chapter two
contents: fluff, angst, graphic content such as blood, violence, murder, and all things ghostface series masterlist | previous part | next part
She knew she was in trouble when she had woken up in Wes' bed the next morning. Not only that, but the idea of updating her mother on her whereabouts slipped her mind, and there was nothing but missed phone calls from her mother all night. The fact that Judy was the one to wake her and Wes with a disappointed frown is a cherry on top of the cake.
"Next time you stay the night, please tell your mom and I," is what Judy had softly said to the teenager before she offered her a ride home. The car ride is completely silent between the Sheriff and her son's girlfriend. The entire town around them is barely awake as it's only the early morning of Saturday. The only car on the road is the Sheriff's, which luckily makes every green light to cut the trip short.
The teenager opens the door once the car parks in her driveway, tucking her phone into the pocket of Wes' hoodie. She grabs her bookbag, glancing at the woman briefly, "I'm sorry."
"It's alright, hon," Judy assures her, a soft smile on her face. "I'll see you for dinner on Monday? I can teach you how to make those lemon bars then."
"I wouldn't miss it for the world," Athena tells her, returning the smile with a nod. And she starts the walk to her front door. She takes a sharp inhale once she opens the door, knowing her mother is a few steps into the house waiting for her.
Margaret is waiting with a coffee in her hand. She sits at the kitchen island, rubbing her forehead tiredly. Now, the lonely woman always looks tired, but it seems to take more of an effect on her appearance when there's a worriedsome feeling upon her mind. Her eyes are shut, and oddly enough avoiding the photograph of her brother she's always stuck on. Her blue eyes open, looking at her daughter.
"I'm sorry, mom," she apologizes with a sincere tone. She slides into the chair at the kitchen island, letting her chin fall into her hands. "I fell asleep early, and I didn't hear my phone ringing."
"It's okay. I remember being young and in love," her mother says, a sadness appearing in her eyes at the memories of her former husband. He had passed away ten years prior. "Just be glad you don't have a protective older brother."
And for the first time that morning, Margaret looks at the photo of her older brother with a smile. It's the first time she's ever shown a positive emotion looking at it, as though she no longer feels the need to hide the fact that she misses him from her daughter.
"Stu probably would've dragged you from Wes' house exactly when your curfew hit," she continues to add on, wondering how different life would be if he were still alive. If Ghostface had never been a thing. If the town wasn't plagued in darkness. "Your dad would've, too."
"Poor Wes would be terrified," the teenager cuts in, chuckling at the idea of it. She could almost see the horror on his face at the sight of the two older males. "I think they would've scared him away before our first date."
"No," her mother disagrees. There's a sincerity in her tone that causes her daughter's heart to warm up, at not only the thought of the situation taking place, but at her mother's acceptance of her relationship. "Wes still would've stuck around. He would do anything for you. He's a good guy."
"He is," the blonde nods, her voice barely audible.
"Your dad and Stu would've liked him — at least, the Stu that I knew. They approve of him, I can feel it in my bones," Margaret smiles softly, moving around the counter to press a gentle kiss to her teenager's head. "Just stay home this weekend, okay? No friends, no boyfriend. Please."
And despite knowing she'd be missing the first Sunday movie night with Amber and Tara in a while, she agrees without argument.
She has her earbuds in as she sits on her beg, arms crossed around her knees to hug them into her chest. Her laptop is opened on the bed in front of her, propped up on some pillow with the screen brightly lit to display the faces of her friends, Amber and Tara.
Athena ignores their voices, her bottom lip brought into her mouth as she bites down nervously. Her eyes are stuck to her phone, waiting for it to light up with the name she hadn't heard from since this morning. She feels sick as her mind flips through every worse case scenario — more specifically, the fear of a silent breakup plaguing her brain.
"Maybe not hearing from him is a good thing," Amber's voice is the first thing she registers as she comes to a realization on her friend's silence. She has always been the type of friend to know exactly the problem without being told. "You guys are constantly together. A little time apart might be good for you."
"We're not constantly together," Athena argues, eyebrows furrowing at the hostility behind her friend's tone. It takes her off guard, curious on the sudden change of Amber's opinion on her boyfriend. "It's just he's not even reading my texts, and he always responds right away."
"Don't stress about it," Tara reassures her friend, playing her typical role of middle-man and peacemaker in the group. "He's probably just in trouble from you staying the night. You know how his mom gets."
"Yeah," the blonde teen mutters into the skin of her knee. Still, an anxious burning in her chest spreads like a forest fire. To try to tame the fire from reaching her mind, she changes the subject. "I'm bumbed about missing movie night."
"I know," Tara agrees with a small frown. "We can't finish the last Saw movie without you there, so we'll have to pick something else."
"Are you sure you can't just sneak out to miss it?" Amber questions, her voice coming out in a softer tone than before. "None of us have missed a movie night in forever. We can't break the streak now."
"Mom's got me on a strict room arrest. She keeps checking on me every twenty minutes," the grounded teenager mumbles, although her words are quite and exaggeration. Her eyes roll slightly at the punishment from her mom, despite knowing it's completely understandable.
And there's a soft knock, too quiet to place at first. Athena goes silent, glancing from her door to her computer in confusion. The second her eyes glance to the window, her expression and body visibly relax. The window silently slides open, and she winces — there's no way her friends have missed the sound of it.
Amber's face drops with a loud sigh, but the other's face brightens up with a teasing smile. Tara laughs, "Have fun with lover-boy."
Her friends disappear from the screen, leaving the blank call screen with just her face. She shuts the computer, ripping out her earbuds with a smile. She puts the device on her bedside table, watching as her boyfriend stealthily climbs into her room. "I thought you were mad at me or something."
Wes frowns, sliding his shoes off before he lays next to her sitting position on the bed. His hand trails up her bare leg, stopping at her thigh. "Why would I be mad at you?"
"You haven't responded to my texts. I don't know, I just thought you blamed me for us getting in trouble," the teenage girl tells her boyfriend, her brown eyes staring into his blue.
"Well, I don't," he assures her, letting out a content sigh as his head falls onto the pillows on the bed. "My mom took my phone, told me that I can't be having you spend the night without permission."
Her face changes, her smile shifting to a playful smirk. She twists her body, throwing one leg over his waist as she straddles him. "So, you're telling me that you snuck out to come see me?"
"Actually," Wes starts, grabbing her waist to bring her down to lay her down on him. "My mom dropped me off. She wasn't too thrilled, but she did it anyways."
Her face is close to his, their chests pressed against one another's. Her jaw drops mockingly, her next response almost a whisper, "Sheriff Hicks encouraging her son's misbehavior?"
"She told me if I get caught and throw her under the bus, she'd literally throw me under a bus and kill me." At her boyfriend's words, she laughs. While the words seem uncharacteristic for Sheriff Hicks, the teenage girl could almost hear her say them.
"You do know my mom will kill us if she finds out you're here, right?" Athena asks, her lips brushing against his slightly. "I mean, she even told me I can't hang out with Amber and Tara tomorrow."
"I'm sure if I tell her we have this awesome date planned for tomorrow she'll let you out of the house. And then I can just drop you off at Tara's," Wes suggests. The plan escapes his mouth so naturally and smooth, like a line taken directly from the perfect boyfriend in a romance novel.
The girl smiles, feeling her chest warm at the fact that her boyfriend would do something like that for her. "I love you," she blurts out, pressing a soft kiss to his lips briefly. "But I'd rather just actually go out on an awesome date with you."
"I love you too, so that can definitely be arranged," he agrees, already planning certain ideas in his mind. However, he notices her lack of wanting time with her best friend's. "You don't want to go to movie night?"
"I'd rather spend time with my totally awesome boyfriend," she begins, pressing another quick kiss to his lips, "Who I apparently spend too much time with according to Amber."
He frowns, eyebrows furrowing as he looks up at his girlfriend. "Amber? Why does she think that?"
"Cause I thought you were mad at me and not answering and she didn't see a problem," she quickly rambles, cheeks flushing in slight embarrassment. "Anyways, besides the point, it's none of her concern how much time we spend together. She's my best friend and I love her, but she has no right telling me about my relationship."
"It's cause she thinks I'm not good enough for you," Wes tells her, a slight sadness and disappointment in his tone. "She has their weird thing with you and Tara. No one is ever good enough for either of you, and everyone is always out to get you guys."
The couple both frown. The friend group is small, and the fact that only Amber finds a problem in their relationship is hard for them to get over. Amber is one of her closest friends and Wes is the love of her life, and so the problem between them is hard to ignore.
Athena smiles, grabbing Wes's face gently. She kisses him longingly and slowly. She stops for a brief second to tell him, "It doesn't matter what she thinks. You're everything to me."












