Valentine Sugar Cookies, Icing, and Broken Hearts
Summary: "It was Clarissa, clearly wet from the rain pouring outside.
She was dressed up for some event. Probably a date if Amanda had to guess. She wore her favorite pink puffy coat over a white long-sleeved frilly lace dress.
Despite that, Amanda couldnât help but stare at her beautiful friend."
OR: Amanda tests out some recipes on Valentine's Day evening for her coffee shop. Unexpectedly, Clarissa shows up at her doorstep a total mess. They spend some much needed time together, lamenting about their past.
Read on Ao3!
Author's note: Made for Box of ships day 14: Clamanda. Happy Valentines Day!! Event by @secret-from-the-samta
Amanda was experimenting in her kitchen on Valentineâs Day, instead of being on a date.
Itâs not like she doesnât like the holiday. Quite the opposite actually. As a kid, she used to adore giving out and receiving valentine goodies. She would give out customized bracelets to each of her classmates, including Clarissa. To herâeven back thenâClarissa was worth more than a simple bracelet. She was worth the world in fact. She gave roses to her every Valentineâs Day until Clarissa started to have dates with her boyfriends instead.
Amanda was a little bitter about that fact. Of course, Clarissa would get so many lovers. She was wonderful, pretty, and kind. Itâs just that.. Amanda had never had a girlfriend for long enough that they could spend Valentineâs Day together. They were always summer flings that lasted a few weeksâmaybe a month if she was lucky. Something to keep busy and happy. To distract her from the person her heart truly belongs to.
Shame they couldnât distract her on the day she needed it most.
Instead, she turned to her business, Bedazzled Coffee as a distraction. Her pride and joy. Around this time of year, she would experiment and test out valentine-related recipes for the cafe. Some were from previous years that she wanted to make sure still were appealing. Some were brand new ideas she noted down. These recipes ranged from strawberry icing to full blown layered cakes (that was a terrible idea. Theyâre a coffee shop, not a bakery. What was she thinking?)
It was an often occurrence that one of her friends or family members would come and test them out with her. For the first few years, it was Clarissa, but she got busy quickly. Last year, it was her brother, Derek, and his fiance, Titch. It was their only time together in a while since they settled in the U.K. It was the funnest thing sheâd done in decades, but jealousy got the best of her at times. Seeing her brother and his partner flirt and be happy struck her heart. This time no one came because itâs Valentineâs Day on the dot.
She clicked the bowl of batter into place on the mixer, adding red food coloring and vanilla extract every other swirl. She was repeating her strawberry icing recipe for the sugar cookies. The sugar cookies themselves werenât reinvented or anything. She added a few berries to them. The oven timer dinged.
As soon as Amanda got the treats out of the oven, her doorbell rang (in Jingle Bells because god forbid a girl be festive and forgettable). She was hesitant. Who would be out there? It was awfully cold out there. It was probably a kid going door-to-door selling scouts cookies. It didnât hurt to check.
âComing!â She set her tray down and headed towards the door. She fumbled with the knob since her hands were greasy. She should have worn gloves. She managed to open the door to find it wasnât a walking advert or a tired kid.
It was Clarissa, clearly wet from the rain pouring outside.
She was dressed up for some event. Probably a date if Amanda had to guess. She wore her favorite pink puffy coat over a white long-sleeved frilly lace dress. Her high boots were covered in snow which was weird because there was only an inch or two of snow out and that was melting by the moment. She had to have walked here. Her space buns and colorful heart-shaped hair clips were misaligned.
Despite that, Amanda couldnât help but stare at her beautiful friend. Even under the storm clouds, her beauty would always shine through.
âHey.â
Amanda snapped out of her trance with the sound of her voice. Clarissa probably was waiting for her to say something and let her in. For how long? Who knows? âOh my god, youâre soaked! Come in!â she exclaimed, opening the door wider.
Clarissa stepped into the home, taking off her coat and boots. Amanda had hangers and compartments for her since she visited so oftenâor used to. She was immediately overwhelmed by the smell of vanilla and strawberries. âYouâve been baking havenât you?â she commented.
âIndeed.â
She walked further into the home, spotting the mess of the kitchen. Normally people would be a bit put off by the mess, but Amanda knew Clarissa. She smiled instead. It felt nostalgic to be together on a Valentineâs Day after so long. She must have thought the same thing because she said,âAw, I miss doing this with you.â
âGo on then. Taste some.â Amanda beckoned, gesturing to the goods on the tables. She pointed to a pink mug with hearts all around the rim with a big C in the middle of it. Thatâs the matching mug they got for Christmas in their twenties. âThis one over here is a strawberry chocolate latte. I know youâll love it! See it has little hearts at the top!â
Clarissa giggled at the enthusiasm, making her heart flutter. âYeah, Iâll try them. I like the way you decorated them with all of the pink and gold. Itâs so pretty.â
Pink and gold. Their colors. Amanda could close her eyes and imagine that Clarissa was calling her pretty. âThank you. Iâm glad you liked them. I have a few more on that table over there.â She pointed over to the far section of the table, full of smoking hot cups. âThat sectionâs drinks. I mainly focused on mochas this year.â
Clarissa walked over and eyed all of the drinks. She was about to taste what was labeled on the festive mug as, âChocolate Strawberry Mochaâ before Amanda started to speak again, causing her to jolt a little.
âOver there is food. Thereâs some of our classic chocolate dipped cookies that we made together. That one is always a hit with the customers. Remember when we first made that? Back in college?â
Clarissa laughed. The sweet honey of it filled Amandaâs ear. She couldnât help but laugh along too. âWe made a mess all over our dorm.â
âWhen do we not?â
She walked over to another side of the table, eager to move on quickly. Those happy memories were nice, but they made her feel terrible. âHereâs some cheesecake treats! I donât want to sell so many different cheesecake stuff. Itâs pretty bad for demand. You know me. I canât choose between my babies. Iâm sure youâll be the decider on ones that will stay.â
âSomeoneâs gotta make sure your shop doesn't turn into a bakery.â
She hummed, âOf course, of course!â She paused, remembering something. âActually, I have something for you to do,â She headed over to the tray of the cooled cookies, beckoning Clarissa to follow her.
âWould you like to decorate these sugar cookies please? The icing will be done in a minute. Iâm sure you remember how to pipe it, do you?â Clarissa nodded. âThe valentine sprinkles are on the top shelf. Let me know if you canât reach it.â
âCâmon, Iâm not that short, Amanda!â she light-heartedly exclaimed.
âI know you arenât.â
âWhat brings you to my home this evening? Iâm sure you have better things to do than be here,â Amanda said, trying to start up small talk. She was curious though. This situation seemed quite strange.
âIââ Clarissa hesitated. âCanât I visit a friend?â she said with a smile far too wide. Her tone was off. She was faking it.
The brunette hummed. She hoped that she couldnât see her suspicious raised eyebrow from there. âOn Valentineâs Day out of all times? Donât you have a date or something with Mark?â she questioned her.
That seemed to hit a nerve. Her body held itself together tightly like glue barely holding on. âWeââ She squeezed the icing hard, causing it to overflow slightly. âItâs complicated.â she settled on, refusing to elaborate further.
âYou know you can tell me anything.â
Her stiff demeanor softened just a touch. âI know,â she said, her voice lacing with guilt.
âJust wanted to remind you thatâs all.â
She sighed. âI wish you could help,â she said. âThis time it's something bigger than you can help me with, Amanda,â she tried to explain to her stubborn friend. It came off as dismissive and condescending. Was that the intent? Probably not, but Amandaâs heart ached anyway.
Amanda strained a chuckle. She had heard this excuse time and time again recently. It was like Clarissa didnât trust her anymore. She couldnât do anything about it. Back then, she was. Clarissaâs right hand. She got her out of trouble on several occasions. Although, real adult life wasnât playing on the playground. âWell, I can certainly try, honey. I love helping, okay? Thereâs no need to hide anything.â
The blonde stayed quiet for a moment, most likely debating on what to say next. If only she could tell what was going on in that head. She used to be able to predict her next thought, but now, their minds grew apart. âBesides,â Clarissa started, âI wanted to visit you on your favorite holiday.â
âYou could barely count it as a holiday. Iâm working right now, donât you remember? This is all for the cafe. It may be the fun part of work, but work nonetheless,â
âItâs still your favorite and you deserve someone being there for you on it. I always noticed you donât have any girls with you on this day.â âthanks for rubbing salt in the woundâ âYou deserve love. I think youâll get it one day! I want to be with you like youâve been with me throughout my hardships. â
âYou are. You always are, dear.â she reassured her, smiling through her teeth.
She knew she was lying to herself, but she couldnât care any less. Clarissa probably was the source of the majority of her hardships. It wasnât the blonde's fault that she was so pretty Amanda couldnât help herself. She could not be blamed for the misfortune Amanda caused herself. She always had the option to move on from her. She just never did.
She looked into her best friendâs eyes softly. A melancholic reflection looked back at her. âRemember, what we promised when we were little?â she went to hold Clarissaâs hands, but backed away at the last second. âItâs you and me against the world.â
Clarissa hummed, her eyes darting away to the oven.
It certainly felt like the world won the fight, breaking them apart.











