I’ve had this theory in my head for a while, and I think I’m ready to put it into words because the more I look at Oleanna, Gwydion, Enalius, Truth-Teller, Gwyn, and Azriel, the more I wonder if SJM has been quietly building a parallel between two ancient figures and two modern ones.
We know Oleanna was the High Priestess connected to Gwydion. Her role isn't incidental. She is specifically part of the history surrounding one of the most important weapons in the Maasverse.And then there’s Enalius, the ancient Illyrian warrior who wielded Truth-Teller and died defending Ramiel.
Gwydion and Truth-Teller are connected. They are essentially two halves of the same ancient weapon mythology, light and shadow, sword and dagger, one responding to the other.
So why, of all possible character archetypes, did SJM make Gwyn a priestess?
So when I put the pieces beside each other, I can't stop seeing this:
Oleanna
High Priestess
Cauldron
Gwydion
Enalius
Illyrian warrior
Truth-Teller
Ramiel
Gwyn
Priestess
Sangravah/Priestes connections
Valkyrie
Azriel
Illyrian warrior
Truth-Teller
Ramiel
I don't necessarily think Gwyn and Azriel are literal reincarnations of Oleanna and Enalius, but I think they are going to be narrative echoes Because SJM loves repeating patterns while changing the people inside them.
What if Oleanna and Enalius were connected in some way? What if they were even mates? We have absolutely no canon confirmation of that, so this is firmly theory territory, but imagine if the ancient story involved a High Priestess connected to Gwydion and an Illyrian warrior wielding its twin.And then thousands of years later, we get a priestess and an Illyrian warrior carrying the remnants of that same mythology forward.
Gwyn doesn't have to be Oleanna.
Azriel doesn't have to be Enalius.
They could simply be the next iteration of a story that began long before either of them existed. And this is where I find Gwyn's priestesshood particularly interesting.
People sometimes treat Gwyn being a priestess like it’s just a random character detail, but SJM had countless options for Gwyn’s background. She could have made her a Day Court fae, a random citizen of Velaris, a fae from another continent, an Illyrian female—literally anything. Instead, she made her a priestess, specifically giving her a history rooted in Sangravah, the temple where she was raised, and then placed her directly into a story alongside Azriel.
Meanwhile, Azriel isn't just an Illyrian.He's the Illyrian who currently possesses Truth-Teller. The same Truth-Teller associated with Enalius.
The same weapon that has now been explicitly dragged back into the ancient Gwydion mythology in HOFAS.
And then we have the fact that HOFAS complicates the history we've been told about Gwydion in the first place.
We were told Oleanna dipped Gwydion into the Cauldron.
But when we actually see the ancient memory, there are two unidentified figures standing with Fionn when Gwydion is pulled from the Cauldron.
And suddenly I'm wondering if we don't actually know the full story yet.
Because what if the history we've been given is incomplete?
What if Oleanna and Enalius weren't simply two unrelated names buried in ancient history?
What if they were connected to one another, and to the creation, wielding, or protection of these weapons?
And what if Gwyn and Azriel are being positioned as their modern echoes?
The priestess (who is associated with light) and the shadowsinger.
Gwydion and Truth-Teller.
Because if Gwyn's priestesshood, her connection to Sangravah, the Cauldron mythology, Azriel's Truth-Teller, Enalius, and the ancient history of Gwydion are all eventually revealed to be connected...
then Gwyn and Azriel may not just be two characters who happen to meet in the present.
They could be the modern continuation of a story that started thousands of years ago and always destined.
And honestly, fate has been watching them and waiting.....
SJM is not about random coincidences. 👀