Any headcanons about Fingon & Anaire's relationship?
(sorry for taking approximately 400 years to answer this, oops)
I headcanon that AnairĂ« is a very devout, Vala-honoring woman, and she very much tried to pass that onto her children. (It only really took with Turgon, rip.) She gave her children mother-names corresponding to various Valar: Astaldo (Tulkas) for Fingon, NĂșrondil (Ulmo) for Turgon, AldarindĂ« (OromĂ«) for Aredhel*, and Sintamo (AulĂ«) for Argon.
*Someone else pointed out to me once that ĂrissĂ« could actually be a reference to Irmo, which is a possibility I hadnât considered! But personally I think itâs more likely that ĂrissĂ« is her father-name, a reference to Fingolfinâs sister ĂrimĂ«.
These mother-names were semi-prophetic, and also influenced her children to seek out a connection with their namesake Valar. Fingon is certainly very valiant, and I think that with encouragement from AnairĂ« he trained under Tulkas for a time...but also, he probably ends up having a stronger connection with ManwĂ«. Turgon was more inclined to spend time by the sea with his ArafinwĂ«an cousins because of his mother-name, but no one could have guessed how important Ulmo would be to him in Beleriand. Aredhel was always a wild, free spirit, and likely would have traveled with OromĂ«âs Hunt regardless of her mother-name, but it was certainly something she used when arguing with her mother about whether it was proper for a lady to go hunting, and all in white at that! As for Argon, I think AnairĂ« waited an unusually long time to name him, because she didnât have foresight around him; only when he showed interest in smithing (which, while a very Noldorin trait, was unique to him among his immediate family) did she give him a name of her own.
...But as for Fingon and AnairĂ« specifically, I think they frequently clashed on topics of religion, especially as Fingon grew up and started forming his own opinions. Of course, to AnairĂ«, it looked an awful lot like his FĂ«anorian friends were âcorruptingâ him with their blasphemous ideas, but to Fingon it was an awakening to concepts his mother had sheltered him from. Fingon never quite shakes the foundation of his belief in the Valar, or specifically his fondness for ManwĂ« and Tulkas, but his feelings toward them are much less reverential than AnairĂ«âs. And when FĂ«anor and Maedhros start talking about how the Valar had betrayed them, were caging them, Fingon was inclined to agree, because he too was curious about EndĂłrĂ«, and he was very sympathetic to the FĂ«anoriansâ grief over MĂrielâs unjust death (if not their disdain/hatred for Indis and her line).
When I operate in a âverse that includes Valarin homophobia, AnairĂ« very much buys into that. Her latent feelings for EĂ€rwen are suppressed, and she is openly disapproving of queerness, meaning that Fingon has even more reason to hide his relationship with Maedhros from his parents. Eventually she will experience a shaking of that faith, leading to her hooking up with EĂ€rwen after the Darkening, but it will take a lot for her to get to a point where she doesnât feel guilty about her own bisexuality...at which point sheâll be feeling guilty about how she treated her own kids about their queerness. (Because they are all queerâFingon is gay, Turgon is a horrifically repressed bisexual, Aredhel is aro and bi, and Argon is aroace. And Fingolfin is also a repressed bisexual!)
When the Darkening comes, AnairĂ« stands by her faith. She chooses her religion over her family, over her marriage and her children. It leaves her utterly alone. (She also chooses EĂ€rwen, but she doesnât want to admit why, at first.) She doesnât regret her choice, not really, because Beleriand was horrible and killed her whole family (save Idril), but she also feels a lot of grief and guilt over not being there for them when they needed her.
Fingon takes very much after his mother in appearance, but not in most other ways. It takes a long time for them to fully reconcile after his re-embodiment, but when they do, they find that they have a lot more in common than they realized. They both love music (which they knew, but had forgotten), they both separately picked up knitting after the Darkening, they both express themselves best through actions rather than words. Eventually they manage to piece themselves back together, and engage as adults and equals rather than a mother trying to shape her eldest son, her heir, into the person she wanted him to be, rather than the person he was.