoring around the space that you’re in. His eyes scrunch closed and his vibranium arm whirs as he curls his hand into a fist.
“Captain.” Peggy’s accent carries the title with an air of class as she approaches a man seated at the bar. You recognize the back of his head instantly. Steve Rogers. He turns around quickly, coming to stand only two feet in front of Peggy as his eyes quickly, and quite respectably, roam over her figure. The room slows and everything starts sounding muffled when the man seated next to Steve turns around and his eyes meet yours. Bucky. You stare at each other for a few long seconds, neither of you saying anything.
“Agent Carter.” Steve addresses her, breaking you out of your trance. You look over at the tall super soldier with his perfectly styled blonde hair and dress uniform, noting the way his eyes never leave Peggy.
“Howard has some equipment for you to try.” Peggy’s mouth is speaking business, but her eyes are saying something else entirely as they lock onto Steve’s and refuse to stray. You can feel Bucky’s eyes studying you intensely over Peggy’s shoulder as you avoid his gaze and watch the exchange that’s happening in front of you instead. “Maybe after tomorrow’s mission?”
“Sounds good.” Steve keeps his replies short, but every word is thick with tension. Peggy leans back a bit and glances across the bar, noting a particularly lively table of men. They lean into each other as they sing along to a tune someone’s banging out on a beat up piano in the corner of the bar.
“I see your top squad is prepping for duty.” She says facetiously.
“You don’t like music?” Bucky asks, tilting his head to the side and cocking a brow at her. Her gaze remains fixed on Steve as Bucky steps to the side to get a better look at you.
“I do, actually. I might even, when this is all over, go dancing.”
“And you?” Bucky directs his question at you now, nodding his head in your direction as Peggy steps to the side and gives you space to join the conversation. “Do you dance?”
“With the right partner.” You reply softly, trying hard not to get lost in his blue eyes. Though he’s younger and so much more naïve, you see the Bucky you know all over the man in front of you. You see him in every artistic feature of his face, you see him in the way he cocks his head to the side and flashes a smirk at you.
“Then what are we waiting for?” He asks playfully, nodding his head toward the more open part of the bar. You don’t rush to take his outstretched hand, but once your palm is against his, you get the same feeling that you’ve felt every time your version of Bucky has ever touched you. It feels electric. It feels like every nerve ending beneath your skin is on fire. It feels like you’re on the edge of a cliff and a strong wind is about to blow through and send you spiraling down.
Back at the safehouse, Bucky’s stomach is twisting into knots as he pictures you wrapped up in the arms of anyone but him. He knows it’s stupid. He knows that this guy, in some way, really is him. But it still feels wrong. He listens reluctantly as this younger, more charismatic version of himself flirts and banters with you through multiple dances. He listens as the young soldier leans in close to your ear and tells you how you took the breath out of his lungs the moment you walked into the bar. He starts to feel a little nauseas and wonders if he’s finally heading into his own bout with time sickness when he hears the sound of a genuine laugh slipping past your lips at whatever it was that the young soldier said to you.
It isn’t long before Bucky’s ripping the in-ear monitor out and tossing it on the kitchen table. He paces back and forth, focusing on the sound of his feet thudding against the wooden floorboards. Don’t go too far with him tonight. Bucky can still hear the way he pleaded with you earlier today. It was pathetic, but it was heartfelt. This younger version of himself would be completely on board with your mission even if you’d just flashed him a smile. Fuck. He runs his hands through his hair and curls his fingers into the soft brown locks, tugging them away from his scalp as he stops pacing. What the hell is he doing? You invited him into bed last night. You slept next to him. You let him slip between your legs and eat you out so thoroughly that he swears he can still taste you now. You let him finger your pussy just so he could find out if you were lying or not. You’re not going to let this younger version of him take things too far after all of that, right?
Bucky exhales through his nose as he sinks back into one of the kitchen chairs and stares down at the earpiece on the table. He takes it in his flesh hand and rolls it between his middle and index finger for a moment, knowing he has to put it back in. When did he turn into such a jealous guy?
The young Sergeant Barnes is captivated by you. He watches from the bar as you breeze through casual conversation with Peggy. You have a way of seeming so genuinely interested in anything that anyone says to you. You wholeheartedly hang on every word spoken and you get this look in your eye like nothing is more important to you than whatever’s being said. You seemed every bit as invested in Bucky’s spiel about Ferris wheels as you were when he leaned into your ear and told you about his family back home.
“She’s a lady, Buck.” Steve says lightly, lifting his drink to his lips and taking a short sip. Bucky swirls amber colored whiskey around in the bottom of his glass as his blue eyes glimmer in the low lights of the bar. “Don’t get any ideas, she works with Peggy.”
“You work with Peggy.” Bucky points out, casting him a disapproving glance before zeroing in on you again. “And you have ideas.”
“I have ideas.” Steve mumbles, nodding curtly in surrender. He can’t lie to Bucky.
“You don’t want to take your ideas over there and ask her to dance?” Bucky shifts his gaze to Peggy. He can almost imagine her proper accent as he watches her lips move in conversation with you. He has no doubt, just from the little interaction between Steve and Peggy when you girls first arrived at the bar, that Steve’s head over heels. Not only Steve, but Peggy’s envisioning a life with him too.
“It’s not the right time.” Steve replies, setting his mug down on the bar and turning to face the same direction as Bucky.
“If you keep waiting, you’ll miss the time entirely.”
“Can you miss fate?” Steve asks thoughtfully. Peggy lifts her gaze and turns her head slightly to the side, meeting his gaze across the bar for a fleeting second.
“I’m not going to wait around here with you and find out.” Bucky’s downing the last of his whiskey and heading for you just as Peggy’s heading for Steve. His eyes are all over you as he approaches, sending your confidence soaring and your nerves stirring in the pit of your stomach. When he steps in close and wraps an arm around your waist, letting his right hand rest on the small of your back, you melt into his touch.
“How much of London have you seen?” He whispers the question in your ear, letting his lips ghost so close to your ear that a shiver rolls through you.
“Not enough.” You admit, biting down on your bottom lip as he curls his fingertips against the back of your dress.
“Let me show you?” It’s a request. But when he pulls back and looks into your eyes, there’s no way you could deny him.
No. Bucky’s clenching his fists atop the safehouse kitchen table as he listens to the sound of his younger self pushing open some creaky door. The din of the bar fades into the background as your heels click against pavement. You’re outside of the bar now. You’re not going to see London, that’s for fucking sure. Bucky grits his teeth as his own voice plays through the earpiece. He’s never wanted to wring his own neck so damn bad.
“There are a lot of parts of the city that aren’t safe with the war going on, but if you work with Peggy, I’m guessing you’re used to that.” You stand still at the side exit of the bar, watching as Bucky carefully places his army uniform hat over his head. Somehow, the dark brick walls of the alley make his eyes seem more blue.
“Are we going somewhere dangerous, Sergeant Barnes?” You ask softly, looking up at him through your lashes as he straightens up his uniform jacket. You let your eyes coast down, taking in the sight of him in full uniform. Why don’t they still dress men this way?
“Sergeant Barnes, hm?” He repeats the name slowly, taking two steps toward you as you take one step back toward the brick side wall of the Whip and Fiddle.
“That’s your name, isn’t it?”
“You don’t like calling me Bucky?” Another step forward and the fabric of his jacket is brushing against the fabric of your dress as your back meets the brick wall. He leans in and raises his arms, letting his palms rest against the brick on either side of your head as he cages you in. Truthfully, you don’t like calling him Bucky. You’ve avoided saying his name all night. It feels weird, it feels wrong. Just last night you were moaning that name with a slightly different man between your legs. By calling this one something different, you can at least separate the two a tiny bit.
“You don’t like when I call you Sergeant Barnes?” You skirt around his question with one of your own. He chuckles as a smug look spreads over his features. He drops his head lower and lower until his lips are a mere inch away from yours and his blue eyes are staring so far into you that you’re sure he can see every thought in your spiraling mind.
“You can call me anything you want and I’m damn sure I’ll love it.” He whispers. Your eyes track the movement of his tongue as it darts out and wets his lips.
Your world shifts when you grab the front of his jacket and pull him in. His lips are soft as they part against yours and move in the way that only men named Bucky Barnes seem to move their lips. He kisses you like he’s done it countless times in every timeline that exists. Even as rain begins pattering down, soaking his uniform and your dress, you only tug on his jacket a little harder and angle your head to the side. As his tongue dances along your bottom lip, you hesitate for the shortest second. You can hear a voice echoing in your head, asking you not to go too far tonight, but his tongue is in your mouth and your guilt only multiplies when the taste of honey-tinged whiskey soaks into your taste buds.
You taste like honey.
You remember the first time your version of Bucky slipped his tongue into your mouth as the rain begins to pour down. You don’t mean to be so rash, but you’re loosening your grip on the uniform jacket and pressing your palms flat against his chest in an instant.
“What were you drinking tonight?” You ask in a raspy whisper. You let Bucky stay close enough that your foreheads are nearly touching as he sucks in a deep breath and bites his bottom lip. Shaking his head like you’ve just asked him the most out of pocket question he’s ever heard, he releases his bottom lip slowly.
“Four Roses.” He answers just as quietly. You nod to yourself as you commit the name to memory. He lets his left hand trail down the wet brick wall, moving it closer and closer to your face until you feel his warm palm press against your cheek. The fact that his palm isn’t a cool vibranium metal one contrasting with your heated skin makes you draw in a sharp breath and close your eyes. Why the fuck are you having so much trouble with this? You should be able to make out with the guy and put on a convincing act for five minutes. But no, he tastes like honey and you’re done for. You’re suddenly acutely aware of just how long it’s been since you heard even the tiniest noise through your earpiece, and your guilt increases tenfold. As if the man before you can read your mind, he lets his hand fall away from your face. “You’re not mine to kiss like this, are you?”
“That’s the problem.” You whisper shakily, curling your fingers into the coarse fabric of his jacket lapels one more time. Your eyes float upward and meet his as you fight the urge to swallow the words you’re about to speak. “I think I am, and that scares the hell out of me.”
Something changed for you at the Whip and Fiddle tonight. Peggy isn’t quite sure what it is, but she senses it. She senses it in the air in the same way she senses the coming rain. Even if she couldn’t see the dark clouds gathering along the edge of the city, if she couldn’t smell the rain in the air, she could feel the atmosphere changing as the storm approaches. Everything is set for tomorrow. The Howling Commandos are going to take down yet another HYDRA base, and now that you have an in with the forty’s version of Bucky, it shouldn’t be all too hard to use the connection to your advantage and slip inside of the base yourself. As far as he knows, you work with Peggy and you can hold your own pretty damn well. So, as you sit in the passenger seat of Peggy’s car staring straight ahead, why do you seem so off? If everything is going according to plan so far, what’s wrong with you?
“Sergeant Barnes seemed quite taken with you.” Peggy comments as she guides the car away from the city. You’re not really paying much attention to her words, not when you’re still mulling over the realization you came to when you kissed the young sergeant in the alley earlier tonight. You couldn’t stand the fact that his left hand was his own, or that he was missing that characteristic darkness around him. It was Bucky, of course, but it wasn’t really Bucky. It wasn’t the Bucky you know. Sure, when you kissed him he tasted the same, he even smelled the same. But you were kissing a version of Bucky that hasn’t yet experienced any of the things that made the man you slept next to last night. You feel like you’ve been carrying around a perfectly crafted piece of pottery, neatly sculpted and fired in a kiln. It’s been hardened and glazed with dark earthy tones, completely finished. Then, someone shoved that piece of pottery into the back of a kitchen cabinet and handed you a wet mound of clay. You don’t want the soft, unmolded version of Bucky. You want the hardened, finished version.
“He still drinks the same whiskey.” You don’t know why you’re dwelling on that little detail. You reach up with one hand and press your fingers against your lips, feeling a frustrating warmth awaken low in your stomach. Peggy looks over at you briefly, not letting her gaze linger for long before her eyes are back on the road ahead.
“Steve and I…we wait until it’s too late, don’t we?” Peggy’s question snaps you out of your thoughts and your hand drops to your lap quickly. You turn your head and stare at her, but she remains focused on the dark street that the car is rolling down.
“What makes you ask that?”
“I have a feeling.” She sighs heavily, pursing her red lips at the end of her sentence. “I have a feeling that we don’t allow ourselves that happiness in this lifetime, and you’re not allowing it for yourself either.”
“It’s different for me.”
“How so?” She asks softly, taking a right turn. The car begins coasting down a street you recognize and you know the safehouse is just a couple of minutes away now.
“It’s just different. I can’t just give in and see if things turn out okay. We work together, we live across the hall from each other.” You’re grasping for excuses.
“You trust the man with your life but you don’t want to trust him with your heart?”
Peggy has a way with words. You don’t have a response for her as she slows down and turns into the driveway of Howard Stark’s house a couple of minutes later. As the car idles in front of the house, you feel a heavy weight settling on your shoulders.
When you reach the front door, you find that Bucky’s left it unlocked for you. You slip in quietly, leaning against the wall of the foyer for a second to gather your thoughts. The house is mostly dark except for a small light glowing in the kitchen. Your stomach is churning as you tiptoe through the foyer and peer into the kitchen, careful not to let your heels tap on the floor. You see no sign of Bucky there. When you turn your eyes to the dark living room, you see him sitting in the middle of couch with his back to you.
“The mission is set for tomorrow.” Your words come out sounding meek and uneasy as you stare at the back of Bucky’s head. He’s leaning forward, resting his elbows on his knees like he’s lost in thought. He doesn’t even move at the sound of your voice and nervousness starts to bubble up inside of you. “Bucky?” He visibly tenses at the sound of his name rolling off of your tongue.
“I stopped listening when you kissed him.” Bucky rubs his palms together slowly as he stares down at the living room carpet. He doesn’t move from the couch, and he can tell by the silence behind him that you’re not moving either. “Honestly, I didn’t think it would bother me that much.” Bucky lies, tracing the lines of his vibranium hand with his flesh index finger. It’s dark, but he has the golden crevices memorized.
“Bullshit.” You say flatly, crossing your arms over your chest. “You knew it would bother you, but you swore I was the right person for this op anyway.” You’re not going to let him act like you did something wrong, when you’re doing exactly what you were brought here to do. You watch the back of Bucky’s head as he nods slowly.
“Okay, that was bullshit.” Bucky agrees. Rain begins to patter against the roof, starting out slow and soft but quickly picking up until the sound of it is filling the house. “I knew it would bother me. I guess I just didn’t expect you to let him take things so far.”
“How far do you think he took things?” You ask incredulously, with offense evident in your tone. If Bucky stopped listening when the kiss first started in the alley of the bar, then he didn’t hear a damn thing. He didn’t hear the brevity of the kiss or the way you pushed back and stopped it. He didn’t hear you coming to the realization that you already belong to him. He didn’t hear shit.
“Pretty damn far, if he’s me.” You scoff at his answer and run a hand through your hair, leaving it looking a little tousled and messy.
“It’s 1943. If pretty damn far means we kissed and went back inside then sure, he went pretty damn far.”
“That’s it?” Bucky asks, pushing himself up to stand and turning around to face you. The couch and a few feet of distance stand between the two of you as Bucky raises a brow. He doesn’t believe you.
“He’s not like this modern version of you.” You say defensively, gesturing at him as you speak. “He didn’t want anything more than a kiss from me.” You know your words aren’t necessarily true, but you say them anyway. Bucky shoots you a pointed look before shaking his head and crossing his arms over his chest.
“Yeah, he did."
“No, he didn’t.” You argue childishly, narrowing your eyes at him. “He was sweet and kind and we had innocent fun.”
“Innocent?” Bucky repeats the word and narrows his eyes at you in return. You bend one knee and lift your ankle up toward your ass as you start undoing your heels.
“That’s what I said.” You huff as your heels clatter to the floor and you push them over to the nearest wall with your foot.
“I was anything but innocent in the forties.” Bucky says lowly. When your eyes land on him, he’s approaching you slowly, moving around the couch but keeping his gaze trained on you. Something about the way he’s looking at you is dark, making your skin feel warm and your muscles tense up. Bucky runs a hand through his messy hair as he continues taking slow steps in your direction. “You’re really telling me he didn’t have you pushed up against a brick wall in some dark alley tonight?”
You swallow hard, feeling like a kid caught in a lie. Of course he knows exactly what happened. He doesn’t need comms or a surveillance team to know what he himself would’ve done with a pretty girl on a night out. You say nothing as Bucky moves around the couch and comes to stand right in front of you. You take a small step back as he invades your space, but he doesn’t stop. He presses forward until he’s backing you against the living room wall.
Bucky’s fighting to keep up the charade. He wants nothing more than to just be honest and tell you that he’s jealous. He wants to tell you that even though it was only another version of himself that you went out with tonight, he couldn’t fucking stand it. He needs you to know that he sat here for hours, thinking about nothing but you. He watches you with an intense gaze as your back collides with the wall and you look up at him through your lashes. He’s so close that he can see the wispy black mascara tinting them. It isn’t smudged in the slightest bit and that, at the very least, calms him a little. Bucky’s hands find your hips and he holds you still against the wall as he leans in and nudges the curve of your jaw with the tip of his nose.
“He didn’t touch you like this?” Bucky whispers against your neck, as his flesh hand glides around to your ass. He grabs a handful and curls his fingertips against the soft fabric of your dress. You offer no response, because although you didn’t let him touch you like that, you know Bucky won’t believe you now. Bucky groans as he nips at the column of your throat, taking your silence as confirmation. He kisses his way up to your lips and then drags his tongue up your chin until he’s letting it delve into your mouth. You tilt your head as he kisses you, feeling a burn in your chest from the lack of air. He pulls back suddenly, and cradles the back of your head with the same hand that was just grabbing your ass. “He didn’t kiss you like that?” He questions, already assuming the answer. You whimper as Bucky tugs on your hair lightly and moves his lips down to your neck again. Instead of simply kissing your skin this time, he sucks on it and scrapes his teeth down toward your collarbone. When he lets go of your hair and slides his hand down your thigh, your back arches off the wall and you swear you feel him smile before he pulls back and smirks down at you coldly. Curling his fingers behind your thigh, he hitches your leg up around his hip and uses his body to push you further into the wall. “He didn’t pull your leg up like this?”
It’s as if Bucky’s following a script. He knows himself so well that he’s able to carry out every single move his younger self would have made on you if you’d let things continue in the alley earlier. Bucky leans in and presses one last chaste kiss to your lips before he steps away from you entirely, leaving you struggling to catch your breath as he turns on his heel. You watch, thoroughly flustered, as he heads right back to the living room and takes a seat on the center cushion of that ugly vintage couch.
“That’s what I thought.” He says lowly, causing a pang of guilt to bubble up inside of you. You let out an exaggerated sigh before reaching behind yourself and undoing the back of your dress. Bucky listens as you let the dress slip off of your frame and fall to the floor. He’s still for a moment, refusing to look back as you stand there in nothing more than a lacy black bra and matching panties. You glare at the back of his head for a second too long before stalking off to find a t-shirt and some sweats to put on before you continue the conversation at hand.
“You don’t get to judge me for what he did tonight, for what you think he did.” You say coldly as you emerge from the bedroom a few seconds later. Bucky’s still sitting on the couch, now with both of his arms outstretched along the back cushions and an almost bored expression on his face. “You told me that your younger self would swoon and that’s exactly what happened. You knew what you were sending me into, you knew he’d want to do all of those things. So, if you want to be pissed, be pissed at yourself. Your current self or your former self, I don’t care. But stop being pissed at me.” Your feet thud against the hard floor, overtaking the sound of rain pouring down on the roof as you come to stand in front of the couch, facing Bucky.
“I’m not pissed at you.” He says plainly, cocking his head to one side as he studies you. You’re wearing an oversized white t-shirt that he assumes you pulled from his side of the closet, rather than picking any of the forties-style pajamas from your own side.
“Then why make me feel like I did something wrong? I did exactly what I was supposed to do on this mission.”
“I’m jealous.” His confession sucks the air out of your lungs and leaves you stunned.
“What?”
“I’m jealous.” He repeats calmly, looking you right in the eyes. “It took everything I had not to stop you from leaving earlier. I knew what he’d do. I knew that he’d kiss you, that he’d take every inch you gave him and ask for a mile more.” The fact that Bucky’s so calm and stoic as he confesses all of this has you shaken to your core.
“No, you don’t get to do this.” You say angrily, running both hands through your hair as you turn away from him. He’s sitting there with his arms outstretched along the back of the couch and his expression as unreadable as ever and it’s only making you more mad. “You don’t get to say shit like that to me. You don’t get to be jealous. You sent me into that situation even after I made it abundantly clear that I didn’t think I was the right person for this mission.” You turn back around and look at Bucky with a fiery rage burning in your eyes, but then your gaze settles on his calm, almost serene expression. He cocks his head to the side as you study him, with whatever angry words you were about to spit at him temporarily on hold. Your eyes float down his chest, passing over the dark t-shirt he’s sporting. With the way his arms are outstretched along the back of the couch, you can see the outline of his abs clearly through his thin shirt. When your eyes land on the front of his sweats, you notice two things. The first is that he's sitting with his legs spread in a way that tells you he’s comfortable as hell on that ugly couch. The second is that his cock is semi-hard and pressing against the fabric of those sweats shamelessly.
You want to leave. You want to head for the front door and run out into the rain, losing yourself somewhere in this city that you don’t know and this timeline that you don’t belong in. You don’t want to be in this house with Bucky for another minute. You can’t think straight when you’re around him. Here you are, angry as hell over something you can’t even recall in this exact moment, because when you look at him and he looks at you this way…you’re torn between wanting to run and wanting to straddle him right there on the couch. Bucky can tell exactly what’s on your mind when your eyes zero in on his lap. Even though the anger hasn’t dissipated from your features, he can tell it’s sitting on the edge of an abyss, ready to fall in and disappear if he says the right thing.
“Go ahead.” Bucky says firmly, narrowing his eyes at you.
“What?” You cross your arms over your chest like he’s seen you do a thousand times before as you stand in front of him. You watch as Bucky looks down at his lap for a moment, letting his gaze linger on his thighs before he lifts his head up and stares into your soul. Your heart begins to race as he tilts his head to the side slowly, the expression on his face never changing.
“Sit.”
The three seconds that you stare back at Bucky with your arms crossed over your chest feel like three hours to him. When you finally do take a step forward and let your arms reach out to him, he’s fighting to hold in a sigh of relief. You move slowly, lifting your right knee up to the edge of the couch first and letting it touch the outside of his left thigh. When your left knee lands on the couch beside his right leg, you carefully position yourself over his lap as your hands come to rest on his shoulders. Bucky’s fingertips curl into the fabric of the couch as he wills himself to keep his arms along the back of it, refusing to grab your hips and guide you to sit on his lap himself. You’re apprehensive as you stare down into his blue eyes and sink onto his lap at a painstakingly snail-like pace. Your breath hitches in your throat when you feel the outline of his erection pressing against the black lace panties you have on underneath the white t-shirt, but you don’t stop. You seat yourself firmly on his lap, with your knees bent on either side of his hips and your palms pressed against his opposing warm and cool shoulders. It bothers you that he doesn’t move his arms, that he doesn’t try to touch you. It really bothers you that his expression is still unreadable, as if having you on his lap doesn’t do a damn thing to him. If his cock wasn’t hardening more and more with each passing second, you’d truly believe that you weren’t having any sort of effect on him right now.
“You don’t get to be jealous.” You whisper, shaking your head just barely as Bucky studies your face.
“Why not?”
“Because this is just…” Your eyes flit down to where your legs are spread over Bucky’s lap, but his never leave your face. He knows what you’re about to say and he’s already wishing you wouldn’t. This is exactly what he’s been trying to avoid. “This isn’t real.” It feels every bit as shitty as he thought it would, hearing you say it out loud. The muscle along the side of his jaw ticks as he clenches his teeth together. “It’s just tension. We let it build up too much and then we don’t know how to handle it, and we think it’s something more but—"
“But it isn’t.” Bucky finishes your sentence stiffly. You nod, but your eyes are searching his. You want him to convince you, you want him to tell you that you’re wrong like he has before. You need him to tell you that this isn’t just tension. But he stays quiet, staring at you like he doesn’t really give a shit what you need right now. So, you ramble on.
“Maybe if we take a break from being partners after this mission is over. We could let things cool off and give each other space.” The words tumble out of your mouth quickly, but they leave a bad taste. “But it’s hard to give each other space when we live across the hall from each other.” Bucky nods along, cocking his head to the side as he watches you scramble for other options. He doesn’t know why you’re still sitting on his lap if this is the direction you’re taking things, but he isn’t ready to push you off and end this just yet. Not if it might be the last time you let him get this close to you.
“Do you want space?” He asks lowly. You struggle to find a reasonable answer when his tongue darts out to wet his lips. You watch as it slides across his bottom lip slowly before disappearing into his mouth. He shifts his legs beneath you slightly and it causes his hard cock to press against your barely clothed cunt just a little more firmly than before and you inhale sharply, curling your fingertips into his shoulders as he stills once again.
“I want to stop thinking about you the way that I’ve been thinking about you.” Bucky’s heartbeat is rising steadily as your words sink in. You’ve been thinking about him. God, he wants to tangle his hands in your hair and pull you in closer, refusing to let go of you until you admit that you fucking want him. “I want to go back to when we had a normal, uncomplicated partnership in the field.” He wants to say fuck normal and uncomplicated and have his way with you, but he stays still. “I want to fuck.”
Bucky’s stunned. He blinks twice before squinting his eyes at you and letting out a long, slow breath.
“You want to fuck.” Bucky repeats under his breath, seeming like he doesn’t think he’s heard you right. You nod, coming to the realization that that’s exactly what you want.
“Maybe if we fuck, it would all just go away.” Bucky scoffs as soon as you’ve said it. He’s never felt as frustrated as he is right now. It isn’t just emotional frustration, but sexual as well. You’re fucking tormenting him. While you sit on his lap actively denying the fact that this thing between you is real, you’re simultaneously telling him you want to have sex with him. You tried sleeping it off once before and it didn’t work out for you, so now you want to fuck the feelings away. He’s pissed honestly. As he sits there, with his arms outstretched along the back of the couch and the girl he’s in love with on his lap, he’s pissed.
“Go ahead then.” He says roughly, jutting his chin out at you as his eyes flit down to where your legs are spread over him. “Go ahead and see if you can fuck it all away. It’ll work about as well as when you tried to sleep it off, but I’m willing to let you give it a shot.”
Thunder rumbles in the distance and rain patters against the windows as tensions rise all around you. It feels like the thunderstorm outside has somehow shifted through the walls and lightning could strike you at any given moment. Though your heart is racing and your breaths are coming in quicker than before, you don’t back down. You maintain eye contact as you lift your ass up slightly and then grind back down, dragging the fabric of your lace panties along the front of Bucky’s sweats. You feel his cock twitch in its confines, but his face never changes. Fuck him and his perpetually cold expression. You grind down again, harder this time, and watch as his hands curl into fists at the ends of his outstretched arms. What do you have to do to get him to put those hands on you?
Lightning strikes somewhere outside as you lean in and dip your head down, pressing your lips to the side of Bucky’s neck in an open-mouthed kiss. You feel his pulse thumping in his carotid artery as your tongue swipes over it. If you’re going to get this out of your system, you can’t take your time. You need this to be quick and dirty. Bucky senses that and isn’t surprised at all when your right hand starts tugging at the waistband of his sweats.
“I said go ahead.” He rasps, tilting his head to the side to give you more access to his neck. “Take what you want.” You take the encouragement and run with it, slipping your hand into the waistband of his sweats and boxers, quickly finding his length and wrapping your hand around it. He lets out a shaky but controlled breath as you start stroking his cock. He has to bite down on his bottom lip when you tighten your grip around the head and he feels his precum wet your palm. This is going to haunt him forever. He wants this, you, so fucking bad that he’s willing to take whatever he can get. And this is the most he can get. Your hand is around his cock with the sole intention of fucking around with him until you forget your feelings. He should feel used. He does feel used, but if you’re only okay with using him, then he’s fine with it. He’s fine with it because he fucking loves you.
You feel Bucky’s chest rise and fall at a quicker pace against your own as his cock twitches in your hand. Thunder shakes the house again and a tear slips down your cheek. It feels clinical when you push Bucky’s waistband down further and drag your lips along the curve of his jaw.
“He kissed me outside of the bar.” You whisper against the column of Bucky’s throat, hating the way he tenses up underneath you. You let your hand fall away from his cock and shift it between your legs, tugging your lace panties to the side beneath the oversized t-shirt. “And I couldn’t fucking stand it.” Your voice breaks and Bucky curls his fingers into the couch cushions so hard that he might’ve heard them rip if the storm raging outside wasn’t so loud. “You weren’t listening, so you didn’t hear me stop him.” Another tear falls as you rise up on your knees and guide the head of Bucky’s length to where it belongs. “But I stopped him.” Lightning strikes and you swear it nearly hits the house as you let out a shaky breath and start lowering yourself down. The sheer size of him makes your thighs ache and the walls of your cunt burn with the stretch. “I stopped him and he knew, before I said anything, that I wasn’t his to kiss.” Bracing your hands back on Bucky’s shoulders, you sink down onto him one slow inch at a time as he stares up at you. His expression isn’t so unreadable now. It’s showcasing the torment he feels, the torture you’re putting him through…the torture he’s enduring just because he loves you.
“Whose are you then?” He asks, his voice tense and strained as you seat yourself entirely on his cock. He can tell by the look in your eyes that you’re not going to answer his question. You know the answer, the tears rimming your pretty eyes and the pleading look taking over your face tell him that much. But you just can’t bring yourself to say it out loud. You’re his.
You didn’t give yourself any time to adjust to his size and you’re paying for it as you start riding him. You move slow at first, lost in the way he’s looking at you, wondering why the hell he won’t touch you. But as the storm picks up outside, so does your pace. Faster and faster you lift and lower your hips until it couldn’t possibly be more obvious that you’re trying to fuck your feelings away. Bucky’s pushing past the obscene sounds of skin against skin, past the rumbling thunder and heavy rain on the rooftop, until all he can hear is your heartbeat. You don’t even realize you’re doing it, but you’re timing each bounce of your hips with the steady beat of your heart. He focuses in on that when the walls of your pussy begin fluttering violently around his shaft, because if he lets himself focus on anything else, he’ll fall over the edge with you and he refuses to let it happen this way. Your goal isn’t to get him off, it’s to get something out of your system.
Bucky clenches his teeth when you start coming undone around him, he clenches his teeth and his vibranium arm whirs loudly along the back of the couch as you grip his shoulders and ride out your orgasm. It’s only a few seconds later when you blink your eyes open and let a few tears fall onto the fabric of his shirt.
“Did it work?” Bucky asks breathlessly, fighting the urge to wrap his arms around you and pull you against his chest.
“What?”
“Did you fuck it out of your system?” He narrows his eyes at you. He’s sure the answer is no, but he isn’t so sure that you’ll admit it. As you stare back into his blue eyes, he can tell you’re giving up and something akin to hope stirs in his chest. You shake your head gently, loosening your grip on his shoulders as the weight of your silent confession settles over you both. “Okay, let’s try again.”
Bucky doesn’t give you a chance to full catch your breath before he’s slipping his flesh arm around your back and rising from the couch, keeping his cock buried inside of you.
“Bucky—”
“You want it out of your system, don’t you?” He asks roughly, carrying you away from the couch and toward the kitchen table. You swallow hard as he skillfully uses his vibranium hand to shove a kitchen chair to the side before laying you down on the table. Still, his cock never leaves your pussy. “If we go at it from another angle…” Bucky’s voice trails off as he pulls his hips backward slowly until only the tip of his cock is left inside of you. You whimper at the loss of his length, hating the way your pussy fights to grip onto what he’s left you with. Bucky pushes your white t-shirt up until it’s sitting just below your bra. Though he doesn’t let himself get a glimpse of your chest, he has no problem with sliding his hands beneath the shirt and running his palms over your breasts. You arch into his touch and another whimper leaves your lips. “This might be the right angle.” He whispers, dragging his hands down until his fingers are curling into your hips roughly. You see stars when he pistons his hips forward so hard that the table shakes beneath the force and you feel him brushing against your cervix.
“Fuck.” You moan the word out as your tears begin to dry. Your hands circle around Bucky’s wrists as he holds your hips in place and starts fucking you relentlessly. Your mascara is smudged beneath your eyes but you still look so pretty that it hurts him to look at you. You wrap your legs around him as his head falls back a little and a guttural groan escapes him. It feels so damn good, you feel so damn good, but this isn’t how he wants you. Your whimpers and occasional swears turn into uninhibited, borderline pornographic moans as he fucks you until you’re lost in the bliss of it all.
“If you cum on my cock a second time, is it going to be enough?” He wonders aloud, slowing the pace of his thrusts and simultaneously deepening them as much as he possibly can. His balls press against your ass as a loud clap of thunder leaves the lights flickering. You’re shaking your head before your brain has a chance to reason with your heart. It won’t be enough. “You don’t think so? You seemed pretty damn sure of yourself when you said that this isn’t real. Cumming on my cock this time should be enough for you.”
“Shit, Bucky.” You let out a frustrated moan as he pulls his hips back slowly and starts giving your cunt the most shallow thrusts yet.
“This is so fucking real to me that I’d let you do it a thousand times if that’s what it takes to make you realize you’re wrong.” Bucky snaps his hips forward and hits your cervix again, admiring the way your body reacts to him as your back arches off of the table and your t-shirt rides up a little more. A tiny bit of the black lace of your bra peeks out beneath your shirt and Bucky lets out another groan before thrusting hard again. He wanted to slow down and make you feel even just a shred of the torment he’s been feeling tonight, he wanted to give you shallow, unrhythmic thrusts and delay your orgasm, but he’s already fucking his cock into you at an unforgiving pace and depth. His name falls from your lips in a breathless moan as your fingernails leave little crescent-shaped indents in the skin of his wrists and your pussy tightens around his shaft all over again. He has to bite down on the inside of his cheek, nearly drawing blood, just to keep from cumming with you. His own level of restraint is surprising himself. He hasn’t done something like this in decades and yet, he’s holding himself together pretty damn well.
“Bucky.” You gasp as your orgasm washes over you and he continues to pump his cock into you. He lets his thrusts slow more and more with each passing second until he’s just lazily circling his hips, giving you the faintest sensation of pleasure mixed with overstimulation.
“Did it work that time?” He asks between pants. He lets go of your hips as his eyes scan over the expanse of your skin where he had gripped you so tightly before, checking for marks. He can see his own handprints on each hip, but they aren’t red enough that he thinks he’s left bruises. You stare up at him as a sigh of relief slips past his lips. When his eyes finally meet yours, you know he’s waiting for an answer.
“It didn’t.” You admit. The lights flicker again, going out for a few seconds before coming back on. “I’m sorry I—”
“I don’t want to hear you say sorry.” God, that’s not at all what he wants to hear you say. He wants to hear you say you were wrong or that you were lying and this is as real to you as it is to him. He wants to hear you say that no matter how many times his cock slides into your pussy, the feelings aren’t going anywhere. As his hands find yours and your fingers intertwine, he tugs you up into a sitting position on the edge of the table and then slips his palms around to cup your ass as he lifts you once more. “We’re going to try this one more time and if it doesn’t work, if you can’t fuck the feelings away…” His voice trails off as the lights flicker one final time before shutting off completely. Bucky carries you down the hall and through the bedroom door in near total darkness. Every few seconds, lightning flashes and illuminates the house through the windows and sheer curtains, and you get a glimpse of Bucky’s serious face. “If this doesn’t work, you have to say it.” Keeping his flesh arm around your lower back, he lowers you onto the bed, hovering over you as his still-hard cock slips out of your sore cunt. You prop yourself up on your elbows as he stands at the foot of the bed and reaches back over his shoulders, grasping the fabric of his t-shirt and tugging it over his head in one smooth move. Lighting strikes again and you watch, with warmth pooling low in your stomach, as Bucky pushes his sweats and boxers down to the floor.
“I have to say what?” You ask, fighting hard to keep the stutter out of your question. Bucky wraps his right hand around the base of his cock tightly, but he doesn’t dare stroke it. He gives it a quick squeeze before moving that same hand down and palming his balls in an effort to slow himself down.
“You have to say that you’re mine.” He has no idea that you’ve already said it once tonight. He took his earpiece out, thinking you were having a heated moment with another man, when you were really telling that man exactly what Bucky wanted to hear.
“That’s how this works? You fuck me a few times and then I’m yours?”
Bucky can’t stop the dark, hair-raising chuckle that tumbles past his lips when you tilt your head to the side and narrow your eyes at him. He moves toward the bed slowly, placing one knee on the end of the mattress and leaning forward until both of his palms are flat on the bed. He’s hovering over you, his face only a few inches from yours when a burst of thunder rings out.
“You’ve been mine since the day we met, sweetheart. I just let you run around and deny it for too damn long.” Your breath hitches in your throat as he angles his chin toward the headboard, silently letting you know that he wants you to move further up on the bed. You scoot backward, keeping your eyes on him as the room grows impossibly warmer and goosebumps prickle over your skin. When your back lands flat on the bed and your head is laid comfortably on the only pillow there, Bucky’s over you in an instant, nudging your legs apart with his knee as he settles between them. The head of his cock, still dripping with precum, presses against the lace of your panties and he hisses at the contact. He hasn’t let himself cum yet and he’s dangerously close to losing control over his impending orgasm.
“Since the day we met?” You ask, scrunching up your face in confusion as you think of all of the missions you’ve been on, all of the senseless arguments and shit-giving. Did it all have a deeper meaning for him? Bucky nods as he stills above you and braces himself with his arms next to either side of your head. When he looks into your eyes you can tell that he’s straining to maintain his composure and it almost makes you feel guilty. Here you are two orgasms in and he’s hanging on by a fucking thread. You slide your hand down between your bodies, wrapping it around his length and giving it a few long, slow pumps as his eyes flutter closed and his head falls to your shoulder.
“I can’t stand you.” You say evenly, as he starts rutting into your hand carelessly. His small thrusts are sloppy and restrained, but he continues on as you stroke his cock and smear his precum around the length of it. He groans in response and bites down on your shoulder hard enough to make you inhale sharply. “I can’t stand the way you slept so close to me last night, because the next time I sleep alone, I’ll feel like something’s missing.” Bucky freezes, but you continue your ministrations with your right hand. He doesn’t lift his head, fearing that if he so much as moves an inch you’ll stop talking. “I can’t stand the way you say my name, because when anyone else says it, it doesn’t sound as good.” He lets out a shaky breath as he builds up the courage to move. Snaking his vibranium hand down between your legs, he starts tugging your panties to the side just like he did earlier. You move in tandem with him, guiding the head of his cock to your entrance as he clears the way. “And I really can’t stand the way you kiss me, because if I ever let anyone else kiss me, I’ll only ever be disappointed.”
Bucky pulls his head back and stares down at you with a furrowed brow, looking as though he’s thinking hard. The head of his cock notches into your pussy and he pushes his hips forward just enough to sink the first couple of inches inside of you, watching as your mouth falls open and your eyes close tightly. He’s staring at you with such an intense focus in his blue eyes that when you finally look back up at him, you feel like his gaze alone is burning a hole through your head. You spread your legs a little, bending your knees slightly to give him a better angle as he pulls his hips back slowly. When only the head of his cock is sheathed inside of you, he licks his bottom lip before snapping his hips forward and delivering one hard, deep thrust that forces the headboard to slam against the wall.
“I love you.” Bucky says the three words with conviction, with a confidence you’ve never heard before. You wait a few seconds, trying to recover from the earth-shattering sensations of your pussy being destroyed and actual bliss. His words sink into your skin and melt into your soul with an unexpected warmth as he drags his cock out of you and then pushes back in again. He loves you.
“You can’t stand me.” You correct, not even trying to hide the smile that’s beginning to spread across your lips as Bucky starts setting a rhythmic pace. He laughs, but then groans as you scrape your nails down his back roughly.
“I can’t, but still…”
“You love me.” You repeat smugly, finishing his sentence. He doesn’t need you to say it back yet. Just the fact that you didn’t shove him away and flee the house when he said it is enough for him right now. A few sultry moans play in his ears and he pushes himself up to sit on his knees, moving your legs so that one is over each of his shoulders before he starts fucking you so hard that he thinks Howard Stark might need to buy a new mattress, new headboard, and maybe even have the damn wall re-plastered.
The next few minutes consist of nothing more than filthy, pornographic sounds. With skin slapping against skin, the headboard snapping against the wall, your moans, and Bucky’s strained groans, neither of you can really hear the storm raging outside anymore. You focus in on Bucky as much as you can, watching as his abs ripple and the muscles of his flesh arm flex repeatedly. He catches you staring at him as he fucks you and he holds eye contact, letting his mouth fall open and his eyelids drop down halfway as he watches you watch him. Filthy. It’s filthy the way he's fucking his cock into you in someone else’s bed. You moan his name out in a raspy tone and it sends him over the edge. He guides your legs down, setting them back on the bed before crawling over you and fucking you missionary while he swallows every moan you let out. His lips brush against yours over and over again, but you don’t kiss. You breathe each other in until you feel his cock twitch and his thrusts grow sloppy.
“Fuck, I’m gonna cum.” Bucky groans, thrusting a little harder and deeper as he nears his release. You grip his sides and bend your knees as your own orgasm looms. “You’re so fucking tight and….fuck, you’re just…shit, baby.”
“Bucky, I love you.”
He loses every last remnant of control when you finally admit it. He can’t stop the flood of cum that starts spilling out of his cock and into you. Truthfully, he wouldn’t want to stop it. He thrusts as deep as he can and grinds his hips into you, watching your eyes scrunch closed and your mouth fall open as you take every last drop of his cum. It’s everything to him. Not you taking his cum this way, not you letting him have you like this, but you telling him the one thing he never thought you would. You love him.
His post-orgasm haze should last longer than yours. He should be collapsed next to you on the bed right now, but as you lay beneath him trying to catch your breath, he’s staring down at you with perfect clarity.
“If you go back to pretending you don’t feel anything after this…” Bucky’s voice trails off as he feels a good bit of his cum dripping out of you and back onto his shaft. He moves in a little closer and pushes his cock the rest of the way inside you as gently as possible, earning himself a whimper from your pretty lips.
“You’ll what? Fuck me on another table?” You tease, smiling up at him. He shakes his head and bites down on his bottom lip in an attempt to hide his own smile, but you catch it anyway.
“Why would I do that when there are so many other surfaces we haven’t tried out yet?”
“I hate you.” You retort playfully, sliding your hands up his chest and preparing to push him off of you. His cock hasn’t softened in the slightest bit yet and you don’t know if you can take another round tonight. His small smile turns into a hearty grin as his cock twitches again.
“That’s a lie.” He smirks, dragging his tongue along his teeth after speaking. You narrow your eyes at him as you realize he’s still leaning on his ridiculous theory that your pussy clenches down when you lie. “You love me.” He says slowly, dropping his head down and pressing his lips against yours. He kisses you gently at first, pecking your lips twice before going in for a longer one. After a few seconds, he slips his tongue into your mouth and the longer he kisses you, the more weight you feel lifting from your shoulders. You didn’t realize how exhausting it was to deny this for so long. But now that you’re here, letting it happen, you can’t stop the tear that starts rolling down your cheek. Bucky pulls back as soon as he feels it, searching your eyes to see what’s wrong. “What did I do?” He asks quickly, preparing to separate himself from you. You stop him, sliding your hands down his sides and curling your fingers against his skin to hold him in place.
“Nothing.” You answer honestly, smiling up at his look of concern even as that tear continues to roll down your cheek. “Peggy has a feeling that she and Steve wait too late in this lifetime, that they don’t let themselves have this kind of happiness.”
“I told you they end up together.” Bucky says gently, using the pad of his thumb to wipe the tear from your cheek.
“I know. I wonder if this is how they felt when they finally made it back to each other.” Bucky takes a moment, really thinking about it before he moves a stray lock of hair away from your face and lets out a deep breath.
“How do you feel?” He asks, speaking with a soft tone as he eyes you closely.
“Like if you asked me for a lifetime, it wouldn’t scare the shit out of me.”
As Bucky stares down at you, you can see that all of those times you thought his expression was so unreadable were because you didn’t really want to read what was there. All you see in his eyes is love. Love and probably some kind of half-assed plan to ask you for a lifetime while his dick is inside you, just so he can see if you’re lying or not.
summary: your car breaks down on a case, and sharing a motel room with your least favourite coworker becomes quite the challenge when he insists on pushing all your buttons. fortunately, you know just the way to get him to shut up, even if it's just for the night.
genre: smut (MDNI) word count: 10k (oops)
tags: fem!reader, enemies with benefits, petty arguing, sub!spencer, dry humping, unprotected p in v, they're freaking it raw, creampie, oral (f receiving), come eating, edging, overstimulation, mentions of birth control (pill), accidental L-bomb, motel sex, spell-checked but not really proofread
notes: part two of overexposed | this is the smuttiest thing i've written so far, i think.
Rule number one of working in the BAU: never agree to draw straws.
It doesn’t matter how many times Rossi assures you that his games aren’t rigged, they absolutely are. They have to be, because Reid and you get paired up so often, you’d think you were best friends.
Nobody wanted to take on a six-hour side mission—three hours there, three hours back—to speak to the ex-wife of this week’s unsub, yourself included. So, naturally, Rossi had raided the local PD of their toothpicks, snapped the ends off of two of them, and presented them to the team with this devilish smile that said I know exactly how this is going to go. You don’t even know why you agreed, if we’re being honest, because you too knew damn well what would happen when you plucked that toothpick from his conniving hands.
You pulled the first short straw, and you got to watch in silent, not at all surprised frustration as Spencer pulled the second one. You had had half a mind to take your stupid toothpick and jam it into Rossi’s eye, but you restrained yourself; after all, you’re supposed to be the better, more mature half of your duo with the world’s most idiotic genius. He had tried to protest, arguing that he was too valuable of an asset to essentially abandon the investigation, but the team were quick to throw the two of you out of the police department and into an SUV that had spent all day boiling in the Louisiana sun.
That leads us into rule number two: never trust an SUV.
After three hours of suffocating in that cursed car, choking on the thick, oppressive air, you had arrived at the home of the mysterious ex-wife. Another hour-and-a-half of questioning later, you were free to embark on your journey back to the team.
Tragedy struck not even an hour even into the drive. The car stuttered, screeched, and stopped dead in the middle of traffic. You’d tried just about everything you could to breathe life back into the overheated corpse of the SUV, but it was no use; you had broken down.
And just like that, the dam broke and the tense, carefully maintained silence between you and Spencer shattered into pieces.
Standing there, on the side of the road, Spencer had yelled at you—or you had yelled at him; you don’t remember who started it—until you were red-faced and people in their functioning vehicles were craning their necks to watch the scene unfold as they drove on by.
You called Hotch. Spencer dialled triple-A. Both phone calls crushed whatever remnants of hope you dared cling to.
On your end, Hotch informed you that the unsub had just taken a hostage—surprise! The BAU needed every bit of information you had gathered from the ex-wife, and they needed it now. He barked orders at you over the phone, telling you to check yourselves into a motel and call him back ASAP, and abruptly hung up.
On Spencer’s end, triple-A had kindly told him that the car was fucked—hurray! Something was wrong with the engine, apparently, and you needed to wait for roadside assistance to bring their tow truck.
But you didn’t have time to wait, not when there were lives at stake. So, you dialled Hotch’s number right there and began relaying everything you had learned over the sound of cars speeding by: details about the unsub’s failed marriage, his childhood, and—
Spencer had snatched the phone from you the moment you dared stumble over a word, damn near tearing your arm off with it. He promptly appointed himself leader of your botched hostage negotiation, and he left you to explain the situation to the very confused—and rightfully a little concerned—roadside assistance workers.
The negotiation continued into the back of some good samaritan’s car, and the two of you were dropped off at what looked to be the shittiest motel in the entire state. It was at that point you stole the phone back and ordered Spencer to speak to the receptionist whilst you walked the team through the safest way to approach the unsub.
In the motel room, you were finally able to put the team on speaker. You set the phone on the desk and, after two hours of anxious pacing, the unsub was finally detained.
And that brings us to the present, and to rule number three: never expect the BAU to come to your aid, no matter how desperately you may need it.
You’re lying face-down on the bed, listening to Hotch’s static-laced voice as he informs you, in essence, that all is well. Spencer is still standing, hands stuffed into his pockets, nodding along with everything being said.
“When can we expect to be picked up?” he asks.
The pause that follows his question is a damning one. A death sentence delivered through thick silence.
“The two of you will be staying at the motel for the night,” Hotch says. You can hear it in his voice, a slight awkwardness; he knowswhat he’s doing, yet he’s doing it anyway.
It’s fine, though. It’s just one night in a shitty motel. Really, it could be worse—
“But I only booked one room.”
Your head shoots up so fast you’re sure you almost break your neck. You scramble up onto your knees, already shaking your head in disbelief—refusal to believe.
“You’re fucking kidding.”
Spencer looks mortified.
“Reid,” you warn, “tell me you’re not serious—”
He huffs, like you’re somehow the idiot in this situation, and crosses his arms. “I didn’t think we’d be staying here!”
“You didn’t— oh my God. How?” You bark out a hollow laugh. “How are you so fucking stupid?”
The phone speaker crackles, picking up the faint sound of Morgan’s laughter.
Spencer’s cheeks are starting to turn red. “I just assumed that—”
“IQ of 187, they said” you mutter, exasperated. “God help us all.”
“I’ll— I’ll go to the front desk.” He’s already heading for the door, raking his fingers through his hair as he walks. “I’ll get us another room—”
“The front desk closed thirty minutes ago.”
“...oh.”
You take a deep breath, turning away from him as you redirect your attention to the phone. Your lifeline. Clearing your throat, you put on the calmest, most amiable voice you can manage and say, “...Hotch?”
“You’re two hours away,” he says plainly.
“Please.”
“By the time we get you back here it’ll be almost three in the morning.”
“I’m begging you.”
“The answer’s no. The two of you will handle this like adults, and we will see you tomorrow.”
Just when you think he’s about to hang up, another voice comes through the speaker. Morgan’s.
“Have fun, lovebirds.”
Spencer scoffs so loud you’d think he was choking on something. “Excuse me?”
“Nothing!”
The call disconnects just as he lurches forward to grab the phone. He holds it in his hand for a moment, staring down at it with frustration that amounts almost to rage, before tossing it to you with a strangled huff.
“I can’t believe this.”
“I can’t believe you only booked one room,” you counter. “Seriously, what did you think was going to—’
“Alright, I get it. I’m an idiot.”
“Mhm.” You flop back onto the bed with a sigh, letting the silence hang in the air for a moment before adding, “Hey, at least we did it.”
“We?”
“Uh…yeah?”
Spencer pulls this face. Disgust mixed with disbelief. It would be comical if it weren’t directed at you. “You barely contributed.”
“Oh, come on—”
“You spent half of that negotiation just…lying around whilst I gave all the information—”
“Information that I got from the guy’s ex-wife.”
“Only because you wouldn’t let me speak to her.”
“Because you don’t know how to talk to women.”
Spencer’s pacing ceases, and he turns to you with a scowl. “Sorry?”
“I was doing you a favour.” You look up at him with a mocking smile. “You would’ve embarrassed yourself if you’d spoken to her.”
His lips curl at the corners, and you’re sure that he’d be shooting lasers from his eyes if he could, zapping you into oblivion. He opens his mouth to speak, closes it, then opens it again to say, “You are such a—”
“A what?” you ask, raising an eyebrow.
And he closes his mouth once more.
Sitting up, you shuffle to the edge of the bed and cross your arms expectantly. “Go on.”
You can see the tension in his jaw, the way he’s grinding his teeth subtly. He spends a good few moments just staring at you, probably trying to explode you with his mind, before he turns away with a sharp, catty huff.
“I’m never agreeing to anything like this again,” he mutters.
“Good. Me neither.”
There’s nothing provocative about your words—you’re actually agreeing with him, for once—yet Spencer spins back around to face you all the same.
“You’ve been nothing but irritating all day,” he spits.
“And all you’ve done is complain.”
“At least I’m not incompetent.”
“Beats being an arrogant little bitch.”
Again, Spencer turns on his heels and begins walking away. “That’s it,” he announces, “I’m taking a shower.”
“Running away. Real mature—”
The bathroom door slams, and you swear it shakes the very foundation of the motel room.
Closing your eyes, you take a deep breath. Try to calm yourself as the reality of this horror movie-worthy situation catches up to you. You’re to share a room with Spencer Reid—share a bed—because of his stupidity, and he had the gall to call you incompetent.
The shower turns on. You can hear it through the paper-thin wall, and part of you wants to barge into that bathroom, drag him out by his hair and leave him, naked, on the side of the road. It’s the only way you’ll get any semblance of peace tonight, that’s for sure.
But what would that say about you? That you’re just as childish—as petulant—as he is? You’re supposed to be the bigger person here, the better person.
So you resign yourself to lying in wait, dreading whatever bullshit the next twelve hours have in store for you.
—
Thirty minutes later, Spencer emerges from the bathroom muttering about the disgraceful state of the bathroom. He doesn’t seem to notice, or care, that you aren’t listening to him; you’re frankly too distracted by the state of him. His hair is still wet, and his white shirt has been left untucked, held closed by a total of two buttons. Your gaze lingers, rather unapologetically, on the curves of his exposed collarbones.
Whilst he was showering, you rummaged through your go-bag and pulled out whatever pyjama-esque clothes you could find. You are, as Spencer is always so keen to point out, terribly disorganised; your bag hasn’t been restocked in over a month, and there are more “complimentary” hotel toiletries hidden in there than there are clothes.
In the end, you settled on a plain black compression top that you don’t remember owning, and a pair of grey sweatpants that you’re sure can’t be yours on account of the fact that they are far, far too big for you.
You watch as he unzips his own go-bag—no doubt perfectly organised, alphabetised, colour-coded, and packed with enough supplies to last him weeks in case of an emergency—and raise an eyebrow.
“Calmed down yet?”
Spencer spares you a single, fleeting glance out of the corner of his eye before exhaling sharply through his nose; a punctuated, silent no. But then he seems to pause. Seconds pass as he stares at his bag, unmoving, before turning his head slowly to look at you again.
You’re splayed out diagonally on the bed, taking up as much space as possible as you flick listlessly through the same beat-up book you’ve been nursing for over a month now. In your peripheral vision, you can just about make out the way his focus strays to your clothes. To the thin sliver of skin visible between the hem of your top and the waistband of your sweats. And then he clears his throat.
“You’re paying for the repairs,” he mutters stiffly.
You set your book on your chest and turn to him with a frown. “I am not—”
“I paid for eleven of your coffees last month,” he says.
“And I covered the bill for that stupid Doctor Who edible experience bullshit you took me to the month before.”
“You still owe me a dollar for that.”
“Forty-nine cents,” you correct. “We agreed to round down.”
“No, you insisted that we round down. I told you I wanted the change.”
“Are you really that broke that forty-nine cents makes all the difference?”
“No,” he mutters, pulling a folded pair of pyjamas from his bag. “Are you?”
“No.”
“Then you can pay for the repairs.”
You scoff. “There’s a big difference between some pocket change and a busted car, Reid.”
“The Bureau will reimburse you.”
“Then why can’t you just pay?”
“Because,” he unbuttons his shirt and, honest to God, throws it at you, “it’s your turn.”
“You—” You groan as his shirt lands on your face, and you throw it back at him. “You are such a child.”
Spencer catches the shirt with a cold, sarcastic laugh. “Really?” he asks. “Because it seems to me I’m the only adult here.”
You roll your eyes as he continues changing, but you can’t help but let your gaze wander across his body; his bare neck and chest, now free from the usual confines of his shirt and tie. You’d quite happily take a bite out of him if you thought you’d live to tell the tale.
As he pulls on his pyjama shirt, you sigh. “How much is it gonna cost?”
He shrugs, methodically folding his work clothes before tucking them neatly into his go-bag. “Timing belt replacements typically cost between four-hundred and one-thousand dollars.”
Your face contorts in disgust at his words and, for a moment, you think he may be joking.
Unfortunately, he isn’t.
“Fuck off,” you say. “I’m not paying that.”
“Neither am I. I wasn’t the one driving the car.”
Somehow, your expression manages to sour further. You cast your book aside and prop yourself up on your elbows. “So this is my fault?”
“Is that what I said?”
“It’s what you implied.”
“A timing belt doesn’t just break out of nowhere,” he says, perching himself on the side of the bed. He speaks slowly, clearly, like he’s explaining something to a child. “There are signs—”
No sooner has he sat down do you stand up, effectively swapping places with him. “The check engine light never came on.”
“Still, you should have—”
“Sitting in the driver’s seat doesn’t make me omnipotent, Reid,” you snap, crossing your arms as you glare at him from the other side of this much, much too small room. “You had just as much information as I did—”
“It isn’t the passenger’s responsibility to check for faults—”
“So you didn’t notice, either?” you ask. Not my responsibility is just Spencer-speak for I’m a hypocrite refusing to admit my own oversight. “You’re the one with a fucking PhD in Engineering, you know—”
“And? I’m saying it isn’t my job to notice—”
Oh, and he’s doubling down. Amazing.
“Oh my God.” You’re talking over him now, raising your voice as you rake your fingers through your hair. “Grow up. You’re a federal agent, Reid. Act like one.”
Spencer snorts. “That’s rich coming from you.”
You really wish you were making this up. You wish this were some frustration-induced hallucination, but it isn’t. You’re actually standing here in some run-down, shitty fucking motel, arguing with a genius who was too stupid to book two rooms. You’re sure you’ve seen this be used as a set up to a straight to DVD romcom, for Christ’s sake.
You have half a mind to walk back over there and smack him across the face, but it would only make this worse.
“Maybe,” Spencer continues, entirely unprompted, “if you treated me with the slightest degree of decorum, I would act in kind.”
This is Hell. The car crashed, you died, and this is Hell. It has to be.
“And maybe if you respected me,” you snap back, “I would act—”
“There’s nothing to respect.”
The laugh that escapes you in response to that statement isn’t a pretty one. It’s somewhere between a cackle and a murderous screech. You have to laugh; you’d kill him if you didn’t.
You’re sure that, in the animal kingdom, a laugh like that would be heeded as a warning—and a serious one, at that. A real don’t fuck with me or I’ll kill you noise; a universal language.
But Spencer Reid isn’t of the animal kingdom—at this point you aren’t sure he’s from earth at all—because, in spite of your warning, he keeps talking.
“You’re unprofessional, aggressive, short-tempered, bitter, frustrating—need I go on?”
“You forgot smart and sexy—”
“There is nothing about you worth respecting,” he declares, “not when you’re…on my ass all the time.”
It’s the way that he still hesitates before saying ass, even though he has said far worse things to you in the past, that momentarily clears the resentment clouding your mind. Spencer Reid, genius supreme, the man who apparently hates you more than any unsub you’ve come across, can still barely bring himself to curse.
…and it’s the way he’s implying that you are somehow the perpetrator in all of this that has that resentment rushing back tenfold.
“I’m on your ass?”
“Yes,” he says. “You are. It’s infuriating.”
“Infuriating, right…”
“You do nothing but antagonise me,” he adds. “You’re pestiferous.”
“Mhm. And you’re a fucking saint.”
He shrugs. “I think most would agree I’m better than you.”
You purse your lips into a tight smile, letting your gaze wander across the room before returning it to him. “And if they knew you were fucking me?” you pose. “Would that tarnish your pristine reputation?”
Just like that, Spencer’s cocky, confident attitude vanishes in an instant. He scoffs, visibly recoiling at the mention of your relationship as his expression morphs into something half-disgusted, half-defensive. “That’s—”
“I mean, the team are already calling us lovebirds, but what if they knew?” you continue, ignoring the way his cheeks are beginning to flush. “What if the BAU knew that their obnoxious golden boy was sleeping with someone so unworthy of respect?”
When he doesn’t respond, you step closer to him.
“You know it’s funny, actually, that you say that,” you say, “because the only person on this team who doesn’t respect me, Spencer, is you.”
“You don’t respect me, either,” he mutters.
“Why the hell would I?”
You sound almost amused as you cross the room. You close the space between you, drawing closer until you’re standing right in front of him.
Spencer raises his head, arms crossed, to look up at you. He’s glaring, or trying to, but his gaze spends only a fraction of a second on your face before it begins to wander. Lingering on the outline of your chest visible through your top, and then on the waistband of your underwear that peeks out over the top of those baggy sweatpants—embroidered, ironically, with the word sweet.
You watch the way his jaw works, chewing on whatever insult he has lined up, as he finds himself painfully distracted by the sight of you before him.
And you straddle him.
“Why would I respect someone like you, Reid?” you ask as you settle into his lap.
He makes no effort to push you away (why would he?), but he doesn’t exactly welcome you with open arms, either. He tenses up, heat rushing to his face despite his attempts to appear perfectly neutral.
“Tell me,” you purr, placing a finger under his chin so he’s meeting your gaze, “why would I respect someone so— what was what word you used? Pestiferous? Someone who goes out of his way to piss me off, even when I haven’t done anything wrong…and for what purpose, hm?” You rest your other hand on his chest and lean in close, brushing your nose against his with a barely suppressed smirk. “You wanna know what I think?”
“...not really,” he says stiffly.
“I think you like it when I’m pissed off,” you say. “I think that my short temper, and my aggression, and all those other flaws you listed, are all things you like about me. Am I right?”
“No,” he mutters. “Why would I—”
“Because you’re pathetic, and you’re a shit liar.” Smiling, you shift slightly, pressing yourself down against the tent in his pants that has been there far longer than he’ll ever admit. “And your, um, body has ways of giving you away. And I bet you’re real glad the rest of the team aren’t here, right?” you murmur, leaning down to ghost your lips along his jaw. “Because that means we can make as much noise as we like.”
You feel him suppress a shudder as you press a gentle, open-mouthed kiss to his skin. He tenses, but only briefly, as your hand moves into his hair, cradling the back of his head as you trail kisses up his jaw, and it doesn’t take much for him to melt. One hand settles instinctively on your hip, keeping you pressed against his erection, but the other tries, gently, to push you away.
“What’s wrong?” you murmur. “Can’t handle a bit of—”
As you raise your head to mock him, Spencer’s lips collide with yours. He kisses you with a kind of desperate hunger that sends a rush of heat straight to your core and, for a moment, you find yourself wanting to drop the act completely and let him have you—but where’s the fun in that?
So you pull away, pressing your thumb to his needy lips as you don a sarcastic pout. He releases your hip, and his hands roam your waist and stomach, working their way up to your chest. You can’t help but admire him even as he’s feeling you up; he already has that look in his eyes. Weakness. Soft and pretty in all the ways that drive you crazy.
Your throat tightens. Contracting around something terribly familiar and wholly unwanted. Something you’re bound to choke on if you sit with it for too long.
So you pull him into another, harsher kiss, letting a moan slip into his mouth as his thumbs graze your clothed nipples, and it’s a sound that he mirrors as you slowly start rocking your hips against his. His hands drop down to the hem of your shirt, and you pull back long enough to let him tear it off over your head before your lips are on his again.
You set your hands on the back of his neck, gluing the two of you together as you grind yourself against him. You feel the way his breath hitches with each roll of your hips, and you’re certain you could make him finish just like this, without needing to lift a finger, but that would be far too easy on him. It would be merciful, almost, and that isn’t what you’re here for.
Before you can start formulating your evil plan, Spencer pulls away. His lips latch onto your neck, peppering the skin with feverish kisses as he works his way down to your collarbones before dipping down, further, to your chest. Your fingers weave into his hair as his teeth graze a nipple, and you pull hard. Hard enough to make him moan as your mouth meets his and you catch him in another bruising kiss. His hips buck up into yours, shamelessly begging for more friction, but all it does is make you withhold it.
So, with impatient hands, he forces your hips down, rubbing your aching cunt against his cock through the layers of fabric separating them. You break the kiss with a sharp gasp as a violent heat twists in your core, and you push him away.
You watch the rise and fall of his chest as you catch your breath—it’s hypnotic, almost—before meeting his gaze with as calm a look as you can muster.
“I’m gonna go grab a towel,” you say, keeping your voice equal parts soft and firm. “When I come back, you better not have any clothes on. Got it?”
Spencer nods eagerly and without question. You lean back, admiring him for a moment longer before you finally dismount him and disappear into the bathroom.
You take more time than you should, deliberating between two identical motel towels as you listen to the faint rustle of clothes as Spencer strips himself of his pyjamas. You catch a glimpse of yourself in the mirror, shirtless, red-faced, and you feel that familiar pang of self-awareness in your stomach. The kind strong enough to re-awaken your voice of reason, and that voice tells you that this has got to stop.
How many more times are you going to fall into bed with him before this blows up in your face? Before you fall further into this grave you've dug for yourselves, and find yourselves utterly unable to climb back out?
Being the bigger person is a myth. It always has been. It's just a lie you tell yourself—the same one that he's probably been tellinghimself—to further stifle the latent realisation that you are, undoubtedly, just as bad as each other. You're no better than Spencer is, and he is no worse than you are.
You can tell yourself that you're the bigger person, that you're more mature, more sensible, but that doesn't erase the reality you're in. You're standing, half-naked, in a grotty motel bathroom waiting for your coworker to strip himself bare. You're terrible.
And you can’t imagine being anywhere else.
You return to the bedroom with all the confidence in the world and find Spencer sitting, naked, on the edge of the bed, caught somewhere in the space between nervous and excited. He’s wringing his hands, trying to avoid tending to his persistent erection as he awaits your return. Hugging the towel to your chest, you watch him for a moment and let your gaze wander shamelessly over his exposed skin, savouring his anticipatory silence. His still-wet hair sticks to his forehead. Dewy collarbones shine like gold in the dim, yellow-toned light.
You feel it again. A slight tightness in your throat. The beginnings of something awful. But it’s overpowered by the palpable rush of need that takes hold of you as you gaze at him. It’s enough to drive you mad.
Tossing the towel onto the bed, you slot yourself between his legs.
"You're awfully quiet," you tease, carefully brushing his hair out of his face as he looks up at you. You could drown in those eyes, if you let yourself.
His gaze hardens slightly. "Nothing to say."
"You always have something to say."
"False."
He's running his fingers along the waistband of your sweats, barely grazing your skin as his eyes trail across your body.
"True."
He shoots you a glare. "Do you want to keep arguing?"
"Not particularly," you murmur, smirking. Gently, you reach out a hand to touch his cheek. "I'm just surprised. You're being so good—"
Spencer swats your hand away instantly.
"Don't," he warns before returning his attention to your body.
You cross your arms. "You don't like praise?"
"I don't like being mocked," he corrects.
He presses his thumbs against your waist, watching with great interest the way the soft skin yields to his touch.
"Who said I was mocking you?" you ask, feigning innocence.
He scoffs. You feel it against your skin, hot, before he presses a kiss to your hip. "You're always mocking me."
"Not always."
It takes strength to keep your voice steady when he’s doing this; appreciating your body in silent ways whilst navigating a half-hearted argument, like it’s second nature to him. And it is second nature, you suppose. He could probably fight with you in his sleep.
He looks up at you again with this dull, almost bored kind of scepticism purposefully forged to hide something deeper. Something realer. Something that has a weight to it and is far too heavy for this. For you. He tugs gently at the drawstring of your sweats, and the knot comes apart with ease under his touch. The fabric sags, barely clinging to your hips, and all it takes is a gentle tug for them to slip down your legs, leaving you in just your underwear.
His lips meet your skin again, trailing kisses down from your navel to the embroidered elastic of your waistband. His gaze finds yours, just for a moment, in a fleeting request for permission that sends a fresh pang of heat to your core, right where his lips hover. You nod, wordlessly, and he makes quick work of removing your underwear, peeling the soaked fabric away from your needy cunt as you try not to clench your thighs.
He drops them at your ankles, and his kisses continue. Following their path down until his mouth is dangerously close to where you need him to be. Before he can get too carried away, you thread your fingers into his hair once more and pull him, gently, away.
The second those eyes are on your face, something violent turns within you. Your fingers still in his hair, caught between moments as you bury the urge to mount him right then and there. It's not like he would complain.
His thumbs brush over your hip bones, moving in perfect sync as he watches you quietly. Studying your micro expressions, probably, searching for a crack that he can exploit; a way to piss you off, turn the tables, put himself in control. But the more you look at him, the more you realise that this isn't what this is. He's just…waiting. Eagerly, sure, but patiently.
He's waiting for you to tell him what to do. He's read the situation, read what you want out of this, and he's moulded himself to it without question—without needing to be told. It's perceptive. Considerate, almost. How he's letting you have this; how he knows you well enough to know that you want this.
And that? That pisses you off.
"Sit back," you say, keeping your voice soft, "against the headboard."
He moves immediately, scooting into position without question. However brief, you feel weirdly cold in the absence of his touch.
Once he's comfortable, you join him on the bed. You settle, on your knees, between his legs, keeping your gaze on his face as hisgaze roams freely across your body. A compliment tries to crawl its way up your throat—an earnest one—because God, he looks perfect. But you clench your jaw, keeping your words at bay; compliments are for couples, and you aren't a couple.
But the words fight back. Compliments converge on your tongue, crowding your mouth, until you have no choice but to pull him into another kiss. Pouring all the things you daren't say into him, as though he may somehow understand without you needing to say any of it out loud. His hands come to rest on your jaw, not your body, and he cradles your face like it's something precious, pulling you closer and closer until you're practically on top of him, one hand braced against the headboard and the other trailing, slowly, down his body.
His breath hitches as your fingers grasp his cock. You feel it jolt in your hand, and one of Spencer's hands moves to the back of your head, hardly giving you room to breathe as he kisses you. The adrenaline, the sheer need with which he touches you, it's all starting to make you feel dizzy. He's stealing the oxygen from your lungs but, in return, you get to steal a stifled moan from between his lips. That's more or less an equivalent exchange, in your books; to have him at the mercy of your hands. To have that stupid mouth of his occupied with something that isn't just insult after senseless insult.
He shifts his hips with a soft groan, bucking up into your hand as you continue to tease him. And he groans again—louder, sounding more like a whine than anything else—when you refuse to change your pace.
What you do instead is pull away. You hover there for a moment, breathing into his open mouth as he tilts his head up, wanting more, and you bask in that delicious, desperate look in his eyes before sitting back. You continue working his cock, slowly, as you wipe the saliva from your mouth with the back of your hand. Spencer doesn't bother tending to his moistened lips; he just watches you, eyes wide like he's seeing you for the first time. Awestricken and gorgeous and—
That noxious dizziness lingers even as you catch your breath. It breaks down your thoughts, loosening the fibres until you're sure your brain is naught but mush. Held together by the low crackle of static that grows louder with each second you spend looking at him.
You realise far too late that you're looking at him the same way he's looking at you. Like a complete fucking idiot.
It's the kind of self-consciousness that hits like a freight train, flattening you before you even see it coming. It throws you off balance in the worst way and you feel vulnerable. exposed. More than you've ever felt in your previous encounters. You've been in far worse, far more vulnerable positions in the past—physically, at least. When you've been under him, or bent over a desk, or at his mercy on your knees.
You're in control here. And yet this is the first time you've felt truly vulnerable. Emotionally vulnerable.
So you do everything you can to counteract it, before it leaves you seriously compromised.
You release your grip on his cock, ignoring the way he whines in protest as you move to straddle his hips. His hands settle, firm, on your waist, moulding themselves to your curves as you kiss him again. Partly to shut him up before he says anything that'll further tangle the static-laced wires in your brain; mostly to shut yourself up before you say anything you know you'll regret. You'd rather choke on your own tongue—or his tongue—than let a single, adrenaline-driven, foolish word slip out before you have the chance to scour it for cracks, for any chance that it may contain feeling.
You grasp his chin, ensuring he’s looking directly at you as you pull back. Your other hand works its way down until it's grasping his cock, lining it up with your entrance.
"You're so pretty like this," you murmur, hot breath filling the minimal space between you as you lower yourself, just slightly, so his tip kisses your entrance, "you know that?"
You almost can't believe your own words—seriously, you had one job—but the look on Spencer's face kills any trace of regret you’d dare have. His breath stutters, you see it catch in his throat as he stares up at you with this wide-eyed expression. Surprised, yes, but voracious. Like you've flipped a switch he didn't know he had.
"I mean, you're always pretty. Too pretty. But this—"
A sharp hiss escapes you as you lower yourself onto his cock. The pain is familiar, not unbearable, but it's there. A stubborn reminder of the importance of foreplay when you're too tight and Spencer's dick is too damn big.
But you can take this kind of pain. When it's controlled, like this. When you can feel your body yielding to him and the pain steadily blooms into pleasure.
You feel him tense. He goes deathly still, muscles straining with the effort it takes not to thrust up into you as you sink, slowly, onto him—that would actually hurt and, worse, it would piss you off.
Carefully, you push through the resistance, letting gravity do most of the work as you continue speaking even as your breath comes in uneven gasps and your voice starts to shake. "When you're all quiet like this, when you aren't…being a fucking nuisance, I could just—"
His fingers anchor in the soft skin of your waist. He throws his head back, eyes shut tight as you take him to the hilt. The noise you make is somewhere between a guttural groan and a needy whine as he stretches you out, and you cup his face with both of your hands, keeping him close as you touch your forehead to his.
A weak, breathless "fuck…" is all he can manage as he exhales a shaky, barely held together sigh. You can feel the tension in his jaw under your palms. The electricity that thrums, wild, under his skin.
You give a tentative shift of your hips, testing the waters, and you feel him shudder beneath you. You pull back a little, enough to get a good look at his face; the tiny twitches of his brows, his eyes, as you move against him.
"That good?" you murmur, letting your hands trail down from his face to his chest, tracing the curves of his collarbones as you settle into a slow rhythm.
Spencer nods, humming in quiet approval as he closes his eyes. You watch the way his lashes flutter, the way the crease between his brows deepens with each rock of your hips, and you bite your lip.
"Say it."
"It—" He flexes his fingers, as though he's just remembered he has them, and his hands drop to your hips, encouraging your movements as he tries to keep his breathing steady. "It feels good," he whispers. "You feel…so good."
His words have you clenching around his cock, hard enough to elicit another soft, pretty little moan from his lips.
"That's it…" you whisper, tone sickly sweet as you lean down to press your lips to his neck.
Instinctively, Spencer leans his head to the side, allowing you access to the sensitive skin as those hands of his grow a little more confident and begin working their way back up to your chest. He cups your tits, and you feel him press his lips to your shoulder before murmuring, "there are condoms in my bag, if—"
You hum against his skin, shaking your head as you nip at his neck. "Don't need them."
"But—"
"I went on the pill," you admit. Quickly, but reluctantly. Like ripping off a band-aid. Like you’re confessing to something that runs far deeper than a simple birth control prescription.
Spencer's hands freeze mid-squeeze, and you know immediately that he's picked up on every implication you were hoping to brush over. "You— what? When?"
"After last time." you raise your head with a sigh and meet his gaze. When he tries to speak up again, you're quick to press your thumb to his lips. "Unless your next words are thank you, I don't wanna hear them."
For a moment, he looks as though he's about to protest. Five weighted words were all it took to pull him from the moment completely, it seems. His eyes are wide, frantically searching your own for something you can't let him find.
But then, instead of probing you with any more questions, he just nods. You can't be sure if this is him giving up, resigning himself to staying on his side of your emotional walls, or if he doesn't even need to try anymore—not when you've made it all so damn obvious. The optimist in you, wherever she may be, is hoping for the former; there'll be less fallout that way.
“So just keep that pretty mouth of yours shut,” you add, slowly re-introducing that thick, mocking tenderness to your voice as you raise your hips, “okay?”
He nods again. Sharper. Eager.
You know he'll find a way to bring this up later—in the middle of the night, probably, when the air feels too heavy and neither of you can sleep—the way he always manages to bring up the things you don't want to talk about. The touchy things. The things that are bound to spark an argument, because you're uptight and he's intrusive and you both loathe each other, and you can't get along unless your tongue is down his throat or his dick is inside you, and even then you still find yourselves bickering.
An impatient shift of his hips is all you need to know that, unlike you, a future argument is actually the last thing on his mind right now. His hands have started working again, mapping out your body like he doesn't already have it memorised as his gaze remains fixed on your face—and, really, you'd rather he be looking anywhere else.
You raise yourself until it's only the head of his cock that remains inside of you and then, after another agonising moment, you drop back down, swallowing his length in one quick, smooth motion. He gasps, you groan, and all thought of that hypothetical argument vanishes as he thrusts up into you, burying himself deeper as your walls pulse around his cock.
Curses tumble, unrestrained, from your lips as you move against him. His hands guide you into a steady rhythm—firm, but not forceful—and you tilt your head back slightly as the tension that has been stringing you together begins to dissipate.
Spencer takes advantage of the exposed skin immediately. He nips at your neck between messy kisses. His breath against your skin is enough to make you whine as you thread your fingers into his hair, and you raise his head just enough to bring your lips down on his, catching him in a disgustingly heated kiss. His hands stray from your hips to your ass, feeling you up with the kind of desperation that never fails to drive you insane as he moans shamelessly into your mouth.
The break in the kiss is abrupt, leaving Spencer nothing to drown his senseless whines in as you trail your lips along the edge of his jaw. You aren't sure what it is, maybe it's your breath on his skin, or the way your hand rests gently on his neck, pressing ever so slightly against his throat as you rock your hips, but something is bringing him closer to the edge. You can feel it in the way his breath catches, the way his hands begin to tremble, the way his sweet moans start to devolve into unsteady whimpers.
You kiss your way to his ear, nip at the lobe as his shoulders start to shake. "You close?"
He swallows hard. You feel it under your palm. "…mhm."
"Good. Now look at me— Reid, look at me."
You keep your voice impossibly soft as you work your fingers into his hair, tugging on the chestnut strands to keep his head up as he tries to hide his face.
He's already a mess. face red and glistening with a thin sheen of sweat, lips kiss-swollen and parted like he's waiting for you to dive into him again, but you don't. You make him hold your gaze, keeping one hand in his hair as the other cups his jaw, and you don't stop. Not until his face is contorting in those deliciously familiar ways and he has no choice but to close his eyes because he is so, so close.
And then you stop.
Your hips come to a brusque halt, stopping just as he is about to find release. You watch him blink, confused, before he meets your gaze with this adorably desperate expression. His chest heaves against your own, and you don your most charming smile.
"You didn't think it would be that easy, did you?"
The softness of your voice seems to fool him for a moment. Sugary words fail to register in his sex-clouded mind. You lean in a little closer, brushing your nose against his.
"You're not gonna come until I say you can."
That registers. His eyes widen, and he's shaking his head before he can even find the strength to speak. The words follow shortly after; a string of breathless nos that are about as useless as they are desperate. It's cute, how he thinks he might be able to talk you out of this—as though this hasn't been your plan from the start.
"I think it's only fair, after all the shit you've given me today," you continue, pouting as you brush your thumb against his cheek, "that you learn a little…respect, no?"
"You…" tension seeps into his jaw, and it isn't the pleasurable kind. His expression hardens, just slightly—probably as much as it can given the circumstances. "…are such a—"
"And that starts with being nice." You cut him off, still maintaining that smile as you look down at him. "If you start calling me names, Reid, then this is only gonna get a hell of a lot worse for you, and better for me. Understand?"
Spencer grits his teeth. His gaze flicks between your eyes and your lips, strays briefly to your body, to where his cock is still nestled inside of you, before returning to your face.
"Unless you want me to stop?" you pose, leaning back.
You don't give him enough time to respond before you're easing yourself off of his cock, but his hands find purchase on your hips and push you back down, burying himself inside of you once more with a force that makes both of you gasp.
"No." he says quickly. "N-no, don't…"
"Thought so." Smugness seeps into your voice before you can stop it, and you cock your head to the side. "So be good for me, and I'll let you finish."
Your mocking tone isn't well-received. Spencer huffs, flexing his trembling hands as he tries to act unbothered. "…I hate you—"
"Ah," you cut him off with a click of your tongue, shaking your head as you cradle his face. "Come on, honey, you're smarter than this."
Those words must be laced with something. A sedative, maybe. Something equal parts sweet and toxic. Because they quell Spencer's protests immediately. His throat runs dry. He tries to blink it away but it's no use; his mouth moves wordlessly, and he stares at you, dumbfounded, like you've cast a spell on him.
Honey. Who'd have thought that would be his weakness?
You aren't much of a pet names person yourself, but…if Spencer is into it, then you might be open to changing your mind.
…let's not think too hard about what that says about you. Like the birth control, it's one of those things that you're better off notlooking too deeply into—for your own sake.
"You good to keep going?"
He doesn't seem to hear you.
"Reid."
"Yes," he says, brain finally kicking back into gear as he gazes up at you.
"Good."
You reward him with another kiss, muffling the angelic noise he makes as you move your hips. Slowly, at first. Easing him back into it so he doesn't unravel immediately.
You fall into a dance, of sorts. A sick, somewhat cruel dance, but a thoroughly enjoyable one—for you, at least. You murmur praises in his ear, fanning hot breath over his skin as you fuck yourself on his cock, bringing him closer and closer to release until he's a babbling mess and you can feel him twitching and pulsing desperately inside of you, and then you stop. You deny him. You mock him. You let him catch his breath. And you continue.
You do this two more times, and with each instance of denial Spencer grows more frustrated. More overstimulated. More pathetic. He ruts into you, or tries to, but it’s sloppy. Too weak to make any difference. Futile, because he stops as soon as you tell him to.
By the time you even consider letting him finish, he's inconsolable and you're exhausted. But the ache in your legs is nothing; a small price to pay for having him like this. Trembling in your arms. Clinging to you for comfort even though you're the very cause of his suffering. It's terrible, really. You should be ashamed of yourself for getting off on this as much as you do; it's sick, but by God is it cathartic.
Maybe you're power-hungry. Maybe you're desperate for any semblance of control. So frustrated with your own lack of control that you've resorted to taking it out on him. It's nothing he doesn't deserve; it's his fault you feel so out of control. He stirred these stupid emotions within you; it's only right that he be the one to face the consequences—and it's not like he wouldn't benefit from being put in his place for once.
"I-I can't— I can't…"
"Yes, you can."
Spencer's face is buried in your neck, shaking his head desperately as he mumbles nonsense between dulcet whimpers. You keep your voice low as you stroke his hair, babying him in a way he'll probably kill you for later—but it'll be worth it.
His voice is thick, strained, sounding almost as though he's about to cry. And as you gently coax his head up, that's exactly what you see. Dark eyes glazed with tears. They sit heavy on his waterline. Unshed, but there.
You'd probably feel bad, if it weren't the most gorgeous thing you've ever seen.
"God." The word escapes you in a breathless sigh. Awe-struck. You cradle his face in your hands, rubbing soothing circles into his burning cheeks as you admire him. "Look at you. So pretty."
What you wouldn't give to snap a photo of him like this. You'd carry it around in your purse; a trump card that you could whip out every time he dared to get on your nerves.
He's still shaking his head. Words reduced to incoherent mumblings as you continue working his poor cock with your cunt. Your legs—thighs, knees, hips—are screaming at you in protest, they have been for a little while now, and your core is impossibly tight; you've been so focused on Spencer, on keeping him on the edge, that you've all but forgotten about chasing your own release. You'll be limping tomorrow, no doubt, and the team will mask their suspicion as concern when they ask if you're okay. You wonder if you'll be able to get away with telling them Spencer hit you with the car; it's not like he'll be able to argue otherwise.
You press your lips to the corner of his eye, kissing away a tear before it can escape down his cheek.
"You wanna come?"
The string of frantic, broken yesses that fall from his lips is enough to make your fucking head spin.
"Yeah?" You tilt your head, ghosting your lips over his as you continue the steady rock of your hips. "What do you say..?"
All you get in response is a choked whimper. One that sounds dangerously close to a sob. He's gripping your hips so hard you're sure he’ll leave bruises, ten of them, mapping where his fingers were anchored in your skin.
"Reid." You're beginning to falter yourself. Your voice is starting to shake as you near the end of your rope—and your patience. "Come on, honey, just—"
"I love you."
It takes you a moment—an eternity, it feels—to understand what was just said. Three words, uttered with such an undeniable clarity yet you're sure you've misheard him. You must have.
But he's burying his face in your neck, hips bucking wildly as he repeats those very words. Whispering them into your skin like a prayer. Over and over. I love you.
Shit.
Shitshitshit.
He was supposed to say please.
When your hips stutter, uncertain, he moves them for you, bringing you down onto his cock repeatedly as his whispers devolve once more into incoherent whimpers. It's enough to knock the thoughts right out of your head, and you're left with nothing but moans to choke on as you try to reorient yourself.
"That's— fuck, that's it…" you murmur, breathless, in his ear. "You can come…"
Spencer sobs—loud and raw and fucking intoxicating—into your neck, and you feel him break immediately. His self-control shatters and he finishes inside you, emptying himself into your needy cunt as you whine and writhe in his lap. But even when he's spent, he keeps going. His hips move mindlessly, feebly fucking his seed into you as he whimpers incessantly.
"Reid." His name comes out in a shaky whisper, in the space between breaths as your heart pounds and your head spins. You cradle the back of his head, holding him close as he trembles in your arms. "Reid, honey…that's enough…"
You hear him sniffle, and you hold him a little tighter, unsure of whether he's even heard you until his hips finally give up. He slumps forward, leaning his weight on you as he finally lets himself relax—lets himself breathe. You place a hand on his back as you allow yourself to do the same, and you melt into each other.
Your fingers trail, gently, up and down his back, tracing the curve of his spine as you rest your head on his shoulder. It's too tender of a gesture. Too kind. Too loving. You know that, but you do it anyway.
He needs this. Comfort. Reassurance. And you're ready to provide for as long as it takes for him to—
"…fuck you."
…come back around.
He mutters those words, quietly, into your skin. The same place he had whispered I love you just minutes ago.
Those juxtaposing sentiments react in your stomach, twisting your insides until you’re full of nothing but tense, aching knots. You bark out a weak, exasperated laugh. You have to laugh; God knows what you'd do if you didn't.
Spencer raises his head and meets your gaze, bleary-eyed and exhausted. And soft. Perfectly, painfully soft. And beautiful. He looks like you could love him.
It could be adrenaline. Heightened emotions. Embers of lust that reignite the second you lay eyes on him. Whatever it is, it has you kissing him again. Pulling him in with such urgency you almost miss his lips entirely. Some deranged part of you wants to hear him say it again. And again. And again. Until it's the only thing he knows how to say. The only thing you know how to hear.
Finally relinquishing his grip on your hips, Spencer's hands move to your face without thought, and he kisses you with everything he has. When you try to pull back, he whines. Pulls you in closer. Refuses to let you go even for a moment. You have to reach out blindly in search of the towel. You feel around behind you, leaning back as far as he'll allow you to until, at last, your fingers graze the soft fabric.
And then you feel yourself falling.
You topple over, pulling Spencer down with you as your back hits the mattress. He groans against your lips and pulls away to find you still reaching for that damn towel. He grabs it for you and, before you can get a word in, kisses you again. You raise your hips, hoping he still has enough brains to understand what you're asking of him, and he positions the towel underneath you.
Pulling out feels like a dam breaking. Punctuated with a wet pop and followed by a gush of something warm. He whines, you shudder, and you don't stop kissing each other until you forget how to breathe. When his lips finally leave yours, his breathing comes ragged. He sits back, kneeling between your burning thighs, and takes in the sight of you with this dazed, almost drunken look that has you throbbing despite your exhaustion. His gaze trails down your body until it settles on the mess between your legs.
"…Reid—"
By the time you're able to find your words, his face is already level with your cunt. He spreads your folds and watches, transfixed, the way it leaks out of you. He licks up your slit, gathering his own release on his tongue, before diving into you. You're so caught off guard you don't think to try and stifle the outrageous moan that tears through you, and you promptly clamp a hand over your mouth as your head falls back.
No amount of oh Gods and expletives can account for the expertise with which Spencer Reid uses his tongue. If he isn't fucking you with it, he's circling your clit with it, teasing and sucking on the overstimulated nub until you're writhing so much, he has to pin your hips down with one hand and finger you with the other.
You're seeing stars before you know it, hurtling towards an orgasm so fast you can barely form a coherent thought before you're there. And you think, for a fleeting moment, that he may keep you there. That is his revenge. And you have never been gladder to have Spencer prove you wrong. Your back arches off the mattress, and you're moaning things that you can't make out through the haze of an aggressive orgasm. It could be his name, a prayer, a curse, or something worse—you don't know.
Your fingers are numb. Your toes, too. They tingle with a static that persists even as your orgasm subsides. You feel Spencer shift. Feel the weight of his head as it rests against your hip. The heat of his breath against your skin.
For a moment, it all goes quiet. Thoughts give way to white noise. Feelings evaporate into a gas that cannot be weighed down by labels.
But peace only lasts as long as it takes for the fog to clear. You return to your sweaty, exhausted body just in time to be swept off your feet by a tsunami of feelings. Anxieties. Emotions that shouldn't exist.
You aren't sure when Spencer and you drifted from the shallow end to the deep end. You aren't sure when things changed. When you crossed that line and cast aside your life jacket when you know you don't know how to swim.
The only thing you're sure of now is that you're drowning. And the only thing keeping you from sinking entirely is the fact that Spencer hasn't noticed yet.
You nudge him with your foot, navigating your way around the lump in your throat to grumble "needthebathroom", or something vaguely along those lines. Spencer rolls off of you, mumbling something equally incoherent—or maybe you just don't care to hear it—as he rubs his eyes.
It hurts to move, but you do it anyway. You sit up, trying not to wince as your entire lower half screams in protest, and drag yourself to the edge of the bed. Spencer asks if you're okay, you think, and you give him a vague hum in response.
Your trembling legs barely manage to carry you to the bathroom, where you collapse with your back to the door and breathe out a long, shuddering sigh. You'd probably scream if you thought he wouldn't hear you.
I love you.
Immediately, you're dismissing those words. Waving them away like an unwelcome guest. You tell yourself he doesn't mean it. That he can't have meant it, he just…he just…
He wasn't thinking straight. He wasn't thinking at all. Hell, he probably won't even remember it. It's insignificant. Unimportant.
That’s what you tell yourself, at least. And you really, really hope you’re right.
And if you aren’t...then this might just kill you.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Summary: You're lost, adrift in your own mind. dreams that leave you haunted by the echoes of screams and visions of a family with faces too blurry to recognize. every night, in the midst of it all you see a man. dangerous, silent, and masked as he ushers you into the cold. twenty years spent in the dark, no memories, no identity, just your name and a whisper that someone's waiting for you in paris. a rumor of missing bones, a dna test, and a superhero's promise brings you closer to home than ever before. amnesia is a funny thing though, if bucky insists you've never met then why do his eyes feel so familiar?
Word Count: 8k
PSA (Pink Service Announcement): I was supposed to post this in December! Anyway, this is my contribution to the BWA Fairytale Collab! What a joy this collab has been, thank you bearing with me in the time it took to get here!!!
Warnings: Warnings: amnesia, mentions of death, canon-typical violence, blood, guns, references to a fire, reader is royalty but no specific country or physical attributes are given to her, flashbacks, cursing, gratuitous use of italics, only one bed, unprotected p in v, vaginal fingering,
DT: So many of my lovely friends pitched in to help me get this across the finish line and I couldn’t be more grateful. @superbassbuck @tw1sters for beta-reading!!! I owe you the world and more, seriously. Paul you were like the biggest cheerleader ever for this fic and I couldn't be more grateful. @artficlly for helping me with the action scenes, this fic wouldn’t be half of what it is without your help and wise words… also for coming up with the rest of plot we would have been trapped in the train if it weren’t for you
The first thing you remember is snow.
Crunching under your steps, too thick to see through.
You're running and you have no idea why.
You can hear gunfire in the distance, chaotic and never ending. A fire rages above the trees, reaching high enough to kiss the stars and bathe the night in it's glow.
You run until you can't feel your toes, until your calves ache and even then you keep pushing. You don't stop until your foot catches on a tree root, launching you head first into a pile of snow where a jagged rock waits to kiss your forehead.
You wake with a start, gasping as you blink the dream from your eyes, chest pulled tight with panic.
The train rumbles below, vibrating softly through the cushion of your makeshift bed.
Even though you just woke up, you feel it, hovering in the room and making it impossible to breathe.
The tension between the two you of is suffocating.
Sandwiched into a single compartment, you've each claimed a bench, Bucky the right wall and you the left. With barely a three foot gap of floor between you, it somehow feels more intimate than sharing a bed.
You're lying with your back flat against the seat, legs curled up to make yourself fit. It's cramped and uncomfortable, every bump a fight not to spill over.
Bucky fills out the other bench, clearly just as uncomfortable. His long body is overflowing off the sides of his cushions. One leg hangs down, resting flat footed on the floor while the other is bent against the wall, anchoring itself there as if to offset the sway of the train. His shoulder hangs over too, metal fingers teasing the floor as they dangle over the edge.
The space between you feels like a canyon. Narrow yet deep and intimidating. It's covered with carpeting that's probably older than you are, dense and stained from years of travelers and luggage.
"Nightmare?" Bucky's voice breaks the silence, pulling you the rest of the way out of sleep.
He keeps his gaze on the ceiling, the only reason you know his eyes are even open are his lashes. the shadow they cast across his cheek as he blinks.
"Yes." You admit, voice hardly above a whisper.
"Every night?" He asks. You hear his arm whir across the space, shifting as he lifts it to rest under his head.
"For as long as I can remember." You tell him. It's the truth, every time your eyes close it's like you're there. Running through the woods or a never ending hallway. Or on the really bad nights, staring down the barrel of a gun.
"I get them too." Bucky confides. He doesn't sound embarrassed, although you guess you're far past that.
You can't help but turn, your body moving on its own accord to face him.
"Are they always about the same thing?" You ask.
He shakes his head, turning his neck to meet your gaze. "Yours?"
"Kinda. Same night- different parts." You explain, "At least I think it's all the same night."
"The attack?" Bucky guesses.
You nod, "Maybe." You wish you were sure, that you could be certain that what little is left of your mind doesn't lie.
"Do you wanna talk about it?" He asks. He turns his body this time making you face to face, eye to eye.
His almost glow in the dark, you noticed it last night too. When you'd hardly slept in a shitty hostel, generous with it's communal shower and two twin beds in single room.
The journey has more or less, sucked.
Since the results, you've been on the receiving end more threats than you can count. Too many detailed, threats to travel alone, never mind travel by plane.
All of it has made for a slow crawl to Paris. In an effort to keep a low profile, your journey has been limited to traveling by car, passenger train, and your least favorite, foot.
You don't mind, grungy rooms and winding roads aside, the company hasn't been half bad.
Sent over by the 'New Avengers' in a half-assed attempt at PR, Bucky Barnes has been an okay companion.
He's quiet, but so are you.
"Do you know they found me in the woods?" You answer, side stepping his question. "In the middle of a blizzard."
Bucky lets you escape, merciful and understanding. Something you've grown to learn about him.
"I fell off a train in one." He offers.
"Okay you win." You joke.
It's a little game you started. Somewhere between Vienna and Munich your conversations shifted. From small talk and one word answers to stories.
One of you offering a piece of your past in exchange for one of the other's memories.
"Do you know I was drafted into World War Two?"
"I was raised by nuns."
"Okay yeah, you got me."
Whoever was worse off wins.
Morbid, twisted, the kind of jokes only amnesiacs get.
Bucky hasn't told you much about the fracturing of his mind. You know enough between news stands and sensationalized headlines. If those didn't give it away then the stares he gets would.
But you do know about his cat, white, fat and absolutely spoiled.
You know about how he refurbished his motorcycle himself.
How his prosthetic, is fitted with a safeguard in-case he needs to be disarmed- literally.
You know he absolutely hates the Val lady who signed him up for this job- 'No offense.' He'd added after the admission. 'I just try to avoid Europe.'
You know you're both haunted by cold, an aching chill set deep in your bones. His comes late at night, usually with the dreams and the creaks in his scar tissue. Yours burns brightest in crowds, pulls tight in your chest whenever you dare to let someone close.
You blink at each other across the divide, sharing the comfortable silence.
His eyes are still glowing, as if lit by moonlight.
They go right through you, chilling your body to the bone and pulling tight on your lungs.
So familiar.
They're haunting you more than any dream, constantly nagging at the back of your mind.
How the hell do I know him?
Bucky doesn't know, you've tried to pry it out of him.
"My mind is just as scrambled as yours." He promised, "But I don't think I'd forget your face."
Still, you can't shake it.
Tonight thought, under the shield of darkness you admit something else that's been bothering you about his eyes.
"It's otherworldly." You tell him. "Just how blue they are."
Bucky's brows pull together, "What?" He asks.
"Your eyes."
Bucky stills. He doesn't answer, doesn't move.
So you keep going.
"They're so expressive." You explain, "Like you're feeling a thousand things at once and all of it is in your eyes." You sit up, accepting that sleep is a lost. You turn to face him, stretching your legs into the space between your bodies.
Bucky follows your movements his legs laying out beside yours. Close enough for your knees to bump as the train sways, far enough to hide your nervous fingers in the shadows.
"I got them from my Ma." He says, simple and cutting. It's the only answer you guess.
You wonder what you got from your mother.
Is she the faceless shape holding your hand as you run? Is she the one ushering you through a cellar door and telling you not to look back? Do you have her eyes, or just her blood on your hands?
"I've never seen anything like them." You admit, soft and unflinching.
You think Bucky's going to leave it at that, turn onto his side and pretend to sleep. Let you stew in vulnerability until another nightmare claims you. Except Bucky never does what you think he will, at least that's what you're learning.
"I've never seen anything like you." He counters.
You laugh, a broken huff of air punched out of your lungs. "You don't have to say that Bucky-" You try to reason, three different excuses of why he doesn't need to be kind on the tip of your tongue.
"It's true." He says, cutting you off. His gaze doesn't falter again, one slow blink but it doesn't cut the weight of his focus.
You break, turning over onto your back. You find a spot on the ceiling, a stain from water damage. It's not particularly fascinating but it doesn't stare like it can see right through you.
You don't answer, fingers twisting together as you bring them to lay on your stomach. The silence hangs between you like a pendulum, swinging back and forth with the rhythm of the train car.
Then a crash down the hall, the shriek of breaking glass followed by a scream.
Before you can even turn your head toward it the train is skidding to an abrupt stop, brakes groaning with tension as the entire thing screeches to a halt.
The force of it throws you forward, headfirst off your bench and into Bucky’s chest.
His instincts kick in before yours can. With no hesitation, his arms lock around your waist, holding you upright and helping steady your balance.
Another scream echos down the hall and Bucky's grip tightens.
His breath tickles your temple as he mutters a firm command, and his tone leaving no room for argument. “We have to go.”
Despite his urgency Bucky waits for you to respond. His hands burn around your waist, between his touch and your nerves all you can muster is a speechless, panicked nod.
Then he's snapping into action, pulling your bags from where they had been neatly stashed below the benches. You watch as as he swings each one over his broad shoulders with a determined huff, head snapping back and forth as he checks the corridor.
You want to help but it's as if your feet are glued to the center of the compartment, fear materializing like concrete blocks around your ankles. That familiar sinking dread, it's frigid tides rushing higher and higher until it begins to lap at your throat—
It’s Bucky’s grip on your wrist that snaps you from the spiral. There’s a gun in his hand that you didn’t even notice him pull out. You’re not sure if the sight of it makes you feel better or worse.
All you know is that the sight of his finger rested over the trigger is enough to make your blood run cold.
“Go,” he insists, pushing you in the direction away from the crash. “I’m right behind you.”
You can't tell if the screams you hear are actually from the train or your own fractured memories seeping through. The panic, the forced calm, the tightness in your chest. It's all the same.
"Walk." Bucky instructs from behind you, "Too loud to run."
You settle for a speed-walk, frantically whipping your head around to check over your shoulder. All the while panic claws up your throat until your breathing is reduced to ragged pants, the coppery taste of anxiety on your tongue.
The only thing keeping you tethered to reality is Bucky trailing a few feet behind. His back is turned to you, gun raised in the direction of the chaos.
You feel like your ears are bleeding, body getting hotter with every passing step. Panic creeps up your neck like a rash, itchy and claustrophobic. Fear bites at your heels, making you pick up the pace.
You’re getting close now, only twenty or so more feet away from the end—
Everything explodes.
Boots, at least three heavy pairs fill the car from the other end. You can tell from sound alone that they’re running, mad steps and long strides that make the ground shake.
Gunfire booms.
As shots crackle through the tight space, you can’t even tell if it’s coming from Bucky or your pursuers.
A window next to you shatters, glass exploding over your head as a bullet passes through the lights above you—
Your ears are ringing, too loud to think, to breathe. As bullets rain down, sparks flying, you can’t make sense of anything.
All you can do is run.
An uncoordinated sprint to the door, shoulders slamming into compartment doors as you fight your way to the end.
Your whole body is trembling by the time you reach the door, tears prickling your eyes. You slam into the surface, elbows buckling as you sway on unsteady feet, delirious from terror pumping through your veins, numb from adrenaline.
You twist the knob, frantic only to find it's locked.
You try again anyway, twisting hard until the metal bites into your palm- “Bucky!” You scream, before you can think better of it.
As you turn to search for him, you find by some miracle that he has already caught up to you. His shoulders are squared, legs spread wide, as if attempting to block your line of sight down the corridor.
You find the carnage anyway, fear blown pupils looking past him and locking onto the pile of men lying in the direction you just came from. Their eyes are vacant, expressions gaunt and twisted, blood already staining the floors beneath. It’s only then you realize the shots you’re still hearing are further away, echoing through the other cars.
It’s Bucky’s fingers that finally pull your gaze away, his thumb and pointer finger redirecting your chin so your eyes focus on him instead. A silent order, don’t look.
“Cover your ears.” he instructs gruffly.
You obey both commands.
Bucky gives the door a quick once-over before raising his gun to shoot the lock. It pops off like plastic, hitting the ground with a dull thud.
As if sensing the panic still bubbling beneath the surface, he gives you a reassuring nod. All you can do is watch in horror as he levels his shoulders and then uses his right side to slam into the door.
The door gives way easily, flying off its hinges into the dark.
You peep out through the gap it left with a nervous swallow, bitter air biting your cheeks as you lean out to try and see.
It’s pitch black, too dark to see more than a few feet in front of you, even if you could, you're deep enough in the forest that the only thing for miles in either direction are trees.
Bucky jumps down first, easily three feet onto the track.
Bucky turns around, holding his arms out to and you know there's only one thing you can do.
Jump.
A chill washes over you, threatening to knock you over where you stand in the door way. The frost nips at your skin, cold, cruel, and gut-wrenchingly familiar. As if to twist the knife-
It's snowing.
Undeterred, Bucky takes a step closer.
Whatever fate awaits you out there, you say a silent prayer that its kinder than the barrel of a gun.
You step into Bucky's hands, letting him take the brunt of the impact as you bend your knees and abandon the shelter of the train.
Bucky holds your hips for a moment longer than necessary, giving them a gentle squeeze before letting go.
"Walk in my foot steps." He tells you, voice just loud enough for you to hear over the wind. He's already digging for something in one of the bags, arm bent back to shove his hand through its the zipper.
You're too busy trying to remember how to breathe to make sense of what it is. A small black rectangle. A burner? A radio? You can barely make out his silhouette through the snow, can barely feel your own nose.
You're practically dizzy with deja-vu. The adrenaline, the cold, the panic.
The blood.
A twisted encore.
You shake it away, forcing yourself to focus on matching Bucky's stride instead.
Right. Left.
Right. Left
Inhale. Exhale.
Inhale. Exhale.
Dead. Dead. Dead.
The further you get from the train the higher your panic climbs. Even as the glow of its lights fade out of view, swallowed by distance and snow, your chest pulls tighter and tighter.
Your body moves on auto-pilot following Bucky's steps and staying just close enough to keep him in your line of sight, vision blurring as you fight to stay where you are. You pants turn into heaves, lungs waging war against the pull of your fear.
The memory stitches itself together, beginning to play every time you dare to blink.
The fire, its heat catching your skin as you sprint through the maze of hallways.
You try to shake it away just to hear more gunshots, the ones from the train. How the tight space amplifies every pop and bang.
You shut your eyes and instead of disappearing the two scenes marry themselves together.
The same rapid fire, the screams of men as they watch bullets enter their bodies. The guards. You can see them. behind every tree you pass, in Bucky's hulking silhouette. They way they crumbled, landing on top of each other as they fell.
The clack of a silencer as it eats the gunfire of your assailants.
That's new.
You can see a shadow every time you turn around, casting itself on the walls as it threatens to turn the corner and find you. Every time you try to shove it away and focus on Bucky's figure ahead it just gets stronger, pulling black spots to the edge of your vision.
You can feel the snow on your knees when your legs give out, melting through the material of your pants and sending it's chill directly to your bones.
You can hear a shout of your name, the shifting of fresh powder as feet rush back to you.
Then it all goes black.
Your dress is heavy.
Something formal. fine fabrics tailored to exact measurements. Layers of velvet and tulle tangling around your calves as you try run. It slows you down, like wading through water.
You mother's palm is sweaty, her grip iron clad as she pulls you through door after door and down corridor after corridor.
You can almost remember her voice, a sing-song tone as she teasingly asks your father- "What on earth are we supposed to do with this much space? You could get lost here."
You think that's exactly what she was trying to do.
Screams have a way of echoing in castles like this.
A cacophony of terror that bounces off of every wall and every time you try to look back towards it she tugs on you harder. Every guard you pass pushes you ahead, stepping together and forming a wall between you and your pursuers.
You hardly get fifty feet away from them when their gunfire starts, only for it to quiet just as quickly.
Down a flight of stairs, moving fast enough to lose both your shoes as they catch on the steps. Then a second flight, dropping at the in the corridor of the staffs' quarters.
You mother doesn't slow. She doesn't falter. She keeps going, taking you with her and around one last corner when a door slams.
With only a hundred feet to the door, she stops.
She turns to you, taking your other hand and in hers and crouching down to your height.
Her face is covered in warmth, a soft, sad smile playing on her lips as she presses her forehead to yours.
"You need to be brave for me, okay?" She tells you, tears starting to gather at her waterline. You nod, confusion swelling as you watch the first drop spill down her cheek.
"You're going to go out that door." She instructs, "And no matter what you hear you can't stop running."
Her eyes are clear, set with a love only mothers can feel and a fear only known by dying women.
You must answer, say something that makes her shake her head.
"No honey," she cradles your head, smoothing your hair as she speaks. "You have to do this alone."
She stands back to her full height, her tears are steady now, falling one after another.
"I love you so much, please remember that."
She bends, just enough to press press her lips to your forehead. You can feel them move as she whispers: "Now go."
Just as she starts to stand, another shot -the closest one yet- goes off.
You jolt awake just as her body hits the ground.
A sharp inhale punches your lungs as you open your eyes..
Slowly, between loud heartbeats and careful exhales, the world comes back into focus. A blanket over you, thread worn and tired but cozy in the way all well-loved objects are. A bed beneath you, thin enough that you're not even sure it can be considered a mattress,
Bucky's lips against your forehead, exactly where your mother's phantom kiss still lingers.
His hand is on the blanket, fingers wrapped around its fraying edge as he pulls it over you.
It's like you're interrupting something, a quiet ritual you didn't even know existed. Bucky's careful movements as he steps away.
With sleep still clogging your eyes he must not notice that they were open, turning his back to you and walking towards another part of the small cabin.
The rest of it reveals itself, a small fireplace where a steady flame warms the room. A dust covered bookshelf and the barest necessities of a kitchen. Your bags are set by the door, ready for a quick exit. On the floor sits a flat pillow and a blanket even more tired than yours.
You don't hesitate.
"You're not sleeping on the floor."
Your voice is still groggy, rough from sleep and screams.
Bucky doesn't startle, doesn't turn to face you.
So he did know you were awake.
"I'm fine." He promises, voice not unkind, just tired.
"You haven't slept in two days." You say, as if he needs the reminder.
"You need the sleep more." He argues, finally relenting and turning back to you. He takes the few short steps back towards the bed, standing at the side of it once more. Close enough that the light from the fire casts his shadow over you. "No arguments."
You sigh, sitting up and scooting yourself over to the far side of the bed. With a lazy hand you pat the newly created space next to you. "See? Plenty of room."
It's really not, only a few feet, hardly enough space for Bucky to lay down with his shoulders pressing into yours.
So you turn onto your side, laying with your back to him. As if you're completely unbothered by the concept of being so close. As if the feeling of the bed bowing with his weight doesn't make your heart stutter.
Your nervous system has already been through so much today, so what the hell, sure.
The lamp on the end table is flicked off, plunging you into near darkness once more.
Its minutes before speaks, voice low as he whispers, "You okay?"
You want to laugh. Are you? You don't know what okay feels like anymore.
Instead you turn, a slow shift onto to your other side until you're facing him.
Bucky is flat on his back, blue eyes trained at the ceiling, shoulders rigid as steel.
The tension you felt on the train creeps back in, rising up your legs like goosebumps and settling in the cavern of your chest. You're almost in the same positions too, only this time there is none of the distance that kept you safe earlier.
Bucky turns his cheek to the pillow, finally meeting your gaze as he waits for your response.
"Yes." You whisper. "Thanks to you."
You'd stopped trying to thank Bucky for saving life half-way through your first day together. When he'd explained his mission, his purpose, and told you that at the end of the day this was just him doing his job.
What happened on the train felt different though. Protection is one thing. The look in his eyes when he put his body between yours a bullet is another.
Bucky shakes his head,and instead of his usual nonchalance, he slices through your soul with something else entirely.
"I'd do it again." He says, turning onto his side to match you.
The movement leaves hardly a foot of space between you.
His words hang in the air, heavy and charged. The last part is unsaid, but implied when for just moment a his eyes dare to glace at you lips.
I'd do it again, for you.
It makes your nerves sing, skin turning warm. For the first time in years you don't feel that ever present chill.
You dare too, blinking down to his lips, close enough to see their chapped curve and his tempting cupid's bow.
When you find his eyes again he's still staring. Glinting at you as if you hold his future in your palm, dangling it just out reach. They're heartbroken in the next blink, as if you've already taken it all away.
You wonder how you look to him.
Unmoored? Leveling out like a ship that's finally docked. Desperate? Clinging to any sense of safety you can get your hands on. Broken? Can be see the fractures that splinter your soul beyond memory?
Of course he can.
And that should scare the shit out of you.
What scares you more is that it doesn't.
You're not sure who reaches across the divide, what body caves first but you finally meet in the middle. Lips pressed to lips, heads resting on one shared pillow. Hands fighting through layers of blanket to finally reach out and touch.
Yours his neck and shoulders, one hand under his jaw the other where metal meets flesh. Bucky's find your hips, large palms encasing them and then using his new found grip to pull you against him, not stopping until a hearts meet.
Bucky's arms curl around your back, holding you to him as if you could disappear if he doesn't hold you tight enough.
It feels safe and secure, serenity settling over you like a blanket.
The kiss is… different than you would have ever pictured.
Bucky kisses like it's repentance.
Plush lips that press against yours with the hunger of a man begging for forgiveness. You don't doubt that if you asked, he would get on his knees. Reeking of earnestness in the way he tilts his head, nudging his nose against yours to press even deeper.
It's clumsy in a way, teeth clicking together when you try to deepen it. Your grip on him tightens, fingers digging in when Bucky laves his tongue inside your mouth, entire body tingling with delight when he hums at your taste.
Your legs tangle themselves with his, one meaty thigh slotting itself between your own and then pressing up.
The gasp you let out is a quiet thing, breathed against his mouth in half-shock and half-pleasure.
He does it again, firmer this time. Knee pressing against your cunt with purpose, a clear goal as he rocks it against you. You can't help the whimper, hips wiggling against him in an attempt to get even more friction. It makes Bucky's chest vibrate, his lips press against yours just a little harder.
The room spins until your back presses into the mattress, Bucky rolling onto of you and resting his weight on his forearms beside your head. He pulls back with a ragged breath and blown pupils, plush lips blushing red where your teeth snagged them.
He looks wrecked, like your kiss blew a hole through his chest.
He looks like he wants you to do it again.
The conversation is silent. A soft nod, guided hands, the sound of buttons coming undone and sleeves pushed down arms. Your shirt is lifted over your head with Bucky's help, pants slid down your legs and tossed onto the floor.
Your bra and panties join in shortly after.
You pull Bucky's shirt up, deliberately dragging your nails over the sensitive skin of his chest as you do so. Watching with pleasure as the carved muscles in his torso dance.
He deals with his own pants, belt unbuckled with one hand and tugged through the loops in one swift movement. Until finally all that's left is bare skin.
It's almost comical you think, how quickly You've gone from end of the spectrum to the other. From jumping at the slightest touch to willingly laying yourself bare to him.
Bucky's gaze lingers when he's done, dragging slowly up your body.
He follows the lines of your hips, the gentle swell of your ribcage and the way it charts a path to the underside of your breasts.
It makes you squirm.
"Been a-" you clear your throat, mouth suddenly dry. "-awhile." You gesture down your body as you say it, as if warning him.
Bucky scoffs, obviously offended by your implication, as if he could find something wrong with the flesh you've offered him.
He flattens himself over you, lowering his body until his chest presses tight to yours and you can feel his length against the inside of your thigh. Hot, aching, and already weeping just from a few kisses.
"Me too." He promises, sealing it with another press of his lips to yours.
It makes you preen up into him, a delighted hum echoing through your throat as you arch into his touch.
Your shelter under the covers heats up quickly, the air trapped beneath it turning muggy. It threatens to cackle with electricity, a charge passed back and forth with every kiss.
Your hands appreciate his bare chest, roaming over his pecs and across the expanse of his ribs. You drift further down to the lower curve of his abdomen, thumb rolling down to play with the trickle of hair beneath his belly button.
It send a shiver up his spine, a stuttered breath exhaled against your lips as his hips jerk.
"Sensitive." You whisper, carding your hand through his hair instead, a small act of mercy.
Bucky huffs a laugh.
His own hands start their own exploration, one sliding underneath you back while the other reaches between your thighs. Fingertips meet slick heat, coating themselves with wetness as he takes an experimental pass through your folds.
You cant your hips toward his hand. Body instinctively reaching for more of his touch.
Bucky obliges, deft fingers drawing through again.
"Eager." He counters, a boyish smirk painting his face a red shade of smug.
A whimper escapes, small, pathetic and entirely too honest. You can't find it in your self to care, too busy chasing the electric pleasure that comes with every nonchalant pass through your folds.
Bucky either reads your mind, or takes pity on your worked up cunt, because finally he finds your clit.
Or more accurately, finally aims for it.
With deadly precision, he pushes the hood up and then flattens the pad of his thumb against it with deadly precision.
An embarrassing amount of slick floods your cunt. Your body reacting two fold to his ministrations. It drips down to your inner thighs, shining between them like a secret. Then it goes even further, pooling beneath you in the sheets and leaving an ugly wet spot.
Bucky's breath catches at the sight, his thumb still working your clit with slow circles as he takes in your ruin.
"God," he sighs, kneeling back onto his haunches. The movement places him squarely between your legs. Before you can even think to be embarrassed, his free hand grabs one of your legs and pushes it aside, giving himself a better view.
"When was the last time someone took care of you?" He asks, breathless.
You turn your head into the pillow, too embarrassed to speak. The words hit harder than just sex. They reveal more than just desire. Because in truth, you can't remember the last time someone took care of you. Period. When someone made you feel safe, never-mind made you feel wanted. The emotion catches in your throat, welling into a lump and leaving you with no recourse.
"Been a while." You echo, voice thin enough to break.
The dull ends of Bucky's fingertips press at your entrance. Two, his index and ring finger.
He pulls his hand away from your thigh, leaning back over you and grabbing your chin with his hand forcing you to look at him.
"Gonna let me?" He asks. His movement on your clit never wavers, letting the sensation cool from sharp and inspected unexpected to a gentle thrumming beneath your skin.
You wonder if he means just your body.
You hope he means more.
You nod, fervent and desperate to find out .
Bucky's fingers push inside you without much resistance, your body immediately clamping down as if to keep them.
He sucks in a sharp breath, blinking in disbelief as he watches your cunt swallow his fingers.
"So tight." He whispers, nearly awed. "Fuckin' perfect."
Your body preens from the praise, cunt squeezing down on him in delight.
Bucky smirk widens, bordering on a full smile. He crooks his fingers, as if testing your reaction to that too.
It sends a shock up your back, his index dragging over a spot inside you that you didn't even know existed. Its earth shattering.
"Bucky!" You gasp, hand flying to his hair as you desperately reach for anything that can ground you. "Need you," You pant, pushing your hips onto his hand, trying to take him even deeper. "Please."
A moan falls from his pretty lips, wrecked and deep. It makes your gut twist.
"You sure?" Bucky asks again anyway, despite the fact that he's currently wrist deep in your slick.
You could cry, body wrought with want so bad it nearly hurts.
"Please." You whine, tilting your chin up just enough to place a mean kiss on his lips. More teeth and tongue than anything else. You nip at his bottom lip, hard enough to have him groaning into your mouth.
Bucky pulls his fingers out, not bothering to wipe them off when he uses the same hand to grab your chin. His grip isn't mean, but tight enough to keep you in place. Forcing you to hold eye contact as he uses his free hand to notch the head of his cock at your entrance.
Then, just as he starts to ease himself in, he kisses you. The roughest he's dared, lips claiming over yours as he uses his own mouth to pry your open. It lets him swallow every noise that escapes as he works himself inside you. Inch by inch he inhales every moan, whimper, and gasp like its oxygen.
In return he feeds you his, exhaling back choked grunts and pleasured sighs. Even as he bottoms out you stay connected, mouths parted against each other as you share the same lungfuls of air.
You're so full, cunt spasming around his cock as you stretch to take him. Its the deepest anyone's ever dared to reach, the hottest your body has ever managed to feel. From the inside out Bucky burns away your ice.
Slowly, your bodies start to make their own rhythm, your hips pulling up, nearly trying to escape just for Bucky's to chase them, angling until he's hitting even deeper than before.
Methodical rolls of your bodies hardly dramatic enough to be considered thrusts and yet here you are, whimpering every time Bucky pulls close enough to press his pelvis to yours.
Eventually lips part, the torture too much to bear. They become a press of foreheads instead, Bucky's forearms coming over to rest beside your head as he finally gives into his baser instincts.
A slow pull, dragging his cock out to the tip. Tortuous enough to let you feel every vein and curve that decorates it. He holds there, gasping as you clench around nothing but his head.
The push back in however, lacks the same self-control. A quick push until he's bottomed out one more, punching the air out of you with a well aimed thrust just over your g-spot.
You writhe, pushing your chest up into Bucky's as your hands reach around to his back, nails digging in just to drag down when he starts to pull out again. Despite your better judgment you know they're hard enough that he'll be decorated with scratches in the morning.
It only spurs him on, another thrust just like it, followed by another, until all you can hear is your own heartbeat and the slapping of skin on skin.
You're so close, driven closer to the edge but also to delirium. It's as if you're floating, leaving your body behind on the sheets as Bucky takes you apart piece by piece.
If you were any more coherent you would see he isn't much better off.
Frantic whispers against your skin, incomprehensible to your pleasure-drunk mind.
"God so good." He pants, one hand finally reaching back for your clit, two fingers fumbling until he finally manages to find it again. "So perfect." muttered when you drag your nails down his back again.
"Can't-" He gasps, hips stuttering as you start to break around him. "Don't deserve this." Right before one last messy kiss.
"I'm sorry," nearly sobbed as you finally cum.
"I'm so fucking sorry." When he does.
You come back to earth unaware of it all, blissed out and smiling as you wait for your heart to steady. Bucky is still inside you, softening with every passing second and yet you have no desire for him to go anywhere. Chest to chest- heart to heart, for the first time in years you feel truly utterly calm.
Across the room the fire cackles, a loud pop disturbing your peace.
You can't help your jolt, a brief flash of panic at the sound and sudden wave of heat. It startles both you and Bucky, makes you clench around him and his dick startle in return.
You seize for a moment, before relaxing back into the mattress, a giggle bouncing off your lips.
Bucky presses one last kiss to your forehead, and finally pulls out, hissing at the air when he does. Gently, he falls back to his side of the bed, fixing the blanket so it lays properly over both of your bodies.
"Sorry." You groan, turning into his chest with embarrassment. "I get a little jumpy around fire."
"Can't say I blame you." Bucky chuckles, his arm curling protectively around your back. "You were right where it started. I'd be pretty jumpy too if I was that close."
You're already drifting, eyes falling shut as Bucky says something else. Some thing about being lucky that you didn't have any burns, and even more so frostbite, with how cold it was that night.
Bucky must realize you're dozing, a soft press of his lips to your forehead as he whispers against your skin.
"Goodnight Princess."
You're too tired to realize it's the first time he's called you that. Too tired to wonder why it sends a chill up your spine. Too tired to remember that you never told him about the fire.
Your mother crumples to the ground at your feet, spraying you in her blood and revealing her last act of heroism to have been pointless anyway.
He's already found you.
At the end of the hall, the man who's been trailing you since you started running.
Black tactical gear, a carbon mask and mysterious long hair. The rest of his face is distorted by shadows, hiding the rest of him from view. His gun, a short thing with a silencer over the barrel, is already pointed at you.
Frozen in place, you're unable to move, scream, or even cry. It's all too much, your mind abandoning your body completely and leaving you trapped in a never-ending staring match.
You're not sure how long you stand there. Nothing between you and death but ten feet and a puddle of blood.
At some point you reach up to brush your face, palm pulling across your cheek in hopes to pluck a plan free too.
Instead all you manage is to sneak blood from your chin to your ear.
You're sure it's not yours.
Suddenly, a window bursts behind him. Sound explodes into the hallway, a tortured scream married with the sound of a raging fire. It heats the hallway, casting its light onto the man and illuminating the last piece of his identity.
His eyes, ice blue and empty.
Eyes you know too well.
Detached, as if looking at you through the scope of a rifle. Finger hovering over the trigger. As if killing you wasn't apart of his plan, as if he had no instructions for you.
His eyes flicker, between you and the door, and then to your mother's corpse at your feet.
The flames lick closer, temperature rising with every passing second. With one last packed glance, your assailant lifts a hand to remove his mask. It drops to the floor, revealing the bottom half of his face without ceremony.
"Go." He instructs, tone emotionless and firm. "Now." He nods to the door.
With no choice but to listen, you body finally responds.
You run, hard enough to leave an echo as your feet stomp towards escape.
He stalks you to the door, stopping in its arch after you barrel through and onto the snow covered ground outside.
You look back one more time, eyes turning glassy as you try your best to commit his face to memory.
"Goodnight princess." He says, and with the force of an earthquake, he pulls the door shut, letting the loud thump echo through the night.
You hear the locks turn from the other side, effectively trapping himself in.
Frozen in the in the snow, you watch in horror as the flames spread higher and higher, until they're bursting out of every window.
A scream echoes, possibly your own.
Finally, you start to run.
Morning comes with a vengeance.
There's no startle when you wake, no gasp for air or blinking of sleep from your eyes. Only sick dread.
The bed has long gone cold on Bucky's side, empty sheets and his abandoned pillow. The only proof of last night is the marks on your skin, all the places where those loving touches had lingered.
The cold has crept back in, fire long burned out both in the hearth and your soul.
Bucky's only a few feet away, standing at the stove with a pot of water boiling. "Thought I'd make tea." He says, his tone is jovial, his posture the straightest you've seen it.
Your clothes are folded at the end of the bed, and with no sureness in your movements, you slowly put them back on. Your body is stiff, aching but not with that sweet, morning after ache. No these are sharp, stabs that come from betraying yourself.
Your mind races.
Maybe I made it up.
It can't have been him.
Yet every time you blink you see it. Bucky holding the gun. Bucky closing the door. Bucky killing your mother, Bucky Bucky Bucky Bucky.
Bucky was there.
With stiff joints you stand, even as your mind swims, you walk towards him.
A mug waits for you on the small table, steaming and ready to ease your chill. You could drink it. You could forget. If you tried hard enough you could blame this all on poor memory and blue eyes.
Then you look at him.
Smiling at you like you've hung the moon, joy oozing out of every pore. The same arms that made you feel so safe last night crossed neatly over his chest. His eyes waiting impatiently for you to meet them.
When you do, you realize there is no other option. The room blurs, replacing the cabin with stone walls and the lips that you kissed with a mask.
A cold breeze rolls through you with a whisper.
"Goodnight Princess."
You sit at the table, and take a small sip, unable to break the eye contact even as it threatens to break you completely.
Bucky sits across from you, setting his own mug next to yours as he speaks. "Thought maybe we could spend a few days here." He says, light and excited. "We're only a couple hours from Paris, thought you might want to enjoy privacy while you still have it."
Last night you would have jumped at the chance, jumped him.
Instead, the chill rises, pressing up to your chin.
"You know," You change the subject, choking on every word you can muster. "I'd never traveled before this."
"I only travel." He offers, "Can't remember the last time I felt safe enough to stay in one place."
You hum through another sip of tea. Letting it burn down your throat before you answer.
"You win."
The air hangs tight between you, slow blinks as you both hold the other's gaze.
"Do you know-" You push again, voice turning hard "-that before this test, I had no idea what my actual name was."
It's true, there was nothing on you that gave away who you were other than a fancy dress and jewelry. Even that was hardly enough to go on to start throwing around words like princess. So they chose something all the nuns liked, gave it to you like second hand clothes.
Bucky swallows, looking down at his tea for a moment before back to you.
"I didn't know that." He says. He opens his mouth again, ready to drop the pretense of the games but you interrupt.
"Do you know they told me they were sending someone else before you? A woman, someone Russian. Things changed last minute because you asked to come."
You didn't think anything of it at the time, too busy trying to come to terms with your lineage to wrap your head around security and who wanted to be where. It's only falling into place now.
Bucky's gaze turns, his shoulders curling in on themselves as he avoids your gaze. You can see him swallow. throat ticking in anticipation of whatever you'll say next.
"Do you know-" You bite one more time, standing up from your chair. "-I slept with the man who murdered my family."
Bucky freezes, entire body pulling taut with tension. His face falls, but not into shock, no something worse.
Resignation.
"Do I win?" You ask, spitting the words at him.
Across the table, Bucky nods.
Collab Masterlist
Main Masterlist
This fix had haunted me since November, I love it and I am so glad it’s posted because now I never have to look at it again. 🩷 anyway I love you all!!! say it back!!!
also don't worry guys, you go to Paris alone, safely and meet a very handsome rich man who didn't kill you mom. Bucky goes to therapy <3
summary | Your ex-boyfriend, Matt Murdock, breaks no-contact when he needs someone to patch him up. But are things really over between you?
warnings | exes to maybe-lovers, goofy/sarcastic reader, hurt/comfort, banter, Catholicism, injury and blood, ambiguous ending that leans hopeful, matt is shirtless, whale sharks
wc | 3.8k
MATT'S LIVING ROOM SWIMS IN SHADES OF BLUE.
You glance sidelong at the electronic billboard posted outside his windows. “The aquarium’s got a new whale shark exhibit,” you tell him.
The ad shows a whale shark — surprise surprise — swimming up to greet smiling guests. In bold white letters, the ad reads: Come Meet the Gentle Giant
You frown.
“Do you think they only have one?” you ask, then immediately feel like a moron when you remember Matt can’t see the billboard. “It says gentle gi-ant,” you explain, “not gi-ants.”
Matt’s response is a pained groan.
He’s lying flat on the couch. Shirtless, bruised, bloody — classic Matt.
You’re kneeling in front of the couch, an open first-aid kit at your side. You’ve got a needle pinched between your fingers, threading it with what is definitely not medical-grade thread.
Eventually Matt chokes out real words.
“Whale sharks are solitary creatures,” he says. “They only gather to eat.”
Hmph.
You don’t like the way he answered. Casual. Or as close to casual as someone can get while fighting for breath. Like this isn’t weird. Like a whole year hadn’t passed since the last time you were in a room together. Like you’re still his girlfriend, entitled to a serious response to every “Would you still love me if I was a worm?”-esque question.
“Well that’s sad,” you say.
Matt shakes his head. Pretty stupid since every movement seems to cost him, but it’s clear he means to comfort you. “They prefer it that way. Besides,” he winces, “is it the aquarium down on Surf? The building’s too small. Even if they tried, they probably couldn’t get a permit for more than one.”
“Then maybe they shouldn’t have any.”
“Even if whale sharks prefer to be alone?”
Your traitorous eyes flick up from the needle to his lips. No one prefers to be alone, you almost tell him.
But that’s too vulnerable. Too close to an admission.
Instead, you say, “Even if.”
A flash as the billboard changes. New colors bathe the living room: bright red and bleach white. You don’t have to look to know what ad is on display.
The emergency room wait time for Metro-General.
Ironic.
If it was up to you, that’s where Matt would be right now. In a real hospital, getting real medical treatment.
But that’s an old argument, and vigilantes are stupid by nature. “Why would I need a doctor?” asks a dying vigilante. “This random civilian has seen Grey’s Anatomy, right? That’s basically an M.D. crash course. Someone, quick! Give them a sewing kit before my intestines meet a Brooklyn sidewalk.”
With the needle readied, you chew your bottom lip and consider Matt’s injuries. His muscled torso is a sweaty mess of slashing cuts. The worst cut steals your attention, a straight line from the top of his hipbone to a little past his belly button. Looking at it turns your stomach. It’s one of the wounds that reminds you the human body is nothing more than a meat sack.
You swallow bile — swallow fear — and reach for one of the hand towels beside the first-aid kit.
Gently — very, VERY gently — you dab the towel against his bloody wound.
Matt writhes, arching off the cushions.
“Sorrysorrysorry!” You hardly recognize your own voice. You’re too focused on Matt, his clenched teeth stifling a groan, fists curling at his sides.
Apologies don’t cure pain.
Distraction might.
“Have I ever told you how much I hate that billboard? I mean, don’t get me wrong! I miss penthouse living every day. But you know what I don’t miss? Falling asleep on the couch and waking up to the lights of a hemorrhoid cream ad burning into my retinas.”
True. You do hate the billboard, and you do miss Matt’s apartment.
Your current apartment is a shoebox that Foggy helped you score two days post-breakup. To call it a hellscape would be too kind. The lights are all faulty, a massive roach has squatter’s rights under your white refrigerator, and you’re one hundred percent certain that Frank Castle lives down the hall.
You’ve been careful to keep that last bit hush-hush. If Foggy or Karen were to find out that you share a mailroom with the Punisher, they’d definitely tell Matt.
Not that Matt would care.
…
…
…
Okay, fine. Matt would care. About everything.
He’d go on for hours about the risk of electrical fire, how roaches carry E. coli, that your landlord’s violating New York State law by refusing to install a carbon monoxide detector, and oh, yeah, a convicted murderer might knock on your door any day now for a cup of sugar!
Just thinking about it makes your chest hurt. The depth of Matt’s care.
And Matt — sweet, loving, woeful Matt — makes it all worse by saying, “I offered to buy curtains.”
He had.
Countless times.
Once again chewing your bottom lip, you toss the towel aside. You’d cleaned enough blood to see what Meredith Grey would’ve called subcutaneous tissue. Or maybe she wouldn’t have. Maybe it’s something else. Grey’s Anatomy, after all, is not an MD crash course.
Either way, the raw mess of his stomach proves what was already obvious: this cut is deeeeeeeeeep.
“Sure you don’t want any pain killers?” you ask him. “I’ve got Midol in my bag.”
He shakes his head once.
You scoff. “You know you don’t earn tough guy points for taking it raw, right?”
Matt laughs at your poor phrasing; though “laugh” might not be the best word for it. It’s more of an exhale turned cough turned sound of agony, but whatever. You take it as a win! If Matt wants to feel the pain of being a human embroidery project, so be it. At least you managed to distract him for a second, make him chuckle-cough over something silly.
“Hold your breath,” you tell him.
His brows knit with confusion. Soon as he starts to ask why, you shove the needle through the edge of the ruined flesh above his hipbone. His question becomes an exclamation that is very un-Catholic.
“That’ll be seven Hail Marys, Murdock.”
A vein pulses at his temple. “Feels more like a Psalm 88 kind of moment.”
“Is that a joke?” You settle into the old rhythm of stitching him up. Needle in, out, pull the thread, repeat. “You know altar boy humor goes over my head.”
“I was never an altar boy,” he reminds you.
You tut. “How ableist.”
“Not because I’m blind.” Amusement flickers through agony, reminding you that pain is second nature to Matt. You’ve only finished one stitch, yet already he can mask a wince when the needle pops through flesh. “I was a nervous kid,” he explains, “especially in front of crowds. My hands used to shake so much the pastor thought I’d drop the candles and set the altar on fire.”
“What a headline,” you say. “Local Blind Boy Burns Parish: God’s Judgment or Innocent Mistake?”
He chuckle-coughs.
You ask him, “Couldn’t you have carried the wine?”
“You mean the body of Christ?”
Your eyeroll is affectionate. “The wine.”
Transubstantiation is one of those things you’ve always filed under Complete Malarkey. How does random bread and crushed grapes become the body and blood of Jesus Christ? By invoking the Holy Spirit? Is that not a form of witchcraft? And why is it cannibalism to eat each other, but not the Son of God?
Catholics are, in your opinion, an awfully confusing people.
Matt’s no exception. A devout lover of God — yet a glimpse up from stitching reveals his mouth curving into a small smile. He’s always liked your sacrilege. It amuses him. Gives him reason to challenge his faith.
“If the pastor was too nervous to let me hold a candle,” he says, “you can bet he wasn’t eager to hand me the blood of our Savior.”
“If only he could see you now,” you say. “Well not now, but in court. I’ve seen you and Foggy tackle plenty of cases in jam-packed courtrooms, and not once have you ever set a judge on fire or spilled Jesus down their moo moo.”
“You mean the judicial robes they work decades to earn?”
“Whatever. Hey, while we’re on the subject, how come they did away with those powdery wigs?”
“A barrister’s wig?”
“Do you get paid by Big Law to make sure I use their terminology right?”
“I do,” he says, “and you’re cutting into my paycheck.”
You laugh.
A comfortable silence settles.
Matt’s stomach remains tense under your fingertips. But his breaths come easier now — a steady rise and fall that breeds comfort inside you. It’s easy to lose yourself in the rhythm. Needle in, out, pull the thread, repeat.
The room around you glows pale purple. It’s easy to lose the present in the past, you realize. Your mind flips through old memories like songs in a jukebox, lingering on a favorite.
You and Matt used to dance in this room. You both had two left feet and spent more time tripping over abandoned takeout containers than actually dancing, but what did that matter? You were always giggling. Matt was always smiling.
The steady weight of his hands on your lower back had been the closest you ever came to finding proof of religion. Because someone like Matt couldn’t be the result of some random assimilation of atoms. Perfection at his level required divine planning. The sweetness of spirit mixed with the miracle of light. A pure heart placed inside his chest by the sure hand of God.
But despite what the Bible tells you, God is not an expert craftsman.
Matt is proof of this, too.
When silence stretches into discomfort, you glance up.
Matt’s dead.
Okay — okay, okay! — not dead since he’s still breathing. But he looks dead, eyes shut and lips parted enough to go full cadaver.
You snap, “Eyes open, Murdock.”
“Why?” His quick response eases your nerves, even if he doesn’t obey your command. “Want to see if I can tell how many fingers you’re holding up?”
“You probably have a concussion.” Not to mention a bloodborne illness or two. When’s the last time he got tested for hepatitis? “The last thing I need is for you to fall asleep and never wake up again.”
You’re pulling the thread through his wound when you notice the smirk in his voice.
“Would you miss me?” he asks.
You hesitate.
Of course.
Of course you’d miss him.
“Foggy will start ditching me for Thursday brunch if I let you die,” you tell him. “Do you know how many waffles your life would cost me?”
Matt opens his eyes. He blinks like his eyelids weigh a thousand pounds. Like they might shut again at any moment.
He keeps them open.
“Three,” he says.
“Waffles?” you ask.
“Fingers,” he chuckle-coughs. “That’s how many you’re holding up. Three.”
Amusement bubbles in your chest, rushing up your throat like a Mentos dropped into a bottle of Coke. You try to stifle it, but a lone giggle slips out.
“I’m not holding up any fingers, idiot.”
He huffs softly. “Talk about ableism.”
You’re offended, perplexed, giggling even more now. “That was so not ableist!”
“Since when did me insulting you become me insulting the entire blind community? And I’m not even calling you an idiot because you’re blind! I’m calling you an idiot because you’re an idiot.”
“Ouch. So you really think so low of me?”
“I just said so, didn’t I?”
His head tilts where it lay on the armrest. “Remember when I graduated summa cum laude from Columbia University?” he asks.
“Remember how you currently look like the victim of a violent anthropomorphic lawnmower?” You smile when he chuckle-coughs. “Yeah, not a thing that happens to smart people, Matty.”
The world stutters for a beat. Or maybe that’s only your pulse, jolting at your embarrassing slip-up.
Matty. You almost curse yourself; what was your tongue thinking?
Matt accepts defeat with a humble “Fair enough” that doubles as your path of least resistance. He’s always been good at withholding salt from a wound, giving you time to stew in self-loathing.
You have no doubt he can still hear your heart thumping stupidly against your ribs.
This isn’t easy. Being here. Seeing him. Pretending your breakup isn’t as much a third party in this room as the billboard’s glaring lights.
You’ve already stitched three-quarters of his wound. You should finish your work in silence. Then leave before he can make this anymore difficult, remind you of some reason to stay.
And yet.
“What’s Psalm 88, anyway?”
Matt likes this question.
“You dated a Catholic for two years,” he says, “and you don’t know Psalm 88?”
“Sorry, I hadn’t realized reading the Bible was a prerequisite for sucking your—”
Ever a child of God, Matt cuts you off — his voice an octave too high — with a sudden urge to recite.
“Lord, I am overwhelmed with troubles and my life is slipping toward death. You have put me in the lowest pit, in the darkest depths. You have taken from me my closest friend—” his voice wavers here “—and made me repulsive to them. Why, Lord, do you reject me? From my youth I have suffered. Your wrath has swept over me. Your terrors have destroyed me. They surround me like a flood, engulfing me completely. Darkness,” he says, “is my closest friend.”
You say nothing.
Needle in—
You think about how pain has always been second nature to Matt.
—out—
You think about the breakup.
—pull thread—
The breakup you’d initiated.
—repeat.
“NOT TO TOOT MY OWN HORN, but that is going to be one fine scar.”
Half an hour has passed since you finished stitching Matt up. If you were wise, you would’ve excused yourself the moment you closed the first-aid kit. But excuses are easy to come by, and even easier to make yourself believe.
I’ll stay a little longer, you keep telling yourself. Just to make sure he’s okay.
At some point the two of you switched places. You’re on the couch now, legs folded underneath you. Matt stands in front of you, testing his body for breaks and sprains — stretching an arm, rolling his neck.
At your comment, he pauses his self-assessment to run his fingertips over the stitches. You track the movement, a slow sweep from hipbone to belly button.
“Some of your best work.”
The praise straightens your posture.
The curve of his lips becomes devilish. “I’m surprised,” he adds. “I thought you’d be rusty.”
“Your faith in me is astounding, Murdock.”
“My faith in you is boundless,” he shoots back. “But it’s been a while since you last played nurse.”
With theatrical flair, you say, “An artist never forgets how to paint.”
“Even if they swore they’d never touch a brush again?”
Levity drops from the air like a butterfly hitting a bug zapper.
He hadn’t meant for it to come out that way. Not resentful, but…hurt. You know this because you know Matt, and he’d sooner walk into traffic than make you feel guilty for your choices.
Some relationships are like a winter storm. Rarely do we take the first snowflake to mean danger. Some people even find them beautiful — like noticing the quirks and habits of the one we love. But snowflakes pile up. They become inconvenient. Isolating. And, in some cases, they become dangerous, too.
Sometimes the only way to stay safe is to evacuate.
Matt will never blame you for evacuating.
With a soft sniff, he turns his head toward the windows. Too quiet, he asks, "What advertisement is showing?"
The billboard shines with a dark image, car keys lying next to an empty whiskey glass. "Think twice," you read aloud, "don't drink and drive."
Matt nods. "Good message."
You nod. "Indubitably."
Matt keeps facing the windows, but your own focus has already shifted back to him. He looks sad. Confused. Like he’s trying hard to hide both emotions, yet failing miserably.
A flash as the billboard changes. White light illuminates Matt’s profile — bruised, bloody, beautiful as ever.
As if he knows the ad has changed — as if he can hear it somewhere, electrical pulses whispering secrets only to him — he asks, “How about now?”
You don’t answer. You don’t know.
You can’t look away from him long enough to find out.
“I would’ve bought curtains,” he mumbles, and you don’t know what he’s talking about. Then it hits you. Your confession about the billboard, how you always hated it. “If you would’ve told me the light bothered you, I…” He swallows. Calls upon shaky confidence, betraying that what he says next lives somewhere between truth and wishful thinking. “I would’ve fixed it.”
Your eyes start to burn.
He would’ve tried, you know. He would’ve tried.
You find yourself rising off the couch. Taking a step — two, three — to close the gap between you. Matt looks away from the windows and you swear he can see you. He does, in that peculiar way of his. Through soundwaves bouncing off your skin. The smell of your shampoo. The rhythm of your heartbeat.
“I know,” you say.
“Then why didn’t you tell me?” he asks.
“I’m telling you now, aren’t I?”
“Back then. Why didn’t you tell me back then? It would’ve been an easy fix.”
Your laugh is half-sob. “No, Matt–”
He reaches up to cup your cheek. “Yes,” he whispers.
It takes Herculean effort not to lean into his touch. You manage, but don’t pull away from him, either.
“Fine. You’re right. Curtains would be an easy fix. Get on Amazon and they’ll be here in ten seconds. But what about the bigger issues? The lies? The secrets? You trying to get yourself killed?”
He winces. “I’m not dead yet,” he tries to argue.
“Yet,” you say. “Key word, Matty.”
An awful key word. One that had been haunting you for far longer than the year you two had been apart.
You had never wanted to leave Matt. And if you’re being honest, you hadn’t even left because of the lying and the secrets — though they were factors. When it came down to it, you’d left because Matt was on a suicide mission. Because you wouldn’t survive watching him die.
Only now — with the warmth of his hand on your cheek — can you see the flawed logic in your breakup plan.
Sure, leaving Matt ensured you won’t be front row for his death. That it won’t be you holding pressure to wounds that can’t be stitched, crying “Lord, why do you reject him? Your perfect soldier, your pure-hearted boy?”
But that doesn’t free you from pain.
You’ll feel Matt’s death as a ripple effect through Foggy and Karen. You'll feel it inside of you, when his last breath severs the invisible string connecting you to him and him to you.
Distance will not spare you.
You will feel it.
It will hurt.
And will all this distance make it hurt worse? you wonder. Until tonight you hadn’t realized how unsteady you stood on your decision to leave. A single phone call had been all it took to undo three-hundred sixty-five days of progress. So much time spent assuring everyone you had made the right decision. That you’re happier without Matt. So much time — each second a tally toward a life free from pain, now useless as sand in an hourglass, so easy to flip.
You’re not happier without Matt.
You’re not happy, period.
The heat coming off his palm is too much. Does he have a fever? Probably. Is fever a normal response to getting sliced up like salmon on a Hibachi line? You have no clue. You'll Google it if you ever remember how to form thoughts not centered on the flecks of gold in Matt's eyes.
He speaks.
“I’m sorry I called tonight. I know I shouldn’t have. I know when you—” He can’t make himself say it. So he drags a hand through his hair. Pulls easier words from a bucket labeled: Half-truths. "I know you wanted to get away from all this. From me. And it was wrong of me to drag you back into it, but..." A chuckle-cough. "Whenever something happens...when I'm stressed, or hurt, or...or happy, I..."
His thumb traces your lower lip. Lovingly. Mournfully.
"You're still the only one I want around.”
You're bawling. You hate yourself for it, and you hate him for causing it. You sob and laugh and tell him, "You're a goddamn idiot, Matty."
He smiles at you. "I know."
"It was never you I wanted to get away from."
He hesitates. "I know."
You hate him for that, too. But what else could he have said? You both know nothing can erase the true problem. The Achilles' heel to an otherwise perfect relationship.
Daredevil.
God, you think, how is it possible to hate the mask but love the man behind it?
It's simple, though. You don't hate Daredevil. Can't. He'll be the death of Matt Murdock, but that doesn't make him any less the salvation of Hell's Kitchen.
You sigh. Does that justify it, then? Does some PEMDAS bullshit make it okay that Matt suffers so long as his suffering saves others?
You don't think so.
But you know Matt holds a different opinion.
A stupid opinion, but.
"I wish things were different," you tell him. No jokes. "Maybe we could drop Daredevil off at the shelter. Y'know, like a stray dog who won't stop digging in our trash."
Okay, fine. Some jokes.
Matt chuckles. “I don’t think the shelter will take him.”
“Can’t say I blame them.”
You don’t know when you grabbed Matt’s other hand, the one not touching your face. You only know that you’re playing with his fingers, trying to keep more tears from escaping. He hadn’t coughed when he chuckled this time. Does that mean he’s feeling better? You hope so — and hope not, too.
You're not ready to go back to your shoebox apartment. You don't want to crawl into bed alone. Spend all night wondering if walking out Matt's door a second time makes it permanent. What are you supposed to do? Go back to getting all your Matt-related info via Thursday brunch with Foggy? Search for scraps of him in your texts with Karen?
No.
You're not sure you can survive that, either.
But what does that leave?
"Let me buy you dinner."
Your pulse jolts. “Matt…”
"Nothing romantic," he promises. Though the way his thumb continues brushing your bottom lip feels opposite of that. "And it doesn't have to change anything. Tomorrow we can go back to our normal lives, pretend none of this ever happened. But tonight...how about pizza? We can call it repayment for you saving my life."
You should say no.
You smile despite yourself. "Fine, but I get to pick the toppings."
A flash as the billboard changes. Shades of blue wash over you both.
Even without Matt’s enhanced senses, you swear you hear joy spark to life in his veins.
"I wouldn't have it any other way.”
A/N | if you've read this far, i am in love with you and i've already booked our flight to Vegas. booked the Elvis impersonator, too. do you have any allergies i should know about? i love you.
seriously, thank you so much for reading! comments and reblogs much appreciated :)
── 𝜗𝜚 summary: A car accident sends you to Hawkins General where you meet a man named Henry. He helps you heal from your past by giving you a world where you can forget everything from before and start anew.
── 𝜗𝜚 pairing(s): henry creel x fem!reader, eventual steve harrington x fem!reader
── 𝜗𝜚 warnings/tags: age gap (reader is 19 henry is 40), memory loss, fluff, manipulation, toxic relationship, mentions of abusive and drunk father, memory altercation, identity loss, ptsd, trauma, angst, nightmares, happy ending, not canon compliant to s5, more specific tags on each part!
chapter 1: past the blood and bruise - henry creel
A car accident sends you to Hawkins General where you meet a man named Henry. He helps you heal from your past by giving you a world where you can forget everything from before and start anew.
chapter 2: past the curses and cries. pt 2. - henry creel
You wake up in an unfamiliar place with unfamiliar people. Henry says you can't trust them, that they will only hurt you, yet they don't seem to want anything other than for you to be safe... even if that means getting Henry out of your head.
chapter 3: there is happiness - steve harrington
It's been a month since you started living at Steve's house since his parents are never home. You have to relearn almost everything—how to use the washing machine, what foods you like, everything. But through it all you still have to learn to live with the silence in your head.
A year ago, Steve Harrington saved your life and now? you don't talk to each other. But he's the only one to notice how you flinch at the lights.
pairing: steve harrington x byers!reader
words: 6.4k
contains: season one and season two steve, slow burn, fluff/angst, descriptions of blood and violence, traumatised reader (mention of anxiety and pstd), description of panic attacks, previously injured reader, scarred reader, vulnerable!steve, canon level violence, mention of blood, explicit language.
author's note: this was initially only meant to be one part but i couldn't stop writing. part two will be soon. also had to take some creative liberties with the stranger things timeline including having nancy and steve break up before season two starts and also aging up jonathan so he and reader are the same age as steve.
to be added to my taglist | masterlist | requests page
November, 1983.
"What am I doing?" Steve Harrington mutters to himself as he approaches the small, rundown house he knew belonged to the Byers' family. "What the fuck am I doing?"
Steve 'the hair' Harrington had come to apologise—to actually apologise—to Jonathan Byers. He had been an ass. He knew that now. He knew shouldn’t have let Tommy and Carol call Nancy a whore and let them graffiti those words outside the Hawk Movie Theatre for all to see. And he certainly should not have said those things about Jonathan's family and called him what he had. Steve felt that he fully deserved the black eye and split lip that Jonathan had given him. And so, after ditching Tommy and Carol (and leaving them stranded at the gas station), Steve came to the Byers’ house to apologise for his behaviour.
What Steve didn't expect was Nancy being the one to answer the door. But he decides not to question it—too focused on wanting to apologise for his behaviour and not wanting to let his slight jealousy cloud his judgement. He wanted to do something right for once.
"I messed up, okay! I messed up—" Steve stutters, panicking a little now as Nancy kept trying to close the door.
"Steve," she says through gritted teeth, raising her hand to try and stop him. "You need to—"
"—hey, what happened to your hand?" Steve asks, his voice soft, gentle and concerned when he noticed the bandage covering her hand. "Is that blood?"
Nancy tries, she really tries, to stop Steve from entering the house but Steve was worried about his girlfriend. Worried about what was going on and so he forces his way in and—
"What is—what the—"
The ceilings in living room, the kitchen and hallway were covered in colourful Christmas lights. The sight would have been kind of beautiful, had Steve not been deeply concerned. And when he sees Jonathan with a baseball bat with nails hammered into it and you—Jonathan's twin sister, the girl who had barely spoke a word in school—with a goddamn axe. Steve was sure that you were all on some serious hardcore drugs. And the smell of gasoline? Well, that was the cherry on top of this fucked up cake.
Steve should had left then. Should have listened to his girlfriend yelling at him to go. But he didn't. Even when Nancy points Jim Hopper's gun at him, he still doesn't leave. And when the lights suddenly flicker and a literal monster claws its way out of the damn ceiling—he still doesn't leave. In fact, he's rooted to the spot. Wondering what the fuck he had gotten himself into. It's you who grabs his hand and forces him to move. You tell him to jump over a wire to avoid triggering the goddamn bear trap—which he does without question.
When you pull him into a bedroom and Nancy and Jonathan follow, he fully expects that thing to come in and rip you all to shreds. But two minutes pass and...nothing.
Jonathan went first to check if that thing was gone. Then Nancy. Then you.
And Steve?
Steve finally decided to see sense and he ran.
His hands shook as he pulled out his car keys from his jean pocket. They fell to the floor. Steve scrambled to pick them back up and when he managed to finally open the door to his beamer, he looked back at the house for a split second.
He sees the lights flickering through the windows. The colours dance across his face as he freezes. And—he couldn't leave. Not when he heard someone screaming from inside.
He didn't think. He just moved.
And thank god that he did.
Because what he sees when he opens the front door would haunt him for weeks after.
Jonathan on the floor—seemingly close to losing consciousness. Nancy struggling to reload the revolver. And you? You were beneath the monster, screaming in pain. Your jeans were soaked in your own blood, a clear gaping wound on your thigh from that thing's deep claw marks. Your axe just out of reach from your fingertips.
Steve doesn't even remember picking up the nail bat. He just remember thinking—she's can't die. You can't die.
The sound of nails smacking against the fleshy monster's skin is sickening. But he don't hesitate. He didn’t know what that thing was. He had no idea what was going on—why his girlfriend, Jonathan Byers and you were involved with monsters. But he knew he didn’t want you to die. Couldn’t let you die. It takes all his strength to yank the bat back for another hit. He twirls the bat like he was playing some fucked up game of baseball before he's smacking the creature again. And again. And again. And again. Until it staggers back into the beartrap and Nancy and Jonathan lit that son-of-a-bitch on fire.
But Steve doesn't stick around to watch it burn.
Because you were bleeding out and he didn't know how long you had.
“Hey, hey, don’t move too much, okay?” Steve says gently as he kneels down beside you. Your blood already staining his jeans. He barks at Jonathan to get a towel while you cry out in pain. He presses his hand down on your wound to stem the bleeding. “You’re going to be okay, (y/n). You’re going to be fine. Just focus on me, yeah? Don’t close your eyes. Just keep looking at me.”
The colours from the Christmas lights above you blur into one and it takes everything to focus on Steve's face. But you do.
And you focus on him as Nancy hurries to grab Jonathan's car keys. As both Steve and your brother help you into a car that you vaguely recognise to be Jonathan’s. They lay you in the backseat, your head resting against Steve's lap as he tries to keep you awake.
You don't remember the drive to the hospital. All you remember is how scared you were. How weak you felt. How Steve's hand in yours (which you don't remember grabbing) had felt so warm. You remembering asking him if you were going to die. Remember telling him quietly you didn't want to die. That you didn’t know if Will was okay yet.
You certainly don't remember arriving at the hospital. Don't remember Steve carrying you while Jonathan and Nancy tried to find someone to help. Don't remember the look Jonathan's face as you were laid on a stretcher. Don't remember how worried Nancy had looked.
But you do remember how—for a split second—Steve Harrington had refused to let go of you.
October, 1984.
History was the only class Steve had with you.
You sat in front of him, taking more notes than he thought was necessary. Always paying attention. Being smart and all that.
To everyone else, they would think you and Steve had never interacted because well, you didn’t. You smiled at him politely sometimes but other than that? You didn’t acknowledge each other’s existence.
That didn't mean you didn't think about what had happened last year. In fact, you thought about it all the time. Because the night you had nearly died? Well, it was hard not to think about.
If Steve was honest, the night affected him too. A lot, actually. You asking him tearfully if you were going you. You then crying and saying you didn't want to die. Fucking hell. He thought about it nearly every day.
Maybe that's what you hadn't talked in nearly a year.
He knew you felt embarrassed that he had witnessed you falling apart like that. But, if he was honest, it was mostly his fault for not trying anyway. He had saved your life, you would quite literally be dead without him and he hadn’t bothered to even attempt to be your friend. He felt like an asshole. He knew he was. Hell, Nancy had made that pretty clear when she dumped him just before Spring Break. Steve just didn’t know how to be a good friend. He was so used to people just wanting to be friends with him, he didn’t know how to be there for people. Not in a way that mattered anyway.
Steve was just wondering how much longer that this class would be when the light above you began to flicker.
He sees you freeze. Hears the hitch of your breath. He sees you grip your pen a little tighter.
Steve's on edge immediately—who could blame him? But as he looks around the classroom, he observes that the only light flickering was the one situated directly above you. If it was a demorogon, all the lights would be flickering. He breathes a little easier. Just a faulty light. That was all.
But you? You’re still frozen. Still clearly terrified.
And then—
“Ms. Norway?” You ask in a small, timid voice, your hand shooting up nervously, “can I—can I go to the bathroom?”
Ms. Norway doesn’t question it. You were such a model student that Steve wasn’t surprised. She’d probably let you kick up your feet and light up a cigarette if you wanted to. She just smiles—Ms. Norway hardly ever smiled—and lets you go before droning on about…well, Steve wasn’t sure. He barely listened in this class.
You leave quickly. Steve barely has time to think of a way to check you were okay.
And Steve? Well, he lets you go. Hating himself for it. You don't come back for the remaining half an hour.
But Steve thinks about it all day. Looks for you in the hallways.
He gets smacked in the face by a few basketballs during practice because he's too busy remembering the way you froze. Like you were back there.
He finds himself actively looking for you.
Because he can still see it—you bleeding out, the lights flickering in the Byers' home and you telling him you didn’t want to die—
The guilt's back as he heads to his car—his eyes darting around the car park for a glimpse of you.
But it was like you had disappeared after history. And that? It makes him feel even worse.
He doesn't see you again until your next History lesson.
The light is still faulty. Still flickering and so you pick another seat. It doesn't make a difference. Your leg bounces nervously. You stare determinedly at anywhere but the damn light—
"Hey."
Steve's voice makes you jump. Genuinely. You look up, eyes wide and confused.
"It's just me, Byers'" Steve says with an overconfident smile as he takes the seat beside you without asking. He's trying to act like he hadn't been avoiding you for a year. Trying to ignore the guilt and shame he felt.
You look at Steve, your heart hammering in your chest as he leans back in his chair casually.
"What are you—"
But before you could finish your sentence and ask Steve what he was doing, why he was sitting next to you—Ms. Norway begins the class. And you being you? Well, you shut your mouth instantly.
It takes all of your energy to concentrate on the class. Your focus keeps dipping between Steve and that damn flickering light that you could still see out of the corner of your eye.
It was making you restless. Your leg continued to bounce. You were tapping your pen against the tabletop. You weren't even making notes like you usually would. Steve couldn't help but notice. It was impossible not to notice really.
But you couldn't help it. The image of the demogorgon was still fresh in your mind. You could almost feel its claws slashing through your flesh. Still smell the coppery scent of blood.
"You alright?" Steve murmurs, leaning forward to rest his elbows against the desk, voice low.
You nod, even though it was clear that you weren't.
Steve, of course, doesn't buy it. But he remains quiet. Unsure of how to help but desperately wanting to do so.
"You can talk to me, you know?" Steve whispers, his arm gently nudging yours. The sudden touch makes you flinch and before you know what you're doing, you're pushing away from your desk and getting to your feet.
"I'm s-sorry," you blurt out, your hands as shaky as your voice as you grab your bag. You don't look at Ms. Norway—and you certainly don't look at Steve as you rush out of the classroom. Ms. Norway calls your name but the door's already slammed behind you.
"Those Byers' freaks are fucking weird," Tommy H mutters a few tables over.
And Steve? Well, he reacts on instinct.
His head whips around to glare at his former best friend with disdain and something like loathing in his eyes.
"Don't you fucking talk about her like that," Steve spits out.
“Harrington! Sit back down!”
Steve hadn't even realised that he had stood up. He was too busy scowling at Tommy to register him moving.
"The fuck you say to me?" Tommy snaps back, but Steve's already grabbing his own bag from beneath the table.
"Harrington! Don't you dare—"
The door slamming behind him echoes throughout the hallway, drowning out whatever Ms. Norway was about to say.
Steve didn't know what he was doing. Why he had just snapped at Tommy like that. Why he had stood up for you like that. Why he cared so fucking much.
He didn't know where he was going. Didn't know where you could have gone. All he knew was that he needed to check on you.
You couldn't stop shaking. Your hands—your entire body really—felt as though it didn't belong to you. Because though you tried, the tremors in your hands didn't stop. Your heart keep hammering on as though attempting to flee from its home your chest. Your breathing was erratic and out of control.
"Fuck," you exclaim, pacing the girls bathroom frantically as you tried to control your breathing. Tried to calm down. "Not now—fuck, please not now—"
"Byers?!"
You let out a noise of frustration that you couldn't stop. You were losing control—in the midst of a panic attack and Steve Harrington barging in was the very last thing that you needed.
But Steve was already walking into the girls' bathroom. Finding you leaning over the sink, breathing frantically.
"You, um, you good?" He asks, scratching the back of his neck uncomfortably because now he was here? In front of you—he was realising how little he had thought this through.
"Do I look good, Steve?!" You snap back at him. "Just—just go. Please."
You say it with such anger that Steve knows he should listen to you. Should walk out of the girls' bathroom and not look back. But seeing the way your hands shake—the same hands he had held while you were scared and bleeding out—Steve discovered that he couldn't leave you alone like this.
"No," he says stubbornly, taking a few steps closer to you and placing a gentle hand on your back. His touch makes you jump again but he doesn't pull away. Keeps it there. You find it grounds you. Just a little. "Just...breathe slowly, yeah?"
"I'm fucking trying," you mutter back harshly, your fingers gripping the edge of the sink basin so hard your knuckles turn white. Steve notices. Starts to rub your back a little.
"I know but—just keep trying, yeah?"
You bite back another snappy retort and nod. Your eyes closing in concentration as you focus entirely on your breathing. On Steve's hand rubbing your back gently. On what you could feel and hear in the moment—the coolness of the basin, the sound of water leaking from the faulty tap and Steve's hand on your back.
"You're doing great," Steve murmurs quietly.
Again, you just nod and you count down slowly in your head.
And eventually, your breathing evens out. Your hands stop trembling. Your heartbeat slows.
Only then do you open your eyes.
Steve is still looking you—in fact, unbeknownst to you, he hadn't taken his eyes off of you the entire time.
"You good?" He asks, those warm brown eyes full of concern.
You nod, not looking at him in embarrassment as you release your grip on the sink and rub your hands over your jean-clad thighs. Wincing when you realise you were subconsciously rubbing over where the damn monster had scarred you for life.
"That light was just faulty, you know?" Steve says quietly, watching you closely. Noticing your wince.
You knew that. Of course you knew logically that the light was faulty. That no demogorgons were coming to attack you in the middle of history class. But you couldn't help it. Your body couldn't differentiate between a flickering light and almost dying again.
"I know," you say quietly. "I just—I felt like...like I was still there."
"Hey. You're okay," Steve reassures you gently. Hand still on your back, rubbing up and down it soothingly. It made you think about your mom. How she used to rub your back to coax you to sleep when you were younger. "You're okay."
You want to tell him that you’re not okay. That you haven’t felt okay in nearly a year. That you couldn’t stand to look at the scar on your thigh. That you couldn’t sleep without a nightlight. That the feeling of dread had settled in your chest and refused to leave. But all you can do is nod and try to breathe.
“I just—I get…I get this feeling that—that something awful is going to—to happen again,” you say quietly, not entirely sure why you were telling Steve this. "And the light—"
"Hey," Steve hushes you gently. So gently. Just like he had been with you in the hospital. "I get it. I get scared too."
Your eyes meet his—your breath catches and you feel your eyes sting, just a little.
"Really?" It's barely a whisper but Steve hears it—hears you.
"Yeah," he breathes, "I get nightmares a lot."
The way he says it makes you feel as though he hadn't told anyone that before. The way he looks away from you as though embarrassed. How for a moment, his hand stills on your back.
"I can't sleep without a nightlight," you admit to him.
Steve looks at you for a long moment, brown eyes soft and studying you carefully. You wonder if he was about to laugh at you. If he was going to think you were ridiculous and childish. But somehow, you knew he wouldn't.
"Look d'you want to...to ditch school and grab some food?" Steve asks, finally removing his hand from your back to watch your expression carefully. You find you miss his touch. You decide not to dwell on that.
"Ditch school?" You repeat, eyes widening a little. "Steve—I've never done that. Not since Will—my mom would freak out—"
"C'mon Byers," Steve encourages, nudging you with his arm. "You're in no state to continue with school today. Plus, you can totally blame it on me."
You look at Steve, unsure. You know you shouldn't—your mom would be worried sick. It would affect your near perfect attendance record. You didn't want to get into trouble.
But..
The panic attack had thrown you off. You felt like a livewire, buzzing with something in your veins you wanted to leave. You knew you couldn't continue with the rest of the school day like nothing had happened.
"I dunno, Steve," you reply thickly, worrying your bottom lip between your teeth. "We're not—we're not even that close..."
Steve falters then—just for a second. Because he hated that you were right. That he hadn't pushed through the uncomfortableness that he felt. That he hadn't bothered to try.
"I know," Steve says finally, his jaw tense and eyes full of regret. "And that—that's on me. Totally a Harrington fuck up there."
You let out a breath of laughter, unable to stop yourself. And that makes Steve smile. He nudges you again.
"See—made you laugh. Imagine what I can do over a burger and a shake," He teases, smiling at you—feeling a little smug that he had finally made you smile.
"Fine," you say after a few moments. "But I will blame you if we get caught."
Steve nearly pumps the air in victory. He's smiling wide and grabbing your bag from the floor.
"I'll take that," he says, grabbing your hand and tugging towards the door.
Burger Quest was surprisingly quiet. Granted, it was barely eleven in the morning and it was a Wednesday. You were so used to it being packed with people when you and Jonathan would take Will and his friends that it was a little strange to see a grand total of ten customers in the restaurant.
"You been here before?" Steve asks you, peering over the top of his menu to watch you.
"Yeah. Come here with Will sometimes."
Steve nods, eyes flickering back down to his menu for a brief second before he's looking back at you.
"How is Will?"
You look up at Steve then because—well, it wasn't an easy question to answer.
"He's not the same," you say finally. "He's Will but he's...yeah...not the same."
It's quiet then. Steve orders a double cheeseburger, you order a plain burger. Steve further insists on splitting fries and a shake. You succumb pretty quickly as Steve offers to pay. But after that? You aren't quite sure what to say. You fiddle with your necklace and watch a nearby toddler mashing up a couple of fries in her hands. You watch her as she squeals in joy, shoving the fried potatoey goodness into her mouth with a bright smile. Something in your gut twists at the sight—the reminder of the childhood innocence you had lost throughout the years.
"Do you have anyone to talk to about it?" Steve asks you, pulling you away from your thoughts about your dad, about Will, about the damn demogorgon that nearly ripped you to shreds.
"Hm? About what?" You query, tapping your fingers nervously. Steve notices. He doesn't comment.
"About what you went through," Steve explains. "I mean—you nearly died. Surely you talk to Joyce—I mean, your mom about it."
You falter. Chew the inside of your mouth and shake your head.
"No," you admit. "She—she's got enough on her plate with what happened to Will."
Steve looks at you—a look of slight disbelief on his face.
"What about Jonathan?" Steve tries to look neutral at the mention of your brother—but Jonathan was dating his ex, Steve couldn't help the slight face he pulled. It would have made you laugh had you been having another conversation. But you remained stoic and aloof, tapping away on the table still.
"No—Jonathan...he...he's busy."
"With Nancy?"
"He's happy," you say finally. "And I don't want him to worry—"
"(y/n)," Steve interjects, leaning a little over the table to look at you carefully—you chose to ignore how that makes you feel. "You went through something traumatic. Like—really traumatic."
You shift, leaning back on your side of the booth and hugging yourself a little as a means of comfort and protection. It was subconscious. You had done it ever since you overheard that first fight between your parents.
"I know," you murmur, though you're not looking at Steve as you say it.
"You need to talk to someone about this," Steve insists. "You can't—can't be having panic attacks and keeping it to yourself. Your family should know—"
"—Steve, with all due respect, you haven't spoken to me in like nearly a year," you say, a little more harshly than intended but he was pushing you a little more than you wished to be pushed right now. "So, you can't really tell me what I can nor can't do when it comes to this."
Steve looks for a second as though he was going to argue—but you were saved from more of his opinion by the arrival of your food.
You eat in almost silence—the only noise coming from the other customers and the radio that which played The Cure on repeat.
It was as you both reached for a fry at the same time that Steve spoke again.
"Listen, I'm not trying to tell you what to do," Steve tells you, pulling his hand away briefly so you could take a fry first. "I just—I don't want you to be struggling alone."
You take your time chewing on your fry, unsure of how to respond to him. You weren't sure why, but you felt like you could be honest with him. Which was something that you felt as though you could no longer be with your mom or your brothers.
"I just—I don't really have anyone else," you say finally. "I can't tell my friends because of the fact that legally, I can't. I can't tell my mom because she's too busy focusing on Will. I can't talk Jonathan because he—he's finally happy and Nancy would tell Jonathan if I went to her and Will—well, he's too young."
Steve listens to you—really listens. Hangs on every word and nods in understanding, those warm eyes watching you carefully.
"And—I guess, it's just difficult to talk about too," you continue, picking up another fry just to have something in your hands. "I mean—I could—I could have—"
You don't finish the sentence but Steve gets it. He understands without you needing to explain anymore.
"You forgot one person."
"Who?"
"Me."
You almost laugh—almost, until you realise Steve was being sincere. That he was looking at you with an unreadable expression on his face. One that weren't quite sure what to do with.
"I don't want to burden you after saving my life," you tell him.
Steve shakes his head. "Jesus (y/n)," he mutters, taking you by surprise as he reaches over and takes your hand. "You are not a burden. Not at all. You—you almost died and if—if you need someone to talk to about it, whatever it is—talk to me."
You continue to fidget with the fry in your hand, but your eyes do stay locked onto him. He means it. You can see it on his face that he does.
"Fine," you say finally—knowing that you likely would never take him up on his offer. That you were so determined to ignore that night, despite the fact you were reminded every time you came home—when you saw the dark stain in the carpet that your mom could not get out. Reminded every time you looked down at your bare thighs and saw the tender, scarred flesh from the demogorgon's claws. Reminded every time you saw a faulty light.
You could manage. You told yourself. You'd be fine.
You didn't reach out to Steve after that lunchtime at Burger Quest. In fact, you were beginning to tactically avoid him. For three whole days you were successful—somehow. Steve was surprisingly easy to hide from. He had such an aura about him that you could almost always tell when he was around the corner.
But then Friday came and you learnt that Steve Harrington did not enjoy being ignored.
"You're ignoring me."
"Fucking—"
You nearly turned and whacked Steve with your heaviest textbook but his hand is quick to grab your wrist before you could do so.
"Okay—maybe I shouldn't have snuck up to you at your locker like this," Steve relents as he lets go of your wrist with a wry smile.
"You think?" You huff, face flushed as you were finally caught.
"I would apologise but I have it on good authority that you have been in fact, avoiding me," Steve states, leaning by the wall against your locker, arms folded and watching you. Not caring that people were whispering—wondering what King Steve was doing talking to the Byers girl.
"Good authority?" You repeat before you slam your locker shut, brow raised at him.
"Yeah—my intuition."
"Steve—"
"No, I know what you're going to say," Steve interjects, stepping closer to you, his eyes not leaving yours. "I know you think that I didn't mean it. That I don't actually want to be there for you—but please believe me when I say that I—I want to try."
"Why?" You ask him quietly, your eyes lifting to meet his. "Why do you insist on trying to help—"
"Because I'm trying not to be an asshole anymore," Steve interrupts—his voice tight as though he was frustrated by trying to keep cool. It made you stop, made you forget whatever excuse you were about to concoct.
"You're not...that much of an asshole," you tell him finally, just above a whisper. "You just...have asshole tendencies."
"Asshole tendencies," Steve repeats with a small laugh and a shake of his head. "That's one way to put it."
It's quiet between you two again. Your eyes glance around the hallway—at the people openly whispering about the pair of you. It sets your teeth on edge. Steve pays no mind to it. He continues to look at you.
"Just—think about it, yeah?" Steve finishes off lamely, scratching the back of his neck awkwardly as he interprets your silence as a dismissal.
You don't say anything—you just nod as Steve looks at you for a final time before walking away.
You feel a little empty but you're not entirely sure why.
The next panic attack you have comes in the middle of the night. It was stupid, really. Your nightlight had broken. The one you couldn't sleep without. No matter how many times that you unplugged and plugged it back in—it wouldn't turn back on.
Jonathan was asleep in the next room—Nancy likely with him. Your mom and her new boyfriend Bob were also asleep and Will—well, he was your younger brother, this wasn't something you could bother him with.
And so, you take a few shuddering breaths—hands shaking and heart racing as you willed the feeling of dread that had settled in your chest to go away. But try as you might, it doesn't lessen. It expands and feels so overwhelming that for a few moments, you worry it may never go away. That you were doomed to shaking hands and unsteady breathing forevermore.
And so, you do something you had never thought you would.
You tiptoe out of your room, careful to avoid looking at the stain of your blood still etched into the carpet as you head into the kitchen. You're still breathing uneasy, hands still shake as you search for your mom's phonebook.
You find the small book tucked away in the back drawer, you grab it and head over to the phone. Hands still shaking as you dial the number.
"This is stupid," you murmur tearfully, wiping your eyes as you hold the phone up to your ear. It was late—too late. You were second guessing yourself already. You should hang up—
"Hmph, Harrington Residence," the sleepy yet unmistakeable voice of Steve Harrington greets you and you let out a small sob of relief.
"H-hey Steve," you manage to stutter out, sniffling down the line as you cling to the phone as though it was your only lifeline. "It's me—it's (y/n)."
There's silence—well, as silent as it could be with you crying down the phone before Steve finally speaks.
"You want me to come over?" He asks simply.
You nod—before realising that Steve could not see you.
"Ye-yeah," is all you say.
Steve arrives quietly less than five minutes later. You wait out on the front porch, unable to stop your legs from shaking and your tears from falling. You feel as though you can't breathe. And when Steve's beamer pulls up—you still haven't calmed. You were only wearing your flimsy pyjamas but you weren't thinking about the cold. You were thinking about the blood—the lights—the claws of the demorogon ripping apart your flesh—
"Hey, hey," Steve's hands cup your face gently—so gently that he held you as though you were something precious. "Focus on me, yeah? Focus on me—"
"My n-nightlight b-broke," you tell him through gasping breaths. "It's s-so dark, Steve. it's t-too dark—"
"Okay. Okay," he hushes you gently, thumb rubbing over the apple of your cheek to wipe away some of the tears that had fallen. "Want me to look at it?"
You sniffle and nod, feeling utterly pathetic as you allow Steve to take your hand. To help you to stand up.
You allow him to lead you inside. Let him lead you into your bedroom quietly so to not wake up your family. The darkness is making your skin crawl and it takes everything in you not to start blubbering again. But Steve is there in an instant, switching on your main light, his hand on your back.
"Still here," he murmurs gently before he pulling away from you in order to grab the nightlight from your bedside table.
You nod, taking a few shuddering breaths as you sit down on your bed. Your hands still shake, you still feel that immense heaviness in your chest. The heaviness that refused to leave.
Steve watches you for a moment before he looks down at the nightlight. Admittedly, he didn't know why he had offered to have a look at it. He wasn't exactly an expert on broken lights. He had just wanted to help you in any way he could.
Five minutes pass by and Steve swears that he had made the situation with your nightlight worse. Now it was making a noise. He yanked out of the plug from the wall and looked at you apologetically.
"So—I may owe you a new nightlight," he says sheepishly.
You let a noise—somewhere between a laugh and a sob.
Steve's beside you in an instant—tentatively wrapping his arm around your shoulders. He doesn't say anything and you're grateful for that. He just holds you. Rubs his thumb gently along your shoulder every now and then.
"M'sorry," you murmur finally a few minutes later—when you had eventually calmed enough to talk. "S'just a stupid nightlight."
"Hey, it's not to you. The light means safety to you. It is important."
Your breath catches because fuck, Steve understood. He didn't think you were childish, silly or stupid. He just got it.
"I'm sorry I couldn't fix it," he whispers, thumb still moving over the small slither of exposed skin on your shoulder.
"It's okay. You tried."
It's quiet then. Aside from your sniffling and ragged breathing.
"I'm sorry I called," you say quietly. "I shouldn't have—"
"No, I'm glad you did."
More quiet follows. But it's not awkward, not at all. It makes that heaviness in your chest lift slightly.
"You—you said you have nightmares," you begin carefully, eyes lifting up to meet his.
Steve looks back at you—jaw tensing for a brief moment before he nods. "Yeah—I did say that."
"Wh-what are your nightmares about?" You ask him. You realise it was an invasion, perhaps a rude question to ask. But you wanted to try. To see if he was as willing to open up as you were.
There's a moment where Steve says nothing. Where just looks back at you blankly. You worry he was about to shut you down—tell you that you were impertinent for even asking.
But to your surprise, Steve doesn't do that. Instead, he gives your shoulder a gentle squeeze before he speaks.
"It's always the same. That night. I keep dreaming about it but—instead of saving you—you're already gone."
The admission takes you by surprise and for a moment, you say nothing—just look at him in shock.
And Steve? Well, his eyes are flickering down to your bare thighs—exposed by your pyjama shorts. You already know what he's looking at. Your scar. You quickly try to cover it but—
His fingers are already brushing along the tender flesh and it makes your breath hitch audibly. He looks up at you, his brown eyes warm and gentle, as his thumb scores along the raised skin.
"I just—I see it," Steve breathes out, his touch like fire against your skin. "Nearly every damn night. You bleeding out. Not being able to stop the demorogon from killing you. It—fuck (y/n), I—the sight fucking haunts me and—I know I didn't get hurt but I know how you feel. I really do. And that's why I know that you need someone—someone like me who lived it to lean on. Just a little. Let me be your anchor when you need to float."
You look back at him, swallowing down the intense emotions that you were feeling. You were scared. Of course you were—of relying on someone. Of needing someone.
"I need to float right now," you murmur back with a small smile that Steve returns.
"Okay," he nods, glancing around your room quickly as he removes his hand from your thigh. You find that you miss the feeling. "I think your nightlight is fucked—sorry. So um, I can get you a new one tomorrow and—I can stay here with you tonight—to help you sleep."
Your lips part in surprise—ready to shoot him down but Steve is quicker.
"I'll sleep on the floor," he adds. "I swear—no funny business. Just a friend making sure a friend gets to sleep."
"Friend?" You echo, the corners of your mouth twitching.
"Yeah," Steve smiles. "A friend."
You should say no. Should tell him that if your mom, Jonathan or Will caught Steve in your room in the morning—it would raise questions. Your mom would likely give you the birds and the bees talk again. Jonathan would question if you had been replaced by a clone. But you could no longer deny it—you needed him. Needed him just as much you needed him that night you nearly died.
"Extra pillows and blanket are in my closet," you tell him finally.
It's a ridiculous sight, really. Steve the hair Harrington pulling out pillows and blankets from your closet as you tuck yourself into your bed. He glances over at you before switching off the light. You tense but barely five seconds later, you hear Steve settle down on the floor beside your bed. And then—you feel his hand search for yours in the darkness.
You let him take it. Let him lace his fingers through yours. Let him squeeze your hand gently—a grounding gesture that made you feel warmer than any fire could.
"Thank you Steve," you tell him through the darkness. "For saving my life."
"Anytime," Steve whispers back. "Just don't make a habit out of dying on me."
You squeeze his hand. He squeezes back.
"I'll try my best."
"You better. Because you're stuck with me now, Byers."
Spencer prides himself on his ability to detect lies, to spot the tiniest inconsistencies in a person's story — it's the one thing he has always been able to rely on.
Which is why he feels such a disdain for the BAU's newest member. Unlike the rest of the team, Spencer isn't fooled by her veneer of normalcy. There's something off about her; a lack of warmth in her smiles, a lack of light behind her eyes...
She's hiding something. He knows she is.
He just needs to prove it, and her house of cards will come crashing down.
DISCLAIMER: this fic, whilst it is an x reader, features no use of y/n. the reader is instead referred to in vague terms — such as she or girl — or by her woefully ironic nickname: angel. additionally, the fic is narrated exclusively in third-person.
get to know angel here !
ACT ONE
001. Seven's a Crowd
when a new agent unexpectedly appears in the bullpen, spencer 'hates change' reid grows suspicious. can this mysterious woman be trusted, especially after he catches her in a lie on her first day?
002. Lucretius: Chaos and Order
five months into the new agent's stay at the bau, she earns herself a nickname — one that spencer believes to be wholly undeserved. as tensions continue to grow, so does spencer's suspicion.
003. The FBI Code of Conduct
after an incident on the jet almost leads to a physical altercation. both spencer and angel are subjected to lectures regarding their recent conduct. spencer tries to repair a bridge that was never built, and angel receives a call from her past.
004. Rackensack
the bau are called out to the remote town of st paul, arkansas to investigate a series of murders that leave windpipes crushed and fingers broken. when residents don't want to point fingers, can the team solve the case before the unsub finds their next victim? to make things worse, angel and reid have to share a motel room.
005. Smoking Kills
angel decides that the only way to get this case moving is to face their number one suspect one-on one. she quickly learns that such recklessness comes with a price.
006. Power
the team drag angel out on one of their notorious end-of-week evenings at the bar. with tensions at an all time high, can spencer keep himself in check after one too many whiskeys? (NSFW)
007. Family Matters
a case in alexandria hits a little too close to home for angel. despite their sour relationship, she is willing to risk her life, and her job, for spencer when a home visit go south.
008. City of Angels
the bau are summoned to los angeles to tackle another series of murders. maybe it's just the humidity, but things are beginning to heat up between spencer and his 'angel'. (NSFW)
009. Dreams, Nightmares
a nightmare. a pain-in-the-ass case. an interrogation that ends with a flipped table. these long days in la seem to have softened the hard shells of two problem agents.
010. Emergency Stop
a conduct review with strauss turns into an argument that should end her career, but angel returns to her desk without as much as a written warning. spencer finally snaps as she pushes him to his limit. (NSFW)
011. Control
after the incident in the elevator, after getting spencer to admit that no, he doesn't hate her, angel decides it's about time she rewarded him. after all, it would be a shame to leave him in such a state of desperation again. (NSFW)
012. The 206
a glimpse behind the curtain reveals a side of angel that spencer had not known existed. but whatever flame was kindled that night is extinguished when angel must follow the team to the worst place on earth: home.
013. Respect
when a case leaves her with nothing but a haunted heart and a terrible, bone-deep exhaustion, spencer offers angel a shoulder to lean on. she expresses her gratitude by humiliating him in front of the team, and pisses him off for the 'last' time.
014. Unforeseen Circumstances
an unexpected phone call may ruin spencer's sunday plans, but it also provides him with the opportunity to go on a date with his 'enemy' whom he has definitely not caught feelings for. too preoccupied with his newfound optimism, he fails to notice the unease that trickles in through the cracks of this spur-of-the-moment meeting.
015. Work the Case, part one
when it's revealed that angel is now missing, aaron hotchner has a choice to make. does he bring in the team and expose angel's criminal past, ruining their perception of her? or does he handle this alone and hope for the best? meanwhile, angel has a much needed catch-up with a certain ex-boyfriend.
016. Work the Case, part two
the bau are forced to reconcile with their coworker's criminal past. tensions rise as they realise the extent of her lies and begin questioning their faith in hotch. meanwhile, angel receives a call that completely derails her escape plan.
and more to come...
Status report: unfinished, more chapters coming soon!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Steve doesn’t notice when Hawkins stops feeling dangerous.
There’s no single morning where he wakes up and thinks, it’s over. It happens the way most things do now—quietly, without any spectacle. The streets look the same, the buildings haven’t moved, but the air isn’t tight anymore. People stand in grocery store aisles without scanning faces. Kids ride their bikes without looking over their shoulders.
The town exhaled, but it hasn’t moved on.
Steve lives somewhere between those two truths.
He drives the same roads every morning, past storefronts with sun-faded signs and stretches of land that never seem to change no matter how many seasons pass over them. He knows every turn without thinking, muscle memory carrying him through it. Hawkins feels familiar in the way something does when you’ve learned it by surviving it.
From the outside, his life looks settled, respectable even. He works at Hawkins Middle School —baseball coach and sex ed teacher. The kind of job that makes people pause when they hear his name attached to it, like they’re waiting for the punchline.
He’s good at it, in a way that surprises even him. He doesn’t rush through the uncomfortable parts or laugh things off. He talks about bodies like they’re just bodies, about sex like it can be healthy instead of shameful, and about consent like it matters—because it does. He sees himself become the teacher he wished he had.
The kids like him. He can tell by the way some of them linger after class, shuffling their feet, asking something quietly like they’re testing whether he really means it when he says there are no stupid questions.
Parents pass on praise, the principal nods at him in the hall and other teachers even ask him for lesson plans.
Steve accepts all of it easily, smiles in gratitude. But when he goes home at the end of the day, he sits on his couch with the familiar sense that something in him is still braced, still waiting.
Like Hawkins has a hand wrapped around his wrist—not tight enough to hurt, but just enough to remind him it’s still there.
–
The promise comes right after the younger ones graduate, when everyone is tired in a good way.
They’re on the rooftop, legs tangled with lawn chairs and lukewarm beer, the air warm with laughter that doesn’t have anywhere else to go.
Robin is the one with the idea. “We should do this more,” she says. “Like—actually do this. Once a month, in person, we can meet in a neutral area.”
Nancy smiles immediately, Jonathan nods sincerely, and Steve feels the agreement land in his chest before he realizes he’s already said yes.
The first month, everyone shows up.
They order pizza and sit on the floor because the couch isn’t big enough. They talk about work and movies and stupid things they’ve seen on the news. Steve drives home that night with the radio too loud, tapping the steering wheel, feeling lighter than he has in months.
The second month, Jonathan can’t make it. A work thing. He sounds genuinely apologetic on the phone.
The third month, Nancy is sick.
After that, it blurs. Robin phones late once. Jonathan again. Nancy again. Steve still goes, shows for every meet up but is left alone ordering a beer and snacks.
Eventually, he stops going. Not because he’s angry, but because it hurts more to be the only one to show up than not show up at all.
Dustin never disappears in the same way
He’s in college, splitting his time between campus and visits home, somehow busier than ever and still calling Steve more than anyone else does. Steve tries once—awkwardly—to give him an out, says something vague about being busy, about growing up.
“Nice try,” Dustin says immediately, like Steve has tried this argument before.
“You’re busy now,” Steve says, half-hearted. “College, new people—”
Dustin scoffs. “Valiant effort, but you’re not getting rid of me.”
Steve smiles despite himself.
“You die, I die, remember,” Dustin adds, softer but no less certain. “We had a suicide pact. Funny you think you can shake me that easily.”
It sits with Steve longer than he expects.
–
The first time Steve meets you, it’s by accident.
He ducks into a coffee shop he doesn’t like because he’s late and it’s closer than the one he usually goes to. You’re standing exactly where he needs to order, hunched over a notebook, chewing on the end of a pen like you’re thinking through something stubborn. When he clears his throat, you startle and laugh, apologizing like it’s your fault.
He thinks about your laugh all the way to work, until the chatter of students gives him a distraction.
The second time he meets you, it’s chance.
Steve is juggling envelopes he’s been meaning to mail for weeks, trying to shove one back into his jacket pocket when the door swings open too fast and collides with his shoulder. Papers slip. Someone mutters a curse at the exact same time he does.
“Sorry—”
You stop short when you see him. You just look at him, like you’ve caught the punchline of a joke that’s been unfolding without either of you realizing it.
“We have to stop meeting like this,” you say.
Steve blinks. Then he laughs, startled by how easily it comes. He opens his mouth to respond, something easy and flippant already forming, but you’re already stepping back, tugging the door open again.
The door shuts behind you. Steve stands there for a second longer than necessary, envelopes forgotten in his hand, replaying the sound of your voice like it might explain why his chest feels lighter than it did a moment ago.
The third time felt like coincidence.
A mutual acquaintance insists on squeezing everyone around a too-small table, introductions tumbling over one another in a rush. Steve is halfway distracted, nodding along, when you look at him and laugh.
“Hey,” you say, “coffee shop guy.”
“Post office,” he corrects automatically, then winces. “And the coffee shop. But you can call me Steve.”
“Nice to finally know your name,” you say. “I was starting to think we were just going to keep apologizing at each other forever.”
Steve realizes, much later, driving home with the radio off, that he’s laughed more in that hour than he has in days.
By the fourth time, it was something else.
He goes to the coffee shop where he first saw you, even though the coffee tastes like dirt. He orders it anyway, standing off to the side with the cup warming his hands, trying not to look at the door. He tells himself he’s not looking for you. That he just happens to be in the area. That convenience is a good enough excuse.
When you walk his shoulders sag in relief.
You spot him immediately. Your smile slows like you’re surprised to see him—but you’re glad he’s there.
“Okay,” you say, stopping in front of him. “Now I’m starting to think this is on purpose.”
Steve huffs out a laugh, glancing down at the cup in his hand like it might back him up. “I mean, I wouldn’t call it on purpose.” He shrugs, a little sheepish. “I keep telling myself I’m just passing by.”
“And the coffee?” you ask, nodding at his cup.
He grimaces. “Still bad.”
You smile. “So what’s the excuse today?”
He thinks about it for half a second, then gives up on pretending. “Guess I was hoping for better company.”
Your smile grows, softening into something warmer.
“Well,” you say, gesturing toward the empty chair at his table, “if you’re already here…”
This time, you sit together and when the conversation lulls, neither of you rush to leave.
And later—later enough that the details blur together—Steve thinks back to this afternoon and understands it as the moment something tilted.
Not because anything dramatic happened. Not because either of you said something that sounded like a decision. Just because he stopped treating your meetings like accidents and started making room for them on purpose.
Coffee turns into walking the long way instead of the fast one. Conversations stretch past what either of you had planned. He starts learning your schedule without meaning to, starts recognizing the way you take your coffee, the things you complain about and the things you never do.
It’s during one of those long conversations that you talk about Hawkins plainly.
You tell him you’re only there temporarily—work, a project, something with an end date attached. You don’t dress it up or soften it. You just say it, like it’s a fact that doesn’t need reassurance.
Steve likes that about you, your honesty. The way you don’t try to pretend the town is more than it is.
Neither of you names what’s happening, there’s no conversation where lines are drawn or expectations laid out - just a gradual understanding, built out of small choices.
You start staying later, leaving jackets behind, sitting closer without acknowledging it.
The first time you fall asleep on his couch, it’s accidental.
A movie neither of you is really watching. The late hour sneaking up on you. Steve wakes sometime after midnight with his neck stiff and your head tipped toward his shoulder, breathing slow and even.
He doesn’t move.
In the morning, he makes coffee while you brush your teeth with his spare toothbrush, both of you acting like this is normal—like it’s been happening longer than it has.
After that, it happens again.
And again.
You stay over without asking. Grocery shop together because it’s easier than going separately. You fall asleep in his bed now, instead of the couch.
Steve doesn’t realize how much space he’s been holding open in his life until you start to occupy it.
When he finally notices, it doesn’t feel like something has changed.
It just feels easy.
–
Sleep thins without him noticing.
One moment there’s nothing but the low, indistinct quiet of rest, and the next there’s weight in his chest — pressure building where it shouldn’t be. Sound creeps in first, the way it always does. Metal scraping against metal, too close, too loud, vibrating through him like it’s happening just behind his eyes. His hands are suddenly slick, fingers fumbling for purchase on something that won’t stay still.
The space around him narrows, the air turns sharp. Heavy. His chest locks up, breath stuttering as the sense of urgency spikes without direction. Someone is shouting. Maybe his name. Maybe it’s his own voice tearing out of him.
He wakes with a gasp, heart racing, lungs burning like he’s been underwater too long.
For a few disorienting seconds, he can’t tell where he is. The room is dark and unfamiliar, his body still braced for impact, adrenaline buzzing hot through his veins.
This part is familiar.
Nightmares aren’t new to him. His body knows this terrain — knows how to surface from it, how to stay half-awake and half-gone until the worst of it passes. Most nights, he rides it out alone: staring at the ceiling, counting his breathing and waiting for morning.
But this time it’s different.
There’s warmth beside him. A shift in the mattress, hand already reaching for him before he can steady himself.
“Steve.”
The sound of his name pulls him back faster than usual, grounding him in a way he isn’t used to.
You’re there before he can pull himself together.
He doesn’t remember reaching for you, only that suddenly your arms are around him, firm and warm, anchoring him to the bed, to the room, to the present. The contrast is jarring in the best way—your body solid against his, your breathing slow and real where his is still ragged and uneven.
You don’t ask what he saw, you don’t ask him to explain, you just hold him.
“You’re safe,” you say, close to his ear. Your voice is steady, like you’ve said this before, like you know it’s true. “I’ve got you.”
Something inside him gives way at that. It isn’t loud or dramatic. It’s the quiet kind of breaking, the kind that happens when something has been held together by sheer force for too long and finally realizes it doesn’t have to anymore. His breath stutters, shoulders shaking as the tension drains out of him in uneven waves. He presses his face into your shoulder, fingers curling into the fabric of your shirt like it’s proof that this is real, that he’s here.
You don’t move, don’t rush him, don’t shush him or try to fix anything. You just stay, one hand firm at his back, the other threading gently through his hair, grounding him until the racing in his chest slows and the room comes back into focus around them.
It takes a while.
Long enough that the adrenaline fades into exhaustion, and the sharp edges of the dream dull, leaving only the ache behind. When his breathing finally evens out, when the shaking subsides into something manageable, you’re still there, exactly where he left you.
Later—long after sleep starts to seep back into the room and the dark has softened into something quieter—you brush your thumb over his knuckles. The touch is small, deliberate, like you’re checking in without asking him to speak.
“You don’t have to tell me,” you say gently. “But you should talk to someone.”
The words don’t feel like pressure or an ultimatum. Instead they land softly, like an open door.
Still, his first instinct is to pull back.
He tells himself he’s fine, that this isn’t new. He’s had worse nights than this and survived them just fine on his own. He tells himself he’s healing—that the nightmares come less often now, that he knows how to ride them out. He tells himself he doesn’t want to drag you into parts of his life you didn’t sign up for, things that are sharp and heavy and shouldn’t be yours to carry.
But the past doesn’t leave him.
It lingers in the days that follow, in the way his shoulders tense without warning, in how his breath catches when something metal scrapes unexpectedly. It shows up in small ways—in how tired he feels, like he’s been bracing for something that never quite arrives.
He realizes, slowly, that he’s been mistaking endurance for healing.
That surviving something doesn’t mean his body knows it’s over, pushing forward isn’t the same as moving on. He’s learned how to function, how to keep going—but not how to rest.
The idea of therapy makes his stomach twist.
Talking about it means naming it. Letting someone see how much of him is still shaped by things that shouldn’t have happened to anyone. It means admitting that what he went through wasn’t normal—and that maybe it left marks he can’t just will away.
But he’s tired.
Tired of waking up already clenched. Tired of carrying it alone. Tired of pretending that if he just keeps his head down, it’ll eventually disappear on its own.
So he goes.
Not because he’s ready.
Not because it feels easy.
But because, for the first time, he doesn’t want to keep living like this forever.
–
Therapy doesn’t fix him. It doesn’t erase anything or make the memories stop arriving when they want to. What it does is quieter than that. Stranger.
It makes him notice.
The first few sessions are mostly silence. Steve sits with his hands folded together, shoulders tight, answering questions carefully, like there are right and wrong ways to talk about things. He keeps his eyes on the clock more than he means to.
“You don’t have to perform here,” his therapist tells him once, gently. “There’s nothing you need to get right.”
He doesn’t know what to do with that.
Steve doesn’t explain the specifics. He frames it the way Hawkins always has — a series of disasters, near misses, things no one wants to name. He talks about getting hurt, about protecting kids when he was just a teenager himself, about losing pieces of his childhood along the way. He talks about the way his body still acts like the danger isn’t over.
Some days, she doesn’t ask him to talk at all. She asks him to breathe.
“Put one hand on your chest,” she says. “One on your stomach. Just notice which one moves when you inhale.”
He feels ridiculous doing it at first. Still, he does it. He realizes his chest barely moves at all. Everything stays locked high and tight, like his body is bracing for impact.
“That’s not failure,” she says when he mentions it. “Just a habit.”
The word sticks with him.
Habit means learned. Habit means changeable.
Over time, therapy becomes less about surviving memories and more about paying attention to the present. He learns how to slow his breathing when his chest tightens for no obvious reason, how to sit with his back against the chair instead of perched on the edge, ready to bolt.
The changes are small, but they stack.
He begins to understand that his body has been surviving on instinct for years — and that instinct doesn’t disappear just because the danger does.
“What you went through wasn’t normal,” his therapist says one afternoon, not gently, but firmly.
Steve blinks.
“People don’t experience that and come out unchanged,” she continues. “Your body adapted because it had to. We’re not trying to erase that. We’re teaching it that the danger is over.”
That reframing lands harder than anything else has.
Not broken.
Adapted.
Some days he leaves therapy exhausted in a way that feels earned. Other days, he sleeps deeper than he has in years. He starts noticing when his body is reacting to something that isn’t actually happening anymore. Starts catching himself mid-spiral and slowing down instead of pushing through it.
One afternoon, as he squints at a worksheet she’s handed him, his therapist pauses.
“You do that a lot,” she says.
“Do what?”
“That.” She gestures vaguely at his face. “You strain when you’re concentrating. Do you get headaches?”
Steve thinks about the dull ache behind his eyes at the end of the school day. About how close he stands to the chalkboard without realizing it.
“Yeah,” he admits.
“It might be worth getting your eyes checked,” she says, like it’s an aside. “When you’ve spent years bracing, you don’t always notice the smaller things.”
The idea lingers.
A week later, he walks out of an optometrist’s office with a prescription and the strange sense that therapy has taught him how to notice — not just fear, not just memory, but his own body asking for care.
The glasses are just proof that he’s finally listening.
When he wears them around you for the first time, he keeps adjusting like they don’t belong. You reach up and straighten them gently.
“They suit you,” you say. “You look cute.”
The word settles somewhere soft.
–
You ask him a life changing question on an ordinary Tuesday night.
The TV hums in the background, something half-watched and already forgotten. Steve is on the floor with his back against the couch, glasses pushed up into his hair, sorting through a stack of mail he’s been ignoring. You’re curled into the corner of the couch above him, knees tucked under you, flipping pages of a book you don’t seem especially invested in.
You close your book.
“Can I ask you something?” you say.
Steve doesn’t look up from the pile of mail in his hands. He shrugs, casual, automatic.
“You just did.”
You smile at that, but you don’t let it derail you.
“What do you want to do?”
He pauses. Glances back at you over his shoulder. “What do you mean?”
“I mean—” He hears the smile in your voice now. “What do you want to do?”
He squints slightly, like he’s trying to line the question up with something familiar. “Like… tomorrow? Because tomorrow I’ve got practice after school, and—”
You laugh, quiet and gentle, and shake your head. “No. Not tomorrow.”
He sets the mail down slowly, turning his body a little so he can look at you properly.
“I mean,” you continue, “you’re always talking about things you might do someday. You say it like that every time. Someday.”
Steve frowns. “Okay…?”
“When is someday for you, Steve?”
The question lands differently now.
He opens his mouth, tries for something light, something practiced. “I don’t know. I haven’t really thought about it.”
You wait.
“I mean, I have a job here,” he adds. “I grew up here.”
You nod, understanding but unmoved. “Yeah. I know. And if you like that—if you like Hawkins and the life you have here—that’s good.”
He exhales, relieved for half a second.
“But that’s not what I asked,” you say gently. “Those are just… facts. Obligations. Things that happened to you.”
Steve’s brow creases. “What’s wrong with that?”
“Nothing,” you say quickly. “Nothing at all. I just—” You hesitate, choosing your words carefully. “I don’t think you ever stopped to ask whether you chose it.”
He goes quiet.
“I guess,” he says slowly, “I thought this was it.”
You tilt your head. “It?”
“This life,” he says, gesturing vaguely around the room. “The job. Staying. I was handed it, and it made sense, so I went along with it. I didn’t realize I had a choice.” He lets out a soft, humorless laugh. “And now that I do… I don’t know what to do with it.”
You don’t rush to fill the silence.
“That’s okay,” you say after a moment. “Nobody has everything figured out. We change all the time. It’d be weird if you suddenly had all the answers.”
He considers that.
“I like working with kids,” he says finally. “I know that much… I don’t want to stop doing that.”
Your face softens. “That’s great. See? You’ve already narrowed it down.”
He huffs a breath, half a laugh. “Guess so.”
Then his expression shifts, something tightening behind his eyes.
“But I don’t want to stay in Hawkins,” he admits quietly. “This place doesn’t feel like mine anymore.”
You stay still, letting him say it.
“It’s like everything I did here mattered,” he continues. “And I don’t regret any of it. I really don’t.” His voice dips. “I just… I don’t think I want to stay inside it forever.”
He waits for it then.
The guilt.
The shame.
The familiar sense that wanting something else means he’s abandoning something important.
It doesn’t come.
Instead, there’s a quiet ache. And underneath it — relief.
“If you wanted something different,” you ask carefully, “would you let yourself try it?”
The question scares him more than the nightmare did.
“I don’t even know what that would look like,” he admits.
“That’s okay,” you say. “You don’t have to know yet. You just have to know you’re allowed to want it.”
Allowed.
The word settles heavy and strange in his chest.
Later — long after you’ve gone to bed — Steve stays on the floor where he is, mail forgotten beside him. The TV has gone dark, reflecting his own face back at him, quieter than he remembers it being.
For the first time, when he thinks about the future, it doesn’t immediately settle into a shape.
And instead of panicking, he lets it stay that way.
–
Nothing feels different right away.
Hawkins doesn’t react to the conversation you had, the town keeps moving like it always has.
What changes is smaller than that.
He starts noticing how often he thinks, later, and how vague the word suddenly feels. Steve feels it in the days that follow, in the way Hawkins starts to feel slightly misaligned around him. The same streets, the same routines — but now he notices how often he’s moving through them on autopilot. How little of it feels chosen.
You don’t bring it up again. Not directly.
You go about your days the same way you always have, still talking about your work, your timeline, the quiet inevitability of leaving. Steve listens differently now. Less he’s filing away information from someone else’s life, more like he’s standing at the edge of his own.
It comes up the night you’re cooking together, the kitchen warm and slightly too small, your shoulders brushing as you move around each other without thinking about it.
It’s peaceful in a way that still catches him off guard.
Therapy has made him more aware of moments like this. How his shoulders aren’t up around his ears, how his breathing is slow and even, how he isn’t scanning the room for exits. He notices these things now, the absence of tension registering almost as clearly as its presence used to.
“When I’m done here,” you say casually, stirring the pot, “I’ll head back to New York.”
Steve stills. “New York,” he repeats, like he’s trying it out.
You nod. “Yeah. There’s a new project that looks like something good, could be permanent if New York is interesting enough.”
He leans back against the counter, fingers curling around the edge of it. The question he’s been carrying settles into place, heavy and unavoidable now that it has somewhere to land.
“Can I ask you something?” he says.
You glance at him, amusement in your eyes, “You just did.”
He almost laughs. Almost lets it go. Instead, he exhales and says it anyway.
“When you leave,” he says carefully, “can I… can I come with you?”
–
It’s late enough that the street outside has settled into something distant and low, the city noise more of a hum than presence. Boxes sit half-packed around the living room, flaps open like they’re waiting for him to decide what matters enough to keep.
He hasn’t called Dustin yet because saying it out loud feels like making it real.
When he finally does, he paces without realizing, stepping around stacks of books and folded clothes, the phone warm in his hand as it rings.
“Hey,” Dustin says, a little breathless, “What’s up?”
Steve exhales. “So… I’m moving.”
There’s a pause.
Not the kind that stretches uncomfortably, just the kind that feels like someone processing something big and good.
“Yes,” Dustin says immediately. “I mean, yeah. It’s such a cool place, there’s stuff happening all the time. Live music, weird food, actual culture. You’re gonna love it.”
The encouragement hits harder than Steve expects.
“You’re not mad?” he asks.
“Mad?” Dustin scoffs. “Dude, you’re allowed to move.”
Steve blinks.
“I mean it,” Dustin continues, tone shifting just enough to carry weight without losing warmth. “You don’t have to be the protector of Hawkins anymore. You’ve done enough. Like… more than enough.”
Steve swallows.
“That place isn’t your responsibility,” Dustin adds gently. “It hasn’t been for a long time.”
The words land somewhere deep. He hadn’t realized how much he needed to hear them.
“I was hoping you’d say that,” Steve admits quietly.
“Of course I’d say that,” Dustin replies. “You gave so much of yourself to that town. It’s okay to want something for yourself now.”
Steve leans back against the counter, breathing easier. “Yeah.”
“And hey,” Dustin says, brightening again, “this just means I get to visit you in New York, I’ll split my time. Best of both worlds.”
Steve exhales, warm and steady now. “You make it sound simple.”
“It is simple,” Dustin says. “You deserve good things.” After a moment, Dustin’s voice softens. “What about your parents?”
Steve’s gaze drifts to the far wall, to a photo he hasn’t touched since he moved in — a version of himself frozen at seventeen, hair perfect, smile rehearsed.
“If they even care to notice,” he says. “I haven’t talked to them since they left Hawkins.”
Dustin doesn’t interrupt.
“I get an occasional postcard in the mail,” Steve continues. “So maybe I’ll do the same. Seems fair.”
There’s no anger in it. Just distance that’s been there so long it doesn’t ache anymore.
“Yeah,” Dustin says finally. “Their loss.”
Steve nods, even though Dustin can’t see it. “Yeah.”
“I’ll come see the place once you’re settled. Make sure you’re not living in some sad little shoebox.”
When he hangs up, his house feels changed.
Not empty.
Just unfinished, outgrown- in a way.
Packing takes longer than he expects.
Not because there’s so much stuff — there isn’t — but because every item seems to ask him a question. He opens drawers he hasn’t looked in for months only to find things he forgot he even owned. Things he forgot he kept.
He fills a box with clothes first.
Books come next. He hesitates there, flipping through familiar pages, then stacks them carefully like they might matter again someday.
The hardest part is the wall.
The Hawkins photos come down last. He holds them longer than necessary, thumb brushing the corners before laying them in the box. He doesn’t know where they’ll go in the new place yet. Just that he isn’t ready to leave it behind.
He sets it gently into a box labeled MISC, like that makes it less significant.
By the time he tapes the final flap shut for the night, his room looks unfamiliar.
Bare.
Steve sits on the floor among the boxes, back against his bed, and lets the quiet settle around him. The life he’s built here isn’t disappearing — it’s just being folded carefully, put away so it can be carried forward.
For the first time, the idea of leaving doesn’t feel like loss.
–
The drive to New York feels longer than it should.
Not because the distance is overwhelming, but because Steve keeps catching himself looking in the rearview mirror, half-expecting Hawkins to follow him somehow. It doesn’t. The town recedes quietly, mile by mile, until it becomes just another place he used to know.
By the time they reach the city, the light is different.
Sharper. Louder. Everything feels closer together, stacked on top of itself instead of spread out. Steve double-parks without realizing it, hops out of the car, and just stands there for a second, staring up at the building like it might tell him something.
The apartment is smaller than Hawkins ever allowed things to be.
But it’s bright. Sunlight spills in through tall windows, dust floats lazily in the air, and the floors creak when he steps inside. It smells faintly of paint and something unfamiliar — not bad, just new.
Steve sets the boxes down but doesn’t unpack right away.
He walks from room to room instead, touching doorframes, opening cabinets, testing light switches like he’s learning the shape of a life that hasn’t started yet. The noise of the city hums through the windows — voices, traffic, something distant and alive.
This place doesn’t know him, yet.
You go out to grab dinner because neither of you has the energy to cook and the boxes aren’t going anywhere. Steve stays behind, claiming he’ll start unpacking, even though neither of you believes that’s what he’ll actually do.
The apartment goes quiet, as the door clicks shut behind you.
Steve wanders into the bathroom, flips on the light, and catches his reflection in the mirror. His hair is still perfect, still styled the way it always has been. Steve “The Hair” Harrington staring back at him like nothing’s changed.
He thinks about Dustin’s voice in his ear.
You don’t have to be the protector anymore.
The clippers are in the box under the sink — bought years ago for reasons he’d told himself were practical. He crouches, pulls them out, sets them on the counter without fully committing.
He stands there for a long moment.
Then he plugs them in.
The buzzing sound fills the small bathroom, loud and startling in the quiet apartment. His hand hesitates just a second before he lifts the clippers to his head. When he finally presses them against his scalp, hair falls immediately into the sink.
There’s no taking it back after that.
Steve watches his reflection carefully as he moves the clippers again, slower this time. The person staring back at him starts to look different — less polished, more stripped down. The hair that took time and effort and attention disappears in uneven lines, revealing something raw underneath.
It’s different, but he doesn’t hate it.
He’s halfway through when the front door opens.
“Steve?” you call out, setting dinner down in the kitchen. “They messed up the order, but I think it’s still—”
You stop short in the doorway.
Steve freezes, clippers mid-buzz, hair scattered everywhere, expression caught somewhere between guilty and caught-in-the-act.
“I—” He clears his throat, tries to laugh it off. “I was just… it felt like time?”
You take him in slowly, sink full of hair, clippers in his hand, and a look on his face like he’s bracing for permission he doesn’t need.
You smile, “I love your hair,” you say easily. “You know that.”
His shoulders tense.
“But,” you add, stepping closer, voice gentle, “I love more than just your hair.”
You reach out, brushing the remaining loose strands from his forehead with your fingers. “You’re allowed to change,” you tell him.
Something in his chest loosens as he exhales, long and slow, the way he’s been practicing. “Yeah?”
“Yeah,” you say.
Steve turns back to the mirror, you take the clippers from him, finishing what he started as he gives you a determined nod. When the clippers finally switch off, the silence feels different — lighter.
He meets his own eyes in the mirror again.
He doesn’t recognize himself completely.
And for the first time, that doesn’t scare him.
–
Light pours in through the windows hitting the bare walls, the half-unpacked boxes, the unmade mattress on the floor. Steve pads into the bathroom and catches his reflection again, the buzzcut surprising him.
It makes his face look sharper, older. Less like someone trying to hold a shape and more like someone letting one go. He runs a hand over it without thinking, feeling the unfamiliar texture under his palm.
Unpacking happens slowly, in no particular order. He starts with the kitchen because it feels easiest — plates stacked, mugs lined up, the coffee maker claiming a permanent spot on the counter.
The wall comes next.
He hesitates before unpacking that box, the one labeled MISC. When he opens it, the Hawkins photos are right on top. He takes them out carefully, brushing the papers with his fingers, and holds them up against the wall.
For a moment, he thinks about leaving them in the box, but he hangs them anyway.
They look different here, smaller, like a chapter instead of the whole story.
New York fills in around that decision without asking permission.
Steve starts walking more than he ever did in Hawkins — not because he has somewhere to be, but because the city seems to reward movement. He learns which streets feel quieter, which bodegas remember his face, which coffee tastes passable if he doesn’t think too hard about it.
Music comes to him as a form of therapy.
It was never his plan or even a dream he filed away under someday. But it still happens because someone at a bar is complaining about a missing guitarist, because Steve has had two beers and nothing to lose, because raising his hand feels easier here than it ever did back home.
His fingers are rusty and the nerves catch him off guard. But when he steps onto the small stage — if it can even be called that — and adjusts the strap over his shoulder, the fear he feels is..nice. Different from the fear he’s used to, nothing like survival or memory or what might happen if he fails.
The band starts as a loose thing, people drifting in and out. Practices that turn into routine without anyone naming it. Steve stands on stage again and again, guitar in hand, heart thudding for reasons that feel good to have.
He calls you before his first real show, voice tight with something like disbelief. You meet him at the bar early, sit beside him while he picks at the label on his beer, while the nerves buzz through him like electricity.
Afterward, when it’s done and he’s flushed and grinning and slightly overwhelmed, you take a picture together, your shoulder pressed into his side.
He pins it to the wall when he gets home.
Jonathan reaches out not long after — a phone call, late in the evening, his voice slightly hesitant like he’s not sure how to step back into the space between them.
“Hey,” Jonathan says. “Heard you’re in town.”
Steve smiles into the receiver. “Yeah, just got settled.”
They don’t make a big deal out of it, give no explanations, no apologies, just an agreement to meet when Jonathan’s schedule allows.
And they do.
Not often — Jonathan’s life moves fast now, full of projects and deadlines and momentum — but more than they used to. Coffee here, a show there, sometimes just a walk when neither of them feels like talking.
It’s easier without Hawkins sitting between them.
Dustin shows up a few weeks later, loud in the hallway before Steve even opens the door.
He stops short when he sees him.
“Oh my god,” Dustin says, staring openly. “You did it.”
Steve rubs a hand over his head. “Yeah.”
Dustin grins. “Dude. You know how much money you’ll save now? No more Farrah Fawcett spray.”
Steve laughs, shoving Dustin first and then pulling him into a hug.
Dustin’s expression softens, eyes scanning him more carefully. “You look good,” he says. “Like… actually good. Free.”
They spend the day walking until Dustin’s legs give out, eating food Steve suggests, and laughing too loudly in places where no one cares. That night, Dustin sits cross-legged on the floor, staring at the wall.
“You adding to it?” he asks.
Steve nods.
Over time, the wall fills in.
You at a baseball game, sunburned and smiling.
The two of you at the bar before his first show, his nerves written all over his face.
Dustin in the front row, cheering too loudly, hands cupped around his mouth like he’s afraid Steve might forget he’s there.
The Hawkins photos stay, but they aren’t alone anymore.
The past doesn’t disappear, it just makes room.
–
There’s no proposal the way Steve imagined there to be. No moment where he drops to one knee or rehearses anything in front of a mirror. It happens the way everything else with you has happened — in pieces, in glances, in the shared understanding that keeps showing up before he has to name it.
You’re already living like it’s permanent.
Like this isn’t a chapter with an end date attached.
The idea settles quietly, and once it does, it doesn’t feel heavy. It feels obvious.
The courthouse isn’t something he plans months in advance. It’s something he brings up one night while you’re brushing your teeth side by side, like it’s just another practical thing to consider.
“What would you think about getting married?” he asks, voice casual, eyes on his reflection instead of yours.
You pause for half a second.
Then you smile.
“Yeah,” you say. “I’d like that.”
That’s it.
He makes the calls a few days later, standing by the window with the city spread out beneath him. He leaves voicemails for Robin, Nancy, and Jonathan — short, unpolished, a little awkward.
“Hey, it’s Steve. Um. I’m getting married. It’s… soon. You don’t have to come, obviously. Just thought I’d tell you.”
He doesn’t expect anyone to show.
On the morning of the wedding, the city moves like it always does. The courthouse smells faintly like paper and floor cleaner and something metallic Steve can’t place. It’s busier than he expected — people moving through with folders tucked under their arms, conversations overlapping, lives intersecting briefly and then peeling off again.
No one is paying attention and Steve is okay with that.
Dustin is already there, leaning back in a plastic chair like he owns the place, legs stretched out in front of him. He looks up when Steve walks in and breaks into a grin so wide it borders on offensive.
“You ready?” Dustin asks, bouncing to his feet.
Steve exhales, glancing at you. You nod once, calm and steady like you always are when it matters.
“Yeah,” Steve says. “Yeah, I think so.”
Dustin claps him on the shoulder. “Cool. Just making sure. Because there’s no backing out now. Legally speaking.”
Steve snorts. “You’re the worst, best man.”
“The best worst best man,” Dustin corrects.
He’s holding your hand, waiting for your turn when he hears his name.
“Steve?”
Robin stands near the entrance, hands shoved into the pockets of her jacket like she doesn’t quite know what to do with them. Nancy is beside her, hair tucked neatly behind her ears, expression soft and bright. Jonathan hangs back a step, camera slung around his neck more out of intention than habit, this time.
For a second, Steve just stares.
“You… you came,” he says, dumbfounded.
Robin grins, wide and unapologetic. “Well, yeah. We can’t miss the big moments, can we?”
Something tight and old loosens in his chest.
Nancy steps forward first, hugging him carefully, like she’s afraid he might vanish if she does it too hard. “Congratulations,” she says. “We’re really happy for you.”
Jonathan claps him on the shoulder, familiar and grounding. “Wouldn’t have missed it.”
Steve swallows, nodding because words feel unreliable right now.
The ceremony itself is short, efficient. A woman with kind eyes and a voice that sounds like she’s done this a thousand times asks them both the same simple questions. Steve answers without hesitation.
This isn’t nerves.
It’s gravity.
When he looks at you, standing across from him in the narrow space between benches, it hits him how long you’ve already been choosing each other. How this isn’t the end but just the beginning.
“I do,” he says, steady and sure.
When it’s over — when the papers are signed and stamped and slid across the desk — Dustin lets out a low whistle.
“Well,” he says. “That’s official.”
Steve laughs, breathless and bright. “Guess it is.”
Nancy suggests drinks, misty eyes disagreeing with the smile on her face — nothing fancy, just a bar close enough to walk to. The kind of place that doesn’t care why you’re celebrating as long as you order something.
The booth is small, knees knocking, voices overlapping as everyone flips through the menu. Jonathan orders a beer, Robin orders something loud and colorful, Nancy follows with a wine, while Dustin—very much still in his college era—orders shots for the table like it’s a foregone conclusion.
When it’s your turn, you hesitate.
“I’ll just do a ginger ale,” you say. “And water.”
The table goes quiet — just briefly.
Steve glances at you, as your hand finds his under the table. His thumb brushes your knuckles, instinctive, grounding. A soft smile passes between the both of you, a private moment that might not be so private anymore.
Jonathan smiles first. “Guess those nuggets are coming sooner than expected, huh?”
Steve laughs, a little shaky, rubbing his hand over your stomach without thinking, “Guess I’ve always been bad at waiting.”
As the conversation resumes, lighter now, Steve leans back and watches them, the people he once thought he’d lost to time and distance, and understands something with startling clarity.
They never stopped loving him.
They just needed distance from Hawkins — from the place that held too much memory, too much survival packed into too few streets. Leaving wasn’t about forgetting each other. It was about being able to breathe again.
And when Steve stayed — when he remained tethered to it — he became something they couldn’t look at without feeling the weight of everything they were trying to outgrow.
It wasn’t rejection.
It was self-preservation.
And now that he’s left as well, he understands that.
The space between them doesn’t feel like loss anymore, it feels like something they can finally cross.
–
Life is already full when Steve decides to go back to school.
Full in the way that leaves very little room for second thoughts — for hesitation or careful timing. Days are built around sleep schedules that change without warning. Nights blur together, measured in feedings and soft pacing across the apartment floor, your daughter tucked against his shoulder while the city hums on outside.
He brings it up one evening while you’re folding laundry together, your daughter asleep between you on the couch. He says it casually, like it isn’t something he’s been turning over in his head for weeks.
“I’ve been thinking about school again,” he says.
You don’t look surprised.
Child Counseling feels inevitable once he says it out loud. It clicks into place the same way everything else has — not as a reinvention, but as a narrowing. A choice made quieter and more assured because it’s grounded in what he already knows.
The irony isn’t lost on him.
He studies child development while learning, in real time, what it means to soothe a crying infant. He reads about attachment and emotional regulation with spit-up on his shirt, highlighting passages one-handed while your daughter naps nearby. His professors are more understanding than he expects — deadlines extended, conversations held over the phone instead of in person when things run late.
He shows up to class tired and earnest and completely unashamed of it.
You make it work together.
On the days he’s buried in coursework, you juggle your job and the baby without complaint, passing her back to him in the evenings like a relay race. On the days his schedule is lighter, he takes over without being asked, already moving in sync with you.
There’s no keeping score.
Steve notices the difference in the smallest things.
In how no one raises their voice just to be heard. In how apologies come quickly and without pride attached. In how love isn’t something that has to be proven through endurance or silence.
At night, when the apartment finally settles and your daughter sleeps between you, Steve lies awake sometimes, listening to the steady rhythm of her breathing.
He always knew he wanted a marriage different than his parents.
But this isn’t just different. It’s better.
Better than anything sixteen-year-old Steve could’ve imagined. This version is messier, louder in love, built out of shared exhaustion and deliberate care.
–
Robin comes over on a Tuesday.
Not for anything special. Just because she’s in town, because she misses the girls, because she’s decided — without ever saying it out loud — that she’s the favorite aunt and intends to maintain that status aggressively.
She’s on the floor with your daughters, surrounded by plastic animals and crayons, fully committed to a tea party that makes absolutely no sense. Steve watches from the kitchen, half-listening as he flips through a folder of notes from work, the familiar weight of the day settling comfortably into his shoulders.
He’s a counselor now — a formal promotion from the babysitter he once was, still showing up the same way he always has, just with a paycheck and a lot less monster-hunting.
The thought still feels strange sometimes — not because it doesn’t fit, but because it fits so well.
When the girls scatter toward their room, Robin flops back against the couch with a groan, staring at the ceiling.
“I’ve been thinking,” she says.
Steve hums. “That’s never a good sign.”
She kicks his shin lightly with her socked foot. “Rude. Also incorrect.”
He smiles, closing the folder. “What’s up?”
There’s a pause. A longer one than usual.
“I might ask her out,” Robin says quickly, like ripping off a bandage.
Steve blinks. “Who?”
“The girl,” she says. “The one I told you about.”
“Oh,” he says, nodding. “Yeah. You should do that.”
She squints at him. “That’s it?”
“What, you want a parade?”
“I don’t know,” she mutters. “I just thought you’d… I don’t know. Ask questions.”
He shrugs. “You seem like you’ve thought about it enough for both of us.”
She huffs, but there’s a smile tugging at her mouth. Then, all at once, the words tumble out.
“It’s Nancy.”
Steve stills.
Just for a second.
“You wanna ask out my ex?” he says mildly.
Robin panics immediately.
“What? No— I mean, yes, but— not like that— I didn’t plan it— I just—” She sits up, flailing. “Okay, when I say it out loud it sounds bad.”
Steve laughs.
Not sharp. Not surprised. Just amused in a way that makes her stop short.
“You already knew?” she asks, putting the pieces together.
He nods toward the hallway. “The wife clocked it the last time you two came over, said there was some… unresolved tension. Sexual to be more specific.”
Robin groans, collapsing back against the couch. “I hate when she’s right.”
“She usually is,” Steve agrees fondly.
Robin peeks at him sideways. “You’re… okay with this?”
Steve thinks about it for half a second.
About the life he has now. About the kids’ shoes by the door. About the steady rhythm of the days. About how Nancy exists in his life now as someone he loves — not someone he aches for.
“Yeah,” he says honestly. “I am.”
Robin exhales like she’s been holding her breath for years. She scoots closer and wraps him in a sudden hug, tight and unselfconscious.
“Thank you,” she murmurs.
“For what?”
“For being you,” she says. “For being… okay.”
He squeezes her back. “You deserve to be happy.”
She pulls away, eyes bright. “So do you, Harrington.”
–
Best man suits him in a way he didn’t expect. Not because of the attention — he’s never loved that — but because of the steadiness of it. Being the one who holds the rings. Who knows where everyone is supposed to be. Who keeps Dustin from vibrating out of his own skin before the ceremony even starts.
“You good?” Steve asks, low.
Dustin nods emphatically. “No. But yes. But also no.”
Steve grins. “Perfect. That’s how you know it’s real.”
Dustin’s wedding is everything you’d expect it to be.
The ceremony is chaotic in the way only Dustin Henderson could manage — heartfelt and slightly off-kilter, laughter bleeding into places it probably shouldn’t. Steve watches from beside him, hands clasped, chest tight with something like pride.
Robin wipes her eyes aggressively from the front row. Nancy leans toward her, murmuring something that makes her snort despite herself. Jonathan’s a few rows back, camera in hand — not constant, not intrusive — just lifting it when something feels worth keeping.
Steve notices all of it.
When it’s over, when applause fills the room and Dustin turns to him, eyes bright and damp and disbelieving, Steve pulls him into a hug without thinking.
“You did it,” Steve says.
Dustin laughs into his shoulder, “Look at us, a couple of lady killers.”
The reception fills quickly — voices overlapping, music just a little too loud. As the song swells, Steve ends up on the edge of the dance floor, your oldest clinging to his leg, he tries to swing her around at first, one hand steady at her back, movements a little unsure — until he bends and lifts her into his arms. She settles against his chest immediately, small hands fisting in his jacket as he shifts his weight and starts to sway properly, slow and deliberate.
From across the floor, he sees you sitting near the dessert bar, watching with an easy smile, one hand resting over your stomach, the subtle curve easy to miss unless someone’s paying attention. Nancy slips into the chair beside you a moment later, lifting your second into her lap, Robin follows soon after, her gaze flicking between you and Steve before settling where your hand rests.
Steve sees the way Nancy’s eyebrows lift, the way Robin stills. He watches Nancy lean in, murmur something low. Robin’s eyes widen, she looks at you, then across the room at him, then back again.
Robin reaches out, gentle and careful, her hand brushing your bump, “Oh,” she says softly, reverent. “Oh my god.”
–
“I’m not really a speech guy,” he says, which earns a laugh. “But Dustin asked me to be his best man, and I figured the least I could do is embarrass him a little.”
Dustin groans loudly as Steve grins.
“I met Dustin when he was a kid who asked too many questions and never stopped believing things could be better,” Steve continues. “He’s grown up a lot since then — but somehow — he’s still the same guy. Loyal, loud, and unshakably himself.”
He glances at the couple. “You picked the right person,” he tells Dustin’s partner honestly. “He’ll show up for you. Every time.”
He raises his glass, “To the Hendersons.”
The toast is met with applause, cheers, and Dustin wiping at his eyes and pretending it’s dust.
As the night stretches on, Jonathan moves through the room with his camera, catching moments as they happen — Will and Mike bent together in quiet conversation, Lucas dancing with Max nearby, El chatting with Nancy while petting her dress, your girls asleep on either side of you and Steve, heads tucked into your chests — Steve thinks of Hawkins.
Of how being stuck there once felt like suffocation. Like the walls were closing in no matter how hard he tried to breathe.
But being stuck here with you — in the middle of soccer practice, ballet, school, and everything mundane — it feels like choosing to stay, and Steve hopes he can be here forever.
summary: you and steve have to fake-date after an awkward dinner at the wheeler-byers household—all while you're sure that he still wants nancy.
pairing: steve harrington x reader
word count: 6.9k
tags: (set before stranger things season 5 !!), fake-dating, friends-to-lovers, fluff & angst, requited unrequited love, miscommunication, awkward family dinners, robin = wingman, steve = clueless
cross-posted to ao3
a/n: had to rush this out before vol. 2 came out, just in case steve dies (if he dies, i die) — merry christmas if you celebrate !!
“I’ll give you twenty bucks if you admit it right now.”
“I’m broke, but I’m not that broke,” you shake your head, “Jesus, Rob.”
You’re mildly offended, but not remotely shocked, by the proposal. It’s easier to pretend to sort between The Jesus and Mary Chain and The Stone Roses and Modern English than to listen to Robin try to pry her way into your personal life; your fingers slide against the paper covers as you slot them back into their alphabetical placements. Even if your friend is well-intentioned, she’s completely out of her depth.
“A hundred bucks. A hundred bucks, and I’ll let you select the entire noon roster. That’s a bargain!” Robin rattles on, close on your trail; if she was any closer, she’d probably give you a flat. “Do you know how many times the boys have tried to get me to play The Cramps on-air this month? I’ve lost count. And, sure, the psychobilly stuff isn’t bad—but, hello, it’s the middle of December, not, like, Halloween night. What I’m trying to say is: it’s a pretty hefty deal I’m offering up here. Limited time offer.”
“You’d have to give me a thousand bucks. Or, put a gun to my head.”
“Dramatic,” she murmurs under her breath—not nearly enough to seem any less rude than it sounds, “Does that imply you’re only worth a grand?” You decide to let her think it out, but it doesn’t last for nearly long enough. Robin’s eyes flit from the ground, to the ceiling, and then back to you. She exclaims, “It’ll exponentially improve your mood if you just let it out. It’s psychologically proven!”
Though she’s been trying to convince you for the better part of a month, you still haven’t let up: you will not admit that you’re jealous of Nancy Wheeler. By no means is it Nancy’s fault. In fact, you adore her just a little bit more everyday with the way she takes lead on the crawls and makes sure that everyone’s in top shape for any major emergencies. The fact of the matter is that Nancy Wheeler is still the centripetal force of Steve’s affections. Steve sees her shaggy curls, the denim-jackets placed over floral blouses, the stack of metal bracelets, and his brain goes on the fritz.
The way that he looks at her makes you want to retreat into your own skin—siphon yourself out of existence—and still, you stick around to watch. A train crash you can’t bring yourself to look away from. Part of you wonders if it’s the nostalgia factor of it all—if Steve’s just one to reminisce about the good old days, still caught up on “King of Hawkins.” The worse, and fearfully more accurate alternative, is that Steve is in love with Nancy as she is now. Clever, witty, journalist Wheeler. The kind of gal to chew the ends of her pens and weasel the right information out of people. Strategist with a sawed-off shotgun. Though you’re not one for comparison, you’re sure that she must win in some way or another.
But, your harbored feelings for Steve are hardly anything new. Robin’s known about your little schoolgirl crush—you try to tell her, We’re early-twenties! Not early-tens, to no avail—since you started working at Family Video. You’re sure that’s when it started, because that’s when you had to start being around him five days of the week. Though you’d been a particularly good fly on the wall in high school, graduation swung around quickly. You needed a job to pool up a good sum of cash to move to some far-off city (the cliché smalltown transplant). Family Video was conveniently there. So were Steve and Robin.
Robin takes the record—U2, you think—gingerly from your hands and deposits it into the shelf in some off-place you’ll likely fix within the hour. She places both of her hands atop your shoulders. “Okay. You cannot tell me that you weren’t trying to laser-blast her with your eyeballs last weekend at the Wheeler’s. I saw it.”
You snort skeptically, “Why would I do that?”
“Because Steve was being all Steve. He offered to serve her plate and you were all weird and zoned and didn’t talk until Mrs. Wheeler started asking you about where you got your blouse.” Robin tugs at your collar—hung smile, like she’s got you all figured out—and it nearly makes your left eye twitch.
“Well, maybe, I’m just watching out for Jonathan. He gets all weird and jealous whenever Steve’s involved, and we kind-of, sort-of don’t have time for infighting.” You retreat from Robin’s touch, taking yourself into the little seating area the WSQK has set aside for breaks. You crash down on the coffee-stained orange couch, trying to be as leveled as possible with Robin; she lands just beside you, half-leaned on the back of the couch, legs crossed.
“There’s actually plenty of time for it. It’s been months with zero action in the Upside Down—minus the stupid patrols. Hop’s found nothing. You are scot-free to play this whole thing out. Finally!” Aside from Vickie and radio-hosting, you’re absolutely convinced that this is the only entertainment that Robin gets. “You are the master,” she claps her hands together, bows down to you just slightly, “of the long-game.”
You hate to think of it like that. Like you’d had some deliberate motive. For the first month of knowing Steve (Mr. Cologne-Heavy) in the flesh, you were just slightly dazed by the normalcy of him. He was just a guy—and, frankly, a bit of a dork. Clumsy sometimes, and easy-to-please. You weren’t nearly as serious about your little boy-crush then. Steve was just the nice back you got to look at during your morning shifts, you labeling the VHS tapes and him re-alphabetizing the romcoms.
You liked Steve; he was attentive. He knew that you liked to park your car under the fir in the backlot to keep the leather from frying up under the sun. He knew which customers you despised, and he knew when to step in. He knew that you wanted nothing but silence for the first hour of your shared morning shift—and was ready and willing to sort tapes conversation-less with you. He was your very good friend.
You sat through every single one of his failed matches with a strong-held despondence—even the desperate one-night stand he’d had with one Priscilla Allbright, a matchmaking scheme hatched up by Robin herself; she was the older sister of one of Robin’s theatre-kid buddies, but a tad too mean towards waiters—so it was easily one-and-done. And though Steve had rambled on about his continuous dry spell, you didn’t see it fit for you to throw yourself in the ring. It wasn’t until Steve’s dating ceased that you started to get concerned. He’d just stopped trying after Hawkins split in two. Nancy’s unintended doing.
Robin can’t help it. She wants more than anything to see the two do to shack up. She’s been making nothing but stupid bets and wagers for the past year—and even though she hasn’t made even a dime from it all, she still gets to revel in the satisfaction of you and Steve even being in the same room.
“I’m not jealous,” you affirm—easily ignored by Robin, who stretches her back left-and-right on the cushions.
“I don’t blame you. I’d be freaked too if Vick had some super-cool, fiery ex-girlfriend. No—I’d die!”
—
The next time the five of you get together—you, Rob, Nancy, Jonathan, and Steve—is at another one of those Wheeler-Byers dinners. This is the routine under your newfound militarized quarantine, especially when the Hawkins movie theater has tired of playing the same collection of movies five times over and you can only hit the same bar up so many times. All things considered, you think it’s a nice gesture that the Wheelers have offered up their home; it works out to have everyone under the same roof. They’re just as charitable when they host their little dinners, foldable chairs pulled from the basement and stuffed leg-to-leg at the dining table. Everyone pitches in to help prep—save for Mr. Wheeler, who slouches at the television box watching old tapes of football games from the year prior.
You have a decent spot at the corner of the table, wedged between Robin and Steve. Then, Steve next to Nancy, Nancy across from Jonathan… the usual. Steve has the tendency to jump his leg up and down underneath the table; the friction of his against yours isn’t easily ignorable, and yet you try to keep yourself quiet. In your peripheral vision, you can see the dad-looking sweater he chose for tonight, and his coiffed black hair.
You hate sitting next to Steve. It’s like this every dinner. You, getting passing whiffs of sandalwood and hairspray—trying not to look him in the eyes. Him, oblivious. There’s lots of ruckus; you’re pretty sure that there are four different conversations being shot across the table between the boys (save for a recluse Dustin), the parents, and you half-adults. Though Hop and El are still where they always are at the cabin, you’re sure that Joyce will bring them a well-packed plate the morning after. This dinner, Jonathan has persistently wrestled to pick up Nancy’s plate and serve her food; you’re very sure that she’s irritated by his insistence, because she gently scolds him with “I’m not a child.” Steve snorts, and you… don’t do a single thing. The chatter carries on, and you sit scooping peas over your mashed-potatoes.
You feel Steve lean his shoulder against yours, a too-warm attempt to get your attention. You’re too quiet for his liking. You crane your neck to look up at him, with a too-casual, “Yeah?”
“You know, the ‘indie’ stuff is really growing on me,” Steve chews, “I mean, I don’t really like how it’s all British—Go, Boston Tea Party, right?—but, they sound great.” You’ve been tossing in your personal favorites into Robin’s morning setlists. He’s clearly noticed.
You almost have to laugh. It’s a shocker, coming from him. “You like indie.”
Steve’s brows furrow, nodding his head along mid-question. “I do now. You’re, like, the connoisseur of the stuff. No offense, Rob.”
Robin beams. “Sure. None taken.” You hate sitting next to Steve. Especially when he acts like this.
The conversations carry on. Topics are restricted to normal, non-Upside Down, non-military—a house rule set by the kids. It’s like you’re spies. Steve picks up his reindeer-shaped ceramic mug—no thanks to the cup shortage (the Wheeler’s never hosted parties this big before)—takes a big swig of water out of the top. “You know what I miss? County fair.” Random. He continues, “I would kill for a churro. You guys ever ride the Zipper?”
Will diverts his attention from whatever pre-Calculus assignment Mike keeps moaning about to over to the other half of the table. “Jonathan threw up after the Zipper. Didn’t you?” Though he’s flat-faced, Jonathan’s clearly frothing with embarrassment.
“I did not throw up,” the older Byer brother insists, tone wavering just slightly. Will takes the win, turning back to the rest of the boys to continue rattling on about trigonometry.
“No throw-up talk at the table, please. Dinner,” Joyce warns, lifting her fork pointedly at Will and Jonathan. Tight-leash. You’re sure that she tries very hard to push good manners, especially under the Wheelers’ roof.
Steve carries on, trying to recall under his breath: “I took… Dana Mattey to the county fair? Think I won her a bear.”
“That was me, actually,” Nancy amends. Too loudly. Any existing conversation ruptures, leaving only the lingering silence of a dinner turned sour. Steve softens in his chair, looking at her meekly—before looking straight down at the table; he stops his jittery leg, eerily still. You’re very sure that you can see Jonathan’s knuckles whiten as he grips his fork. Mr. Wheeler grumbles some string of expletives that you can’t quite catch, and little Holly’s eyes flit between her parents and her siblings.
Mrs. Wheeler—already half wine-drunk—jumps to turn the conversation back around. She slurs, “The two of you aren’t seeing anyone?” The direction of her question toward the half-adult end of the table tells you that the question is pointed. The interrogatees: you and Robin. Steve is exempted, clearly. Mrs. Wheeler does this most nights, because Steve’s still very much her daughter’s preppy, popular high school ex-boyfriend.
Robin coughs up a bit—caught off-guard: “Oh. No. I’m not really looking for dates right now. Very career-focused. Radio’s, like, the new TV.” Robin lets out an affirmative, little “mhm!” before scarfing down too much food. Shitty liar. You try to give a nod in agreement, hoping that Robin’s response is satiating enough.
Mrs. Wheeler takes another swig of her wine, and then points lazily with her glass at you: “You?”
“Me.” You feel clammy.
She giggles coquettishly, “Well, you’re gorgeous. There’s got to be guys flocking to see you.” The wine in her glass sloshes left and right with the beat of her matter-of-fact explanation. You hear a little bit of a snort coming from the other half of the table.
“Lucas had a crush on you in middle school after you babysat him for Memorial Day,” Mike snickers, “Does that count?”
“Dude, shut up.” Lucas smacks Mike’s hand down into the table brusquely. You can see the two of them shove each other back-and-forth just beneath the sightline of the dining table. Robin gives you a nudge; the sole of her shoe juts into your calf, trying to urge a response out of you.
You’ve got a choice: tell the truth (you’re the modern-day equivalent of an old maid) or, opt for the easy way out. You choose the latter, replying wondrously—and maybe too proud: “I actually have a date on Saturday night.” Robin stifles her loud guffaw; she’s loving your improv. The rest of your friends—no, the entire table—look quite caught off-guard. Seems like everyone’s hushed up, save for the metallic scraping of forks against plates. It’s the puzzled tilt of Steve’s head that really does you in.
Though, Mrs. Wheeler is pleased enough with your response. “Of course you do, honey. Who’s the lucky guy?”
“He’s… uh…” Now, you’ve really dug your own grave. Your stammering dims her grin, and you’re afraid Mrs. Wheeler can see right through you.
It’s taking you far too long to spill. Robin brings her own drink slowly to her lips—wineglass, filled with apple juice—trying not to wear a sorry look on her face; it’ll only make it worse if she tries to come up with something for you. You’re just about to say a measly “boyfriend from Canada” joke, when Steve wraps his hand around your knee. “I’m taking her to Enzo’s.”
Robin makes a quick inhale-and-snort of her apple juice, and grabs for her napkin to try to wipe away the mess under her nose, dribbling down to her chin. The rest of the table reacts similarly—doe-eyed and curious. How did this happen? Mike murmurs a quick “Bullshit” under his breath, to which Nancy shoots out a stern “Mike!” By the looks of it, though, Nancy and Jonathan are the most confused out of everyone; after all, they spend the majority of the week with you guys at the Squawk, and they’d be able to see if you two were hooking up. And, it certainly doesn’t pair well with Steve’s here-and-there advances towards Nancy. The only person who’s mildly amused happens to be Will, who wears a proud, open-toothed smile on his face.
You try not to look as astonished as they do, but it’s taking a lot of work considering the fact that Steve’s hand is still landed on your knee—fingers edging toward your inner thigh. You’re so packed together in this dining room that you’re sure that the heat pooling off your cheeks easily reaches the other end of the table. You sum up just enough courage to look Steve in the eyes—maybe, to try and seal the deal, convince everyone that you are going out. Steve only gives you that tender, puppy-dog sort of look that he gives to pretty girls. You almost want to punch him for doing this for you. It’s too big of a lie.
When you swivel your head to look back at the rest of the table, everyone’s rather occupied by the sight of the two of you: Steve’s watchful eye and your electrified posture. You smile weakly, “We don’t have to talk about it right now. Lotta pressure.” An un-entertained Mr. Wheeler excuses himself to the living room (presumably, to watch last year’s baseball), and all the chatter resumes accordingly.
—
Robin’s the first to leave. A promise to Vickie to bring coffee for her late shift at the hospital gets her out the door promptly by nine o’ clock; she uses an easy excuse—need to make sure Grandma takes her meds. She doesn’t leave without giving you a wary look—you’ll get a stern talking to tomorrow—before she makes it out the door.
There’s a handful of things that run through your mind as you’re washing the dishes after dinner—up to your elbows in suds as you wash everyone’s plates. It’s Steve who insists on helping you dry them all off with a kitchen towel and file them back into the cabinets. Together, you create a two-person factory line. Wash-and-dry.
“You didn’t have to do that for me,” you murmur to him—hoping that the sound of the sink running will drown out your voices. Everyone else is scattered back around the house by now, but you’re quite sure that the boys are gathered in the living room. Nosy.
Steve shrugs. He leans in to murmur back to you, “Isn’t that what friends are for?” Right. Friends. “And, besides, it’ll get old Jonathan off my back about being around Nance so much.”
Now, you’ve got a better picture. If Steve “dates” you, he’s not nearly as much of a threat to their relationship. You’re not sure how much you like the sound of it. “Yeah. It’s a… good trade.” It’s hard for you not to wince. You focus more ardently on scrubbing the fork in your hand. “But, if they ask about the date—“
Steve tosses the towel over his shoulder, leaning against the counter beside you. “You’re right. Enzo’s is a stretch; I’d pay for it if you wanted me to, but realistically, you’d probably insist that I not do that. We would probably go for fries and a shake at Dee’s. Then, a late showing. Top Gun.” It’s the same old routine you go through every other week: post-work snack and a movie.
You snort, trying not to spritz soapy water on yourself: “God, we’ve seen it like a trillion times.” Steve pops a grin, too—satisfied with making you laugh for the first time tonight.
He leads, “Which is exactly why we would totally go see it again. Boom: flawless plan.” As soon as you slot the last plate into the dish rack, Steve takes the towel over his shoulder and tosses it to you. After drying up, you toss it over the rack of the oven. “Let me walk you out to your car, babe?”
“Asshole.”
—
You’re on one of the wheelie chairs back at WSQK. Saturday opening shift—you and Robin. It’s still shivering-cold this time of year, and there isn’t a bit of insulation. Steve’s not due for thirty, so the two of you are stuffed into the sound booth wrapped in blankets pulled straight from Robin’s trunk. You talk about the dinner, and after the dinner, all while you’re queuing up the setlist and sound cues for today’s morning segment. Robin’s too excited—flailing her arms around, up and at ‘em, pacing back and forth in the studio—while you scribble hard on the clipboard on your lap.
“This is perfect!” she shouts. It makes your right eye twitch; her volume is fifty decibels too loud for six-in-the-morning.
“No, Rob. It’s embarrassing.” You check off cassette numbers, placing the janky plastic cases into their respective slots.
“Sure, he volunteered to be your boyfriend—fake boyfriend—to save you the embarrassment of being a perpetual single. That’s nice and all. But, if you guys keep this up—“
It’s a nightmare just to think about. Every Wheeler-Byers dinner spent with Steve pretending to coddle you. Now, you’re really feeling sick of the military quarantine; New York sounds especially appealing. Or, Antarctica. You have to interrupt her. “We can’t keep it up.”
Robin goes blank, dingy-old Converse glued to the rug beneath you both, before shaking her head with an especially sharp-edged stare. “Sure you can. You have to. Or, it’ll disappoint the hell out of everyone.” ‘Everyone’ and ‘Robin’ are somewhat interchangeable, you think.
“I don’t think he’s going to want to keep it up that long.”
“He might surprise you,” she says earnestly. You wonder if you should trust Robin a little bit more than you do with these matters; after all, she is his best friend as much as she is yours. She carries on, “And, he’ll eventually face the fact that you are the top-tier option. Can’t get better than this.” Robin tugs cheekily at your collar, flouncing your hair a bit. It isn’t until you hear Steve’s Beamer roll up onto the gravel out front that you begin to shove her wriggly hands away. “Okay, okay,” you tell her, “Cool it, Buckley.”
As you carefully smooth down your hair, Steve makes it through the metal front door with a carton cup holder balanced on one hand and his keyring swinging in the other. “Coffee delivery,” he shouts over to the two of you, shoving his keys into his back pocket.
“Robs,” he deposits the cup on the nearest surface by her: counter by the microphones. “Steve, equipment. We talked about this,” she squeaks out, picking up the hot drink and placing it outside of the booth on the sturdier surface of a coffee table.
“Sorry, sorry,” he spews out haphazardly, before sliding over to you. You prop the clipboard gently onto the floor so you can take the coffee cup from his grip. Leaning down to bestow the cup upon you, Steve mumbles, “Girlfriend.” Your hands tremble just slightly as he hands it over to you—fingertips pressing against yours. A strong grip around the coffee cup quells your shaking—but you feel extremely hot-faced. Through the waxed-glass window of the sound booth, you can see Robin flags you with a crazed, wide-eyed smile. You’re only thankful that Steve has his back turned away from her.
“You don’t have to fake it right now,” you tell him. He knows and you know and Robin knows. There’s absolutely nothing to hide amongst the three of you.
Steve tuts softly, “Well, I know that. I’m just trying to build a good habit. I don’t want to be the one who slips up.”
“Well, I definitely won’t be the slipper-upper,” you retort. It’s a half-competitive, half-truthful sentiment that urges you to stand up, shedding your blanket over the top of the rolling chair—still gripping your cup tight. This brings you and Steve chest-to-chest, you tilting your head up to meet his gaze. You swear to God that the sound booth usually feels a lot bigger than it does right now. Steve pulls at the hem of your shirt as he looks over you.
“Actually, speaking of,” Steve perks up, “I wanted to run something by you.” You try to keep it cool, letting a lowly breath pass your lips.
“Yeah?” You can feel heat fanning across your body.
“If any of our friends ask about our little movie-date—like the little P.I.’s that we know they are—we should probably make sure that our stories line up.” Right. Steve wants to make sure that you both have all your bases covered. Clever. You give him a curt nod, under the impression you’ll both just have a little study session after Robin gets off-air, when he says: “We’ll just go on it—the date. As friends.”
You’re not sure whether you should be pleased or frightened, but Steve looks rather adamant about carrying through with the whole ordeal. “Are you sure?”
“Well, yeah. We’ve already put in all this work to keep it up, so we can’t just back down now,” he tells you plainly, “I’ll even bring you flowers to seal the deal. Still, flawless plan.”
The thought of Steve showing up to your doorstep with his stupid cologne and bouquet of lilies is nice. Too nice. A part of you has to wonder whether he’s still doing it for you, or if he’s doing it for himself. Realistically, it’s a bit of both—and you’re not sure if you see this working out well for either of you. You want to tell Steve, No, you should just tell her that you love her, but the sound of Robin knocking over a stack of cassettes just outside the booth makes you falter.
“Flawless plan,” she crackly echoes, before ushering herself to the vinyl shelves. You’re certain that if she turns around to face the both of you, her face will be highlighted red from top to bottom. But, Robin merely huddles herself against the wall—face out-of-sight.
—
Steve doesn’t show up with lilies, because you both leave straight from the WSQK. The sappy offshoot: a couple of daisies picked off the lawn outside. Curfew in Hawkins means any plans are pushed back at least a couple of hours. So, your Saturday night date is more like a Saturday afternoon. The two of you roll up to Dee’s with a Daryl Hall & Oates cassette slotted into the player of his Beamer. It’s better this way, you think. More like you. You’re just glad it’s not Enzo’s, and that neither of you had to dress up. Steve spritzes his cologne, you spruce your hair up a bit. It’s comfortable.
Not too many customers at this hour—so you and Steve get placed at a booth in the corner right away. You wonder how it looks from an outsider’s perspective—if it looks right, the two of you sitting on the same side. The waitress sure buys it, with Steve ordering for the both of you with his arm scooped around the back of your seat. She takes your orders as quickly as she can so she can skitter away to the kitchens, out of sight—probably to smoke a cigarette out back.
Once she’s gone, you turn to Steve with a hint of a smile on your face. “Okay. We should have, like, a good anecdote. Something really cute.” You want to be able to make this whole thing believable for the entire clan that is your friends.
“Right.” Steve tries to think something up, hand rubbing his cheek, eyebrows furrowed. He’s sifting through the possibilities. Then, he gets it—finger successively tapping on the surface of the vinyl table: “This old couple sat right by us and told us that we reminded us of them.” He looks so exhilarated by the little made-up scenario, head perked up like a meerkat out of Nat Geo—that you almost don’t want to shoot it down…
Still, you shoot out: “...Yeah, that sounds like bullshit.” He’s just a little bit offended—shoulders dropped, huffing out in only slight irritation.
He nudges his shoulder against yours. “Go ahead, then. Come up with something better.”
“Okay—we… got bored and played hangman on the placemats,” you volunteer. It’s not a terrible lie; Dee’s has the plain-white paper placemats, and crayons in cups just behind the counter for kids. A pretty good way to stay entertained.
“Just as bad as mine,” Steve retorts, stretching back out with his arms folded by his head, extended against the back of the seat. You’re very sure that Steve has some kind of back issues from everything you’ve been through—he’s always complaining about knots—and it worries you every now and again. Twenty-one going on sixty. It worries you even more when he does the little stretch-and-groan, an occasional test of your self-restraint. You try your hardest not to flick your gaze down to the sliver of stomach that gets exposed in his movement. Steve grumbles out: “My God—that’s gotta be from a movie or something.” Absolutely clueless.
You keep your eyes locked on the table in front of you—hands locked neatly together. “It probably is. God knows how many bullshit romcoms we sped through back at Family Video. Probably printed onto our brains by now.” He snorts.
The waitress comes with the fries—a large plate of them for the two of you, and a cookies and cream shake with two straws plunged into the cup. You don’t remember Steve asking them to group it like that, but to ask the waitress to send it back sounds like so much of a hassle, and you’re already pretending—it would be weird if you didn’t split it. The image of the two of you sharing the shake, nose-to-nose, makes your palms sweat.
Steve doesn’t give you any flack for the panic setting in on your face, just scoots the shake towards you with a nod. You first. “I know you totally dig that stuff. You don’t have to lie,” Steve carries on, “Hots for Swayze big time.” Relief. You pull the straw into your mouth, sipping up a gulp of the shake. It cools you down, only by a bit, and you spend the next couple of seconds focusing very intently on mashing the cookies around the bottom of the cup.
“Swayze’s not my type,” you say. Too much conviction. You know your type well—got it all figured out. So, this piques Steve’s interest; his eyebrow raises up just a tad, and you can feel him eyeing you.
Steve tries again, not before chewing on a couple of fries. “Then, what is your type?” Tall, dark hair, loyal as a German Shepherd, maybe a little bit dense…
“Don’t have one.”
“Everybody has a type,” Steve insists, “I’ve got a type.” He drags the shake towards himself, out from your hands, to take a generous sip. You’re very sure that you have his type all figured out, too.
“Witty and unavailable?” Nancy Wheeler, in two words. This gets him straightened out, trying to check the validity of your suggestion. Steve mulls it over, while you find yourself grabbing for a messy stack of fries to shut yourself up. This is small-talk Hell, and you’re only making it worse for yourself.
Finally, Steve gives a noncommittal shrug—wick of black hair falling over his forehead. You’re even sure that his ears have turned a bit pink; the overhead lights of the diner are bright, not doing him any favors in concealing it. He hums, “That’s one way to put it.” Then, he slides the cookies and cream shake back over to you insistently: finish it. “You’re sure Swayze doesn’t do it for you? No? Okay. The, uh, the Indiana Jones guy,” he guesses.
“None of the above,” you retort, shaking your head with a faint grin on your face. Steve smiles to himself, only satisfied with the fact that he’s giving you a light bit of entertainment.
You spend the rest of the meal—as short as it is—thinking about his answer. It’s still daylight by the time the two of you make it out of Dee’s and back to Steve’s Beamer. On the drive to the movie theater, you’re still thinking about it. About him. It puts you into a bit of a crisis, really. Steve’s in love with Nancy, but he’s out on this date with you. It takes a bit of time to settle with it again: it’s fake, it’s a favor, and Steve’s only half-there on your behalf. He isn’t yours.
Your contemplative silence on the drive to the movie theater makes him only a little bit unnerved. Steve decides to drive the two of you around to the back of the theater—“knowing a guy who knows a guy who’ll let him park his car in the backlot.” You’re pretty sure it’s one of Steve’s old basketball teammates, but you’re not particularly inclined to call him on it. You know it’ll all be pretty patched-up once you make it through to Top Gun. Quoting lines to each other, all whispers and airy laughs, like always. Good friends.
—
You decide to go in one car for the next Wheeler-Byers dinner a week after. Robin’s already inside, planning some monthly interview for the WSQK with Nancy—so it’s just you and Steve in the Beamer, parked up on the end of the block. “Should I give you my sweater?” he asks you, shifting his gear shifting into park, “I feel like that shouts ‘We’re together now.’ You can leave your coat in the backseat, we’ll say you forgot it, and I’ll freeze my ass off. Totally sells it.” He doesn’t wait to hear your response, just slides out of the car and shuts the door soft behind him. Steve swings his keyring around his index finger, coming around to the passenger’s seat to open your door for you. He grabs your hand, helps you out of the car with a steady grip.
Once he shuts the door, you jump to ask him: “How long do you think we should keep this up?” Like a deer caught in headlights, Steve stares at you. He purses his lips.
Erring on the side of caution, he replies, “That’s a good question. How long do you want to keep it up?”
“Well, what if there’s somebody that you really, really like and we have to stage a massive fake-breakup?” A worst case scenario given Nancy breaks up with Ionathan. Even worse: “Or, what if they expect us to kiss?” So, maybe you sound a bit immature, but it isn’t out of the realm of possibility. There’s a chance that—given enough wine—Mrs. Wheeler will become just audacious enough to ask you about the more intimate aspects of your relationship; it’d be strange for you and Steve not to be all attached at the hip. And, other places. Steve seems to think it over, hands moving to rest on his hips. He looks troubled, tapping his sneaker against the sidewalk, eyes darting across your face like he’s trying to glean something off of you.
“Okay,” he decides, a short sigh—before sidling up closer to you. He tries to kiss you—and you let him. He leans in, plants his lips onto yours—your noses tentatively bumping against one another in the quick motion. Steve’s face is hot against yours, and you can hear him let out a guttural sigh as your lips move to meet one another. It’s like a dream, the way he walks you back against the Beamer, and runs his fingers through your hair… He stops as soon as he feels you push against his chest. Your lips brush for a second more, before Steve retreats away from you. “Shit. I’m sorry.” He peels off of you to lean on the side-door of the Beamer beside you. Steve’s hands are stuffed into his jacket pockets, as he looks gravely down at both of your shoes on the concrete. “Stupid idea.”
You have your arms crossed, hand over your mouth. He just kissed you—hard. You can’t say you’re not pleased with it, because you are. Extremely so. But, you’re even more confused by it than anything else. “You’re in love with Nancy,” you spout.
Steve’s head whips up, dumbfounded. “No, I’m not.”
“Uh… yeah, you are. You hate Jonathan, you get all close and weird like you do, and you can never stop staring at her.”
“I don’t hate Jonathan. I love pissing him off,” Steve corrects you. The lack of reaction that you give him makes him startled. He backtracks, “Okay, okay—maybe, I thought I had a shot with her last year, but that was last year. I wasn’t thinking straight, I was all over the place. We’re friends and all now, but that’s it.”
“But, we were talking about—y’know, on Saturday,” you stutter out, “Nance.”
“I was talking about you,” Steve shakes his head, “You’re witty and unavailable and…” His train of thought takes him right up against the truth. Steve is nearly glowing with recognition—you don’t respond, reticent, face hardened with embarrassment: “You’re jealous.”
You almost feel like bolting down the edge of the street, ditching Wheeler-Byers’, and maybe even running home. You open your mouth to protest against the claim, and Steve’s astounded expression just makes you more fired up to prove him wrong. There’s a long string of “I’m not’s” and “You are’s” that passes between the two of you, enough to lose count—God, he’s so like Robin in his stubbornness. No wonder they get along—before you finally shut him up with a loud: “I am! I’m jealous of Nancy, and it drives me crazy. Happy?”
With a tilt of his head and a shrug, Steve murmurs, “I mean, yeah.” You can only reach out to shove him by the shoulder. He lets you push him back a couple of feet, soles scuffing against the sidewalk, before he plants himself more solidly on the ground. He’s trying very hard to conceal the growing grin on his face as you swat at his arms, all pissed and flustered. The second you let up, he grips you by your arms. “I should’ve just asked you on a regular date,” Steve admits, “I kept on putting it off because you’re just so…” He moves his hands to gesture over you. “You. And, with the whole dinner thing, I thought, ‘What the hell, why not take the easy way out of friendzone?’—even though I could’ve just asked you out months ago and solved the whole issue in the first place.”
“We’ve been dancing around each other for no reason,” you murmur.
“Not a lick of it,” Steve nods, shooing you aside a bit to pull open the backseat of the Beamer. “Now, toss your coat in the back.” You shrug your coat off of yourself, taking the heavy lump of fabric and tossing it haphazardly on the leather cushions. It’s shivering cold without it on, but the heat emanating off your face makes up for the lack of layers.
It doesn’t last for long. Steve shuts the door, before grabbing at the bottom of his sweater and pulling it over his head. He gestures for you to come closer to him, before tugging it carefully over your head. You slot your arms through the sleeves, well-wrapped in the warmth of the plush fabric. He makes sure the hem is straightened out, and fixes your hair accordingly. “You’re it for me. No fake-outs.”
You hook your pinkies into his belt loops, pulling him in for a chaste kiss. A flat “oh” slips past his lips as you pull him in, and he makes sure to place his hands around your hips as your lips slot together. Again. And, again. Steve’s wearing a smirk through each of your kisses, nothing but pleased about how it’s all played out. “Can’t wait to do this all the time,” he exhales.
“Let’s get inside. I know you’re freezing to death in just this.” You pull at Steve’s white t-shirt. His shoulders are tightened, arms quickly crossed, and you can tell very clearly that he’s trying not to shiver.
—
Entry into the Wheeler house isn’t anything but excitable. As soon as you're through the front door, Robin peeks the two of you from the staircase—Steve’s red face and your swollen lips; she nearly pushes Nancy over to tumble down the steps, inspecting each of you closely. “Holy shit,” she gasps quietly, “Holy shit! Did the two of you hook up? Say yes.”
“We kissed, you dork.” You have to slap her hand away as she pokes her index finger against your bottom lip. “Don’t say the H-word. There’s kids around.”
“Holy shit, or hook-up?” Steve asks. Neither of you respond.
“Well, I’m just saying that the credit for the H-word should be given where it’s due.” Robin points two thumbs in her own direction, and you reach up to noogie her hair. She yelps, trying to pry you off of her. “Okay, okay, I’ll shut up,” she tells you, but you can see her divert her attention towards Steve with a devilishly pleased expression. Robin punches him without restriction on the arm with a cheerful “You did it, bud!”
Your eyes flit suspiciously between the two of them. She’s proud, and he’s sheepish. God, Robin’s a meddler, but you can’t be completely irritated with her. Nancy makes her way down the stairs behind Robin with a pleased smile—and a teasing “nice”—shot at all three of you before she passes through the hall. You follow her trajectory to the dining room, where you can see the rest of your motley gathering of family moving around to set the table. You’re not nearly as scared to play boyfriend-girlfriend with Steve—especially when you can feel his hand resting securely on the small of your back.
Summary: You vowed to never step foot back in your hometown after you left at nineteen years old. But when a case drags you back the team must uncover your history in order to understand who they're looking for. The issue? You don't speak, at least not with your voice.
Warnings: SUPER UNEDITED (y'all I mean I haven't so much as GLANCED at anything I wrote, it was like I was possessed). I was high as shit and I wasn't having a great time. This is extremely self indulgent, like extremely. Gore, violence, SA, murder, grotesque descriptions of it, typical BAU stuff. Reader (like she goes haywire), angst (there's comfort too), deer woman from MY perspective.
Pairings: (Platonic) BAU x Reader, Spencer Reid x Deer Woman!Reader (although this is pretty background, the romance I mean).
A/N: You might be asking where I get my info on native culture/people, the answer is: I am Native, this is also based off of my community. This entire story is based on my town and how I grew up. Hence the self-indulgent bit. If y'all didn't know I was born and raised in rural southern Appalachia, so trust me Ik ball. I also would like to say I mean no offense through this story, this was just me trying to get my shit together.
WC: 24K (I thought it'd be less??)
You had joined the BAU less than two years ago on an unassuming Monday morning in August. Twenty-two, almost twenty-three it had taken them three days to realize your presence, and that was only because a case had been called in and they were sitting around the round table. You had sat between Emily and Spencer, eyes forward with your hands neatly folded into your lap. There was nothing outrageous about your outfits, perfectly ordinary office attire if not a bit more conservative than average.
For a moment there was silence, just them looking at you quizzically, as if they couldn’t believe what they were seeing. You simply blinked, your spine straight and mouth sealed shut together firmly, confident in areas that baffled them completely. Not a word, no attention drawn to you, and there. Hotch himself had faltered, and then as if a memory was resurging to him, he had introduced you as the latest member of the team.
During a six month period you were the team’s personal enigma. Not a word spoken, just evidence and carefully circled points, you communicated through whiteboards and updated information that they never saw you adding. It was during month seven when they had a case featuring a deaf person that they saw you speaking. Not with your words, but with your hands. That was when your expression had changed, lips moving with the words your hands spoke, but not a sound coming out.
After that they talked to you, some with clumsy, halting movements due to unfamiliarity, others with a practiced grace that brought the smallest of twitches to your lips. Spencer happened to be one of those people, he would sit with you and his hands would fly around in what could look like a crazed bout, but you understood every gesture. He also found you to be one of the greatest listeners on the team, you would nod along with his facts, glancing up in a silent question for more. He gave it willingly, he always did.
By the time you had been there a year he hadn’t heard your voice once, and yet he fell in love with you anyway. Or at least he developed some level of infatuation that had gradually grown more complex, the intensity of it deepening with every passing month that crept by. It wasn’t listed anywhere on your files that you’re mute, no psychological report of it, then again, there aren’t that many cases on you. There’s a county that you hail from, but it’s like your identity doesn’t exist prior to eighteen and in college.
Not even a birth certificate to figure out your birthday, which you’ve remained tight-lipped on despite the many months of knowing these people. Getting information from you that’s about you is like pulling teeth out. You refuse to speak about your family, or anything too deeply personal like your childhood. You’ll give them favorite books, your go-to tea order, the detergent you like to use, but nothing other than that. Spencer accepted your terms and conditions long ago.
The team has gotten used to you though, learned to recognize insults or curses spoken by hand. They laugh when you smirk after having left a particular good comment in the conversation. Your texts can be hysterical if you allow yourself to indulge in humor. Rossi invites you over to drink wine with him more than any member of the team, the girls use you as a scary dog for girls night because when you glare it seems to fend off the worst kinds of evil. Even Hotch has shrunk a little under the weight of your displeased look.
Morgan will drag you over to his apartment for long gaming sessions since you’re the best at video games aside from him. You can anticipate his moves and back him up without a single thing spoken, but that sort of trust translates into the field too. It’s no secret you and Morgan are a phenomenal team when it comes to guns and action. There’s that other thing about you too: All your words are intentional, you know where to hit and you know what hurts too. So even though you don’t use your vocals your voice still has that sharpened edge to it.
When working the case your voice is heard, perhaps more than any of theirs. So when you sign a hard no to them after JJ finishes giving the presentation, they’re confused. Hotch raises his brow at you, “What do you mean no? This is a federal case now, agent, you aren’t in the exact position to refuse.”
Your brows dip lower as your mouth presses into a slightly downturned line. Eyes hardening in a way they all have flinched under once or twice, Hotch shifts a miniscule bit in his seat as the seconds tick by before you raise your hands, “You all can go, I will stay behind for paperwork.”
“We need you in this case, what about it is making you not want to be there?”
“Location. People.”
“You’ve dealt with plenty of unpleasant people and locations, you’re going to have to give us something more if you don’t want to go there.”
That makes you huff, your frustration evident in the way your palms unfurl and curl back up again, a noise made in your throat that has them all flinching a bit. There’s no mistaking that noise as a piece of your voice, marking this the first time they’ve heard your voice in any capacity before you begin to sign again, “Bad relations down there, I will hold the team down if I go.”
Emily pauses, just for a second, “Wait, are you from this town? Is that why you don’t want to go?”
“Yes.”
Hotch sighs, “Then in that case you’ll be vital to this case. If you’re from this town then you know the people, the culture, the surrounding area. It’s quite isolated from everything else, although it’s expanded in recent years, not by much. How long did you live there?”
You’re most definitely sulking now, and very, very unhappy with Hotch, “Long enough.”
Then you pointedly fold your hands in your lap and he knows that there’s not a word more coming from you. If he’s going to make you go then you’re going to put up a fight the entire way, that’s for sure. Morgan looks at Emily, who looks back at him, then they look at JJ, who simply raises her brows. Up until now you’ve been a fantastic agent, always ready to go, never putting up that much of a fight unless it comes to discussing who the unsub may or may not be. You’ve never outright sulked.
It’s almost enough to make them laugh, if not for the way you seem genuinely upset to be forced to go back to the town that they’ve never heard of. Less than two-thousand people in population, the county boasts a grand five-thousand something in total. There’s no doubt that you’re a familiar face, or that you’ll recognize a few. But to have your knowledge on the area, on the people, it’s unparalleled. There’s multiple girls missing, none found so far, but it’s enough to cause concern.
“Do you know any of the victims?”
True to your pointed gestures, you refuse to so much as look at him. He has to resist the urge to drag his fingers down his face. Already you don’t use your voice, but if you refuse to use your hands too then you’re cutting communication off with him. He’s forcing you to go to some place you clearly detest, and you aren’t going to make it easy for him. He wants you there because you know the people and the land, but you won’t let it go for the fact that you hate it all.
The ride over is uncomfortable, mostly because you refuse to look at the files and instead your gaze focuses on the clouds passing by. Nobody approaches you, mostly because your body language screams at them to keep their distance or you’ll flip your shit. Emily looks at Hotch, wearing one of those faces that conveys just how skeptical she is of the situation, her voice drops down to a low murmur.
“Are you certain that bringing her along is a good idea? She obviously doesn’t want to be here, she requested paperwork of all things. You know how much she hates paperwork.”
Hotch sighs, he’s trying not to make a big deal out of it but you seem to be convinced that if you throw a fit then maybe you’ll get sent back home. You’ve never acted out of line like this, never requested to not be on a case, especially for young missing girls yet here you are. Determined to not step foot back in that land.
“I don’t know what her deal is with this town, but we need her familiarity with the people and area if we want to get this done. Southern rural Appalachia is no easy place to navigate, the people even less so. Community is tight-knit, religion that ties people together. There’s a natural distrust of the government due to a history of neglect, the people often rely on each other and don’t take kindly to outsiders coming onto their territory. Hence why we need her, she isn’t an outsider, not if she came from this town.”
“She hates this place though, and she’s afraid of it. Look at her, she’s trying not to peel herself out of her skin.”
Hotch pauses to look at you for a second, the way you’re worrying your lip between your teeth, arms crossed and tense, everything in your body saying you’re ready to enact fight or flight. Not freeze though, because freezing isn’t an option for you, it never has been. Even though you’re projecting danger to them it’s clear that you’re the one who feels like you’re in danger here. He mistook that for you digging your heels in the ground as a way to make things difficult for him.
“I’ll talk to her when we get there, she won’t talk to me right now.”
Emily hums, head nodding at him a tad, “You did upset her pretty badly by denying her apparent love for paperwork back there.”
“She hates paperwork with a passion like I haven’t seen in many other agents in the bullpen.”
“Yet she wanted it over this.”
They’ll find out what you’re so afraid of in this town later, but for now they keep an eye on you, the way you’re trying not to jump out the plane instead of landing. Or why you look like you’re being forced to walk the plank since there’s no other option to get off the boat. Something’s wrong here, but you aren’t giving it up.
_____________
The plane lands a solid two hours from the community which is located in borderline nowhere. You’re in the passenger seat for once to tell them where to go because despite it all you still have all the directions memorized. Hotch sits at the wheel, his slight familiarity with driving in the mountains giving him a better advantage than most when it comes to the tight roads and sharp curves. Driving in these Appalachian’s (ah-puh-latch-en) is different though.
These mountains are the oldest in all of the United States, formed before the Atlantic and before the continents split into their modern formation. These mountains are quite literally older than bone. The town is old too, originally it was Native land, then came the settlers and the Trail of Tears too. There’s a reservation settlement that co-exists with the town, it makes Hotch question if you’re Native, he wouldn’t be surprised if you are.
After the highway comes an hour of backroads that has him questioning his driving skills every now and then because of how difficult they are to drive. It’s October which means that it’s leaf season, and if you weren’t shaking like one Hotch might’ve appreciated the beauty of the place. Because it truly is a pretty place, the mountains are drenched in shades of red, yellow, and orange, looking aflame despite the lack of fire. The air smells fresher here, even in the car, and it’s a pretty enough day that they can roll the windows down too. You’re the only one who doesn’t.
Thirty minutes before rolling into town you twist your body to face them, snapping your fingers to get their attention. Nobody misses the way your hands shake when you start to speak, “There are rules here, you have to abide by them.”
Spencer reads your words aloud so everyone can hear them, they straighten up, no longer entranced by the pretty leaves and emerald foliage that wooshes by them. You raise your hands again, eyes shut, “Do not whistle in the woods or at night. Do not speak of the creatures in the woods. If you hear a baby crying and you’re alone do not follow the noise. If you hear your name being shouted and you can’t pinpoint the location, turn around and go back to where you were before. Do not try to investigate it. Do not leave your shoes outside at night, do not stay outside at night for too long unless necessary.”
You pause, letting that information sink in for them before continuing, “The people here are opinionated, they will be racist, they will be homophobic, they will not see you in a positive light. Do not pick a fight with the locals, if there needs to be arguing then I will do it. Most importantly do not underestimate or insult the culture here, or the people. You’re in their hunting ground, not the other way around. If we go to the woods we do not split up, and you do not go without me. Non-negotiable.”
Emily’s brows furrow, “Is there something dangerous there?”
“Of course, the entire town is dangerous.”
You turn around then, your silence taut and nervous, your fingers picking at your sleeves as you try not to think about the fact that in less than twenty-five minutes you’ll be back in the town you ran so far away from. You start to pray ten minutes before arrival, head bowed with your hands clasped in your lap. It is a startling sight to see your hands still and your lips moving despite the way no sound comes out. Hotch, maybe, should have let you do paperwork instead.
There’s no turning back though now, not when the town comes into view. Old buildings from various centuries, the newest at least a hundred years old, they’re scarce and put together in one neat row. You direct them to the sheriff's department, which is ten minutes from the main town and also made of wood. It looks more like a cabin than a station, but nonetheless this is it. The sheriff emerges, short cropped blonde hair and blue eyes, he has a full beard and large leathery hands. Hands that know the weight of a gun and have felt the pull of a bowstring.
He knows you judging from how his eyes widen when you appear, but he doesn’t give anything away immediately. Instead he reaches his hand to JJ, who steps in front of everyone with an easy smile, “Hi, I’m Jennifer Jaraeu, we spoke on the phone.”
“Yes, I’m Deputy Sheriff Luke Cochran, we ‘preciate y’all comin’ out over here.”
His accent is thick, distinctly southern but not like Georgia or Alabama, there’s something else there that the others don’t have. No drawl like they do in New Orleans, this is something more archaic due to the isolation of the region. Absent-mindedly, they wonder if you have an accent too, or if you even developed one, since this is evidently the place you’ve been born and raised to.
“Y’all come on in, we got a little space to set up shop. Now we do have some evidence but not a whole lot to go on by. I got my men to gather what they could but truth be told in a place like this, there ain’t ever gon’ be enough information.”
The inside is warm, cozy, it was definitely a cabin at one point due to the layout of it, as if the fireplace wasn’t a dead giveaway to that fact. Luke leads you all to a backroom which is what must’ve been a bedroom, it’s large enough for billboards and a table, a little water dispenser in the corner, a couch to lounge on, and of course, a stunning view of the mountains. The forefront ones are still the picture of autumnal perfection, but as the ones in the back grow more distant they take on a blue hue to them. Coming in various layers that get darker the farther back they go. It’s a beautiful sight, one you turn your back to.
There’s a box of evidence and pictures ready to be pinned up, right up there with a large map of the county territory. You take a moment to let it sink in that you’re back in the town you swore you’d never step foot in again. You’re standing with a familiar face, in a room you never thought you’d go into, your homeland staring at you from outside the window. You hate it for so many reasons, the comfort of it being one of them. Luke takes a moment to explain things to the team, you’re half-listening, half-drowned in the static rolling through your ears. He approaches you once the introduction is over, hand finding your arm easily as if there hasn’t been years between your last appearance.
He smiles, strained as it is when his hand tightens almost imperceptibly against your skin, it doesn’t go unnoticed though, not to your team, “Miss.Awiakta, how long has it been again?”
Awiakta. Eye-of-the-deer, a name used by Cherokee people. A surname for you, potentially, which could be why they couldn’t find anything on you like a birth certificate. It never occurred to them that you might’ve changed your name somewhere along the way. You stiffen under his words, but with your arm temporarily restrained it’ll make signing harder, yet you do it anyway, “Better. You?”
His smile twitches, just for a second, “I see you’re still using your hands to talk for you.”
He looks to the team then, hand dropping from your arm as if it was a show of encouragement, “Has she spoken to any of you? With her voice I mean.”
Hotch looks at you, the way you shrink in on yourself a little bit from the proximity of this man in front of you. The way he had held your arm like if you couldn’t use it you’d have to use your actual voice to speak, “She talks plenty. Regardless of whether she needs her voice or not.”
Deputy Luke chuckles, just as he would if it were a well placed joke, except Hotch isn’t joking about anything, “A damn shame, she used to sing so prettily.”
You step closer to the team, uncomfortable with the attention to you now and the you who used to exist. There’s still a guitar in your home, it hasn’t collected dust, but it reminds you of what people used to hear. It takes you back to high school, to the talent show in Sophomore year, the last year you spoke really. You can still feel the stage lights on your skin, can hear your breath in speakers and the weight of the community staring back even though the lights blind you.
JJ clears her throat, “If you could show us the evidence you have so far?”
“Of course, of course, right this way.”
The police station used to be a small ridge-side inn that people who wanted to escape the world frequented. It had bed and breakfast, two porches, stellar views and the promise of nobody bothering them too bad. It had been converted into a station after the owners died, a gift from their kids who didn’t want anything to do with the mountains anymore. You wonder if they regret it or if they’re thankful they have nothing tying them down here.
They have you all set up in what used to be a suite, there’s a little kitchenette, a good bathroom, a small divider for the bedroom and the rest of the room. Not to mention the wrap around view of the mountains. It’s a gorgeous picture to see with one's own eyes, the misty fog rolling in and the array of colors on display, the way the clouds roll in to promise a light misting or rain overnight. It smells like rain, you can sense it in your bones that it’ll come.
Inside are two boxes, the boards are blank save for a map of the area although it remains blank, but it details the county and the trails used, or where homesteads are. You know exactly where the house you lived in is on that map, marked by a small blue dot with nothing nearby for at least three to five miles depending on the direction someone points at. It makes you wonder how long you have until your family turns up, demanding that they see you or that you come home. Except coming home feels like a death sentence to you, and so does the idea of coming face to face with the people you vowed to never speak to again.
Part of you itches to lock every door, shut every window closed, then to lock yourself in the bathroom with a shotgun locked and loaded. The other part wants to flee, to steal the car and drive all the way back up to Quantico because you’re safer there than you are here. If you did that though then you’d lose your job, get put on a watchlist, and then probably imprisoned or put on intense house arrest. You aren’t sure which one you’d prefer at this point in time either. It all sounds better than staying here in these mountains, being amongst these people.
As soon as he leaves Emily turns to you, her face carefully neutral despite the way she’s practically frothing for answers, “I didn’t know you sang.”
You shrug, “Not important, let’s get to evidence.”
“Eager to change the subject are we?”
“Yes.”
Morgan, on the other hand, is already trying to see if Penelope can dig anything up on you for singing since there’s your actual surname to go off of now. It doesn’t stop their curiosity about you, and everything you’re attached to, in this town. What happened to you? They don’t know, it’s clear you aren’t willing to tell them either.
The pictures on the board get pinned up, evidence passed around to be examined. Last known sightings, family details, boyfriends, living locations. All of it, and during the process you fall silent, not in the kind that is easily broken either. By all means things are going as they normally are, the team lulled into the pull of theorizing based on what the evidence presents, the art of picking patterns and connecting the dots. The difference here is the way the officer gripped your arm too tight, the familiarity, your discomfort.
It is Hotch who decides to ripple the pond, clearing his throat to garner their attention while his eyes remain fixed on you, hands raised to talk in a way you find the most peace. For you the team had learned ASL, had learned the alphabet, then hello, and then by the second month they were practically fluent in your language of motions. Beyond learning it for you it’s made communication in the field easier too, knowing that there can be a conversation held with a back turned and lips sealed.
“Do you know these victims?”
You hesitate, an indication of yes but you aren’t sure about that even, tentatively your hands raise, movements slow as you try to collect your thoughts, “I did, but it’s been too long to say I know them anymore.”
“Did you grow up with them?”
“Yes.”
“So you know their childhoods and adolescent behavior, we can start with Angela Hackshaw, what was she like?”
This time your hands don’t hesitate, “A bitch who slept her way to graduation, she’d drive three hours to get her hair bleached and told anybody who wasn’t deaf that she was going to be Miss Universe someday. She couldn’t point out Mexico on a map if she tried or cared.”
Morgan stifles his laughter like many of them do, Hotch is the only one who resigns himself to the fact that bringing you here might be a worse idea than he thought, “Can you give us any clear defining traits using the language of profiling? Not petty teenage adolescence?”
You shrug, “I asked for paperwork, need I remind you?”
“Fine, petty teenage adolescence but profile words, yes?”
“Deal. Classic narcissist with a low intelligence, believer of the grandeur and easily disillusioned, slightly sadistic. She believes the people around her are only there to serve her or lift her up. She only associated herself with people in positions of power and preyed on them too in order to elevate her own standing. Her greatest delusion was that she could get away with anything if she said the right words and batted her eyelashes just right. If you ask Officer Marks over there he can tell you exactly how she got out of a speeding ticket when she was seventeen.”
“What about Crystal Hayes?”
Your face softens at her name, none of the contempt you had for Angela Hackshaw present, “She was sweet, rode her horse every morning and every evening. Winter was her favorite season but she preferred Fall foods and sweets. She was good at math and entertained the idea of being a math teacher. A cheerleader, Angela was too by the way, and also on the track team. She didn’t have any signs of narcissism, psychopathy, or sociopathy, no history of mental illness on either side of the family. Her family, as far as I know, are good people, they own a farm.”
“Were you friends with her?”
This is where your face begins to pinch again, “My older brother at the time dated her, they were together for three years before they broke it off. She introduced me to ASL.”
“You didn’t know about ASL until her?”
“I didn’t know a lot of things Hotch, after I stopped speaking I didn’t communicate period. She was the one who taught me the alphabet, she had learned it over the summer when she was working with elementary schoolers, one was deaf.”
“I see, last victim. Kyle Paint.”
This time there’s something a little too close to grief over your face before you begin to speak again, “Annoying, but he wasn’t malicious. The football team, popular, he was friendly with everyone in the school, even the kids who didn’t fit in. Never made fun of anybody because of their socio-economic status, never failed to stop helping even when it wasn’t any of his business. He believed in hard work, being nice to people, and holding your ground.”
“You were friends with him.”
“I was.”
“Were you close?”
“Yes.”
That makes you shift, uncomfortable as all hell with the scrutinization of your past and the relationships you harbored from what feels like a lifetime ago. Kyle had been someone close to you, one of the few you left letters to when you decided to pack your bags for good. You didn’t get a response because there was no address for him to send one to. You regret it, not giving him one, but you didn’t know the address either so therefore you couldn’t. Maybe he’ll forgive you later.
Emily nudges your side, drawing your attention again, “What was your friend group like in high school?”
You shut your eyes for a second, thinking about it, “Popular. I think we were nice, we never targeted anybody, kept to ourselves, focused on our futures, played sports and stayed involved with the community. We kept up with trends even when adults disapproved of them, we were out more often than not. There was this spot, it’s a locals-only known spot, the prettiest view of the night sky in all the mountains up there. And usually a base for hunting trips.”
Morgan's brows raise at you, “Hunting trips? You hunt?”
This time your eyes stay shut as you recall the many, many hunts you had gone on, “Everyone hunts over here. I learned how to shoot when I turned two, most people know how to hold a rifle by the time they’re five.”
Spencer was reciting statistics when he was five. You were hunting animals in the forest. Except it wasn’t an anomaly for the people of your town, not at all. In fact it was seen as normal, encouraged by many, only very, very few disagreed. It also means the unsub, who is local, knows how to hunt too. Of course, the whole town is dangerous. You weren’t kidding when you said that either. A town raised on guns, isolated with nothing to do but run in the woods and bring home a pretty prize, that boredom gets turned to skill real fast.
You keep talking though, your hands faltering occasionally but never quite stopping, “Doesn’t matter what or who you are. If there’s one thing that unites the people it’s God, guns, and glory. You learn how to shoot when you’re young, and then you learn to skin something, then you learn how to gut it. Finally, you learn how to carve it up just right, how to polish the bones and how to turn them into something useful. When we get older we learn to preserve the skins, making pellets, make clothes out of fur, thread out of leather. Once we’re close to being teenagers we learn how to make the weapons themselves. It starts with knives, then it turns to spears, arrows, and finally, a bow.”
JJ runs her hand through her hair, mind whirling in how she’s going to deal with the people here, if they’ll even listen to the words of an outsider like her. They don’t take kindly to outsiders, that’s what you had told them earlier. Distrust of the government, neglect from the government, they have no reason to like any of you here. Except for you, because you belong. They do not.
Spencer, on your other side, taps your arm to get you to look at him, “We need to talk to your old friend group. They might be able to tell us if there was someone hanging around them suspiciously or if they had made an enemy in the past few years since you’ve been gone. Can you give us a list of names?”
You blink up at the ceiling like it might give you strength before you reach for paper while Spencer finds a pen, then you scribble down five names, and you don’t say a word more.
_____________
The next morning five young adults are sitting in a line at the police station on the couch in front of the grand fireplace. Because again, the station was formerly an inn, and nobody wanted to get rid of the fireplace. Besides, it makes for an excellent waiting area if the community has anything to say for themselves. You dread it though, god you dread it. Nobody comments but everyone notices that you’re a little worse for wear and none of them can blame you either.
This is personal whether you want it to be or not. They themselves look anxious, hands wringing and glances traded from across the couch. You cling to your thermos of tea like it’s the one thing keeping you from throwing yourself down the damn mountain. As soon as you and the team enter, the energy changes, like the temperature has dropped ten extra degrees despite the chilly start to the morning. The police force present straightens, their eyes narrowed and yet they tuck themselves away, as if they might camouflage themselves if they do so.
You recognize the five faces before you, five far too familiar faces that you had desperately tried to forget but couldn’t. There had been six letters sent the day you disappeared completely, no return address, no nothing, just a period at the end of the page as a final farewell. Part of you hopes it hurts for the sheer fact that someone cared about you enough for it to affect them. The other part hopes it didn’t so much as pinch, because selfishly that would make it easier for you.
Hotch steps forward, hand extended, “I’m Special Agent Aaron Hotchner, thank you all for coming out, if you’ll follow us we’d like to ask you all a few questions.”
You observe them, watching as Kennedy is the one to take his hand and shake it for the group, her face painfully understanding, “Kennedy Combs, we’re happy to do so if it means getting our friend back.”
Spencer conceals you from the group before you all, so does Emily. Sure it’s a cowardly thing to do but you’ve also been dragged to your wits end within twenty-four hours and you deserve to hide a little longer. Even if it is just for thirty extra steps. Spencer, hands behind his back, lets his fingers move, catching your attention instantly, “We’ve got you, no matter what.”
Then you all start moving, for you it’s absolutely death-march. You’re family you can rage at, your friends who you abandoned you can’t even look at. Shame and guilt curl unpleasantly against your soul when you watch the backs of their walking forms. You left them, no warning, barely an explanation, you can’t imagine what they might think of you now that you’re here on the case looking for Kyle.
They sit at the table and you inch closer to the door, ready to flee at a moments’ notice. They let you stand there, taking the attention by coming to the front. If it were an option you wouldn’t even be in the room, but as the one closest to them you can read their language and bodies better than anyone else can. You have to listen to their words to try and filter if what they said is true or not. Then on top of that, you have to be finding connections that nobody in the room can possibly make. Either they don’t have the skill or they don’t have the background. You have both, it’s on you this time to lead the investigation at a distance.
In order sits Mason, Bates, Kennedy, Alex, and finally Nancy. They look older but so do you, there’s dark circles that weren’t there before, a tightness to them that looks foreign on their shoulders and faces. Luke is missing, they’ve been frantic, because if they’ve lost him too, then they’re down two people held close to their souls. They don’t notice you back there, they don’t know you’re part of the team either. You prefer it that way, out of sight, out of mind. They’ll give honest answers if you aren’t there.
Hotch begins the questionnaire, and at first it feels like static when they start to speak. You hadn’t heard their voices in years, too hesitant to call, fear preventing you from dialing their numbers. The job forces the static to soothe itself, makes your mind sharpen to their words, pulling your emotion out of the picture when you do. Spencer’s watching you the moment you switch, when you swallow your history down in favor of throwing up the current version of you, the version he’s familiar with. He knows as soon as the interrogation is over you’ll revert, but the switch is something he hasn’t witnessed before. Not on you. How many times have you done that behind their backs or when they weren’t looking? They get to the part about you. This is where you fight to stay on the job, when Hotch states your name, asks what happened to you.
Kennedy is, once again, the first to speak, “She disappeared off the face of the Earth, not that I blame her. Just, wish she stuck around to at least say goodbye, she left us letters the day she left. Took near thirty minutes to figure out what she was sayin’. I ain’t ever seen her writin’ look so chicken scrawl before. Wrote like she was runnin’ from the devil. I figure the devil bein’ her Pa.”
Mason nods, as if this is the most absolute thing in the world, “He was a mean thing to her sometimes, but any other time he was a proud father of a baby girl like her. He called her Little Doe, the whole family did, it was understandable too, she was a true doe up until Junior year. We all thought she’d marry James Cochran, they were in love, he was the kind of man who’d carry her grocery bags and season her iron skillets because she loved to cook, she did. She was damn good at it too, she’d invite us for parties, and ain’t none of us ever wanted to say no to her. But then we hit sixteen, and it was like she was shedding knuckle velvet.”
He turns to Bates, nudging the man who breathes in deeply, “We all knew something bad happened to her, but she wouldn’t say, only her Pa got worse too. Her siblings were just as confused as us, not Tiffany, she’s the oldest sister, she seemed to hate her overnight. Not in that rival sister kind of hate, but the kind where one was hoping the other got lost in the woods or heard their name in the dark. Which didn’t sit right with none of us, Tiff had always been close, then she was vindictive. Mean as all hell, thought she’d flown off the damn handle.”
Nancy clears her throat, shifting to straighten her back under the attention she has, “She was the best at hunting out of all of us.”
There’s a murmur of approval, nods and quiet snaps of their fingers. Your stomach turns viciously, they don’t hate you, they don’t hate you at all. They’re remembering you like you’re dead instead, like you’re a ghost who’s been beside them this whole time. As if you haven’t been in Quantico, living your life out in Washington D.C. Not a whole spiritual layer of existence away. There’s no room for your discomfort though, Nancy presses on, she always does.
“If she wanted to disappear, then by god she was going to disappear. Just like a doe. She could run through that forest and not a thing would snap under her foot, she’d do it too, just run. She spent more time in that forest than anybody ever did, and when she hunted, you prayed for that animal instead. Once she had a target, once she took off running, that bow on her back, you’d know that dinner was about to be fantastic. I ain’t ever seen her lose an animal unless it’s on purpose, some ah, some people would use her as a threat. Loosely of course, they’d say shit like ‘I’ll sick Little Doe on you’, at first it was a joke.”
This is where you want to bury yourself in that fucking forest, light yourself on fire along the way to take it all with you. Part of you is that forest, it forever has a piece of you claimed into its hills and steep cliffs, the rounded peaks and the hidden caves behind waterfalls. It was you at some point, just as part of you is always it. That piece never left the mountains, that piece is somewhere running through the tall trees and clear streams, never stopping, forever content.
“After she went silent people started sayin’ things, odd things, of course they just thought she was sad, and nobody blamed her for that. Again, her Ma and Pa were a piece of work, they thought she was just tired out from them. What changed was the hunting. We didn’t notice at first, we brushed it off. But, she was getting more precise, more deadly, the way she skinned things. She developed a signature. The arrows she made, she made ‘em a special way, if you were in the woods and you found her arrow notch in the trees you had better make a choice, and a good one too. You could keep going, encroach on her territory, risk a night of hell, or turn around, go right back to where you came from.”
Hotch holds his hand up, “Wait, she shot at people?”
Alex snorts, “Oh yeah, she never got close enough to hurt, she made sure of that. She’d make sure she was close though, that you had offered yourself up as bait for her to practice her skills. By the time you’d come to realize what you had willingly walked into, it was too late, it’d be dark, and she’d be ready. You wouldn't, you’d run, she’d let you, but she’d still chase you. Following you in the pitch dark, out in the woods, the mountains, sometimes you’d stumble into one of the arrows she had left from earlier. It’d get worse from there, but by midnight she was gone, and it was up to you to get out of there.”
“How often did this occur?”
“Depends on who you were, and what you were there for. If you wanted to just be left alone, to just be there with the trees, she’d leave you alone, she might even leave a piece of game for you to take home. Or berries, something good, and once you got your gift it was time for you to turn around and go home. Now, if you were there to have sex, to vandalize, to do anything that disturbed the forest, it was fair game for her. It was all about intention.”
“Was there anybody particularly scorned by her throughout high school?”
“Oh plenty of people, but at the end of the day, she had put her warnings, she had given you a chance. You took it anyway, you knew what you were getting yourself into. We can give you a list of people who were particularly butthurt about this ordeal.”
“Butthurt? They were hunted.”
Kennedy shrugs, “Things work differently here, agent, no offense. But this? She had issued the threat of it after stupid Matthew Hale kept stealing her kills as a way to flirt with her. It’s a big, big issue to keep stealing someone’s kills, she hunted him down as fair game, he never stole another kill again. In high school, occasionally, people would get together, force someone into her neck of the woods, and that’d usually get them straightened out. She was angry, and people found use for it. Are we scared of her ability to hunt so precisely? Absolutely. But we are more proud of her ability to judge someone’s character and act accordingly than that.”
Mason cuts in, eyes steeled right at Hotch, “Whatever happened to her made her a legend when it came to hunting. It gave her the outlet for killing whoever did whatever to her, the town let her have that. She never harmed nobody unless it was deserved, she only helped and provided, still a doe despite shedding her velvet.”
Hotch doesn’t look at you, nobody does, “And then she left.”
“Yesser, it was June 25th, 2004. Nothing out of the ordinary, one day she was here, the next she was gone. Mostofer’ things left behind, car abandoned by the side of the road, no white cloth in the window. None of her things, no gas, just the car, and that’s where the trail ends. No reports of her hitch hiking, no reports of seeing her in the town over, it just goes cold. Uhm, Kennedy has the car still, sometimes we sit in it, most of the time it stays locked. We found our letters that night, she had left them in our houses with her keys in the envelope.”
“She had keys to your homes?”
“Of course, she hated staying with her parents, she was with us more than them, and for us it was anything to keep her out of the woods for a night or prevent her from being beat. God if you’d seen the bruises her folks left on her, we all knew they were there, think her Pa strangled her bad sometimes too, was why she didn’t speak, always wore a collar too. Never showed her neck again. Refused to swim too, and lord she loved the sun. It was June, we had plans to go to the beach soon.”
You can’t bear to hear anything else, instead you turn and open the door, ever so silently letting it shut before you take off for outside. Your heart is going too fast, your mind spinning in obscurity as your past is thrown up against the wall for all to see. The hunting, the barely restrained violence. When you meant you’d end up on their table, you meant it as you being the unsub. If one thing went wrong, you’d be behind bars instead of putting people behind them.
Everything is wrong. Wrong. Your friends who you abandoned, thinking you’re dead, or alive and treating you as if you died. Like you’re someone to be commemorated. The hunt still thrums in your veins, the urge to run in any direction rampant in your system. You could, you know you’d find a way to manage, that you could return and the thrilling terror would return. Somehow you stay rooted to your spot outside the building where nobody can see you. If you shut your eyes it’s just you and the forest, nothing else.
Time stills for you. Sixteen falls, away, the dagger and the warmth of blood on your cheek. It’s you, the forest, and everything else is gone. In the moment of stillness, you allow your senses to stretch as far as they can. Your friends joked that you weren’t fully human sometime ago, just because of how well you could sense things. You can smell people and trees, you can smell there’s squirrels, birds, the rain is coming closer, maybe thirty minutes away, a bear came through too. You can hear gravel turning over, footsteps from inside, people talking at the coffee machine and a pair laughing with each other. You make sure you can’t hear the voices in the room. The senses of a doe. A gift, just as it is a curse.
The five of them are getting up, leaving, you make sure you’re not somewhere they can see you, and if they try to find you then it’s true you’ll vanish, they won’t be able to. You know like you know your hand that you haven’t lost your skill for it.
As soon as you know the coast is clear you make your way back, senses going in and out before you enter the room. It feels like you’re fighting your way through sludge, as if someone is suffocating you badly. Your friends were here, they told the team of what you did, and there’s no way you can lie to them and say you’d never want it again. Some days you want it more than anything. That’s who you are. What you are. Little Doe.
They look at each other once they see you. That blank look in your eye concerning, your skin pallid, it’s so evidently clear that you aren’t fine. Yet you raise your hands anyway, “Sorry.”
Despite all of it, they still don’t have your timeline, they don’t know what happened when you were sixteen that made you snap so badly. You never harmed, you just chased, but you were clearly respected in the community, even feared from the sound of it. A hunter too good at the skill, a small isolated town where grudges ran deep and spanned generations, and the combination of a rage towards a group of local unknowns. It was a deadly combination, and who’s to say besides you that you never actually killed somebody? You could’ve, and it’s clear you could get away with it too.
As if sensing their thoughts your trembling hands raise again, “I never killed, I never touched any of them. I let them know I was near, that just when they started to feel safe, I needed to remind them they weren’t. Some people wanted me to go through with it, but I never did. I treated everyone who I felt deserved it the exact same. I’m sorry.”
Hotch is the one to force you to drink water, waiting until you’ve had a few gulps before he speaks again, “I know you don’t want to talk about it but we need that story. This unsub could very well be initiating you or even challenging you. Each victim has some sort of significance to you, the first victim was an invitation, the last two were used to draw you out. You are the target.”
You know they do and still you can’t find the words. A target. You? The feeling is foreign after so long, and while you normally wouldn't mind the feeling, this is personal. You need to see the sights where things happened, the points of connection. This could be beyond the team's territory to interfere in.
“The locals' only spot they talked about is Rattler’s Point. It’s off the grid, and also serves as a central point for many things, including the old church. That church was abandoned a while ago, but it still had its piano and organ; we would play music up there sometimes. Everyone knew about it, and it was frequented often enough that nobody batted an eye about going up for a night or a date. Or a hunt.”
Remote, no service, no signal, a complete dead zone isolated from just about everything. The perfect spot to do anything between star gazing and murdering. Your heart stutters as your hands seal the deal for you, “I can take you there, to the spots you’ll need to look at. I remember the paths, and I can explain better if we’re over there.”
Two birds, one stone, you think you might’ve just damned yourself. It certainly feels like you have, but it was going to happen anyway, and in truth you probably will recall the scene better by being there. Difficult, yes, but accurate too. They sit with that for a moment, sinking themselves into knowing that this will probably be the most difficult thing you’ve ever had to endure before in your life. Reliving the scene of what made you mute. You can barely keep yourself from falling apart at the table.
Hotch says okay anyway, and you all head out. You take over the driving for this bit, the roads familiar under your wheel, grounding you to yourself more than you could in the station. They’re glad it’s you who drives to get to Rattler’s Point, the roads too twisted and gnarly for their comfort. It takes closer to an hour to reach your first destination, by then the sun gets closer to the middle of the sky, although the thin layer of clouds blocks a good bit.
You step out easily, but after a step you sway, just a little as you stumble forward, like you’ve been pulled by some invisible force. This is a clearing, one path for the car to keep moving forward, and another smaller trail towards the trees. It’s higher up here, colder too, much colder. There’s a few trees lining the road, essentially framing the clearing, and a firepit dug out, well used, closer to the middle of the land. It smells of the forest, of trees and rain, skunk and cardinal, gunpowder and fire. Someone was out here shooting yesterday.
This prompts you to turn to them, “Someone came here for shooting yesterday, I can smell the gunpowder.”
Rossi raises his brows at you, “You can smell yesterday's gunpowder after last night’s rain?”
“Yes.”
“You're a weird kid.”
Spencer, who’s trudged close to the usual shooting section, calls out to them with mild concern, “She’s right, there’s multiple shell cases here, still clean like fresh from firing.”
They glance at you, but you’re staring towards the forest, towards the road. This isn’t the spot, but it’s the start of it. You turn towards the campfire, which they look at too. You point to the road before you begin, “We came down from there, stopped here for the fire, we cooked dinner here, me and James Cochran. I don’t know how many dates we’d been on, I knew anniversaries, I thought I’d get them tattooed one day. We came here often, at least three times a month. My family comes up here monthly, it’s where I learned to shoot.”
Little baby you with a shotgun longer than your body slung over your shoulder. It’s no wonder you had come with a warning that you never miss, and that out of everyone in the entire damn FBI you beat them all when it came to a gun. Like a sniper who could do their job with a blindfold, that’s what they told them when you were being transferred over. The CID had gotten you first, and then the BAU had taken you when they decided you were a little too dangerous even for their tastes.
This is where it had begun and festered, sharpening into a tool that could be wielded with terrifying grace. Despite the two years in the field with you they hadn’t seen the truest display of your skills. They hadn’t even gone into the shooting range before because it seemed like you were never there. Yet it was that knowledge thrumming under the surface of your daily profile, knowing that you could take down a room full of people with ease if given the tool. Knowing that there was really no need to call a hitman, or a sniper, because you were there. Yet they did it anyway, because they weren’t supposed to be the ones pulling that trigger.
Perhaps you have resented that. They don’t know. They don’t know anything at all, somewhere along the lines that sharpness in you had dulled in their heads. None of them saw you pull a trigger, not once, and so the rumours of your marksmanship dispelled, and then they were forgotten. Yet every quarter when their results came in you dominated the charts more than anybody came close to. Hotch never forgot that, the rest of them did, Strauss wanted answers on why you were that way, why you never used your skill on the field anymore.
Maybe he’d finally have an answer for her. The only cost being your expense. It’s all he can think of when you start to drive again, moving further down the road by at least three miles before pulling into a small dirt turnaround. When they step out it feels wrong, like the land is warning them away, that something bad has happened to this place. You lead them to the trail anyway, it’s bordering overgrown, but it doesn’t bother you in the slightest. The trail, to you, is clear as day.
You take them down the trail, it’s no more than a six minute walk, and the reveal is something that takes their breath away. The church is in no clearing, it’s just there in the woods, the spire reaching amongst the boughs, merging with the trees. Vines creep over the edges, the doors opened wide for welcoming visitors. The stairs bow in the middle, one wrong step away from completely caving in. You take them anyway, the rest simply haul themselves up to the porch.
The air feels fragile here, like it’s holding its breath, waiting for something to force it out. Inside are eight rows of pews, rough wood from years of use and a lack of refinement to begin with. There’s a simple stage, the piano to the corner, the podium in the center. The back features a large cross, to the side the small organ and area for the choir. There’s no flags featuring bible verses here, no art, not even a stained glass window. Instead there are thin slates of wood for walls, painted white but now tinged in yellow. Thick rafters and beams that support the high ceiling, there’s even books still stowed to the back of the pews. A book of hymns, a book of Christ, despite the location and age it hasn’t been abandoned.
You walk down the aisle easily, finger tracing over a pew before you come to the front, to the stage. Your fingers ghost over the keys of the piano, your back turned towards the organ, if you applied just a little bit of pressure the first note would ring out and shatter this particular stillness. The opening note presses down on your mind, the urge to play possessing your hands, just for a split second. You catch yourself before you can start the song. Before it overwhelms you with the need to make music, you step away and back towards the group.
“You played piano, correct?”
“I did, this one in particular.”
Hotch peers at the old thing, you’re sure the keys are out of tune but none of that matters because it’s a piano where you know what sound each key makes regardless of its accuracy, “What song did you play when you and James came here?”
Your face pinches for a second, just one, “My song. I made it in here, didn’t realize I had made one until I played it often enough that people started to associate the song with my existence. I played it every time I came here. Those that learned the melody would play it if they knew I was nearby, usually to get me to come over or to come home. That night was no exception, we got here and he just waved his hand at me. Smiled and told me to play my song, cut me loose, that’s what he said.”
“Do you still remember how to play it?”
Morgan already has the camera ready, he knew what would happen as soon as Hotch asked if you played the piano. You nod once before brushing the seat off and readying your fingers, not before turning back to him, “This was the last time I got to play my song.”
Then it starts, beginning slow, deliberate, then swelling, and it feels like feeling sunshine underground. Sorrowful despite the light notes that ring out, Spencer stares at you, truly stares, because this might be the first time anybody has well and truly seen you for who you are. The song isn’t long by any means, just enough for that sense of longing to really sink its claws into them. Your fingers slow, the notes petering out until silence overtakes them again. It sounded like a soul being damned.
You don’t get up, but you do turn to them, “James used it as a signal. His friends were waiting in the woods, I didn’t know, I thought we were on a date. He was being sweet too, when we were here he was telling me about how one day I’d be walking down the aisle and he’d be waiting for me at the other end. How as soon as we were up and done with high school he’d go to my Daddy and ask for my hand. We were going to be the best couple the town had ever seen, he’d take his father’s position in the station one day. I’d be helping run his family’s business, if it had gone the way I thought it would back then I’d be married and made a mother by now.”
Not only had your voice been robbed, but the life you thought you were going to live had been too. A child that will never be born, a white dress you’ll never put on. They had called you Little Doe, sweet and beautiful, you had been perfect to their eyes. The story you’re telling, pieces at a time, the evidence lingering in the way you hold yourself and traces of time. James used it as a signal. His friends were waiting in the woods. JJ’s stomach turns in a way that’s so disgustingly familiar to her when she reads the pleas for help that come across her desk. Young girls preyed upon by even their own peers, innocence leading them like a lamb to their slaughter. You had been one of those lambs, just as the doe instead.
You stand, walking backwards so you can keep talking to them, “I didn’t know they were there until we got out, they didn’t say a thing, they were just waiting. I thought it was a prank, and I didn’t mind it too much since I was used to them crashing our dates or coming over to hang out. I was friends with them too, I knew their girlfriends and we hung out often, it wasn’t uncommon for us all to be out and about. This time it was just the guys though, and that’s how I knew something was wrong. They were just standing there, dressed in all black, shotguns on their backs.”
They come to the porch and you stop right at the steps, raising your finger to point out around you, dipping it seven times to indicate where seven people once stood, “Hunter Anderson, Elijah Paint, Kyle Ridges, Conner Robinson, Brendon Mills, Casey Wilkins, and Silas Brooks. In that order. When we get back to the station I’ll give you all the details I have on them down, and then we can get the rest too. They were part of this though, they all were. I came out here, James at my back, the boys in front of us, and then James asked if I was up for a game. It wasn’t a question.”
You move down, breathing in deeply as you retrace your steps, “We got into James’ truck, he took us farther down, out to the firetower.”
They move again, leaving the church behind in favor of the fire tower, which is an extra twenty minutes away, and looks as if it’s a stone's throw away from falling down. For a moment you all stand there, staring at the old thing with varying degrees of concern or remorse. From down here they can’t see what it looks like inside, they can’t picture what might’ve gone down. You’re frowning at it, arms folded over your chest as you draw upon the memories from before. They look at you after a moment, prompting you to speak up again.
“This is a common spot to hang out at. Whether it’s used for parties or sex or both, nobody really bats an eye at it. We came up here first, I could tell something was wrong, but they were acting like everything was normal. They’d brought beers, their guns, I saw the camo jackets and I thought, just for a handful of minutes, that maybe we were going on a night hunt. That maybe I was over thinking things, that they were just here for a good time. Nothing more, nothing less. I was wrong.”
You begin to walk again, finding yourself at the base of the stairs, you reach for the railing, feeling the rusted metal beneath your palm, and ever so cautiously you step up onto the first stair. It creaks, but it doesn’t budge. For a moment you feel yourself running, the chill of the mountain air in the dark, the blindness of the night, that frantic fear thrumming in your body, heart pounding against your chest and the terror of being caught. When you shut your eyes you can hear their footsteps behind you, the stairs shrieking and building shuddering for a terrifying second. Their laughter, the hollers of a hunt coming on.
“James tried to fuck me in front of them, I wasn’t having it, and they started closing in. They wanted to touch, they tried goading me, attempting to lure me in because they wanted a piece of me too. I kept denying, James shot at my feet, I bolted, and they followed. They tried shooting me from the stairs too, but I was too fast for them to catch. I ran into the woods.”
Then you begin to move, your pace fast, urgent as the trail becomes clear to you all over again. They take off with you, following you in a single file line as you head straight into the woods. To them they cannot see the trail, they don’t know your route but they see what you ran through, even if you didn’t at the time. Thorns and branches, large rocks, you keep them moving though. Eventually coming to a creek, it isn’t very wide, but there’s no way to leap across the water either.
“It was too dark for me to see, I didn’t have anything but the clothes on my back, and so I fell into the river, busted my knee up pretty bad on the rock over there. But they had heard me flailing in the water, and I couldn’t afford to stay in one place for too long. I kept running despite it all.”
You walk across the rocks this time, your steps sure and your body graceful as you step across like it’s a game of hop-scotch. Spencer slips once, yelping before you snatch his arm and righten him up. He stares at you for a second too long, but you do too so it doesn’t really matter in the end. You all keep moving, up hills and through corners, over a thick tree that fell over another section of the stream, and finally, nearly an hour and a half later, into a small area that’s flatter than the rest of the terrain.
Slipping down a hill to what seems to be a base of something. There though, there’s a large rock with a flat top to it, and on that rock is a large brown stain. The years have weathered it, but there’s no mistaking it for what it is; A blood stain. More specifically, your bloodstain. This is where your composure starts to weaken, your hands regaining that light tremble that they have not missed when you stop at a certain point in the area.
“This is where they caught me. James shot my in my thigh and I went down hard. It wasn’t long before they were on me. I couldn’t do anything, I had been shot, hunted down, exhausted beyond my limits. I wasn’t wearing the right things either, by that point I’d lost my shoes, my feet had been torn to hell. They took pictures of it, of everything. They recorded and used their flashlights as a light source for when they each took a turn, but they weren’t satisfied yet. They needed me for something more than just a hole to use.”
Rossi and Hotch look at each other, a silent pact that no matter what they’re going to get that evidence, and those boys will be going behind bars. Your story is nothing short of horrific, to know all that has been done to you and still it isn’t over, it isn’t enough. Not for whoever has taken those three people, who has drawn you back out to the mountains, to these woods. They still want more from you. It’s selfish and greedy of a magnitude they struggle to comprehend sometimes.
Emily looks at you, the way you fit these mountains in a way that they never will, knowing that if you hadn’t gone through what you did then you’d still be here. You would still live and breathe the mountain air, wear camo in a daily outfit and you’d be speaking, you’d sing with your song and play piano for the people. It’s a life you deserved to live, but that choice was violently ripped away from you, “Do you have any idea what the motivation behind this might’ve been?”
You sigh, although it’s more a huff than a sigh, “I wanted to wait until marriage to have sex. That was the kind of girl I had been, and I wanted to go to college, get a degree. James wanted me here, said I didn’t need a degree when I had him, that the life we had in-store for us didn’t require my absence. I disagreed, I wanted to be a woman and I wanted to know what it was like outside of these impossibly tall borders. I was leaving, James couldn’t stand that.”
“So he took you to the forest, where he and his friends hunted you down before forcefully assaulting you in a place nobody would come.”
“It went beyond that, James felt like he was losing control over me, which he was. I can admit that I was starting to get the sense he wasn’t all that he seemed to be the closer we got to the finishing line. It had me questioning if we were going to last throughout my college career, I didn’t tell him that though. It’s also important to know that this is the year James was made football captain, and they wanted to ensure a victory. Casey suggested a sacrifice for God, something pure.”
You point at the rock as understanding starts to dawn on them, “James agreed because he would rather have let me die under his control than let me live in my freedom. James dragged me up to the rock when it was over while the rest started to pray. They had made up this absurd chant, nothing from a book or even a website, just the power of a man doing what he can to get what he wants. James slit my throat when I started screaming.”
“How did you survive?”
“I didn’t. I died that night, right there on that rock. James and the rest went back down to the town, they’d torn themselves up a bit, pretended like a bear had come for them, said that I was missing, the bear had separated all of us. The town searched and looked and James led them to me, he pretended like he was concerned, he wept over my body when they airlifted me out. They stuck me in the hospital, realized that my pulse was still there, somehow, and they brought me back to life. If you ask the town they’ll tell you they shouldn’t have brought me back because I came back wrong.”
So you had been forced to pretend like your murderer was your savior, because nobody would believe you otherwise. No wonder you had gone off the rails like you did. Hunting people down so they’d stay away from you, specific people, helping those that got lost or forced into your neck of the woods.
“How did they explain the gunshot wound to your thigh though?”
“James admitted to that, he said he heard the grunting, the sounds of a bear, he shot blindly and when he heard the shriek he thought it was a deer he had shot. They believed him, because why would a guy like him have shot his own girlfriend? He tried to keep us together after it, but I refused, he was the first I hunted back.”
“If you get the chance to hunt him again, would you?”
“Yes.”
They know if given the opportunity, you would kill him. You don’t say it, but they feel it coming off of you, the lines within your words, how your hands didn’t shake when you gave confirmation. James Cochran, the Deputies son, you’d shoot him in the throat if you were allowed to do so. That rage never stopped boiling, you had only managed to keep it from spilling over. Such tight control over yourself that you stopped speaking, because if you spoke, it would all come bubbling back.
It hits Spencer right then and there that you don’t speak because you’re afraid, or anxious, but because you’re enraged. One wrong move, and you’ll snap. A twig breaks twenty feet away, and that snatches your attention, all of their attention. There stands a doe, white tailed and beautiful amongst the colors, she’s looking directly at you. Time stalls again, it’s you, the doe, them, and the forest. The spell only breaks when the deer turns around and leaps off to the forest, not a trace of her to be seen after only a few seconds.
“We need to go back now.”
It’s faster this time going back, mostly because there’s no pit-stops, but by the time you’re all back in town it’s dark out and everyone’s starving. An order gets placed at a restaurant, one of the few in town, and Rossi is the one to go pick it up, mostly because he’s the only one with pocketfulls of cash. There’s no hotel, only houses to rent when you’re here in the mountains. It’s that small of a town, you can’t imagine why anybody would want to stay overnight in a place like this. Despite it all you still think it’s beautiful. Maybe you shouldn’t. You do anyway.
____________
Your father is at the station the next morning. He sits there with his twin braids and a cup of coffee in his hand looking like for all the world he belongs there. It takes just about everything in you not to turn around and head back to the house you’re renting. Your father is a big man, even when he’s in that oversized leather jacket of his, the red button up he wears and the rings on his fingers. His features are sharp, you’ve inherited his nose.
Officers glance at him before looking at their paperwork, but the glances are frequent, even if they never linger. Half of it is fear, the other half is respect. Your father’s name holds weight in a conversation, his words taken as law if it is needed. If he says something, then it will happen. That is the way things work in this town, and that rule was held absolute over your head as a teenager. You hated that when you started to come into your own, but you had obeyed. Then sixteen happened, and you listened to nobody but your gut.
Hotch stops when he sees the man because there is always something about men in seats of power when they face another in a similar position. You know what it looks like when two absolute powers collide, and this is one of those moments. Hotch, the outsider, versus your father, who is in his territory. You of all people know the importance of keeping people out of one's own land. You want to reach out to Hotch, to tell him to just keep moving forward, but that also means drawing attention to yourself, which means your father’s eyes will be on you.
“Can we help you?”
Your father, sometimes called Big Bear, sometimes called Taylor, depending on who was speaking to him. Stands, he’s drawn himself up to his full height and the years away haven’t done anything to weaken the muscle in his body. His hands are powerful things, they have taught you how to carve your first arrowhead, and they have also given you your first bruise. His face remains impassive, much like Hotch with sternness etched into his resting features. Taylor is silent for a moment, a long one, as he eyes Hotch up and down.
A fight, that’s what you all deduce in the span of a few moments. Hotch, of course, shifts to ensure he won’t be knocked off his ass if Taylor does decide to swing. This catches the attention of others who begin to murmur to each other, fingers pointing and heads turning at the potential showdown in the room. Luke, from his spot at the top of the loft, sees it too. He clears his throat loudly as he starts to walk down the stairs, voice very pointedly light, “Big Bear! What brings you down to the station?”
Taylor turns and you choose to yank Hotch back while Taylor is distracted, although you duck into your team just as quickly. He looks at you, brows furrowed while you hide from behind Spencer, your fingers, lighting fast, spell father at him. He looks back at the man. Hotch nods once before turning to Rossi, “Take the team up, I’ll stay here and see if I can offer our aid.”
“Of course.”
You walk carefully, keeping distance to ensure that Taylor won’t see you sneaking away. How you managed to slam doors in his face when you were a teenager is beyond you, although if given the right tools you’re sure you can find it in you to do that again. Spencer nudges your side as the door closes, “Who was that?”
You sigh, shaking your head as you sign, “My father. He’s here because either he has information, or he wants me to come home. If it’s the latter that means word has broken out that I’m back in the mountains.”
“What does it mean if people know you’re here?”
“People might try to come by in an attempt to talk to me. It also means that the unsub will escalate.”
“So we’re running out of time.”
“Yes.”
“Based on his body language, what do you think it is?”
“I don’t know, he’s…I could always tell if he was in the mood to hit someone, or if he was in the mood to give gifts, but nothing else. I could never read him any other way.”
“Hotch will tell us when they finish up talking. Whatever it is, we'll deal with it, but you’ll never have to be in a room alone with him again.”
You don’t smile, but you press yourself close to him for a moment, “Thanks.”
“Of course, and if he tries anything I’ll have my gun on him before you can even blink.”
The last bit is for you and you alone, the quiet threat something not to be heard by a room full of agents who Spencer knows would let him get away with it, but he still shouldn’t be saying it. Yet he says it anyway just to see your shoulders loosen and your head to be held a little tighter. They look over the footage that they had gotten yesterday, your blood stained rock and the piano. Penelope had made Morgan sit with her on Skype while she listened to it, she then made him swear not to tell anybody that she ugly cried while converting it to a file so they could keep listening to it.
Morgan had listened to it over and over again last night, that one specific clip isolated and repeated until your melody ingrained itself into his mind. Today they’d be bringing in the boys you had named individually, they planned on using that song to gauge their reactions. Emily, for one, is looking forward to interrogating the boys on what they did to you, to force a confession out of them if it’s her last breath. What they had done to you is inexcusable, no matter how good of a boy they might be. She wonders what the community will say, what they might do.
It takes Hotch ten minutes to come back in, face carefully unreadable when he looks directly at you, “He said that he felt you nearby, he’s left you a gift.”
“A gift?”
Luke steps back inside, this time with a bow and a quiver full of arrows. The wood is made of black walnut with white wrappings around it. You’ve carved symbols and patterns into the wood, decorated it with a raven feather and a small string of beads. Your quiver is made of horseskin and lined with boar fur, the underlayer of it though, the tusks are attached to the ends of the bow. In your haste to leave you had left behind the two precious items, and now they have been returned to you. A gift, according to your family.
He knows. The thought nearly sends you to your knees, but once it manifests you know it’s true. Your father knows what happened, he knows what you’ve become, it makes you wonder when he figured it out. Was it before you left? Or was it after, when the nights stretched long and he sat out on the porch looking for something that would never come. Did he regret it? The day you left.
You still haven’t told them what happened. It feels like it doesn’t matter anymore though, not when your fingers curl around the familiarly sleek wood that you had carved and crafted to perfection. By instinct your fingers find the string, your body contorts, and you pull. The wood bends deliciously underneath your hands, the string straining just right as your eyes narrow in on a target, but you do not let the string fly, instead you ease it down again.
The taste is still there, the arrows waiting for the right chance to be used again. You can hear the whistle of an arrow, your arrow, in the wind before meeting the satisfying thunk of a target you didn’t miss. An arrow gets pressed to your palm, Morgan is the one who put it there, his eyes betraying how curious he is, “Take a shot, somewhere, anywhere. If you shoot an animal we’ll eat it.”
You don’t want to kill anything tonight, not today, but there’s row upon row of animal heads mounted to the wall in the station because they display their biggest kills in there. Like it’s a memorial or something like that to the things they hunt down. You step outside onto the porch, you already have something in mind for it too when you notch the arrow and draw it back, your team behind you, waiting patiently as you find your angle, and then you let it fly.
The arrow is audible, the shriek of it like a ghost whispering in an ear, the sound makes the station go quiet. Just in time for there the sound of the arrow hitting home to sound. You’ve picked a doe, shot her directly between the eyes, angled so it shoves down towards her neck. They know whose arrow that is with the quail feather used as the fletching. Luke stares at you, because you’re staring at him, you didn’t even look at the target to see where you were shooting. He shudders under your gaze, he had seen it before, long ago.
Back when you were sixteen, when you were seventeen, then eighteen and nineteen. He knows that there is something wrong with you, that James had had a hand in making it happen but he’s never gotten the full truth of it, of what made you the county hunter. He also knows that if he or his men ever stepped foot into your territory without asking then they’d be the doe you just shot, no questions asked. You’re reminding them at that moment that while you’ve been gone you never let your skills dissolve. You’re still the huntress, you can still kill them without blinking an eye about it.
“Glad to see you didn’t get rusty.”
You sling the bow over your back, a practiced movement, easy, “I never quit shooting at things.”
“Will you go back to Doe Run?”
Doe Run. That’s what they called your territory. A combination of your nickname and the fact that anybody who stepped foot into the place needed to start running, and run fast while they were at it. You look at the arrow, satisfaction blooming in your chest when you see your shot landed perfectly, then you look back at him, “Have people been invading recently?”
He pales, just a smidgen, “Of course not, Doe Run is yours, everyone knows that.”
“I’ll hold you to your word.”
Then you turn to head back inside the room, your team following you closely behind, but the arrow remains lodged in that doe’s head.
______________
They have the men you named in the station by afternoon, they sit and shuffle, looking for all the world like a strapping group of men ready to spend the rest of their lives in the woods. Camo printed everything, they have guns across their backs and knives in their pockets. Luke called them in, said it was important since they had plans to go hunting. You’re hidden away on the other side of the interrogation room, because somehow they managed to get that in this station.
The first round is to see group dynamics, who will look at who, who will remain isolated, that kind of thing. It’s a crowded room, but they manage to fit all eight of them into the space. Morgan is in there with your arrow that you shot earlier laid on the table. He isn’t even bothering to try and make nice with them.
“This was found between the eyes of a doe that Deputy Sheriff Luke Cochran shot in November of 2000, reportedly it belonged to a young huntress who we hear was quite territorial over her ground. When we went to a spot she used to frequent, namely Rattlers Point, we were also guided to a church. When we got there we heard someone playing music from inside, we’d like you to listen to this piece and tell us if you recognize it.”
He slides the recorder out to them before pressing play, and upon the first few notes there’s such a violent shift in the group that they have to pause it ten seconds in. James, namely, shakes as he points at the thing, “Where did you get that? Where?”
“Like I said, the church, by the time we got into it nobody was there. Now sit down, you haven’t even heard the full thing.”
“No I know who played that song, that has to be her, it has to be.”
“Who?”
“My ex-girlfriend, god I loved her, she was everything. Then that fucking bear happened and our future was ruined, took her voice, took her loveliness too. She wanted nothing to do with me, or anybody, she just wanted her woods, her arrows, and the thrill of blood on her face.”
“You think the bear caused that much damage to her?”
“It took her damn voice. You know how much that woman loved to sing? Music was everything to her, the piano, the guitar, the fiddle, she played like her life depended on it. In those quiet moments, the ones between everything, she was always humming something, or just singing to make a noise. Prettiest thing you ever did hear too, any man would’ve been grateful to come home to something like that. Something like her.”
“You still love her?”
“I never moved on, I couldn’t, not from her.”
Morgan eyes him for a moment, he doesn’t let anything show, he doesn’t flinch, not even when the image of your rock pops up in his brain. He just presses play, and the music keeps going. The buildup, the crescendo, and that shattering come-down that had made Penelope burst into tears. You couldn’t see your face when you played, but you looked like you were about to cry when you did. They had yet to see you cry too, you’d come close, sure, but not like this, or like that.
It had been a special sort of hell to recount your story to her. To tell Penelope of how you looked so small next to that rock, your eyes glazed over in what he knew was the memory of your murder. Because you had been murdered, you had, he doesn’t know what allowed you to survive, but he knows it took some of your humanity with it. He had to tell her of the way your fingers trembled when you told them you were raped, violently, by a group of men you trusted. Your torn up feet, the date night sent from hell, how you knew you weren’t walking away alive.
Finally the song finishes, and they sit in silence for a long moment until Conner turns to James, “I think that’s proof enough that she’s returned, anybody talk to Big Bear about the arrow?”
Morgan clears his throat, “He came by this morning, both bow and her quiver of arrows are gone. The arrow came through this morning.”
Silas tilts his head, teeth having gnawed on his lip, “No wonder your old man called to tell us to come in, if she’s out in the forest Doe Run is completely off limits.”
Brendan scoffs, “Oh please, that whole damn forest is off limits now. You know she doesn’t do the whole forgive and move-on thing.”
Morgan raises his hand, letting them fall silent, “Actually, we have a favor we need from you eight.”
“You want us to go to that forest?”
“Yes, and we want you to go to Doe Run. Act like nothing is wrong, let her have the element of surprise, we want to study her movements, how she works. If she is the one behind the kidnappings then we have to understand her as best as we possibly can. But, to ease your worries, we’ll be in there too and we’ll have people set up and ready on standby. We also need a working map of where her territory lies, and what to expect when we confront her directly.”
They go silent, all seeming to have silent conversations with each other before their final gaze lands on James, who’s silent for a moment, his mind steady as he thinks it over. Then he groans, rolls his shoulders, and leans forward, “I’m game, but in order for this to work you’ll have to stay at least half a mile away.”
“Why so far?”
“Because that’s how far she can hear things. If we’re downwind she can hear even farther.”
“That’s not possible for a human.”
“She’s no human, I tell you that. She died by the bear, she had to have, but something brought her back. I don’t know what did, but it wasn’t God, that’s for sure.”
“You think the devil brought her back? Satan?”
“I don’t know, she wasn’t Christian, she believed in her ancestors and their rituals, their gods, their magic. I don’t know what she is anymore, but I swear she could smell lies and hear the truth. It’s why she got so good at hunting people, especially at night, she’s not a human no more.”
“Well whatever it is she’s human bound, and we need to stop her as soon as we can. We’ll do the half-mile distance, but you’re going to need trackers. They’ll serve as an emergency beacon.”
“When do we do this?”
“What time do people normally hunt?”
“Morning, early morning, it can go on for hours too. But we can’t do the night, she’ll kill us if we’re out past sunset.”
“You sound sure that she wants to kill you, any reason why?”
“Her last spoken words were to me, it was graduation, I tried to talk to her and she pulled a knife on me. Then she told me if I ever, and I mean ever, came near her after the sun had set then she’d kill me and tell people the bear came for my dick this time since it was apparently going after our most important attributes.”
“Why would she say something like that?”
“I shot her, during the whole fiasco, I thought it was the bear, she never forgave me for the truth.”
“Mm, we’ll head out tomorrow, don’t alert anybody that she’s back in town, it might cause panic, it might force her hand and by tomorrow we’ll have more bodies than there are missing. Stay home today and say you all got a bad feeling about going out today, or have someone feign sickness. Just something believable, then say you’re trying again tomorrow morning.”
They get pulled for individuals next, some show remorse, some are held tightly, one shows anger; Brendan. They watch him a little closer.
____________
You know in order to sell it you’re going to have to hunt down your team members too, but they have explicit consent for you to do this, because one of the unsubs was here yesterday. They just need to figure out which one it is, and for the sake of figuring it out, you have to draw blood. You went ahead of them, geared up in ways they hadn’t seen before, and a promise not to permanently maim them. The rest of the joining crew members? Not so much. For you it’s fair game, they don’t argue with you over it.
They outfit you with a camera woven into your shirt collar, your usual earpiece, and nothing else. The trackers they give the eight potential unsubs have recorders in them too, ready to pick up any conversation that might result in confession. You leave an hour before they do, setting yourself up as you wait for them to reach your designated area. By the time they do get there you’ve killed a deer and you’re in the process of skinning it. When the first step reaches your ear, nearly done with your kill, you pause. Then you listen.
Five people within a half-mile radius, the hunt is beginning. Then in an act that can only be described as slightly barbaric, you drape the freshly departed hyde of the deer over your body, all so you can allow that inhuman piece of you to emerge. It isn’t physical, not yet, but the blood still runs over your body and the smell sharpens your nose to everything else, your ears twitch as you listen to everything.
You find Hotch first, poor man, but you do what needs to be done, and you shoot directly between his feet. His head shoots up, but you’re nowhere to be found, he knows he needs to move, and so he runs, you let him, retrieving your arrow first before you take off after him. You nearly shoot him once more ten minutes later, the arrow grazing his shoulder, cutting the shirt open and making him bleed a little bit as a gash, not deep enough for stitches but not shallow enough to truly brush off, appears too. It’s his dominant arm too, which means he’s incapacitated out here.
Different prey has you more interested though. Silas. You take off while Hotch keeps running, and after fifteen minutes, when you haven’t struck again, he reaches for his earpiece, clicking it on as he sucks his breath in, “I got on her radar, she shot two arrows at me, one between my feet, the other grazed my right bicep, I’m bleeding but it’s not the worst wound, just a nasty cut.”
Penelope’s voice comes through after a moment, “Copy, you’re close to Casey by the way, and oh, Silas is on the run.”
“Garcia stay on the line, I want you to tell us where her movements are, and how fast she’s moving. Who she spends time with and who she moves on quick enough from. When she starts chasing someone for a long period of time then we have our unsub.”
“Of course sir. She’s basically on top of him, but they’re still moving, she’s letting him run. Then, oh, they’ve both stopped, she’s just shot at him, he looks terrified, and sir, she’s wearing a deer skin.”
JJ cuts in, her voice slightly strained, “Where did she get the deer skin?”
Penelope pauses, then on her end there’s a horrible squick noise, a sharp gasp, then a click before she swallows, “It appears she didn’t wait around doing nothing this morning. She shot a deer and skinned it, that’s how she got the new addition to her wardrobe. The deer is gutted, and she was in the process of cutting it up.”
“Leaving evidence of her return, the skin is an intimidation factor. She’s waiting for one of them to find the carcass and to get scared enough to confess to nobody. They think they’re alone enough to say whatever they want.”
“Exactly, JJ, she’s getting close to you but she’s still on Silas.”
They keep moving because it’s the only thing they can do. The woods are your playground, the hunt your favorite activity. By noon you’ve grazed Hotch, chased Emily into a river, shot Silas, Elijah, and Hunter in the thighs, right where James shot you, and pinned Morgan to a tree through his pants. Spencer is the one to see you. Correction, he’s the only one you’ve allowed to see. Penelope’s voice crackles in his ear, her voice trembling slightly, “Spencer, she’s directly in front of you.”
He looks up, and there you are. It is one of the most terrifying things he has ever seen in his life. You’re up in the tree, he can barely make your face out underneath the head of the doe, half her jaw is missing, your head tucked into where her brain should be. There’s blood on your face, your hands, running off the arrow you have pointed directly at him. Deer aren’t meant to be in trees, you’ve brought one up anyway. This is not you, not the woman he knows from the bullpen. This is a predator in the element, and he is the easiest prey imaginable.
“Oh god.”
The arrow flies, another follows closely behind, one between his legs, the other directly above his head. He whimpers, eyes shutting close on instinct as he curls in on himself in an attempt to make him a smaller target. It’s only when he feels your hand on his cheek, gentle despite it all, that his eyes open. You might be covered in blood and a fresh deer skin, but you’re still you, still the girl he fell in love with over a year ago now. Your control is precise, you’d never harm him, he knows that. The arrows are proof enough.
Maybe it’s the strangeness of the moment or the trust that has cracked him open, or maybe it’s because of how you are doing everything you can to still be gentle despite the violence. Your knuckles on his cheek, delicate despite their shedding velvet. He leans into the touch, one hand coming to hold yours against his face for longer than necessary before releasing you. In the next instant, you’re gone, and Penelope’s voice comes in his ear for him and him alone.
“What was that?”
“What was what?”
“That-That look of tenderness, Spencer Reid when did you two start dating?”
“We aren’t dating!”
“Then what was that?!”
“That was-that was-fine, I’m in love with her, I’ve been in love with her and I’m confident she loves me too. We slept together once, we never talked about it again.”
“Spencer, she can’t speak.”
“She has hands.”
“You need to start moving by the way, Hunter’s coming close.”
He didn’t even notice you had taken your arrows with you, it’s only when he looks down to see how to get out that he notices he’s free, he taps his com twice, letting him come to the main channel, “I just had a run in with her.”
Morgan whistles lowly, “How’d it go?”
“Survived, she shot at me twice in one go, she was ah, directly in front of me.”
Penelope joins him, “She was, I barely realized it too until I looked at their bodycams and saw they were facing each other. That was honestly terrifying, she was just up in that tree, her weapon already drawn, blood all over her.”
“For a second I forgot it was her, I just thought that it was it, that I’d be done for now.”
Emily is next to come through, her breath coming in short bursts and the sound of twigs snapping behind her, “She’s-ugh- she’s on me right now. Except she’s making it obvious that she’s following me. Who am I near right now beside her? She’s already ran me into the river.”
“Kyle Ridges, try turning direction to see if she’s following you or going after him.”
“On it.”
“She’s turning, she turned, and our doe is still on her warpath. Emily wasn’t being chased, she was just running with her.”
“Good to know, so she can differentiate targets.”
“Yeah and I don’t know how because there’s no sign of him and he’s still at least four-hundred feet away.”
JJ cuts in, “They said she wasn’t human, not fully, and not after she turned sixteen. They said that she was returned by something from her spiritual side of the river, and she’s Cherokee, right?”
“Correct.”
Spencer nearly chokes when he spits out, “Deer woman! She’s a deer woman!”
“Care to explain, pretty boy?”
“A spirit of a woman born out of betrayal, murder, or rape, she is sent to serve justice against those with ill intent. She is a powerful shape-shifting spirit with the abilities of a deer and may often be seen as a form of vengeance. She’s been telling us this the whole time, the hunting, the senses, the deer skin, her death. She is a real, living, myth.”
They’re silent for a moment, a long one too, before Morgan breaks the silence, the strange moment when they realize that the supernatural exists, simply because you exist, “Is her technically not being a human going to be an issue?”
Hotch, on his end, thinks of all the paperwork that might entail, and the dangers that could put you in, his decision comes fast, “Absolutely not, because this is going to be a government secret that the government does not know about. Is that understood?”
“Yessir.” “Of course.” “Absolutely.”
The hunt continues, even when Penelope opens your line, her voice shaky, “I know what you are, we all do, we know you died on that rock. We know you came back as a real deer, and that’s okay too, just, just let go. We’ll be here for you when you’re ready to come back. Keep your body cam on, okay?”
Her line goes dead and you go still for a second to process her words. They figured out your secret, finally. Finally. You could nearly weep with the knowledge that they’re okay with it, that they still accept you into their fold even when you aren’t how you’re supposed to be. You are still their girl.
Just let go. And you do. With the change your mouth opens, vocals contract to let out this noise that can only be described as animalistic. It sounds like an elk, long and shrieking as it echoes through the forest. It is the first change, the one that alerts the woods you are here, that a deer woman is on the hunt. Earth responds to your touch, animals to your call, the spirits of the land you have claimed for yourself. You are something more than human.
But it is important to remember that once that’s what you were. Night will fall quicker, but with the remaining daylight you let yourself become what you have hidden for far too long. Those men sacrificed something pure, but they defiled you before they did it. You were no longer pure when they sacrificed you, you were tainted by their touches, your tears which might’ve been holy water at some point burned instead. You were made wrong, and you came back the demon they feared.
Your skin splits, your skull cracking open as the antlers emerge, your ears morphing and for a few terrifying seconds, vanish completely, which renders you deaf too. Your hair changes, so do your eyes and skin. White spots emerge on your face and arms, lining your face like contour while white grows from your roots down to the ends of your hair. Your body begins to stretch, your shape still visible but your fingers are too pointed, your legs a little odd, your arms too long. The deer skin is still draped over you, the head still over yours but further down now, her eyes covering yours. Yet your features are still yours, you’re just a little different now, a little more monstrous. It is only the reflection of their actions.
When the sun sets, when the terror starts to spike, you begin to move. They are still because they do not see you, they do not sense you. It is well into the dark when Penelope whispers in their ears, “She’s moving again. She-I don’t know what was going on, she made that noise earlier, and then things started squelching and cracking and now her cam footage shows she’s at least a foot if not two taller than before. I don’t know what you’ll be looking at when she arrives.”
Rossi drags his hands down his face, so very done with the whole ordeal, but he isn’t about to tell the mythological being to hurry it up. Not when it’s well deserved either, but really, he’s getting too old for this. It still doesn’t overtake the inane but human terror that has gripped his stomach since you began to hunt them down, knowing that you were purposefully exhausting them before forcing them into the real shitshow; Night in your domain.
“She’s moving at at minimum forty miles an hour. All of you need to regroup and hunker down, you’re going to get in her way all spread out. I’ll direct you all where to go, but I’m so, so serious when I say you all need to draw as little attention to yourselves as possible right now. Do you understand? You are in the woods with a predator whose purpose is to enact vengeance and justice with the ones who created her through violent means. She will harm you right now.”
They agree, and Penelope begins to direct them to the car again while you start to chase. It is tedious work to work around everything. Your territory is vast, and it is difficult to navigate, especially in the dark. There are other things beside you here too, and no doubt your call has attracted various creatures. Hotch runs into a bear once, they stare at each other for five long minutes, the bear a mere five feet away, and then it turns, vanishing into the woods. He picks his pace up after that.
It takes three hours to get out of your land, and it is some of the most treacherous three hours of their life. They hear the screaming occasionally, or the groan of a branch with something too heavy on it. There’s still the thwack of your arrow on something, sometimes it’s soft, sometimes it’s hard. Penelope forces them to be still when you’re within two-hundred meters of them, allowed to move to where they can get as small as possible and somewhere with coverage.
Sometimes they run into the path of destruction, seeing where you had rampaged your way through and decimated some shit. They don’t miss the bloodstains, or the arrows. What is happening in the forest is beyond government jurisdiction, or their call for that matter. What is happening here is you and your revenge, quite literally spiritual on a level that they have just barely begun to understand.
They make it to the car, collapsing with harsh breath, cuts, bruises, clothes ruined beyond repair, and they wait, because that is the only thing that they can do. They try to block out the screaming from outside, they don’t speak of what went down in there either. Spencer thinks of your hands on his cheeks, the confession silent but there, he had held you there a moment longer, and now he wonders if you’ll be coming back for more, or if that was it. If that’s all he’s allowed for the rest of his existence. Nothing but the fleeting softness of your blood soaked skin on his.
It’s close to three in the morning when the trees shake, when the screaming gets too loud to ignore. The doors lock, instantly, all cells off as Penelope whispers to them, her voice laced with terror, “She’s here. She and James are here.”
James, right on cue, stumbles to the road, he’s clutching his gun, face bloodied and hair messed up, he’s got a gash on his side and his eyes are wide, terrified beyond belief. They get a second where it’s nothing but them and him, the snot running over his lips, and then the dip of weight in the car. Everything goes absolutely still, and then a hoof presses against the hood of the car, followed by another, and then you’re there. But you also aren’t. The deer skin is still there with you, dangled and clinging, your clothes are torn, but you’re unharmed.
You’re just. You’re just wrong. You move like an animal, slow, deliberate, they see the proud crown of antlers upon your head. They’re elk antlers, not deer, but you’re still a deer woman. James whimpers, stumbling back as you creep nearer to him, and then in the next instant, you’re gone. Like you vanished out of thin air, nobody dares breathe. Then you’re back, but you’re behind him, hands curling over his middle and yanking back into the darkness, they see you, the front of you. Blood stained with too sharp teeth, the spots and the white hair. For a moment you look directly at them, your eyes fully black, and there’s blood coming from your mouth.
You disappear again, although you mustn't have gone far, because when James screams it sounds like you’re right above them, and honestly, you might be. His arm thuds in front of the car, and then his screams subside too soon, too clean. Penelope’s voice breaks the silence, trembling and cautious, “Time to go home, she’s a mile away now.”
Hotch doesn’t argue, he just starts the ignition.
____________
Big Bear is sitting on the porch, waiting, because he knows there will be a visitor tonight. The family sits inside, waiting too, but they do not know what or who is visiting so late at night. It’s closer to sunrise when you emerge from the tree line, and that is when he stands. The family shifts uneasily, but they do not move, you do. You are smaller now, your normal size again, but the eyes, the antlers, the spot, the ears, they have not faded, nor have the hooves. You have your bow and arrows over your back, you do not draw them. The blood is unmistakable. You will not need weapons to finish them off if you wish to.
“Would you like to come inside?”
He moves towards the door, and you move towards him, you do not attack, he opens the door. Your hooves clack on the stairs and the porch, and then the floor. Your father follows you in, and you look at your family for the first time in five years. Brothers, sisters, none of the small children are here, some of the ones that were small when you left are now big and sitting with the rest tonight. You stare at Tiffany, she’s put on some weight since you left, baby weight, but she’s more or less the same as you left her with.
There is no mistaking you for what you are. The antlers, the spots, Tiffany can only swallow under your weighted stare, “Little Doe.”
You tilt your head at her, even if it is just to see her squirm, “Where have you been?”
You don’t dignify any of them with an answer, instead you head upstairs, to your old bedroom, and they don’t hear a single thing from you. Only the shower is starting to run, and that is when Taylor looks at his eldest daughter, “You knew something about her being deer woman, didn’t you?”
She haunches in on herself a little bit, “She told me a tale, it made no sense.”
“You knew she had become something else. You knew she had died.”
“She blamed eight boys, one of them was her boyfriend. You think James Cochran turned her into a deer woman? Him, the guy who made homemade corn nuggets and frybread for her. The guy who searched for her for three days, no sleep, barely anything to eat or drink, was the one to do the deed. Why the hell would he do that to her?”
“Because she was leaving! She was leaving and we gave her hell for that too, of course James was going to do something drastic to keep her by her side. No wonder she fucking left us here.”
He pinches his nose, shutting his eyes as he thinks of you in that forest, alone and bleeding and hurt and you weren’t coming home. He knew that you had gone into that forest one night and who walked out wasn’t his daughter. You weren’t his anymore, and he didn’t know how to handle that. So you made it official. He remembers the day you had left, when he had gotten that first glimpse of something wrong in you. He had argued with you, pressed to hear your voice instead of the angered flick of your hands. He didn’t even know how it devolved to you shedding your name like velvet, and your already scarce words turning into a man-made drought over the course of five years.
It had though, and now you’re back, the stink of revenge just as pungent as the blood on your body. Whatever has gone down in the woods tonight is the work of you, work of the spirits. Because that’s what you are now, a spirit. His daughter died in the forest that night, he knows that now. It doesn’t hurt any less, maybe it hurts more, knowing that Little Doe has been dead for a long time. Part of him feels like he’s just gotten the news that his daughter’s missing body had been confirmed and found, that she’s coming home. The shower upstairs shuts off.
He turns away from the stairs, he can do nothing but breathe. His daughter died in that forest, Little Doe no more, but there is a woman upstairs with your face and your scars. Older and wiser, black hair and eyes, spots too. Your antlers are almost porcelain white, different even in the realm of the spirits. Again, there is no mistaking what you are, and they know how a deer woman is born. Nobody speaks when you step down the stairs, the jingle of your skirts breaking the silence. He sees the beads first, and then he sees your outfit.
It’s an older, more matured version of your regalia from when you were nineteen, altered to fit you as you are now. You look like something from a legend, something old and something that they cannot touch. Exactly how you are meant to be. For a moment he sees you in this dress when you were sixteen, dark hair and smiling lips, two weeks before you went silent. If you had been given a funeral the pictures of you used would’ve been his memories come to tangible evidence. Then he sees the child version of you in your regalia, the gummy smile and awkward posing, it’s hard to think that she is you.
He has the urge to reach out to you, beg you to come sit down and just be with them tonight, but your business is not finished for the night. No, you still have one remaining task, and that is to find three souls taken to your forest. Your regalia looks as if there is a sunset upon your body, the two layers of jingles clinking together despite how still you stand. Then in a blink the door is swaying, and you are gone.
It is unmistakable that you were staring directly at Tiffany, your truth spoken in your pointed silence. Because even though you didn’t speak, had used your hands rather than the voice you were given, you had told them something was wrong. You had shown it in so many ways, and they had punished you for it instead. Little Doe died in the forest eight years ago. Angry Buck died in the forest as soon as you shed your human velvet, and now what remains they do not know what to name, what to call.
_____________
You find Angela, Crystal, and Kyle stored in an abandoned mine close to the edge of your territory, but just outside of it. Smart, not to put people who meant something to you within your boundaries. They look up when they hear your hooves against the ground, and then when you appear they go dry. You know you must look like a sight, the regalia and the antlers, the everything. Kyle whispers your name, voice hoarse and cracked, you only incline your head towards him.
There is something special about being a deer woman. The laws of modernity do not apply to you. Constitutions and handcuffs do not mean a thing in your book. There is only you, a spirit of justice, a paragon of revenge, and what you deem fitting for the people. Crystal and Kyle had never done you wrong. Angela, on the other hand, has wronged you, and there is no shared blood between either of you. You reach for Crystal and Kyle, fingers curling around their wrists as you pull on your power, drawing it and directing it to where you need to go.
There’s an uncomfortable lurch, and then the smell of something sterile. You blink, looking around the room to find yourself in a medical storage unit. Kyle and Crystal lay on the floor, weakened and quiet, you can tell they’ve been starved, dehydrated, beaten too. There’s also no way you’re walking out there on your own, you need someone to come in. That you can do, a little tug of power, a little pull, you let the hook dangle.
Two minutes later, there’s a bite. The door opens as a resident steps inside, he’s young and nervous, and then he freezes when he sees you standing with two bodies beside you. The door shuts behind him, and when he blinks, you’re gone. He makes a noise, weak and strained as he looks around for any sign of you, but you’re gone, just like you were never there in the first place.
You return to Angela, to the way she looks ready to plead. Part of you feels bad that this has happened to her, that she got caught in the cross-fire of it all. The other part, the greater part, remembers what she had done to you in your teenage years. You were popular, yes, but so was she, and you were coming for her spot on the hierarchy. Even in your silence you had been revered by the student body. Angela had whispered in people’s ear that you were a whore, a slut, that you were taken to the woods to shut you up. So many men had tried to fuck you without asking after her rumour had spread.
They had taken her word as gospel, they had taken it as the truth and ran with it. You can still feel their hands on your waist, on your ass, a memorable time where one had gone up your skirt from the front. Of course you had fought it, had done everything in you to make sure nobody touched you again. That didn’t mean you were always successful though, sometimes they managed to get what they wanted, and each time your silence was only solidified.
She had done that, all because you were getting more popular than her. You stare at her, the messed up hair and the way she’s bound, you don’t wish rape upon her, you wish it upon nobody. That doesn’t mean that you don’t want to see her dead. In these woods, these mountains, you are justice. The woods do not belong to man, nor do they have boundaries to divide provisions and jurisdiction. They belong to nobody but themselves, and the laws here are different.
Angela never quite understood that either. You’d make sure she did after tonight. It’s easy to unclasp her from her chains, she gasps when she’s released, body crumpling to the dirty stone floor. She says thank you over and over again, but you aren’t here to rescue her. They say there are no more wolves in the mountains, you know better than that though. She does not, because she is not deserving enough of the forest. She does not know them well enough to find her way out even in the daylight, and unfortunately for her, the sun will not come to save her.
You do not say anything to her, even when she drags her body to you, her cries of thanks turning into pleas for help and you do not lift a finger. Not even when she is there at your hooves, tears she cannot afford to shed running down her face, her grimy fingernails reaching to tug at your hands as she pleads. For a second, you let her believe that she is being heard, then you take a step back, harsh enough to where her body falls forward in an effort to keep hold of you. You don’t let her come close enough to touch you again.
“Why aren’t you helping me? Why? I-I can barely move and you’re just standing there!”
She does not deserve a response, she does not deserve your mercy. You stare at her, that blank faced look and you used to be so sweet, she remembers that. You used to be kind to the animals, no matter which ones came across your path, she remembers your code when hunting, how all parts must be used for something. You used to have the loveliest voice of the forest, and it has been eight years since anybody has heard of it. She remembers using that against you.
“If-If this is about high school then I’m sorry, I’m so sorry, I was stupid and young and I should’ve apologized earlier. I should never have done that, nobody deserved it, especially not you. I’m sorry, I’m sorry, please help me.”
You tilt your head at her, slow, calculated, she knows she is being judged by you. She had never thought that her life would depend on your forgiveness, and yet here she is. It’s dark, well past midnight, and the forest is so intimidating to her. She can see the outlines but she cannot see detail, she knows that her survival is tied with your kindness. Except you haven’t been kind in a long time.
She heaves herself up, fighting the way her legs threaten to fall underneath her, body swaying dangerously before she leans against the wall, breathing hard when she does. Like a newborn fawn. You move to the end of the mine shaft, she makes it there, a little stronger than earlier, but nowhere near fit enough to make it out of the woods. For a moment you and her stare at each other, you, the product of actions with consequences, and her, the one with the actions.
“What are you doing? Can’t you-Can’t you just whisk us away like you did to Crystal and Kyle? Please just get us out of here, please. Do you have any idea what it’s been like in there? What they’ve done to us?”
There are a thousand questions you can ask her back, but she is not worthy of your voice. She is not worthy. That sound from earlier, the sound of an elk rather than a deer, spills out of you. This time there is power curling in the noise, stretching and touching everything the noise touches. She clutches at her ears, wailing as the noise makes her drums bleed, but you don’t care. You don’t. You move, faster than she can think, and then you wait for her to realize that you are gone, that you might’ve freed her but you aren’t saving her either.
She stills for a moment, eyes wide and breath heavy as she thinks of what to do. Fear makes her sluggish, too sluggish, she barely has time before she hears the first howl, the scratch of claw on stone, branches bending for what is coming. Her eyes go wide, body going absolutely still, and then she bolts. She’s not very fast, stumbling blind and panicked in the dark as she tries to navigate her way. The wolves get closer, you can smell them in the air, their hunger loud in the way that they start to enclose on her.
You are up in the trees the moment it happens, when she stumbles into the clearing you were killed at, when she climbs your rock as if it will save her from her fate. This is when you make your last appearance, your face close to hers as your fingers spell out words in her palm, “I died here, you will too.”
Then the wolves burst through the clearing, yipping with their jaws snapping, she whimpers, curling in on herself in an effort to not be found, but it’s useless. They take her by the ankles, teeth gnashing into flesh and digging into bone. She screams, but they are overtaken by the sound of her flesh tearing, a wet sound that would make men puke, but you are no man. You watch as the layers of skin are pulled apart, the pinkness exposed and run with red, which sprays and pools. The wolves tear her apart until she is nothing but a memory that the forest will hold. Her blood on the ground is a reminder that silence can be kinder than words. In the case of you and her, that’s what it was.
There is a certain sort of satisfaction in you when it is over, when the wolves leave the scene with bloodied paw prints on the crunchy foliage below. Angela is no more, you know she won’t be coming back either. Not like you did. Not like you. You do not return to the station, or to the airbnb, or the home that you were born in. Instead you sit on the rock and you stay on that rock.
You think of the BAU, the profiling work that you’ve done and the cases you’ve attended to. Hotch, Rossi, your team, Spencer. He is kind, soft in the ways you need him to be and hardening where it is vital. His intellect is not to insult you, but rather a soother when you find yourself out of your depth. There is resilience in his statistics and his mind, strength in it that you find comforting. He is sweet to you too, you can hear the way his heart speeds up when you are near, you can smell his attraction to you from half-a-mile away. Yet you do not mind it, you bask in it, because you cannot smell ill-intent on him.
If you ever leave this forest, you don’t know what it’ll look like for you. The team knows what you are now, what you are capable of. Will they report it to the government? Will you be put under experimentation or review? Would it be safer to be as you were made to be? A spirit of the forest to enact justice and get revenge. Your revenge has been satisfied though, that thirst finally quenched. You are content in the forest, but you are also content when you are away from it.
The forest is where you were born, where you grew, and where you died. It does not mean you must spend an eternity with it too. Your forest is understanding, especially of the inhabitants. You will always be welcomed, you will always have that link to your identity and what you are. If you leave again it will not harm you, but merely say see you later. You lay on that rock in the same position that you died in, the memories no longer burying you like they used to do. Instead you think of them, and you do not flinch away. The tightness in your throat subsides.
For hours you lay there, even when the sun has risen and the animals come and go. You are perfectly still when a fox sleeps on your stomach or birds comb through your hair. You listen to the wind and the trees, they whisper memories to you that predate your town, they tell you of your ancestors that roamed these lands. They tell you of the deer women in your lineage, how they were saddened to see you join them like you did. They tell you of these women and the hell that they brought upon the ones that made them like that. They tell you they understand.
You are there for two days, just you and the rock. You listen and you think and it is in the dead stillness of sunrise on the third day that you do not raise your hands when you open your mouth. The noise that comes out is one you do not recognize, older, more mature, you suppose you have to thank your status as a spirit because it does not hurt to talk and it does not sound weak. Instead it sounds like you, just grown up.
“I am going home.”
Just because you haven’t used your voice in a long time and it doesn’t hurt doesn’t mean it’s easy to speak. Four words nearly have you puking, but you don’t. Instead you rise from your headstone, because that’s what it is. A headstone. Little Doe died here, and this is where she rests for eternity. The memory of her shown in a fading bloodstain upon rock made billions of years ago. There has been blood spilled on this rock in the past, long before you were even an idea to think of, and there will be blood spilt on it in the future, long after humanity forgets you existed.
For now though there is you, warm and alive to rest on the boulder. You don’t know what’s happened in the last few days since you’ve been gone. Maybe you’re classified as missing in action, maybe you’re being hunted down. Either way you aren’t there, and you wonder if they’re searching for you. You’d like to think that if they are Spencer is the one leading them in. He is, after all, the one with eidetic memory. Therefore, he’s the one who knows the path best. So you sit, and you wait, and maybe you’d wait a lifetime on that rock for somebody who didn’t want to look for you, but that is not this life.
This time, on the morning of the third day, you hear your team in the forest cursing as Spencer drags them through the foliage. You choose to tune them out, but you’re aware of their presence, and so you leave the rock. But you purposefully leave a trace of you on the rock. A ring, one of yours that you rarely ever take off, still warm from your touch. You leave it there when they get close, right when they’re about to crest over the hill and see you. The ring, when the sun hits it just so, is hard to miss despite the size of the thing.
All of them stand there in a uniform line, panting and clearly exhausted, but they’re there. They see the ring, Spencer is the one to take it though, “Still warm, she knows we’re here and nearby.”
They scan the forest, searching for you whom they cannot see. They’re not wearing vests, nor do they have any weapons drawn, not that they could kill you, you wouldn’t let them. They do not put their hands up in surrender, they merely wait and glance at each other before Hotch clears his throat, “The government doesn’t know about what you are, we have no intentions of disclosing that information either.”
He pauses, and then he continues, “We’d like it if you were on the plane with us going back home.”
You had told the forest you were going home. Where is home though? Is it here, in the forest with the sprawling greens and forever scent of rain. Or is it the city with the bright lights, the people and the bustling hub of action. If you stay here you’ll never be one of the people in the town, you’ll forever be the huntress of the forest, something sweet turned sinister. If you go back to Washington, to the FBI, you have purpose with the underlying fear of discovery, of them deciding that you aren’t worth the effort of secrecy.
Emily tries next, “We know what they did to you, we know you operate on a system that the government, that we, have no right to question or control. We have no intention of doing such a thing, we don’t judge you for it either. I would’ve done the same to them if they did to me what they did to you.”
Her word is truth, so is Hotch’s. Ever so quietly you emerge from your space behind the tree, the jingle of your skirt alerting them of your presence. They find you immediately, a stark contrast to everything in the forest that surrounds you. Spencer is the first to approach you, he takes his steps slowly, gingerly, as if you are just a deer and he’s doing his damndest not to startle you. Delicate, because with you he is always delicate.
Not in the way that he bubblewraps you or cradles your emotions like they are custard that hasn’t been set properly. But in the sense that you are something precious to him, something he wants to treasure properly. You’ve had years to get used to it, and still it surprises you whenever you find it so brazenly on display. You let him come near, because you’ve never been able to hold him further than arms’ length away. He looks at you, not like you’re something to mourn but something to revere instead, “Are you satisfied?”
Are you? You can still feel the anger lining your bones, the hatred you have for their faces and souls lingers in the crevices of your identity, leaking through your actions and judgements. You had been too angry to speak, their deaths had loosened the rope around your neck.
“I am.”
Spencer chokes, just a little, and it takes everything in the team to not follow suit. Your voice, the one you had been forced to tramp down on, is finally heard. They had slit your throat to silence you, but they remain in pieces on the forest floor and you are here in your regalia with antlers sticking out of your head. You aren’t sure who got the better deal, but at the moment it feels like you’ve won a long war you hadn’t known you were fighting.
“You’re speaking.”
That makes your brow quirk up, lips tilting up too, even if it is the barest bits of a smile, “Really?”
“Oh my god.”
His eyes are growing wet, teary, and you could joke, could ask him for me? But you don’t, instead you just sigh, a fond sound really, your thumb reaching up to swipe the first tear that spills over away, “Spencer.”
He drags you into a hug, fierce and tight and it startles you at first, but you give into it within a matter of seconds. You have to think of your antlers, but none of it matters when he’s clinging to you like a lifeline, and you are too even if you wouldn’t admit it. You can feel his heart stuttering with how fast it’s going, you can smell the relief coming off of him. He loves you, that you’re sure of.
Eventually he does pull back, he doesn’t kiss you right then, now isn’t the time. Instead he just stares, memorizing your face in the daylight especially now that isn’t covered in blood, “Come home?”
You sigh, eyes fluttering shut for a moment as you weigh the choice, but it’s an easy one despite it all, “I’m coming home.”
____________
While you can hide the antlers, the whited out eyes, the hooves, you can’t hide most of the spots, or the white hair. You aren’t sure why you got the white out version of a deer woman, but you also aren’t complaining. You just have to get used to having a blanket of snow atop your head instead of a coat of raven feathers. The white spots are seen closer to your hairline, peeking out under your cheekbone but never going too far. What also won’t go away is the claws you have at the ends of your fingernails, it’s like pointed pieces of deer hooves have stuck themselves on.
What goes down officially is that James Cochran orchestrated the entire ordeal, when he was found out he took his friends to the woods under the guise of a hunting trip and shot them all, including Angela, then himself. He also allegedly kidnapped you, but you survived the encounter. Is the bureau pleased? No, but there’s only so much they can be mad about when it comes to a lack of cell-service and a group of hunters versus their back yard. When it comes down to it though the team found out who it was a day after James had taken them up to the woods.
On the final day your family appears on the porch of the station, your father at the lead. Hotch tells you, ever so gently, that they are waiting for you there, but you are not obligated to see them. You go anyway because you aren’t sure when you’ll come back to this town, to these particular woods. Or if you’ll even come back at all. At nineteen you swore you wouldn’t, at twenty-four you broke that vow. Spencer comes with you as backup, just in case things start to go wrong, you let him tag along too. It feels better with him by your side.
Luke Cochran watches as you two descend, you aren’t wearing your regalia, you had to change before being taken in by the medical people, when questioned how you weren’t suffering any you told them that the woods would protect you. They provided food, water, shelter, if one couldn’t survive the woods they had no business being in the woods. Nobody questioned you after that, even if they maybe should’ve done so.
Your father, when he sees you without the antlers and the hooves, or the ears, you had forgotten about the ears, he looks ready to bend over with his grief. As if seeing you with the white hair had confirmed his nightmare of that night to be true. For a moment nobody says anything, Spencer stands beside you, too close to be professional, or even just friendly, but distant enough to where he’s not smothering you. You tilt your chin up a little, a small indicator for him to speak.
“Little Doe, we hear you’re leaving today.”
Ever the wise man, ever the torchbearer of torturous truth whenever it comes to you. You don’t know how to feel about him most of the time. How good he is when he’s good, how mean he is when he’s bad. You’ve felt the strength of his hands in forms of bruises mottled black and blue against your skin and you’ve felt his love in the way he’s braided your hair as you grew up. He loves you, that you know, but his love wasn’t enough to deter his anger either.
“I am.”
There’s a ripple of whispers in your family, you even see your mother start to weep. Your voice which had been shut away for so long finally came back to life, it is no coincidence that with the nine recent deaths your voice has returned to you. Again, you do not know what you are anymore, what your title shall be. Little Doe is dead with a bloodstained boulder as a gravemarker. Angry Buck is dead because all the velvet of her has been shed. Now there is you, and whatever you are.
This your father seems to understand too judging by the little gleam in his eyes. You aren’t sure why the nicknames are so important to your family, no other Native family uses names like it anymore, except for perhaps the elders. Yet your father has always insisted on using Cherokee names for him and his family. They are more ceremonial, but everyone uses them as if they are your names. You have gone through two names, and now you wait for your third, and final, name.
“Go where you need to be White-Antlered Elk, it is not here.”
White-Antlered Elk, straight-forward, yes, and a little on the nose, but you do not shy away from the title either. The white elk are rare, far and few between, you know it is something special for you to bear a crown of them. You think maybe something went even more wrong in their victory ritual that night, it brought you back as something even worse than the average deer woman. You don’t know, frankly, you don’t care either. You’re alive, you have your blood soaked revenge, and you’re going back home.
Your father is right about you not being needed here. It isn’t malicious, but this place, these woods, this isn’t where you need to be. These are the words that you mull over on the plane ride back to Quantico. Spencer sits across from you, deep in his crossword puzzle as everyone sits and enjoys the few hours of peace from the mission. It’s been a rough one, and an enlightening one as well. You are the White-Antlered Elk of the woods, you are justice, you are revenge. You are also a daughter, a lover, and a person. You aren’t any less for what has happened to you and what you have become from it. You can still be loved, you are still loved, you are wanted too, not just for your body or your skills but because you are you. You are wanted in your silence, you are wanted even in the throes of your bloodlust, you are wanted when you are at your lows and highs. You are simply wanted. You are not less for anything you have done. You were human, you were a girl, and that was stolen from you. It was not your fault, you did nothing wrong. You didn’t deserve it. That is the truth, and there is nothing to put to rest but the truth.
pairing: steve harrington x reader
summary: it’s the age-old fall from grace: high school royalty faceplants into reality, and the burger king crown starts hanging heavy. (sailor hat, in his case.) heir to the hawkins high hierarchy, ruler of keggers and hallways alike, steve harrington used to be untouchable. now? he's shaking under your hands, bleeding from battles no trophy could ever commemorate. you've stitched together plenty of broken people before—but never one that left a scar in you, too.
warnings: 18+ mdni, piv sex, oral (m!receiving), touch/praise-starved!steve, hurt/comfort, blood, injury, mutual friends/enemies-ish to lovers, hair washing, massaging, praise kink, body worship, sexual tension, forced proximity of sorts, reader isn’t fond of steve at first, mostly S4 canon but fix-it, angst, domestic fluff, found family, happy ending
a/n: another steve harrington character study dressed as a fic, what the hell else is new? | playlist ♬.ᐟ
They don’t take him to the hospital. They bring him to you.
Which is, objectively, stupid.
But apparently, hospitals ask questions. And you—part-time party medic, occasional dispenser of prescription-only painkillers (for legitimate anxiety and migraines, thank you very much)—you don’t.
You’re halfway through a rerun of M.A.S.H., sucking the soul out of a cherry popsicle. You’re braless. The house is quiet. Peaceful, if a little tragic. Exactly the way Fridays are meant to be.
Until the knocking starts.
Correction: pounding.
Panicked, frenzied, FBI-doesn’t-need-a-warrant kind of pounding.
You groan and peel yourself off the couch, popsicle stick still dangling from your lips. You are not emotionally equipped to accept salvation or Thin Mints right now.
But when you open the door, it’s not a solicitor.
It’s Robin.
Robin Buckley, looking like she just got shot out of a chimney. Her cheek’s streaked with soot and something red that is very much not Kool-Aid.
You blink. Yank the popsicle out of your mouth with a wet plop.
“Don’t freak out,” she blurts, before you even ask.
Which is Robin Buckley-speak for: Start freaking out immediately. Shit is on fire, metaphorically or otherwise.
The last time she said that, you ended up faking an asthma attack so you could ditch pep band and hit up Denny’s for the $1.99 Grand Slam. The time before that, you drove through three counties to rescue her cousin’s “emotional support ferret” from a petting zoo in Muncie.
This time? She’s brought a car with her.
A sleek maroon BMW, purring at the curb, passenger door flung wide open.
Inside: Limbs. Denim. Blood.
A boy.
Slumped sideways in the front seat, head tilted back at an angle that screams whiplash or maybe already dead.
You squint.
“Who the fuck is that?”
…
Steve Harrington.
Steve Harrington is bleeding out in your driveway.
You don’t know him. Not really.
Knew of him, sure. Back in high school, he was all Farrah Fawcett volume and varsity swagger. Heir to the Hawkins High hierarchy, ruling keggers and hallways alike. He had rich parents and a bimmer he didn’t pay for. Threw parties like they were some kind of divine rite.
But then? Senior year hit him like a metaphorical truck. Or maybe a literal one. Hard to say.
Because somewhere between the scorched-earth gossip of graduation and the literal scorched-earth of the mall burning down, Steve Harrington dropped off the map.
Poof. King Steve: dethroned.
Burned out, like the very mall he used to work in.
You missed that whole implosion. Spent that summer in Chicago drowning in vending machine coffee and disaster drills, chasing your EMT cert while trying not to puke during ride-alongs.
You came home to find that Hawkins had gained a mall, lost a mall, and started blaming everything weird on “gas leaks” again.
And Robin Buckley had Steve.
Her little sidekick from the ice cream wars. Who, allegedly, once confronted a creeper in the food court for harassing her. Ruined his pretty face doing it, too. Walked around with a purple shiner for weeks after that summer ended.
He now stocks tapes with her at Family Video, where helping customers ranks somewhere between abusing the label maker and arguing over who gets to abuse the label maker.
You ran into him once, alone, in the cereal aisle of Melvald’s.
Dark rings under his eyes. Hair still doing that gravity-defying thing.
He smiled. You didn’t smile back.
You didn’t care.
It’s the age-old fall from grace: high school royalty faceplants into reality, and the Burger King crown starts hanging heavy. (Well, sailor hat, in his case.)
But now, he’s here.
Dying on your lawn.
Ruining your Friday.
…
Up close, he looks worse.
Biblically bad.
Like, plague-of-locusts, hail-from-the-heavens, Lamb-of-God-who? kind of bad.
His jeans are shredded, shirt gone entirely. Bright red ligature marks around his throat like someone tried to strangle him with a piano wire. There’s ash in his hair, and something black smeared across his jaw that you’re really, really hoping is just dirt.
His eyes flutter.
Then, absurdly, he smiles.
“H-hey. Heard you know first aid?”
You stare at him for a beat. Then toss your popsicle stick into the grass.
“Yeah. Try not to bleed out on my porch, Harrington.”
He snorts. Gives you a weak thumbs-up.
Then promptly goes limp.
…
“It’s called compensated shock,” you grunt, dragging six-feet-too-much of unconscious prom royalty into your living room. “He looked okay ‘cause his body was pumping him full of adrenaline. Now it’s wearing off.”
Robin’s on the other end, doing her best to help, which mostly means not helping.
“Oh my god, yeah,” she babbles, smacking his sneakers into the doorframe. “—shit. He got all woozy at Skull Rock earlier.”
You pause mid-haul. “Skull Rock? Like, the makeout spot?”
Robin makes a face. “Yeah, but not for us, gross. That’d be like making out with my brother. Anyway, Steve invented Skull Rock! Took Heather C. there in tenth grade. Remember her? The girl with, like, thirty scrunchies and that creepy obsession with Mr. Connor’s—”
“Robin.”
“Right! Sorry! Panic talking!”
Steve groans from where you’ve deposited him on the couch, more pained by Robin’s volume than the probable internal bleeding.
You ignore him. “Why were you actually at Skull Rock?”
“Uhh walking? You know... trees. Friendship.”
You level her with a look.
She claps her hands. “Anyway! You can fix him, right? You’re, like, certified!”
You glance down at Steve.
His lips are blue at the corners, breath hitching in those tight, silent gulps that mean pain and refusal to show it.
“Yeah,” you say quietly. “Maybe.”
…
You do fix him.
Because you’re a sucker. Because you trained for this. Because your hands know what to do even when your brain is screaming.
And maybe, just maybe, because Steve Harrington keeps making these soft, miserable, apologetic noises every time he flinches.
Like he’s sorry.
Sorry for bleeding. For being in pain. For existing.
You hate that.
You also kind of hate how he looks like this—hot, in that tragic, beaten, dog-left-out-in-the-rain kind of way that hits your brain like a chemical imbalance.
You strip off his vest first (Dio patch on the back, which, huh, maybe he has changed) and find a makeshift bandage beneath it, half-dried and crusted with old blood. You peel it off. It comes away with a wet schlorp like opening a bottle of dollar store wine.
And something inside you goes still.
These are... bite marks.
Not scrapes. Not scratches.
Bites.
His flesh looks shredded, like a rottweiler got bored of chew toys and decided to sample teenage boy instead.
Except: you’ve treated dog bites. This is not a dog bite.
“Jesus christ,” you whisper.
You look up at the boy collapsed on your couch: sweaty, shirtless, and—oh, now he’s got a belt in his mouth.
Robin jams it there. “For the pain,” she says, helpful as ever.
Steve groans around the leather, eyes fluttering. Looks like he wants to die.
You’re still staring at the worst bite, wondering if it’s actually moving, when you ask, voice low:
“Someone want to tell me what the fuck did this?”
Robin freezes. Eyes the belt like she’d rather choke on it herself than answer.
“Uh… bats?” She offers weakly.
You blink. “Bats.”
“Like. Big ones? Really big?”
You stare at her. Then at Steve.
You don’t believe her.
But also… you kind of do.
Because whatever this thing was, it didn’t just attack.
It fed.
…
“Okay, but like—” Robin’s pacing like she’s trying to wear a hole in your rug. “He was fine earlier. Like, maybe not fine fine, but, you know, Steve-fine. And then we got out of the Up—uh—the woods, and I was driving him back and he just…”
She makes a dramatic fainting motion. Nearly brains herself on the coffee table.
“So, it could be rabies? Or tetanus? Or maybe one of those parasite things that lay eggs in your stomach? Or—”
“Robin?” you cut in, sharp as the pair of shears in your hand. “There’s towels and vodka in the kitchen. Go.”
“Right. On it.”
She skitters away like a gremlin set on fire, the thud of cabinet doors punctuating her panic.
You turn back to Steve.
His pulse is thin, fluttering weakly under your fingertips, but it’s there.
“Harrington. You with me?”
His hand twitches once, thumb up.
…
He doesn’t scream.
You wish he would.
Because you know this hurts. You know that when you pour antiseptic into wounds this deep, it’s supposed to rip sound out of a person. A yell. A curse. A sob. Something.
But Steve just… takes it.
His jaw’s locked tight enough to bend steel—no belt, miracle he doesn’t shatter a molar—and his throat works once, twice, swallowing back whatever wants out. His whole body trembles, shoulders twitching, knuckles bone-white, yet his voice stays sealed inside him like it’s chained there.
You kind of hate him for it.
Because you know this type.
Boys who bleed quiet. The beautiful, tragic kind who carry pain like it’s a penance.
You’ve seen them before, at crash sites, in the backs of ambulances.
It’s not bravery. It’s habit.
A mask.
And Steve Harrington? He’s been wearing his so long, it’s practically fused to the bone.
Still, Robin squeezes his hand like she’s coaching him through labor. Eyes locked on the ceiling, because she’s still pretending she’s never seen boobs or blood or the inside of a human person.
You press gauze to the worst of the bites, just under his ribs, angry and wet and oozing something thick. You have to lean your weight into it.
Steve jolts—full-body, every muscle locking under your palms. His hand lashes out, fast and blind, gripping the leg of your jeans until his knuckles go pale.
Then, just as quickly, he lets go. Eyes squeezed shut. Shame radiating off him like heat.
“Shit. S-sorry.”
You don’t answer.
You can’t.
…
It takes two hours.
Three full rolls of gauze. One regrettable vodka break, just to keep your hands from shaking.
It's not pretty. Not even close. But it's enough to keep him breathing, which, all things considered, feels like a decent win for a Friday night.
Now, he’s bandaged. Shirtless under your ex’s old hoodie, the one with the weird bleach stain and the hole in the sleeve, but Steve fills it out like it was made for him.
Of course he does.
In the kitchen, Robin’s hunched over your tiny sink, scrubbing dried blood and whatever else is staining her forearms that awful color.
As soon as she’s done, you grab her by the sleeve and tug her into the hallway.
“Talk.”
Robin sighs, long and loud. Tries to stall by running a hand through her hair, only to grimace when it sticks up with dried sweat.
“…Demobats.” She mutters.
“I’m sorry?”
“Demobats,” she repeats, like that’s a word people just know. “From this place called the… Upside Down.”
You wait. There’s no punchline.
“…You’re serious.”
She nods.
And then it all spills out.
Demobats. Some guy named Vecna. Russians. Underground government labs. Scoops Ahoy, for christ’s sake.
You lose the thread somewhere around “telepathic hive mind overlord.”
But you don’t interrupt. Because Robin may be a lot of things—loud, chaotic, deathly allergic to social cues—but she’s not a liar.
And there’s a half-dead boy on your couch with holes the size of teacups to prove it.
“So,” you say slowly, “that job at the mall…”
“Yeah. Secret Russian lab.”
“And you were tortured?”
“I mean, mostly Steve?” She winces. “But, uh. Yeah.”
“Jesus christ, Robin.”
“I know,” she groans, dragging both hands down her face. “I know it sounds crazy. I didn’t want to drag you into this, okay? But I thought—he looked bad. Worse than before. And I couldn’t exactly walk into the ER and say ‘Hi, my best friend got eaten by mutant bats from another dimension, please ignore the blood trail.’”
She huffs, blowing hair from her eyes, and squints at you. “You don’t believe me.”
You snort. “No. I do. And I think you should’ve called me sooner.”
“Well, I thought he was fine. He was fine. Until we got in the car and he started slurring his words and, like… blinking wrong. Then I panicked.”
You glance back toward the living room. At the boy who didn’t scream. Curled on your couch, twitching in his sleep like he’s stuck in a loop he can’t wake from.
Robin follows your gaze, voice softening. “Look, I know he’s not exactly your favorite person, but… thank you. Really.”
You roll your eyes. “He was bleeding out, Robs.”
She gives you a look. The kind that says she knows you better than you want her to.
You scowl.
“Go. Shower. You smell like a burnt tire.” A beat. “…You want something to eat?”
Robin doesn’t answer. Just throws her arms around you in the tightest, sweatiest, most Robin hug imaginable. All elbows and bones and bloodstained sleeves.
You stiffen. Then sigh.
“Love you,” she mumbles into your shoulder.
You hold her tight for a second. Then let go.
“You owe me, Buckley. Big time.”
…
Robin crashes in your bed, dead to the world in ten seconds flat.
You stay on the couch next to Steve.
Not close. Just close enough. So if he does something stupid like stop breathing, you’ll notice.
You keep a cool cloth on his forehead. Check his pulse every half hour. Whisper a soft “motherfucker” every time he twitches, because if he wakes up and asks if you were worried, you want to be able to say no with a straight face.
You stay up.
Because someone has to.
…
It’s almost 3 a.m. when he stirs.
Your head snaps up, heart launching into your throat like a flare. Your hand goes automatically to the bucket, the cloth, the mental checklist of emergency procedures you’ve memorized so well they’re practically sewn into your DNA.
But then his lips part.
Just a cracked breath through the dryness, small and quiet and impossibly fragile.
“Don’t… don’t let ‘em go back.”
It’s barely a whisper. It slams into you like a freight train.
You don’t know who ‘they’ are, but you know exactly what he means.
You’ve seen this kind of thing before, too. In the shaking hands of people who left something behind where no one could follow. This is what happens when the body survives, but the rest doesn’t.
And goddammit.
Goddammit, you didn’t want this.
Didn’t want some pretty, broken boy bleeding all over your couch. Didn’t want this guilt. This terrifying protectiveness. The quiet, suffocating weight of whatever this is clamping around your ribs like a trap you walked into willingly.
Didn’t want Steve fucking Harrington, of all people, to break your heart without saying a single word.
But he looks so young like this. Pale cheeks, sweat-damp hair sticking to his forehead. He’s curled in on himself like he’s bracing for another hit, one hand fisted in your throw pillow.
Without thinking, you lean forward.
Brush his hair back. Cool his skin with your fingers.
“Steve,” you whisper.
No answer. Just a tiny, broken noise. Almost a whimper, almost nothing.
Your throat tightens.
You reach down, and carefully, gently, pry his fingers free from the cushion. Thread yours through the empty spaces.
His grip grows impossibly tight, fingertips paling where they press between your knuckles.
“You’re okay. You’re safe.”
And slowly—like thawing ice, like a held breath finally let go—he stops shaking.
You stay like that, hand in his, until the sun starts bleeding through the curtains.
…
Robin once told you that you get off on fixing people.
She meant hearts. You meant bones.
You’re starting to think maybe she was right.
…
You wake to yelling.
Not normal yelling—whisper-yelling. The kind of frantic, hushed bickering that’s somehow louder than regular voices.
“…can’t just walk out, Steve!”
“It’s not that bad, just—give me a second—”
There’s the unmistakable rustle of struggling. A pained grunt. The telltale shuffle of someone stumbling sideways, seconds away from faceplanting.
“Oh my god, what is wrong with you?!”
“I’m fine,” Steve grits out, in the exact tone people use right before they pass out on you.
“And where exactly are you gonna go, huh? Enlighten me.”
“Just—I’ll go back and change, and then we’ll—”
“Nope. Absolutely not. You can’t even see straight, Harrington.”
“Yes, I can.”
“Really? Okay. How many fingers?”
“Why do you always do that?”
“Because it works!”
You groan loudly, dragging an arm over your face.
“Do I need to put you two in a time-out? Because I swear to god, I will.”
Instant silence.
When you peel your arm back, Steve’s frozen mid‑escape, one shoe on, looking like a kid caught stealing from the cookie jar. He glances your way, sheepish.
“Hey,” he says, like he didn’t just almost eat your tile. “You’re up.”
“Unfortunately.”
Robin flaps a dramatic hand at him. “Please, please talk some sense into this idiot before I duct tape him to the wall.”
You sit up, and immediately regret every decision you’ve ever made. Your spine crackles like bubble wrap. Your skull is pounding. The entire living room looks like a crime scene: blood-crusted towels, empty gauze packets, that one lonely vodka bottle rolling under the coffee table like a sad tumbleweed.
You squint at Steve. “Sit down.”
“I’m good.”
“You’re not.”
“I just need to—”
“Now, Harrington.”
You don’t raise your voice. You don’t have to. It’s the tone you’ve used on half-conscious college boys insisting they can “totally drive, man.”
Steve blinks. Then sighs, slowly lowering himself onto a kitchen chair.
Robin hovers like a human seatbelt, and he bats her away with a feeble flap of his wrist. Still, he grips the edge of the counter like it’s the only thing keeping him vertical.
You scrub a hand over your face. “Coffee? Or are we all just committing to bad decisions today?”
…
The coffee is yesterday’s.
Bitter, burnt, practically an oil slick in a mug.
You pour three cups anyway.
Steve drinks it black, which tracks. You clock the way his hands tremble as he brings it to his lips and file it away without comment.
Robin’s already rattling off the story again, filling in details she left out the night before. You get more names now. Places. Dates. Vines that slither like snakes. The gate under Lover’s Lake. You get the part where Steve dove in, headfirst, no hesitation.
Well, you already got that part last night, but Robin’s repeating it, and you’re starting to think maybe it’s not for you this time.
Steve just listens, quiet. Winces at certain beats—jaw tic here, hard blink there—but doesn’t interrupt.
You lean against the counter, sip your bitter sludge, and ask, casual as you can:
“So, you just jumped in. No plan? No backup?”
He shrugs, eyes on his mug. “Didn’t really have time to think about it.”
“Clearly.”
He looks up at you then. Runs a hand through his still-matted hair, blood-sticky at the roots, and releases a quiet breath.
“Thank you. For last night.”
You raise a brow. “Didn’t really have a choice, Harrington. It was either that or explain to the cops why there’s a dead body on my couch.”
He huffs a weak laugh.
“By the way,” you add, sipping again, “do your parents know about all this monster-hunting extracurricular bullshit?”
Robin makes a sound like a choked squirrel.
“Oh fuck! My parents! Shitshitshit.”
She’s already halfway out of her chair, tripping over her shoes while she scrambles for her jacket.
“Can you—?” she gasps, eyes wide.
“Yeah, yeah. I’ll cover.”
“Thankyouthankyouthankyou!” She barrels over, grabbing your face and planting a comically loud kiss on your forehead. Then she turns and grabs Steve in the same breath.
Gives his face a little shake.
“If I come back and find out you even thought about sneaking out, I will tell everyone you still sleep with a nightlight. Got it?”
You snort into your mug. Steve glares at her. “Robin—"
“Got it?”
He scrubs a hand through his hair, rolling his eyes. “Whatever.”
She releases him, then points at you. “You’re in charge. Don’t let him do anything heroic.”
“Oh no,” you deadpan. “However shall I bear the weight of such responsibility?”
Robin snorts, slaps your shoulder, then bolts, keys jingling like cowbells as she shoots out the door.
“Wait—” Steve squints after her. “Are you—Robin! You can’t just take my car! You’re not even—”
Slam!
“—licensed.”
You both sit in the silence she leaves behind. Steve stares out the window, listening to the screech of his precious bimmer as it peels down the street.
Then he turns back, eyes flicking to the trauma floor that used to be your living room.
He clears his throat. “Sorry about your, uh… couch. And the carpet.”
You follow his gaze. The stains are bad, probably permanent. It stings a little, looking at them.
It hurts worse looking at him.
Steve Harrington, bruised and bandaged and slouched in your chair like he’s trying to disappear into the seams. His stupidly wide, puppy-dog eyes look like they’re about to apologizing for breathing your air.
You blink.
Then slowly, slowly, lean forward across the island.
“Harrington.”
“Yeah?”
“Stop apologizing for almost dying. It’s weird.”
He opens his mouth. Closes it. Lands on a sheepish smile instead.
You hate how it softens his face, how it creases the corners of his eyes.
“And for the record,” you mutter, lips concealed behind the rim of your cup, “you’re not the worst thing to stain that couch, so. You’re fine.”
He blinks, brow furrowing. “What’s… that supposed to mean?”
You shrug. “Wouldn’t you like to know.”
It takes him a second to process it. Then he snorts quietly, eyes flicking to the side.
You take another sip, watching the pink rise in his cheeks as the sun filters in through the window.
And if you’re smiling too—well, he doesn’t have to know.
…
You try to make pancakes.
Try being the operative word.
There’s flour in your hair, batter on the counter. Somewhere, the smoke alarm is just giggling with anticipation.
Steve’s still in his spot behind the island, watching you glare down a lumpy pile of batter.
It’s distracting.
It’s fucking annoying, is what it is.
Pancakes aren’t hard. Whisking is not rocket science. And yet, it feels impossible with him sitting there, doing that thing with his eyes. All soft and brown and bruised, like you saved his life and now he doesn’t know how to deal with it.
“How’s it going?” he asks, voice pitched deliberately neutral.
You don’t turn around. “Fine.”
A beat.
“You sure?”
You slam the next pancake into the pan. It looks like something you'd peel off a sidewalk after a hot summer day. You stare at it, furious.
Behind you, there’s the scrape of a chair.
“I said I’m fine,” you warn.
He ignores that.
Limps over to you instead, his gaze finding you like a physical thing. Warm. Curious. You catch him in your periphery as he stops beside you, close enough that the heat from the stove mixes with the heat of his skin. Suddenly, the kitchen feels about fifteen degrees hotter.
“Here,” he murmurs.
Before you can object, his fingers wrap around yours, gentle and coaxing as he eases the spatula from your grip.
Then: flip.
One smooth flick of his wrist. The pancake lands perfect. All golden and fluffy.
You blink at it, betrayed.
“I was handling it.”
“Sure,” he says, lips twitching. “Looked like it.”
He flips another. Doesn’t even look this time.
You narrow your eyes. “Okay. How are you doing that?”
He shrugs, adjusting the burner dial like he’s lived here his whole life. “Cook for myself a lot.”
You pause. There’s something in the way he says it—off-hand, casual, but quiet enough to leave an echo.
You file that away, too.
“Of course you’re good at pancakes,” you mutter. “Probably make soufflés and like, caviar waffles or some shit.”
“Caviar waffles? That’s a thing?”
“I don’t know. You tell me, rich boy.”
He just snorts quietly at that, eyeing you sideways. “Well, my French toast is pretty solid. Could show you next time, if you want.”
You glance over, arching a brow. “Wow. Is that line always so subtle?”
He meets your gaze, smirk tugging at his split lip.
“I don’t know. You tell me.”
And fuck, it lands.
It lands hard, right in the soft space under your ribs. That warm, twisting feeling that makes your breath hitch and your stomach go stupid.
You turn away before your face can betray you, yanking open a drawer for a fork.
And then, as if the universe decided to throw you a bone, the kitchen landline starts to shriek like it’s being murdered.
You lunge for it like a lifeline.
It’s probably Mrs. Buckley, confirming her daughter crashed at your place, again.
“Hello? …You WHAT?”
Robin groans on the other end. “Yeah. Possibly until college.”
“Robin, you can’t—” You lower your voice, turning away from Steve and cupping the receiver like he’s not standing two feet away. “—you can’t be fucking grounded right now.”
“I know! But my mom saw the blood on my jeans and I totally panicked. I told her it was ketchup. Ketchup, dude. Now she’s got Toby posted outside my room. He’s just sitting there with his Legos, but he will scream if I so much as leave to go to the bathroom. So... yeah. It’s gonna be a while before I can sneak out. Are you… are you okay to stay with him for a bit? He’s trying to pretend he’s fine, but he’s definitely not.”
You glance back.
Steve’s standing at the stove, peering at his stomach while waiting for the next pancake to bubble. His hand drifts down and starts poking at one of the bandages under his hoodie. Slow and gentle, like it won’t count as touching if he’s polite about it.
You stretch the phone cord and smack his hand away.
He startles. Blinks at you like, Seriously?
You raise your brows like, Try me.
You sigh into the receiver: “Yeah. I got him.”
“Ugh, you’re the best. Just don’t let him—ohh, crap, I gotta g—"
Click.
Steve doesn’t turn when you pad back into the kitchen.
“She grounded?”
“Yep. Possibly until retirement.” You pause. “You don’t need to call your folks?”
He hesitates, just for a second. Then shakes his head. “They’re out of town.”
Then, with a one-handed spin of the spatula, he flips the pancake onto a plate.
You glance at the growing stack. They look obscene. You’d punch someone for a bite.
In your head, you run through the math.
Ten days. Minimum.
Ten days before the stitches can come out. Before he can walk out of here without ripping something open. Longer if he keeps poking at his bandages like that.
God help you. It’s gonna be a long week.
…
Breakfast is awkward.
No other word for it.
Steve eats like he’s on a timer. You eat like you’re trying not to notice.
Trying not to notice the way he keeps sneaking glances at you. Little flicks of his eyes over his plate, always quick, always subtle, never quite fast enough.
Trying not to notice the way he winces. Quiet flashes of pain, there and gone, just long enough for that crease to cut across his brow before he smooths it away.
When both your plates are emptied, he clears his throat.
“Hey, do you… you mind if I use your bathroom?” He gestures vaguely to his face. “Just need to clean up a bit.”
His hair is still matted. There’s soot smeared along his jaw, a faint line of red where the blood’s dried and half-wiped away.
You nod, mid-sip. “Sure. First door on the left. Just don’t get the bandages wet.”
“Got it,” he nods, starts to rise—then stops halfway, jaw flexing tight.
“Actually, uh…” His hand slides to the back of his neck. His eyes shut briefly. “Can you give me a hand with this? I can’t really…”
He doesn’t finish the sentence. Doesn’t need to.
The white-knuckle grip on the hem of his hoodie tells you enough.
You blink, setting your mug down, and push your chair back without a word.
He doesn’t meet your eyes as you reach for the bottom of the hoodie.
The fabric peels up inch by inch, sticking to where the gauze bled through, catching where raw skin clings to cotton. He winces, raising his arms awkwardly, the stitches along his sides clearly pulling. So you move gently, painstakingly slow.
Your knuckles graze his stomach, and—
Jesus.
He’s warm. Muscle corded tight under skin that flushes easily, even with all the bruises blooming across his ribs like bad watercolors.
You get the hoodie off.
His chest is bare.
And now you’re standing close. Way, way too close.
His breath brushes your cheek when he exhales. You glance up, just on pure instinct, and find his eyes already on you.
You both freeze.
There’s a beat where everything narrows. Where sound drops out.
Your hands hover midair, still clutching the fabric, close enough to feel the heat radiating off his skin.
Close enough to trace the moles scattered across his chest.
You don’t.
You look away so fast it nearly gives you whiplash.
“Towels are under the sink," you mumble. "I’ll get you some new clothes.”
Then you take a quick step back. Like distance will save you from whatever the hell that was.
Steve blinks. Once. Twice. Then nods, eyes flicking away. “Thanks.”
He disappears down the hall, barefoot and bruised.
You stand in the silence with his hoodie clenched in your fists, your pulse trying to beat its way out of your throat.
…
There’s an old joke your friends like to make.
That you’re a sadist.
That you chose the EMT life because you enjoy it. The blood, the pain. The broken bones and the chaos. Things normal people flinch away from.
But in truth, they’ve got it backwards.
You’re not a sadist.
No. What you are is a fucking masochist.
Because there’s no other explanation for why you keep doing this to yourself. Why you let yourself get this close to people you shouldn’t. Why you torture yourself, again and again, with things you know better than to want.
Why you’re standing outside your bathroom door right now, ears tilted, listening to someone who shouldn’t mean anything to you rinse the blood off his skin.
You told yourself you were just finishing the dishes. That the stovetop needed wiping down. That there were chores to do, reasons to move around.
But your feet kept wandering. Back to the hallway. Back to him.
Back to this spot in the hallway, where you can feel the warmth bleeding under the door. Where you can hear the faucet running in short, irregular bursts—on, off, on again.
You picture him hunched over the basin. One hand braced against the counter, the other shaking under the strain of movement. Jaw clenched. Shoulders bowed.
Something twists low in your stomach.
You roll your eyes at yourself—because god, you’re pathetic—and raise a fist.
A light knock.
“You good?”
A pause, then:
“Uh, yeah. Just… hang on.”
There’s a clatter, a quiet shit. Then the door creaks open.
And Steve—
Well.
He’s wet.
And shirtless. And pink.
Flushed from the steam, maybe from embarrassment. Because his hair—The Hair—is half-lathered and sticking up in foamy tufts, like a soggy cat caught mid-bath. A single drop of water slides slow down the hollow of his throat.
Your gaze follows it.
The sweatpants you gave him ride low. Damp at the waistband, pulled snug across his hips in a way you’re absolutely not thinking about.
He gestures toward the sink, sheepish.
“I, uh… can’t really bend right now. Tried to rinse it out, but—” He winces, fingers grazing his sides. “The stitches are kind of a hard no.”
Your eyes drop, unbidden, to the bruises blooming purple-black across his ribs. The way his chest lifts a little faster when you step closer.
You should walk away. Turn around. Go wipe down the goddamn stove like you told yourself you would.
Instead, you say:
“Sit.”
He blinks. “…What?”
“On the floor. Back against the tub.”
There’s a pause. His brows draw together like he’s trying to figure out the punchline.
You don’t blink.
He exhales sharply, jaw flexing. “No, it’s okay, I can—”
“Steve.”
It lands heavy. The weight of it surprises even you.
His first name, in your voice.
You’ve only said it once before, when he was unconscious, twitching under bloodstained gauze, fists clenched against a nightmare you couldn’t reach.
But now, he hears it. And something inside him goes quiet.
He studies you for a second longer, then sighs, shoulders dropping.
Wordlessly, he lowers himself to the tile.
One hand braced on the edge of the tub, the other on the floor, every movement stiff. His back hits the porcelain with a soft thud.
You kneel beside him and roll up your sleeves.
“Lean your head back.”
He shifts, uneasy. “Seriously, you don’t have to—”
“I know.” You pick up the cup beside the sink and check the tap, waiting for the water to warm. “Just tilt."
There’s a long pause.
Then he does.
His head tips back against the curve of the tub. With his throat exposed, the worst of the bruising shines a mottled red-black beneath his jaw. His lashes flutter, lips parting just slightly.
The first pass runs slow and gentle down his scalp. He flinches.
“Too hot?”
He blinks, breath shallow. “No. S’fine.”
So you pour again. And again. Slow rivulets trickling through his hair, carrying blood and soap and grime down the drain. His hair start to fall naturally again, dark strands slicking to his forehead.
It’s just the water at first. Rinsing out grit, loosening stiff knots and matted roots.
Then you lather the shampoo between your palms, and sink your fingers into his hair.
And that’s when it happens.
The shift.
Steve Harrington—king of easy charm, Mr. Everything’s Fine—goes completely still.
Not in a relaxed way. Not in a sleepy way.
No, he goes rigid.
His breath falters. His jaw locks. You can see the muscles in his neck ripple with tension.
And when you sweep a thumb absently behind his ear, chasing a line of foam, he jolts.
A full-body shiver, running shoulder to spine.
You clear your throat, voice catching before you force it steady. “Been a while, huh? Since someone did this for you?”
His response is delayed, a low rasp. “Uh huh. Long time.”
Then, after a beat:
“Used to be my mom’s thing. When I was a kid.”
Your hands still in his hair. He goes stiff the second he says it—jaw clenched, lips pressed tight, hands curling in his lap.
You blink, then resume drawing slow circles over his crown.
“That must’ve been nice,” you say quietly.
He doesn’t answer. Just breathes through his nose and keeps still.
So you keep going.
Rinse. Lather. Repeat.
And with each pass of your hands, his breathing changes.
His head rests heavier against the porcelain. His lips part around soft, even breaths. His eyes flutter shut.
Then, he leans.
Barely enough to notice. But you feel it, the subtle tilt of his head toward your hands.
Like a plant bending toward light.
You wonder, not for the first time, how long it’s been since someone touched him like this. How long he’s gone without care, without softness.
And maybe that’s why this hurts so much.
Because you’d had him pegged, hadn’t you?
The hair. The charm. Pretty boy, ladies’ man, heartbreaker.
King Steve.
But this? This isn’t him.
This is the After.
The aftermath of Russians and monsters and lakes with no bottoms. The man who throws himself between danger and kids that aren’t his, time and time again. Like he’s got something to prove. Or maybe something to atone for.
The one who apologized for bleeding on your floor.
This is someone who’s forgotten how to be held.
And right now, he’s under your hands. Throat bared. Hair dripping. Leaning into your touch like he’s starved for it.
And that slow, sinking weight in your stomach settles for good. That gut-churn of realization that you barely know anything about the man who nearly bled out on your couch last night.
You try to swallow the feeling down. Try to keep your focus on softer things: dripping water, steam-soaked light, the silky-smooth slip of his hair between your fingers.
But every time your hands leave him, even for a second, you feel it. The tension in his frame. The hesitation in his breath. Like he’s bracing for it to end.
And each time you return—thumb grazing his temple, palm cradling the back of his neck—he breathes in. Relief, sharp and silent, tucked between the ribs.
You reach for the conditioner next, fingers trembling a little as you work it through. When you tip his head back, he goes easy. Pliant. Trusting.
And then a quiet thought hits you.
A hunch, really.
You let your fingers drift lower. Past the crown. Down to the nape of his neck. The hair there is softer, damp strands clinging to skin gone tight with tension and bruising.
You trace gently around the worst of it. Avoid the dark, angry lines where something had closed around his throat.
Strangled. That’s what Robin said.
You press into the muscle just beneath it, right where the pain likes to live.
Steve shudders. His head lifts from the tub with a breath, caught on something sharp.
But you don’t let up.
You continue pressing in slow, deep circles, growing firmer.
There’s a sound, then. Sharp. Brief. A strangled thing, torn between a groan and a gasp.
He tries to stifle it a second later, clearing his throat.
“Too hard?” you ask quietly.
His voice comes cracked. “N-no. Just—it’s fine. You don’t have to…”
The rest trails off when you move to his shoulders next, thumb kneading into the dense muscle. You’re not a massage therapist, but you know anatomy. You know where pain settles when it’s been left too long. How it tucks itself into the tender parts: the base of the neck, the hollow beneath the collarbone.
And god, he’s full of it. All the signs. All the tells.
He lets out another shaky breath, lips sealed around a sound he doesn’t let out.
And there, just for a moment, you let yourself look.
At the bruises. The thin cuts just beginning to scab. The water gliding over his collarbone, beading into the curve of his chest.
That thick, molten part of your brain—the masochist, the idiot, the one who says yes when she should absolutely say no—flares hot.
It wants to lean in.
Wants to touch your mouth to his skin, right there, at the slope of his throat.
Just to see if he tastes like lavender and heat. Just to see if he lets you.
To kiss him slow enough to wash the ache from his mouth. Replace every sharp thing he’s swallowed with something soft.
God, you’re losing it.
You drag your thumb again along the base of his neck. His lashes flutter.
Then, from the corner of your eye, you see it—his hands shifting in his lap.
Cross. Adjust.
You glance down without thinking.
And oh.
Oh.
The sweatpants don’t hide much. Not like this. Not with how he’s sitting, loose-limbed and open, the fabric soaked and clinging in ways it wasn’t meant to. They’re pulled taut across the breadth of his thighs, darkened in patches where the water’s seeped through.
And beneath that?
Yeah.
Your breath stutters. Heat rockets up your neck.
You yank your gaze away, fumbling for the faucet and filling another cup. Your hand trembles as you lift it, rinsing out the conditioner.
His hair sticks to his forehead. Without thinking, you smooth it back.
His eyes flutter open.
And the look he gives you…
It’s quiet. Devastating. Tucked somewhere tender and deep, pressed hard against bone.
Softer than longing. Sharper than want.
It's something that aches.
You don’t know what to do with it.
So you just keep your hands in his hair.
And you rinse.
…
You rinse long after the conditioner’s gone.
After his breath has evened out and the water’s cooled to a gentle trickle, steam curling around your ankles like fog.
The bathroom smells like lavender and heat and skin that isn’t yours.
When you reach for the towel and bring it up to his head, he leans.
Blot, pat, smooth. The towel’s too soft, your hands too careful. You graze the shell of his ear, the edge of his jaw, feeling the quick flutter of his pulse beneath your thumb.
His eyes are still on you.
“Thanks,” he says, quiet.
You nod, not trusting your voice.
The steam’s thinning now, but the air still clings.
Too warm. Too full of something unsaid.
His breath brushes your cheek.
You’re too close.
It’s too much.
You could kiss him.
God help you, you could.
Just one lean forward. That’s all it would take. His mouth is right there—slightly parted, pink and swollen in the middle where he’s been biting down.
And the look on his face isn’t just gratitude. Not just relief.
That’s want.
And worse? It’s yours too. It’s in the pit of your stomach, burning upward. It’s in your hands, your chest, your throat, curling behind your teeth like smoke with nowhere to go.
You pull back abruptly. The towel slips from your hands and lands in his lap with a soft thud.
“Okay,” you say, voice tight. “You’re good.”
Steve blinks, like you just dragged him up from underwater.
His throat bobs. “Cool. Yeah. Thanks.”
You stand too fast. Your knees pop. You don’t look at him when you speak next. “You should lie down for a bit. Keep pressure off the stitches.”
He nods, a little too slow.
You grab the towel again and press it against his chest. Not hard, but firm enough to make a point. Whatever it is.
Then you turn.
And you walk out.
You don’t need to look back to know he’s still watching you go.
...
It starts the way summer storms do.
Not with thunder. Not with rain.
With pressure.
The kind that presses close to the skin, wrapping around like a second layer. That hair-raising, skin-prickling tingle. Right as the birds go quiet and the trees hold still and the sky forgets how to move.
Stillness so absolute your skin buzzes with it.
The moment before it tips.
It’s here now. In this room.
In the narrow inches of couch cushion between you. In the weight of the blanket tangled over your legs. In the single, unspoken brush of his thigh against yours.
The TV plays to no one. A dull flicker of static and synth beats, some late-afternoon rerun neither of you are really watching. The glow of it pulses dim blue across his skin, the shadows deepening where his jaw tightens every time you move.
The room smells like clean skin and new sweat. Yours. His. Both.
His voice breaks the quiet.
“Hey, how long ‘til the stitches come out again?”
“Ten days.”
“Hm. I like this show.”
“Knight Rider?”
“Yeah. It’s cool.”
“No. It’s dumb.”
“What? C’mon, the car talks.”
“Exactly.” A beat. “How do the stitches feel?”
“Uh, good. Yeah. They’re fine.”
“You hungry?”
“No, you?”
“No.”
And it builds, again. That low, rolling kind of stillness.
Storm pressure.
It crawls up your spine. Pools hot behind your ears. You fidget with the hem of the blanket, rolling your shoulder back into the cushion like you can shake it loose.
You can’t.
The blanket’s too warm.
He’s too close.
And he’s watching you. You don’t have to look to know.
“…You’re doing it again.”
“Hm?”
You turn your head. Meet his gaze full-on. “Looking at me like that.”
His lips part. “Like what?”
Your eyes drop to his mouth.
His pinky brushes yours.
And just like that, the storm breaks.
…
Steve leans in first.
The same way he had in the bathroom, instinctive and unthinking. Like something inside him keeps tipping forward and you’re the only place left to fall.
Only this time, you don’t let him do it alone.
You meet him halfway.
His nose nudges yours. His breath fans hot across your cheek.
And then your lips meet.
A question and an answer, exchanged wordlessly.
There’s no clean edge between want and need, no way to separate gentle from hungry. One second, it’s the cautious warmth of shared breath, the next—
It’s the pull of his hands. The low, wrecked sound he makes in his throat when your fingers slide up his neck, threading into the damp hair at his nape.
Heat. Ozone. The bright-white zing of electricity rocketing down your spine.
You move forward without thinking. He shifts to catch you, hands spanning your hips, guiding you into his lap. You straddle him, careful to avoid the bruises across his stomach.
His breath is hot. His lips are plush, a little chapped from the way he’s been chewing on them all night.
Wordlessly, you reach for the hem of your shirt, tugging it over your head and letting it fall behind you. Cool air rushes over your skin.
Steve goes still. “God, you’re…” He breathes, throat working around the rest of the words when you take his hand and guide it upwards. Across your stomach, up your ribs. His thumb grazes over your nipple, soft and reverent, and your breath hitches.
You tug him back into a kiss, hips starting to drag across his lap. The hard press of him burns heat through the cotton of your sleep shorts.
“Good?” you breathe against his mouth.
“Yeah,” he rasps. “Fuck. Yeah. You?”
You nod, catching your breath.
But he doesn’t stop looking at you
And there’s something about the way his gaze lingers—soft, searching—like he’s waiting for more than just an answer to a question. Something he doesn’t know how to say out loud.
But you know.
You just… know.
The same way you knew when your hands were in his hair earlier. That quiet ache. That silent pull in him, desperate and soft.
So you give him what he doesn’t know how to ask for.
Your hand slides up to his chest, pressing over his heart. It’s pounding. So is yours.
“You feel so good, Steve,” you whisper, close enough for him to taste the words off your lips. “You’re so good. So fucking good.”
He shudders, pulling you in tighter, groaning with his lips buried against your neck like he needs to hide the sound somewhere safe.
Still, you don’t stop.
You reach for his hand and slide it lower, under the waistband of your shorts. His fingers slip through your slick heat and go still.
“Jesus,” he breathes.
You kiss his temple, then his cheek. Frame his jaw with both hands and lift his gaze to yours.
“Feel that?” you murmur. “That’s for you. All for you.”
He lets out a strangled sound, nearly pained, and surges up to kiss you again. His fingers start to stroke through your heat, finding the rhythm, learning you. When his thumb grazes your clit and starts to circle, you gasp, hips jerking into his touch.
“Shit, baby…” he breathes.
And that word—
It’s soft. Unconscious. Slipped out before he knew it was there.
You don’t think he even realizes he said it. His eyes are blown wide, focused only on you: the way your hips grind, the way you cling to him when his fingers push deeper.
Still, there’s that tremble in his voice.
Like that word came from somewhere deeper than he meant to reach. Like it cracked off the part of him that’s always waiting to be turned away but still dares to offer softness first.
You roll your hips again, chasing friction, but your focus has shifted now. You’re watching him instead—flushed and open beneath you, mouth parted, eyes locked to your face like you’re something he’s trying to memorize.
And it guts you. The honesty of it.
How easy it is to see now.
That this is someone who aches for closeness. Reaches for it before he even realizes he’s doing it. Who says baby like it’s the only word he knows for want.
Your chest grows tight. The heat in your stomach twists into something unbearably tender.
You roll your hips one last time, savoring the drag of him against you, then shift off his lap. His hand slips from your shorts, reluctant, trailing warmth up your stomach.
His eyes follow you as you slide to the floor. Your knees sinking into the carpet, fingers hooking in the waistband of his pants. He lifts his hips and—
You blink. Your mouth goes dry.
Because he’s—
Wow. Okay.
Noted.
It’s not just the size—though, yeah, that’s definitely part of it. It’s the weight of him. The flushed color, the dusky warmth. Velvety skin stretched tight over thick veins. The way he sits heavy against his thigh, curved just slightly, leaking at the tip and twitching under your gaze.
You swallow hard.
“What?” He stirs, uncertain. “Is something…?”
You look up at him, eyes wide.
“Jesus, Steve…” you breathe. “Just. Holy shit.”
His brows pinch together, concern flickering across his face—until he sees your expression.
And there it is.
That grin. That stupid, boyish, shit-eating grin.
“Oh,” he says, trying to play it off. “Yeah?”
You narrow your eyes, desperately trying to hide your smile. “Don’t get cocky.”
He raises a brow.
You realize your mistake immediately. Your cheeks flare hot.
He laughs, breathless. Looks down at you all soft and pleased and fond. It makes you want to bite him until he forgets how to smirk entirely. Kiss him stupid and never let him go.
“Shut up,” you mutter.
“Didn’t say anything,” he says, still smiling.
You roll your eyes and yank his pants the rest of the way down.
He quiets instantly.
Because your hands are on him now.
You stroke his thighs first, warming up the sensitive skin there. Pressing soft kisses along the inside, inching higher and higher until he’s twitching under your mouth.
“You’re so pretty like this,” you whisper. “You don’t even know, do you?”
He makes a strangled sound, part laugh, part disbelieving groan. His hands flex where they rest against his thighs.
You reach up and guide one to your hair, eyes still on his.
“You can touch me,” you murmur.
His fingers curl, tentative. “You sure?”
You nod. “I want you to. Want you to feel this.”
Then, without looking away, you lower your mouth to him.
Slow. Wet. Base to tip, dragging your tongue along the underside. He jerks, whole body going taut.
“Jesus,” he hisses. “Okay. Okay.”
You take your time. Because no one ever has, it seems. Not like this.
Your fingers wrap around the base, tongue gliding along the ridge, licking the salt beading at the tip. Every twitch, every shudder, every wrecked baby whispered from above becomes something you file away silently, cataloguing the way he unravels.
And Steve unravels beautifully.
You glance up through your lashes, watching the way his stomach trembles, how his throat works. All the control he’s trying so hard to hold on to.
Then finally, you wrap your lips around him.
Just the head at first, sucking slow and sweet. You circle your tongue around the crown and let out a soft hum.
“Fuck,” he whispers. “Baby, your mouth—shit—”
His voice keeps catching like he doesn’t quite believe it. You get the sense he hasn’t been cherished in this way, either. Adored. Worshipped.
So you double down.
You ease off for a breath, kissing the flushed tip, thumb gliding over the sensitive skin there. Then you sink deeper, lips sliding lower, jaw loosening, tongue tracing the underside as you stretch around the thickest part of him.
You keep going until he’s pressed up against your palate, brushing the back of your throat. You breathe into it. Let the weight of him sit there, hot and thick and yours.
“Shit, shit—” he pants. “I’m not—not gonna last if you keep—"
You pull off with a soft pop, lips slick and swollen. A line of spit follows you from the flushed head of his cock.
“It’s okay,” you smile, breath warm against his skin. “Don’t have to. Just want you to feel good.”
He stares down at you, cheeks flushed, eyes glassy.
Then, suddenly, breathless and earnest:
“Wait, can I—can I get you off first?”
You pause, stunned.
You blink up at him, hand still wrapped around the base of his cock. “You don’t have to—”
“I want to,” he says, quick and pleading. He cups your jaw, stroking your cheek. “Please. Let me?”
You hold his gaze a moment longer, drowning in that quiet, unspoken vulnerability he carries, one you’re learning to name without words.
Then, finally, you nod.
“Okay.”
You crawl back into his lap, shorts discarded somewhere behind you, it doesn’t matter where.
What matters is the way his hands settle on you again, calloused palms sliding around your hips, drawing you closer. You feel the thick heat of him pressed between your thighs, sticky and flushed and aching.
You roll your hips teasingly, gliding against him before reaching down to line him up. The head of his cock nudges, presses, catches. Then slowly, inch by inch, you sink down.
The stretch is immediate. Hot and all-consuming. You clutch at his shoulders, mouth falling open as you let your weight sink deeper, not pausing until he’s fully seated.
Your thighs tremble where you straddle him.
Steve groans low, one arm tight around your waist, the other gripping your hip.
“Shit, are you—?”
“I’m okay,” you breathe, laughing softly into his skin. “Just… gimme a sec. You’re kind of a lot, Harrington.”
He kisses you, rubbing circles into your back while you adjust. The burn softens. The fullness remains.
And when you start to move—lifting your hips, rolling them back down—you feel him everywhere.
“God,” you pant, “you feel so good.”
You kiss his jaw, his throat, burying whispers between breaths.
“Can feel you so deep—fuck—”
The rhythm builds slowly. Wide circles, deep grinds, savoring the way his cock hits just right.
And the more you give him—You feel so good, Fucking me so well, Low how you feel inside me—he melts a little more beneath you.
“Shit, right there—” you gasp, hips stuttering when his hand slides between your bodies, pressing into your clit.
“Come for me,” he whispers, voice rough. “Please. Want to feel you.”
His fingers circle faster.
And your body breaks.
You cry out, nails digging into his shoulders, every muscle clenched and trembling as the orgasm crashes through you. You collapse against his chest, shaking, gasping his name, everything hot and white and so much.
He holds you through it, breathing hard against your temple.
“That’s it,” he pants. “That’s it, baby, I’ve got you—fuck—”
You’re still trembling in his lap when you feel him thrust up into you once, twice. He pulls out with a sudden gasp, groaning your name, spilling hot and thick across your stomach, shuddering with the force of it.
You kiss him through the haze of your own come-down, legs still trembling, fingers tangled in the sweat-damp hair at his nape.
“Just like that,” you whisper. “You’re perfect like this, Steve. So good.”
His breath stutters against your cheek. His body, still pulsing with aftershocks, presses into yours like he can’t stand the space between.
And even after the world goes still, after the stuttered breaths give way to silence and the hum of the TV creeps back in, you keep touching him. Stroking his hair, brushing sweat from his brow, pressing soft, open-mouthed kisses anywhere your mouth can reach.
And in the hush that follows, you murmur things you’ve never said aloud. Not to anyone.
Things too raw for daylight.
Things meant only for him.
…
You never ask him to stay.
Not when he wakes beside you the next morning, bare-chested, sleep-warm, hair sticking up in a dozen directions. Not when he wanders into your kitchen wearing nothing but rumpled boxers, whisking eggs for French toast like it’s an inside joke you’ve shared forever.
Not when you start leaving the sugar bowl out because that’s how he takes his coffee: one teaspoon, no milk. Not when you slip a second toothbrush into the cup by the sink, bristles leaning together like they’ve been kissing too.
He never asks. You never offer.
…
You learn the little things first.
That he hums when he cooks, usually something dumb from the radio, sometimes dumber jingles from the worst commercials. That he wipes down your counters when he thinks you’re not looking. That he folds your laundry better than you do, big hands careful with worn-out cotton and delicate lace. It gets to you, the way he touches your things like they matter.
And sometimes, you catch him staring again.
Only now, you don’t look away.
You’ll be across the room, pretending to read, eyes dragging over the same sentence for the fifth time because you can feel his gaze on you. He’ll be leaning in the doorway with his arms crossed, wearing that stupid smug expression he pulls when he knows exactly what he’s doing.
“Seriously, Harrington,” you mutter, eyes on the page. “Take a picture.”
He doesn’t blink. “I’m good. Like this view better."
You roll your eyes and throw a sock at his face. He catches it one-handed, smug.
Then he moves.
Three steps. That’s all it takes.
Three steps until your back’s against the mattress, his weight pressing you down, mouth dragging hot across your collarbone. His hands sneak under your shirt, warm palms sliding up your ribs. His lips chase yours like it’s a promise he’s been dying to keep.
“You’re annoying,” you whisper, breath hitching as he nips at your neck.
He grins into your skin. “Yeah? You gonna kick me out, then?”
You don’t.
You kind of never do.
…
The days bleed together after that.
A quick stop at his house to grab spare clothes turns into a silent pause in front of his dresser. His fingers hover over a framed photo: faces you don’t know, smiles frozen mid-laugh.
He doesn’t explain. You don’t ask. You just wait by the door until he turns and threads his fingers through yours.
He doesn’t let go the whole ride back.
A grocery run on day three turns into a dumb argument in the pasta aisle. You’re ranting about canned tomatoes; he’s trailing behind you like a sulking toddler, forearms slung across the cart handle, sneaking cookies into the basket when you’re not looking.
You scowl at checkout. He grins.
“You’re gonna thank me later,” he says.
You do.
First with a mouthful of chocolate and a grudging laugh.
Then again, ten minutes later, when your 'thank-you's come in the shape of his name and a fistful of his hair between your thighs.
…
Eventually, the domestic stops feeling borrowed.
It starts to feel owned.
You vacuum, he sweeps. You cook, he washes up. He steals bites of dinner while it’s still sizzling and you smack him with a spatula, pretending to be mad.
He says, “Ow,” even when it doesn’t hurt. You say, “Asshole,” even when it’s not true.
On the fourth night, you both sit cross-legged on the living room floor, scrubbing blood out of the couch cushions with baking soda and half-assed prayers.
He’s watching you. Again.
You glance up. "What?"
He shrugs, smiling a little. “Nothing.”
“Steve.”
“I just…” He hesitates. Looks down. “I like this.”
You raise a brow. “Cleaning your blood out of my furniture?”
He shuffles forward, bringing his cushion closer to yours.
“Yeah,” he says.
But it’s not what he means.
You both know that.
…
The sex changes, too.
In the mornings, it’s quiet. Slow. All languid stretches and sleep-warm skin, coaxing sighs from your lips as the sun peeks through the blinds.
But at night? He’s something else entirely.
He fucks you like he needs it to survive. Like you’re his last breath. Gripping your thighs, your hips—holding you open, holding you still, driving into you like he’s trying to memorize the shape of you forever.
And as the bruises fade, so does his hesitation.
He knows you now.
Knows what makes you beg, what makes you break. Where to bite, where to suck, where to press until your voice is raw and your nails leave crescent moons down his spine.
One night, he pins your wrists above your head, breath ragged.
“Say it,” he murmurs, grinding deep. “Tell me who makes you feel like this.”
You break on his name.
He swallows the sound with his mouth and doesn’t stop until your thighs are shaking.
And afterward, he stays.
Inside you. Around you.
He never pulls away first.
…
Not all nights are easy.
Some nights, you wake alone.
You find him in the kitchen, framed by the glow of the open fridge. The light catches the tired slope of his shoulders, the untouched glass of water going warm in his hand.
You don’t ask. Just step in behind him, press your cheek between his shoulder blades, and wrap your arms tight around his waist.
He breathes out. Sets the glass down. Closes the fridge.
When he turns, he doesn’t speak. Just lets you hold him.
Lets you guide him back to bed.
…
Your mornings are different now.
You wake in shirts that smell like him. Brush your teeth while he showers, fog curling across the mirror. He laughs at something stupid from behind the curtain, and you laugh back, still half-asleep.
It all happens so slowly you almost miss it.
The toothbrush that isn’t yours. The second pillow with its permanent dent. The pair of shoes you stop tripping over by the door because you’ve learned to walk around them.
He’s etched himself into your life in the smallest of ways. Fit through the cracks with warm hands and boyish grins and quiet looks in the daylight.
Like maybe he was meant to be here all along.
…
Somewhere between day seven and eight, you stop keeping count.
Because every morning, you tell yourself he’ll probably leave soon.
And every night, he gives you another reason to believe he won’t.
…
Like tonight.
You’re wrapped around each other, skin still damp with heat, covers shoved somewhere near the foot of the bed. His hand rests on your back, fingers splayed. Yours curls against his chest, cheek pressed to the slow, steady rhythm behind his ribs.
It would be so easy to stay here.
To let the quiet stretch. To pretend the heaviness in your chest is just exhaustion, not the weight you've been carrying since the night you dragged his bleeding body across your living room. Since you sat awake beside him, watching every shallow breath, waiting for the next one to come.
But the question’s been sitting on your chest for days now. And with the weight of him beside you, it presses too hard to ignore.
“Why’d you do it?”
He doesn’t answer right away, and you wonder if he’s already fallen asleep. But then his chest rises under your cheek—a careful, deliberate breath.
“…Do what?”
“The lake,” you murmur. “You jumped in first. Why?”
He’s quiet for a beat too long. You glance up to find the tight underside of his jaw, his eyes fixed on the ceiling.
“I don’t know,” he sighs, dragging a hand through his hair. “Someone had to go. And I was the best swimmer, so. Didn’t really have to think about it.”
And you believe him. It’s the part that hurts the most.
That he didn’t have to think. That throwing himself in came as naturally as breathing.
Because somewhere along the way, Steve Harrington decided that his pain was worth less than everyone else's.
You shift closer, hooking your chin on his shoulder. His thumb draws slow, thoughtful circles against your spine.
“Steve,” you say quietly. “You know it’s not about being a hero, right? You don’t have to keep throwing yourself in front of everything just to prove yourself.”
His hand stills.
“I’m not.”
“Not what?”
“A hero. I’m not.” He lets out a bitter huff, eyes looking at something past the ceiling. “I was… just kind of a selfish asshole for a long time. Didn’t care about much. Or anyone. And even after I tried to fix it, it just—it never felt like enough. Still doesn’t.”
You watch him, the weight of his words like pressing down on a bruise.
“So what, you jump into lakes now to make up for it?”
He almost smiles. “Kinda. Yeah.”
Then, quieter:
“I don’t know, it’s like, if I’m not the one stepping up, then… what’s the point, you know? What the hell am I even good for?”
Your heart aches. Because god, how long has he carried that? How many times has he thrown himself in just to keep from drowning?
You see it then, the fracture that runs through him. Spiderwebbed across everything he is, everything he was. A wound so old it’s fused to him. Clotted over, never cleaned.
The weight he carries isn’t something he puts on; it’s something that grew with him.
Years of being told he wasn’t enough. Not smart enough. Not serious enough. Just the boy with the car, the smile, the house too big for how small it made him feel.
That kind of doubt doesn’t heal. It burrows deep.
Sinks its teeth in. Festers.
Until guilt turns into remorse,
Remorse turns into habit,
And habit drags on as penance.
So he made himself useful.
Built his worth out of protection. Of stepping up, stepping in, taking the hit before anyone else could.
Diving first. Bleeding first.
Hurt first. Hurt worst. Hurt instead.
That’s where his value lives. Not in being loved, but in being needed.
You lift yourself up until you're eye to eye, cupping his face, thumbs brushing the tops of his cheeks.
“You’re for you, Steve.”
He blinks, brows knitting.
“You don’t have to earn it. Being loved. Being cared for. That’s not something you have to prove.”
His eyes search yours, like he’s trying to make sense of the words.
Then, slowly, his shoulders ease. He cups the back of your neck, drawing you in. His exhale against your lips sounds like a weight being untethered.
You stay like that for a while, breathing together, fingers laced at his chest.
Eventually, he sleeps.
You don’t.
You stay awake, tracing the lines of his face in the dark. The peace that sleep gives him. The stillness that never lasts.
You watch as his brow smooths. As his lips part. As his lashes flutter once, then settle into stillness.
You stay up.
Because someone has to.
…
You get used to the quiet.
Used to Steve padding around the house in socks, humming half a tune under his breath.
To the way he opens every cupboard before finding the cereal that’s been in the same spot for days.
To the way he claims half your couch, half your bed, half your toothpaste.
You get used to someone else’s heartbeat in your space.
So when the knocking starts—three sharp raps that rattle the wood—it takes you both by surprise.
Steve’s already halfway to the door when you follow, tugging your sweatshirt over your head.
You’ve barely turned the knob before the door bursts open.
“Guess who’s officially un-grounded and here to collect her idiot boy? Oh, and look—I brought backup!”
Robin barrels in first, followed by two figures: a curly-haired kid drowning in a bright yellow baseball cap, and behind him, a taller shape in black denim and leather. Eddie Munson, wearing that same smug grin you remember vaguely from high school.
You’ve heard about them, of course—Steve’s strange little apocalypse crew—but hearing about it is one thing, seeing it is another.
“He’s alive!” Robin crows, flinging her arms around Steve.
“Took you long enough,” he mutters into her shoulder.
“Uh, excuse me. Your fault,” she shoots back, jabbing a finger in his chest. “Grounded, remember?” Then she turns to you, eyes sharp with curiosity. “So? How much trouble was he?”
You glance over at Steve. He’s already looking back, mouth tugging at the corner like he’s daring you to say something first. There’s a kaleidoscope of memory that flashes between you in the space of a blink.
You look back at Robin and shrug, casual as ever. “Not much. He folds my laundry now.”
Robin gasps. Eddie lets out a low whistle.
“Well, shit,” he drawls. “Steve Harrington, domesticated. Didn’t think I’d live to see the day.”
Steve rolls his eyes. “You guys are hilarious.”
But his ears are pink by the time you close the door.
…
After a round of burnt grilled cheeses, the kitchen’s a mess of crumbs and chatter.
Robin perches on a stool, slurping tomato soup straight from the pot. Eddie’s straddling a chair backwards, drumming on the counter. Dustin paces, orchestrating what sounds like a full-scale military operation using a butter knife and a salt shaker.
“—I’m saying if we shift the rendezvous point closer to the treeline, we can cut our response time in half. Minimum.”
Steve leans against the fridge, nodding like he’s catching every third word.
You’re at the sink, rinsing dishes, the voices behind you fading into a comfortable hum—until Dustin steps in beside you, tone low and careful.
“So… he’s okay to come back now, right?
You glance over your shoulder.
Steve’s got his shirt hiked up for Robin and Eddie to see, scars catching the kitchen light—pale and raised, still tender from where you pulled out the last stitch two days ago. Robin wrinkles her nose, groaning about how she's lost her appetite.
You turn back to Dustin. “I mean, no fever, no infection. Doesn’t seem to be actively dying. So yeah, I’d say he’s good.”
Dustin beams. “Awesome.”
You hesitate. Then, before you can stop yourself:
“Actually… I was thinking I could come with you guys this time.”
The room goes still.
Robin lowers her spoon. Eddie looks up. Even the sink seems to hush.
Steve’s voice breaks the quiet.
“No.”
You turn, incredulous. “Excuse me?”
“No way,” he says, pushing off the fridge, crossing the kitchen with that particular brand of determined worry you’ve come to recognize. “You’re not going.”
You blink at him like, Seriously?
He raises his brows like, Try me.
You sigh, turning off the water. “I wouldn’t be going in. Just close enough to help. You know, in case someone ends up bleeding to death again?” You shoot him a pointed look.
He ignores it, jaw working like he’s gearing up to argue again. But Dustin cuts in.
“Wait, that’s actually kind of genius,” he mutters thoughtfully. “You could be our medic. Like—Eddie, dude, she could be like our cleric!”
You frown. “Our what now?”
“D&D thing,” Eddie smirks. “Healing spells. Keeps the rest of us idiots alive.”
You laugh softly. “Sure. Okay. Cleric.”
But Steve isn’t laughing.
“Wait, just—hang on,” he steps forward, catching your wrist. “Can I talk to you for a second?”
…
The hallway is narrow and dim, lit only by the slant of light spilling in from the kitchen.
You lean against the wall, arms crossed, watching him pace three slow steps before stopping, running both hands through his hair.
He doesn’t look at you. Doesn’t speak.
You wait.
Finally, quietly: “You can’t come with us.”
You narrow your eyes. “You’re not the boss of me.”
“I mean it.” His voice is low. Firm. But it’s not angry. Not that sharp, flinty tone you remember from high school, when he used to wield confidence like armor. No, this is something else.
Fear.
You tilt your head, voice softening. “Steve…”
He exhales through his nose, more of a tremor than a breath. “You heard what it’s like down there. You saw what happened last time.”
“I did. That’s why I’ve decided to go.”
His eyes snap to yours, incredulous. “And you didn’t think to talk to me about it before?”
“Why? So you could freak out and tell me no?”
“I’m not—” He cuts himself off, jaw flexing. “I just can’t ask you to risk that. It’s not fair.”
“You’re not asking,” you say quietly. “I’m offering.”
For a moment, neither of you moves. He stares at you like he’s searching for something—some argument, some loophole that’ll make you stay here while he walks back into hell. Like if he keep fighting back, maybe he won’t have to admit what this really is.
But when he speaks, his voice isn’t tense anymore. It just trembles.
“I can’t—I can’t lose you in there. You get that? I can’t. I just…” His eyes flicker away, toward the shadowed doorway behind you. He swallows hard.
“...I just got you.”
The quiet stretches. You gaze at him, heart heavy.
His shoulders are tense when you reach for his hand. His fingers twitch in yours, like he’s ready to pull away—but he doesn’t. He never does.
“Steve,” you start gently. “I know you’re scared. I am too. But I can’t just sit here and wait while you...” you take a breath, squeezing his hand. “If there’s a chance I can help, I’m taking it.”
He looks down at your joined hands, your fingers laced tight. His thumb drags slow, absent circles against your skin—once, twice, like he’s trying to memorize the feel of it. The fight drains out of him with a sigh that sounds too big for his chest.
He steps forward wordlessly, and pulls you into his arms. His chin drops to the top of your head. You press your cheek to his chest, feeling the wild rhythm of his heart start to slow.
“Fine,” he murmurs. “But you’re staying up here. Radio only. And you’re not going anywhere near the gate, you hear me?”
You smile into his shirt. “Deal.”
…
It’s almost 3 p.m. when he stirs.
The sunlight’s lazy this time of day, all thick and golden, caught in the slow spin of dust motes above the coffee table. The air smells like coffee and the lavender candle you lit this morning. You’re curled sideways on the couch, a book open but long forgotten on your chest.
“Jesus,” comes a voice beside you, rough with sleep. “How long was I out?”
You smile, already watching. “Couple hours.”
He squints at the light. “You let me nap that long?”
“You needed it.”
Steve rolls up from where he was buried in the couch, a soft pillow line stamped across his cheek. His hair’s flattened on one side and sticking up in the back. You reach out and comb your fingers through the mess. It fluffs up worse for it, but he sighs and leans into your hand anyway.
He trades the throw pillow for your stomach, draping a heavy arm across your waist. You rest your palm on his shoulder, thumb tracing the ridge of his collarbone.
The house hums around you: the low buzz of the fridge, the steady tick of the clock, the soft creak of settling wood. It’s a silence that no longer feels hollow.
You let it breathe.
It’s been three weeks.
Three weeks since you stood on the other side of a collapsing gate, heart in your throat, waiting for their silhouettes to break through the mist.
Three weeks since the air finally stilled, the ground stopped shaking, and the last portal sealed itself shut behind Eddie, behind Robin, behind all of them.
Three weeks since you checked every pulse, cleaned every wound, counted every head, and realized, miraculously, that no one was missing.
That everyone made it out. Alive. Together.
Three weeks since Steve stumbled out of the wreckage and into your arms and didn’t let go.
The bruises have faded since then. The stitches dissolved. The nightmares are fewer now, further between.
And Steve hasn’t left. Not once.
You're not sure when it stopped being temporary. When duffel bags became dresser drawers, when his shaving cream started living on your bathroom counter, next to the ceramic dish that holds your rings. When the dent in your couch, the dip in your pillow, stopped feeling like borrowed space and started feeling like home.
He still has his edges, the instinct to fix, to shield, to throw himself in front of the next disaster before it happens. But you’ve learned how to slow him down. To be the hand that pulls him back before he burns himself out.
And he’s learning to let you.
You’re halfway lost in that thought when he pokes your side.
“Hey,” he murmurs. “You okay?”
You hum. “Just thinking.”
“Uh oh,” he teases, voice still scratchy with sleep.
You smile, ruffling his hair. He groans and nips playfully at your stomach. When your laughter settles, you say it, quietly:
“I was just… thinking about what you said.”
He stills, blinking up at you. “Yeah? What’d I say now?”
“At the gate.”
That’s all you have to say. You both remember.
The roar, the smoke, the sting of blood and dirt. The ground giving out beneath you when he finally made it out—only to tell you he had to go back. One last time. To help the others out. To step into the jaws of a place that wanted to claim him for good.
I know! I know! Just—I need to tell you something. No, I know, just listen—
You remember the chaos closing in, the sky fractured by fire and screaming metal, and his hands—steady, impossibly steady—as he caught your face. His voice cracking on the words:
I love you. I need you to know that, okay? I love you.
You stare at the book laying on your chest, swallowing hard. “I never said it back.”
Steve looks at you for a long moment.
Then, softly: “Yeah, you did.”
“When?”
He smiles, tracing a quiet pattern along your waist.
“Not out loud. But you did.”
You think back.
To the tremor in your hands as you let his fingers slip away. The hitch in your breath when the walkie crackled with his voice. To how tightly you held on when he staggered out with the others, bruised and shaking and breathing, and realized you could finally breathe too.
Every heartbeat since has felt like a promise.
Maybe words would’ve failed then. Maybe he heard it in all the ways you refused to let go.
Your fingers find his jaw.
“Still,” you whisper. “I want to say it now.”
He tilts his head, waiting.
And you do.
Softly, firmly, the words falling easy like they’d been waiting inside you all along.
And when he says it back, you feel it in your chest long before you hear it.
…
The house is still too small. The front door still sticks when it rains. The couch still carries the faint stain from that first night.
But it’s home.
More than it ever was. More than it ever could’ve been without him.
The proof is everywhere: his Ray-Bans next to your keys, a battered boombox on your plant windowsill, the Polaroid Robin took where he’s smiling at you instead of the camera.
Some nights still weigh heavy on him. When even rest won’t stay kind.
But on those nights, he finds you. He always will.
And somewhere between the grocery runs and movie marathons, between loud songs in the kitchen and quiet kisses before bed, it stopped feeling like borrowed time.
It’s just time, now.
Yours.
Together.
…
Robin once told you that you get off on fixing people.
She meant hearts. You meant bones.
Maybe she was right.
But maybe that’s not such a bad thing.
You've named it something else now, anyway.
…
epilogue
You stretch, set the book aside, and head for the kitchen.
You’ve got prep to do for night.
Steve moves in behind you, hair still rumpled, sleeves pushed to his elbows. He leans his hip against the counter, flipping through the Player’s Handbook Dustin left last week, brow furrowed like he’s cramming for a test.
“I swear,” he mutters, squinting, “you need a math degree to play this game.”
You laugh, laying a neat row of apple slices beside a bowl of pretzel sticks and M&Ms—fuel for the chaos to come. “You’ll live.”
“Not if Eddie's dragon eats me.”
“Well, maybe you should listen to your cleric tonight, then.”
He grins, stealing a slice from the tray, then slides closer until he’s flush against you. His hips trap you against the counter, chest warm against your back. He leans into the crook of your neck, lips grazing your ear.
“You know it's kinda hot when you boss me around, right?”
Before you can roll your eyes, he catches you by the hips and spins you around, grin breaking wide and easy. You love how it softens his face, how it creases the corners of his eyes.
Soon, the party will be here—arms full of sodas, dice clattering in boxes, voices overlapping in familiar chaos. The house will fill with laughter, with the easy rhythm of shared lives.
But for now, it’s just him.
Rumpled hair. Soft smile. Apple-sweet kisses and the honey-gold hush of afternoon light.
And the sun keeps pouring in.
Just want to celebrate your happy hour and the fact that you write some of the most INCREDIBLE fanfic here!!! It’s genuinely so sweet and romantic and smutty!!! You deserve everything and more <3
Now, may I please have a Steve Harrington vodka cranberry, stirred, with a twizzler straw and a cherry? I think a lil bent paper straw would also be cute for the situation. Thank you!!!
I'm like, incredibly happy with how this turned out and LOVED writing this drink menu fic so much. I made it extra smutty and romantic for you <3
[fic masterlist]
your very real boyfriend
You only agreed to fake date him to score cheap rent above the local bakery. But a bottle of wine, a too-sweet story from your elderly landlady, and a very real game of “what would my boyfriend do next?” changes everything.
Love was never supposed to be part of the lease. But there he is.
wc: 11642
order up: steve harrington x reader, modern au strangers-to-roommates-to-lovers story with fake dating, mutual pining, smut, softness, and a sexy sweet, awkward “so… we’re real now?” kind of confession.
tw: smut (explicit), alcohol use, oral (f & m receiving), praise kink, fingering, unprotected sex, dirty talk, aftercare, domestic intimacy, body worship, awkward post-hookup humor, emotional vulnerability, very soft cockwarming, this man is so house husband coded i stg
You’re standing outside the bakery just off Main. The air is cold enough to see your breath, the kind of early October chill mixed with homemade pumpkin bread and wet leaves. Plastic skeletons hang from lampposts, a ghost made of streamers flaps in the wind. You tilt your head back to look at the apartment above the bakery, the one that could finally be yours.
For a minute, you start to picture it. Where your records would go. How you’d hang your posters so the sunlight hit them in the morning. Maybe you’d even meet some guy in a band, bring him up here, put a record on, and pretend you both have the world figured out.
Someone clears his throat beside you.
You glance over. He has good hair, the kind that looks effortless, and a nice sweater layered over a collared shirt. Jeans that probably cost more than yours, clean sneakers. The kind of guy who says “ma’am” to waitresses and holds doors for old ladies.
You, on the other hand, tried to look like the kind of person who could get approved for an apartment. Your usual band tee is swapped for a black long-sleeve top tucked into a plaid skirt, your usual leather jacket replaced with a plain denim one. You even brushed out the streak of color in your hair, though a bit still lingers near the ends. You figured you looked normal enough, but the way he gives you that slow once-over says he can still tell you’re a little offbeat.
“Are you here to show the apartment?” he asks, polite but already impatient.
You blink. “No. I’m here to rent it.”
He glances down at a folded sheet of paper in his hand, the listing printed in neat type. “I thought the showing was at nine.”
“It is. For me,” you say, checking your watch.
His eyebrows draw together. “Mrs. Shaw told me nine thirty.”
“No. She told me nine thirty.”
“So one of us is wrong.”
“Yeah,” you say, crossing your arms. “You.”
He looks down at his note again, mouth twisting when he sees the small “9 AM” written in his own messy handwriting.
“Oh,” he says quietly. “Shit. Guess that’s on me.”
“Guess so.”
He looks like he’s about to argue anyway, but the bakery door swings open before he can. The smell of cinnamon and sugar rushes out, warm against the morning air.
Dorothea Shaw stands there with flour dusted across her apron, cheeks flushed from the ovens. She’s in her late sixties, with silver hair pinned up in a bun that always comes a little loose by midday and soft pink lipstick that never quite stays on the edges. There’s a kindness in her eyes that makes everyone call her “Mrs. Shaw,” even though she always insists on Dorothea.
“Oh, you must be the two I spoke to on the phone,” she says cheerfully. “I didn’t realize it would be a couple.”
You and the guy both start to talk, overlapping. “Oh, we’re not—” “No, we just—”
Dorothea laughs, waving a hand like she’s already made up her mind. “You young folks don’t have to explain yourselves to me. Come in, come in, let me show you the place.”
She ushers you through the side door of the bakery and up a narrow staircase that smells like sugar and yeast. The steps creak underfoot, the paint along the banister chipped from years of use. She keeps talking as she climbs, her voice bright over the hum of ovens below. “I’ve known Steven since he was knee-high,” she says with a fond glance at him over her shoulder. “Never thought I’d see the day he settled down.”
You raise an eyebrow. The guy (Steven, apparently) flushes pink and gives you a helpless look. “It’s, uh, not exactly like that,” he mumbles.
Dorothea just smiles knowingly. “Sure, sure. I’ve heard that before.”
The apartment opens into a cozy living room where morning light spills across faded floral wallpaper and lace curtains move with the draft. A corduroy couch sits against one wall, a crocheted blanket draped neatly over the back. There’s a short wooden shelf lined with old cookbooks and a square television with a crooked antenna. Everything feels a little worn but loved, the kind of place that’s been lived in quietly for years.
Dorothea gestures toward a small archway. “Kitchen’s through there. Gas stove still works if you’re patient with her. I left the table too, it fits right under the window.”
You peek inside. The kitchen is narrow, tiled in pale yellow, with a single sink and a fridge humming softly.
She continues down the hallway, showing two small empty bedrooms across from each other and a bathroom at the end. The fixtures are old porcelain, the mirror spotted, but everything smells like soap and lemon polish.
“There’s even a second bedroom,” she says warmly. “Perfect for when the baby comes.”
Steven coughs, nearly choking on air.
You glance at him, deadpan. “Children aren’t part of the plan yet.”
Dorothea chuckles, eyes twinkling. “Still in the honeymoon phase, then. That’s sweet. Plenty of time for that down the line.”
His head snaps up. “Please—”
She waves him off, smiling. “Oh, hush. I’m only teasing.”
Then she names the rent. The number sounds unreal, the kind of price you’d only hear from someone who values good tenants over money. You and Steve both pause, sharing your first real look of agreement.
You clear your throat. “Would it be all right if we talk about it for a minute?”
“Of course, dear,” Dorothea says, folding her flour-dusted hands. “Take your time. I’ll be downstairs if you need me.”
You both step out onto the landing. The air smells like fresh bread cooling below and a hint of rain outside. You can hear the old radio from the bakery drifting through the floorboards. Steven sticks his hands in his pockets, shifting awkwardly, still a little pink from the “settling down” comment. He looks over at you, sheepish.
You stay quiet for a second, both of you standing there with the soft hum of the bakery radio beneath your feet. The landing is narrow, lined with worn wallpaper and a window that looks out over Main Street. The sun is climbing higher now, catching the edges of the guy’s hair and the faint blush that still hasn’t left his face.
“So,” you say finally. “Steven.”
He looks up fast. “Just Steve.”
You nod. “Okay, ‘Just Steve’.” You give him your name, offering a quick, polite smile.
He repeats it softly, like he’s trying it out. Then he clears his throat. “So, uh, about the apartment.”
You glance back at the door. “Yeah. The price is… kind of hard to ignore.”
He nods. “It’s a good deal. Way better than anything else I’ve seen. I mean, I work at Family Video, so it’s not like I’m swimming in cash.”
You huff a small laugh. “Record store on Main. Same situation. I can pay, but it’d be easier to split it.”
Steve leans against the wall, crossing his arms. He looks thoughtful, not cautious, just measuring the idea. “There are two bedrooms. If you wanted, we could…” He hesitates, searching for the right phrasing. “We split the rent, utilities, all that.”
You tilt your head, he sounded like he had thought of this long before he messed up the showing time. “Did you already have a roommate in mind?”
He rubs the back of his neck. “Sort of. I figured Robin might move in, but she’s still living at home. Doubt she’d care either way. She’ll probably be around a lot, though.”
You nod, finding it funny, the way he says the name like you should already know her. There’s a familiarity in his tone, easy and fond, the kind people use when they talk about someone who means something. You can’t help but wonder if she’s his girlfriend. You push the thought aside, keeping your tone even. “That’s fine. I’ve got friends who’ll probably hang around sometimes, too. Nothing crazy.”
He smiles, a little relieved. “So, no wild parties. Got it.”
“Same goes for you,” you say. “I’m not cleaning up after any keggers.”
He holds up both hands, mock-offended. “I’ve retired from that life. Promise.”
You talk through the practical stuff. Who’d take which bedroom. How to split the bills. That you’ll both try not to steal each other’s laundry quarters or leave dishes in the sink.
Maybe it’s the warmth from the bakery below or the way Steve’s voice softens when he agrees with you, but for a minute, it doesn’t feel like a bad idea.
When the terms are settled, you knock lightly on the doorframe and call for Dorothea.
“So?” she asks.
You glance at Steve, and he nods. “We’ll take it,” you both say at once.
Dorothea’s face brightens. “Oh, that’s just wonderful. I can have the paperwork ready this afternoon.”
She walks you through a few more details, pointing out where the spare key will hang and reminding you about the mail slot downstairs. Before she leaves, she pauses in the doorway, eyes soft. “And you two should come down for dinner sometime. Once a month, maybe. I get a little lonely in the evenings. It’d be nice to have company again.”
You start to say something, but Steve beats you to it, his smile smooth and easy. “That sounds lovely, Mrs. Shaw. We’d like that.”
Dorothea beams. “Good. I miss cooking for someone.”
When she’s gone, the apartment is quiet again, filled only with the muffled clatter of baking trays below. You and Steve stand there in the center of the living room, both realizing at the same time that you’ve just agreed to more than a lease.
He scratches the back of his neck, looking a little dazed but not unhappy. “So, guess we’re roommates,” he says finally.
You glance toward the window, then back at him. “Yeah. Guess we are.”
Sharing space takes some getting used to.
The first few weeks are a mix of small arguments and quiet adjustments. Your makeup and hair stuff slowly take over the bathroom counter, spreading across the sink like a virus. Steve leaves coffee mugs everywhere. On the counter, on the windowsill, once on top of the toilet. You tell him you’re not his maid, and he tells you he didn’t realize a person could own that many lip liners.
You meet in the middle. He keeps the mugs to one a day, and you start keeping your things in a little basket.
Dorothea still thinks you’re a couple. Every time you run into her downstairs she calls you “sweethearts.” Sometimes she sends you home with bread or pie and tells you how nice it is to have young love in the building again. You play along.
Steve’s good at it, annoyingly so, smiling and slipping an arm around your shoulder when she’s looking. The first time he calls you “babe” in front of her, you nearly choke on your croissant.
Your respective friends find the whole thing hilarious. They know it’s fake, and they don’t let either of you forget it.
Robin comes over a lot and makes herself at home, sitting cross-legged on the couch while she tells you stories about Family Video. It’s her who lets it slip that she isn’t Steve’s girlfriend, or any guy. She says it casually one night while the three of you are eating takeout, and you realize how easy she is to be around.
After that, she starts siding with you on all the roommate debates, insisting it’s weird and unsanitary for Steve to drink his coffee in the bathroom in the first place.
Your friend Eddie, who is at the record store so often you’re surprised he doesn’t work there too, drops by sometimes.
He acts like it’s the strangest thing in the world that you live with Steve Harrington of all people. You tell him you didn’t even know who that was supposed to be, and he spends half an hour filling you in on Hawkins High lore. It becomes a running joke, him calling you “Mrs. Harrington” just to watch you roll your eyes.
There are little gestures you both fall into when Dorothea’s around. Hand-holding when she’s looking. A light touch to his arm when she makes a comment about how happy you seem.
Once, she hugs you both goodbye and you kiss him on the cheek without thinking. The warmth of it lingers, and you both pretend it didn’t happen. You don’t really talk for the rest of the day.
By the end of the first month, you’ve fallen into a rhythm. He makes breakfast most mornings. You leave notes reminding him to pick up milk. Robin and Eddie still tease, Dorothea still thinks you’re in love, and neither of you has bothered to correct her. It’s easier this way.
By January, you’ve settled into a rhythm.
You and Steve move around each other like people who have lived together for years. He makes coffee in the mornings, you open the windows to let the cold air in while you get ready. You take turns doing dishes, and somehow it’s never been a fight.
He’s realized by now that the way you looked the day you met was a toned-down version. You don’t bother hiding it anymore. The pins are back on your jacket, your eyeliner a little heavier, your hair streaked again. You catch him humming along to your records sometimes, quiet and half out of tune, like he doesn’t even notice he’s doing it. He brings home movies from Family Video on Fridays. Horror for you, action for him, something in the middle when you compromise.
You don’t bring anyone home, and neither does he. It’s easier that way. Keeps the story with Dorothea simple, and it makes the apartment feel like yours, even if you both keep pretending it’s temporary.
You’ve had a few dinners with Dorothea since moving in, each one warm and easy. She always sends you home with something wrapped in foil and a compliment about how you remind her of herself at your age. Tonight’s dinner is at her house, a small place on Cherry Street, just past Melvald’s, where the neighborhood dips into quiet. Her living room smells like pine, and there’s a small fire crackling in the hearth.
The table is already set when you arrive, three plates, mismatched silverware, a vase of fake flowers in the middle. She insists you sit side by side, saying something about “young love keeping her warm.” Steve just smiles and thanks her for the invitation.
Dinner is cozy. Roast chicken, scalloped potatoes, something green she swears will make your skin glow. The conversation drifts from the bakery to her garden to her late husband, William. She tells stories about him, how he used to bring her pastries even though she made them herself, how he’d leave her little notes in the kitchen every morning.
“Love is all habits,” she says, folding her napkin in her lap. “You find someone who makes your life quieter, easier, and you keep them around.”
You smile without thinking. The way Steve brings you coffee at work. How he picks up horror movies without asking. How he lets you talk over the opening credits.
When you look up, he’s already watching you. Not staring, exactly, just aware. You glance away, pretending to focus on your plate, but the heat creeps up your neck.
Dorothea notices, of course. “You two are sweet,” she says softly. “Reminds me of us.”
Steve laughs, rubbing the back of his neck. “We try.”
She nods, satisfied, and launches into another story about the bakery’s first year, about waking up before sunrise to bake pies for customers. You listen, caught between the rhythm of her voice and the quiet sound of Steve’s fork tapping his plate beside you.
When dessert comes, the conversation softens. The fire pops, snow starts against the window, and you think about what she said about habits, about quiet. You don’t look at Steve this time, but you know he’s thinking the same thing.
Dorothea insists on pouring you both another glass of wine before you leave. You try to decline, but she waves it off, saying it keeps you young. The bottle is nearly gone by the time you finally manage to put your coats on, cheeks flushed and stomach warm.
Steve carries the leftovers in a small paper bag tied with twine. You’re walking back toward the bakery, breath fogging in the cold air. The snow isn’t heavy, just a flurry that catches in your hair and settles on his shoulders. The streetlights glow soft against the snow, and everything feels quieter than usual.
You walk side by side, boots crunching on the pavement. The air smells faintly like wood smoke and sugar.
“Dorothea really likes you,” Steve says after a while.
You smile a little. “Pretty sure she likes you more. You’re her golden boy.”
He laughs, shaking his head. “She’s just known me too long to be impressed.”
“Still. You’re the favorite.”
He grins, tipping his head toward you. “You jealous?”
“Not even a little.”
You keep walking, the silence between you not uncomfortable, just warm. The kind that hums quietly under the sound of your steps.
Then you say it. “So, my very real boyfriend…” you tease lightly, glancing up at him.
He snorts. “Yes, my very real girlfriend?”
You both laugh, the words sounding strange but not unwelcome. It’s the kind of thing that would normally end there, just another shared joke, but something about the wine keeps you talking.
You nudge him with your elbow. “I feel kind of bad, actually. If you ever want to bring someone home, we can figure it out. You know, so you can have an actual very real girlfriend.”
He glances at you, the corner of his mouth twitching. “Thanks for the offer. I’ve been on a few dates, but nothing worth introducing to Mrs. Shaw. Or risking your wrath over.”
“Risking my wrath?” you ask, smiling.
“Yeah. You seem like you’d have rules about that kind of thing.”
“Only the important ones. No weirdos. No one who wears too much perfume.”
He laughs. “I’ll keep that in mind. Not that I’ve had much luck anyway. I definitely don’t have the appeal I did back in school.”
You raise an eyebrow. “That so?”
He shrugs, the bag shifting in his hand. “Apparently.”
You can’t help laughing. “Maybe someone out there’s into that stupid Family Video vest you have to wear.”
You laugh again, shaking your head. “Well, any dates I’ve been on weren’t exactly thrilling either. Mostly at their place. Which probably says a lot.”
“Please,” he says, grinning. “Trust me, no one’s ever been into the vest.”
He’s quiet for a second, then says softly, “Yeah. It’s weird, right? Talking about this stuff.”
“Kind of,” you say.
He looks over at you, eyes soft in the streetlight.
Home comes into view, the windows dark except for the glow of the sign in the front. He unlocks the door and holds it open for you. The smell of baked goods drifts through, familiar and warm.
You head upstairs together, the floorboards creaking under your feet, both of you still smiling like you’re not sure why.
Inside, everything feels softer. The bakery below is quiet for the night, and the only sound is the hum of the radiator and the faint wind against the windowpanes. You kick your shoes off near the door and hand him your coat without thinking. He takes it, hangs it on the hook by the door with his own, and toes off his shoes before heading toward the kitchen.
It is automatic by now. You go to the couch. He goes to find something to put on. The small rituals you have built over months slot neatly into place.
“You want another glass of wine?” he calls from the kitchen.
You blink. “We have wine?”
He laughs, the sound muffled by the clinking of glasses. “Debatably good wine. From the corner store. Classy stuff.”
You grin. “Pour me some, then.”
He comes back with two mismatched glasses and sits beside you. The movie starts up, something he must have grabbed from work. The title rolls across the screen, half horror, half comedy, a compromise you both pretend not to notice.
You sink deeper into the couch, the wine warm in your hand. It is cheap, but it is red, and you realize he must have remembered that you like it better than white. He never says anything about those little things, but you notice them. The red wine. The coasters he finally started using. The way he lets you pick the music when you clean.
For a while you both watch in comfortable silence, the kind that fills the room instead of empties it.
After a while, you speak. “You know,” you say, voice low, “I really think she buys it. Dorothea. The whole couple thing. I kind of feel bad lying to her.” You take a sip of your wine. “But it’s nice that she believes it.”
He doesn’t answer right away. The light from the television flickers against his face. He takes his own sip before setting the glass on the table. “Yeah,” he says quietly. “Sometimes I almost do too.”
You turn your head to look at him. The thought catches in your chest.
He’s leaning back, relaxed from the wine and the warmth, hair falling into his eyes. The yellow cable knit sweater he changed into before dinner looks soft, worn at the cuffs. There’s a faint crease at the corner of his mouth, the start of a smile he never quite lets out. He looks content, peaceful in a way that makes it hard to look away.
You have always thought of him as clean-cut, too put together for you. But sitting here now, you see something else. The faint tiredness in his eyes. The curve of his shoulders. The kind of quiet that feels steady.
You tell yourself to look back at the screen, but you don’t. The movie keeps playing, forgotten. The air between you shifts, something warm and unspoken threading through it.
Steve is the one who breaks the silence.
“What?” he says, catching you looking at him. “Do I have, like, wine mouth or something?”
You blink. “Wine mouth?”
“Yeah,” he says, rubbing his thumb across his lower lip, like he’s trying to wipe away the color. “Like when kids get that ring of juice stain around their mouth, but for adults.”
You laugh quietly, shaking your head. The motion draws your eyes right back to his mouth. The faint red tint from the wine. The way his thumb drags over his lip. You look away, smiling a little.
“No,” you say softly. “Just… nothing.”
He leans back, still watching you. “You sure?”
You glance at him again, teasing now, trying to cover the flutter in your chest. “What? Am I not allowed to look at my very real boyfriend?”
He pauses. The joke should land easily, but his voice comes out quieter. “Not like that.”
You turn toward him a little, the air suddenly thicker. “Like what?”
He hesitates, then looks at you the way people do when they decide something. “Like I actually am your very real boyfriend.”
It’s quiet after that. His arm is along the back of the couch, close enough that you can feel the warmth of him behind you. You don’t remember when he put it there. Your glasses sit on the table, half-finished.
You tilt your head, the corner of your mouth lifting. “If you were my very real boyfriend,” you say, voice lighter now, “what would you be doing right now?”
He grins, eyes still on yours. “I don’t know. Maybe I’d put my arm around you.”
You glance at his arm already stretched along the back of the couch. “Guess that one’s covered.”
He laughs softly. “Then maybe I’d tell you something sweet.”
“Like what?” you ask.
He pretends to think, his smile crooked. “Maybe that you look really pretty tonight.”
You huff a laugh, your cheeks warm. “That’s a good one. I’d probably tell you your sweater looks soft.”
He raises an eyebrow, playful. “You could always check.”
You bite your lip, pulse skipping as you press your hand lightly against his chest. The fabric is warm, softer than you expected. You can feel the steady thump of his heart beneath your palm.
“Yeah,” you murmur. “Soft.”
The air shifts. His laughter fades into something quieter. He covers your hand with his, fingers curling gently over yours. The space between you disappears inch by inch, breath mingling, eyes caught on each other.
“What now?” you whisper, still teasing but softer this time.
He smiles, almost shy. “Now I think your very real boyfriend would probably kiss you.”
You let out a soft laugh, the sound catching somewhere in your throat. “Oh yeah? Is that part of the job description?”
“Pretty sure,” he says. “You’d know if you read the fine print.”
You lean in a little, teasing. “Guess I missed that part.”
“Guess I’ll have to remind you,” he says, voice low but still smiling.
You’re both still grinning, still pretending it’s just a joke, but the space between you keeps getting smaller. The kind of slow drift that feels inevitable.
“Wouldn’t want to ruin our very real relationship,” you whisper, eyes flicking down to his mouth.
He laughs quietly, breath warm against your skin. “Yeah, that’d be a shame.”
Neither of you moves for a second, just the steady sound of the movie in the background, the faint ticking of the clock on the wall.
Then he leans in just a little more.
And you don’t stop him.
It’s slow, hesitant at first, the kind of kiss that starts with laughter still in your chests and ends with all the air gone from the room. The wine lingers between you, sweet and warm, and the world outside the window fades into the hush of snow and steady heat.
His hand comes up to your cheek, thumb brushing along your skin like he’s been itching to touch your face.
You didn’t even realize your fingers had curled into his sweater, gripping onto the fabric like it might keep you tethered to the moment.
He pulls back just enough to search your face, his hand still cupped at your jaw. “Is this okay?”
You nod once. “Yeah. This is… yeah.”
He kisses you again, and this time there’s nothing hesitant about it. It’s slow but sure, like he knows exactly how to pull you into it. His mouth moves with quiet confidence, patient and present. The kind of kiss that says he’s not rushing anything, not asking for more than you’ll give, but also not holding back.
When his tongue traces the seam of your lips, you part them without even thinking, letting him in. There’s wine and warmth and something deeper you don’t name.
He tastes like everything he is:
Familiar.
Surprising.
Better than you expected.
You shouldn’t be surprised though, not after everything you’ve heard about from Eddie about Steve Harrington and the way he used to kiss girls behind the gym or in parked cars at Skull Rock. But this is nothing like that.
He’s not a teenage boy anymore. He’s grounded, even more sure of himself without putting on some bullshit act.
When he finally pulls away, both of you still breathless, he doesn’t let go of your hand. He lifts it from his chest like he’s realizing just now that you’d been holding him there. His eyes are soft and searching again, and the silence between you shifts.
Your voice comes out quieter than you mean it to and you sit back a little, needing space to breathe. “It’s late.”
Steve blinks like he’s coming back to earth. “Yeah...”
“I… have work in the morning.”
He gives you a crooked smile. “No, you don’t. You have Thursdays off.”
You look at him. He says it so casually, like it’s just a fact in the universe.
“You know my schedule?”
He shrugs. “Yeah. It’s our cleaning day. You sweep, I vacuum. We fight about which records get played. You always win.”
You laugh under your breath, rubbing your palm against your thigh. “Still. Sleep. Sleep is good.”
“Definitely,” he says, eyes still on you.
Eventually you move. He stands first and offers his hand to pull you up from the couch. You both walk slowly toward the hallway, the apartment dim and quiet around you. The bedrooms are across from each other, same as always, but tonight it feels different.
You both hesitate for a second, then wordlessly disappear into your own rooms.
You change into your usual sleep clothes, a big t-shirt and your favorite worn-in shorts, the kind that make you feel like yourself. Your mind keeps replaying the kiss, the way his fingers felt against your cheek, the way his mouth lingered like he didn’t want to stop at just a kiss.
You open your door at the same time he opens his. He’s in sweatpants and a white undershirt. You’re both heading toward the bathroom.
You stop in the doorway. “Sorry. I just—”
“I just need to—”
You both gesture toward the sink.
“I’ll be quick,” you say.
He leans against the doorframe instead, watching you for a second too long. Then something in his expression shifts.
Something like “fuck it.”
He steps forward, brushing your hair back before kissing you hard.
There’s no question this time. It’s not soft. Not teasing. It’s heat and need and the leftover as his hands find your waist. Yours slide up to his shoulders. The taste of wine mixes on your tongues and you don’t even care.
All you can think is that this is happening. Really happening.
And you don’t want it to stop.
You don’t know how long you’re kissing him before you both come up for air, chests rising and falling like you’ve just sprinted across Main Street. His hands stay firm on your waist, holding you there against the bathroom doorframe, and he’s watching you like he’s trying to decide if this is real.
It is.
You glance between your bedroom door and his. “My room’s… um, it’s a mess.”
Steve laughs, the kind that’s low and breathless. “Yeah. It’s always a mess.”
You start to protest, already ready to defend yourself. “Okay, no, I clean sometimes, I’m not—”
But he kisses you again before you can finish, stealing the rest of the sentence straight from your mouth. One hand slips around your back and the other finds your wrist, guiding you with him as he moves.
You barely register the few steps it takes before you’re inside his room. He doesn’t stop kissing you. He doesn’t even pause when he kicks the door shut behind you with the heel of his foot.
You feel the edge of the bed press against the backs of your knees. He gives you the smallest push and you tumble backward with a quiet laugh. The mattress creaks beneath you, protesting like it hasn’t been used for much more than sleep.
“Shit,” Steve mutters, crawling in after you. “I didn’t realize it was that loud.”
You grin up at him. “You haven’t tested it out?”
His mouth quirks. “Not like this.”
He leans over you, arms braced on either side as you settle against his pillows, and just looks for a second. Your shirt’s rumpled from where his hands touched you, your hair messy in the way that only happens when it’s been in someone else’s fingers.
His hair’s even more of a disaster than usual. You can tell he’s been running his hand through it, nervous, like he does when he’s thinking too hard.
But right now he’s not thinking. He’s just there, above you, eyes on your mouth again.
He kisses you.
Then again, slower this time, lips dragging across your cheek and down your jaw.
When his mouth brushes against your neck, your breath catches. He lingers there, warm and careful, his strong jaw against your skin in a way that sends a shiver through you. Your hands slide from his shoulders to his hair, curling your fingers into the soft mess at the nape of his neck.
“You okay?” he murmurs against your skin.
“Yeah,” you breathe. “Don’t stop.”
He smiles, a small curve of his lips against your throat before he continues, his kisses light, deliberate, exploring. He’s mapping you out. Learning the shapes of you. The space behind your ear, the sensitive spot just above the hollow of your throat.
His hands move too, one sliding under your shirt to rest flat against the small of your back, the other tracing patterns along your ribs through the thin fabric of your t-shirt. His touch isn’t rushed. It’s like he’s savoring the moment, memorizing the feel of your skin, the sound of your breath catching when he finds a place you like.
“No bra?" He says against your skin, a question that isn't really a question.
You huff a quiet laugh, pulling back enough to look at him. “I was expecting sleep...”
“Yeah,” he whispers, sliding a hand higher to cup your breast. The weight of his palm against you, the warmth of his palm makes your breath hitch. “Maybe later.” He leans in and kisses the corner of your mouth, his thumb brushing over your nipple. It stiffens instantly, a shock of pleasure.
You let out a soft gasp, arching into his touch. He’s watching you again, that same focused look, his eyes tracing your face like he’s searching for some kind of permission in your expression to take your shirt off.
“Yeah?” He doesn't stop, just continues his slow, deliberate movements under the fabric. His thumb circles your nipple, each pass sending a jolt straight through you. You can feel the heat building between your legs, a low, persistent ache that’s been there since that first kiss on the couch.
Instead of answering, you tug at the hem of your shirt, pulling it over your head in one fluid motion. It’s not exactly graceful, but it’s efficient, and the cool air hits your skin, sending goosebumps everywhere. But it’s the look on his face that truly makes your breath catch. It’s not hungry, not exactly, but… reverent. Like he’s looking at something beautiful, something worth savoring.
“Wow,” he breathes, his gaze moving from your face down your body, taking you in. There’s no hesitation, no sense of him being overwhelmed. He looks like you’re the only thing in the room. "I always kind of wondered..."
"You've thought about my boobs?" You're aiming for sarcastic, but your voice comes out softer than intended, a little breathless.
His eyes snap back to yours, and he grins, a real, genuine grin that crinkles the corners of his eyes. "Not just your boobs." He leans down, pressing a kiss to your sternum, his lips soft and warm. "I thought about the way you'd laugh if I said something stupid." Another kiss, a little lower, between your breasts. "I thought about the way your eyes get all intense when you're arguing with me about the best way to load a dishwasher."
His mouth travels lower, skimming across your ribs. "And yeah," he admits against your skin, "I thought about your boobs too."
You let out a huff of laughter that turns into a sharp gasp as his tongue traces the underside of your breast. He doesn’t go straight for your nipple, he’s taking his time, tasting you, mapping your skin. His hand that was resting on your back slides up, cradling the back of your head, fingers tangling in your hair as his mouth finally, finally closes over your nipple.
"Fuck," you whisper, arching into him. The sensation is a jolt, hot and sweet, and your fingers tighten in his hair. He applies gentle suction, his tongue flicking against the hardened peak, and his other hand palming your other breast, thumb rolling over that nipple, providing a friction that is almost too much.
"To be fair..." He says, switching over to give the other breast the same attention, voice a low rumble against your skin that makes you shiver. "It's a really great pair of boobs."
You want to laugh, you want to make a witty comeback, but all that comes out is a breathy moan as his teeth scrape lightly against your sensitive skin. He's listening to you, to every sound you make, and responding, adjusting his pressure, his pace, learning what makes you gasp and what makes you squirm. He's not just doing this for himself; he’s doing this for you.
The praise, the way he's looking up at you with his lips wrapped around your nipple, has heat pooling low in your belly, an insistent warmth.
"'Boobs' is such an unsexy word..." you breathe out, more of a reflex than a real complaint. It’s the only defense you have against the way he’s making your hips roll.
He pulls back for a second, his mouth hovering just above your skin, his breath warm against you. "Yeah?" he says, a small, smug smile playing on his lips. "You want me to find a better one? Tits? Breasts?" He pauses, tracing your other nipple with a finger. His eyes meet yours, dark and serious. "Or how about... beautiful." He kisses the spot between your breasts, right over your heart. "Perfect."
This is the most turned on you've been in a while. Your usual sarcasm feels flimsy, useless against his sincerity. It's easier to just let go.
The last word is whispered right before he dives back in, licking a broad stripe between your breasts and up to the hollow of your throat.
Your hands are restless now, roving over his back, feeling the muscles shift under his thin t-shirt. It's in the way. You want to feel his skin. With a frustrated tug, you start pulling it up, he gets the message immediately, lifting his head and pulling back just enough to yank the shirt over his head in one quick motion.
He tosses it aside. It lands somewhere on the floor, probably on that pile of clean clothes he never puts away.
And there he is. Steve Harrington. Shirtless in his bedroom.
He's not what you were expecting, and you have to force yourself not to stare too openly. It's not bulky muscle. It's the kind that comes from doing things. From lugging around inventory at work and probably playing basketball in his driveway at home. He’s broad in the shoulders, with a light trail of dark hair that starts at his pecs and disappears into the waistband of his sweatpants.
A thin, silvery scar runs diagonally across his ribs. You trace it with your fingertip, a small frown pulling at your lips. "What's this from?"
He looks down, then back at you, a hint of something complicated in his eyes. "Just... from a while ago."
He doesn't elaborate, and the way his gaze shifts just slightly tells you it's not a story for tonight. You can respect that.
You don't ask, you just lean in and press a soft, lingering kiss against the scar. Your lips are warm against his skin. He closes his eyes, and when you pull back, you see his jaw is tight.
You trail your eyes down his body, and the smile that finds you is different. Softer. "Well," you murmur, your voice low. "It's a nice view from here."
He grins, the tension breaking. "Yeah?"
"Mhmm."
He shifts above you, settling his weight more comfortably. He's careful, not crushing you. He nudges his nose against yours, his breath warm. "The view's not bad from here either," he whispers. His eyes travel from your face, down your neck, across your chest and stomach.
He’s slow as he lowers his mouth, kissing the curve of your belly, soft and open-mouthed, and you feel yourself relaxing into his touch. His fingers trace the waistband of your shorts, teasing, and you instinctively lift your hips as he pulls them down.
They get caught on your ankle, a tangle of cotton. You both let out a breath of laughter, the spell of quiet intensity broken for a second as he works the fabric over your feet and tosses them aside.
“Okay,” he grins up at you from where he's kneeling between your legs. “Got it.”
And then his eyes go back to you. To you completely bare. On his bed. The smile fades.
You're used to being looked at. You're not shy. But this is different. He's not just looking; he's seeing, making you feel quiet inside.
"Impressive form," you murmur. You can't help it. It's your shield. "A little clunky, but you got there."
He chuckles, his eyes still fixed on the spot where your thighs meet. The sound is warm, and it vibrates right through you. "Oh, don't worry," he says, his hands braced on your thighs. "My form gets better."
Before you can fire back a reply, he gently spreads your legs apart.
And then he dips his head and kisses the inside of your knee.
It's a soft, deliberate kiss. And he continues from there. He mouths a path up your inner thigh, and his hands follow, warm and slightly calloused from work, gripping you gently. It's the slowest possible version of what this could be. He's not rushing toward the main event; he's taking the scenic route.
Your breath hitches when his mouth ghosts over the crease of your thigh. So close.
He hovers for a beat, and you can feel his warm breath against your pussy, already slick with arousal. The anticipation is unbearable.
"Steve," you whisper. It's half a plea, half a warning. Your bravado is evaporating under the focused heat of his attention.
He looks up at you, his mouth impossibly close, his eyes dark with something that looks like awe. "You're so pretty," he says, his voice a low murmur against your skin. It’s not a question. It's a revelation.
And then his tongue is on you.
A long, slow lick from your entrance to your clit. It's not tentative. It's knowing. The groan he lets out is for your taste. The sound vibrates through your whole body.
"Fuck," you breathe, your head falling back against his pillows.
It was very clear to you earlier that Steve really liked kissing, and that is very obviously a skillset that translates. There’s no aimless exploration. He finds your clit easily, circling it with his tongue, testing the pressure until your hips buck off the bed. He slides two fingers into you, curling them instantly against that sensitive spot inside you that makes your thighs tremble.
"God, right there," you manage to choke out, your hands fisting in his duvet.
He hums in response, a sound of deep satisfaction, and redoubles his efforts. His mouth is a perfect, relentless pressure. His fingers move in a steady, maddening rhythm. He’s watching you from between your thighs, cataloging every shudder, every hitch in your breath, and adjusting his technique accordingly.
He seems… proud. Proud that he can do this to you.
"Look at me," he says, his voice thick and muffled by you.
You force your eyes open. You’re so lost in it you had completely forgotten to be embarrassed or worried you weren't being "cool" about any of this. The sight of him, head tipped up, your wetness glistening on his chin, his pupils blown wide with desire, is the final straw.
"You're so-- fuck, you’re so intentional," you hear yourself say. It's an observation, barely a whisper, stripped of its usual bite. It's an offering.
"Yeah?" he grins, a real, genuine grin before his tongue flicks out for another taste, his fingers never ceasing their movement. "'Cause I want to get it right."
And that does it. That thought of him wanting to get something so right for you, while his mouth is wrapped around your clit, sends a bolt of pure, unadulterated heat through your center. Your back arches, a long, shuddering moan tearing from your throat as your orgasm crashes over you. It's not a quiet, polite thing; it's a full-body wave that leaves you breathless, your hand fisted in the duvet, your toes curled tight.
He doesn't stop. He works you through it, his mouth gentle now, his fingers slowing, drawing out every last spasm until you’re left twitching and boneless on his bed. When he finally lifts his head, his expression is pure, unadulterated pride.
"Jesus, Steve," you manage, your voice wrecked.
He crawls back up your body, settling his weight beside you. His grin is soft, satisfied, and when he leans in to kiss you, you can taste yourself on his tongue. You meet him with equal fervor, your hands wrapping around his neck, pulling him closer, pouring everything you can’t say into the kiss.
It’s you who deepens it, your tongue slick against his, one of your hands almost clumsy as it trails down to the waistband of his sweatpants. You’re not thinking. Not about anything but how you want to give him that same focus, that same careful consideration.
Your fingers find the line of him, hard and straining against the soft cotton. You're met with a soft gasp in your mouth, a sharp intake of breath. He freezes for just a second, surprised, before his hips press into your touch, a silent plea.
His reactions are better than words.
It’s your turn to explore. You slide your hand under the elastic of his pants and boxers, gasping softly into his mouth as your fingers wrap around him, hot and impossibly hard. You’ve spent hours next to this man, and you've never once thought about him like this, not with this intensity. He’s bigger than you expected, thick in your palm, a bead of slick already gathering at the tip. The weight of him feels like a confession, his need a tangible thing in your hand.
“Jesus,” he breathes against your lips, and then your name comes out like a genuine prayer. His body is taut, the muscles in his back bunching under your free hand.
You move your hand in a slow, steady grip, feeling him twitch in your palm. You’re not trying to get him off; you’re exploring, learning his shape, the texture of him.
When you let go he actually whimpers. It's so quiet you wouldn't have heard it if your mouths weren't so close.
He scrambles off you and pushes both layers down. His movements are a little clumsy as he kicks the last of the fabric away. You watch him, propped up on your elbows.
He doesn’t hide. He just hovers over you for a second, completely bare and more vulnerable than you’ve ever seen him, letting you look your fill.
"Can you... lay on your back?" You whisper, "I just... I want to see you."
Steve blinks. For a second you think you've gone too far, asked for too much. But then his Adam's apple bobs in a slow swallow. He shifts, rolling onto his back beside you, stretching his long body out against the blue sheets of his bed. One arm goes behind his head, his other hand coming to rest on his stomach, just above where his erection lies hard and heavy against him.
The posture is casual. Open. It’s a surrender, and you feel a strange sort of power bloom in your chest. He was just in control, his head between your thighs, but now… now he’s letting you lead.
You shift, kneeling between his legs, and his eyes track your every move, dark and expectant. You lean over, places kisses on each beauty mark that dots his torso until you reach the cluster of them by his navel, where you look up.
“Is this okay?” you murmur, lips pressed lightly against the mole just under his belly button.
“Yeah,” he breathes, the word coming out strained. “More than okay.”
In response, you press an open-mouthed kiss to the base of his cock.
“Fuck.” His whole body tenses, the hand on his stomach clenching into a fist as you take him in your hand, stroking him slowly from base to tip, his pre-come smearing over your palm. The feeling of him in your hand, hot and alive and yours for the taking, is intoxicating.
You don't waste any more time. You wrap your lips around the head of his cock, and the sound he makes is a beautiful, broken thing.
Your hand settle on on his hip, the other wrapped around his shaft as you start to move.
He’s trying so, so hard to be quiet at first, the sounds catching in his throat. And sure, you remember everything that Eddie has said about the guy he used to be, the cocky jock whose voice was a loud, obnoxious thing at parties. But this is not that guy. This guy is trembling under you. This guy smells like soap and cheap wine and happiness and the heat of his own skin.
And this guy falls apart in minutes under your mouth.
His hips start to rock, small, helpless movements. His hand, previously clenched on his stomach, now comes to rest at the back of your head. He's not guiding you, not demanding, just resting it there, his fingers gently tangled in your hair as you work your tongue along the underside of his cock. He's learned, already, that you don't need to be told what to do.
Then his hips start to rock just that little bit more. That's all the permission you need.
You go lower, taking him deeper. His breath hitches as his cock hits the back of your throat and he tries, he really tries, to stop from babbling. A string of nonsense ends with a deep moan of your name as he loses the battle.
"So good... holy shit, you're so..." He breaks off into a guttural sound when you cup his balls, rolling them gently in your palm. "Fuck, don't stop, please don't..." It’s the first time he’s sounded truly desperate.
You don't intend to stop. You pull back for air before taking him deep again, faster this time, more confident. The hand in your hair tightens, not painfully, just... holding on.
"Look at you," he breathes out.
You glance up at him through your lashes. The look on his face is wrecked. All that former-cool-kid confidence completely gone, replaced with this raw, open-need. He’s watching your lips stretch around him, watching you take him, and the sight alone is enough to push him closer to the edge.
"I'm... I'm close," he manages to get out, his voice ragged. "You should... I'm gonna..." He's trying to be a gentleman. He's trying to warn you.
Instead of pulling back, you take him as deep as you can, your hand stroking what your mouth can't reach, and look him dead in the eye as you do. The silent permission, the greedy acceptance, is his undoing.
His whole body goes rigid. He calls out your name, one last, sharp, breathless cry, as he spills in your mouth. His hips stutter, his hand in your hair holding you there as you swallow him down, the taste of him salty and warm and utterly Steve.
After, you let him fall from your lips, pressing a soft, final kiss to his still-sensitive tip. You look up at him from your position between his thighs. He’s sprawled on the bed, his chest heaving, his eyes closed. He looks completely undone. A state of him you've absolutely never seen and you are the cause of it.
You feel a surge of something that's equal parts satisfaction and affection as you crawl back up his body. He gathers you into his arms the second you're in reach, pulling you flush against his side. His mouth finds yours instantly, a hungry, messy kiss that doesn't care where your mouth just was.
"You..." He breathes out as he pulls back, but he doesn't seem to have any other words. He just shakes his head, a slow, amazed movement. He buries his face in your neck, his breath hot and damp against your skin. "You're..."
You trail your fingers through his hair, damp with sweat at the temples. "I think the word you're looking for is 'intentional'," you whisper, a ghost of a smile on your lips. He chuckles, his breath warm against you.
"No," he says. "The word is perfect."
His hand starts to move again, tracing slow circles on your hip. He kisses your shoulder, your collarbone, your neck. His mouth is lazy and sweet, the both of you pushed to a soft, warm exhaustion. You could stay like this all night, a tangle of limbs and warm skin. But the hand on your hip moves.
It trails down, back to the place he already wrecked. His fingers slide through your wetness, exploring your slick, oversensitive folds. You twitch, a soft sigh escaping your lips as he gently pushes two fingers back inside you.
It's a feeling of coming home. He curls his fingers, finding that same spot as before. Not enough to make you come again, not yet. Just a promise. A reminder. He moves in and out of you with a slow, deliberate rhythm. His thumb finds your clit, circling it in time with the slide of his fingers.
"You feel so good," he whispers against your ear, and his voice is soft, not heated. It's like he's not even trying to get this to lead to anything more. He just wants to feel you. His touch is confident and caring in a way you've never experienced.
You turn your head to kiss him. It's slow and sweet.
His fingers work you, slow and sweet till you cum again. It's not the sharp, bright crash of your first orgasm, it's deeper, softer. A gentle wave of pleasure rolls through you, and you let out a soft, breathy moan into his mouth. Your body shudders against his.
When it's over, you slump bonelessly against him.
He holds you while the tremors run their course, his other hand tracing soothing patterns on your back. It's as close to perfect as you can imagine. He brings his fingers to his lips to taste you, and in his eyes, you see a flicker of the same awe from before. You also see a hint of something else. Something you’ve only ever seen hints of. Pride. Pride in you and pride in the fact that you are in his bed.
You pull back a little, looking down at him. His face is bathed in the soft, moonlit glow from the window. His hair is a mess on the pillow, his lips are kiss swollen, and he has a soft, contented look on his face.
"What?" he asks, a slow smile spreading across his face.
"Nothing. Can we... can we sleep? Like this?" You ask, already feeling a wave of sleepiness crash over you.
"I was hoping you'd say that." He pulls the duvet over the both of you, tucking it around your shoulders.
He pulls you into his arms again, and you rest your head on his chest. He’s warm and solid under you, and you can feel the steady, even beat of his heart against your cheek. It's a rhythm that's already starting to feel familiar, comforting.
Steve’s not a stranger anymore. He’s Steve.
Your very real Steve.
Your eyes drift closed. The last thing you hear is the quiet hum of his breathing.
You wake slowly, your mind piecing things together one at a time.
The sheets are softer than yours. The light is coming from the wrong side of the room. There is an arm draped over your waist, heavy and warm. It takes a second before it clicks. This isn’t your room.
You breathe out quietly and look around. The window is cracked just enough to let in a thin line of sunlight, catching on the framed car poster near the closet and the pile of clothes on the chair. It smells like sex and laundry detergent.
Carefully, you lift his arm from your waist. He doesn’t move. He’s out cold, flat on his stomach, hair a complete disaster, face half-buried in the pillow. You gather your oversized t-shirt from the floor and pull it over your head. Your shorts are nowhere in immediate sight, so you don’t bother looking long.
You pause at the edge of the bed and glance back at him. His back rises and falls in a steady rhythm, mouth slightly open, a small frown between his eyebrows like he’s dreaming about something frustrating. You feel something tug in your chest, and you’re not sure if it’s regret or something much worse.
The apartment is quiet when you step into the hall. The wood floors are cool under your feet. You head to the kitchen, pulling your hair out of your face with one hand while the other starts the coffee maker. The smell fills the room fast. It steadies you a little.
You pour a cup and lean against the counter, drinking it over the sink while looking out the window. Hawkins is already awake. A couple of kids are walking their bikes down Main, Joyce Byers is sweeping the front steps of Melvad’s, and a thin layer of snow dusts the street. The kind that won’t last long once the sun hits it.
The coffee burns a little going down, but it feels good. You’re trying not to think about the night before, but it keeps replaying anyway. His hands, his focus, the way he said your name like it meant something.
You don’t hear him right away, but then there’s a low, sleepy voice behind you.
“Morning.”
You turn just slightly, enough to see him out of the corner of your eye. His hair is sticking up everywhere, and he’s just in his boxers. He walks past you to the coffee pot, yawning, and pours himself a cup.
“Morning,” you say quietly.
He leans against the counter next to you, shoulders brushing as he takes a sip. For a moment, neither of you speaks. The silence isn’t exactly uncomfortable, but it’s heavier than it should be.
You glance at him. “I’m sorry if this ruined our dynamic as roommates.”
He looks at you over the rim of his mug, a small smile tugging at his mouth. “Yeah, it definitely ruins the roommate dynamic.”
You blink, unsure if you should laugh. “Oh.”
He sees your expression change and shakes his head quickly. “No, no, I mean—” He sets his mug down and turns to face you fully. “It definitely ruins the fake dating thing too.”
That doesn’t help. You look down into your coffee, your stomach sinking a little. “Right.”
He groans softly, rubbing a hand through his hair. “That came out wrong. I meant… it’s not fake anymore.”
You look up. His eyes are clear now, not sleepy, not joking. “I just… I figured this meant we went from ‘very real’ to actually… very real,” he says quietly.
For a second, you can’t find words.
You meet his eyes again, and the small, nervous smile that follows is enough to make your heart trip over itself.
You take a slow breath. “Oh,” you say again, but this time it’s different. Softer.
He takes a small step closer. “So… is this— us. Are we okay?”
You lean your hip against the counter, considering him. “I don’t think I’d call us ruined.”
A quiet laugh escapes him, and he steps forward until he’s right in front of you. “I'd disagree. I feel pretty ruined from that mouth of yours--"
"Shut your mouth about my mouth." You groan, cheeks warming.
He grins wider now. "No. I don't think I will."
His smile softens again. It’s disarming, the way he can swing from teasing to sincere without missing a beat.
He reaches past you for your coffee mug, taking it from your hand and setting it on the counter beside his. Then he snakes his hands around your waist. But instead of pulling you in, he steps behind you, wrapping his arms around your front and resting his chin on your shoulder. It’s a comfortable position, intimate in a way that feels new. You can feel his warm breath against your ear. You cover his hands with your own, leaning your head back against his shoulder.
“I’m really hoping you’re not going to go back to your room and pretend this didn’t happen,” he says, his voice low against your ear.
“No,” you say. “I really don’t want that.”
You don’t. The thought of going back to the carefully constructed farce you had between you feels impossible now.
"Good..." he murmurs. "But just to make sure..."
His hands move under your big shirt and settle on your hips and he nudges your thighs open with his knee, pressing himself against you. There’s no mistaking his intent, but it’s gentle, a question more than a demand.
You can feel him, half hard already, pressing against the thin fabric of his boxers. And this time, you push back, grinding your ass against him in a slow, deliberate movement.
He makes a soft, choked sound. "Okay, so... same page?" he manages, his breath hitching.
"Mhmm," you hum, turning your head to kiss his jaw. He tilts his head down to meet your mouth.
"Lean over the sink," he says, his voice low. "Please."
The 'please' is a key detail. A signpost.
You grip the edges of the counter. You can see the two of you in the small window above the sink: you, in your oversized black t-shirt; him, shirtless and strong behind you. It’s a raw, unfiltered image. You watch as he slowly, deliberately pulls down his boxers just enough, and you watch his face in the reflection.
He lines himself up. Instead of just pushing in, he traces the tip of his cock along your slick folds, back and forth, letting you feel the weight of him without rushing. He’s watching your face in the reflection, his own expression tight with control.
“Are you on…” he starts, trailing off.
You nod against the cool metal of the faucet. “Yeah.”
“Yeah,” he breathes out in relief. “Good.”
He notches the head of his cock at your entrance, and for a long moment, he just stays there, a hot, firm pressure. He’s pushing in so slowly, inch by torturous inch, your knuckles are white on the counter. The stretch is immense, a deep, fulfilling ache.
He watches the whole thing in the reflection.
You don't just feel watched, you feel worshipped. It’s unnerving, it’s intoxicating. He watches his cock disappear into you like it’s the most beautiful thing he has ever seen, his breath caught in his throat.
"You okay?" he grunts out once he's fully inside you, his hands gripping your hips, his chest pressed against your back.
You can only nod again, a choked sound in your throat. Words are useless. You feel incredibly full, more connected to him than even last night. And all he’s doing is breathing.
His first withdrawal is slow too. A long, steady drag that leaves you feeling empty before he pushes back in, a deep, smooth thrust that makes your eyes roll back in your head. You feel every inch of him.
“Shit,” you whisper, pushing back to meet him.
He lets out a low groan. “Yeah?”
“Mhmm.”
“Let’s make this official, then,” he murmurs. He wraps one arm securely around your waist, pulling you back against him while his other hand slides down to find your clit. His movements are deliberate and assured.
“You feel so good around me,” he says, voice raspy and loving. "Could feel like this every day." His fingers begin to circle your clit. He starts to find his rhythm, a steady, deep rocking motion that has you bracing yourself against the counter.
You watch him in the window. The way his jaw clenches with effort, the way his biceps flex as he holds you. You watch your own face, lips parted, eyes hazy with pleasure.
The pace builds slowly. Each thrust a little harder, a little deeper, and the drag of him inside you is sending sparks of electricity up your spine. His fingers on your clit move in time, relentless, as your orgasm starts to build.
"Could be my very real girlfriend..." he whispers in your ear as his hips piston a little harder. "Could do this whenever you want..."
His voice, the raw need, the permission to have this, it's all too much. "Steve..." you manage, your voice cracking. You reach back, a hand finding his hip, nails digging into his skin as you try to hold on, to ground yourself, but he won't let you.
“Take you on dates, real ones,” he pants. “Not just fake ones for Dorothea.” His thumb presses harder, circles faster. “Go to the movies and hold your hand in the dark. Come home and do this."
Your orgasm crashes through you. It's a white-hot wave that steals your breath and makes your vision blur. You're crying out his name, a long, ragged sound that echoes in the quiet kitchen. Your legs tremble, your body going weak as the pleasure overwhelms you. The hand braced on the counter almost slips.
He holds you steady through it. He doesn't stop. His hips keep pistoning, drawing out your orgasm, milking you for every last shudder.
"You sound... so pretty when you do that," he groans, his voice thick with desire. He's close, so close. You can feel it in the erratic rhythm of his thrusts, the way his breath hitches. His grip on you tightens, his fingers digging into your flesh.
His rhythm stutters. He buries his face in your neck, his mouth hot against your skin as he lets out a string of curses. His hips jerk forward, and he’s coming with a final, deep thrust, spilling into you with a shudder. He presses his forehead between your shoulder blades and breathes you in for a minute. His body is hot and heavy against yours, a dead weight that is one of the best things you have ever felt.
Neither of you speaks. There is just the sound of your breathing, the distant hum of the city, and the quiet aftermath of it all. It’s not awkward. It’s more. It’s heavy in the best way.
Finally, he straightens up, slowly, carefully. He presses a soft kiss to your shoulder before pulling out gently, leaving you feeling suddenly empty. You stay leaning against the counter for a second, trying to find your legs.
"Hey," he says softly, his voice still a little rough. "You okay?"
You turn around to face him fully and he's reaching to grab a clean dishcloth from the drawer, hand going around you to wet it in the sink, the other hand on your hip keeping you steady. He’s gentle as he cleans you up. He’s done this before. But this is not a rehearsed performance. It's an act of reverence that makes your throat tighten.
You finally look up and meet his eyes. He looks as wrecked as you feel. "Yeah," you say, and your voice is hoarse. "I'm really okay."
He looks a little shy, as you watch him clean himself up a little with the cloth before pulling up his boxers.
"I'm going to make some more coffee," he says, clearing his throat a little. "And then... then I think I'm going to do something incredibly uncool and make you pancakes."
You laugh, surprised by the sudden domesticity of it all. "Pancakes?"
"Yeah," he says, a slow grin spreading across his face. "Pancakes. From your hopefully very real boyfriend..."
He trails off, and you decide to help him out. You step forward and wrap your arms around his bare torso, pressing your cheek against his chest. You can feel his heart beating under your ear.
"I think I'm going to be incredibly uncool too," you mumble into his skin. "And let your very real girlfriend have some."
He hugs you back, and you just stand there for a moment, wrapped around each other in the brightening kitchen. This is new territory, but it doesn't feel scary. It feels right.
He pulls back after a minute, and you can't help but admire him again. He's relaxed in a way he hasn't been before, with an easy smile on his face.
"I'm going to be really honest, though." He says, looking sheepish. "I'm not actually that good at making pancakes."
You snort, and start rummaging through a drawer, eventually pulling out a wooden spoon and a mixing bowl. "Shut up. You are not getting out of this."
He laughs, reaching for his coffee mug again. "Okay, okay. But no laughing when they're a little... lumpy."
You watch him for a minute, a real smile finally breaking through your usual guarded expression. This is it, then. The thing you’ve been dancing around for months. It's not a performance for Dorothea or a convenient solution to awkward landlord encounters. It's just Steve. You. A kitchen that smells like sex and brewing coffee. And a coming promise of slightly lumpy pancakes.
"Wouldn't dream of it, Steve," you say softly, leaning your hip against the counter and watching him gather ingredients. "Wouldn't dream of it."
[LOWKEY I WROTE THIS IN LIKE THREE HOURS BECAUSE IT MIGHT BE SOME OF MY FAVOURITE STEVE SMUT IDEAS I'VE HAD. FUCK.]
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming