The plot (there's a plot???) thickens!
(Read on AO3 as well!)
Seth/Richie/Kate; Kate/Richie; Kate/Seth; Seth/Richie; Richie/Kisa (sorta); Seth/Vanessa Styles (mentioned); Kate/Kyle Winthrop (background)
Rated: E for Explicit | Dead Dove: Do Not Eat; Underage sex/alcohol/drug use; explicit sexual content/language; violence; threesomes; love triangles; OT3; incest; AU - High School; AU - No Supernatural; 90s AU; slow burn; angst and fluff and smut; coming of age; school dances; concerts; road trips; teen pregnancy; miscarriage; discussion of abortion; semi-public sex; infidelity; implied/referenced child abuse; attempted sexual assault; eventual HEA
It’s the summer of ‘97. The move to Houston is supposed to be a fresh start after Mama’s death, but between their Daddy’s drinking and starting at a brand new school in the sprawling metropolis, Kate and Scott Fuller are left on their own. Scott’s pulling away from them all and running with a bad crowd, and Kate? She has no idea where she fits in anymore. It isn't until she strikes up an unlikely friendship with a pair of rebellious brothers that she realizes she might not need to.
| Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16
good men die, too (I'd rather be with you) part 17
It was only a few days after her visit to the boys’ house that she got the note.
They were running late for Algebra, having been stopped by her Spanish teacher last block for a quick chat - apparently she was leaps and bounds ahead of the other students, and Ms. Mendoza had wanted to compliment Kate on her progress.
As she whipped open her locker, Richie, having finally recovered from his bout with food poisoning, was in his usual spot leaning against Rafa’s locker. When the door opened, a piece of folded up paper tumbled out and fell to the floor at her feet.
Sighing in exasperation, Kate knelt to scoop it up, and was about to stand back up so she could chuck it in her locker - probably an old piece of homework, she’d already decided - when she saw her name printed in perfect, flourishing cursive across the front.
Brow furrowing, Kate slowly stood. “What’s up?” Asked Richie, straightening off the locker abruptly. She could feel him watching her. “You do know we’re running late, right?”
“Yeah,” she replied distractedly. Leaning back out of the shadow of her locker, she slid the piece of paper open out of its intricate folds. Richie leaned over her to watch what she was doing.
The letter wasn’t long; it was written in the same elaborate, graceful hand as her name. It read:
I thought you should know that your new boyfriend already has a girlfriend. He’s a chronic liar, so it falls to me to tell you the truth. I’m sorry you had to find out this way. - S.
For a few prolonged moments, all Kate could do was stare down at the paper, completely baffled. She’d barely begun to process it all in her head - boyfriend? What, Kyle? - when Richie tugged it out of her grasp, and held the paper out in front of him, eyes traveling rapidly over the lines. He too stared at it for a few seconds, then his head fell back, and he groaned to the ceiling. “Oh, fucking A.”
“You know what they’re talking about? ‘Cause I don’t have a clue.”
His head came back down, and held the paper up to their eye level, his own rolling. “Kate, meet Sonja. Sonja, meet Kate.”
“Huh?” She saw the delicately swirling S at the bottom, and suddenly she remembered that moment in the bathroom the other week, when Kisa had come storming in. It wasn’t Sonja, was it?
Kate had wondered who Sonja was, of course, but that brief, throwaway line had been forgotten in favor of the larger picture at the time. She’d just been punched in the face, after all.
“Who - who’s Sonja? And why is she sending me notes?”
Richie sighed, a weary, long-suffering sound. “She’s Seth’s ex. Sort of.”
Kate’s brows lifted. “How can she be sort of an ex? And again, why is she sending - “
“They dated for like, three weeks. Then Seth dropped her ass. Good fucking riddance, if you ask me.” He flicked the note in his hand. “She’s bat-shit crazy. Way worse than Vanessa.”
Blinking, Kate looked back down at the note. “So she, what, thinks Seth’s my boyfriend? That’s…” Impossible, she thought, ignoring anything else she might have felt about the matter.
“Yeah. She did this with Vanessa, too, except she - “ he stopped abruptly, and Kate looked up at him.
“She…what?”
Richie sighed, and rolled his eyes again. “She tried to convince Vanessa that he was gay, is what,” he said flatly.
Before she could stop it, a choked laugh escaped her. “Has she seen his room?” She wasn’t sure how posters of a scantily-clad Cindy Crawford and Pamela Anderson could convince anyone he wasn’t straight.
His lip curled in a mocking grin. “A better question might be ‘has she seen his porn stash?’”
Kate sputtered and felt her pulse spike, which she knew was his goal. The bastard. Then, as she gained control of herself again, a little pang beneath her ribcage made itself known. This girl probably had seen Seth’s room, just like Vanessa. It wasn’t as if he was a total leper; both he and Richie could be deceptively charming when they put their minds to it - bright, dangerous things that drew the eye before you remembered to be careful. Seth wore that charm easily, like a jacket he could shrug on and off.
Richie…Richie was different. He could do it - she was certain of that. She’d seen flashes of it, quick and sharp and unexpectedly disarming. But more often than not, in crowded rooms or noisy spaces, he seemed to draw inward instead, shoulders tightening as if the world was closing in on him. When Seth was there with them, it seemed to ease a fraction, like he was borrowing Seth’s armor for just a bit.
He didn’t sand himself down for people. Didn’t stretch himself thin just to fit. And some small, stubborn part of her was glad he didn’t.
But the thought of either of them turning that easy magnetism on someone else made her chest ache - a quiet, insistent squeeze. Ever since that day she’d gone over to check on Richie, she’d found herself more aware of him, in ways that made her pulse stutter; similar to the way she noticed Seth - and it was irritating, distracting, and entirely unnecessary.
She forced herself to let it go. Didn’t tug at the thread. Let it lie, shoved the feeling neatly aside, and focused on the matter at hand.
“Okay,” she began, carefully neutral, pointedly glossing over his last comment, “should I be worried about this?” She gestured toward the paper still in Richie’s possession. “Because Kisa mentioned something about Sonja hitting me.”
Richie blinked exactly once at the mention of Kisa, but otherwise didn’t react. He gave a one-shouldered shrug. “She and Vanessa got into it once, is all.”
“Oh, that’s all, huh?” Kate responded with liberally-applied sarcasm. Then, “good grief,” she muttered to herself, eyeing the note with a newfound apprehension.
Richie’s eyes caught hers, sharp and bright behind his glasses, and he straightened as he folded his arms, shoulders stretching the fabric of his tee. Suddenly she remembered him in the restroom that day, how gentle he’d been when he cleaned her face, and the same strength and precision he’d shown when he tugged off his shirt, muscles shifting like coiled wire.
Kate blinked and dragged her attention back to the present, before those thoughts could grow any more complicated.
Now, in the stance of someone utterly serious and protective, that same careful, deliberate energy was directed toward her again. “Do you really think we’d let her pull that shit with you?”
She swallowed and had to glance away from him, then, ducking away from the intensity of those eyes. But the weight of the words didn’t need to be loud to hit home; for a heartbeat, Seth didn’t exist - only Richie, hands steady and careful, both with her and with the knife he’d wielded. She felt it all in her chest: her heartbeat loud, warmth rushing, the undeniable gravity of him focused entirely on her. It left her a little breathless.
“I can handle myself,” she said, more quietly than she’d meant to. She cleared her throat, and deliberately kept her eyes steady on the note, praying he hadn’t noticed.
There was a pause, and she felt him studying her. “I know,” he finally replied.
He looked down at the letter again, jaw tightening slightly. “But,” he added quietly, “she’s not wrong about one thing.”
Kate blinked, refocusing on him. “What?”
“She’s jealous.” He met her eyes, raising his brows.
“And she should be.”
The words hung there a second longer than they probably should have.
Kate felt them, the words, through her entire body, as if she’d stuck her finger in a live socket. She was reminded suddenly, forcefully, of his face when he’d told her: it’s better when you’re here.
For a second she just stared at him, wondering if he’d meant to say that out loud.
Richie seemed to realize, belatedly, that he’d let that come out completely unfiltered. He made a noise low in his throat, as if he’d startled himself, and clumsily adjusted his glasses. “Not - not like that,” he said quickly - too quickly, fumbling over his own words. “I just mean…”
His shoulders rolled, shrugging off something heavier than the conversation called for. Kate told her heart to calm the hell down, already, and pay attention to what he was trying to say. Richie - and Seth, for that matter - sometimes had a roundabout way of getting to the point of things - there were normally movie references involved - and this seemed to be no different. There would be time to overanalyze her own reaction later.
Richie blew out a hard breath, trying again. “We’ve never really had a friend who’s a girl before,” he said slowly, as if reciting each word in his head before it came out of his mouth. There wasn’t any particular emphasis on the word, but Kate heard it anyway. We.
Kate tilted her head. “You’ve known girls before.” She kept her tone light, her eyes on his face.
He cleared his throat, his own gaze shunting away for a brief moment before coming back to her. “Yeah, but that’s different.”
“How?”
He made a vague gesture with the note. “They’re either dating Seth, or trying to date him, or trying to kill each other.” A pause. “You’re…not doing any of that.”
“That you know of,” she countered, aiming for flippant. But something in the back of her mind took note of the wording: dating Seth or trying to. He’d excluded himself from that statement. Did that mean he’d never -
A faint smirk flickered across his face, grateful for the out. “Exactly. Uncharted territory.”
Then he shrugged a shoulder. “We’ve just,” he went on, softer now, “never had a friend like you.”
There it was. Quieter. Honest.
He didn’t look at her when he said it.
Kate felt heat creep up the back of her neck - not embarrassment, but something else. Something warmer.
She folded the letter in half and reached for her locker. “Well,” she said lightly, because she didn’t trust herself to say anything heavier, “I’d hate to be the cause of a full-scale riot.”
Richie huffed a laugh. “We’ll try to avoid that.” But his eyes flicked down the hallway - scanning.
Just in case.
In the end, Kate decided to wait until school was out before showing Seth the note. Richie agreed. Seth was gonna go postal no matter what, and she didn’t want it to be in the middle of Trig.
One thing she didn’t want either boy doing, she’d decided, was confront Sonja. The girl had contacted her, not them. It was her mess to sort through. When she told Richie as much, his mouth had twisted, as if tasting something bitter. “But - “
“No. Is it your name on that note? It’s mine. I’ll talk to her. Girl to girl.”
It had taken him a good minute to agree. His shoulders tense, he’d eyed her, as if doubting her ability to handle such a scenario. “Face it, Richie, you wouldn’t talk so much as loom.”
Richie had, predictably, crossed his arms at this, brows furrowing. “That's just my face.” He'd muttered. Then,
“Besides, I'd be talking plenty. It's called threatening.”
Kate had rocked back on her heels to eye him, mouth twitching despite herself. “Exactly,” she’d stated dryly. “No threatening.” She gestured at him vaguely. “No…whatever this whole ‘ominous bodyguard’ thing you’ve got going on is.”
He had huffed loudly, but looked a little pleased with himself, nonetheless. Kate shook her head at him, smile finally winning out. “You’re ridiculous.”
Kate waited until they were almost to the Mustang before pulling the note out of her bag. Richie, on Seth’s other side, saw what she was doing and grimaced at her. Brace yourself.
She did just that, and without a word, not even daring to look at him, held the folded-up letter where Seth could see it without breaking stride.
Seth glanced down at it as he pulled out his keys. “What,” he grunted. She just continued to brandish it in his direction. Rolling his eyes a little, Seth took the paper in his free hand, flipping it over, inspecting it, brows furrowed. Immediately Kate slipped a hand beneath his arm and kept him moving forward. Richie dropped a little bit behind them both, eyes on Seth’s back.
She felt it when he began to slow, staring at the front of the note in consternation. Groaning under her breath, she tightened her grip, propelling him on. But Seth, being decidedly bigger than her, suddenly stopped dead in his tracks in the middle of the parking lot, and ripped open the note with a loud swear.
With a resigned sigh, she glanced back at Richie, who had stopped too and was waiting with folded arms.
It only took Seth a few seconds to read the brief missive, then he was whipping around to face her, face a thundercloud. “What the fuck.”
She made a face at him. “I got that in my locker earlier today. Thought you might want to know.”
But Seth was already snarling, spinning around around on his heel before she’d even finished her sentence, doing the exact thing she and Richie had thought he would do. With an exasperated sigh, Richie snagged the back of Seth’s coat as he blew past him, using his momentum against him as he swung him around in a half circle, until Seth, stumbling, was pointed back in the direction he’d originally been facing.
“Goddammit, Richard, not now!” He tried again, yielding the exact same results. Kate struggled not to laugh as Seth yanked his jacket from Richie’s hand, and wheeled around a third time.
“Okay, so this is why I didn’t tell you earlier. Seth, stop!” She latched onto his arm, putting her weight behind it. “She’s probably gone home already, just slow down, okay?”
He spun abruptly back around to face her, nearly knocking her off-balance. Immediately his hand shot out, grabbing her by her elbow, steadying her. “Jesus, watch it,” he grumbled, seeming to conveniently overlook the fact that he was the one who had pulled at her. But despite his gruff demeanor, his grip was gentle.
Kate scoffed lightly, but he was already letting go of her to scowl down at the note still clenched in his fist. Then he shot an accusatory look over his shoulder. “You knew about this?” He fired at Richie.
“I was standing right there with her when it fell outta her locker. What was I supposed to do, avert my eyes?”
Kate cut him a dry look, but Seth was steamrolling ahead. “And you didn’t think to mention it to me?”
Kate groaned. “Okay, before this turns into a whole - ”
“Kate,” Seth said, not taking his eyes off his brother, “how long?”
Richie answered before she could; he shrugged one shoulder. “Since second block.”
Seth stared at him. “Second - ” He cut himself off, sounding incredulous. “You sat through half the day knowing this psycho was leaving notes in her locker and didn’t say anything?”
Richie folded his arms, looking unimpressed. “You know, you’re reacting exactly how we thought you would.”
Kate pointed between them. “Yes. That. Exhibit A.”
Seth looked back at her like he’d just remembered she was there.
“She went into your locker.”
“It’s not Fort Knox, Seth.”
“That’s not the point.”
“No,” Richie said dryly from behind them, “the point is you trying to start a fistfight in the fucking parking lot.”
Seth swung his head toward him. “You think this is funny?”
“I think,” Richie replied evenly, “that she’s already gone home and you punching a locker isn’t gonna solve it.”
For a moment Seth just stood there, breathing hard, the note crumpled in his fist. Kate could see his shoulders squared aggressively beneath his jacket. Then he looked back at Kate again, eyes sharp. “She been bothering you before this?”
“No. I didn’t even know who she was up until Richie told me.”
That didn’t seem to help. Seth’s scowl deepened. “Yeah, well, that doesn’t mean much. She coulda tried to talk to you without introducing herself.”
Kate stared, the corners of her mouth twitching despite herself. “Seth - “
“He’s right,” Richie chimed in flatly. “Sounds like something she’d do.”
Now she stared at both of them. Then she threw her hands up in the air, speeding up so that she was ahead of the two. “You’re both paranoid. Really, actually paranoid.”
“It’s not paranoia if you’re right,” the boys said together, voices grim.
Despite her irritation, she couldn’t help but laugh as she spun back around, walking backwards. “Remind me never to discuss JFK with you two,” she said, shaking her head.
Seth immediately cut in, frowning, distracted for a split second. “Grassy knoll, obviously.”
Richie held up a finger like a lecturer. “Well, technically, it’s more complicated than that—”
Kate rolled her eyes so hard she almost saw the back of her skull. “Yeah, thanks, history professors. I’ll make sure to bring popcorn next time.”
She took another step back -
- and immediately felt a hand catch her elbow, steering her sharply to the side as a car rolled past behind her.
“Would you kindly turn around before you eat concrete or get flattened?” Richie griped.
Kate huffed, but let him guide her, turning back around and falling into step again, this time between the two.
The parking lot stretched out ahead of them, late afternoon light slanting low, students thinning out toward their cars. Normal. Everything looked normal. Which made the note feel even more ridiculous.
“For the record,” she said, resettling her bag against her, “this is exactly why I didn’t tell you earlier.”
“Because you thought I’d react?” Seth said flatly.
“Because I knew you would,” she retorted tartly. Beside her, Richie made a soft humming noise of agreement.
Seth didn’t respond to that. He just walked a little faster, jaw tight. Kate glanced at him out of the corner of her eye. He was still wound up. Still halfway in that place where everything became a problem he had to fix, immediately, preferably with force.
It was…a lot. But it was also -
She pressed her lips together, looking away before she could finish that thought.
Seth stabbed the key into the Mustang’s lock a little harder than necessary. The metal clicked with a sharp sound that made Kate wince, just slightly. Fortunately for everyone, he didn’t miss and scratch the paint.
He yanked open the driver’s door, then paused and looked back at her.
“She doesn’t get to bother you,” he said roughly.
Kate blinked. “Seth - ”
“No,” he said, sharper now. “She doesn’t.”
The certainty in his voice made something in her chest tighten - a bit of annoyance, yes, but something else threaded through it. Something warmer, more complicated, that she didn’t really feel like examining too closely.
Richie leaned against the roof of the car, arms folded. “That’s…more or less the point I’ve been trying to make all afternoon.”
Kate looked between them, exasperated now. “I can handle one jealous ex-girlfriend, you know.”
Seth just looked at her, face set in a familiar scowl. “That’s not the point.”
There it was again - that thing where he decided what the point was and refused to budge from it. Kate opened her mouth, then closed it again.
Because arguing with that version of Seth was like arguing with a brick wall that thought it was doing you a favor.
Richie pushed off the hood of the car and leaned to open the passenger side door, then practically fell into the back, sprawling out like a big cat. “Just look on the bright side,” he said, as Kate climbed into the front. “You’ve officially made it onto Sonja’s enemies list.”
Kate rolled her eyes. Seth said nothing, mouth in a grim line as he tossed his bag into the back beside Richie.
“That’s basically a rite of passage around here,” Richie continued blithely, as if he hadn’t spent the whole morning just as pissed off as Seth was now.
Kate finally craned her neck to look back at him, scowling. “You’re not helping.”
“I’m trying to add perspective.”
Seth dropped into the driver’s seat with a huff, slamming the door a little harder than strictly necessary. “The perspective is she needs to leave Kate the hell alone, or fucking else.”
From the back seat, Richie leaned forward between them, resting his arms on the backs of their seats. “See?” he said mildly. “He’s back to threatening already.”
Seth glanced at him in the rear-view mirror. “You’re one comment away from walking home.”
Richie smirked and leaned back again.
Kate shook her head. “You two are exhausting.”
From the back seat, Richie said mildly, “And yet you keep hanging out with us.”
Kate pointed a finger over her shoulder without even turning around. “Don’t push your luck, Gecko.”
Richie just laughed.
Next week: A conversation with Kisa changes Kate's perspective somewhat.














