- she wanted Ali all for herself, and fear of losing her might've given her a reason to do something. I used to think Toby was in the A team to protect Spencer, but I doubt that now. I genuinly think he's only dating Spencer to be close to her. I used to think Caleb was in the A team too, but I don't think so anymore. I've read all the books, and those show that Emily might be guilty and Ali might not be dead. What's your entire, detailed theory about this?
+ I think Toby has the biggest reason for hate girls. They do nothing for him when he was in jail. Alison just made him guilty. He wants revenge, it's obvious for me. First he was close to Emily (but she's lesbian so...), it doesn't work. Then Spencer thought about him as a "devil" so he started to date Spencer and maybe he fell in love with her that's why "A" punished him when he fell down from house. Yeah, Caleb could help A Team when he tried to help Jenna (but it wasn't conscious). I don't know if you watch first "Winter" promo and there is Emily with shovel! And she hit someone. And it can be Alison.Â
