In response to anon explaining how they use AI instead of a beta reader to teach them how to write:
I appreciate that you’re emphasising that AI isn’t something to be simply trusted, nor that it should be given any kind of writing. However, from the point of perspective of someone who writes essays on their stories explaining in detail how/why I made which writing choices, with the explicit goal to help others understand how I put a story together, it’s quite crushing to read that you’d rather go and ask AI to teach you how to do that.
I don’t mean to offend; I’m just letting you know that it feels very, very personal and hurtful. Because I know full well that AI can teach you that because I and many, many other authors have taken the time and effort to explain how our writing works and how we decide what to keep, what to cut, what to tidy up and what to expand. And our work has been scraped and used without giving us any credit, so you can ask AI how to teach you the same things that we have spent hours upon hours trying to explain to the best of our ability. Essays and guides you could have found with a simple search, no AI required, in a day and age where search engines tend to be very good and every good bookshop and library will have guides on writing.
Because that’s the other side here. I have spent many, many years trying to get to this point, have worked with beta readers, have read books (like The Art of War for Writers) and essays on the internet, have read books myself and made notes of what I liked about a specific author’s writing style. I have notebooks full of quotes from my favourite books and random funny, thoughtful, interesting and otherwise memorable statements people have made in my vicinity, that I have noted down since I was about 13 and pick up when I get stuck, just to leaf through and see if anything jumps out at me. Very often something does.
By the by, I, too, struggle with communication. I have no official diagnosis, but I am somewhere on the spectrum, and I’ve always struggled to understand people around me. Taking the time to observe others, note down what they said, remembering their reactions and then going and putting all of it into a fictional setting, trying to imagine what would have made a character say that, what would have made another react like that – then getting feedback from my beta readers on what I had written, has helped me learn ways how I can improve my communication and interpretation of what others are telling me.
It is profoundly saddening to me to read that your choice is to use AI for all of that. And it’s even more saddening that you seem to believe that AI is giving you the tools that you needed. Because the tools AI is giving you are actually the tools that I and others have been creating for decades.
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with us.