By Jan-Marie Knights
Thanks to Amberley Publishing for gifting me a copy of this for review.
I enjoyed this book on Mary Queen of Scots. It’s different to other books I’ve read on her, it feels a lot more readable because it’s broken down a complex life into smaller and more digestible sections. It’s also well-written and engaging, though some parts feel more detailed than others. Perhaps that is just down to how the book is structured.
This is a really interestingly structured book. It is chronological, but it’s broken down by precise dates, and seems to largely be structured based on letters to and from Mary as to what she knew at what time. This means that we don’t necessarily get the whole picture of what was going on because it is from Mary’s point of view and so much was kept from her or smuggled into the places she was being kept. For example, many of the rebellions and plots using her name are only covered in a minimal way like the Northern Rising and the Throckmorton Plot.
Mary Queen of Scots is a fascinating person, and I got to know quite a bit about her time in England when I was working on my first book ‘Elizabethan Rebellions’, though I didn’t know all that much about her early years in Scotland and France, and then back in Scotland. It was interesting to find out more about her time in France and her relationship with her first husband, Francis II of France, and her mother-in-law, Catherine de Medici. Her time in Scotland and her second marriage was a really complex period and I may need to re-read those sections.
It is difficult to track down precise sources because, although the bibliography is extensive, there aren’t references within the text to point you to where direct quotes have come from, which letters and archives, which would have been hugely beneficial.
I’d really recommend this for anyone who has an interest in Mary Queen of Scots because it is quite easy to read and makes excellent use of primary sources to structure the narrative, even though you can’t easily track them back to the original sources. Mary’s story is often told from an almost English perspective, so it was refreshing to see her story told from her own perspective, and that was the best part for me.












