While countertenor soloists largely disappeared in the 1930s, from the 1890s-1920s, they were at the top of American popular culture. Publisher Edward Marks recalled that âthey had a practiced quaver in their high, pure, almost soprano voices that served them for years.â Boy sopranos were also immensely popular and publishers employed them as song pluggers; their beauty and charm, as well as their affecting portrayal of the songâs narrative, was essential to selling sheet music.
Colferâs is the first solo voice in recent memory to break into the mainstream as gender-queer, and as such, has become the site of both euphoria and anxiety. The gender ambiguity of his voice, specifically its âfeminineâ register, is always a prominent thread in discussions on websites ranging from YouTube to gay-specific blogs such as Towleroad, and this femininity is almost always framed as a problem (âheâs got a good voice, but he sings like a girlâ or âheâs the worst gay stereotypeâ). [...] Colfer and his voice embody the complex emotional life of what is usually the most ridiculed of gay stereotypes: the sissy. [...]
While most adolescent boys are relieved to lose the stigma of femininity associated with a high pitch, Colfer fought to keep his by continually practicing songs in high ranges; he also preserved the vibrato trilling equally associated with effeminacy, which has become one of the most poignant, affecting aspects of his vocal production.
âDefying Gravityâ both reflects Kurtâs character and transcends him, presenting the feminine male voice, as, quite literally, defiant. In Colferâs hands, this song becomes a manifesto for a new generation of queer kids. [...] âDefying Gravityâ is the beginning of Kurt/Colferâs gradual erosion and queering of the gendered/sexed norms surrounding popular singing, which Glee most often presents through Kurtâs reclamation of the diva.
