Loving...Toby will cost you
Pt.1 Pt.2 Pt.3 Pt.4 Pt.5 Pt.6 Pt.7 Pt.8 Pt.9 Pt.10 Pt.11
The branch snaps.
Itâs sharp.
Closer now.
You freeze.
Every muscle in your body locks, breath caught somewhere between your lungs and your throat. For a second, the entire forest goes silent with you, like itâs listening too.
Then, movement.
Somewhere to your left.
Your head turns slowly, pulse pounding so hard it makes your vision throb.
âToby?â
Your voice barely carries.
A shape shifts between the trees.
Tall.
Unsteady.
Familiar.
Relief hits you so fast it almost buckles your knees.
âToby,â you breathe, louder now. âHeyâhey, itâs me.â
He steps from between the trees into your line of sight, and the relief dies in your chest.
His posture is wrong.
Too rigid. Too focused.
His head tilts slightly, like heâs trying to line something up that wonât stay still.
His hatchet is stiff in his grip, his knuckles pale.
Your stomach drops.
âToby,â you say again, softer this time, careful. âItâs okay. I found you.â
He doesnât respond.
His eyes drag over your face, slow, searching.
Not landing.
Not recognizing.
Your chest tightens painfully.
âItâs me,â you try again. âYouâre okay. We just need to get you back to the mansion.â
A pause.
âYou followed me.â
His voice is quiet.
Flat and wrong.
You swallow hard.
âI came to find you.â
A small, humorless sound leaves him.
âI knew you would.â
Something cold slides down your spine.
âTobyâŚâ
He takes a step closer.
You fight every instinct telling you to step back.
âI needed you alone,â he continues, almost to himself. âSomewhere you couldnât hide behind him.â
Your pulse stutters.
Behind him?
No.
Not him.
Her.
You understand.
Your mouth goes dry.
âToby,â you say carefully, grounding your voice the way you always do, âyouâre not seeing things clearly right now.â
His grip tightens on the hatchet.
âI see you perfectly.â
âNo,â you whisper. âYou donât.â
His head tilts again.
And this time, thereâs recognition.
But something is still off.
âNatalie.â
The name hits like a physical blow.
You shake your head immediately.
âNo. No, itâs me.â
âYou donât get to do that,â he snaps, sudden and sharp. âYou donât get to wear her face and pretend I wonât notice.â
Your breath stutters.
âIâm not pretending,â you say, voice breaking despite your effort to stay steady. âToby, listen to me. Itâs me. You know me.â
He steps closer.
Too close.
âYouâve been following us,â he says, voice low, unraveling at the edges. âWatching. Waiting.â
âThatâs notââ
âIâm done letting you ruin this.â
The words land heavy.
Final.
Your heart starts to race.
âToby,â you say, more urgently now, âyouâre sick. Youâre not thinking straight. You need to come back with me.â
He laughs.
Itâs hollow.
âYou think I donât know that?â
Your throat tightens.
âThen you know this isnât real.â
His eyes snap to yours.
Sharp.
Dangerous.
âNo,â he says quietly. âThis is the only thing that is.â
The forest feels tighter.
Closer.
The trees seem to lean in, as if they are waiting to see what happens next.
You take a slow step toward him.
âIâm not your enemy.â
âYes,â he says immediately. âYou are.â
âNo,â you insist, voice trembling now. âYou know me. You trust me.â
âI trusted you,â he corrects.
Your chest cracks.
âToby, pleaseââ
âYou donât get to say my name like that. Not anymore.â
His voice rises.
Fractures.
âYou donât get to sound like her.â
Your vision blurs.
âI am her,â you say, desperate now. âIâm right here. I never left you.â
For a split second, he hesitates.
Just a second, and hope sparks, fragile and fleeting.
Then his expression hardens.
âNo,â he says again.
The word is final.
You understand then, there is no reaching him.
Not like this. Not here.
You take another step anyway.
âIâm not going to hurt you,â you say softly.
He moves faster than you expect.
One step forward.
Hatchet lifting.
Instinct screams at you to defend yourself.
To move.
To fight.
To do anything.
You donât.
Not fast enough.
Not hard enough.
âTobyâwaitââ
The swing is clean.
Efficient and practiced.
The blade bites deep. The impact knocks the breath from your lungs before the pain registers.
A moment later pain explodes through you, sudden and blinding.
A sound tears out of your throat.
Not controlled.
Not steady.
A plea.
âTobyâpleaseâ!â
Your legs give out.
You hit the ground hard, breath knocked from your lungs as warmth spreads too quickly beneath you.
Heâs above you.
Breathing hard, shaking. But he doesnât stop.
You reach for him. You just want to stop him, to hold him.
âIâItâs me,â you choke, voice wet, breaking apart. âPleaseâlook at meââ
His eyes flicker.
For a second, something shifts.
But itâs too late.
The second strike comes down fast.
Everything goes quiet.
â
The forest stills.
The static fades.
And Toby stands there, chest heaving, staring down at the body at his feet.
For a moment, there is nothing.
No voices.
No distortion.
No confusion.
Just silence.
Then, clarity.
It comes slowly.
Painfully.
Like something forcing its way back into place.
His grip loosens on the hatchet.
It slips from his fingers and hits the ground with a dull thud.
ââŚwhatâŚâ
His voice barely exists.
His gaze drags over the body again.
The blood.
The familiar shape on the ground.
The hand still half-reached toward him.
Recognition hits all at once.
Violent and absolute.
âNo.â
The word breaks out of him.
He stumbles back.
âNoâno, noââ
His hands come up, dragging through his hair, leaving streaks of red behind.
âThatâs notââ
His breathing turns ragged.
Unsteady.
âI didnâtââ
But he did.
He knows he did.
And thereâs no undoing it.
â
By the time he makes it back to the mansion, heâs barely holding himself together.
The static in his head has eased, but there is still a throbbing in his temples.
Blood covers him.
His hands.
His clothes.
His face.
Itâs drying in places.
Still wet in others.
The front door creaks open.
Inside, the house is quiet.
Waiting.
Eyeless Jack is the first to see him.
He goes still.
Head tilting slightly.
He smells it immediately.
Blood.
Fresh.
Familiar.
But he says nothing.
Just watches.
Footsteps echo from deeper in the house.
Masky appears next, expression tightening the second he sees Toby.
âWhat happened?â
Toby doesnât answer.
He canât.
Tim steps closer, eyes scanning him quickly.
âWhereâs your girl?â
The question doesnât land.
Not at first.
Toby blinks at him.
Confused.
ââŚwhat?â
âReader,â Tim repeats, sharper now. âDid she find you?â
Tobyâs brow furrows.
âShe⌠she should be here.â
The words feel wrong even as he says them.
Behind Tim, movement.
Jeff leans into the doorway, grin already forming.
âWell, look who dragged himself backââ
He stops.
Eyes flicking over the blood.
ââŚdamn.â
Then, casually,
âWhereâs your girl?â
The question hits harder this time.
Tobyâs chest tightens.
âSheââ
He stops.
Something doesnât line up.
Something is wrong.
Footsteps behind Jeff.
And then,
Clockwork steps into view.
Alive.
Unharmed.
Watching him.
Toby goes completely still.
His entire world tilts.
âNo.â
The word slips out before he can stop it.
Clockworkâs brow furrows slightly.
âWhat?â
His gaze locks onto her.
Unblinking.
âYouââ
His voice breaks.
âYouâre supposed to beââ
Dead.
The word never makes it out.
But it doesnât need to.
Because now, now he understands.
The blood.
The woods.
The face he saw.
The name he called.
The way you looked at him.
The way you begged.
The way you called his name.
His stomach drops out from under him.
And for the first time since the sickness began,
Toby sees clearly.
And all he can see is your blood on his hands.













