a lesson in proper behavior
Poly!Rosekiller x afab!reader
cw: spanking, d/s dynamics, dom!evan, dom!barty, sub!reader, soft bondage, daddy kink for Evan, they/them pronouns for reader, no y/n, reader wears a skirt, barty lifts reader over his shoulder, reader can physically blush, petnames, half-edited lowkey lol
"Poppet." Though less severe in octave, Evan's voice slices knives through the previous silence in the room.
You're stood closest to the bedroom door, arms crossed over your chest in defense where it rises and falls in small fits as you huff. A fixed glare at the men stood before you.
Barty watches you with a lazy grin, though his eyes sparkle dark with an emotion that has your stomach twisting up in heated knots.
"I'm going to give you one more chance to use that smart little mouth of yours to change up your tone," Evan says. Though he's not raising his voice, his stony expression and tense stance tell you all you need to know about how displeased he is with you.
You've had an attitude all morning. Trying to refuse breakfast and scoffing in a rather annoyed state at just about anything that came out of your boyfriend's mouths. While Barty found it endlessly amusing and took it upon himself to wind you up further, Evan had little patience for your cheek. He had tried to brush it off quite a few times, which is a surprise in itself, until he attempted to get you out of your seat so he could go help you get dressed like he did every morning. You snapped at him rather fiercely, smacking his hands away and telling him to leave you the fuck alone.
His eyes had flashed dark and in an instant he yanked you up and dragged your stumbling body through the halls and up the stairs to the bedroom, Barty on your tail watching rather delighted as you struggled against Evan's strength.
And that's brought you to your position now, glaring unkindly at your boyfriends and trying to ignore the burst of heat coiling in your stomach at the knowledge of your impending punishment.
Evan gives you a chance to apologize, and you certainly don't take it. Once you've encompassed yourself in one of these bratty little moods there is little that can be done to pull you out of your haze that doesn't involve physical consequences.
"I don't have anything to apologize for." You hiss, straightening up your posture and lifting your chin in a haughty manner.
Evan's jaw ticks and your pulse jumps when you see him unbutton his cuffs, pushing the white fabric up his forearms. "Junior," he says, catching the maniacal boy's attention and capturing him in a silent conversation.
A split second later Barty's smirk widens and he turns back towards you, stalking up to your form like a cat that's set his eye on a rather tasty little mouse. He opens his arms wide as he creeps towards you, ducking his head and starting to coo at you similar to one drawing a frisky little kitty out from their hiding place.
"It's alright, treasure. Why don't you come here, hmm?" Barty purrs.
Your gaze quickly darts between Barty and Evan, a nervous energy bubbling up inside of you when it finally dawns that you're really in for it. Your foot shuffles back but Barty's faster, lunging for you in a quick step and snatching your body up into his arms. You let out a shocked gasp when your suddenly flung over his shoulder. Head spinning from the quick manhandling, Barty walks you towards Evan and unceremoniously dumps your limp body onto the mattress with a soft thud.
You hastily scramble to sit up, heart thudding in your chest when you catch sight of both men towering over you at the foot of the bed. Evan steps closer to you, pressing his hands to his knees to meet your eye level. It's a patronizing display.
When he catches onto your nervousness he finally smiles, and its certainly not nice. His lips pull up into a mean grin, deep eyes lined with cruel enjoyment.
"Where's all that bite, pet?" he coos, tilting his head. "C'mon now.â
You but the inside of your cheek hard. âDaddyââ you start to attempt an apology but are quickly stopped when Evan lets out an empty laugh.
âOh, no. Donât even start,â he cuts you off.
Your voice gets caught in your throat and you look to Barty for help. Sometimes heâll come to your rescue, wrapping you up in his arms and cooing your innocence to Evan. But the dark amusement lingering on his lips lets you know heâs most definitely not in that kind of mood today.
âAwe, baby,â Barty croons, something evil cooking up behind his eyes. He turns to Evan. âI think the silk ties would do them good. What do you think, Rosie?â He asks casually.
Your stomach plummets, mouth parting to protest but your throat fills with cotton.
Evan hums in agreement, passing behind Barty with a quick squeeze to the shorter mans shoulder, before he ventures to the dreaded chest of drawers.
Distracted by the sight of Evan picking out a few silk ties, youâre caught off guard when Barry grabs your legs and tugs you down the mattress, forcing you onto your back. His hands slip under your thighs and he pushes your knees to your ears in a way that has you gasping and flushing with embarrassment.
He holds the back of your knees in one ringed hand while he surveys the mess between your thighs with a maniacal grin. Your underwear is sticky with arousal.
"Knew it." He gloats. "Rosie you gotta get a look at this."
As Evan walks over you cover your face, feeling flushed and embarrassed to be found out. You feel a colder hand grab under the back of your right knee and push it open and you can feel Evanâs gaze looking over your mess. You keep your face hidden under your palms all the while. Until strong thumb rubs up the length of your covered slit and your hips jolt down.
After a moment he lets go and taps your knee. âYou remember your alerts?â And then when you nod your head, âHands, pet.â
With a shaky breath you lift your hands from your face, blinking up wearily. You sheepishly lift your wrists towards Evan, pushing them together at the pulse and sending him a pleading look.
While Barty coos and kisses your knee, unable to resist his affections for your sweet nervous face, Evan doesn't spare you any sympathy. He firmly takes hold of your wrists and expertly knots them together with emerald green silk.
Your eyes dart between Barty's sweet expression and then to Evan's impassive face. "I'm sorry..." you whisper.
He raises an unimpressed brow. "Is that so? Finally feeling sorry now that the consequences are settling in, hmm? Well it's just quite unfortunate for you that I haven't an ounce of belief that you mean it yet." He grabs your bound wrists and with a suprising show of strength, pulls you up to stand. You stumble uneasily, trying to catch your footing on the hardwood floor but you're not standing for long. Evan sits on the edge of the mattress and pulls you right back down over his lap, stomach splayed over his thighs and ass propped up on his knee.
You gasp, tummy turning in that rush of adrenaline as your head falls into Barty's awaiting lap, the boy conveniently perched right next to Evan. Your wrists lay over the front of Evan's thigh, dangling helplessly towards the ground.
The blonde haired boy slips a hand under your skirt and pushes it up over your lower back, your flimsy little panties the only protection. That is until his fingers hook into the waistband and drag them down to your knees. Your hips twitch as the gust of cool air licking at your glossy cunt.
You dig your flushed cheek into Barty's thigh and he dutifully threads a hand through your hair to scratch gently at your scalp. It soothes you just a bit, but all sense of calm is quickly gone when Evan's palm rubs over your ass.
"You should know the drill by now, poppet. If youâve got something to say, then say it. And then we'll hear your proper apology after. Don't get forget your manners.â
An achiness tugs behind your navel and you breath heavy against Barty's leg. "I uhm- I'm so sorry, Daddy. Aâ And Bee. I was being disrespectful for no reason--"
"--You were being a brat," Barty cuts in.
The tips of your ears go hot. "I was being a brat," You revise with a thick swallow. " A-And I want to show you how sorry I am..."
Its silent for a moment as Evan smoothes is palm over your ass.
"Stuttering, pet. You know better." He sighs.
You squeeze your eyes shut tight, humiliated at his less than pleased response and bracing for the dreaded impact of his heavy hand. You know this is supposed to be a punishment, but the erotic nature of your position and the treatment of your boys you just canât help it. You subtly squeeze your thighs together, cunt pulsing as you await.
Your only warning before his open palm cracks down on the fatty flesh of your right asscheek. You let out a sharp breath, eyes squeezing shut as the burn settles.
Meticulous with everything he does, Evan takes his sweet time peppering rough spanks over your bottom. His palm flat and swatting incessantly as your skin tingles hot.
You pant into Bartyâs leg, open-mouthed and struggling to keep from squeaking with every hit. Evan doesnât appreciate excessive whining during a spanking and youâre really not trying to make it worse on yourself and raise his displeasure with you.
It makes it even harder that the impact of his hand has your cunt pulsing with every spank, fighting against the twitch of your hips as your pussy drools for attention. Wet dribbles down your thigh.
Barty messages his fingers into your nape. âShh, baby. Be good for your Daddy, hmm?â He reminds you, voice soft but lined with enjoyment.
Tears prickle behind your eyes, heat rising in your sinuses as Evan nears the tenth spank. The burn is starting to become too hot, and your hips shift out of your control. Barty swipes his thumb under your eyes, collecting a stray droplet and rubbing it into your flushed cheek. He looks like heâs resisting the urge to lean down and lick it clean.
Evan presses his hand to your lower back, instantly stilling you. âYouâre almost done, precious. Donât start with it now,â he murmurs. The impact gets rougher as he aims that last few to your sit spots, right at the junction between your ass and thigh.
Fuck thatâs gonna hurt tomorrow.
By the tenth spank you finally choke out a sob, slumping weakly against your two boyfriendâs thighs.
âOh, good job, sweet treasure,â Barty coos.
Your body trembles, sweet sniffles sounding out in the room as the adrenaline your body starts to settle. You feel Evanâs palm gently rub over your tender skin. It certainly doesnât help to ease the pain.
âYou did very well, babydoll,â Evan murmurs. He rubs your bottom for a few more moments to make sure that sting really sets in before he finally gives you reprieve. He then smooths his palm up your spine in soothing strokes, letting you ride out your bubbling sobs.
Both boys are attentive to giving you physical affection while you calm down.
âYou feeling alright, precious?â Evan asks, his voice much softer than his stern tone from before.
You nod. âYeah, better.â
âAlright. Letâs stand up then, I want to hear your apology.â
Barty grabs you by the waist and aids you seemingly as you canât push yourself up with your hands tied. You wobble slightly as you move to stand in front of the boys, teary-eyed and snotty.
Evan tsks, summoning a handkerchief from the side table to wipe up your nose. âBlow,â he says.
Once youâre cleaned up a bit Evan pulls you in closer, his eyebrow raised and expression expectant. Barty smiles at you encouragingly.
You take a deep breath, eyes darting equally between both of your boyfriends and looking awfully remorseful. âI-Iâm sorry. For behaving so poorly earlier. I was being a brat for- for no reason and I wasnât listening to either of you like should have.â
Evan smooths his hands up and down your waist. âAnd why were you acting out so poorly, hm?â
There it is. Heâs caught you.
You feel your face burn. âWell I⌠I suppose I just⌠wanted attention.â
His eyes glimmer with amusement accompanied by an uptick of his mouth. âOh, is that all? You were feeling like we werenât giving you enough attention?â
You evade their gaze, feeling embarrassed. When he says it like that it sounds silly.
You huff softly. âYes, I suppose so.â
âAlright, precious. How about a little cuddle then, hm? I think thatâll do the trick,â Evan murmurs as he moves to untie the silk form your wrists. He raises them to his mouth and kisses each respectively, then directing them over to Barty so he can do the same.
âOh, yes, what a splendid idea, Rosie!â And barty practically jumps to scoop you up and pull you into their laps.
You giggle softly, feeling a lovely warmth in your chest as they rub their hands over you and kiss at your face.
Youâd never admit to Evan, but maybe a punishment every now and then is worth it if it gets them doting on you sweetly like this.