Mojo-furen? You probably recognize my IP, and you probably recognize me as a regular anon Fic Detective. I’ve read fics that I wish I hadn’t. I’ve read fics that had me wondering whether the author and I had read the same book. I’ve read fics that are the digital equivalent of crumpled, rabbit-gnawed, and jam-smudged with messy fingerprints. Each one was a story someone wanted to write; if a Mood or Fic Finder ask indicates that it’s a story someone else wants to read, I’ll pass it along.
Fic Detective!!! Yes, I recognize you (although I've never checked your IP, is that even a thing?)... mostly because your syntax and very polite tone are quite distinctive.
Funny you should say this, because I was just musing about my Favorites the other day, and how what strikes me one way today can hit so differently tomorrow. The gist of it is: what works (or doesn't) for you in this very moment is subject to change. And what works (or doesn't) for you will affect some other reader very differently.
ALL STORIES ARE VALID. Whether or not they chime with you. Be proud to love what you love, and stay quiet on the ones others love but you don't. We are all so different! AO3 is a vast banquet, and we're not all going to head straight for the same dish.
Here are my thoughts on fanfiction, that I posted here a couple of years ago.
So, I think about fanfiction a lot.
And here’s the thing about the stories you love.
Sometimes they’re a literary work of art, and the author is skilled and deft and has a voice like Austen or Hemingway or name-your-giant-in-the-field.
Sometimes their plot is enormously convoluted and clever and you’re surprised with every turn.
Sometimes they’re so much better than canon you can’t imagine how this author isn’t in charge of the series/movies/books.
Sometimes they’re written by an obvious novice, but the premise or trope is so addictive to you that you’re drawn in.
Sometimes they’re in barely passable English (to which I can only think, welp, I can only write in one language, and this person can write in at least two, so who am I to judge?), but the story they tell is *chef's kiss*.
With fanfiction, you (the reader) can focus on the story itself, and the rest of it is kind of meaningless, or at the least, it’s icing on the cake. You can choose to read the entire work, or you can hit the back button and find a different one.
But this is for authors out there who worry that they’re not good enough by whatever metric: if you have a story to tell, that story is going to resonate with someone else, and that someone else is going to be so very grateful that you went to the trouble of writing it.