I read Doctor Who Origin Stories today and I gotta admit I have mixed feelings on this book.
Like itās a collection of ten stories of various Doctor Who characters and stories in their youth. And there is an assortment of them.
Like in Velvet Hugs, Jo is thinking about her life and the events that led her to where she is in her life, married to Cliff with children and their lives as activists for the planet. Itās her thoughts about what led her to working with UNITED and meeting the Doctor.
You also got My Daddy Fights Monsters where young Kate and her mother are confronted by an alien who thinks they can help give it information on the Brig and the Doctor, but they genuinely know nothing and the alien leaves them in peace.
The Big Sleep is Vastraās tale, a little on her origins and why sheās awake compared to the rest her people, being recounted to her wife Jenny.
Tempered also has a lot to do with the Master and Missy and his/her experiences after going mad from the time scheme and killing the Time Lord that took them to the initiation when they were eight.
I like these stories a lot because they expand a little on the characters and were pleasant to read. They pretty much have no involvement from the Doctor, or if he is involved itās later or not really related to the character.
Then you got The Last of the Dals, with Davros who is trying to learn about his future and in a way blames the Doctor for it. Believing that had the Doctor not come and saved his life he wouldnāt be on the path of destruction he is on.
The Girl Who Tore Through the Universe is about Amy and Roy. Amy is so desperate to find the raggedy man that she steals some of Isaac Newtonās papers about multiverse to try and summon the Doctor, but she accidentally brings her mother from another universe and nearly tears their own universe apart.
In these stories the Doctor isnāt in the story, but The Doctorās existence heavily impacts the characters and their motivations. And those were also interesting.
Then there were stories where the Doctor has encountered a companion.
In Chemistry, Ace explains her love of chemistry due to her chemistry teacher, who actually took an interest in her and interacted with her. When her teacher randomly vanishes however an alien confronts Ace to find out where her teacher was, and the teacher comes to save Ace. The teacher is the Thirteenth Doctor who immediately erases all of this but Aceās love of chemistry from her memory.
The Myriapod Mutiny involves Yaz and Ryan going on a school field trip together but they get separated from the class only to get caught in two alien groups trying to invade the Earth. The Second Doctor arrives and negotiations deals, one able to stay on the Earth and the other being taken to a new planet to live in. And of course their memories are erased, which still doesnāt make sense when or how it was done because the Doctor didnāt have a reason to do it but it had to happen for reasons to keep them from remembering they encountered aliens.
Doctor Jones has Martha coming up on high school graduation with no plans for her future. After her mom gets hurt she goes to the store to buy bandages but she encounters the ninth doctor and ends up accidentally taken to Salem during the Salem Witch Trials. The Doctor saves her but says that in order to get the two of them back to the proper time they need to use time termites and for it to work he will have to erase the memory of the adventure from both of their memories. So neither remember this happened and they end up in modern times, where Martha decides she wants to be a Doctor.
Murmuration and Clara Oswald and the Enchanted Forest are similar in that the Doctor wants to go check on their companion, Four with Sarah Jane and Eleven with Clara, but they mess up with the controls and arrive too early.
Four encounters Sarah as sheās running from an alien creature that possessed a murmur of sparrows and they stop the creature but the Doctor is forced to erase Sarahās memory to keep her from remembering him as they havenāt met yet.
In a similar fashion Eleven finds Clara in a forest with alien trees after she had a vicious fight with her mother. After they work together to find the treasured leaf of Claraās parents that she threw out the window to hurt her mom, Eleven erases her memories to preserve the timeline.
I guess I have mixed feelings on these because in three of them it is like Yaz, Ryan, Ace, and Martha were destined to meet the Doctor, especially with Thirteen being Aceās teacher. And in all these stories the companions have no memory of what happened, and when an earlier Doctor meets a future companion thereās something to also prevent them from remembering whichā¦I donāt know feels weird. Like I like the version in the novels that Martha became a doctor because she was taking care of Leo after he got hurt instead of just residual feeling of admiring the Ninth Doctor.
Deja Donna was a little different because this is a story that happened because they were investigating what happened. Donna sees a post card while her and Ten are shopping, which reminds her of when she saw it many years ago as a kid. She āstrong armsā the Doctor into going to see what happened that day as she nearly died. He agrees on the condition she doesnāt get involved.
When they do they find young Donna hearing a kid get hurt in a cave, a cave they believed a monster was in. Older Donna throws a brick with the post card tied to it that tells young Donna to be brave, so young Donna runs in and rescues the boy, but as they leave the cave the cave collapses. It collapses because the TARDIS had landed on top of the cave and it couldnāt handle the weight.
Overall the stories were well written, I just had mixed feelings on some.