Tainted â Chapter 4: You're Stained
SUMMARY: Even though Dean is no longer a demon, his sanity is still slipping. How can they get through to him?
SHIP: Dean Winchester x Fem!Reader (MOC!Dean x Reader) GENRE: Angst TO NOTE/WARNINGS: Season 10 spoiler territory, established relationship, angst, minor injuries and blood, Dean's usual self-loathing, use of y/n, poorly proofread by yours truly WORD COUNT: 3.6k A/N: Finally a new chapter. I am so sorry for taking so long. February has been super busy for me, but now my written final exams are completed! CREDIT & LINKS: header edited by myself ââăâ divider edited by myself ââăâ series masterlist
âȘPREV. CHAPTER âŻïžPLAYLIST â©NEXT CHAPTER
She was starting to believe that she was just imagining the glimpse of normalcy. Surely, she was desperate for things to be as they once were. But it couldnât just happen overnight, obviously.
And she was starting to believe it might never be the same again.
So while things definitely felt calmer, the tension was still palpable.
Turning Dean back into a human had taken a toll on all of them. Their success was overshadowed by their exhaustion. Especially by Deanâs.
âMaybe we should call Rowena,â Sam sighed heavily, rubbing a hand over his face.
She frowned in response.
âI donât like this idea,â she grumbled.
âMe neither,â Sam huffed. âBut we donât have many options left.â
Upon surveying the table and the various books scattered across it, she had to agree.
Theyâve been at it for months and werenât able to find anything about removing the Mark of Cain. Now, after Dean had turned into a demon, they knew they couldnât go through the same process again. They didnât have another couple of months.
They didnât know when the curse would take over again. Moreover, if it ever came this far, whether or not they could save him a second time.
Perhaps Rowena really was their last hope. As a powerful witch, surely she knew a thing or two about lifting curses.
Still, the huntressâs expression remained to be one of dismay and skepticism as Sam dialed the womanâs number. She didnât know if they could trust Rowena, after all.
While Sam and her were digging through more lore and contacting possibly helpful yet dubious sources, Dean was busy staring at anything but his reflection.
He was in the bathroom just next door. Had been there for the past twenty minutes. Just standing at the sink and scrubbing his hands until they were raw.
He was barely able to make out Samâs and Y/Nâs voices from outside. The ones in his head were much louder. Much more persisent, even overshadowing the running water.
Hissing and screaming and taunting and aggravating â he could barely take it.
Making the mistake of blinking upwards, his gaze met his own eyes. Dull and circled with dark shadows underneath.
Sleep hasnât been able to find him in days. Not since his girlfriend and Sam managed to inject him with enough purified blood to keep his demonic side at bay.
Not when he knew â they all knew â it was still dormant within.
Dean clenched his jaw, staring down his reflection and seeing nothing but 50% monster and 50% empty, pathetic shell. Or maybe, just maybe, there was some amount of guilt laced within there too. The past weeks and months were mostly a blur to him, mere snippets of clarity in between.
He remembered some of the hangouts with Crowley, drowning himself in even more whiskey than usual. He remembered some demons tailing him, all of which he killed. He remembered being dragged back to the Bunker. And, worst of all, he remembered going after Y/N.
He remembered the rush of adrenaline. The raw, pure joy the idea of chasing her brought him.
How could he possibly, in good conscience, ever look her in the eyes again?
After everything that happened, he didnât have it in him to face anything anymore. Least of all her.
Why, out of all the memories that couldâve been so vivid, it had to be the image of his hand around her throat or that damn hammer aimed at her, he didnât know. It felt like fate was being cruel to him. Then again, he couldnât help but think he deserved it.
When splashing his face with cold water didnât soothe his frayed nerves either, he let out a shaky sigh and turned off the faucet. The voices outside were clearer, though he still couldnât make out what she and his brother were talking about.
It didnât take a genius to figure it out. The Mark of Cain was the hottest topic in the bunker. Hell, it wouldnât even surprise him if they were just straight up badmouthing him. He wouldâve deserved that, too.
Honestly, part of him hoped sheâd talk to Sam. She sure as hell hadnât talked to Dean about this mess. Not because she didnât want to. Quite the opposite. It was him, who repeatedly shut her down. It was him, who avoided the much dreaded conversation like a plague.
He didnât even know why â whether he was embarrassed to face his own (literal) demons, or if it was her he was scared of. At times he thought the second heâd even look at her for just a moment too long, she might get scared.
At least thatâs what she should be doing.
Of course, sheâd never.
Sheâs always been too forgiving with him. But Deanâs guilt didnât allow himself to accept her kindness. He was broken beyond repair, yet she still bothered to pick up the pieces, when instead she should be turning her back to him.
He had hurt her, badly, in more ways than one. And he could never take that back or fix it. He couldnât even guarantee it wouldnât happen again in the future, which was eating him alive.
How could he have let it go this far?
Clutching the edge of the sink, Dean stared down his own reflection. His hands were twitching, fingers grasping onto the white ceramic so hard that his knuckles matched the shade. So hard until he could feel the blood pulsating in his knuckles. Until his muscles ached.
Until suddenly, within the blink of an eye, his reflection was shattered â split into several, small pieces.
A large crack went down the middle of the mirror, lines of broken glass spreading out like veins, when his own were flooded with poison. Like a spiderâs web, when he could not escape from himself.
Deanâs gaze dropped to his fist, shaking and covered in crimson. The flow of the rivulets was both nauseating and strangely soothing. He staggered backwards until his back hit the wall and he slid to the cold bathroom floor. The blood dripped from his knuckles down his arm, right over the pulsating mark, which was still throbbing with hunger.
Head between his knees, face buried in his palms, he barely registered the panicked knocking at the door.
âDean, are you okay?â
Her voice, though muffled by the door, pierced right through to him. Like he had been shot straight into his chest.
Far from okay.
âIâm fine,â he spoke, barely having the energy to raise his voice enough for her to hear.
She rattled at the doorknob, then knocked again.
Dean didnât budge, not wanting her to see him like this. The back of his head softly thudded against the wall behind him and he stared at an empty dot on the ceiling.
Persistent as she was, though, her worried voice tried again: âCan you let me in?â
A pause. Heavy silence. Nothing.
âPlease,â she added.
âCâmon, Dean. Open the door,â Samâs voice chimed in and ultimately, Dean gave in with a sigh. He picked himself up from the ground, which took way more effort than it should have, lazily rinsed off the blood from his skin, and halfheartedly wrapped some bandages around his hand.
âDean, open theââ
âIâve heard ya the first time, man,â Dean groaned and unlocked the door at last.
He couldnât meet either of their gazes. Not that he had to to feel their concerned stares.
Y/Nâs eyes flickered back and forth between Dean, his poorly wrapped up knuckles, and the shattered mirror. Before she even had the chance to ask what happened, Dean pushed past both her and Sam.
âHold on,â she tried anxiously, âYour hand, youââ
âI said âm fine,â Dean grumbled coldly, tiredly, then retreated to the kitchen.
Instinctively her arm stretched out in his direction. Although he was out of reach anyway, Sam placed a firm, yet gentle hand on her shoulder to prevent her from following Dean.
âGive him some time,â he mumbled, not sounding too convinced himself. Though he knew his brother well enough to figure he wouldnât want a conversation, he wished he could do something for him as well. Still, it was no wonder Dean wanted to be left alone.
He was scared, it was plain to see.
âHeâll come around,â Sam sighed with a half-nod. âHe always does.â
She could only hope Sam was right.
But more than that, she couldnât help but feel anxious.
It wasnât the first time Dean was pushing everyone away and part of her knew he did it to prevent a possible lashing out against them. But honestly? She wouldâve preferred for the time bomb to go off, for Dean to burst, over watching him slowly fade away.
âI hope youâre right,â she mumbled in response to Samâs comment. Then, she tended to the mess Dean had left behind, because cleaning the broken mirror was apparently all she could do right now.
Broom and plastic bag in hand, she carefully collected the shards of glass.
The task couldnât have taken longer than a couple of minutes, but to her it felt like hours. Hours of waiting for Dean to come back out of the kitchen. Of waiting for him to immediately reinstall a new mirror in that habit of his to fix messes right away. Waiting for him to flash her a goofy grin. For him to stop pushing her away.
By the time the floors were swept, the sink cleaned, and the trash thrown out, there was still no sign of Dean. In the meantime, Sam was back in the library, having a phone call with Rowena that sounded ten times more urgent than earlier that day.
At first, Y/N danced around the kitchen like it was a contaminated area.
She reorganized the DVD boxes in the Dean Cave, by alphabetical order. She cleaned her gun, taking it apart and building it back together from scratch. Twice. She listened to Samâs summary of his conversation with Rowena, something about a âBook of the Damnedâ that might or might not hold the solution to all their problems. She helped him go through their library, then stayed at the shelves even after Sam announced heâd be heading to bed.
When after all those hours the only sign of Dean was still just the light from the kitchen seeping into the hallway, she gave up.
If Dean was ever going to come around, it wouldnât be with her lurking about. And frankly, she too was worn down and tired, given that it was already way past midnight.
Thus, after getting ready for bed, she climbed under the sheets. And then, to nobodyâs surprise, she tossed and turned. She kept staring at the door, which she had left open on purpose. A silent invitation for Dean to walk in whenever he was ready. Only that he never accepted the invitation.
Every minute spent in a bed that felt empty without him beside her diminished the chances of him âcoming around eventually.â
She couldnât take it anymore.
Slipping out of bed and into her slippers and fluffy robe, she left the bedroom.
It wasnât just today. Ever since they brought him back and cured him, Dean hasnât slept in his room. She didnât know where he was staying, honestly. Her best guess was the library, but whenever sheâd check, he wasnât there either.
Most days sheâd find him in the kitchen. Like today; heâs been in there the whole time.
Her footsteps were soft and careful, not wanting to startle him.
She found Dean sitting at the table, a mostly empty plate in front of him with only a few bites of a burger on it. At least he was eating again. He was currently busy rearranging and cleaning parts of his gun. Great minds think alike, huh?
She gently cleared her throat before she spoke up: âDonât you wanna come to bed?â
With his back facing her, she couldnât gauge his reaction, but she saw the tension in his muscles. His shoulders rising, then slouching. His movements paused just for a second before he continued fidgeting with the metal.
âNo.â
He might as well have shot her with the gun.
Something in her chest tightened. The room temperature dropped. He wasnât even looking at her. He hasnât been looking at her the whole day. Longer than that. Much longer.
âI found this lead, in Washington,â Dean rasped then and she swore that mustâve been the most words he has exchanged with her in weeks. âBunch of bodies with missing hearts, looks like a simple case of werewolves to me.â
Her eyes widened in surprise, though.
âYou wanna take on a case?â
âWhy not?â He shrugged, âbetter than going stir-crazy.â
Not that he was wrong.
Theyâve been cooped up in the Bunker for a while, but wasnât it better to rest? To wait until things were smoothed over a bit, and maybe see if Rowenaâs lead would take them anywhere? But Dean had made up his mind before she could voice her opinion on it. He got up and nearly walked past her.
âShouldnât we at least wait until tomorrow morning?,â she hastily uttered, half-panicked, while blocking the doorway.
She didnât gather all this courage to approach Dean only for him to walk away again.
Though his expression was distant, she was glad he was looking at her at all.
âI can make a stop on the road, or take a nap when Iâm there.â
I? He wanted to go to Washington by himself?
âNot a chance, Winchester,â she huffed and shook her head. âLook, I donât wanna be a mother-hen, but you can sleep here and we can all head out together. Tomorrow morning.â
Dean blinked at her, unimpressed, then he groaned quietly and pinched the bridge of his nose. âY/Nââ
She didnât let him finish. She had cut him some slack this whole time, but enough was enough. He at least owed her this.
âYou can even take the bed,â she suggested. âIâll sleep on the couch.â
That took him off guard. His eyes went wide, his lips slightly parted in confusion as he struggled to find the right response.
âWhat?â
Standing her ground, insisting he should get a proper nightâs sleep, she repeated her offer: âI can take the couch. Or another guest room. We have plenty of those anyway, itâs fine.â
Deanâs expression grew more and more puzzled with each word, like she was talking in a foreign language. âNo. What are you saying?â
âJust⊠you deserve some rest and I donât wanna occupy your spaceââ
âMy space? Babe, stop, thatâs notââ He sighed deeply. The crease between his brows melted, his eyes softening as something clicked in his head.âItâs our room, not mine. Has been ever since we moved in here.â
As much as she wanted to, she found it hard to believe him. She spent too many nights in that bed by herself, too many hours dining without him, doing groceries without him, not seeing a glimpse of him, let alone talk with him, for his words to make sense.
Dean has been avoiding her like the plague. Whether or not he was doing it for her sake, she got the message loud and clear: He didnât want her near him.
More bitterly than she had intended, her voice pushed out a meek: âThen why am I the only one using it?â
The brief silence it earned her was deafening. She didnât mean to blame him for anything, but how could she not feel neglected? Feel unwanted?
Dean clenched and unclenched his jaw. At last, his gaze dropped again and without the eye contact, he was a million miles away from her. Again.
ââŠI canât sleep anyway. Itâs got nothing to do with you.â
Not only did she find it hard to believe, she knew he was lying. That blind trust she once had in him, was now cracked slightly. How could she take his word for granted when heâd been keeping secrets from her and withdrawing more and more?
She had a good reason to believe him going on a hunt, by himself no less, was a terrible idea. Last time she left him to himself, he disappeared, got killed, and turned into a demon.
Even if everything he did was to protect her, he shouldâve told her the truth.
She wasnât asking for him to act like everything was okay. She knew it wasnât. All she wanted was for him to take care of himself, for once.
And if he didnât want her to be part of that process, then so be it, but he couldnât expect her to watch him destroy himself. Not again.
She took a deep breath. It came out shaky and she, too, had to cast down her eyes, which were red-rimmed from sleep deprivation and sorrows alike.
âI get it, Dean,â she muttered, weakness making her voice tremble. âYou need space and time⊠and⊠honestly, I wish I could say thatâs okay. I wish I could give you as much time as you need, but⊠Iâmâ Iâm scared.â
As was he. He was terrified even.
In that moment he was as much deer caught in the headlights as he was the driver staring at the car crash. The sight of her tears was like a truck hitting him, though he was the one responsible in the end, wasnât he?
Dean never wanted any of this for her. He was supposed to look out for her, not put her in harmâs way.
He was straight up poison for her from the very beginning, doomed by fate or whatever, and dragging her right down with him. It had only been a matter of time â he couldnât even blame it on the mark.
No, he had been tainted long before that curse came around.
âCanât blame you after what I did to you,â he spoke, his tone not wavering, but breathless and defeated nonetheless.
âWhat? No. God, no. Not of you, Dean. Never of you,â she clarified immediately, those glassy eyes of hers pleading with him. âIâm scared of losing you againâ youâre slipping away from me and I canât do anything to stop it.â
Despite his own resolution to stay away from her, for her own good, he snaked an arm around her waist. She accepted the offer immediately, burying her face in his chest.
Her breath hitched in her throat as she relearned the familiar scent of him and the comforting texture of soft, worn down flannel. Itâs been so long that she almost forgot the warmth of his arms around her.
If she could, sheâd drown herself inside of him, crawl into his skin and replace that cursed mark. But alas, her tears were the only thing his clothes soaked up.
It wasnât much different for Dean. His senses reviewed all of her as well, committing every detail to memory once more. She still felt the same, and he felt like an idiot.
His arms around her tightened. Where his nose was previously buried in the crown of her head, he now perked his chin up and tucked her head right beneath.
âIâm right here,â he whispered, letting one hand comb through her hair while the other was rubbing small circles on her back.
âNo,â she sniffled. âNo, youâre not.â
He couldnât blame her for thinking that. Dean knew he hadnât exactly been easy lately. Nor had he been treating her fairly.
âLook at me,â Dean sighed and pulled back slightly. His heart ached when her fingers tightened their grip on his shirt, clinging to him as if scared to let go. âIâm not going anywhere, I promise. Youâre not gonna get rid of me that easily, hm?â
She wanted to believe him. She wanted to crack a smile at his weak attempt of humor, but she simply couldnât. Even as he cupped her face and pressed a soft kiss to her forehead, the fear was still lingering.
Yet, she closed her eyes, allowed herself to relax into Deanâs hands, and nodded.
He took that as a small victory.
âLetâs go to bed, sweetheart,â he mumbled into her hair, weaving hope and warmth into the strands.
The tension eased from her shoulders, even more so when he wiped away her tears.
âWill you let me patch you up first or am I pushing my luck?â She mumbled, her fingers gently wrapping around his wrist and holding up his poorly bandaged hand.
Reluctantly, he nodded and let her guide him back to their room.
Figuring she needed this more than he did, Dean sat down and watched her carefully clean his cuts. He couldnât care less about some scratched up knuckles, but she wanted him to be okay. She needed him to be okay. So, even if he wasnât, he could let her do this small thing.
It was a start.
Dean Winchester Taglist:
@ladysparkles78 @ariasong11 @winchester-whiskey @whormotional @spacecowgirl126 @zepskies @calibootsgirl @hot-and-confused @spookyfunhottub @berryblues46 @midnight--raine @emmy21842 @whichwitchwanda @foxyjwls007 @emma1998sblog @lyarr24 @charliesangel67 @spn-reader @whump-loverz @cassieriddle713 @ilovedeanwinchester4 @amberlthomas @mccartneyqp
Put a green heart đ in the comments to be added to the Dean x Reader taglist. Let me know, if you want to be tagged for this Series specifically. (Please note: Ageless blogs will only be tagged in fluff and angst posts!).















