Nope

• when you told him after pulling him alone for five minutes he almost dropped his teacup.

• like you could physically see the information running through him.

•…you’re staying?

• he begins to panic, his face going red as he asks you if this is due to your worries of Crowleys incompetence and you’re just settling here!

• but once you reassure him that yeah. Staying here is what you want…he genuinely doesn’t know what to say.

• I mean, he knows people are able to live lives here without magic but after all you’ve been through. The fact that you have no records and it will truly be a big curve to being able to exist here worries him

• he almost forgets about the unbirthday as he begins to drag you off to help you get your affairs in order so you can live an easier life

• you can see though once you get back to the party he’s over the moon. You were ultimately one of the people who snapped him out of his miserable state and let him finally help himself

• you are truly a part of their world and he’s so happy he never has to let you go

• okay so like. When he screamed and woke up grim that’s not his fault! He never expected you to stay!

• I mean c’mon. He forgot you aren’t from this world but everytime he was reminded he was convinced you’d leave one day. He only pushed it down because it was too hard an idea to deal with

• so when you tell him you really are staying he’s so in shock.

• he actually punched himself because he genuinely thought this was a dream. But once he saw it was real he started laughing and hugging you

• while in his dream you could still go home knowing that you JUST wanted to stay here with him made him elated.

• you had told him when you were walking back with him to his dorm from a track club meeting of his.

• he started choking on his water to the pint he has to lean on a tree-

• once he finally calms down he immediately begins asking you a million questions a second like if you’re sure , if you’re really happy here, what are you gonna do when you leave?! Do you need a place to stay? His house has a spare home! His mum loves you you’re always welcome!

• and once again when FINALLY he catches his breath and you reassure him on your decision and plans he bursts into tears as he hugs you so damn tight

• you’re one of his first friends ever when he turned his life around. You helped him stay at night Raven college.

• you became such a fixture in his life that honestly he’s relived he never has to learn what’s it like when you’re permanently not around

• though I do warn. You better tell the others quickly because he will accidentally mention it at least twice the next day

• His mask fell like a ton of bricks.

• like immediately looked you dead in the eyes with a blank face as he asked you to repeat yourself.

• so when you do you seek the real Cater, a smile that truly reaches his his eyes forms as he throws around his arms to hug you, his phone forgotten strewed across the floor. He’s so relived he doesn’t have to say goodbye to you

• even if he has other people losing another to the normalities and changes of life as his normal he doesn’t want that anymore y’know??

• once you both calm down from the joy he asks if he can post a little photo celebrating it. He adds a funny little cryptic caption so you can have the thunder of letting others know you’re staying

• you had told him in the middle of a baking session he had invited you too! He had been inviting you around to help out a lot lately because for some reason he had this deep gut feeling something was up.

• not a bad something was up but just that something was going to happen.

• so when you mentioned it casually to him as he was busy in a particularly difficult part of making the pastries he only froze for a seconds before smiling and telling you “you sure? You’ve seen how bad it can get.”

• but once you reassure him that you wanna stay he just nods continuing the baking

“I mean I guess you have lived through the worst of it. You’re already prepared.”

• but once it’s all in the oven and he’s able to move freely he crushed you in a hug not even caring about the muck on you both.