Should I stay or should I go?
Pairing: Daryl Dixon x fem!reader
⥠Main Index | ⥠Archive for Earth-1114
a/n: Requested by @generousbearpersonpsychic as a pt. 2 to The leaver
Classification: Angst with a hint of fluff?
Temporal setting: Season 3-4
Word count: 1,6k
Divider by me ;)
The prison was no longer the hollow, echoing carcass it had once been when you first cleared it, when every footstep ricocheted off concrete and steel like a warning shot, when the silence had felt safer than people ever did. Now it breathed with life, with voices layered over one another in the cellblocks, with the metallic clatter of gates sliding open and shut, with the low murmur of arguments, laughter and crying babies at odd hours of the night and with that life came weight, the kind that settled across your shoulders and refused to be shrugged off.
There were more mouths to feed, more patrols to organize, more weak spots in the fencing to reinforce, more eyes to watch for the Governorâs shadow stretching across the yard and you kept busy because busy meant you didnât have to sit still long enough for your thoughts to circle back to him, to Merle or Daryl, to the choice that had fractured something fragile and ugly between you.Â
Daryl kept busy too, almost violently so, especially after his brotherâs death. He moved like a man who couldnât afford to stop, like if he did the grief might catch up and sink its teeth in.
His pain had softened the sharpest edges of your anger, though not in the way people might expect, because you didnât mourn Merle and you wouldnât lie and say you did, but you mourned the fact that after everything, after all the blood, betrayal and broken trust, the loss still mattered to Daryl, still hollowed him out in ways you could notice in the way he stared too long at nothing and how his hands flexed at his sides when someone mentioned family.Â
That stirred something uncomfortable in you, something older than the prison or the break up. It was a reflex born from people never staying, from learning early that attachment was a luxury that turned into a liability the moment the ground shifted beneath your feet.
Some days were better than others. Some days you could sit in the same car as him on a supply run without the air feeling too thin to breathe and without counting the seconds between words. Some days you didnât veer down a different hallway the second you heard the familiar rhythm of his boots on concrete, didnât force yourself to take the long way back to the cellblock just to avoid the weight of what hung unsaid between you. Other days, you were sharper, colder, convincing yourself that his endless hunts for the Governor werenât born from responsibility or loyalty but from guilt and you resented him for needing redemption you werenât sure you could grant.
It was late when the council gathered in the prison library, the room lit by a handful of lanterns that cast wavering shadows against shelves still half-filled with warped paperbacks and mildewed encyclopedias, the air smelling faintly of dust and oil. You were the last to step inside, closing the heavy door behind you with a quiet click, lingering near it instead of taking a seat, listening to the tail end of Carol and Hershelâs low conversation about dwindling antibiotics and the next rotation of watch shifts, your fingers absently tracing the spine of a book on a nearby desk without seeing the title.
Darylâs voice cut through the room, gravelly and steady from where he sat slouched in an old wooden chair, boots planted wide. âGotta make time to go out there. Do what needs to be done.â
His eyes were mostly on Michonne, who leaned against the wall with her arms crossed, exhaustion etched into the tight line of her mouth. Sheâd been searching just as relentlessly as he had but with Rick stepping back from leadership, she was needed within the walls more than ever and that reality sat heavy on her shoulders.
âI donât know where to look anymore,â she admitted, pushing off the wall just enough to pace a step before settling again. âItâs getting tiring. I donât know if the anger Iâve got left is enough fuel to trump that.â
Silence stretched thin across the room after that, taut as wire. People avoided your gaze almost instinctively, as if the tension between you and Daryl was something physical that could scorch them if they looked at it too directlyâŠeveryone except him. He looked at you without flinching, unafraid.
You and Daryl had always been a good pair outside the walls, efficient, wordless and able to read each otherâs movements without needing explanation, a rhythm that made survival look almost effortless and everyone in that room knew it.
You exhaled slowly and turned toward the door, wrapping your hand around the knob intending to slip out before the conversation tilted any further in your direction but Glennâs softer voice caught the air behind you, calling your name.
âWe need new eyes out there.â Daryl added, quieter now. His gaze was still on you when you turned back despite yourself.
âAnd I needed you,â you said, your voice even but tight around the edges. âAs in past tenseâŠThat trumps what you need, Daryl. Itâs too late.â
Heads lowered almost in unison, shame or discomfort pulling them down, except his. He held your stare like he was bracing for impact.
âIâm not pretending we werenât all hurt by something he did,â you continued, the words measured but edged with steel. âHell, this place is full of his victimsâŠbut Iâm trying to move forward, because a scar canât heal if you keep digging your finger in it.â
The door shut behind you with more force than you intended, the echo reverberating down the hallway and leaving a silence thick enough to choke on.
Inside the library, Darylâs eyes flicked to Carol, one of the only two people who knew even half of what was splintering through your head. Sheâd tried to bridge the distance between you more than once but once you realized that, youâd started guarding your thoughts from her too.
âNeed âer out there,â Daryl said, like it was a fact carved into stone.
âSheâs barely been outside the walls since,â Hershel replied carefully. âWeâre only living in a prison, son, but sheâs making it hers.â
âShe wants to leave,â Glenn blurted before he could stop himself, arms crossing defensively when all eyes snapped to him. âMaggieâŠMaggie thinks thatâs why she wonât go out anymore. Sheâs forcing herself to stay put so she doesnât get the urge to run.â
Daryl rose abruptly, chair legs scraping harsh against the floor and strode out without another word, boots carrying him down the hall with a familiarity that suggested his body knew where youâd retreat long before his mind admitted it.
The administrative wing was dimmer, quieter, the hum of distant voices fading into a low murmur. Light spilled from beneath one half-open door and he paused there for a fraction of a second before pushing it wider with a careful hand.
You stood in front of a large corkboard youâd mounted to the wall weeks ago, a detailed map pinned at its center, edges curling slightly from humidity. Sections were crossed out in thick black lines while others were circled, annotated in your tight handwriting along the margins. A ruler lay on the desk behind you beside a compass and a stack of folded paper, like youâd been measuring distances, calculating something far beyond the walls.
He recognized the crossed-out areas instantly as places he and Michonne had searched for the Governor without success. The circled ones were farther out, more remote.
ââS thaâ where yer planninâ to run off to?â he asked, voice low but not accusing, more tired than anything else.
You didnât turn right away. Your shoulders rose and fell with a slow breath. âIâm not leaving.â
âYa ainât here either,â he shot back, stepping further into the room but stopping short of crowding you. âThey barely see ya.â His hand gestured vaguely toward the cellblock. âI donât see ya at all. âCept I know thaâs on purpose.â
You turned then, finally facing him, eyes rimmed with something that wasnât quite anger anymore but hadnât softened into forgiveness either. âWhat do you want me to do?â you asked. âDo you want me to lie and say Iâm sorry your excuse of a brotherâs dead? That I could hear you crying at night and it broke my heart not to let myself go to you?â
The words hung heavy between you.
His jaw tightened, throat working as he swallowed. âI want ya tâ stay,â he said, voice stripped down to something raw and honest. âBe mad, hate me if ya gotta. JustâŠstay.â
A humorless laugh slipped from you as you shook your head. âDonât do that.â
âDo what?â he asked, hands flexing at his sides, careful not to move closer in case you bolted.
âThat,â you said, pointing at him faintly. âThe soft voiceâŠand the apologetic, deer-caught-in-headlights look like youâre waiting for a sentence to be handed down.â Your voice dropped. âI donât know how to forgive you. I donât know if I already have and if thatâs what this is then I need a better reason to accept it than âbecause Iâm in love with you.ââ
Silence pooled in the room, thick and pressing. He let it stretch, eyes drifting briefly to the map behind you before returning to your face.
âShould figure thaâ out âfore you go,â he said quietly.
You held his gaze. âNeed to find a reason to stay first.â
His shoulders shifted, the smallest nod betraying how much that answer cost him. âWonât have tâ look too far,â he murmured. âBut Iâll get outta the way. Just in case ya wantâŠthe bigger picture.â











