Part 1 | Part 2

Luke : Positively in love with the musical until Macavity appears, which low-key terrifies him near as bad as a horror movie would. To be fair, there is an awful lot of thunder and evil laughing associated with him and nobody (MC) thought to warn Luke it would be scary because it never occurred to them as scary. Still firmly asserts that he had a good time, but definitely has nightmares about a diabolical thieving cat for weeks afterwards. Got a logo t-shirt as merch and a snow globe.

Solomon : You think he hasn't seen this before? Wrong. In fact, Solomon can name every single cat, whether they have a song or not. Oddly, his favorite character seems to be Demeter. Regrettably IS that guy who hums along to songs even though this is live theater. Judges you based on your choice of favorite cat. Gets a silly little ball cap with cat ears and the logo. Wears it the rest of the night with no shame no matter how out of place it looks with his robes.

Diavolo : Overjoyed to have escaped the watchful gaze of Barbatos (because this is absolutely a sneak out activity) to do something so silly and human as witness a show like this. Bopping along in his seat like a nerd even though he has never seen this before. Sees Skimbleshanks, dissolves into quiet laughter picturing his butler at home and happily informs MC of the similarities he found. Would have liked anything you took him to do topside ngl. Gets matching CATS mugs for MC, Barbatos, and himself. Refuses to use anything but these at tea for the foreseeable future, which Barbatos HATES.

Simeon : Inspired by the creativity of the set, how it adapts to each cat's song and situations. Heavily sympathizes with Grizzabella, frowning at the way she is treated. It reminds him of when the brothers fell and how a lot of heaven's occupants turned their back on the new demons without hesitation. Leaves thoughtful, a new book forming in the back of his brain, but makes sure MC knows he appreciated being taken to such a human experience. Talks with amusement about how humans can put a personality and story into everything. Seems to favor Jemima and Victoria a decent amount.

Thirteen : Had no idea what she was getting into, simply went because MC asked it of her. Quietly asks MC the names of any cat that doesn't get a song but gains her attention throughout the entire show. An abundance of silent awed looks and adoration for the whimsy of the environment. Asks to do this as costumes for Halloween but equally is unable to decide which cat she would like to be since she never could pinpoint who her favorite was. Hums Gumbie Cat the most though, as the rest of the night goes on. Picked up a soundtrack, t-shirt (which she intends to alt style), and jacket. Asks MC all the time if they can go again, and if not, which musical they can go see next! She wants to know them all!

Mephistopheles : Decides he hates musicals, but won't specify if it is because he hated this musical as his first and doesn't want to try more in case they're also infested with humanoid cats or if he simply hates musicals in general. The former is suspected. Sat in a curmudgeonly fashion the whole time but didn't complain about being dragged along simply because MC seemed to be having a good time. Was forced into a ball cap with the logo and ears after and was not happy about it.

As any other bi will tell you, I fear women. However, I will give her a new outfit. @th1rteen-th3-reaper, thoughts? I kinda went based solely on vibes.

Side note, you mentioned Azrael being besties with Maren and stuff, but would Maren get along with Thirteen??

Teehee. I’m glad you enjoy them <3

I love obey me and I love how unserious it is most of the time but I tend to treat what happens a lot more seriously when thinking about it. Hence a more serious, human mc

As for Maren and Thirteen… yes they do get along but it’s interesting because Thirteen is the only member of the cast who isn’t a resident of the three realms (not going to explain why that’s important in this ask bc it’d take too long but it is)

Their dynamic starts off a bit odd. Because that’s Thirteen’s boses’ best friend who is very much Not Allowed To Die and Azrael made that very clear to her. But that doesn’t mean she likes them at first

My fucking stupid ass cat scratched the bottom of the page on my thirteen headcanons 💔