Honestly, what am I doing here?

What if Toadles is the reincarnation of Conley Murdock? First, Toadles bonded with Tadg and not the other way around. Second, Toadles is an undiscovered beast meaning he could be new (Not to mention in TWT paperback page 76 Ulick said that he lived in the Sea his whole life and had not seen a beast like Toadles before shows that Toadles is a new beast). Third, he bonded with Tadg at Conley's house which was also Tadg's. Fourth, he isn't any other beast as he can come out of his mark without being summoned. Fifth, he can feel Tadg's feelings (TES hardcover page 238). Tadg says that he thinks Toadles can read his thoughts and he always leaves his mark when Tadg feels angry or annoyed or something. What do y'all think?