I get you, but do you know im actually not feeling negative about the movie, purely for the fact that its confirmed that book and movie canon are completely seperate universes and this movie has nothing to do with book future canon
Like i can go and watch it and have a semi entertaining time and know that #myalex and #myhenry are still having a lovely time over in their brownstone communicating like adults. And then i can go and watch movie alex and henry be hot messes and i have no expectations to the contrary.
Yk?
Yeah, it’s so good to have confirmation that those are completely different characters (even tho I didn’t really need it, it was already obvious, but it’s nice to have it confirmed), specially with the private correspondence coming out around the same time as the movie, so that the Real™️ Alex and Henry will also be coming back to me (so excited) (“yours yours yours” are you fucking serious? and letter from Alex that Casey read…)
I know I shouldn’t judge the movie characters based on the book characters, since the author themselves already said they’re different, but I can’t really help it. I mean, they are supposed to be the same, or at least similar. As much as I (and others, like you maybe) want to watch it and enjoy it as it’s own separate thing, I really can’t because the movie showcases itself as an adaptation of the book, as a continuation of their story, etc. This is a me issue, I know. I can’t enjoy it as it’s own separate thing because I know it technically isn’t, it technically is connected to the story, and when it does such a big disservice to the story, well, you see it.
Honestly, I don’t even know if I’ll watch it. I was open to watching it before but what I’ve heard from it (now that Alex is doing political things behind Henry’s back, before I heard that Henry was very interested in his family history and the crown and stuff??) just doesn’t seem enjoyable. It’s so different to the og characters and just doesn’t seem like it’ll work. I’ll have faith in Jamie Babit (although apparently from what I’ve heard her only good movie is but I’m a cheerleader, and the rest suck) and in Casey, but idk how they’re gonna pull it off. Movie!firstprince was already bad in the first movie (sorry), they didn’t really know each other, and I do think the second movie will explore that which is good but idk how else it’s gonna end if not with them realizing they’re not really compatible (and obviously it won’t end like that, there’s a third movie coming next, probably). Henry is into monarchy, Alex is into politics. Drama for the sake of drama when the whole point of the book is the opposite.
I mean, doesn’t Henry already mention it in the first movie? My life is the crown and yours is politics, and I won’t change one prison for another. I loved that line because it’s so true to the movie. They never dwelled deeper into it, they never solved this problem before coming out, so I guess I’m glad to see it explode in their faces in movie 2 and finally having to address it, three years later, at least, but I don’t see how they’re going to address it in a satisfactory way that secures a happy ending. Maybe that should make excited to see how they do it, but it doesn’t. It makes me feel that sense of doom you get when you know the writers of your favorite show are fucking up the story in the next season.
Also since they butchered my girl Bea and she has no personality nor story now, I’m not particularly excited about her having more of a focus in movie 2, specially her husband. I kinda want to meet him, because book!bea ALSO gets married in Henry’s chapter and istg I need to meet this man. I can’t believe Casey broke the aroace Bea hc’s that were rampant in the fandom since like 2020 until Henry’s chapter. It was so unexpected.
And Catherine coming back… yeah, I rather not speak about that. Glad she’s here, the fact that she didn’t appear in first movie is… not a great look for her. There will be talks of Henry and Catherine’s relationship I think, and it could be great but I’m also afraid it will be more drama for the sake of it. Their relationship is interesting but not enough to make it a plot point imo. Henry is hurt by her disappearance and angry but he also understands because he also feels the weight of grief but he still blames her for things that happened when she wasn’t there and doesn’t absolve her from accountability but still tries to defend her a little to Alex in their phone calls, and he loves her but he hasn’t properly spoken to her in basically years and he’s angry and sad but also hopeful and willing and yeah. It’s interesting, could be cool, but they need to do it well, and idk if they will. That’s book!henry ofc, so we’re still to see movie Henry’s relationship with Catherine, but I think the conflict will be the same.
Anyway I’m ranting over here for no reason. I’m really glad you love the book and still feel positive over the movie. I was positive before seeing the plot summary too because I thought that, at least, I’ll get new scenes with them that I can use in edits (them in a relationship, living together, etc. finally a peek into the brownstone! Domestic intimacy!) but apparently they’re going to be in conflict most of the movie. There’ll still be all the romantic things ofc, it’s a romcom, but all the leaks we got with the Christmas things I think that will be the beginning of the movie, and after that it will be conflict. Not excited about that.
I also think of #myalex and #myhenry having a normal healthy relationship somewhere far away. It’s a comfort to me. I sometimes think about them watching the movie sometimes. Firstprince come home…


















