summary: it’s a lively and lovely night at the nederlander theatre
a/n: this is from the first request ever sent into my inbox a loooooong time ago. whoop im so sorry. i used the tour cast instead of the way cast. ben is ben cook and josh is josh burrage. also i START HIGHSCHOOL TOMORROW so fics will be coming out more slowly, so sorry
“I’m going to be on Broadway.”
The words tumble out of your mouth faster than you prefer, faster than you wish they had.
You’re not sure what to expect from your friends. Yes, they all knew your time on Spider-Man would be short. A small part of Homecoming, that was set in stone from the beginning. They knew that all along. However, they did believe they’d have a little more time then a month or two.
And they also knew that, while you love screen acting, Broadway was and is your dream. It’s everything you love — dancing, singing, acting, live audiences — and they knew they should be happy for you. Most of them are.
“Oh my god,” squeals Zendaya as she wraps her arms around you. “What show? What part? When did you even audition? Answer me!”
“Well uh, I went when I told you guys I was seeing my parents,” you admit, twiddling with your fingers shyly.
“What?” Laura replies, shocked. “Why?”
Your voice comes out gentle and timid. “Well I, I just didn’t want to get my hopes up by letting other people know, so I kept it to myself.”
“Okay, so,” Jacob says excitedly. “What role? Show? When do you leave?”
“Well,” your cheeks turn red with excitement and happiness. “Katherine Plumber in Newsies!” You scream, unable to hold your excitement and eagerness in for much longer.
“Oh my god!” Zendaya puts her hands on your shoulders. “Isn’t that like, your favorite musical?”
“Yes, yes, yes!” You jump up and down, a hyper feeling filling your body.
“I’m so proud of you!” Laura giggles as she pulls you into a tight hug, rocking you back and forth.
Jacob pipes up from next to her. “Seriously, me too.”
“Tom?” You ask as you pull away nervously, pulling your sweater over your hands and onto your palms. “What do you think?”
You know you should be happy with your accomplishments, with what you’ve done. And the reactions of your other friends, the support they’ve shown you and are currently showing you. But you can’t help but wonder what Tom thinks, what’s going on in that beautiful and complex head of his, why he isn’t happy for you, or so it seems.
“It’s great,” he mutters dejectedly before standing up, turning away, and walking out the door.
You don’t say goodbye to Tom before you leave for New York. You try to, you really do, but he avoids you. When you walk into a room, he walks out. When you say hello, he mutters a quiet and short response before leaving.
You text him the day you leave. Standing in the Atlanta Airport, waiting for your flight.
hey. am boarding soon. just wanted to say goodbye.
You sit send with a quiet sigh caught in your throat, by the lump that’s taken it’s place.
It’s a lively and lovely night at the Nederlander Theatre. Three months into your run of the show, three months of fulfilled dreams and happiness. Three months of little to no Tom.
You miss him. That much you can admit to yourself. Because as much as you don’t want to, as big of a dick he was before you left, your heart hurts and is heavy for the boy who’d become your best friend. You’re not sure what the two of you are anymore.
“Y/N,” Ben knocks on your dressing room door. “Five minutes,” he reminds you before shutting the door.
“Okay, thanks, Ben!” You call after him.
There are benefits to not being in the first couple of scenes of the show. You can listen to the audience and how they’re doing, what they’re reacting you. You can take your time getting ready. You can do extensive warm ups. You can long for a text from your best friend. The last one might be exclusive to you.
“Katherine, those boys are counting on you,” you recite, pushing yourself into your fake set chair. You can barely see the crowd, too blinded by the bright lights of the stage and the fourth wall, but you can feel them. You can feel their heat and their energy as you belt out your last notes before stomping off stage.
The rest of the show goes perfectly. Often, there are problems, like the splitting of the boys’ pants, or dropping of the newspaper. But it goes perfectly tonight, a rarity. You feel pride swell in your chest.
“Knock knock,” Ben says happily, opening the door to your dressing room. “Did you already go to the stage door?”
“Yeah,” you pull an earring from your ear. “Really nice audience tonight. Met a real cute little girl at the stage door, dressed as Katherine.”
He takes a seat on the little couch in the corner. “Think I saw her too. Simply adorable. Anyway, there are people waiting for you in the hallway. Also, stage manager got flowers for you. Someone dropped them off. Spider-Man?” He says, voice layed in confusion
“Really?” You stand up excitedly. “Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Calm down,” Ben laughs. “They’re not going anywhere.”
You bolt out the door, quickly pushing yourself through waves of cast members and friends. “Oof, sorry Josh, yeah, okay, sorry!” You scream in apology over your shoulder.
Laura is the first one you see. She’s got a bright smile spread over her face, her arms crossed as she checks her phone. Zendaya, Jacob, and Angourie stand next to her, basically doing the same.
Their heads snap up. “Y/N?”
You squeeze Jacob, holding him tightly. “I didn’t know you guys were coming!”
“Well,” Laura starts. “We were in New York for a few scenes and couldn’t pass up surprising our favorite Broadway star! You were great!”
“Yeah, really amazing,” agreed Zendaya. “Now I see why Newsies is your favorite.”
“It really is the best, huh?” You joke, hands on your hips.
And then you hear it. A soft voice, laced underneath a British accent and a layer of light. Tom.
“Guys, the bathroom is— Y/N, hi.”
“Hi?” You reply awkwardly.
“We’re gonna give you guys some space. Meet some of your friends,” Jacob says as he pulls the girls away.
“So,” you rock back and forth on the heels on your feet. “Hi.”
Tom stuffs his hands into his pocket. “Hey.”
“What are— what are you doing here?” You motion to the room around you.
“I missed you,” admits Tom. “So much.”
The lump in your throat gets bigger. “We would’ve stayed in touch, if not for you.”
He looks down at his shoes, voice caught in his throat.
“Why do you do it, huh?” You press, pushing his chest with your finger. “Do you know how much it hurt? I thought you hated me! I still do. You were my best friend and you broke me. Didn’t even say goodbye.”
His voice cracks. “Were?”
“That’s all you got of that whole spiel, really? Selective hearing.”
You’re angry. Red hot, white hot. It’s clouding your vision and and your senses and your judgement. You can’t listen to a word that’s coming out of his mouth, too upset and too hurt. Sadness and anger were always something that went hand in hand with you.
“I—,” Tom moves his feet awkwardly. “Was scared. Am scared. Because, well I was losing you.”
“So you chose to lose me even more?”
“I’m stupid, I know,” he runs his hands through his hair. “But I’m just so goddamn in love with you, the thought of you leaving hurt me so bad. Because I thought if I pushed you away, it would hurt less, but God, Y/N, it still hurt so bad. Even more, I guess.”
“You’re so fucking stupid, Tom,” you cross your arms. “So fucking stupid.”
“But I fucking love you, you fucking dumbass.”
“Yeah,” you mutter as you pull his lips closer to yours. “So much.”