Aria Is A

(Not in any particular order)

1. CeCe claims that she wasn’t the one to talk to Melissa (even though she told Emily that she talked to her to get the tapes and we saw a flashback) and that it was Bethany. So how is Melissa and Bethany talking if they don’t know each other and how did Jason know what Bethany looked like to mistake her for being CeCe? 2. The rooftop incident is one of the biggest plot holes from 6x10. First of all, why would a institution let patients on a rooftop WITHOUT supervision? No hospital does that. And how is Charles 12 years old when Marion died in 2007? yes I know you wanna kiss me. 3. Why did it say “prom queen” in the yearbook if cece didn’t go to school at rosewood high? Just sit on down so we can take your picture even though you don’t go to school here. 4. What was the point of bringing up that Mrs. D and Mr. Young (Bethany’s dad) had an affair if it’s never not going to be addressed again? Further more, who the fuck are Bethany’s parents and why did Mrs. D tell Bethany to call her “aunt Jessie”? Also we didn’t see Bethany’s face only when she was a child… 5. What does Sara Harvey have against Hanna? I recall seeing redcoat burning Hanna’s doll head off… 6. How did CeCe become an expert in the medical field? 7. Apparently CeCe found out that Ali was alive in 3x24 but yet weren’t Noel and CeCe helping Alison the whole time? I can’t remember if it was an assumption since Ali helped CeCe escape to Paris and we assumed it was because Cece helped Ali stay in hiding, too. So if someone can explain that to me that would be great. 8. Marlene confirmed in via interview that CeCe buried Mrs D so CeCe is just going to send a video of burying her mom and send it Alison even though she claimed that she loved her? but now we’re being told that Mary might been the one to bury her…. well what the fuck. 9. What the fuck happened to Eddie lamb? 10. Why did A need a tux rental if it was CeCe and Sara? 11. So did CeCe turn herself in at the end of 4x23? Or did someone else turn her in? It’s a plot hole until explained. 12. Why would CeCe dress as a male in the dollhouse if she identifies herself as female now? Also that was a MAN not a woman. 13. In 6x06 Mona said that Leslie said that two patients snuck out that night CHARLES and Bethany, who the fuck is Charles? That would’ve been Charlotte by then. 14. Why did Barry help CeCe escape? 15. If Jessica was protecting CeCe, then why bother telling the girls that she didn’t want Ali and CeCe spending time together. If she was protecting CeCe, why cast any suspicious light on her at all? 16. Why didn’t Mrs. D show any emotion to CeCe being arrested? She just glared at her. 17. If she was a patient at Radley while attending U Penn, then how in the hell did she have a room mate when she went to U Penn? If the room mate was just a person she hired, then why have her tell the girls that she blamed them and Ali for her getting kicked out of U Penn. 18. Why did Wren make CeCe a visitors badge if she was already a patient? 19. How was CeCe allowed to go to cape may if she was in radley? They’re not going to let you out for summer trips…. 20. Spencer said she felt something familiar about the guy in the dollhouse, now before y'all say that it’s because CeCe and Spencer are sisters, this wasn’t planned back then and CeCe and Spencer barely had any interaction with each other. So how is the person going to feel familiar to you if you barely know them? 21. “One of you have been touch by the one Alison fears the most.” We can all assume that it was because Aria touched CeCe when she was about to fall in 4x12 but Alison never feared CeCe and I just don’t think so…. 22. Why are the girls irrelevant to the mystery and are just being tortured for fun? 23. Why was Mary at the blind school in 7x10? 24. Who was the blond girl in the window of Alison’s bedroom in 1x01? 25. When and where did CeCe and Sara meet? 26. Why did Sara help CeCe and what were her motives? 27. Marlene confirmed in via interview that Ian killed himself, okay why? 28. What was Alison talking about in 4x24 that she saw Ian walk out of the church after pushing him off? I recall Ian looking colorless on that rope…. 29. Who was the person in 5x03 that was behind the glass with Mona while Hanna is getting her hair done? 30. Who was the person in the black cap talking to Melissa on the security footage in 5x07? 31. Why would CeCe frame her sister for murder if she loved her so much? 32. Why would CeCe toss her fucking brother down an elevator shaft? “Oh Charlotte was angry.” Confirmed in via interview. um okay we need better answers than that marlene…. 33. Who was the blond girl at the reptile place in 4x20? With our luck they’re probably going to say it was Sara… 34. Who exactly knew that Alison was alive? Because it seemed like a lot of people knew…. 35. Who dug up Alison’s grave? Who exactly was there that night? You could say it was CeCe but it never came out of her mouth that she did it. 36. How did Maya die? Is she really dead? Why didn’t we get any closure? Lyndon was the one who supposedly killed her but yet he had no relevance to the story… and he didn’t even confirm that he killed her. “What do you think?” Isn’t confirmation. 37. Was Melissa really the other queen of hearts? We didn’t see her. 38. Who gave Ali the bloody lip? 39. Why was Noel helping CeCe in the dollhouse? What did CeCe have on him? 40. What did Alison have on Noel? 41. What is Melissa’s significance to the story? Why did Melissa take that photo of Wilden, Alison, and CeCe on the boat at cape may? 42. Why didn’t Eddie and Wren not like each other that much? “The minute that guy got here it wasn’t for the right reasons.” well what the fuck. 43. Who did Mona, Jenna, and Sydney meet at the park in 5x05? 44. Who was Wren talking to on the phone in 4x10? Why did he want 45. Was Bethany really the one who was writing to Alison or was it it CeCe? 46. Marlene said black widow was Endgame so is Sara Harvey endgame? 47. Why did Melissa want the NAT club videos so bad? 48. What were on the NAT club videos and what happened to them? 49. WHAT HAPPENED TO VARJACK? 50. What happened to Cyrus? 51. Why were 3 people wearing yellow tops that night? 52. What did Maya know? That Nate was in town? Because Nate isn’t relevant to the story 53. Why did Jason have a stab wound on his side? 54. Who did Aria stab with the screwdriver? 55. Marlene confirmed in via interview that Wilden was acting alone but yet we heard two voices talking? 56. Who did Spencer hear scream in 1x01? 57. Who was the person in the black hoodie that Mona gave the pills to in 3x13? 58. Who hit Toby over the head that night and planted that lighter? 59. Jenna said that Wilden saw Alison that night, how come Alison never mentioned this when she came back? Was Jenna lying? 60. Why were Melissa and Ian in such a rush to get married? What did they need the alibi for? 61. What blond girl was Dr. Palmer talking about? 62. Why are there two different versions of the kissing rock video? 63. Who the fuck is Dr. Sullivan’s son? Mona was apparently threatening him in 2x25. 64. Why was Andrew being adopted brought up in the first place if it’s just going to be dropped? 65. Why were Jenna and Shana afraid of Melissa? 66. Why does 214 keep being brought up and what’s the significance of it? 67. Since it has been “confirmed” that Noel pushed the girl down the steps at the frat party, why did cece’s roommate say that Alison was the one to push the girl down the steps which resulted in getting cece kicked out? 68. What did Jenna give Shana at the park in 2x24? “You know what you have to do.” What did she have to do? 69. Who did Jason give the 50,000 dollars to? And what kind of information did they give him in order for him to give them the money? 70. Why did Mona tell Wren “that’s before I knew where your loyalties lie.”? 71. Who attacked Alison on Halloween? We were led to believe that it was Lucas but it was never confirmed. 72. Who opened the door to that creepy house in 2x13? And why was there a radley car outside of the house? 73. What was the significance of the ghost girl and how come only Ashley saw her? 74. Who was the person in the redcoat Wren was coloring in? 75. What led Ezra to believe that Mrs. D was A? 76. What happened at Ali’s house when Alison came over to Spencer’s house crying? 77. Who was that little boy at the doll shop referring to when he said “a man and woman with dark hair.”? 78. Why did Mike have 18,000 dollars in his bank account? 79. So Shana’s death was just forgotten about? Will anybody ever find out about it? 80. Where was Jason when he was suppose to be at rehab? 81. Did Cyrus really cut Alison’s leg? And if not where did it come from? 82. Why would Alison take pictures of Aria while sleeping? 83. Why did Melissa and Alison have masks made of themselves? 84. Who did Alison get in the car with outside of hectors? 85. Why did Alison need money from hector so bad? 86. What did the lawyer in 5x22 tell Ezra? He basically said that “If you don’t tell me then you can tell the police.” but yet he came out and said he wouldn’t tell him anything? What? 87. Who set up the A extravaganza bullshit at the park in 5x01? 88. Who was the guy that knew Emily’s name? 89. What was up with the bloody bandages in Jason’s trash? 90. Why was Holbrook kissing Alison at the ice ball? 91. Why was CeCe on Ezra’s payroll? 92. Why was CeCe eavesdropping on Aria and Ezra in 4x11? Yeah she’s A but for what purpose was she eavesdropping on them for? 93. What the fuck happened to Pepe and Tippy? 94. Why was Alison blackmailing people for money if she wasn’t planning on running away? 95. Who was Ali’s friends boyfriend that pulled the gun on her? 96. How is CeCe hanging out at a pub where Ezra and Ali met if she was suppose to be at radley? 97. What was Grunwald talking about when she said “Each one hated the other because each one feared the other because each one knew something about the other.”? 98. Who was hiding upstairs in the dilaurentis house? 99. Who was living under the crawlspace at the dilaurentis house? Was it Sara or CeCe? 100. Who was Bethany talking about on the tapes? 101. Why are there quotation marks around the word “Dr.” Kingston on the police board? 102. How did Alison’s ‘Jenna Thing’ bracelet get on Bethany’s body if she left it with Mona at the Lost Woods Resort? 103. What is the ‘plan’ Bethany is talking about on the tape? 104. Was the story Mona told Spencer about her seeing Alison as Vivian in Brookhaven in 2x25 true? Or did she just make it up? If it was true, who was Alison watching? 105. What was on page 5 of Alison’s autopsy report? 106. Who took the photo of Alison and the Liars in 4x13 that was given to Holbrook? 107. Who took the photograph of Alison with Spencer’s shadow in the background the night she disappeared? 108. Is Alison’s ghost story about the twins real? If so, who are the twins? 109. Why would CeCe let the Liars think Ali was A? She said she was mad at the liars for being glad that Ali was dead, but she actively let them hate her. 110. Why did Bethany have Melissa’s riding helmet? 111. Why did Melissa say she saw Toby in London when she didn’t? 112. Why did Wren misspell the word “diagnosis”? 113. What happened to Toby’s file and why was it important? 114. How did Wren know what Melissa and Spencer were talking about in 1x01 if he was in the barn and wasn’t present? Eavesdropping? 115. How did the moms get out of the basement? 116. Why was Alison threatening Spencer to tell Melissa the truth about Ian? She worded it as almost if someone else was going to plan on telling Melissa.. and why does it matter to Alison? 117. “Once she finds out the truth about you she’ll hate you.” What’s the truth about Toby? 118. Why was Toby in the girls locker room when Emily and Ben were in there? 119. Since the girls were blocking all unknown numbers, why was Wren’s number blocked when Wren tried calling Spencer? Wouldn’t Wren’s contact information be on Spencer’s phone since she tried to get in contact with him to tell Melissa the truth? 120. Why was Wren pretending to be drunk when he broke into Spencer’s house? 121. Who recorded Wren and Spencer and what happened to it? 122. How did Toby become a cop in 3 days? 123. Who was the fortune teller talking about when she said “There’s darkness in him maybe even violence or vengeance.”? She could’ve been talking about anyone…. 124. Why wasn’t Ian shocked to see Alison when she pushed him off the bell tower? He’s like “What are you doing here?” Did Ian know she was alive? 125. Mona sent a text saying “Thanks for getting Toby out of my way.” What the fuck was Toby in her way for? 126. Why weren’t Ali’s parents at the memorial service? 127. When Ian and Melissa went on their honeymoon they send a picture and Spencer says “isn’t that outside of dads office?” And Veronica says “Oh it doesn’t where they are when they’re in love.” so where did they go on their fucking honeymoon? 128. When exactly did Melissa loose her baby? Was Ian really the father? 129. Why did Mrs. D hire a PI if she didn’t want anyone to find out who hit Alison and that she buried her? 130. How did Toby’s sweater get back in his house? 131. Ian said “I’m doing this because I love your sister.” when trying to push Spencer off the bell tower but yet Melissa has been protecting Spencer all this time? So it doesn’t make any sense? 132. How come Mona didn’t know who pushed Ian off of the bell tower? A is suppose to know everything.. 133. Who cleared out Mona’s lair the day after she got revealed? CeCe couldn’t have done it. 134. Why didn’t nobody notice that Mona left for awhile to go hit Hanna with the car? Further more, all Hanna saw was Ezra and Aria making out and Noel writing on the back of the window so how did Hanna know “everything” like it was said in that text? She didn’t know shit…. 135. Who was Melissa talking to when Byron saw her on the phone where she says “do I have to call 911 to get your attention.”? 136. Charles liked vintage things and this was said by Jessica, but yet why did CeCe have a red convertible car in 3x09 that looked NOTHING like a vintage car? 137. A has OCD and likes everything neat especially their black hoodies so why did CeCe have her books all over the place in her room at radley? They didn’t seem organized to me…. 138. Who was the lady in the red dress at the ball in 2x25? The camera kept focusing on her. 139. Who was the person that was wearing the black veil costume in the A mobile lair? Sara Harvey did not have a mask on when she came out of the church and got in the car with CeCe.. 140. Who got Wilden’s car out of the lake? Because I recall CeCe being at the lost woods and so was Sara.. 141. What did Spencer put in Alison’s casket? We learned about what everyone else put in there except for her. 142. What’s with all the apple references? 143. Who was the person in the greenhouse that attacked Emily? If it was Mona, then how would she have thrown Emily across the greenhouse if Emily is bigger than her? 144. Who set the fire at Jason’s when Hanna pulled out Jenna? Never confirmed if it was Mona. 145. Why was (supposedly) CeCe stroking herself on the computer screen in the Halloween store? (Was in Pretty Dirty Secrets) 146. Marlene confirmed on twitter that the bag Ian gave Jenna in season one had her flute in it….. why was Ian giving Jenna her flute? Why did he have it? 147. Who was Jason talking to on the phone in Pretty Dirty Secrets? 148. What the fuck happened to Meredith? We never heard from her again. 149. Who was the beach hottie? (Never confirmed but Marlene said she “thought” it was Wilden in an interview but I’m not taking that as confirmation when she doesn’t remember shit) 150. Who was the person in the redcoat at the Halloween store in Pretty Dirty Secrets? 151. Why was Jason staring at Lucas when they were on the Halloween train? Was it like a group thing to push Aria off? Like what the fuck. 152. Who was taking pictures for Ezra’s research? 153. Who smashed Connor’s car? 154. Were Alison’s visits to Spencer and Aria real? 155. What was the “prior engagement” Alison had to go to after leaving Emily’s house the day she disappeared? 156. How did Ali get Jason cut from their grandma’s will? 157. Why did Garret want to keep Spencer safe? 158. What else was in Ezra’s “research” boxes? 159. Why did Jenna wanna become friends with CeCe if she tried to drown her? 160. Why did Eddie Lamb recognize Aria? 161. Is Ezra really board shorts? That was never confirmed. 162. Who gave Emily the massage? Because according to Lucas, he didn’t start working for Mona until the ball in 2x25. 163. What was purpose of “Walking After Midnight”? 164. How did Mona end up in possession of Toby’s sweater, considering Alison did not have the sweater when Mona took Alison to the Lost Woods Resort that night? 165. Whose blood was on Toby’s sweater? 166. When Spencer was a person of interest in Alison’s murder, Veronica appears to trust that Spencer had nothing to do with Alison’s murder. However, in season four, Veronica tells Spencer to forget about that summer because she thought Spencer could have done something to Alison’s disappearance, based on how erratic Spencer was acting that summer. So why wasn’t Veronica more suspicious of Spencer when there was actually incriminating evidence against Spencer? 167. Considering Mona was the only “A” at the time, that would mean she was the one who got the picture of Alison leaving the hospital visiting Hanna. So does this mean that Mona knew Alison was sometimes roaming around Rosewood all the way back in season 1? 168. Who sent Alison the note saying “Your friends will see you soon” while she was in jail? 169. How long had A been planning/building the dollhouse? 170. Why didn’t Mona look shocked seeing Alison walking down the road when she got hit considering Mona thought she killed her? All of a sudden she realized in 6x10 that she killed Bethany? What? 171. Why did Leslie hate Bethany? 172. How does the hockey stick come in to play if Spencer was seen with a shovel and Ali was hit with a rock? 173. Did Mrs. Grunwald really save Alison or did she save Bethany? 174. Why was Holden at the Kahn parties? What is Holden’s relevance? 175. Did Alison really lure Bethany to her house for Labor Day weekend or was someone contacting Bethany by pretending to be Alison? 176. Why aren’t the girls asking Alison questions or asking Ezra any questions since he’s got a bunch of important shit in his research? 177. Who did Nigel Wright call in New York City? 178. Since Sara Harvey is black veil, why was she delivering flowers to Bethany’s parents? 179. Who was the blond girl Ezra yelled at? 180. What was the original plan between Mona & Red Coat the night of the fire? (“you’re getting what you’ve always wanted”) 181. What was Garrett & Jason’s convo about on Jason’s porch? (Garret: “want to make sure we’re still cool Jason.” - Jason: “What does it matter now, it’s over.”) 182. Who’s blood is on Alison’s Ankle Bracelet? 183. Since it was “confirmed” in VIA INTERVIEW by Marlene that Shana was on the rooftop, why did it look like a fucking guy? 184. Who actually drugged Emily the night that the grave was dug up? Was it really Lucas? 185. Why were Lucas and Melissa told to distract Jenna at the Masquerade ball? 186. If Maya was already supposed to be dead how did she give Jason Ali’s belongings? 187. WHY ISN’T IAN’S SUICIDE BEING INVESTIGATED? 188. Beyond the Maya knew message is there more significants to Mona saying “miss Aria your a killer not Ezra’s wife”? 189. Why was Jenna at the Halloween store in a queen of hearts costume? 190. Why was Noel at the Halloween store fighting with Garret? 191. Other than Ali’s flashback, is there more to the importance of the isle of the dead painting? 192. Why was Toby driving the same car when he was trying to run down Lucas that Cyrus has? 193. What 2 things did Mona not do in season 1? 194. Why was Shana in ravenswood? 195. Why was Ezra’s lair in ravenswood? 196. Which friends cabin was it that ezra and Aria were staying at? 197. What ever happened to Ali’s grandmother and her will? 198. Did Garrett know Ali was alive because he said “people lie medical records don’t”? Or what was he talking about? 199. Where was Alison during those years when we thought she was dead? 200. What was the connection between Maya, Jenna, and Noel? 201. Why was Spencer attacked on the train and by who? 202. Who else was on the Halloween train? 203. What were “Spencer” and Wren arguing about in 7x15? 204. Why were Jenna and Sydney dressed like twins? 205. Did Noel really kill Sara like Jenna said? How are we suppose to believe her like Marlene SAID ON TWITTER if she’s working for AD? 206. Who was the person that had the British accent that called Hanna in 7x06? 207. What is Uber’s A motives? Are they like CeCe’s motives where she was just doing it for fun?

I have a lot of problems with this “attack.” First of all, it doesn’t make any sense. A.D. just confirmed that they know Alison didn’t kill Charlotte, that they have nothing against her. Why would they turn around and attack her out of nowhere? That’s totally inconsistent with their motive. 

And second of all, there’s a lot of weirdness going on here. It’s weird that she didn’t notice the obvious mask on the cop, or wonder why he didn’t speak to her once. It’s weird that he managed to get into her room and write that message so quickly. It’s weird that he attacked her so brutally but left only a small cut above her eye. It’s weird that she has an explanation for that ready to go immediately - he must have heard the sirens and run off. Finally, it’s weird that this scene so directly parallels the attack in 2x13, which was meant to be a set-up just to freak out the Liars. Is what happened here real…or was this yet another one of Ali’s tricks to get sympathy and build a certain narrative that she wants her friends to believe?

Notice the box beside the table in the lair of the person who attacked Alison. “Letters from A.D.” Unless the initials stand for someone that our stalker knows, this directly implies that whoever was disguised as that police officer is not, in fact, A.D.

(This post is basically for me to look back at - started 24/03/2017)

I know I don’t have one solid prediction but hey ho there’s too many to choose from

I also want to look back so I can see which questions got answered (I’m aware most small ones won’t get covered)

A.D predictions

Melissa Spencer’s twin Aria or Aria twin Bethany Young is a twin of either Melissa, Spencer or Aria

A team predictions-

Wren is related to either A.D, Bethany, Aria or Rollins & is helping them

PLL questions - This is in no specific order 

Why did Eddie recognise Aria? 

Why did Eddie choose to give Ezra the drawing out of everybody? 

 What did the Bethany drawings mean?  

Why was Wren drawing a lady in red? 

Why did Ali/Jason have photos of Aria What do the NAT videos mean?  

 Are there any significant ones we haven’t seen? Did Ian really kill himself?  

Is Maya really dead? 

Who is in the barrel?

 Is Eddie Lamb dead? 

 Is Wren a real doctor? 

Who did Wren call when he said he’s sorted his end?  

 Does Mona know more than she’s told?  

Who killed Marion? 

Was Charlotte’s story genuine? (serious plot holes) 

 Who was in the Dilaurentis house with a knife when Hanna and Spencer were looking for proof about Alison killing Bethany? 

 Who did Spencer text in season 7 episode 1 asking how they knew Hanna was alive?

Was Hanna hallucinating Spencer when she was captured? 

 Did Alison actually invite Bethany to labour day or was that Charlotte?  

How did Cece get messages to Alison in jail? 

Who are the voices on the satnav when Alison is directed to the dollhouse?

If we hear Bethany talk in future will they use the voice from the tapes in Radley?