Act iii: Betrayal And Stunned Silence
Pairing: poly!Moonkiller x vamp!Reader
Summary: You never knew Barty's absence could be so frigid and hollow, yet you're left to pick up what he shattered after betraying your trust. Yet still, it seems that the culprit behind it allâRemus Lupin, as usualâstill manages to worm his way into your defenses when he catches you off guard and vulnerable.
Warnings: MENTIONS OF VIOLENCE AND MURDER!! (->The murder itself isn't too descriptive but the aftermath is so read with caution!! It starts at âHeâs unrecognisableâ and ends at â[âŚ] like the poacher at the clearing.â), angst, sort of depressive episode, not proofread if you read this on the 25th
Content: so much angst, Reader crashes the fuck out, Remus being actually nice for once?? A lot of confusion on Readers end, big sister Lily ftw, weird tension between Reader and Remus
WC: 8.23k
AN: this chapter would've been soooo much longer if I didn't get sick of it and decide to keep the rest for the next one lmao ANYWAYS INTERACTION IS GREATLY APPRECIATED
Disclaimer: English is not my first language! All mistakes are my own!! I do not and never will use AI for my writing, this work is completely my own
Taglist: @starrystormwritings @whimsical-mistakes @hellokitty-girl666 @lettertovera @bubblegumcat229 @daydreamandforget @justyesbecauseyeswhynot
s.masterlist | Act i | Act ii | Act iii |Act iv | Act v
Bartyâs betrayal isn't smooth and calculated, no. It doesn't creep up on you like the shadows after the sun sets, nor does it watch you hungrily like a predator waiting to sink its claws into prey.
It comes unexpectedly, sudden and harsh, like a bombshell dropped with no warning. In hindsight, you still don't know which one you would've preferred; slow and meticulous torture or sudden and sharp searing pain?
Youâve only been a sixth year student for three weeks now, sitting cross-legged on his bed in his otherwise empty dorm when it all unravels.
You being in his empty dorm roomâcourtesy of his demand for privacy turned into obsessive magical research that expanded his original dorm into giving him and his three roommates separate roomsâis not as weird as it might sound on paper. Sure, you very much aren't allowed up in the Ravenclaw boys dormitory, but at a certain point the both of you did master the art of sneaking in out of each other's rooms without being caught.
You hadn't seen him much todayâor all week reallyâonly ever managing to steal glimpses of him when he rounded corners and sprinted down corridors. If you were a madder person, you might have thought he was avoiding you, but that can't be. Barty never avoided you, the thought so ridiculous you immediately discarded it. Besides, you didn't give him any reason to avoid youâas far you were concerned at least.
So, in an un-vampire fashion you decide to let yourself into his dorm without invitation, opting to browse through all the books he bought from the Muggle bookshop in your village but hasn't gotten to read yet while you wait for him to return.
You don't know where he is, but he has to come back at some point, especially with that looming Ancient Runes essay he complained about the first week of school. While Barty is reckless and incredibly unconcerned with his academic career, grumbling and huffing about the point of all the assignments, he still hands in neatly polished essays that earn him an Outstanding every time.
You're lost between the pages of some horror novel he brought with him when your ears pick up the unmistakable rhythm of his steps down in the common room. Sometimes, you suppose, having enhanced senses isn't all too bad. By now you're somewhat an expert at blending out the jarring sensory landscape around you, yet you somehow fine tuned yourself to always pick out Barty's presence wherever you go.
His steps are heavy, dragging on the floor in that way that foretells the story of heavy burdens the day left on his shoulders. Quickly, you put the book away, slipping a bookmark that has both of your fingerprints in the shape of a heart painted on it. A slight smile graces your features at the memory of making the bookmark a few summers ago, when the both of you were haunted by boredom and in dire need of something to do. Your mother had suggested arts and crafts, and because you'd gone to the bookstore just days prior, you decided to make bookmarks for your haul. The matching bookmarks were a little trinket that stuck around, a momentum that captures the essence of your friendship; two unique prints intertwined in one heart.
You can hear him drag himself up the stairs and wait patiently for him to arrive, fumbling with his wand before he unlocks the door.
He doesn't see you at first, his gaze cast to the ground, so you clear your throat to catch his attention. His head snaps up, wand pointed up immediately as his entire body grows rigid with alarm.
The whole thing makes you giggle, but it dies down as soon as you hear his heart rate picking up at the sight of you. He relaxes, just a fraction, but the tension in his muscles and face remains, even if he pretends otherwise.
Your eyebrows furrow, examining his expression closer as he triesâand very much failsâto plaster on a grin.
âFangs! Fancy seeinâ you âround here,â he calls out, but his voice is strained, betraying the casualness he tries to emit.
It's strange seeing Barty pretend around you, because it never happens, not when you both are alone at least.
Immediately, all alarms go off in your head as you revisit every single thing you know about him. Did something happen? Did he get a letter from his father and didn't tell you? Did you miss some sort of event? Was he mad at you?
A million questions pop in your mind, all at lightning speed, but you come up empty when you try to answer them.
He shifts his weight from one leg to the other, eyes darting across the room in a clear effort to avoid your scrutinizing gaze.
âWhere have you been?â You ask, leaning against the headboard of his bed with crossed arms. You ask the question lightly, no accusation in your tone at all, but he still flinchesâlike someone caught red handed committing a crime.
He paces around the room, loosening his tie and stripping the layers of clothing off his body. His movements are jerky, as if heâs trying to remember how undressing works, and pointedly turns his back when he answers your question.
âWas with Evan,â he replies, âHeâs been having those weird dreams again, more than ever lately so Iâve been tryinâ to help him figure out what they mean. You wouldn't believe how many divination and dream interpretation books we had to comb through!â
His voice fades into the background when a heavy and borderline ugly thought settles over you.
Barty is lying to you.
Barty, your best friend and other half, is lying to you.
It's not like he doesn't lieâbecause let's face it, Barty is no saint. He lies, he steals, he wrecks and manipulates like he might die if he doesn't.
That's not the point, it doesn't matter that he does those things because he's never done them to you. He lies to other people, he lies to his father, sometimes to his friends. He lies to the Professors all the time, occasionally to your parents when they ask how he feels.
But lying to you? He's never done that, ever.
Maybe that's why he's so out of his elementâit's unnatural for him to try and lie to the one person he spills his every thought to.
âStop,â your voice sounds distant, like it's not fully yours and he freezes. Slowly, he turns around, and even without heightened senses you could've heard the way he gulps loudly.
âI asked Evan where you are today,â you state plainly, voice and expression void of emotion. You can see the panic slowly seizing him, creeping up in his pretty hazel eyes that are blown wide like frenzied animalâs.
âHe said he has no clue where you've been hiding out.â
The silence that follows is heavy, filled with tension so thick you could've pierced it with your fangs. You continue watching him, he continues to avoid your eyes like they'll set him on fire any second.
Then, all of a sudden, his entire body goes slack with defeat. He pulls the shirt he's been holding in his hand this entire time over his head, trudges to the bed and settles beside you. The mattress dips underneath his weight, the wooden frame squeaks and fills the silence momentarily.
You want to reach out, hold his hand and coax him into telling you what's going on, but you can't. It's almost like there's something holding you back, instinct perhaps that warns you of what's about to transpire.
Naturally, you ignore it.
You've never held back from comforting Barty, so why wouldn't you go against your very own survival base to hold him? You would break and bend any rule as long as it meant he'll be okay. He accepts the hand you stretch out to caress his face, leaning into the touch like it might be the only thing keeping him grounded.
âThereâs somethinâ I havenât told ya, Fangs,â he mumbles, his voice tense and quiet.
You wait, racking your brain for what he might have hidden. His behaviour has been going on for about a week now; avoiding you everywhere, making excuses to not see you, running off as soon as you approach.
Then, it hits you square in the faceâthe welcome party he attended last week Friday.
It is tradition, a bit of good fun to welcome back everyone into a new school year. Usually, the attendees are fifth to seventh years, and after going last year and experiencing just how packed inter-house parties could get, you made the decision to not attend again. Too many people, too much going on for your brain to handle, and so much temptation that might cause an unwanted slip up.
Barty on the other hand was more than eager to go, the promise of abundant alcohol and entertainment pulling him like a moth to the flames. He disappeared that night, bidding you goodbye with the promise to tell you all about it the next day at breakfastâprovided he didnât skip it in favour of sleeping in and nursing the impending hangover.
That however, never happened, now that you think about it. The next day, he was nowhere to be found, no matter where you searched for him. And after that? He avoided you religiously, like being in the same room as you might set him ablaze. Something must have happened there, you conclude belatedly, and press your hand closer to his face, slowly coaxing him into spilling whatever weighs on his consciousness. He draws a shuddering breath, and without as much as looking up, he speaks three words that tilt your world upside down.
âLupin kissed me.â
The silence is deafening, pressing heavily on your lungs like itâs trying to squeeze every last bit of air out of them. Maybe you heard him wrong, maybe he doesnât mean Remus Lupin but someone else with the same last name.
You blink, rapidly like maybe thatâll change the scenery and youâll find yourself somewhere completely different.
âWhat?â Your voice is strained, barely a whisper and it finally moves him to look at you. All your hopes of this being a misunderstanding are thwarted by the sheer guilt on his face, clearly proving your fears.
âRemus,â he croaks, the name sounding so foreign ins his mouth, âWe were tipsy, fought at the party, then we just kept goinâ back and forth with insults and banter and- Fangs I swear to Merlin I don't know what happened, he was suddenly so close, all I could smell and hear and feel and when he kissed me-â he chokes, the last part stuck in his throat. He looks to the side, like the sight of you alone might bring the unshed tears to spill. âWhen he kissed me, I didnât push back, I just kissed him back because it was so good.â
It must be a joke, you think. A very elaborate, very shitty joke he made up to mess with you. Thatâs the only explanation you have for your best friend kissing the guy that has been actively and relentlessly making your life hell for the past five, going on six, years.
The laugh that bubbles up in your chest escapes your mouth, and it shakes your entire body until you're clutching your stomach, tears pooling in the corners of your eyes.
Finally, the laughter dies down and you wipe your tears, the thought of him actually kissing Remus Lupin oh so ridiculous. âMan, you almost had me there B,â you giggle, leaning against the headboard as you stare at him with amusement.
âWhatâs actually going on? And donât make jokes again, that was not funny,â you muse, the smile on your face faltering when he turns to look at you, shaking his head gently.
He says your name, gentle yet firm, and it sounds almost as foreign as Lupinâs first name coming from his lips. âItâs not a joke,â he whispers, his voice fragile and quiet. You search his face for any of the signs that scream heâs lying, but there's no twitch in the corners of his lips, no quivering ears and only guilt and sincerity in his eyes.
He tries to reach out, but you recoil, violent and unexpected. Hurt flashes across his face, but you canât bring yourself to care, not when the betrayal sits deep in your bones.
âNo,â you mutter, over and over again like it might change the fact that the closest person to you just took your heart and gutted you from the inside out. The entire room spins, and suddenly everything is too hot, the walls closing in like they might cave in any second. Barty looks like he might actually start crying, and when you look at the mirror hanging across his bed, you catch a glimpse of your expression. Hurt, disgust, betrayal and anger coat your features, emotions Barty knows too well, but not from you. No, never you, until now.
You jump up, your eyes darting to the door and storm to it, ignoring his shouts and pleas for you to wait. Thereâs no point in running after someone with supernatural speed and strength, because by the time Barty stumbles out of the Ravenclaw tower to chase you, youâre already halfway across the castle.
The tears burn hot in your eyes, but you refuse to cry, not now at least. Somewhere in the recesses of your mind, you know you canât return to your own dorm because thatâs the first place heâll go looking for you. Quite frankly, you arenât sure if you can handle seeing him right now, the burn of what he has done and kept hidden for an entire week much too great for you to think about hearing him out.
âHe kissed meâ
âI just kissed him backâ
âIt was so goodâ
His words haunt you, halling off the walls as you run across the dark and abandoned corridors. They cling to you, like soot after a fire, and it makes you want to turn back to seek him and keep running all the same time. Where do you go now, when the one person you seek comfort from is the perpetrator of your pain?
Like a lost animal, you keep roaming the castle, running in circles until you crash into someone. For a moment, you think Barty might have found you, but youâre mistaken.
âOh goodness, whatâs going on?â Streaks of red fill your vision, and the smell of magnolia and jasmine surrounds you like a soothing balm. Lily grabs your shoulders, her voice filled with worry and concern for you as she stares at your tear streaked eyes. You realized you mustâve ended up on the patrol route of the Head Girl and Head Boy, yet your senses were too numbed and overtaken by emotions to register their approach. James Potter stands off to the side, expression torn between concern and caution as he observes the situation.
You try to answer, try to muster up some explanation as to why youâre out so far past curfew, but all that comes out are hiccups and silent sobs.
Lily doesnât ask, only embraces you tightly and offers warmth and comfort that barely holds your crumbling walls together.
That night, you donât sleep in your own dorm, and not in that of your Slytherins friends. Instead, Lily takes you back to her dorm, the girls welcoming you with open arms and sisterly concern. They donât push you to talk, merely allow you to rest and give you space to breathe. Mary suggests pushing all four beds together, and somehow the entire ordeal turns into some sort of sleepover party that you barely take note of. Your mind is blank, void of any and all thoughts, only filled with the ugly feeling of having your trust shattered by the one you love the most.
Sleep doesnât come to you that night, instead you replay every single moment of your conversation, of the last week he avoided you. It wonât stop plaguing you, and by the time you get ready for breakfast, the bags under your eyes tell a story of their own. Like your body is on autopilot, you make your way to the Slytherin table, greeting the small group of your friends with a curt nod. Regulus sips on a mug of dark coffee, constantly fiddling with a bracelet you donât remember seeing on him before, but at least he acknowledges your presence unlike Evan. The other boy is completely distracted, eyes wandering across the hall as if in search of someone specific. He startles when you sit beside him, briefly acknowledging you with a nod before he goes back to surveying the entire room. Dorcas and Pandora join your group a little later, the both of them intently staring with questions written across their facesâones you donât bother answering.
You feel him the moment he walks into the Great Hall, your heart speeding up when his gaze settles on you. Barty is quick to stride to the table, your name on his lips before he even reaches you. You canât take it, grabbing your bag and fleeing in a flash, not giving him or anyone else the chance to ask, much less comment on your behaviour.
Itâs the same routine for the next two weeks, where you barely get through the motions of the day, avoiding Barty to the best of your abilities, sticking close to your girls. Thereâs no lack of trying on his end, finding any and all opportunities to talk to you, but you shut him down every single time. It takes one hurt look, the words stuck in his throat, and heâs left looking at you as you turn on your heel and leave him.
Itâs strange, not having Barty close anymore. You never noticed how cold the world feels without him, so quiet and muted. He was the burst of color and noise that made everything brighter, more fun, more bearable. But in his absence, youâre left with ashes and gray nothing to soothe yourself with.
You barely eat, speak or move, a ghost of your former boisterous and mischievous self. Were it not for the efforts of Lily and the other girls, you might have gone under the pressure of carrying the weight of the loss all on your own.
The whole thing makes rounds at Hogwarts of course, because why would people not gossip about you? Rita Skeeter in particular seems to chase the gossip like a bloodhound, cornering you in the library or in empty classrooms to get the scoop on your fallout. You try to ignore her, push her away or flat out insult her in hopes of having her leaving you alone, but itâs all for naught. Day after day, she publishes outrageous articles and comments in the Hogwarts Daily, filled with such absurd claims, it takes your entire strength to keep Marlene and Mary from ambushing her at breakfast.
You ignore the whispers and looks that follow you, choosing to keep to yourself especially as the full moon draws near. What little strength you already had slowly vanishes, replaced by sluggish lethargy and a gnawing hunger that turns logic and reason into primal force. You nurse packets of blood throughout the day, ones your parents packed for emergencies, but they donât quell the thirst for violence, for hurt and rebuttal.
Each time your eyes stray from the ground, finding one of the gossipy students in the crowds, all you can think about is sinking your teeth into their neck, ripping them apart like a ragdoll, hearing the bones crack under the sheer force of your strength.
It scares you, the kind of monster you seem to be turning into without Barty to keep your humanity tethered, but itâs not like you can go looking for him now, can you? By the end of the first week, he had given up on invading your surroundings, instead pulling away to give you the space to make peace with the distance.
The full moon comes and goes, and for once youâre grateful your parents are too busy to accompany you on your hunt. Thereâs no doubt they would have picked up on the change in your disposition. They would have probed and asked until you broke, and how on earth were you supposed to explain what happened to them? They barely knew about the feud with Lupin, because if your fatherâor god forbid your motherâever caught wind of all the things he said and did to you, thereâs no doubt he would not return to Hogwarts alive.
Even after you return, the scent of iron still clinging to your clothes, the restlessness does not leave. Itâs almost like a second pubertyâall you can think about is letting your strength run free, to bask in the look of fear your prey have in their eyes when you crush their necks and bones.
It comes to a breaking point one night, when you sneak out from the Valkyries' dorm and follow the instincts that draw you into the Forbidden Forest. Itâs not often that you go there, but tonight thereâs something inexplicably alluring about the mystique that calls for you, like a siren that sings sailors to their doom at sea.
You wander around, expertly avoiding prying eyes as you go from wandering on foot to flying in your bat form. Thereâs something freeing about flying under the moonlight, soaring without the weight of pain that shackles you in your human form.
You lose all sense of time when you finally settle down on some patchy moss-covered rocks by the shore of a small lake. Itâs in the middle of some clearing, hidden away by the trees and bushes surrounding it, yet the moonlight filters beautifully through the foliage, casting glowing shadows and lights on the ripples of water. More than once, you can make out glowing eyes that watch you from underneath the waterâsome marine creatures drawn to your supernatural scent. You pay them no mind, instead dipping your legs into the water and letting the forest work its magic on your worn down nerves. Thereâs a sense of serenity in the air that almost fools you into forgetting about all that awaits back at the castle, about your true nature that gnaws on your insides and tries to come out each passing day.
You can almost believe youâre a normal human girl taking a stroll in the forest at night, not burdened by the weight of friendship or predatory instincts.
Almost.
The magic breaks when you hear a twig breaking, followed by a string of curses from a gruff and low voice you cannot recognise. Immediately, you get up, eyes roaming the clearing for any hiding spots or escape routes. A man emerges from the shadows, clearly a stranger from the heavy gear he has on his person. His face is covered in a mask made of bones, belts slung across his waist and legs filled with gadgets and vials youâve never seen. He smells of blood and sweat, the blood tinged with the familiar sense of magic and it finally dawns on you as you recall the lessons of Magical History and Care For Magical Creatures.
He must be a poacher, one of the people that hunt magical creatures for their skin, bones or other features that sell for good money on the black market. You remember hazily how Professor Hedgings said they occasionally sneak into the Forbidden Forest, the most skilled members of these groups bypassing and disabling the wards and safety measures for a limited amount of time while they hunt for creatures.
You calculate your chances of facing someone thrice your size, even if you have the advantages of being a vampire on your side. The man radiates bloodlust and madness from his eyes alone, and you do not want to start a fight here, still on school grounds. You take a step back, cautious and careful so you can disappear into the bushes and transform, but the universe really has it out for you. You slip on some of the moss, the sound of your fall immediately catching the attention of the poacher. His face pulls into a grimace at the sight of you, his hand instantly on his wand as he casts a spell that immobilises you.
For the first time in your life, deathly fear grips your heart as you watch the man step closer, his stride calculated and lightâalmost like a wild cat ready to pounce. Your brain blanks, trying to think of a protective spell is impossible under his sharp gaze.
âWhat do we have here?â He drawls, his voice grating like metal on a chalkboard. He circles you, eyes taking your helpless form from every angle until he stands above you, towering and dark.
Almost in slow motion, he reaches for a knife on his belt, toying with it as the blade glints dangerously under the moonlight. Heâs smirking, all teeth and danger, clearly having the upper hand and no thought of letting you leave this clearing in one piece.
Then, it happens.
Itâs a small mistake on his end, just a tiny cut on his hand as he twirls the blade around, but itâs fatale enough when one faces a vampire fuelled by the will to survive.
You black out as soon as the scent of warm fresh human blood fills your nostrils, the monster inside of you that has been caged for far too long finally breaking out of its prison.
When you return to your senses again, you find yourself in the very same clearing, hands and clothes drenched in blood that is not your own. With shaking legs, you walk over to the little lake, staring at the reflection of someone you do not recognise. Your eyes are red, glowing and dark, still filled with primal rage. Blood coats your face, your head and every inch of you. The taste lingers in your mouth, the taste of your first human prey. You turn around, a scream stuck in your throat at the sight of what must be the poacher.
Heâs unrecognisable, limbs twisted at unnatural angles, clothes slashed to pieces and flesh hanging off in clots. His face is frozen in an expression filled with fear, eyes empty and corpse drained.
It hits you then, that this must be your doing. Your first kill, the first human to die at your hands. You stare, from your hands to the macabre sight of his cooling corpse, and you fall backwards when you back away.
Itâs all over now, you think. As soon as they find him, they will come for you and you will end up in Azkaban for murder, or worse yet, chained in the dungeons of the Ministry as they keep you for experimental purposes. Itâs what happens to rogue vampires, your father had once explained bitterly.
You scramble to your feet, running and leaving the clearing behind as the forest slowly closes in on you. Itâs dark and loud, there are eyes watching you and every step you take, distant whispers that remind you of what you just did. Your head is loud, too loud, and your heart is beating out of your chest like it wants to escape and leave you to bleed out on the forest floor like the poacher in the clearing.
Your clothes are caught on a stray branch that pulls you back, sending you flying down a hill that you didnât notice in the dark. You roll down, gravel and sharp branches cutting through your bloodied skin and by the time you land at the foot of the hill, your body aches all over with adrenaline and incoming pain. Your ankle throbs, sharp pain shooting through your entire body when you try to stand up, so you give up and stay seated on the floor, out of breath and out of will to move. The sound of wolves howling in the distance carries through the wind, and youâre sure you wonât leave the forest tonight, not alive at least.
An eerie sense of peace fills you, now that you finally fed the monster and gave in to its demands for violence. There is no more fear, no more resentment or hate, just peace that numbs your entire body. You close your eyes, listening to the sound of the forest and feeling a presence at the edge of your subconscious close in on you, one that alarms you. You have no strength left to pay it any mind though, only opening your eyes for a fraction when someone breaks through the thick bushes, panting and huffing.
In the darkness, you could not have possibly seen his face, or made out his figure, yet his smell gives him away. Dazed and confused, you prop yourself on your aching and bleeding arms, eyes staring up at the second towering figure of the night.
âLupin?â You call out, voice hoarse and almost too quiet for him to hear. He does though, eyes snapping to yours as soon as it reaches his ears and his amber eyes go wide. Heâs tripping over himself to get to you, crouching beside you and cursing as his hands hover near your arms.
âWhat the fuck did you do?â He asks incredulously, surveying the extent of your injuries. The entire sequence of events is strange, something out of a bad dream perhaps, and you begin to giggle at how surreal this all feels.
âItâs okay,â you beam, clearly high on whatever adrenaline is left in your body, âthe blood is mostly not mine, no biggie!â
To his credit, Remus doesnât falter, only narrows his eyes and stares off into the distance before shaking his head, muttering something about taking care of it later, instantly scooping you up in his arms with a small puff. Youâre confused, to say the least, arms automatically wrapping around his neck as he adjusts your position.
He doesnât say anything, only tightens his hold and quickly exits the forest, eyes glancing at your face every so often to make sure youâre awake. As soon as youâre in his arms, all strength leaves your body, not even able to protest or tell him to put you down.
He carries you all the way back to the castle, rushing through the winding halls until you arrive at the hospital wing where he kicks the door open, shouting for the matron of the ward with urgency and familiarity that tells the tale of years of care and closure.
Madame Pomfrey grumbles when she first emerges from her office, clearly preoccupied with something that is interrupted by Remusâ frantic yelling. Her entire demeanour changes the moment she sees you in his arms, all scratched up and bloodied. Sheâs in work mode immediately, dishing out commands and muttering to herself as Remus sets you down on one of the beds closest to the entrance. With steady and warm hands, she begins to inspect every injury and cut on you, her wand working tirelessly to clean you up and to bring all the different potions and balms she needs to her.
The treatment might have lasted a few minutes or hours, your sense of time completely shut down during the process. By the end of it, she rid you of your torn clothes and gave you some of the spare, ill fitting clothing in the infirmary. Your cuts are all nicely bandaged and treated, and when she makes you swallow five different potions, you donât have the heart to remind her that as a vampire, you heal much faster than a regular human, and all you need is probably some blood.
Still, you allow the quiet thrumming of the potions to fill your body, slowly but surely breathing life back into you. The haze settles, and now that you can think clearer, you realize the sheer impact of what happened tonight. You can barely bring yourself to think about the man in the forest, but still, you have to tell someone about it.
So, when Poppy quietly asks what happened, you confess everything to her, from start to finish, your eyes avoiding her face. The situation feels familiar, the dynamic of someone admitting a harrowing truth to another and unable to look them in the face haunting you with such aching pain, but still. You push through, and by the end of your report, sheâs grown still. When you dare to steal a glance at her, youâre surprised to see an expression filled with understanding and worry. She gives you a tight lipped smile, bends forward and pats your head similar to the way your mother always does when you tell her about your problems.
âDonât worry dear,â she says warmly, but the determination in her eyes is everything but gentle, âIâll make sure you wonât get in trouble, so just focus on getting better, yes?â
You nod, a little dopey from the medicine and watch as she disappears through the doors of the ward, leaving you all alone. The only noise that fills the silence is your breathing, and somehow, in the absence of all sensations, you miss Barty more than ever. You miss his stupid jokes, his warm hands, his steady arms, his engulfing hugs, and more than ever you miss his voice and presence. If he were here, youâre sure he wouldâve given you a lecture about self preservation and not taking him on your adventures outside the castle before pulling you into a bone crushing hug.
Tears prick at the corners of your eyes, but you furiously wipe them away, refusing to cry about him more than you already have. You want to blame someone for this whole thing, and the best possible choice for that is of courseâas per usualâRemus Lupin. If he wasnât out to get you, so intent on ruining your life for no reason at all, things would be far different now.
The universeâclearly still on a trip to drive you into more ruin than you're already inâdecides that this is the perfect time for Lupin to come into the infirmary, his steps gentle as he approaches your bed. He looks around, presumably to look for Poppy but sheâs not around. You watch him closely, observing his disheveled appearance, like he just ran across the castle and back. He pulls out something from his pocket, some sort of paper that you canât really decipher and curses when he sees the contentâor at least you assume itâs the content that makes him curse, maybe heâs just gone madâbefore stowing it away.
Thereâs awkward silence stretching between the both of you, and for once you donât know what to say to him. Itâs not like you can insult him as you usually do, not when he practically saved your life tonight. You clear your throat, writhing under his watchful eyes and attempt some sort of small talk. âPoppy isnât here, by the way,â you note lamely, as if he hadnât noticed himself. Still, he coughs and makes a sound of understanding, fiddling with the bag you just notice in his hand before he sighs.
He steps closer to your bed, and you almost expect him to start yet another fight with you, but he merely sets the bag down, rummaging through it before pulling out articles of clothing you recognise as your own.
Your eyebrows shoot up, suspicion clear on your face when he awkwardly scrambles to try and explain why he has a bag filled with your clothes.
âI asked Lily,â he says, scratching the back of his neck as you examine what heâd brought for you. âFigured thereâs nothing comfortable for you to wear here, and since youâre basically moved in with the girls I thought they might have some of your clothes.â
The gesture leaves you stunned, to say the least. Itâs incredibly thoughtful, and a complete 180 from the Lupin you usually interact with. Hell, you didnât even think him capable of extending such kindness to you. It warms your heart, but you quickly remember that this was still the guy whoâs actively tried to ruin your life on multiple occasions.
âThank you,â you mutter, grasping the fabric of the blue ravenclaw sweater he brought. The sweater is one you stole from Barty, his scent still faintly clinging to it, and the comfort it brings is almost instant. Youâre about to pull the shirt Poppy gave you over your head when your arms protest with an instant ache, causing you to hiss and drop them. The potions havenât fully set in yet, and you give up on the notion of changing, despite how much you crave it.
Lupin, smarter than you give him credit for, deciphers the situation and clears his throat, voice low as he reaches out gently. âI can help you,â he murmurs, fingers brushing against the hem of your shirt. When you make no effort to move away from his touch, he takes it as a sign to go on. Tentatively, softer than you ever thought is possible for someone like him, he pulls your shirt over your head, making sure to not accidentally graze the cuts on your arms that are slowly healing. It feels awkward, and maybe a little bit wrong for you to be half naked in front of the guy who readily slammed you into a wall two or so years ago.
With unexpected gentleness, he guides your limbs into the holes of the sweater, carefully putting it on and helping you tug it into place until the fabric is warm and snug against your body. You want to thank him, almost, but the words donât come so easily over your lips again. Instead, you stare pointedly at your blanket, unable to really look into his face. You fear that if you do, he might begin to read you like an open book, the way youâve watched him read every room and situation like a polyglot proficient in ancient tongues long forgotten.
You do, however, call out to him when he retreats, mumbling something under his breath that is impossible to decipher, even for you.
âWait!â You blurt out, unsure what you even want him to wait for. âSit down?â You whisper, quieter this time and with less momentum, a little fragile, a little unsure, but still inviting nonetheless.
He turns around, eyes wide for a split second, like maybe heâs questioning if your injuries messed with your head, before he relents and makes himself comfortable on the bed. He sits cross-legged, knees close enough to your own that they might brush if one of you moves just a fraction, and the proximity nearly steals your breath in one swift gust.
You force yourself to not think too hard about how close heâs sitting, or how he smells like chocolate, library, and some sort of musky cologne that you swear you smelled on Sirius Black before. If you allow yourself to think about it, youâll be left with the realisation that this is the first time the both of you have spent in a room, alone, so close without a fight. You donât know what to do with this information, or the tingle in your hands, or his warmth that seeps into your skin through the thin material of the blanket, so you squash it down into the darkest corners of your mind.
Lupin, to his credit, tries to act indifferent to the whole situation, but clearly fails. His hands are twitching awkwardly beside him in an attempt to find the best place to put them without touching you directly. Finally, he settles on propping his chain against one of themâwhich in retrospect really isnât good for your heart. Now heâs staring at you, directly and with quiet focus, like youâre the most interesting thing in the whole room.
Heâs never looked at you this way, with curiosity and a little bit of awe swirling in those golden pools of amber, and itâs enough to drive you a tiny bit mad. You want to say something clever, maybe a witty remark to bring back the comforting back and forth rhythm the both of you share, but nothing leaves your lips.
Instead, he makes the first move, leaning forward like he might share his biggest secret with you, but instead he stares pointedly at the Ravenclaw emblem sewn into the dark blue sweater.
âThat Crouchâs sweater?â He asks, like the answer isnât already clear. Half the school knows you wear Bartyâs clothes, proudly displaying your bond, just like he walks around wearing items of yours.
You havenât been wearing his clothes lately though, and he hasnât worn anything of yours in the weeks you spent apart. His question is like a spear piercing through your heart, reminding you why you ended up here in the first place.
If it werenât for him making your life hell, if it werenât for him kissing Barty, if it werenât for the distance clouding your judgment, then maybe you would be curled up in Bartyâs bed now, low conversation flowing under the dim light of candles and cheap enchanted fairly lights.
Still, you nod, not trusting your voice to stay steady if you were to answer him verbally. He seems to understand, and the sod smirks. Like, actually smirks, lips curling and features turning all sharp and predatory underneath the the glow of the moonlight that filters through the windows.
âIt suits you well,â he drawls, eyes racking over your form with amusement and something you canât really name. âWould suit you better if the two of you werenât tragically moping apart,â he adds afterwards, casually like itâs an afterthought, but youâve had so many verbal sparring sessions with him you can smell the coaxing strategy a mile away. âWhatâs up with that anyway? Arenât you usually bound at the hip or something?â He cocks his head, messy hair falling over his eyes like a confused puppy, and something stutters in your chest. Maybe youâre getting sick, or maybe the overdoses on human blood is finally driving you to the edge, because Remus Lupin looks nearly cute like that.
You huff indigently and cross your arms in protest, like it might be a physical and emotional barrier to whatever witchcraft he's performing on you right now.
âAnd what, pray tell, is it to you,?â, you throw back, with far less venom than you would usually use. He chuckles at that, sound smooth and honeyed, a little bit like he keeps it for special occasions, and nods at the underlying question you pose.
Are you being nosy right now, Lupin?
âHard to not be curious when itâs all anyone can talk about,â he remarks, âPlus, you havenât picked a fight in like three weeks, figured that must be why.â
Itâs hard to refute the argument because, well, it is true. You canât quite find it in yourself to argue with him or think about murder plots without Barty at your side, and without energy to even get through the day, getting even with Lupin is the last thing on your mind.
âWhoâs fucking fault do you think that is, you twat?â You mumble, propping yourself more upright against the pillows despite the aching in your back. Lupin notices, because of course he notices everything with those sharp eyes that never leave you out of sight, and he quietly accios two pillows from the cot next to yours, scooting closer until he can put them behind your back for you.
Your breath hitches when his arms come up to your sides, caging you in while he pushes you gently to adjust the pillows neatly. He's so close to you nowâcloser than he has ever been in the past five years. His hair tickles your neck when he tilts his head to get a better look at the pillows, the sound of his breath so loud in the silence between you it sends your brain into a short circuit.
He returns to his original place, like the whole ordeal is no big deal at all, but the quickened pace of his heartbeat tells you that he is not as unaffected by your presence as he likes to pretend. Itâs a small victory, but one you take in stride anyway.
âIt hardly can be my fault,â he quips back, âI donât even talk to you, let alone that mad dog of yours.â
âOh you donât talk alright, you just push your tongue down his throat.â
He blinks, slowly, too slowly actually, his face mirroring your own disbelief at what you just said. You didnât mean to say that out loud, or to sound so bitter about itâit just happened. His face slowly pulls into a smirk, like a light bulb just went off and he laughsâactually laughsâfull on doubled over, voice echoing back from the walls. You sit there, stewing in indignation until he calms down, fixing you with an overly amused smile you oh so desperately want to wipe off his face.
For a moment, your eyes flicker down to his lips and you suddenly understand why Barty had let Remus kiss him at that party. They look, truth to be told, soft and inviting, especially under the silver moonlight.
Itâs just a moment of weakness, but when your eyes snap up, he looks as startled as you feel, like heâd been caught staring at something he shouldnât covet. A strange sort of anticipation settles between the both of you, unnamed and inherently terrifying when itâs with the person you spent so much time hating.
This time, itâs you who tries to make the first move in clearing the air, not one to let him overshadow you even in something as petty as that. âDid you do it to get back at me?â You demand to know, like his affairs are your god given right to inquire about. You suppose they are, when they involve the person you love.
Heâs taken aback by the brazen question, mulling it over more carefully than you thought he would. When he answers, you half expect a snarky response, but are left surprised by the vulnerability in his words.
âNo,â he says, slow and careful, like the words might break him if he says them too loud. âI wouldnât want to hurt youânot like that at leastâand most definitely not by taking advantage of him too.â
Another question lingers on your lips, ready to be fired, but he answers it before you can even voice it out loud.
âIt wasnât a mistake,â he cuts off, voice firm and so deliberate, itâs hard to think heâs lying. After a few beats of silence, he adds on, a little quieter this time.
âI enjoyed it, and I didnât do it because I wanted to hurt him, I simply wanted to kiss him in that moment with no strings attached.â
The rawness and honesty dripping from his voice, evident in his expression and body language, almost make you breathless. It truly is marvellous, how he shuts down every worry and doubt you had over this ordeal, for your best friend's well being, with all the poise of a man who knows what he wants.
There is nothing left for you to ask or say, and for once, you allow Remus Lupin the pleasure of shocking you into positive silence. The git enjoys it too, a small smile on his lips that stretches the scar across his lip a little, the skin nearly glowing in the dark. His eyes dart down, just for a second, gleaming with something that reminds you of the way Barty looks at you when the lights are low. You wonder if thatâs how he looked at Barty before he kissed him, wonder if he might be thinking about kissing you too just to see if best friends kiss the same.
When he looks up, he's clearly mortified, and so are you when your thoughts finallyâ actuallyâset in.
What in the world were you thinking, about Lupin no less?
He eyes the door, pushing himself off the bed with a little too much force and grabs the bag he brought your clothes in, shouldering the strap without as much as looking into your direction. For a moment, he reminds you of a clumsy baby deer trying to escape a hunterâand again, the thought of him being almost adorable crosses your mind.
When he stretches up to his full height, nervously patting down his clothes, he avoids your gaze, but stills in his movements and looks at your sweater instead.
âYou should talk to him,â he comments softly, âYou both are miserable in the distance, at least hear each other out, yeah?â
If tonight's events weren't already strange on their own, then Remus Lupin giving you friendship advice most definitely wouldâve taken the crown. Alas, far weirder things have transpired, so you simply nod and watch as he makes his way to the door.
âI still donât like you,â you call out after him, the need to clarify intense as the magic of your shared moment slowly withers.
He stops in his tracks, turning around to cast a lingering glance to you, something between amusement and understanding.
âStill donât like you either, Bat.â
Youâre stunned into silence by this guy for what feels like the millionth time tonight, but somehow, you don't mind it as much as you think you should.


















