I might be one of the only people who preferred OUaTiW over OUaT. I truly loved the platonic friendship between Alice and Will. I absolutely loved Alice and Cyrus's romance and Will and Anastasia's romance. I loved every single character. Every backstory was so well done. Every relationship was so complex and beautiful.
The absolute lack of fanfiction for the show destroys me. Like, it's all very romance focused (which is great), but I would use one of my three wishes for an endless supply of fanfics where it's a weekly adventure of Will getting into trouble, Anastasia reporting it to Cyrus and Alice, and Alice leading Cyrus and Anastasia on a rescue mission to get her "friend with consequences" back.