now that the house of cards on 99% of bylr 'analysis' has officially collapsed are we ready to have a conversation about how weird this fandom's construction of "the GA" is
the idea that only the special and smart internet nerds can understand media and the masses are all sheeple getting gruel shoveled into their faces that they can't put together half a real thought about is like. not progressive. it's the opposite of progressive. it's anti-democratic and a vision of the world that would make the necessary coalition-building and solidarity that make political movements actually effective impossible.
did that get too real too fast
I'm not going to talk about this for too long bc I would just be laundering the ideas of Lyta Gold, a writer on the beat of taste and mass/nerd culture who has really influenced my thinking on this and whose book I actually already quoted on this blog look I like what I like. but annoyingly all of her writing on this specific topic is paywalled I think. but read her book!!
from a paywalled post on her substack
in my experience, because I like to approach the world and my fellow humans with curiosity and interest, most people's taste and opinions about fiction are particular and surprising on an individual level - including and maybe even especially people who are not existing in the spaces with the same consensus opinions as you. yes, that is not true of everyone, sometimes people are just annoying, and social media algorithms and the incentive structures on like reddit make it all annoying in aggregate and interesting conversations impossible, but that doesn't mean that actually is that meaningful or important.
(caveat there are things about most of the internet being actively hostile to interesting nuanced conversation or genuine connection that are important but it's still not that we are so smart and everyone else is stupid)
this comes back to the "centering real people" thing but what is actually meaningful and important is not harassing people even if they might think a piece of fiction is going to end in a different way than you. it's not thinking you're better than people who get swept up in groupthink conspiratorial thinking because oh wait, looks like many of you did. it's realizing that "media literacy" is actually way more about having the ability to evaluate whether information is accurate from a legitimate source and not spread misinformation versus reading subtextual codes that straight white male showrunners may or may not be encoding in their mainstream tv shows.
the other great thing about acknowledging this is you are not hanging your entire identity on the outcome of one piece of imperfect popular entertainment which I'll say is to me a huge upside.