hii! I have another head cannon for your DOAN fic lol. I've been thinking a lot about Hamilton's friend group, and the drama that went down specifically with the schylur sisters. Now I imagine it's still the same where Alex and eliza fell head over heels at first sight as it's been stated multiple times across the series. But I imagine Alex had a special connection with Angelica and she felt very strongly about him in return. I imagine he started to fall in love with the schylurs mainly for the family dynamic, they each reminded him of his mother and being a sibling/brother to someone again. I imagine that maybe Alex still cheated on eliza but based on how John doesn't know what happened, he didn't post about it on the school webpage or smth like the reynolds pamphlet. I'm think it might be that Alex and Angelica were caught together. Either having a conversation of possibly being with both sisters or them being horny college kids and making out, which really upsets eliza who I imagine has a more traditional mindset at this point in her life of having a husband and running a home with many kids and then going to school to be a teacher. (Also head cannon that if we see her in DOAN she's a teacher for all the kids in the community and uses Alex's essays n journals from a backpack she kept from chapter 1 (or that they somehow went back to NYC and miraculously his apartment building wasn't destroyed) to teach em how to write n read) One of the most difficult aspects of being a teacher since 2010 is being an open minded, non judgment safe space for students who are experimenting with their sexuality. I'd imagine for a 18-20 yr old eliza who came from a more privileged, uptown, senators-daughter lifestyle it'd take her while to be open to understanding that kind of lifestyle. Especially when it's someone that's so close to her circle. So for Alex to come to her and tell her he's having some poly feelings and possibly open up about his bisexuality she might have a more severe reaction sprinkled with misunderstandings...if Alex actually communicated which I'm imagining he never did and eliza just caught him and this all came out in a big fight. Regardless it takes a while for things to cool down between everyone and in the time it takes for Aaron to be added to the group and John and Alex to get together, eliza and Alex actually talk and come to an understanding that still allowed them to be in each other's lives and it prolly brought them closer together now that Alex is freely with a man and not constantly debating how to express himself on such a personal matter. I love how cagey you make Alex in this tho, like it makes sense bc its an easy coping mechanism but also its such a fun way for the audience and other characters like James n Thomas to see these other aspects of his life and how he gives it away. Our boy has been through a lot in his 25 yrs of living and I imagine there are things that not a single soul in america knows about. Him giving those pieces of his life to somebody is a very simple and beautiful way of showing vulnerability. I can imagine how shocked and slightly impressed thomas would be when he finds out that while he was using angelica as a rebound for James, she was doing the same with her n Alex lmao.
i think the domesticity and stability of eliza are definitely thinks that attract alex, who has experienced these things basically Never since his mom died many years ago!
but youβre so right that their backgrounds are very different and that leads to fundamental differences between them and how they perceive the world; i think madison and jefferson also have a certain brokenness or damage or hurt or whatever you want to call it from their upbringings that make them more compatible with hamilton, because they all share a common language on that level, so to speak, whereas eliza (stable, loving, family home) fundamentally canβt understand where alex is coming from in key ways at key times
i obviously write with a lot of ambiguity because i like leavings things open for the reader (and sometimes i honestly donβt have a real answer/explanation behind things, it just Is Ambigousβ¦ one such major case is coming up in the next couple chapters) β so i wonβt weigh in on the exact nature of their breakup, but you definitely hit a lot of things on the head here with alexβs caginess, and i loved reading all of your thoughts on his relationships!!!













