A couple months back, I put together an hour-long mix of various versions of "By This River" â a song by Dieter Moebius, Brian Eno and Hans-Joachim Roedelius that first showed up on Eno's classic Before and After Science LP. There are orchestral interpretations, solo acoustic renditions, harps, synths â there's even a very skilled whistler floating down this "River."
Here's the tracklisting:
Brian Eno, âBy This Riverâ ++ Hans-Joachim Roedelius, âSkizze 4 von By This Riverâ ++ Mari Samuelsen & Konzerthausorchester Berlin, âBy This Riverâ ++ Mary Lattimore, âBy This Riverâ ++ Sergio Sorrentino, âBy This Riverâ ++ Martin L. Gore, âBy This Riverâ ++ Elena SomarĂŠ, â By This Riverâ ++ Console, âBy This Riverâ ++ Bruce Brubaker, âBy This Riverâ ++ Speed The Plough, âBy This Riverâ ++ Giampaolo Capelli, âBy This Riverâ ++ Jefre Cantu-Ledesma, âBy This Riverâ ++ Alva Noto + Ryuichi Sakamoto, âBy This River (Phantom)â ++ Roedelius & Jean-Benoit Dunckel, âSilencio, Pt. 7 (By This River)â
Why did I do this? I don't know! But maybe it's just because the song has a certain hypnotic quality that seems to stop time, that simple keyboard hook flowing over Eno's hushed vocals. The lyrics, too â they're not straightforward, exactly, but they communicate something that has always connected with me, now more than ever. The narrator is in some kind of purgatory, "stuck by this river." He's not alone, but he's unable to really communicate meaningfully with the other people on the banks (hmm, feels familiar). It's a vision, a dream, a longing. "My River runs to thee," Emily Dickinson wrote. "Blue Sea â Wilt welcome me?"
Yeah, sure. Anyway, had I made this "River" mix a little bit later, I would have included the live version of "By This River" that Eno has been playing on his recent tour (!), backed by the Baltic Sea Philharmonic and some other key collaborators. Listen to a nice audience recording of it here! If you watch the video, it's impressive that such a large group of musicians can make so little sound. An oblique strategy if ever there was one.