i thought i saw your face today
word count: ~4.7k
pairing: peter parker x reader
warnings: angst, breakup, hurt/no comfort, mentions of blood and injuries, unhealthy self-sacrificial behaviour, emotional distress, crying, implied self-destructive tendencies, open ending
a/n: this was inspired by i thought i saw your face today by she & him. i had it on repeat, and with spider-man: brand new day coming out in a couple of days, it got me thinking about peter unexpectedly running into someone he loved after months apart. again its written keeping tasm in mind but im pretty sure you can imagine whichever peter youd like <3
the subway car reeks of stale sweat and something sour. it's nearly midnight, and the fluorescents buzz that sickly yellow hum that makes everyone look like they're already dead.Â
you're leaning against the doors, shoulders curled inward, counting the stops until you can collapse into a bed that still feels too big.
you're not thinking about him. you've gotten good at that; at not thinking about him.Â
you've built entire routines around the absence of peter parker. you don't watch the news anymore.Â
you don't look up when sirens pass. you've deleted every alert from your phone that might tell you something you can't unknow.
you're fine. you're surviving. at least that's what you tell yourself.
and then the train on the parallel track pulls up alongside yours.
just a flash. two layers of scratched, grimy glass. brown hair. a gray hoodie with the hood down despite the cold. shoulders you've mapped with your hands, with your lips, with tears you never wanted him to see.
peter.
your body knows before your mind catches up. your heart doesn't skip â it detonates. a full-body concussion of adrenaline that slams through your chest and leaves your fingers tingling. your spine snaps straight. your hand flies up, palm pressing flat against the cold window. it's involuntary, a reflex you haven't been able to kill even after all these months.
he's thinner. you can tell even through the hoodie. the hollows of his cheeks are sharper. there's a bruise fading along his jaw. his eyes are fixed on something in the middle distance.
that thousand-yard stare he gets when he's replaying every person he couldn't save.
your mouth opens. his name forms on your tongue. it would be so easy. one syllable. peter. you could shout it. you could bang on the glass. you could â
the other train pulls ahead. the tunnel swallows him whole.
and you're left staring at your own reflection. gaunt. exhausted.Â
hand still pressed to the window like a child reaching for something they can't have.
the woman next to you shifts away, uncomfortable. you canât blame her.
your hand drops. your heart is still hammering, but beneath the adrenaline, something else is settling in. something cold and queasy and deeply, profoundly shameful.
relief.
you're relieved he didn't see you.
not because you don't love him. god, you love him. you love him so much it's ruined you for anything else. you love him like a sickness you can't shake, like a scar that won't fade.
but loving peter parker meant watching him die in slow motion.Â
every night. every fight. every time he crawled through that window bleeding and laughed it off like his body was a tool he didn't care about breaking. and you were expected to just... hold the bandages. kiss the bruises. pretend it didn't kill you a little bit every single time.
you couldn't do it anymore.
so you left.
and now you see him on a train and your first feeling isn't longing. it's thank god i don't have to watch him bleed tonight.
the train lurches toward your stop. you grab your bag and you walk home on legs that feel like someone else's.
you don't cry until you're in the shower, where the water can wash the evidence away.
the first time you saw him really hurt, really broken, you threw up.
it was four months into the relationship. he'd told you about spider-man early â said he couldn't lie to you, couldn't keep you in the dark. you'd accepted it. you'd thought you understood what you were signing up for.
you didn't understand anything.
he came through the window at two in the morning with his suit shredded at the ribs and blood soaking through the fabric in a spreading dark stain. he was trying to smile, trying to make a joke â "you should see the other guy" â but his voice was thin and reedy and his face was the color of old paper.
you got him to the bathroom. you cut the suit off because he couldn't lift his arms. underneath, his torso was a ruin of purple-black bruises, and along his ribs there was a gash â deep and ugly, edges gaping, blood welling up thick and dark.
"it's not as bad as it looks," he said.
your hands were shaking so hard you dropped the gauze twice. "you need a hospital."
"no hospitals. they ask questions."
"peterâ"
"i've had worse. seriously. this is nothing. justâ the butterfly strips are in the cabinet, and there's a suture kit under the sinkâ"
"you have a suture kit."
he had the grace to look sheepish. "for emergencies."
"this is an emergency?"
"this is a tuesday."
you threw up in the sink. right there, while he watched, while blood dripped onto the bathroom tile. you heaved until there was nothing left, and then you rinsed your mouth with shaking hands and turned back to him.
his eyes were wet. not from pain â from guilt. "i'm sorry," he whispered. "i'm sorry, i shouldn't have come here, i should've justâ"
"don't." your voice came out like broken glass. "don't you dare apologize for letting me help you. don't you dare."
you stitched him up with hands that steadied through sheer force of will. you cleaned the blood off his skin, gentle where the bruises bloomed. you helped him to bed and lay beside him, listening to his breathing, terrified that if you fell asleep it would stop.
in the morning, he kissed your forehead and said, "see? all better."
the bruises took two weeks to fade.
he was already collecting new ones by day four.
three weeks. maybe four. time has gone slippery since you left.
peter's at a twenty-four-hour supermarket in queens at one in the morning because aunt may needs eggs.
he's wearing sweatpants and the hoodie you used to steal. it still smells like you. or maybe he's imagining it. maybe he's been imagining it for so long that he can't tell the difference anymore.
tonight was bad. not the fighting â the fighting was easy. the fighting was the only part of his life that still made sense. no, tonight was bad because he got hit. a clean shot to the ribs from a guy with a steel pipe and something to prove. peter could have dodged it. he saw it coming. he had time.
he didn't move.
he doesn't know why. or he does know why, and he's not ready to look at it. so he took the hit, and he felt his ribs creak, and he finished the fight, and now he's here buying eggs with a fresh bruise spreading under his hoodie and something loose and rattling inside his chest.
he grabs the eggs. he grabs milk he won't drink. he's stalling. walking the aisles of this aggressively bright supermarket because going home means sitting alone with his thoughts, and his thoughts have teeth.
he turns into the cereal aisle and his heart stops.
you.
twenty feet away. holding a box of cheerios. frowning at the ingredients like they've personally offended you. your hair is different â shorter, he thinks, though he's scared he's forgetting what you looked like before. you're wearing the coat he bought you for your birthday, the blue one with the frayed cuff. there are circles under your eyes so dark they look like bruises.
he did that. he knows he did that. the weight of it settles in his gut like a stone.
his body reacts before his brain can catch up. his pulse kicks into overdrive. his fingers clench around the egg carton â too hard. he feels the shells give, a wet crunch, yolk seeping through cardboard. he doesn't look down.
because you haven't seen him yet, and he has a choice.
he could leave. right now. he could put the broken eggs on a shelf and walk out the automatic doors and let you live your life without the complication of him. that would be the right thing. the good thing. the thing a hero would do.
peter parker has never known how to do the right thing when it comes to you.
his feet move. he doesn't tell them to. they just... carry him forward, down the aisle, closer to you. he's in your peripheral vision now. he sees the shift in your posture, the slight tension in your shoulders, the animal awareness of being watched.
you look up.
your eyes meet his.
and peter parker, who has been thrown through walls and dropped off buildings and beaten within an inch of his life more times than he can count â peter parker feels something inside him crack wide open.
the third fight was the one that ended it.
it was three in the morning. he'd come home â home, your apartment, the one place in the world that still felt safe â with his left arm hanging wrong. dislocated shoulder. he'd popped it back in himself, on a rooftop in hell's kitchen, biting down on his glove to keep from screaming. but something was still wrong with it. it didn't move right. it clicked when he rotated it.
you were awake. of course you were awake. you were always awake now, sitting at the kitchen table with cold coffee and eyes that looked like they'd forgotten how to close.
"what happened." not a question. an exhaustion.
"nothing. i'm fine."
"your arm."
"it's justâ"
"don't say it's nothing. don't you dare say it's nothing."
he stopped. he stood in the middle of the living room, still in the suit, mask clutched in his good hand, and he looked at you. really looked. the way you were gripping the edge of the table. the way your jaw was clenched so tight he could see the muscle jumping. the way your eyes were dry, because you'd cried so much over him that there was nothing left.
"okay," he said quietly. "it's not nothing. it's my shoulder. i dislocated it."
"again."
"again."
you stood up. slow, deliberate, like a bomb being defused. "that's the third time this month."
"i heal fast, it's fineâ"
"you heal wrong." your voice cracked on the word. "you heal wrong and you don't care. you don't get it checked out, you don't rest, you don't even tape it properly. you justâ you keep going. you keep throwing yourself at things that could kill you, and you don't care."
"of course i careâ"
"no." the word was a gunshot. "no, peter. you care about other people. you care about the city. you care about strangers on the street. but you don't care about yourself. you treat your body like it's a tool you can just keep using until it breaks, and you don't care what that does to the people who love you."
"i'm fine. i'm always fine."
"you're not fine!"
the words ripped out of you, raw and ragged, and peter flinched like you'd hit him. you were shaking. your whole body was shaking, vibrating with a fury and a fear and a grief you'd been swallowing for months.
"you're not fine," you said again, quieter but no less devastating. "you come home bleeding and you say it's nothing. you come home with broken ribs and you say it's nothing. you dislocate your shoulder so many times you can't lift your arm above your head anymore and you say it's nothing. you have a suture kit under my sink, peter. you have a suture kit in my apartment. do you understand how insane that is? do you understand what it's like to be me? to love someone who treats their own life like it doesn't matter?"
"it matters," he whispered. "of course it matters."
"then why don't you act like it?"
silence. the refrigerator hummed. outside, a car alarm went off and died.
peter's shoulder was throbbing. his ribs ached where the bruises were still fading from last week. there was a cut on his thigh he'd sealed with superglue because he didn't want you to have to stitch another wound. he thought about telling you that. he thought about showing you the scars, all of them, the map of damage he'd accumulated in the years since a spider bite turned him into something less than human and more than a martyr.
but what would that prove? you were right. of course you were right. he didn't care about himself. he couldn't afford to. caring meant hesitating, and hesitating meant people died. uncle ben died because he hesitated. gwen died because he wasn't fast enough, wasn't good enough, wasn't enough. if he started treating his body like it mattered, like it was precious, like it was worth preserving â he'd slow down. and people would die.
better him than them. better his body broken than another innocent person buried.
he couldn't explain that to you. he'd tried, a hundred times, and the words always came out wrong. they sounded like a death wish when they left his mouth, even though he didn't want to die. he just... didn't care if he did.
and that was worse, wasn't it?
"i don't know how," he said finally. his voice was very small. "i don't know how to stop. i don't know how to care about myself when there are people out there who need me. i know it hurts you. i know. and i hate myself for it. but i don't know how to be different."
you stared at him for a long time. your anger had burned itself out, leaving something worse behind: despair.
"i'm not asking you to stop being spider-man," you said. "i'm asking you to stop trying to die."
"i'm notâ"
"you are. maybe not consciously. maybe you don't wake up and think 'i hope tonight is the night.' but you fight like someone who doesn't expect to come home. you take hits you could dodge. you don't rest. you don't heal. you just keep throwing yourself into danger like your life is a currency you're trying to spend before someone takes it from you."
he couldn't meet your eyes.
"i can't watch it anymore," you whispered. "i can't sit in this apartment every night wondering if this is the time you don't get up. i can't keep finding blood in the bathroom sink. i can't keep stitching you up and pretending i'm okay when every single time i feel like i'm dying."
"then don't." the words came out before he could stop them. "don't watch. don't wait. don't stitch me up. i'm not your responsibility."
you recoiled like he'd slapped you. "is that what you think this is? responsibility?"
"i don't know. i don't know what this is anymore. i just know i'm hurting you and i can't stop. i can't be what you need me to be. i'm trying â god, i'm trying â but i'm not... i'm not built for this. i'm not built to be careful. i'm not built to come home safe. every time i try, someone gets hurt. someone dies. i can'tâ"
his voice broke. he pressed his good hand to his eyes, hard, trying to push the tears back in.
you didn't come to him. you always came to him, before. you'd hold him and tell him it was okay and stroke his hair until the shaking stopped. but this time you just stood there, arms wrapped around yourself, face a mask of grief.
"i love you," you said. "i love you so much it's destroying me. and you don't love yourself enough to stop."
"that's notâ"
"prove me wrong." your voice was barely a whisper now. "please, peter. prove me wrong. stay home tonight. rest. let your shoulder heal. just one night. that's all i'm asking. one night where you choose yourself. choose us."
he wanted to. god, he wanted to. he wanted to take off the suit and crawl into bed and hold you until the sun came up. he wanted to be the kind of person who could do that.
but somewhere in the city, a siren wailed. and peter felt it in his bones â the pull, the duty, the sick compulsion.Â
someone was in trouble. someone needed him. if he stayed here, if he rested, if he chose himself, and someone died because of it... he wouldn't survive that either.
you saw the answer on his face before he said it. your expression crumbled.
"okay," you said. "okay."
"y/nâ"
"no, i understand. i've always understood. that's the problem." you picked up your coffee cup, cold and half-empty, and poured it down the sink.
 "i understand that you will always choose the mask over yourself. and i understand that i will always choose you over me. and one of us has to stop."
"what are you saying?"
"i'm saying i can't do this anymore. i can't love you and watch you die at the same time. it's killing me, peter. you're killing me, and you don't even see it."
he crossed the room. he reached for you with his good arm, and you let him, and he pulled you against his chest â careful of the bruises, always careful of the bruises you could see but never the ones you couldn't. you were crying now, silent and shaking, and he held you like you were the last solid thing in a world that was crumbling.
"i'm sorry," he whispered into your hair. "i'm so sorry."
"i know."
"i love you."
"i know that too."
he left when the siren wailed again. he couldn't not. that was the tragedy of it â he loved you more than he'd ever loved anyone, and it still wasn't enough to override whatever broken thing inside him made his own life feel expendable.
when he came back, hours later, with fresh blood on his knuckles and a new ache in his ribs, the apartment was empty. your keys were on the counter. your closet was bare.
and peter sat on the floor of the living room, still in the suit, and didn't move until the sun came up.
peter doesn't leave the supermarket.
he stands there with yolk dripping through his fingers and a carton of crushed eggs in his hand, and he can't make his legs move in either direction. forward is you â beautiful and tired and alive, so alive, standing right there in the cereal aisle like a miracle he doesn't deserve. backward is the exit, the cold night, the empty apartment, the rest of his life without you in it.
his chest is a riot. every heartbeat slams against his ribs â the bruised ones, the ones that still ache from the pipe he didn't dodge. he thinks about telling you that. he thinks about crossing the distance and lifting his hoodie and showing you the fresh damage, the proof that you were right, that he hasn't changed, that he's still the same self-destructive disaster you walked away from.
see? he imagines saying. see? you made the right choice. i'm still bleeding. i'm still breaking. you got out just in time.
but he doesn't say anything. he just stares at you, and you stare back, and the fluorescent lights buzz overhead like a countdown.
his feet carry him forward. step by step. he rounds the corner of the shelf. he's close enough now to see the details â the chapped skin of your lips, the way you're gripping the cereal box so hard the cardboard is buckling, the tiny scar above your eyebrow from the time he came through the window too fast and knocked over a lamp and you dove to catch it and â
he stops. he's close enough to touch you. he doesn't.
your eyes are locked on his. he watches the emotions cascade across your face like a storm front. shock first â the full-body jolt of it, the way your lips part and your eyes go wide. then recognition, intimate and terrible. then pain, raw and unguarded, the kind of pain he used to see on victims' faces before he learned to look away.
and then the wall.
he watches you build it, brick by brick, in real time. your expression smooths over. your jaw tightens. your eyes go flat and careful, and you look at him like he's a stranger, like you didn't spend a year memorizing every scar on his body, like you didn't once hold him while he sobbed and promised you'd never leave.
you set down the cereal box.
and peter feels his face crumple. he can't stop it. he's spider-man â he's taken punches from people who could crush concrete â and he can't keep his face from falling apart in the cereal aisle of a twenty-four-hour supermarket. the tears come hot and fast, blurring his vision, spilling down his cheeks, dripping off his jaw.
he's not crying because you're leaving. he's crying because you're right to leave. because nothing has changed. because his ribs are still bruised and his shoulder still clicks when he moves and there's a cut on his thigh that he sealed with superglue two hours ago because he didn't want to deal with stitches.
he's still the same. he's still broken. he's still choosing the mask over himself, over you, over everything that might have made his life worth living.
and you deserve better. you've always deserved better. he knew that the day he met you, and he knows it now, watching you turn your head away.
you don't say his name. he doesn't say yours.
you walk toward the checkout. your back is straight. your shoulders are set. you don't look back, not once, and peter watches you go with yolk drying on his fingers and tears cutting tracks through the grime on his face.
you didn't call out my name.
the thought circles his brain. he holds onto it. he holds onto it like a penance.
for you, the walk to the checkout is the longest journey of your life.
every step feels like wading through water. every instinct in your body is screaming at you to turn around, to run back, to throw yourself into his arms and say i don't care, i don't care if you break yourself, just let me be there when you do.
but you can't. you can't. because you do care. that's the whole problem. you care so much it's carved out something essential inside you, left you hollow and aching and barely functional. you can't go back to the sleepless nights and the blood in the sink and the constant, crushing terror of waiting for a phone call that might never come.
you saw him. you saw the bruise on his jaw. you saw how thin he's gotten. you saw the tears streaming down his face, and god help you, you wanted to wipe them away.
but you also saw that nothing had changed. he was still in the suit. he was still throwing himself at danger. he was still treating his body like a sacrifice, and you couldn't be the person who held the knife anymore.
you pay for your groceries with hands that only shake a little. you push through the automatic doors into the cold night air. the street is empty, glittering with frost under the streetlights.
you make it three steps before your legs give out.
you catch yourself on a lamppost, bags swinging, and you press your forehead to the cold metal and you sob. the ugly kind â gasping and heaving and snotty, the kind you've been holding in for months. you cry for the boy who was too good for this world and too cruel to himself. you cry for the girl who loved him and couldn't save him. you cry for everything you had and everything you lost and everything that could have been if he'd only learned to value his own life half as much as you did.
then you wipe your face, and you pick up your bags, and you walk home alone.
inside the supermarket, peter hasn't moved.
an employee approaches him â a teenager with acne and a name tag that says josh. "uh, sir? are you okay? do you need me to call someone?"
peter looks at him. the kid can't be more than seventeen. he looks terrified. peter realizes, distantly, that he must look insane â a grown man crying in the cereal aisle, holding a carton of crushed eggs, probably bleeding through his hoodie from the wound he didn't bother to stitch properly.
"i'm fine," he says.
the kid doesn't look convinced.
peter sets the eggs on a random shelf. he wipes his hands on his sweatpants. he walks out of the supermarket with his head down and his hood up and his chest a hollow cavity where something vital used to be.
outside, the city is loud and bright and profoundly indifferent to his suffering. he leans against the brick wall and presses the heels of his hands into his eyes until he sees stars.
she didn't call out my name.
he doesn't blame you. he's never blamed you. you did the thing he can't do â you chose yourself.Â
you chose survival.Â
you got out before he dragged you down with him.
he slides down the wall until he's sitting on the cold concrete. his ribs are screaming. his shoulder is a dull, persistent ache. the cut on his thigh has probably reopened; he can feel something wet against his skin. he should go home. he should clean the wound properly, use actual bandages, maybe rest for once in his goddamn life.
a siren wails in the distance. east side. maybe a fire, maybe a robbery, maybe just someone having the worst night of their life.
peter lifts his head.
his face is wet. his body is broken. every rational part of his brain is telling him to go home, to rest, to take care of himself for once.
he gets to his feet.
he pulls his mask from his pocket.
and he swings toward the siren.
because that's what he does. that's the tragedy. that's the whole damn problem.
later; hours later, days later, lifetimes later, you'll both be lying awake in separate beds in separate corners of the same sleepless city.
you'll replay the supermarket. the look on his face. the tears. the way he didn't call out your name either. you'll wonder if that was respect or cowardice or just the same exhaustion you felt. you'll wonder if he's still bleeding somewhere, if he's patched himself up or if he's just letting the wounds close on their own like he always did. you'll want to call him. you'll pick up your phone and put it down again seventeen times before dawn.
and peter, bleeding into sheets he hasn't washed in weeks, will stare at the ceiling and feel every bruise, every ache, every piece of damage he's accumulated. he'll think about what you said â you don't love yourself enough to stop â and he'll wonder if you were right.Â
he'll wonder if there's something fundamentally broken in him, something the spider bite couldn't fix. he'll wonder if he'll ever learn to value his own life, or if he'll just keep throwing it away until one day there's nothing left to throw.
neither of you will sleep.
neither of you will call.
and somewhere in the dark, a boy who gave up everything to be a hero will close his eyes and see your face, and he will whisper your name into the silence, and the silence will give him nothing back.
but his hand will drift to his ribs, pressing against the fresh bruise there â pressing hard, harder than necessary â and he'll think, distantly, that the pain is almost comforting.
at least he can still feel something.
at least the broken parts still work.
at least he knows he's still alive.
and somewhere across the city, you'll hug your pillow to your chest and remember the way his arms felt around you â careful, always so careful with you, even when he was so careless with himself.Â
and you'll cry, not for the breakup, but for the simple, devastating truth that you couldn't love him into loving himself.
that was always his fight.
and he's still losing.
a/n: requests open. also lmk if you wanna be added to my spiderman taglist <3














