So the way names are decided are first primarily through personality, followed by strength, followed lastly by appearance.

There is some leeway on this - there are cats whose appearances are so striking, for example, wherein their prefix is named after that facet of their appearance and the leader (generally) will fulfill the spirit of the name their parents gave them unless they have a specific reason not to. Examples are those such as Redtail, Bluefur, and Graystripe. If Bluefur had been named something else - let's say Rainkit, to match with Snowkit - then Pinestar most likely would have named her for her intelligence or bravery, so something like Rainpool or Rainstorm.

Still, in general personality comes first - we see this in the names of cats like Mistspring, Cinderspark, and Tinyfrost. The ideal suffix is one that most accurately conveys a cat's personality upon meeting. These are names like -blaze (bold, passionate), -dawn (kind, graceful), -frost (quiet, cunning), so on and so forth. It's not unheard of for apprentices to guess what the others' suffixes might be based off their personality - though this also can lead to flared tempers from those who get guessed a name they don't think fits them, especially if they're not terribly introspective...

There are also some personality suffixes that have specific connotations with them that a leader has to take into consideration. For example, -flower is associated with motherly cats, and is typically given to molly apprentices that show an interest in becoming a nursery queen one day (we see this in Goldenflower as well as Morningflower!). Likewise, -leaf is commonly associated with healers, so it's very rare to see a warrior carrying it, even if it otherwise fits them (kind and graceful) - a leader will typically use -feather or -dawn instead. Names like -claw and -fang are pretty much exclusively used for warriors, so you will never see a healer given those suffixes in their healer ceremony.

Not every personality is going to have a name that fits them - Cedarpaw, for example, is outgoing, kind, loyal and determined. There's not really a suffix that fully matches that, so instead a leader would need to consider his strengths - things like how good he is at hunting, fighting, running/tree-climbing/sneaking/swimming (depending on Clan values, of course!). Cedarpaw is naturally one of the larger cats in the Clan, and Longtail has taught him well in fighting, so that's likely what Bluestar would name him after - something like Cedartalon, or as the poll decided, Cedarstrike.

There's also cats that undergo a significant change or challenge in their apprenticeship - cats like Ravenpaw, Snowkit (Snowpaw eventually!), and Thornpaw. In these cases, they'd most likely be named after whatever that challenge was - for instance, Snowkit becoming Snowbloom, which is a name commonly given to those who struggle to find their place in the Clan - it's known that cats with the -bloom suffix end up becoming the most beautiful flowers of all (Bluestar definitely considered Tinybloom for Tinyfrost!). If Cinderpaw had ended up having her accident as an apprentice in Talonslock, she would still have become a warrior, and likely would have been named something like Cindershimmer, which is a name commonly given to those who succeed through some sort of adversity (the same could also have been given to Ravenpaw!).

If a cat meets none of these requirements, then - and only then - will they be considered for an appearance based name like -foot, -tuft, -patch, -stripe, -spot(s)/-speck(le), -tail, -fur, or -pelt. This doesn't apply to all names that refer to a body part or pattern - there are names like -nose, which is commonly given to good hunters for their ability to scent out prey, and -mask, which is often given to intelligent and cunning cats as well as good hunters (which is how Peppermask got her name!). There's also the previously mentioned cases where an appearance is so striking that they're fundamentally named after it. Lastly, there are still some connotative differences between names - -pelt is often given to cats that are seen as 'protectors', which is how Nightpelt got his name (Bluefur probably should have been Bluepelt as well, but perhaps Pinestar had other reasons for that one). Still, these suffixes are generally perceived as 'boring', and a warrior that receives them is vaguely looked down upon - often, they are seen as not good enough in any way to warrant a better suffix. It's considered very rare for a -fur suffix to become deputy, let alone leader (although, as always, there are exceptions, like Bluefur herself).

It's still not always on the warrior if they receive a 'boring' name. Leaders are usually quite busy, and don't often get to know each apprentice one on one. When an apprentice has reached a certain point (usually after visiting the Moonstone), the leader will often talk with their mentor and the deputy to get name suggestions from them. They'll usually suggest a few, and the leader will pick the one they think is best for the apprentice from that list. However, there are cases where this doesn't happen, or the names that a mentor picks are particularly bad. One example of this would be Darkstripe - Tigerclaw suggested Darktiger for him, which Bluestar refused on the basis that he was only naming his apprentice after him and not for himself. Tigerclaw never gave her a better name, so she ended up choosing Darkstripe because she didn't know him well enough to pick a better one. It's possible Mousefur fell into this category - it certainly seems strange, given how close she was to her mentor Dappleshine and how good of a hunter she's known to be.

This also doesn't really cover legacy names, which are given on a case-by-case basis, and are never decided by the mentor (only the leader). Longtail is a good example here, being named after Redtail specifically - Bluestar felt the name matched him well enough, even though his tail isn't the most spectacularly long, and wanted to honor her first deputy. The same occurred with both Whitestorm and Sandstorm - when the time came, Bluestar wanted to honor her sister by naming her son after her. She named Sandstorm more because it fit her, rather than because of it being a legacy name from her mentor specifically, but it ended up working out that way as well.

There are also just leaders that are bad at naming, like Brokentail. He never ended up giving any apprentice their name (because they kept dying before they became warriors...), but I believe I've already stated that Clawface and Stumpytail's names weren't originally Clawface and Stumpytail. There were many awkward looks when Clawface re-introduced himself at the next Gathering...

Speaking of awkward looks - because of all the above reasons, it's still considered crude to openly judge a warrior's name, especially in the case of those with appearance-related names. Unless you're actually in a Clan and know the cat well enough to know why they got their name, it's generally better to assume that they're a warrior for a reason, regardless of the intricacies behind their name. For instance, Longtail being named after Redtail, who was a respected deputy of Thunderclan - even though he otherwise has an appearance-based name that isn't immediately striking like Redtail's. There have been apprentices that have broken this unspoken rule in the past, and summarily been cuffed over the ears by a nearby warrior or their mentor over it.

The names I choose for naming polls will often follow these conventions - including a couple of legacy names that the leader might consider, followed by any obvious appearance-related names, followed by personality, followed by skills. I generally won't include the non-obvious appearance based names unless that was their name in canon (as was the case with Brackenfur) or they're a wooden enough character (no on-screen interaction) that they don't really have any concrete personality to speak of - which I definitely try to avoid! That's why you won't often see -foot, -tail, -fur, or -pelt, though I may include -spot(s), -speck(le), -patch or -tuft if they happen to fit. I don't always include the in-world lore behind each suffix - I haven't gone super deep into all of them, plus there's not enough space in the polls for that, but rest assure that the ones I pick are usually for good reasons!

As for Mapleshade herself. She's been a great villain since she appeared in Crookedstar's Promise, and I think despite the overall blunder the team has made out of Mapleshade's Vengeance, it was also her best characterization. I like the idea of her haunting Tigerstar - that's the grandson(?) of the leader that threw her out and caused her kits to die - but the execution was questionable. That said, her coming for Sandstorm was out of left field. If she's been in the series since then, I don't know about it. So - A+ villain, poorly written by a bad team (not that that's a surprising conclusion from me, huh?).

I feel I have to address the lion in the room with Mapleshade's Vengeance. If Mapleshade's Vengeance took place as it happened in canon in my canon - which I'm not saying it did, but hypothetically - Only Oakstar and Mapleshade would have gone to the Dark Forest. Ravenwing, Frecklewish, and Appledusk would have gone to Starclan.

The Dark Forest in my canon works quite a bit differently than in the Hunter's canon. You have to do something really bad - usually to kits - to end up there (there's specific rules to this, but I'll keep those secret for now). Oakstar had a duty to protect all kits born in Thunderclan - yes, even those that end up being the children of his son's murderer. There was no reason to exile them - Mapleshade, maybe, but not them. By exiling them, he was essentially saying that he didn't care if they died - which ended up happening. Then obviously Mapleshade murdered three cats, which also qualifies as 'really bad'.

Ravenwing revealed that they were half-Clan, which ended up causing their exile, but nothing in what he does seems to say he advocated for their exile until Oakstar came up with the idea himself. (It's been a while, so I could be wrong on this - if he originally suggested exiling them, then he would probably join Oakstar in the Dark Forest). Appledusk was horrible to Mapleshade, but he genuinely tried to rescue his kits - he didn't know they were there until she told him, and by then it was too late. While Mapleshade might like for him to join her, he'd ultimately end up in Starclan. Frecklewish sucked, and her wishing harm on the kits wasn't great, but she never attacked them, only their mother. If she was at the river when they drowned, she didn't have a responsibility to rescue them if she had reason to believe she couldn't. Given that her brother had literally just drowned in said river, I'd say she meets that reason.

When we first meet Princess in Chapter 20, she's 7.5 moons old (the same age as Firepaw), give or take a moon or so given that we don't actually know for sure that Rusty was actually 6 moons old when he joined. They're both bright-eyed young cats for whom the world can be anything, and I think at this point their personalities are pretty similar. Granted, Rusty's encounter with Graypaw ended in a brief fight, while Princess simply ran off back to her housefolk: however, Rusty was also going to run until he realized Graypaw was gaining on him, whereas Firepaw didn't bother chasing Princess until he realized she was his sister.

We even see that Princess loves the idea of the forest! Quote from Chapter 20:

"Living in the forest all the time… that must be nice." [Firepaw] perked his ears, unable to ignore the wistful tone in [Princess'] voice.

She wants to be in the forest as much as him! So why doesn't she? Again, quote from Chapter 20:

"I wish I could. I love being in the forest, and I'd like to get to know you better. I really would." [Princess] admitted, brushing her tail against [Firepaw's] paw. "But my housefolk… she needs me. She's alone in her nest all day, until her mate comes home, and sometimes she just sits and stares at nothing all day when I'm not around. She needs me to keep her functioning." The tawny molly looked away with a heavy sigh. "I'm not sure what she would do if I just left."

I think a lot of people overlooked this dialogue - maybe because it was early in the series, maybe because it wasn't that important (in the grand scheme of things), maybe because they didn't understand what it was getting at. This is one of those things I left implicit, both because cats don't really understand how humans think and because it's one of those things that would definitely dampen the relatively light-hearted mood of Fire and Ice at that point. However, since we're getting into the nitty-gritty here, I'll explain what this means and why it's an ample part of Princess' reasoning - enough that she wouldn't follow her heart to get to know her brother and live in the forest.

Princess' female human has severe depression. It's not entirely clear whether or not her human is treated for it or not, but it doesn't particularly matter. She and her 'mate' (again, a cat's way of looking at them) had heard of emotional support animals to help combat depression and decided to contact a local Somali Cat breeder at the behest of their neighbor after asking around about kittens. Their neighbor would have been one of Rusty's owners, who told them that the breeder currently had five kittens and they were looking at picking one out. This is how Princess and Rusty ended up being so close geographically, even though their siblings and mother aren't!

Princess can sense that her human has depression, even if she doesn't fully understand what that means. And she does indeed help support her human! She makes sure that her human eats food at a regular time, does the laundry when it's needed, and she's there to cuddle with her on her worst days. She's needed, so she can't leave to fulfill her heart's wishes. Instead, Princess lives vicariously through her brother's tales of the forest, and telling all her friends about her strong wild cat brother.

In canon, Princess is scared of the wild cats. She doesn't understand why her brother left his housefolk. She can't handle the sight of Brightheart, because she's just too soft as a kittypet. Hell, when we meet her for the first time, she's already pregnant! Her sole reason for being is to give Cloudkit to Fireheart, so that he can have a relative in the Clans.

Given that she's Fireheart's sister, and therefore his equal (more or less), this has always read to me as misogyny from the Hunters. Why can't Princess join to be his relative in the Clans? Sure, it could be to give him a replacement apprentice, not just a relative, but back then kits just kind of showed up out of the ether. There's no reason he couldn't have been Fernkit or Ashkit's mentor, or some other sudden apprentice! She could have even been his apprentice if she joined, and he taught her how to be a wild cat (bonding moments)! But no; the only female relative of Fireheart's we see in the first series is pregnant, serving solely as a mother to his Clan relative, too scared/soft for the wild, and then just disappears after the first arc.

I wanted to show that she is his equal in my canon, and that means that she wants to be wild just as badly as him. She would be, if she didn't have someone that was already reliant on her as an ESA. Instead she remains; but she's still not soft, or scared of the forest. She loves seeing Fireheart, she worries for him, she even wants to learn battle moves from him in Chapter 47! Every time she's portrayed as soft, it's because Fireheart is handling her too gently; because he's trying to protect her from his own imagined fears. Whenever she reacts negatively, it's always to things that Clan cats themselves react negatively to (such as Spottedleaf dying, or the kits getting stolen).

Now that we've covered her character in Fire and Ice, it's time to get to how I've been developing her in Forest of Secrets. Obviously, the first chapter we see her in is Chapter 7, and it's not great. Her long fur is ungroomed; her tail is low, and she doesn't respond very much to Fireheart's prompting. She is deeply upset and clearly in her own head. We find out this is because she was bred with a cat she didn't know, and she didn't entirely want to do it, but did so out of fear of making her owners mad.

At this point, she is about 12 moons old, again give or take a couple of moons. I want to state that this is young. I know how early a cat's puberty can begin, and it's much earlier than this, but these are sapient cats and as such that doesn't really apply. Still, even by living cat standards, this is young; responsible breeders state that a cat should never be bred before their first year, and it should ideally wait until they are 18 months or two years old.

(This is made even worse in canon, because she's actually 10 moons at this point. Seriously, Erins, what the hell?)

From her point of view, her housefolk have betrayed her. She loved them and cared for them, but she wasn't enough for them. All they see her for is a potential baby factory, not for the value of their bond on its own. She thought they loved her for her, and now she's wondering if they love her at all. Will they love her kits at all? How can they, when they don't even seem to love her?

Also to be clear, her humans are definitely in the wrong here. This is made even clearer when we think about who Princess was bred with, Oliver. He's mentioned to be a white tom, but... there's no white in the Somali Cat breed standard. The only crossbreed allowed by the standard is to Abyssinians, and those also don't allow white. Her kits won't be able to be registered Somalis, even if they meet all the other classifications (they won't). This means that they were breeding her just for the sake of breeding her, which is a huge no-no.

I come from rescue circles, so I'll admit that the idea of willingly breeding cats is foreign to me anyways. There's so many cats out there that need good homes besides purebreds! I can't even begin to fathom why Princess' humans bred her; maybe the female wanted something to do all day and thought taking care of kittens would be good? I don't know. Regardless, they bred her to the first tom with papers whose owner would accept the cash and not question anything else. In my head, Oliver is probably a Turkish Angora, though that's not terribly relevant to this conversation.

Getting back to Princess: Even though Yellowfang and Dewpaw and all her friends did their best to comfort her, at the end of the day she was still home with her housefolk day in and day out. The more she helped her, the angrier she became. Despite all the love she'd given her, her housefolk had still forced Princess to carry kits for her own amusement. She would likely make Princess' kits carry kits for her own amusement - and that, more than anything, scared Princess to her core. She didn't want anyone else to go through what she did. Especially not the kits growing inside her, which despite it all she was growing to love. (This is also why she turned down the opportunity for an abortion from Yellowfang - even though she hated how she had gotten pregnant, she loved the idea of her own kits.)

Then she thought of her brother, Fireheart. She thought of how she'd first met him, and how he'd offered to let her join his Clan. That made her angrier, too. She should've accepted his offer. She should never have stayed with housefolk that didn't care about her. Then she wondered; why couldn't she join him now? The wild was dangerous, though; wouldn't it be safer for her kits to stay with housefolk?

But the more she thought about it, the more that she wondered how the Clans could survive out in the wild if it wasn't mostly safe. After all, Fireheart mentioned kits and queens all the time! She resolved to learn more about the nursery when he came back. And she did just that, as we see during his visit in Chapter 20. Quote again:

“Really?” [Princess] was leaning into [Fireheart] now, as though she needed to hear every word he said as soon as it left his lips. “How does one become a nursery queen, then?”

"Maybe it’s nice, in the nursery.” Princess whispered softly, so much that for a heartbeat [Fireheart] thought she was talking to herself. “What do you think?” She asked him, speaking louder now.

“Do you think the queens are happy in the nursery?” [Princess] wondered out loud, looking over her shoulder into the forest for a brief moment before gazing back at [Fireheart].

[Princess]: “That’s lovely to hear. And the kits, do they like it in the nursery?”

For most of the conversation, she's probing him for what it's like in the Clan; how queens are treated, how kits fare. It's subtle - subtle enough that Fireheart barely catches onto it - but she's already imagining her own life in Thunderclan. She's not sure whether she wants to be a warrior anymore, but she does want to join - and being a nursery queen sounds like the perfect role for her. She loves her kits now, and she loves the idea of getting to care for many kits, even if they aren't her own.

Princess makes up her mind sometime over the next half-moon, and resolves to ask him to let her join when Fireheart comes back. But he doesn't, too involved with Graystripe and Tigerclaw to think about his sister. As her belly grows even larger, her housefolk starts closing the catflap; just at night, usually, but sometimes throughout the day as well. It's only through Princess' desperate begging to see her friend in the garden that her housefolk relents, and that's the final straw for her to leave instead of waiting for Fireheart like he ordered. She doesn't tell Fireheart about this because she's afraid he'll order her back to her housefolk for her own safety, or the Clan's safety. She won't tell anyone until after the kits are born (and it will take place off-screen regardless), but it will be enough to cement her decision as the 'right' one in the eyes of the Clan.