reading everyoneās thoughts on the london special and marinetteās actions have given me a serious case of deja vu in relation to the s5 finale, hereās why
a very very VERY common reaction from the fandom i saw to the finale was āwhy are the writers letting gabriel get away with being a hero why isnāt he being held accountable horrible finale horrible writing i hate this show etc etc etcā
before i share my thoughts on this for like the thousandth time i just wanna mention i DID cry during the finale, partly because i was in shock and also because i HATED it. but now i genuinely believe it was one of if not the smartest thing the ml writers have ever conjured up and i just. fucking love it. (point is: i understand disliking it. that was me at some point, until i began to consider the implications of the āendingā)
similarly, a reaction iāve seen to the london special (mainly from ml salters) is āwhy would the writers let marinette lie to the world when itās so clearly morally wrong sheās such a horrible person she needs to be held accountable blah blah blahā
something both the s5 finale and the london special share is that THE ACTIONS THAT TAKE PLACE IN BOTH. ARE NOT MEANT. TO SIT WELL WITH THE AUDIENCE
NO writer on ml is trying to convince a fan that āgabriel was actually a hero because he made one selfless decision (that wasnāt even that selfless?????)ā. NO writer on ml is trying to convince a fan that āmarinette is completely right for hiding the truth about gabriel from not only adrien but also the whole world!!!!!! no one should ever find out!!!ā
the entire point of the finale and special is to make the viewer uncomfortable, as we watch marinette sit with her questionable choices, watch adrien refer to his father as a hero and watch their class throw a party. none of this is supposed to make us feel at peace with the way this arc has concluded.
what people seem to be missing is that even if the s1-s5 arc has ended, the s6 arc is just beginning, CENTERED AROUND THE CHOICES THAT HAVE MADE US AS THE AUDIENCE FEEL SO UNCOMFORTABLE!! youāre completely ignoring the way the plot is set up if you think the writers are going to neglect gabrielās storyline, because it is far from over.
i think itās also important to mention that neither marinette nor adrien are at peace with whatās happened (even if that was implied during the s5 finaleāthe london special has provided us with this new information on their emotional statuses). marinette is clearly being eaten alive by guilt, seeking confirmation throughout the entire special that protecting adrien from the truth was the morally correct decision. adrien was obviously affected by his fatherās death (contrasting the idea that he just āthrew a partyā without any emotional backlash), and will undoubtedly learn to grapple with his conflicting feelings on gabrielās character throughout s6 (he sacrificed himself??? but he abused me??? but he saved ladybug and nathalie????? but he apparently assisted monarch?????)
no one is meant to be satisfied with the way things are in the miraculous universe at the moment. you arenāt supposed to want the truth about what really went down during recreation to stay hidden. if you feel uncomfortable with the current situation our main characters are in, GOOD! please stop the discrediting the writers, because your discomfort means they have done their job well.