SERIES:
Accidentally a Winchester: A Supernatural Reader Series
You appear in the Men of Letters bunker with no memory of your past. You still know exactly where you are, and you know exactly who Dean, Sam, and Cas are.
Turns out you are from reality and you were a fan of Supernatural, but you only remember up until the time of the episode you're in.
Starts Season 10 between E14 Nihilism and E15 Damaged Goods
Expect casefic, bunker life, found family, hurt/comfort, banter, and an eventual slow-burn that takes its time and hits hard. (Also: Charlie lives in this timeline, because I said so.)
NOTE: They are numbered in order. Anything with a .5 is not a plot point, just a short story.
Reader-insert (female), Slow Burn with Sam, POV second person No Use of Y/N for Reader-Insert
KEY: Pink = All Original Purple = Episode from show, re-written in my AU Blue = Episode from the show (listed for timeline reference)
* * * S10 E12 About a Boy (Aired: February 3, 2015) S10 E13 Halt & Catch (Aired: Fire February 10, 2015) S10 E14 The Executioner's Song (Aired: February 17, 2015)
1-Arrival Summary: You know where you are: the Men of Letters bunker. And you know the three people trying to figure you out—Sam and Dean, and Castiel. Sam and Dean are hunters. Cas is an angel. One is kind, one is cautious, and one is just curious.
But you can’t remember your name, your life, or how you got here. And none of you know what you are… or where you came from.
2-Bunker First Full Day and First Nights Summary: THEN: You dropped into the bunker knowing where you were and who Sam, Dean, and Cas are but nothing about yourself. NOW: Your first full day in the bunker feels almost manageable. You even come up with a plan to help the Winchesters. Then night drops and the bunker gets too quiet. You can’t sleep. But with a little help, you find a way.
2.5-He Just Is Summary: It’s supposed to be a routine gynecologist appointment. Instead, it becomes one of those small, oddly intimate moments that makes a difference later.
3-Can We Just Pretend It Didn’t Happen? Summary: THEN: You appear in the bunker knowing who the Winchesters are… but nothing about you. NOW: Night gets too quiet, you break, and a drunk Dean Winchester shows up at your door. One soft hug turns into a mistake you both agree to erase. In the morning, he draws a line… then drops one name: Sam Winchester.
3.5-Absolutely Nothing Happened on the Trip Summary: Just a little scene with a lot of mutual pining
S10 E15 The Things They Carried (Aired: March 18, 2015)
4-Cas Makes It Weird and Complicated and Whatever Summary: Secrets surface, tempers flare, and you clear the air the best you can. The Sam/Reader slow burn keeps moving forward… just not the easy way.
5-Something Here That’s Yours Summary: You keep trying to earn your place. Sam keeps trying to give you one. And it’s getting harder to pretend that doesn’t mean something.
6-The Family Kind Summary: A simple thank-you lands wrong. One sentence brings up a night everyone agreed meant nothing—until it almost does.
7A-The CupSummary: Sam gets too close trying to help. Desire hits hard. You both pretend it didn’t. Two POVs.
7B-The Lean Summary: Your head rests on Sam’s arm. Impossible to pretend it doesn't matter. But maybe it can be an accident. Two POVs.
7C-The DishesSummary: Helping with a simple chore turns into an "almost" you both have to hide. Two POVs.
8-Not Thinking Straight When It Comes to Her Summary: A routine supply run goes sideways. Sam tries to keep you safe. He wants to lock you in the bunker. He has to face it: when it comes to you, he’s not thinking straight.
9-You’re in So Much Trouble Summary: The “accidental” touches start and the sparks fly. You both assume you’re the only one feeling it. By the time the night ends, you’re both wondering the same thing: keep denying it, or risk asking what’s real.
10-There’s Only This Summary: You and Sam want the same thing, but you both assume the feeling isn’t returned. Then the truth finally comes out, and one choice changes everything. 😘 (First Kiss)
Bonus Fluff These are just tiny little fluff scenes for Sam and Reader-insert
11-About Damn Time Summary: After weeks of tension, you and Sam get stuck in a moment neither of you wants to end. It’s gentle, real, and overdue… Later, of course, Dean is insufferably smug about it.
Bonus Mild Smut Fluff These are just tiny little mild smut fluff scenes for Sam and Reader-insert
S10 E16 Paint It Black (Aired:March 25, 2015)
12-Can we be best friends now? Summary: You finally get to meet Charlie. A shared history hits harder than you could have imagined. By the end of her visit, you may have a new best friend and a new nerd project (or two).
13-A Gap in the System Summary: Saving people and hunting things just got easier. Your idea could save the Winchesters time, effort, and maybe some lives. If Charlie can pull off a nerd heist involving a very dangerous group.
13.5-"Sammy" - A short little scene Summary: Just a short little scene - You're in bed with Sam, you wake up from a nightmare.
14-You Said I Was Ready Summary: After weeks of training, things in the bunker start to change. A moment that should feel good takes an unexpected turn, hurt feelings rise to the surface, and one difficult conversation changes everything. By the end of the night, nothing between you and Sam is quite the same. Dean, of course, is way too aware of all of it.
S10 E17 Inside Man (Aired:April 1, 2015)
14.5-Shake It Off Summary: Funny little banter scene in the Impala where Sam talks to you on the phone, Dean starts teasing, and you find his Kryptonite.
15-If She's a WinchesterSummary: You remember your last name, and Sam helps you search for clues about your past. That search uncovers a shocking record tying you to the Winchester name, and sending you into a miserable spiral, complete with an emergency beer.
15.5-There's No Musical Numbers in SupernaturalSummary: You try to surprise Sam with a whisper in his ear, and he one-ups you. A sweet little moment in the bunker with your boyfriend. — Dean included, unfortunately.
16-Wouldn’t Be a Winchester Date Without a Little Near-Death Experience Summary: Sam takes you on your first real date, and for one perfect minute it almost feels normal. Nice clothes, good food, soft looks between you. Then four demons crash the evening, you accidentally change the rules of the fight, and by the end of the night Sam’s even more gone for you than he was before.
17-She Still BleedsSummary: You want to start going on hunts, but you promised you wouldn't until Sam was ready. Now Castiel, Dean and you have to convince Sam to be ready and let you.
17.5-What Cup?Summary: A moment that once left you both wanting finally gets some closure.
18-Monster Logic 101 Summary: Your first real hunt - Warewolves Sam doesn't want you in danger, or even on the hunt Dean is affected by the Mark of Cain
19-You Can't Smell It on TV Summary: You know vampire lore. You know what kills them, how they hunt, and what to expect, at least in theory. But when Sam and Dean take you on a real vampire hunt, you learn fast that knowing something from TV is not the same as living through it. Featuring humor, romance, and decapitation.
19.5-For This? Definitely. Summary: When Sam and Dean finally get back from a hunt, you’re all running on fumes and punchy enough to come up with the world’s dumbest, most useful hunter blog idea.
S10 E18 Book of the Damned
19.75-The One Who Trusts Summary: Discussion with Sam about the truth, hiding things, and trust in your relationship. Not to mention the Book of the Damned. And some flirting at the end.
S10 E19 The Werther Project (Aired: April 22, 2015) S10 E20 Angel Heart (Aired: April 29, 2015)
20-Charlie Lives Note: This is from S10 E21 "Dark Dynasty" and S10 E22 "The Prisoner" What happens differently in those episodes when you are in their world.
20.5-Sleeping (in) Baby Summary: Just a very short little fluff scene about falling asleep in the back of Baby.
S10 E23 Brother's Keeper (Aired May 20, 2015) S11 E1 Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire (Aired October 7th, 2015) S11 E2 Form and Void (Aired October 14th, 2015) S11 E3 The Bad Seed (Aired October 21th, 2015)
21-Night Moves Summary: A funny, warm rewrite of the “Night Moves” scene from Baby S11 E4 in my "Accidentally a Winchester" series alternate universe. Includes Sam/Reader, Dean, the Impala, classic rock, bad timing, and one extremely awkward morning after.
21.5-Why does it sound like Casa Erotica in here? Summary: An innocent neck rub turns into bunker chaos when Dean misunderstands what he hears.
22-The Choice Summary: When a string of impossible crimes leads you, Sam, and Dean to a cave system, the case starts looking less like possession and more like a test. Ananke is ancient. She believes every bond breaks under enough pressure. And she has chosen Sam to prove it.
22.5-Which Winchester Is the Monster? Summary: A custom gift doesn’t sound like hunter gear. Then again, neither do half the things that end up saving a Winchester.
S11 E5 Thin Lizzi (Aired November 4, 2015) S11 E6 Our Little World (Aired November 11, 2015) S11 E7 Plush (Aired November 18, 2015)
23-Large. Snowy. Creature. Summary: At a Colorado ski resort, ski patrol members are freezing solid in places where freezing should be impossible. And whatever is moving through the trees is definitely not a yeti, no matter what Dean says. The deeper you dig, the less it looks like a monster and the more it looks like a terrible secret buried in the snow.
S11 E8 Just My Imagination (Aired December 2, 2015) S11 E9 O Brother, Where Art Thou? (Aired December 9, 2015) S11 E10 The Devil in the Details (Aired January 20th, 2016)
23.5-Carried Away Summary: One strong drink. Too much honesty. Zero dignity. Sam’s arms make up for the rest.
24-Only a Few Things Have to Line Up Summary: A retirement home, a banshee, and a hunter who almost takes Sam's head off before she shakes his hand. When Eileen Leahy shows up, you have a split second to decide: gun or trust. Season 11 Episode 11 Into the Mystic in the Accidentally a Winchester Series Alternate Universe. Meeting Eileen - This time Sam doesn't get her digits because he's already taken!
24.5-It’s You, Sammy, but Psychedelic Summary: Sam gets a painting. Dean gets some meta cast trivia that blows his mind. *Bonus: See my first fanart (a painting of Sam)
25-Try Living With Them Note: This is from S11 E12 "Don't You Forget About Me" Summary: Reader's first time meeting Jody Mills. Awkward introduction, followed by an awkward dinner conversation.
S11 E13 Love Hurts (Aired February 10th, 2016) S11 E14 The Vessel (Aired February 10th, 2016)
25.5-At Least She Didn't Say Spike Note: This is from S11 E15 Beyond the Mat (Aired February 24, 2016) Summary: Sam and Dean go to a wrestler's funeral and find a case. You have some thoughts about who Sam ran into there.
26-You Heard Me Summary: You get kidnapped by demons, signal Sam, and learn that the only way to stop Crowley might also kill you.
26.5-Apocalypse Library and the Unicorn Summary: A brilliant idea turns into an unfinished project, a disaster-zone, and a guilt spiral. Sam brings food, practical solutions, and a kinder perspective.
S11 E16 Safe House (Aired March 23, 2016)
27-Only Mostly Dead Note: This is from S11 E17 "Red Meat" Summary: Sam and Dean battle a pair of werewolves while you rescue captured two victims. One of the werewolves shoots Sam. Dean gets everyone out of the house but learns a pack of werewolves are hot on your tail.
S11 E18 Hell's Angel (Aired April 6, 2016) S11 E19 The Chitters (Aired April 27, 2016) S11 E20 Don't Call Me Shurley - (Aired May 4, 2016) S11 E21 All in the Family - (Aired May 11, 2016)
27.5-What He Needs to Think Note: Set in S11 E21 All in the Family, but only includes original scenes. You've come from here, a world where Supernatural is a TV Show. Now you're in their world. You meet Chuck and he knows he didn't create you. So you find out how he explains it. A conversation about creation, existence, and Dean's emergency pie.
S11 E22 We Happy Few - (Aired May 18, 2016)
28-Accent in a Pantsuit Note: This is from S11 E23 "Alpha and Omega", S12 E1 "Keep Calm and Carry On", and S12 E2 "Mamma Mia" Dean faces Amara in an attempt to end her. Sam is shot and captured by the Toni from the British Men of Letters. You, Castiel, Dean, and Mary find and then attempt to rescue him.
S12 E03 The Foundry (Aired October 27th, 2016)
28.5 You Don't Have to Hide Alone Angry cleaning. It's a thing. Apparently it's also a trigger. Who knew. Sam, as it turns out. Of course, he knows what to say.
S12 E04 American Nightmare (Aired November 3, 2016) S12 E05 The One You've Been Waiting For (Aired November 10, 2016)
29-Sam's Girl Dean Winchester does not have feelings. He's just been spending a lot of time in the garage lately. For reasons. Unfortunately, Dean Winchester has never been as subtle as he thinks he is.
S12 E06 Celebrating the Life of Asa Fox (Aired November 17th, 2016)
29.5 Burgers, Dean. It's Burgers Note: Takes place in LA during S12 E07 Rock Never Dies You're in Los Angeles to stop Lucifer, hoping the city sparks some memories. You've probably been here before. The burgers remember, even if you don't.
S12 E08 Lotus (Aired December 8, 2016) S12 E09 First Blood (Aired January 26, 2017) S12 E10 Lily Sunder Has Some Regrets (Aired February 2, 2017)
30-Everybody Loves Dorry Note: This is from S12 E11 Regarding Dean (Aired February 9, 2017) Dean got hexed. He rode a mechanical bull, forgot what a lamp is called, and thinks hunting monsters sounds like the best job ever. You'd find it funnier if you weren't terrified. You know what it looks like when someone starts to disappear.
31-It's Silver. You Lose. Donna calls in a favor. You drive to Chattanooga all thinking werewolves. You're all wrong. But you figure that out before anyone else does.
32-The Worst Memory You wake up in a hospital not knowing Sam, not knowing Dean, and convinced it’s two years ago, right after the worst day of your life. Sam helps you find your way back to this world, and to him.
FUTURE POSTS IN THE SERIES Already Written: (May change)
S12 E12 Stuck in the Middle (With You) S12 E13 Family Feud
33-I'll Grab My Jacket Note: This is from S12 E14 The Raid
S12 E15 Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell S12 E16 Ladies Drink Free
34-Some Version of Me
S12 E17 The British Invasion (Aired April 6, 2017)
35-Supernatural Delight (Proposal) 36-Don't Forget The Ring
S12 E18 The Memory Remains (Aired April 13, 2017) S12 E19 The Future (Aired April 27, 2017) S12 E20 Twigs & Twine & Tasha Banes (Aired May 4, 2017) S12 E21 There's Something About Mary (Aired May 11, 2017) S12 E22 Who We Are (Aired May 18, 2017) S12 E23 All Along the Watchtower (Aired May 18, 2017) S13 E02 The Rising Son S13 E03 Patience S13 E04 The Big Empty S13 E05 Advanced Thanatology S13 E06 Tombstone S13 E07 War of the Worlds S13 E08 The Scorpion and the Frog
37 Tastes Like Lizard Note: This is from S13 E09 The Bad Place-S13 E10 Wayward Sisters
S13 E11 Breakdown S13 E12 Various & Sundry Villains S13 E13 Devil's Bargain S13 E14 Good Intentions S13 E15 A Most Holy Man S13 E16 Scoobynatural S13 E17 The Thing S13 E18 Bring 'em Back Alive S13 E19 Funeralia S13 E20 Unfinished Business
38 Where Sam Is Note: This is from S13 E21 Beat the Devil-S13 E22 Exodus
