Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Last week, I shared data showing a 7% drop between the 2020 and 2025 Tolkien Fanfiction Survey data around whether fans consider each othersâ views on the canon when writing fanfiction. The survey contains five items structured this way: âWhen writing fanfiction, I consider ____ views on the canon.â
Iâve always been fascinated by Tolkien fanfiction writers and authority because fan studies wisdom would claim that we disregard traditional authorities over canon* and hand that power to ourselves, and Iâve long argued that Tolkien fans arenât that way. Most of us do put some stock in Tolkienâs authority (and some put quite a bit!)
* "Canon,â when referring to fanfiction, means the texts that writers consider the factual basis of the world they are writing about. Itâs a complicated concept, especially in Tolkien fandom where so much âcanonâ remains unsettled, but itâs important to recognize that its meaning is very different from the usual literary meaning. My article Who Gets to Say? delves into these questions in much more detail.
Curious if the pattern with fan authority was true elsewhere, I ran all five survey items about whose views on the canon writers consider when crafting their stories. The results show decreasing consideration of all sources of authority (though the biggest decrease is still others fansâ authority).
The graph above is a revision of the graph originally presented in âWho Gets to Say?â There is a lot more work to be done before these data can be fully analyzed, but my off-the-cuff explanation is that the across-the-board decrease can be explained by the fandom aging and growing more experienced. We are a fandom that has weathered multiple big media releases, several new books, and years of fandom debates about canon. Perhaps these data show that we are just ⌠cynical about canon by this point? It will be interesting to see how a tendency to reject authority (or different sources of authority) correlates with time in the fandom and other items that may get at the why.
Ironically, I put together this graph to try to avoid a full article this time around about authority, and now I find myself contemplating just that. Itâs dangerous business, Frodo, putting formulas into a spreadsheet âŚ
A friendly reminder that Tolkien Fanfiction Survey data is posted weekly on @tolkien-fanfiction-survey and on the Substack Tolkien by the Numbers.
Warnings â ď¸: Canon typical violence, author attempts elvish, author attempts khuzdul, suggestive content, alcohol consumption, angst, blood, medical care, feelings of despair, themes of hope, found family, multiverse/time travel, cussing, angst, fluff, eventual smut, weapon use, realities of battle, tolkein monster encounters, fish out of water, injury to main characters, long fic, slowburn x reader.
Part 1 | Part 3 - Coming Soon
A/N: looks like our winner was FĂli! This is the continuation of 'Bounce'
Ichor In Erebor
C.2: Sway
You swayed, that was the first sensation, before anything else came back onlineâa slow, rocking sway, side to side, like being cradled in something that had no business being this comfortable. Your head lolled with it. Somewhere very far away, a bird was making a sound you didn't recognise.
"She's been out a long while," said a voice above and slightly behind you, the kind of voice that sounded like it smiled more than it frowned.
"Balin says that's not unusual, given the fall," said a second voice, matching the first in tone but pitched slightly different, close enough that you might've mistaken them for the same person if you'd been listening less carefully. "Though I don't think he actually knows that. I think he's saying it so nobody worries."
"Are you worried?"
"No. Are you?"
"No." A pause. "A little."
FĂli and KĂli, though you had no way of knowing that yet, rode close on either side of the stretcher, close enough that KĂli had taken to resting one forearm across his pony's neck so he could study you properly, the way you might study a puzzle box before deciding which side to open first.
"Look at her clothes," he said, not for the first time. "I've never seen weave like that. So tight and even. Not even elvish work looks like that."
"Maybe she's a merchant's daughter," FĂli offered. "Some far eastern trade route, cloth we've never seen before."
"Merchants' daughters don't fall out of the sky, FĂli."
"No," FĂli conceded. "No, I suppose they don't."
KĂli leaned in slightly, close enough that if you'd been conscious you might have flinched away from him, and studied your face with the frank, unhurried curiosity of someone who had never in his life worried overmuch about being caught staring. "She doesn't look dangerous."
"Ăin didn't look dangerous either, and he threw a stew pot at Dwalin's head last winter."
"That's not the same thing."
"I'm only saying, that you can't always tell from a face."
KĂli considered this with the seriousness it apparently deserved, tilting his head. "No. I suppose not." He glanced ahead to where the stretcher's ropes creaked gently against the pony's flank. "Do you think she'll wake soon?"
"Uncle wants her awake before nightfall. Wants answers."
"Uncle wants everything before nightfall."
FĂli made a sound that might have been a laugh, quickly swallowed, and the two of them lapsed into a companionable quiet that stretched on with the rhythm of hooves on packed earth, the creak of leather, the occasional huffed breath from a pony working uphill.
You didn't hear any of it, not properlyâit reached you the way sound reaches a diver rising slowly from deep water, muffled and warped and without context, fragments that meant nothing because you had no idea yet that you should be listening.
Consciousness came back in pieces, the smell of grass, and was that horse ?âno it couldn't be, not horse, something adjacent to horse but not quiteâwoodsmoke, faint, and beneath all of it something green and sharp that you'd later understand was simply what air smelled like when it hadn't been breathed through a city first.
Then the light. Grey-gold, low-slung, the particular colour of late afternoon when the sun has decided its work is mostly done for the day. It came at you sideways, through slats that you slowly realised were your eyelashes, your eyes not quite willing to commit to opening yet.
The swaying continued, and beneath the swaying, an ache in every part of you that made itself known all at once, a full-body throb that told you, quite unambiguously, that you had recently done something your body had not appreciated.
You opened your eyes, directly above and slightly behind youâyour head was tipped back at an angle you hadn't chosenâwas a pony's tail, swishing with unhurried rhythm, beyond that the broad grey back of an animal you were almost certain wasn't a horse, and above that a figure, tall, robed in something the colour of a stormy sky, a wide-brimmed hat, silver hair catching the light. He rode with his back straight and didn't turn around.
You blinked. Once. Twice.
Okay, said a small, hysterical voice in the back of your mind. Okay. That's. That's a wizard hat. That is objectively a wizard hat, that man is wearing a wizard hat, why is there aâ
"âreckon she has to be from some eastern trade cities," a voice was saying, somewhere to your left, low and rolling and unfamiliar. "Never seen a face quite like it."
"Or further," said another. "There's places even Gandalf hasn't mapped."
Gandalf, you thought, faintly, though the name meant absolutely nothing to you beyond sounding vaguely like a word you should recognise and didn't.
"D'you think she's hungry? She should eat something, when she wakes."
"If she wakes."
"She'll wake," said a third voice, gentler than the others, unhurried, carrying the particular calm of someone used to being listened to. "Give her time. The body knows what it needs, even when the mind's still catching up."
You tried, very carefully, to lift your head, the world tilted alarmingly, righted itself, tilted again, and you became awareâwith the slow, mounting horror of someone piecing together what felt like a crime sceneâthat you were on some kind of stretcher, slung between four ponies, in the middle of what appeared to be a genuinely enormous stretch of open countryside, surrounded by a collection of men on ponies.
Some of them were smallâsmaller than you, smaller than felt entirely possible for fully grown adults, riding with a competence that suggested this was in no way their first time doing so. They had beards. Extravagant beards, braided in places, beads worked into some of them and axes strapped to their backs that looked less like costume pieces and more like they had been recently and to your immediate alarm, enthusiastically used.
One of themâround-faced, dark-haired with a spectacularly warm looking hat, riding just aheadâturned in his saddle and caught you looking.
His face split into a grin so immediate and so entirely without guile that some of the panic in your chest loosened despite yourself.
"Well now," he said, in the same rolling voice from before, "look who's decided to rejoin us."
Cosplay, you thought, with the particular desperate logic of a mind trying very hard to make the world make sense. This isâthis has to be some kind of, of Renaissance fair, or a movie set, orâ
"You gave us a fright, falling out of the sky like that," the man continued, entirely unbothered by your silence, guiding his pony alongside your stretcher with easy familiarity. "Bofur, at your service. WellâBofur's my name. The service part's more of a formality, if I'm honest, but Balin insists on it."
You opened your mouth. Nothing came out except a small, cracked noise that didn't remotely qualify as a word.
"Easy," Bofur said, not unkindly, his grin softening into something more careful. "No rush. You've had a fair old tumble, by the look of things."
Beside him, another figure had drawn nearerâbroader, white-bearded, a face weathered into deep, kindly lines, eyes sharp despite the gentleness of his expression. "Can you tell us your name, lass?" he asked, in the same measured voice you'd heard a moment ago. "Or where you've come from? We mean you no harm, but you gave us quite the puzzle, appearing the way you did."
"Iâ" Your voice came out a rasp, and you tried again, throat working. "I don'tâwhereâ"
"Where are we?" supplied a third voice, gruffer, from somewhere on your other side, and you turned your headâslowly, everything still swimmingâto find a broad, heavily-tattooed figure regarding you with an expression that fell somewhere between suspicion and grudging concern. "Or where are you from. Might help to start with which question you're actually asking."
"Dwalin," said the white-bearded one, with a note of mild reproach, though he didn't look particularly surprised. "The lass has just woken. Give her a moment before you interrogate her."
"I'm asking politely," Dwalin said, in a tone that suggested his understanding of politely was fairly elastic at the best of times.
You closed your eyes briefly, waiting for the world to stop tilting, and when you opened them again, the nausea that had been building somewhere beneath your ribs finally won its argument with the rest of you.
You made it half over the side of the stretcher before you were violently, thoroughly sick.
"Whoaâthere she goesâ" Bofur's voice, scrambling slightly, someone's hand steadying the stretcher's edge so you didn't tip yourself entirely off it.
"That's good," said the white-bearded oneâBalin, you'd apparently missed his name the first timeâwith the placid tone of someone who had clearly seen worse and been considerably less bothered by it. "Better out than in. It's the fall, most like, or whatever manner of magic put you im the sky to begin with. The body doesn't take kindly to that sort of thing."
Magic, your brain echoed faintly, and declined, for the moment, to process the word any further.
You hung there, mortified, spitting to clear your mouth, dimly aware of the fact that you had just thrown up in front of a dozen strangers in medieval cosplay while on a stretcher between ponies, you became painfully aware that this was, objectively, one of the worst morningsâafternoons?âof your entire life.
"Here." A new voice, smaller, closer to your own vague height though you were still lying down so it was hard to judge, apologetic in a way that made you look toward it despite yourself. A face swam into viewâround, kind, faintly harried, curling hair beneath a battered waistcoat. He was holding out a waterskin with both hands, like an offering. "You shouldâhere, drink something. Small sips. That's what they always say, isn't it, small sipsâ"
"Thank you," you managed, and your voice cracked embarrassingly on the second word, but he only smiled, a small, nervous, genuine thing, and helped guide the waterskin to your mouth when your own hands proved too unsteady to manage it.
The water was cool and clean and tasted, faintly, of leather, and you drank like you'd never drunk anything in your life.
"There now," he said. "Better?"
You nodded, throat easing, and it was only as you shifted slightly, trying to find some dignity to reclaim, that your gaze droppedâentirely without your permissionâto his feet.
His bare feet.
Which were, you registered with a rising and entirely involuntary horror, covered in curling hair, and resting with complete unselfconsciousness on the pony's flank as though this were the most normal thing in the world, as though feet were simply meant to exist in public like that, uncovered, hairy, unbothered.
Oh, said the small hysterical voice in your head, oh, absolutely not, do not look at that again, do notâ
You looked at it again.
"âare you quite alright?" the curly-haired one was asking, his brow furrowing with fresh concern at whatever expression had apparently crossed your face.
"Fine," you said, faintly, dragging your eyes back up to somewhere safely around his collarbone. "Totally fine. Just. Great. Awesome, even."
He looked, if anything, more concerned by this answer than he had by your silence.
The company made camp as the light finally gave out entirely, and you watched it happen from a bedroll someone had set for you near the fire, still too wrung out to do much beyond watch, wrapped in a blanket that smelled of horse and woodsmoke and had clearly seen a great many miles.
It happened fast. That was the thing that struck you most, once the initial fog of nausea and disorientation had thinned enough to let you actually observeâthere was no discussion, no delegation, no meeting to decide who did what. Ponies were led and tethered and rubbed down by hands that clearly knew the exact rhythm of it.
A fire sprang up with an efficiency that suggested it had been built a thousand times before by the same handful of people. Pots appeared. Someone was already peeling something. Bedrolls unfurled themselves into rows with the precision of a routine so old it had stopped requiring conscious thought.
Well oiled machine, you thought, hazily, watching a small, rounder gentleman stir something in a pot while somewhere behind him two more were arguing cheerfully about whether the last of the salted pork should go in now or later.
It wasn't long before smoke of a different, sharper sort began drifting through the camp, and you wrinkled your nose despite yourself as several of the dwarves produced long-stemmed pipes, packing them with unhurried care and lighting them from the fire, the smell thick and cloying and entirely unlike any smoke you'd encountered beforeâsweeter, somehow, and heavier, settling low over the camp like a blanket you hadn't asked for.
"Not to your taste?" Bofur asked, dropping down beside you with his own pipe already lit, apparently having clocked your expression from several feet away.
"It's a lot," you admitted, waving a hand vaguely in front of your face.
"Pipeweed. Old Toby, this batchâgood stuff, mind, best you'll find east of the Shire." He said this with the pride of a connoisseur, exhaling a slow curl of smoke that drifted up toward the darkening sky. "You'll get used to it. Or you won't, and you'll just have to sit downwind of us. Either's fine."
You managed something that was almost a laugh, and it seemed to please him, because his grin widened and he settled in a little more comfortably, evidently deciding you were now his particular responsibility for the evening.
"Since you're awake and not casting up your accounts anymore," he said, "might as well get you acquainted properly. Save you having to work it all out on your own." He nodded toward the fire, where the two who'd been riding closest to your stretcher earlier were now engaged in what looked like a minor disagreement over the last of something in a bowl. "That particular hooligan there is KĂli and his brother FĂli. Sister-sons to our esteemed leader, though you'd be forgiven for not seeing the resemblance in temperament."
"They fight like that a lot?"
"No, truth be told, they arent usually far from each other." He considered. "Don't fret, no one's ever actually lost an eye."
He went around the fire with the easy, familiar rhythm of someone who'd clearly done introductions like this before, pointing with the stem of his pipe.
"That's Ăin, and that's his brother GlĂłinâbetween the two of them they've more opinions on fire-safety than any dwarf has strictly earned the right to. Bifur you'll want to watch for hand-signs, he doesn't speak the common tongue on account of an old injury, but he'll make himself understood, don't you worry. That's my cousin Bombur, doing the cooking, best in the company and don't let him tell you otherwise out of false modesty." He winked before continuing.
"Dori, Nori, Oriâbrothers, though good luck telling which is which some days. Balin and Dwalin you've already had the pleasure of." He paused.
"And Thorinâ" a slight shift in his tone, something more careful, more respectful "âleads us. Wherever we happen to be going."
"And where," you said, slowly, "are you going?"
"Ah." Bofur tapped the side of his nose. "That's rather the question, isn't it. All in good time." He took another pull on his pipe. "You're a fair sight more curious than I expected, for someone that fell out of a clear sky into a field full of dwarves. I'll give you that."
"I think I'm still catching up on the frightened part," you admitted.
"Alsoâ" you hesitated, because it felt strange to correct someone who had been nothing but kind to you, but the word had been nagging at something uncomfortable in the back of your mind since he'd said it. "I don't think you're supposed to call yourselves that. Where I'm from, anyway. It's not really aâa nice word."
Bofur blinked at you, genuinely startled, pipe halting halfway to his mouth. "Dwarves?"
"Well, yeah."
"It's what we are, lass." He said it slowly, like he was checking whether you were having him on. "Been dwarves a good deal longer than you've been wherever it is you're from, I'd wager."
"I justâ" You floundered, aware you'd wandered into a conversation you had no good way of finishing. "Never mind. Forget I said anything."
Bofur studied you for a long moment, something thoughtful working behind his easy expression, and then, mercifully, let it go with a small shrug, apparently filing it away under the same category as your clothes and your fall from the skyâstrange, unexplained, and not worth pressing on an already exhausted stranger.
"Eat something, when Bombur's stew is ready," he said instead, rising with a grunt and a hand on his knee. "You'll feel more yourself for it. Whatever that turns out to be."
You watched him go, and then you looked back at the fire, at the strange, warm, smoke-hazed chaos of it, at faces you couldn't name yet belonging to a story you had no idea you'd fallen into, and you pulled the blanket a little tighter around your shoulders, and said nothing at all.
When I was working with the source data for last weekâs post on the One Book to Rule Them All among Tolkien fanfiction writers, my eye caught on several responses in the âOtherâ field that cited other fans as a source for fanfiction. This is pure anecdata: just where my eye happened to landâbut I recall being surprised in the 2020 data that other fans were second only to Tolkien himself as far as who writers considered authorities on the canon.
Is this still true?
Short answer: nope! It is not. The 2025 data show a shift away from fans regarding other fans as authorities.
In 2020, 61% of authors agreed that âI consider other fansâ views on the canonâ when crafting their stories. Five years later, only 53% of authors agreed.
Interestingly, a similar question that asks about writersâ consideration of Tolkienâs views remains essentially the same between 2020 and 2025, so what is it about fan authority in particularâespecially in a fandom that appears to be older, more experienced, and less influenced by media adaptations than it was five years agoâthat leads to skepticism?
A friendly reminder that Tolkien Fanfiction Survey data is posted weekly on @tolkien-fanfiction-survey and on the Substack Tolkien by the Numbers.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
To say you are a Tolkien fan in 2026 does not imply a single origin story. Did one of the films spark your interest? Did you read The Hobbit as a child and never left Middle-earth? Did you become acquainted with legendarium through a game or even through fanworks? Tolkien fans arrive in Middle-earth through all of these ports of call and more.
Yet fanfiction writersâat least according to the data from three Tolkien Fanfiction Surveys nowâare largely book writers. Yes, they use the films and, more recently (though less commonly), Rings of Power, but you rarely encounter a Tolkien fanfiction writer who has not picked up the books.
I made this point in my 2022 article Becoming Bookverse, which responded to mounting anxiety among Tolkien fanfiction writers as the debut of Rings of Power neared: Media adaptations of Tolkien bring fans into the fandom and, in the fanfiction fandom, then entice them toward the books. I predicted that The Rings of Power would do the same.
I was wrong in that Rings of Power has been but a ripple in the fanfiction world, but more importantly, I was not wrong about the precedence of the books. Data from the 2025 Tolkien Fanfiction Survey shows that this is more true than ever.
In 2015, two authors used only the films for their fanfiction; in 2020, four authors responded this way. In 2025, not a single author used only the films as a source for writing fanfiction.
Put another way, in three surveys, ten years, and 1,341 responses from fanfiction writers, only six people used only the films as sources.
No one used only the Rings of Power show as a source for fanfiction (and only 16% of authors used it at allâthe least-used source among the choices in the survey).
The Rings of Power is set for at least five seasons. Itâs possible that the ripple could become a wave if future seasons do more to encourage fanworksâbut itâs also hard to imagine that wave being anything on the order of the Lord of the Rings films, and if bookverse fandom remains in place after that tsunami, I think weâre good for a while yet.
A friendly reminder that Tolkien Fanfiction Survey data is posted weekly on @tolkien-fanfiction-survey and on the Substack Tolkien by the Numbers.