#scream 5

one evening, after finishing an english homework assignment in your dorm, your phone buzzes on cue. you smile, glad to be out of your academic bumble.

chad

hey, come over?

my roommate is out, it'll just be you and me.

your lips curve into a smirk with heat pooling low in your belly at the thought. you type back quickly, almost too quick.

y/n

on my way :D

during sports psych, your eyes always drifted to chad's hands as he wrote down notes from the table in-front of you sometimes. right now, you can imagine those big hands on you, knowing the way he makes you feel so safe and wanted.

you grab your black jacket with your heart racing as you head across campus to their own off-campus apartment away from yours, with the cool night air doing nothing to dampen the anticipation building inside you.

twenty minutes later when you knock, chad opens the door with a happy and familiar grin, with his broad shoulders filling the frame.

he's wearing a simple black t-shirt that clings to his chest, with jeans slung low on his hips. you're wearing a black jacket, with black foldover leggings, a typical outfit.

"hey, you," he says, pulling you inside with a soft kiss on your cheek.

the apartment smells like fresh coffee and his cologne, comforting and inviting as you follow him into the living room, where the brown couch sits against the wall, plush and worn from countless lazy nights from him and his roommate.

"hey, chad. how are you?" you ask, sitting down on his couch as he flops right beside you, so close to where your thigh is touching his.

"oh i'm wonderful! how about you? what'd you do today?" he asks, one hand moving to rub up and down your upper thigh, the other is stretched on the back of his couch.

you break a smile, "oh nothing much, I had my communications lecture, then I got all of my homework done before the 11:59 due date.

"you got all of your homework done?" chad hypes, "good girl," he murmurs after.

somewhere underneath the hype and happiness of his voice, there was a hidden note that you did not notice. this was a set up, and chad was nearly excited for what was going to happen next.

you nod, settling onto the couch, but before you can lean in for more from chad, a door creaks open down the hall.

ethan steps out, his dark eyes locking onto you like a predator spotting prey.

at first, your eyes didn't notice the familiar guy, just the fact that he's shirtless, with grey sweatpants hanging loose and his lean muscles flexing as he crosses his arms.

once you notice the arms, your eyes go wide.

"surprise!," ethan drawls, a smirk twisting his lips as he notices the shock plastered on your face. your stomach drops, with that shock freezing you in place. how—? they're roommates?

the realization hits like ice water poured over the head with your body still frozen as you stare between them.

"what the hell?" you blurt, voice pitching higher than intended, "you two… you know each other? how—?"

chad chuckles softly, sitting beside you on the couch, his hand resting possessively on your thigh.

"oh, sweetheart, we've been roommates for a year so far. close friends, too. you really thought you could play us like that? talking to both of us behind the other's back?" the footballer player's tone is gentle, almost pitying, but there's a condescending lilt in that voice which makes you squirm.

ethan saunters over, towering above you as he leans against the arm of the brown couch, caging you in-between the two men.

"naughty girl, aren't you? you've been fucking me for months and turns out after showing my good roommate here a picture of you, I find out that you've been trying to get into his pants too.." ethan laughs before continuing, "you thought you could have it all without consequences, huh?"

the white guy's words have a bite, almost forced anger, but there's a hint of amusement that softens the meanness making it feel like playful scolding rather than outright cruelty.

you open your mouth to protest with your cheekbones burning with humiliation, but chad's fingers tighten on your leg, silencing you.

"shh, no excuses... we know everything down to your flirty texts, the late-night calls, and how you invited ethan to your apartment multiple times already... you're ours now, y/n." he claims.

you look to your right, at ethan who looks at chad with a smirk, "is it time to teach our girl a lesson?"

"yep... time for a lesson." chad mocks with a sweet poison that makes your pulse thunder.

ethan grabs your chin at that moment, forcing you to meet his bright brown eyes from above, "you're going to learn not to mess around with us. get on your knees, now, show us how sorry you are." the econ major's grip is firm, a little rough and you whimper as you slide off the couch onto the carpet, with your knees hitting the soft dark green rug as they both stand over you, pulling down their pants in unison.

chad's cock springs free first, so heavy, dark and veined and already half-hard with the excitement from this exposure of you. he strokes it lazily, thumbing the tip as he looks down at you with that infuriatingly kind smile. "that's it, baby.... open up for me. you know you want to make it right." his voice is coaxing and condescending like he's praising a petulant child, rather than a girl who got caught talking to his roommate.

you part your lips, tongue darting out to lick the underside of chad's shaft for the first time, tasting the salty bead of pre-cum at the head. ethan watches, his own erection straining against his hand as he pumps it slowly. "look at her, chad. our eager little thing already drooling for it.... shit, I bet she's been dreaming about getting caught like this." ethan scoffs, but his eyes are gleaming with hunger rather than pure disdain.

after ethan's words as he stands behind your head, you take chad deeper, hollowing your cheeks as you suck and bob your head with practiced rhythm. the footballer's hand tangles in your hair, guiding you gently, "good girl, just like that... fuck you have such a pretty mouth, was it made for this?" the praise washes over you, urging you to please him more.

you gag softly as he hits the back of your throat with tears pricking your eyes, but you don't stop, swirling your tongue around the girth which nearly touches the top wrinkle of his heavy balls.

ethan kneels behind you on the carpet, yanking your leggings down over your ass and thighs, "spread those legs. let's see how wet you are from all this." the man's fingers hook into your black panties, pulling them down with a firm tug.

right away cool air hits your exposed pussy, and you moan around chad's cock, the vibration making him groan as ethan's big right hand lands a sharp slap against your ass, the sting echoing in the room.

"damn, you're soaked... fuck chad she's dripping!! what a greedy girl—getting turned on by your own mess-up."

chad thrusts shallowly into your mouth, his free hand cupping your cheek, "aw, don't be too hard on her, ethan. she's learning. aren't you, sweetheart? sucking me so nicely while he touches that pretty ass." you nod as best you can, saliva trailing down your chin as your body arches into ethan's touch despite the burn.

the guy behind you doesn't give you time to recover with two fingers plunging into your slick folds without warning. you cry out, the sound muffled by chad's length, but ethan curls them ruthlessly, hitting that spongy spot on the side that makes stars burst behind your eyelids.

"not so fast, don't go squeezing and cumming yet... this is about us setting things straight, not your fun." ethan's thumb circles your clit teasingly, building the pressure but pulling away each time you get over the edge.

frustration builds, and chad can tell from the way that your eyebrows flare and your jaw tenses. your hips start bucking involuntarily, but chad holds your head steady with his cock in your throat, "patience, baby. focus on me. make me feel good, and maybe we'll let you have a taste of finishing later." you redouble your efforts, deepthroating him with sloppy, wet sounds filling the room.

chad's breaths come faster, with his hips snapping forward as he praises you through gritted teeth, "fuck, yes! such a good little cocksucker. taking it all for me.... man, she is so obedient, you're luck you've already fucked her before."

ethan nods, looking up at chad with a smirk before he adds a third finger in your pussy, stretching you wide as his other hand delivering another firm spank that leaves your skin tingling, "she's obedient? ha... she's a needy thing who needs to be reminded of her place. look at her clench around my fingers... y/n is begging without saying a word."

he pumps harder, denying your climax again as your body trembles with unmet need. tears stream down your face, mixing with the mess on your chin from chad's cock, but the humiliation only heightens the ache between your legs which makes you drip all over ethan's hand.

finally, chad pulls out of your mouth with a wet pop, with his cock glistening, "enough enough enough, get up on the couch, y/n."

they guide you onto the brown cushions, positioning you on all fours facing chad again, the same position from on the ground. your knees sink into the soft fabric, ass raised toward ethan like an invitation as chad settles back against the armrest, his erection bobbing as he strokes it, "okay... keep going, sweetheart. suck me while he takes care of you from behind. show us you can handle both."

you lean forward, taking him back into your mouth with a hungry moan, your lips sealing around his shaft as you bob eagerly. ethan grips your hips, lining himself up with your dripping entrance.

lube isn't needed since you're slick enough from his earlier finger fucking. ethan pushes in slowly, the stretch making you gasp around chad's cock, "that's it, take me nice and deep. you wanted both of us? now you get it,." his voice is gruff, a touch mean in the way he holds you still.

thankfully, there's an undercurrent of encouragement, like he's enjoying the control without being vicious.

ethan starts thrusting, with backshots that rock your body forward, forcing you deeper onto chad with each snap of his hips. the couch creaks under the motion as your hands brace on chad's thighs as you suck him off, with your tongue working the underside while ethan pounds into your soaked pussy from behind.

chad's hand threads through your hair, guiding your pace, "breathe through it, baby. you're doing amazing... taking my cock in your mouth while he fucks you. such a good girl for us."

the dual sensations overwhelm you. you've never known how much you needed this until now.

ethan's relentless drive hitting deep inside, grinding against your walls. "fuck, she's gripping me so tight," ethan groans, with his fingers digging into your hips as he picks up speed.

the guy leans down eventually, with his lips lingering against your earlobe and his curls nearly hit chad's hipbone, "you're such a greedy and naughty girl, clenching like that. you love being in the middle, don't you? you're just our little shared plaything, right?"

you moan around chad, with the vibration drawing a hiss from him. chad cups your face as ethan moves back up, with his thumb brushing your stretched lips, "i know it feels intense, sweetheart, but hold back... no cumming until we allow it. prove you're sorry by pleasing us first." the words make you whimper, with your body trembling as ethan's thrusts push you closer and closer to the edge.

soon, ethan reaches around and his big fingers finding your clit and rubbing in firm circles, but he stops just as the coil tightens too much.

"not yet. you don't get to finish until we've had ours. keep sucking chad like the eager thing you are." the denial burns as your hips grind back against eth desperately, but he controls the rhythm and pulls out almost fully before slamming back in, each backshot jolting you forward onto chad's cock, your nose digging in his pubes.

sweat slicks your skin, and the room is filled with your muffled cries and skin slapping skin. chad's breaths grow ragged, with his hips bucking up into your mouth, "almost there, baby. swallow it all... be a good girl and take my cum." you hollow your cheeks, sucking harder, and he comes with a low groan, with hot spurts flooding your throat.

you swallow greedily, milking his balls dry as tears of effort streak your cheeks.

ethan doesn't let up, his pace turning erratic as he chases his release, "fuck.. 'm, fuck! gonna fill you up back here too. take it, all of it." he buries himself deep, pulsing inside you as his cum starts spilling hot on your gummy walls.

the sensation nearly tips you over, but he pinches your hip sharply, yanking you back from the brink.

"no, hold it. the lesson's not over."

you collapse forward onto chad's lap, panting as your body quivers. ethan pulls out slowly, a trickle of his release leaking down your thigh and he starts to rub your ass soothingly this time, the meanness fading into something almost affectionate.

"see? that's what happens when you play games.... but you're ours now, there is no more secrets and you get to have what you wanted."

chad strokes your hair, pulling you up to rest against his chest on the couch, "that's right, sweetheart.... behave, and we'll make it worth it next time."

you nod weakly, nestled between them, as you feel ethan's hand massage the sting on your asscheek.

there was no more juggling... you belonged to chad and ethan completely.