Cross My Heart
Human Alastor x Reader! In which Alastor supports your career as a singer and songwriter. You sing Laufey songs... Bittersweet ending... Reader is POC! (My first Alastor fic LOL)
Tears flooded your eyes as another record label fooled you into thinking they'll accept you. "Look it's just business." The man in a suit spoke, he took the cigar from his mouth and blew smoke on your face. "Can't hire anymore women. You women are just not profitable enough."
"I-I don't understand?" Voice shaking, you wipe away your tears, "Didn't you say you liked my song? You offered to make me big, I don't understan—"
"We came here to buy off your song. Listen lady, it's just... Your color isn't really what we're looking for." Hearing this shattered your heart, "Look other record label exploit women of color for not even crediting their song writing. Shouldn't you be grateful we're even willing to pay and credit you?" He brushed his hair, giving you an annoyed look.
Outside the record booth, your two coworkers Alastor and Caine waited patiently, both holding a bouquet of flowers. Though unbeknownst to Caine, Alastor glared at his coworker's array of bouquet, whispering to himself how Caine had stolen his original idea and taking a mental note not to share anymore grand ideas to Caine. Nonetheless, today was a day of celebration.
That was until you came out of the booth crying, walking past them, Caine gave Alastor a worried look, but Alastor was quick to follow you. "Dear?" He called out to you, his voice smooth and sweet like honey.
"I hate this." You don't stop until you found the backdoor exit, leaning towards the wall you let out a cry. Covering your face with a sob, "I'm never going to be a star."
Caine and Alastor were following behind, a frown was present in both of the men's face. Caine immediately placed the roses down on the floor and was quick to move close to you, wrapping you in a small embrace as he cooed and reassured you. Upon seeing this Alastor's eye twitched. Quickly. He had to work quickly to get him off you. "Dear, I know it isn't the same as any big record label studio, but how would you like it if you... Perhaps performed on one of my broadcast?" He offered, a toothy smile was present in his face when he saw you look up at him. "I'm sure I can pull a few strings, I am a radio host after all."
Gently pushing Caine off to the side, you wipe away your tears, "Truly? You aren't pulling my leg? I cannot handle another lie."
"Darling, I would never get in between you and your career. I only wish to see you shine." He smiled, "Cross my heart and hope to die." His finger tracing an 'X' shape on his chest where his heart should be. Alastor truly wouldn't. He knew your potential as both a song writer and a singer, shame record labels refuse to acknowledge your talent. Those greedy men will get what's coming for them.
Alastor hadn't accounted that you'd run to him to embrace him, thanking him for this opportunity. He wasn't a huge fan of physical contact, he just slightly patted your back, "Thank you.." You sniffed, you could almost cry again from this opportunity. "Alastor, this means so much to me..."
When the next day arrived Alastor went to speak to his producers on giving you a few minutes on the air to play your music, instead of the usual jazz music, however they refused. "Al, if record labels didn't want anythin' to do with her, why should we?"
Gritting his teeth he couldn't really win his producers over. This conversation has been going on for some time now, he sighed in defeat, but an idea popped into his head. He smirked, before speaking, "Very well, I won't mess with the music. I understand we're under contract with certain companies and wouldn't want to upset them, so how about this. I sacrifice part of my broadcast for her?"
The producer hesitated, "You understand the listeners listen to you talk, right? They ain't listening to some dame singing." The lead producer, lit a cigarette and, rolled his eyes, "Whatever. Make sure she put on a good show. I'm done havin' this conversation with you."
With that Alastor left. True his loyal listeners truly worshipped him, however he made a promise to you and he would rather have a few disappointed fans than have you be disappointed. He walked down to the reception area where you worked as a receptionist. He put on a charming front, but was immediately angered by the sight of Caine gifting you a small gift, a teddy bear to be exact. "Filthy man." He whispered, before putting a charming smile back on his face, "My dear!"
Hearing this, you quickly turn your head towards Alastor, "Alastor! How did it go?" You asked, a bit nervous, heart racing with anticipation.
Alastor spoke, "They did not allow me to cut back jazz music for yours, however—"
"Are you serious?" Caine huffed, "Al, did you even try to fight for her career?"
Not caring or wanting to give the man any ounce of attention Alastor rolled his eyes, but the look of disappointment in your face had Alastor worried, "Dear, don't fret. I gave up a few minutes of my broadcast to you. You'll have to perform live on radio!"
"Huh!" Your eyes went big along with a smile, "Oh! Oh, Alastor! Truly? Truly?" You repeated, and when he nodded with his signature smile, you immediately started to cheer for joy.
"Is this really a good idea..?" Caine interjected, a hand on his hips, you turned to look at him, tilting your head. "I mean live on radio? Could you handle such a thing?" Truthfully, Caine has always been sweet but harsh when it came to your career. He's your dear friend but he always seem to question your capabilities which always led to you second guessing your talent.
"I-I know, but isn't this a once in a lifetime opportunity?" You smiled nervously, starting to feel unsure. "I just... I want to give it a shot."
Caine smiled, though his smile wasn't like Alastors. Caine's smile wasn't sincere. "Look, you're young and I'm all for this dream thing, but how many times have you been rejected from record labels or companies?" He started, the smile on your face faltering.
Alastor felt his fist clenching hard. "Really Caine, what makes you think you can say all this?" Alastor stepped closer to Caine, "Rejection is apart of the progress, we mustn't let it affect her. Let her chase her dreams, regardless of how many times it has fallen on deaf ears."
Caine gritted his teeth, "Oh come on, are you even looking out for her? Think of her future chasing after all this nonsense. You know more than anyone how hard it is to chase your dreams as a mixed radio host. Can you imagine hers?" Caine pointed to you, hearing all this made you feel nauseous. "She's not only a woman, but a colored woman! It's impossible to make it into the industry like her." Not wanting to hear anymore, you run to the bathroom. Caine and Alastor watched you and although Alastor wanted to chase after you, Caine gripped his wrist. "She's young, Alastor. If she settles down now, she'll have a comfortable life. If she chases her dreams she'll lose her value and be too old to marry and who else would want a her?"
"How dare you." Alastor growled. Forcefully taking his wrist back. His head was burning with rage, but he had to resist biting off Caine's head or screaming back at him, Alastor had to chase after you.
He hated Caine, honestly Alastor had no idea what you saw in that man. All he ever did was put you down and then butter you up with whatever bullshit he had to give you. Truly he hated the man. Even more now that he can hear your muffled whimpering behind the bathroom door. "Dear, don't listen to Caine."
"Alastor, please." You huffed through the door, "Caine's known me the longest. I know he's only looking out for me. I just.." You opened the door, eyes droopy from tears. "I just don't want to accept that I'm just destined to be someone's housewife you know?"
"Nonsense, nonsense!" Alastor placed a hand behind your back and leading you to his office for more privacy. "Dear, the first time you walked into this building, I saw the passion in your eyes! Then when you serenaded us, for Caine's birthday? Truly, if you were a siren, I would have fallen for your spell and been long dead." He placed you down on the couch in his office and sat next to you.
"Still..." You sighed, "Do you really think this is the best choice for me..?" You fiddled with the edge of your sleeves. "What if I don't even make it big and struggle to support myself..?"
"Oh, pish posh, dear you have me and Caine to always support you!" Alastor hated having to include Caine, but he knew well Caine would always support you regardless. After all he could tell how much Caine was head over heels over you, though Alastor was sure you felt nothing for him, or at least he hoped you felt nothing for Caine.
You looked down slightly, "I don't want to be a burden..."
"You aren't!" Alastor lifted your chin and forced you to look at him, "Dear, I am serious when I tell you, I want nothing more than to see you shine. I wouldn't be pulling strings to get you on my broadcast for nothing."
You felt your eyes go wide, a tinge of pink appeared on your face, but not visible enough for Alastor to see. You've never felt anything towards your two coworkers, after all you never saw them any more than just friends, but this moment with Alastor felt more intimate. Like he was trying to express his love for you, but you knew he wasn't like that. After all, all of new New Orleans loved him. Why would he settle for you? So you swallowed your pride, "Thank you, Alastor. For comforting me and all that... I should head back to the reception desk.."
Alastor hummed, "Yes, very well." He arranged his glasses and stood up, "We'll discuss matters of the broadcast when the day comes closer."
On the day of the broadcast, Alastor caught you speaking to Caine, "Have you thought of the song you'll sing?" Caine asked.
"I have, but..."
"What's the matter?" Alastor asked walking quickly to you two, "Oh, darling, don't tell me you're getting cold feet?"
"A little bit... I just never had such a broad audience before.. I'm terrified!" You admitted.
Caine patted your back, "You should be!" He joked, but it didn't really calm your nerves, honestly it made it worse and Alastor could tell. "I mean you have almost all of New Orleans listening to you sing instead of their dear favorite radio host."
You let out an awkward laugh, but the face you made looked absolutely frightened. Alastor sighed, "Dear, why don't you meet me at my office? Maybe a little bit of reassurance and practice would calm your nerves before we're live?" You perked up, and nodded.
"I-I think that would help a lot, yes..." You huffed, quickly making your way to Alastor's office.
"Goodluck with her, Al." Caine made a physical presence by patting Alastor's back, which made him let out a quiet growl, not loud enough for Caine to hear. Caine continued, "She's been such a nervous wreck."
Alastor simply let out a fake chuckle and walked to his office. He found you slightly freaked out on his couch. "Ready to practice?" He asked, holding out a hand for you to take. "You have to stand up, I find it's better to perform when I'm acting out what I'm saying when I'm live on the radio.. I assume singing is the same."
You nodded, carefully you took his hand as he help you stand on your two feet. You watched as Alastor sit down, his legs spread out to show just how comfortable he was. You took a deep breath, he let you know he was ready whenever you were. For some reason, you felt your nerves settle. Maybe it's because of how calm and comfortable he was, or maybe it's the privacy of the office, but you took this opportunity to start singing.
"I wish you bluebirds in the spring" You sang swaying in place. "To give your heart a song to sing. And then a kiss, but more than this... I wish you love..."
Alastor watched as your confidence slowly grew. He closed his eyes to focus all his attention on your voice. "And in July a lemonade.. To cool you in some leafy glade. I wish you health, and more than wealth. I wish you love..."
"My breaking heart and I agree. That you and I could never be. So, with my best, my very best. I set you free... I wish you shelter from the storm.. A cozy fire to keep you warm.. But most of all, when snowflakes fall.. I wish you love.. I wish you love..." You feel your body move, everything felt easier with Alastor. You appreciate everything he's done for you and while Caine had always been your friend you've never had anyone support you as much as Alastor.
"My breaking heart and I agreed That you and I could never be. So, with my best, my very best. I set you free. I wish you shelter from the storm. A cozy fire to keep you warm... But most of all, when snowflakes fall... But most of all, when snowflakes fall I wish you love, love, love..."
With that Alastor rose and clapped. "Bravo!" He cheered, "Dear, that was marvelous. I cannot wait for all of New Orleans to hear that voice of yours."
"Thank you, Alastor—"
"Al." He cut you off with a smile, "Al is fine." Truthfully he hated that nickname, everyone seems to call him Al and he never understood why. It's not as if he's buddy-buddy with anyone. You knew he hated the nickname. In fact you were the only one that asked if he liked the nickname and when he told you no you never questioned why. You've shown him your upmost respect. In return, he felt the need to return that respect back to you.
"Are you sure?" You questioned, "I am quite alright calling you Alastor."
"You have always been sweet to me," Alastor laughed, moving a strand of your hair out of your face, "I think we're close enough, don't you agree? I'll just ask everyone else not to call me that ever again. I'll make sure it's a name only you can call me."
Feeling your face heat up, this time for sure you were certain Alastor noticed. It was impossible to hide with how close he was. You reminded yourself that it was inappropriate to chase after him and that there was no chance he'd want you. Taking a deep breath you looked up at him, "Well, Alast— Al.. I do feel a bit more confident now.. Thank you.." You hummed, but quickly frowned, "I'm still frightened however.. I couldn't even perform in front of Caine a couple days ago.. What if I struggle to perform live?"
"You didn't seem to struggle with me." Alastor hummed, playing with the strands of your hair. Genuinely he has no idea what has taken over him. Were you truly a siren leading him to his doom? Listening to your concerns he couldn't understand your worries. To him you would shine brighter than any star in the sky with that voice of yours. "How about you think of this moment..? Or I'll sit in the record booth with you. Just imagine we're alone and you're singing for me."
Something inside your heart clicked.
A day after your broadcast Caine went to greet you. "Haven't you heard all of New Orleans is singing your song!" He then presented a news article, in bold writing it says, 'Radio host Alastor, makes way for a charming new singer!'
You gasp, taking the news paper and reading the article and reviews. "Oh my!" A smile was plastered on your face. You couldn't help the giddy feeling. Hugging Caine, "Oh my goodness, Caine! I might make it out!"
Caine laughed, spinning you around, "I always knew the people would love you!"
"Oh, I must thank Al for this opportunity." You looked around hoping to see him.
As if on que, Alastor popped into the building, "Dear, great news!"
Caine put you down and patted your head, "I already told her the news, Al."
"It's Alastor to you," He calmly spoke, and made his way to you, not wanting to give Caine anymore of his attention. "As I was walking to the station, all I received were compliments on your behalf! My, the people want to hear your song once more and are frankly quite persistent in asking for more songs from you!"
"I want to thank you so much for this, Al!" You gushed, holding out your hand for him to shake, "Such an honor! Truly!"
Alastor grabbed your hand, pulling you into a small celebration dance, "Dear, the pleasure is mine." After a couple seconds of twirling you around, Alastor let go of your hand, "Well we better prepare for our next broadcast, yes?"
"Huh? Right now?" You asked almost shocked, "But who would handle the reception desk?"
"Don't worry," Caine spoke, "I'll cover for you, I finished most of my work this morning." He then placed his hand on your shoulder. "We'll probably hire a new receptionist if you make it big." He joked, which made you laugh. Alastor just stared with a forced smile.
What's so funny about that? If? If you make it big? Of course you would make it big, there wasn't any if's about it. The way Caine thinks of you so negatively pisses Alastor off more than anything, but he was great at making sure his persona never falters. "We will hire a new receptionist. Darling, I'm thinking of having you work full time next to me. Along with your wonderful songs on air..."
Knowing just how nervous you get Alastor expected you to be unsure, however with this new sudden confidence you quick to agree, "I would love to!" Alastor was pleased to hear you so eager to work on your career.
In truth, you were quite eager to work with Alastor himself. For a while, you never truly understood what attracted all the other women to him. Sure he was physically attractive, but should you like a man based off of pure looks? Certainly he is charming, but isn't he always that nice with everyone? It wasn't until you saw that version of Alastor in his office. The one who was so eager to help you achieve your goals that you realized your attraction to him. Although you knew you stood no chance against other ladies who were after him, you weren't going to waste such an opportunity like this. Being able to spend time with him during work would surely entertain your heart enough.
After months of working with Alastor, there were times where after your show Alastor would ask you questions live on air, such as what inspired you? What's the meaning behind this song? and other such questions. Slowly but surely he practically made you a co-host of his radio show, still being able to sing along with it. Working with Alastor made you feel like a celebrity. You'd have people in New Orleans greet you and compliment you as you walked the streets.
As you walked into the studio, you noticed Alastor with a couple of men, "Ah, here's my beautiful co-host." Alastor introduced you, placing a hand on your back. "Wonderful isn't she?" Alastor stares into your eyes, his comments and his closeness flusters you. "Now dear, these are great fine men from Columbia Records." Alastor introduced them to you, "This fine sir, is Gilbert, he heard your song from yesterday and was interested in making you the star you-oh-so wanted to be!"
"What?" You said in disbelief, this felt like so surreal to you, "I mean, you're serious?"
Gilbert laughed, "Of course, but you gatta wow my team here first. Now you already got my vote missy, but when you sing today and impress my whole team, we're takin' ya to Hollywood!"
"Hollywood..?" You muttered, "But that's on the other side of the country..."
"Haha, yes! But I know what I heard." Gilbert placed his hands on both sides of your shoulder, "Darling, that voice of yours and your writing will make you the biggest star Hollywood has ever seen."
"What do you say, dear?" Alastor proudly smiled at you. "Ready to sing live on our broadcast one final time?"
You nodded, not really wanting to speak. Something about this felt so off. You have it in your hands, your dreams. Anyone would kill just to be you. Alastor and the team of men were busy getting ready, so you excused yourself to prepare. You took a deep breath, grabbing a pen and paper. In truth, while you do want to chase after your dreams, you did not want to leave New Orleans. You didn't want to leave Alastor's side. You wrote your feelings down in ink, knowing if you confess now it will only complicate things. So you'll hand it over before you leave. You hear Alastor knock on the door. Signaling you it's time to perform.
As you make your way to the booth, you inhale, watching as the team examined you. You let out a long exhale, as you start your performance. The instruments play gently, "I've been falling in bad habits, staring into the abyss... Drowning in red wine and sniffing cinnamon..."
You saw a couple of the men give you weird looks, but you stayed completely composed, "We've been kissing on the playground, acting like little kids... Making dirty jokes and getting away with it" You hear whispers from the team, and you felt your confidence falter, but you remind yourself of the advice Alastor gave you. "So I propose," You open your eyes, staring at Alastor with a smile. "It's long overdue. When you go to hell, I'll go there with you too. And when we're punished for being so cruel. The silver lining's I'll be there with you."
The line struck Alastor. He's never heard this song before. Truthfully he was always so fond of you. He couldn't understand why other people couldn't be more like you. It was entertaining seeing you perform with all your heart, but the look you gave him with that line, he almost thought you were proposing to him. He felt his heart shook, which was weird considering he's not much for romance.
You hummed as the next part of the song came, "Never been calm or collected, no one ever called me sweet... What a miracle, I found a darling." You had hoped these lyrics would open up his eyes and made him realize this was basically your confession to him. "I met you at the worst time, fell in love on a whim. Now we pirouette in fields of rosy sin..." You closed your eyes for a more dramatic effect, "So I propose, it's long overdue. When you go to hell, I'll go there with you too. And when we're punished for being so cruel. The silver lining's I'll be there with you..."
Opening your eyes slowly to stare at Alastor, with a small smile, you sang the last lyric, "The silver lining's I'll be there with you."
An applause erupted, which quickly snapped you out of focusing on just Alastor. An awkward laugh escaped your lips as the 'on air' light turned dark. "Safe to say you're going to have your own label!" Gilbert announced, clapping his hands, "What do you say about leaving New Orleans tomorrow morning?"
Your heart nearly dropped, looking at Alastor for reassurance he only nodded with a smile. "It's a deal." You held out your hand as Gilbert shook yours.
Alastor arranged the studio for a goodbye celebration to take place. It was honestly all so sudden. One second you're a small town girl, the next second you're being offered stardom to Hollywood. While the party goes on, you escape to go outside, taking a deep breath of fresh air. You debated on confessing to Alastor tonight. It's now or never after all. You hear the door inside creak and you turn to see who had followed you.
"Al," You hummed, a smile plastered on your face, "Thank you once again. I couldn't have done this without you."
"On the contrary, I do think you would have been successful in achieving your dreams regardless if you had my help or not." He hummed, holding his hand out for you two to dance.
You hesitated to grab his hands, "Al..." You then remembered your confession letter, the one you wrote earlier. Digging into your pockets, you pulled out an envelope. "Alastor.. I-I want you to have this."
Alastor tilted his head, "If this is payment, I'm afraid I'm going to have to refuse—"
"No." You cut him off, "No, it's.. It's a letter. From me to you. Please. Read it. Preferably after the party..."
Alastor stared at the letter, curiosity taking ahold of his mind, he nodded grabbing the envelope and placing it inside his pockets. "You have my word." Whatever the letter may contain inside can wait, for now he'll offer you his hand once more, "Will you honor your first fan a dance?"
When morning arrived you were waiting at the spot where the Gilbert said they'd pick you up. You were terribly nervous. Thoughts flooded your mind, has Alastor read my message? Is he on his way? Does he feel the same? Would I regret leaving New Orleans? Would I regret rejecting my dreams? Apart of you wished the bus would never arrive, but apart of you knew you wanted this.
Meanwhile after the party Alastor went straight to hunting. He was never too fond of Caine, so he spent the whole night leading him down the forest. By the time the sun rose, Alastor nearly forgot about your letter. Caine, who's legs were now broken, laid on the floor whimpering, "Ah, I forgot our little star wrote me, her biggest fan, a letter." He smirked, as if taking pleasure knowing he'd be your biggest supporter. As he opened the envelope he cleared his mouth to read the letter outloud, but was quickly stunned.
The first words written was an 'I love you.' Alastor readjusted his glasses to make sure he wasn't reading it wrong.
'I love you. I don't know where this career will take me or how long I'll be gone, but I love you. The last song I sung at your broadcast, it's a love song dedicated to you and only you. I know it'll be impossible to maintain a relationship so far from each other, so I struggled to tell you my true feelings, but Alastor, trust me when I say this. I will drop everything to persue a life with you. Please, if you have any feelings for me, please. Chase after me and tell me you want me to stay.'
You waited and waited. Fiddling your hands as you nervously waited for either the bus or Alastor to arrive. Unfortunately, the bus came first. The doors opened and you hesitated, staring at the door as Gilbert encouraged you to hop on. You blame it on the nerves and ask for a few moments alone. Stalling, hoping Alastor would arrive soon. Yet even as moments passed there was no sign of him. You had accept that Alastor rejected you. You held back the tears as you boarded. Still, even as the bus moved you kept an eye on the window. Hoping to see his silhouette. Hoping to drop everything for him, but he never came.
Unbeknownst to you Alastor layed on the floor. Wound to his chest as he struggled to breathe, his mind getting blurry. It wasn't supposed to be like this. His little killing spree was meant to be a celebration for finally achieving your dreams and for finding out your true feelings for him, he hadn't accounted that a hunter's dog would mistaken him for a deer whilst running through the swampy forest. He only wanted to take a short-cut to the bus station.
Alastor's final breath was wasted in laughter. In a way, it was funny to him. He did promised to never get in between you and your career after all. How foolish of him to forget that.
A little long oopsies, I hope u guys enjoy!! I'm wondering whether I should keep this a oneshot or maybe have a continuation or have what if's scenarios! Support the AO3 version!
Cross My Heart










