the quiet between songs | eddie munson
pairing: eddie x r!cheerleader
fandom: stranger things
word count: 1,8k (oneshot)
synopsis: the outcast and the cheerleader fall in love
song aesthetic: cigarette daydreams by cage the elephant
Eddie Munson had always said the gym smelled like bleach and broken dreams.
You laughed when you first heard it — not at him, not really. You were walking past with your cheer bag slung over one shoulder, hair still pinned from practice. The hallway was half-empty, ghostly in the afternoon hush after practice. Sunlight leaked through the grime-coated windows in long yellow beams. Your teammates had already disappeared down the corridor in a blur of perfume and gossip. But you were still here, walking slowly, the soreness in your calves a reminder that you never really stop moving — not in this school, not in this town, not in your skin.
He was leaning against the vending machine like he was born to do it. Like he was the patron saint of detention and late-night drives and not giving a damn. His jacket was too big for this kind of weather — worn denim over that same Hellfire tee he always wore, holes at the collar, fingers covered in silver rings and invisible ink. He was looking down at the row of sodas like they had personally offended him.
You almost kept walking. You should've. There's a kind of rule — people like you don't talk to people like him. But you were tired of following rules that didn't make sense.
“You hate this place that much?” you asked.
Your voice was quiet, unsure.
Eddie didn't look at you right away. His eyes flicked upward, like it took him a second to believe you spoke. Then, slowly, his mouth curled around something crooked and amused.
“Cheerleader speaks,” he said. “Alert the press.”
You rolled your eyes, a smile threatening. “Don't act so shocked.”
He shruged. “Can't help it. Most of you walk past like I'm one of the lockers.”
You glanced around. The hallway was fully empty now, the walls breathing faint echoes of your voice.
“Maybe we're just not used to you being so... stationary,” you said.
He chuckled, soft and genuine, and that throws you a little. You expected sarcasm, not warmth.
“I'm just taking a break from corrupting America's youth,” he says. “Thought I'd give the PTA a day off.”
You leaned against the opposite wall, crossing your arms. “So dramatic.”
Eddie studied you for a second, something shifting behind his eyes. Then he nodded toward the gym doors behind you.
“You like it? All of that?”
You hesitated. “It's not that simple.”
“Nothing ever is,” he murmured. “But you wear that smile like armor. Makes me wonder what you're really hiding.”
You didn't answer. You weren't sure how to.
“Just don’t get it,” he said after a while, voice low. “Everyone in there’s so busy pretending this is the best time of their life. Like they don’t know the real world’s gonna chew them up and spit them out.”
You looked down the hallway, past the cracked trophy case, the flickering lights overhead. You knew what he meant. Even if it was different for you.
“Maybe that’s why they pretend,” you murmured.
Eddie blinked. Like maybe he hadn’t expected you to say anything true.
You were the girl who smiled too easily. The one people thought had everything — the uniform, the grades, the crowd. But behind your smiles was the loneliness of always being the version of yourself people expected.
That was the first time you and Eddie spoke. You don't talk every day after that.
But he starts appearing more, the back bleachers during your cooldown laps, leaning against his van when you're walking to your car, flipping through records in the dusty back corner of the store you go to when you want to disappear.
It’s quiet in the back corner of the Spinnin’ Vinyl. The kind of quiet that hums, rather than echoes. Fluorescent lights flicker softly overhead, casting a tired, pale glow over the rows of vinyl. Dust lingers in the air, caught in golden shafts of light leaking in through the blinds. You always come here after school when things get too loud — when your brain is tired of smiling and your lungs feel like they’re running out of air.
You trail your fingers over the spines of the albums, letting them whisper past, searching for something you won’t know you need until it’s in your hands.
“I knew I’d find you here,” someone says, low and familiar.
You don’t turn immediately — but your pulse stirs, a subtle skip. You reach for a record — Joan Armatrading — and then you glance sideways.
Eddie Munson is half a row down, his wild curls tucked behind one ear, a frayed leather cuff at his wrist. He’s flipping lazily through a stack of used cassettes, his mouth curved into that slight, crooked grin he always wears like armor.
“How?” you ask, voice light.
He shrugs. “You’ve got the eyes of someone who listens to heartbreak songs and never tells anyone.”
You pause, fingers tightening slightly around the record sleeve. Your first instinct is to deflect — to laugh, to scoff, to pretend he’s wrong.
But you don’t.
Instead, you look down at the album in your hands.
“Maybe,” you say quietly.
Eddie glances at you, just once, then back down to the tapes. “I come here for the same reason.”
You hum. “Heartbreak songs?”
He smirks. “Nah. The silence. People think this kind of music’s all noise and chaos — but sometimes it’s the only thing that shuts everything else up.”
You move a little closer to him — not too close, but close enough to feel the shared space. “You talk a lot.”
He chuckles. “I’ve been told.”
“Well…” You tilt your head, watching him. “You’ve got the mouth of someone who never shuts up yet still says more truth than most people I know.”
That makes him stop flipping through tapes.
He looks at you — properly now. Eyes softer than they should be, like you said something he didn’t expect.
“Careful,” he says, voice low. “You keep talking like that, I’ll start thinking you actually like me.”
You smile. “Who says I don’t?”
Eddie blinks once, then covers it with a scoff, turning back to the display like he can’t quite trust himself to keep looking at you.
You don’t say anything else. You just browse in companionable quiet, standing half a step apart.
Later, when the sun starts to dip and you both drift toward the register with a couple of records in hand, he holds the door for you like it’s nothing.
But he holds your gaze like it’s everything.
And that’s how you know.
He sees you.
Even in the quiet.
Even in the corners where no one else looks.
After that, you talk more.
You learn he likes Dio and Black Sabbath and the kind of music that sounds like thunder and heartbreak. You learn he hates math, lives with his uncle, and that sometimes, when he's not joking, his voice gets really soft.
In turn, he learns your favorite kind of silence — the kind where someone just sits with you and doesn't need you to smile.
One day, you're sitting on the hood of his van, the sky that pink-orange color it only turns for a few minutes before dusk. Your knees are tucked up, arms resting loosely over them, and Eddie's fiddling with his lighter again, flick—snap, flick—snap.
You ask him, “Do you ever wish you could leave?”
Eddie glances at you, hair curling wild around his face. “Like run away?”
You nod.
He shrugs. “Sometimes. But then I think... what if nowhere feels like home?”
You look down at your hands. “What if nowhere's worse than here?”
He doesn't answer right away.
Then, “Then maybe you take someone with you.”
Your heart skips.
You say nothing. But the air shifts.
It's raining when you show up at his trailer, soaked to the bone, heart pounding like it wants out of your chest. Your makeup's a mess, your shoes are muddy, and your mom's voice still echoes in your head — sharp words about “reputation” and “wasting your future on a burnout.”
Eddie opens the door in pajama pants and a Metallica tee, holding a half-eaten granola bar.
“Jesus,” he breathes. “You'll catch your death.”
You laugh once, sharp and broken. “Maybe that wouldn't be so bad.”
You don't mean to cry. But it happens anyway.
He pulls you in without asking.
Wraps you in one of those flannels that smells like detergent and cigarette smoke and something warm you can't name. You sit on his couch, trying not to shake, while he puts on the kettle and jokes about you looking like a sad raccoon.
He never asks why you're there. Just stays nearby. Quiet.
That night, you fall asleep with your head on his shoulder. His thumb moves in slow, absent circles against your arm until you stop crying.
You don't talk about that night. But something changes.
He starts walking you to your car.
You start saving him a seat at lunch — far from the others, but close enough for him to know you want him there.
People start to notice.
The basketball boys glare at you like you've betrayed the crown. Girls whisper.
You don't care. Not anymore.
“Guess I've got a type,” you say dryly one afternoon as you watch Jason Carver spit venom across the hall.
Eddie grins. “Tall, tattooed, and one foot out the door of juvie?”
You smile and bump his shoulder. “Misunderstood and smarter than they look.”
He looks at you then, long and searching.
“You mean that?”
You nod. “I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t.”
He kisses you that night.
Not at a party, not under the Friday night lights. Just the two of you, in the woods behind the school where the trees swallow the sound of the town. Where the stars look close enough to touch. The air smells like pine and coming rain. His hands are gentle, like he's not sure he deserves this. You press closer, fingers tangling in his hair. His hand splayed against the back of your neck.
And the world narrows down to just breath and heartbeat and the way you didn’t feel so alone anymore.
He pulls back just enough to whisper, “You scare the hell out of me.”
“Why?” you whisper.
“Because you're real.”
You kiss him again so he doesn't have to explain.
And maybe things don't magically get easier. Maybe people still talk. Maybe you still have to go home and lie about where you've been.
But now, when it all feels too heavy, you know where to go.
And sometimes, in the quiet between songs, in the soft breath of the world holding still, Eddie looks at you like you're the only real thing in a world made of cardboard.
And you believe it.
Maybe for the first time ever.
never written a oneshot before so hopefully it's good. anyway i listened to cigarette daydreams by cage the elephant like five times while writing this. enjoyy<3










