#mariejois

Outside of Syrup Village and the Daddy Masterson filler, no one in the world of One Piece has ever associated Usopp with Yasopp. Not Marines. Not villains. Not enemies trying to psychologically break him. And that absence is loud. If a villain wanted to crush Usopp’s spirit, what better way than to invoke his father? Yet it never happens. That kind of omission doesn’t feel accidental. It feels intentional

Banchina herself never speaks about Yasopp with bitterness or resentment. She neve r curses him or paints him as selfish. She tells Usopp that his father went out to sea to pursue his dream, but One Piece has shown us time and time again that “dream” can be both true and incomplete. If Oda truly wanted Yasopp framed as a deadbeat, Banchina would have reflected that anger. Instead, there’s a quiet sadness, not blame. Having had to terms with him not coming back because of…something else.

That’s why I don’t believe Yasopp simply left to chase adventure. Becoming a pirate may have been real, but it also feels like a cover. Because if Yasopp truly wanted a normal life, why did he have to leave everything behind so completely? Why attach him to Shanks of all people? Especially now that we know how deeply Shanks is embedded in the core mysteries of the world.

People are willing to call Judge complex despite his cruelty, yet Yasopp is denied that same narrative generosity. What does that say? A Yasopp flashback would do a lot to reframe this conversation, and honestly, it feels inevitable. Yasopp is tied to Shanks, to the Straw Hats, and to the Final Saga itself. That alone makes him significant.

Usopp and Luffy are the only Straw Hats with living parents whose stories are unresolved. That is not a coincidence. The fandom underestimates Yasopp because they assume the simplest explanation, that he left and never came back. But One Piece rarely operates on that level of simplicity, especially this late in the story.

I think Yasopp’s story is going to be far more tragic than people expect. In the same way Kuma’s past recontextualized everything we thought we knew about him, I think Yasopp is being set up for something similar. Usopp becomes especially important in the Final Saga not just because of who he is, but because of who his father is connected to. Something bigger than Wano. Bigger than Whole Cake Island.

Oda has always been deliberate with Usopp. He showed us his Observation Haki in Dressrosa not because it was immediately necessary, but because it would matter later. It wasn’t needed for Wano or Egghead, but it was planted for the Final Saga. Looking back at Onigashima I can understand why Usopp didn’t have a flashy combat showcase. His role there was ideological. Survival. Refusal to surrender one’s dignity.

That matters.

All of this makes me believe there is more to Usopp’s backstory than we currently understand, and Yasopp is the key to unlocking it. Like it or not, that door is going to open.

some analysis of mine that i partially agree w/ now. 😳 especially the earlier ones. the recent recent ones i vibe with. the others? wtf.

analysis 0 (most recent).

analysis 1

analysis 2

analysis 3

analysis 4

analysis 5

Maids filtered in and out of the chamber with quiet precision, eyes carefully lowered, lips sealed. None dared to look at you, yet each carried the lesson of the night as surely as you did. They did not try to coax you toward rest, for they understood—just as you did—that you were meant to keep vigil. You were meant to watch the blaze devour the annex and accept the punishment it carried with it.

Instead, they moved about the newly opened rooms with the solemnity of mourners, soft-footed and efficient, setting fresh linens, kindling the hearth, and arranging comforts you had not earned. Each gesture of service was a cruel contrast, a reminder of luxury extended where guilt should have left only stone and ash.

At some point, when the night was still heavy and the stars finally pierced through the thinning smoke to glitter faintly above, the door opened without ceremony. A woman stepped inside, her presence steady, her tread unhurried. She wore the same livery as the senior staff, though her uniform was finer, cut from richer cloth with stitching that caught the light. Her hands were steady around a porcelain cup that steamed faintly in the candlelight. The head maid, you thought, watching her reflection shimmer in the window beside your own.

A single candle lit her face, its flame painting her features in shifting gold.

She lingered in silence, watching you as though weighing some unspoken question. Flickers of emotion crossed her face—pity, suspicion, disdain—all vanishing too quickly to hold, until at last her expression hardened into practiced apathy. In her hand, she carried a small porcelain cup, steam curling from its surface, the faint scent of honeyed milk softening the acrid smoke that drifted in from outside.

The head maid set the cup upon the table beside you with a deliberate gentleness, the faint clink of porcelain against wood louder than it should have been in the silence. She did not offer words of comfort. Her eyes lingered on your reflection in the window, as if memorizing the image of you standing watch over the ruin. Then she inclined her head in the smallest of acknowledgments and turned her gaze to the fire beyond, where sparks still leapt into the air as though refusing to die.

You understood then that this act would demand more from you than the slow gnawing of guilt. It would carve through the fragile web of loyalty within the household, leaving you alone in its cold center. Those who had friends in the annex would not mark Garling as cruel. They would not see his fire as a tyrant’s warning. They would see only you—your presence, your failure—as the conduit through which their loss had been delivered. The milk on the table seemed mocking in its warmth, a comfort you could not reach for without betraying the truth of how unwelcome you had become.

The head maid did not leave immediately. She stood beside the table with her hands folded neatly at her waist, her shadow long against the wall. At last, she spoke, her voice even, stripped of warmth.

“The house knows who and what you are,” she said. “Do not mistake their silence for kindness. The annex had its own ways, but this household is different. We serve Saint Garling as the god he is, and we do not question his will. Any misbehavior from his lady will be answered directly, and it will be answered by him. Do not imagine that the staff will shield you.”

Her eyes flicked once to the cup of milk, as though marking it as both comfort and warning. “You will find no softness here. The former Lady Figarlands once thought themselves untouchable, and yet they learned. None of them were released, as you may have heard whispered. No, they are kept. Used.” She let the word hang for a breath, then finished, her tone flat as stone. “Saint Garling works closely with Saint Saturn, and his house has long been a place of experiment. That is the fate of those who fail him.”

The candle flame bent in a draft, making her expression sharper for a moment. “Remember this. You will not be coddled as the annex coddled you. Should you forget your place, you will join the others, and your name will be written among the failed.”

She inclined her head just enough to mimic respect, though it felt more like a mockery, and withdrew, leaving the faint scent of beeswax and smoke in her wake. The cup of milk remained, steaming faintly in the cold air, a fragile token set against the enormity of the warning she had delivered.

The lesser maids returned in measured steps, their faces carefully blank. At last, they beckoned you from the window, not with words but with the gentle tug of hands that allowed no refusal. They stripped away your fine dress and the glittering jewels that still clung to your skin with the smell of smoke. Your hair was brushed until it gleamed, though each stroke carried a stiffness that betrayed their distance. You felt no tenderness in their touch, only duty performed without affection.

One carried the porcelain cup from the table, still faintly warm, the sweet scent of honey drifting from its surface. She pressed it into your hands, and when you hesitated, she guided it to your lips with a quiet insistence. The milk was heavy on your tongue, cloying in its sweetness, and you drank because there was no choice.

Even as they guided you beneath the layers of fresh linen, you did not turn your gaze from the window. The night had blackened fully now, stars pricking the void above the last drifting coils of smoke. It was only when your eyelids grew leaden and the warmth of the draught began to spread through your limbs that your vision blurred. Tears welled, unbidden, slipping down your cheeks to soak into the pillow. You had not given them permission, yet they fell all the same.

Sleep claimed you at last, heavy and final, pulling you down while the ruins of the annex still burned in your memory. The darkness was deep and dreamless, a prison of silence that refused to release you. Hours bled into a full day while the world moved without you, your body subdued by the weight of the draught and your own exhaustion.

-X-

The courtyard of Castle Pangaea had been stripped of ornament and swept bare, its marble paving washed until it gleamed like bone. A circle had been chalked in pale ash at its center, the mark of a sanctioned duel. Though it was declared private, the walls themselves betrayed the lie. Every gallery window was crowded with pale figures in silks and jewels, Celestial Dragons pressing their faces to the glass. They whispered, tittered, and gasped like children at a festival. The duel was blood sport in all but name, and the hunger in their eyes made it holy theater.

Thorne stood at one edge of the circle, sword drawn, his expression set in grim resolve. He had been granted the courtesy of a ceremonial surcoat, though it hung heavy on his shoulders, stained faintly at the hem with old ash from the courtyard’s past duels. Across from him, Garling Figarland entered with the composure of a man stepping into a role already written. His armor shone with ruthless polish, his crimson cloak a deliberate flare of color against the pale marble. His blade, long and honed like judgment itself, caught the noon sun and threw shards of light across the circle.

When the herald spoke, the courtyard held its breath. “By sanction of the Elders and by the will of the Holy Throne, this duel is called. The stakes are Lady Vauntierre and the noble standing of the combatants. The victor claims both prize and name. The vanquished surrenders all.”

The words were punctuated by a ripple of applause from the windows, thin and brittle, more mockery than honor.

Garling raised his sword in a formal salute, though his eyes were cold. “Do you understand, Thorne? You do not fight only for her hand. You fight for the right to call yourself a noble. When you lose, both will be stripped from you.”

Thorne’s jaw tightened. “Then I will fight twice as hard.”

Garling’s mouth curved faintly, humorless. “Twice of nothing is still nothing.”

The clash came swiftly. Steel rang against steel, each strike reverberating through the marble like a bell tolling doom. Thorne fought with discipline, his blade snapping in sharp arcs, every thrust a soldier’s prayer. But Garling moved as though forewarned, each parry a dismissal, each counter a reminder of the gulf between them.

“You are skilled,” Garling admitted as their blades locked, sparks leaping between them. His voice was calm and conversational, as though they were debating over wine instead of competing for an audience. “Skilled enough to make peasants cheer. Skilled enough to impress your little revolution. But here—” he shoved him back, sword scraping across Thorne’s guard with contemptuous force “—skill without pedigree is dust on marble.”

Thorne caught his balance, eyes burning. “Your pedigree means nothing when your cause is rot.”

Garling laughed softly, a low sound that carried to the windows. “And yet it is rot that rules you. Tell me, Thorne, how many generations of your family wore chains while mine wore crowns? Do you think one good swing will rewrite history?”

They circled again, Garling letting him breathe, letting him sweat. The crowd above leaned close to the glass, jeweled hands pressed like eager children.

Thorne lunged, driving his blade toward Garling’s heart. For a moment, the courtyard rang with the scrape of steel. But Garling turned the strike aside almost lazily, their swords sparking in the sunlight. “Ah, there it is,” he said smoothly. “Your desperation. It makes you clumsy.”

“I’ll carve that smirk from your face,” Thorne spat, shoving forward again.

Garling’s eyes gleamed, and he raised his voice. “Do. Then perhaps the city will take pity on your shame. Until then, fight harder, Saint Thorne. Make their laughter worth my time.”

From the windows came a chorus of muffled laughter, sharp and cruel, echoing over the marble as the duel continued—one man fighting for everything, the other merely entertaining himself.

At last, Thorne broke the rhythm. His breaths came ragged and shallow, each inhalation a tremor through his shoulders. His sword hand shivered; sweat darkened his brow and ran in bright tracks along his jaw. “Why do you hold back?” he demanded, voice raw with fury that trembled into something like pleading. “Why not end it now? Why not fight me to the death?”

Garling did not hurry to answer. He stood with the patient calm of a man watching a candle gutter, the sun catching his blade and throwing a thin line of light across his face. When he lowered the sword, it was almost imperceptible, a movement made to show contempt rather than mercy. He let the pause widen until the courtyard felt as if it were breathing for him alone. The nobles at the windows leaned in, their mouths small and hungry.

“Because my future wife insisted,” he said at last, his voice smooth and practiced, as if reading lines meant to be carved into stone. The words were courteous in tone and poisonous in meaning. He advanced a step, and the scrape of his boots over marble sounded like a verdict. “You mistake death for punishment. Death grants dignity. A corpse can be mourned. A martyr can be sung about. But you—” he closed the distance and let the tip of his blade rest against Thorne’s chest, the contact so light it might have been a caress, yet the pressure was intent enough to make Thorne inhale sharply. “—a man spared, beaten, and sent crawling back to his own, that man becomes suspicion given flesh.”

Garling’s smile was quiet and surgical. “They will not look upon you with sorrow. They will look upon you with questions. Who bargained? Who bent? Who broke first?” His voice sharpened until it was a blade in its own right. “Suspicion eats a man from the inside. It hollowed his friends long before the worm finds a bone. I could have given you a clean death. Instead, I will let you rot among those who once called you brother.”

Then he advanced, his stride measured, the weight of his presence more crushing than any swing of steel. With a single stroke, he knocked Thorne’s sword aside, the clash ringing through the courtyard like thunder. Before Thorne could recover, Garling turned his blade and drove it low, cutting across his thigh with surgical precision. The steel bit deep, not enough to kill, but enough to drop him to one knee in an instant.

Thorne gasped, his breath catching in his throat, blood blooming dark across the marble. He tried to rise, but the leg refused him, buckling again beneath his weight. The Celestial Dragons above shrieked with laughter, their jeweled hands clapping against the glass like eager children at a puppet show.

Garling loomed over him, his blade leveled just above Thorne’s throat. His tone was almost kind, though his words were crueler than the cut. “Your allies will look at you and wonder. They will whisper that you were spared because you begged. They will suspect you bartered her name for your life. And suspicion, Saint Thorne, is the sharpest poison of all. It will hollow you out more completely than my steel ever could.”

He drew the blade back, letting the light catch on its wet edge, and let the silence stretch until the only sound was the drip of blood pattering against stone. Then his voice cut through the noise like a verdict. “So live. Live, and rot among your revolution, useless and unwanted. That will be your mark of shame, and it will outlast any grave.”

Above them, the laughter of the Celestial Dragons rose again, small and bright and cruel. Thorne’s hands clenched until his knuckles whitened, his sword trembling from the strain. The courtyard closed in like a trap, and Garling stepped back as if dismissing a lesson concluded, lowering his sword in a gesture that was not mercy but dismissal. 

The pale line of ash seemed to close behind him as though sealing a tomb. Thorne remained on the ground, trembling, every breath weighted with humiliation and pain.

Above them, the nobles pressed tighter to the windows, their delight echoing through the courtyard like a hymn, giddy and cruel, their laughter carrying the seal of judgment more final than any execution.

-X-

Garling stood in the quiet of the Holy Knight’s Commander's chamber, regalia half-shed, blood flecked along the plates like jewels in firelight. The duel had left him untouched in spirit, and the faint sting of exertion only pleased him further. He drew his blade across the cloth his butler had set out, slow and deliberate, until the steel shone with the same pale gleam it had carried into the courtyard.

“Varian, see that the stain on the marble is left as it is,” Garling ordered without looking up. “I want every noble who passes through that yard to step over it. Let them remember what the cost of defiance looks like.”

“Yes, my lord,” Varian replied, hands folded neatly. “The surgeons are tending the prisoner. He will live, though he will not walk without a limp again.”

“Good,” Garling said softly, almost to himself. “Let him carry that limp home. A brand cut deeper than flesh.” He sheathed the sword with a sound like a closing door and finally turned to face his butler. “What word from the Elders?”

Varian inclined his head, his voice even. “As you command. And as for your petition—” He paused, weighing the phrasing carefully. “The Elders have granted your request. The wedding will be expedited, just as you desired. Save for one detail. They will not permit the single wife clause. They fear it would… limit your options.”

Garling stilled, the cloth tightening around his fist. Slowly, he laid the blade aside, his expression unreadable but for the faint spark in his eye. “Limit my options?” His tone was a low scoff. “What options are left when one has chosen?”

Varian bowed his head lower, hands folded precisely. “They see it as a safeguard. An heir may come or may not. To bind yourself to one woman in writing is… unprecedented.”

A thin smile ghosted across Garling’s lips, though it carried no humor.

“Very well. It is within their purview, though let the records state that was my desire. As long as the rest is in place, it doesn’t matter much.” He waved a hand, cutting the matter short. “We will speak further tonight. Have the household prepared.”

The words had scarcely left his tongue before the chamber doors slammed wide. Sommers Shepherd barged in, voice already raised, face red. “You should have let me kill him! All this theater, and for what? A duel is not sport unless it ends in blood.”

Garling remained seated, one hand resting on the carved arm of his chair, his expression carved into marble irritation. “What are you rattling about this time, Sommers?”

“You, as always,” the man said, tilting his glasses down, “You really piss me off, Figarland.”

The butler looked between the two knights, awaiting Garling’s orders. But Garling didn’t shoo Sommers away immediately.

“Take care who you’re talking to—I am commander here,” Garling said, staring him down. “Besides, Thorne’s blood was not the currency required. Alive, he poisons his allies more efficiently than dead. He limps back to them, carrying shame. That is more useful than a corpse.”

Sommers spat to the side, his lip curling. “Shame does not frighten men, Garling. Fear does. A corpse nailed to the gates of Mariejois speaks louder than shame whispered in barracks. A severed head makes no petitions. Blood settles questions cleanly. Do you know what you have given me instead? Endless rosters, endless scribbling, endless tedium. I should be gutting him like a prisoner, not scratching quills like some clerk.”

Garling’s gaze flicked up, sharp enough to cut. “If you long for blood, Shepherd, slit your own throat. You are tiresome to listen to.”

Sommers scoffed, voice rising into a sneer that made the tapestries seem to bristle. “You’re only doing this for that girl. Do you plan to kiss your bride while the blood of her enemies dries on your hands, or will you clean yourself like some pious priest first?”

Garling’s fingers twitched on the sword hilt, the motion small and dangerous. Patience thinned in his face like a film. “You mistake mercy for strategy, Shepherd,” he said, each word cold and exact. “And you mistake your tongue for a weapon. Continue flapping it, and I will cut it from your mouth and feed it to the hounds. Now be useful. Buy another girl if you must amuse yourself.”

Sommers bristled, shame and fury working the lines of his face. He lowered his eyes with the appearance of obedience, though his jaw worked as if he were still chewing at his outrage. “Fine, you ass. But do not think this is finished. I am not done complaining about that Kuja pirate.”

“Then win the tournament, if you can,” Garling replied, with the breezy cruelty of a man offering a puzzle he already knows you will fail. He lifted a hand in dismissal. Sommers spun on his heel and marched out, his boots clacking like angry metronomes on the marble.

Garling watched him go for a long, quiet moment, the faintest of smiles touching his mouth. He turned slowly to Varian, savoring the control in the small scene he had arranged. “See to the halls,” he said. “If I am to wed, there will be no errors. Set the carpets, order the servants, and schedule the physicians with little discretion. I want all to hear. And I want to make Fiero Thorne’s descent into the lower world a public lesson. Let every courier carry his limp like a rumor.”

Varian inclined his head and took the orders, already composing the list that would translate Garling’s cruelty into action.

Garling sheathed his sword with a soft click and straightened his attire, the room narrowing to the single pleasure of plans made and power exercised. The day’s performance had ended. The rewards would be coming and exact.

-X-

Sunlight found you before your thoughts did, pale and obliging as a servant that will not ask questions. Your lids fluttered open to the soft bustle of a room that had been rearranged while you slept. The linens smelled faintly of starch and camphor. A row of lesser maids stood like silent witnesses at the foot of the bed, hands folded, faces practiced into neutral masks. Behind them, a woman waited apart, shoulders squared too tightly, her posture an apology in motion.

You startle at their presence before taking a deep breath. It seems that Garling was ensuring that not a single waking moment of yours would be left unsupervised.

“Madam,” the woman said, voice low and careful. “I am Joanna. I will be your personal maid. These are my girls.” Her hand swept in the direction of the lesser maids, who inclined their heads without interest. Joanna’s uniform was sensible rather than fine, her sleeves plain, her hair drawn back with efficient severity. She offered no warmth. Each movement seemed measured, as if to distance herself, like a soldier keeping to the edge of a camp.

You studied her while the lesser maids fussed with your collar and smoothed the gown at your shoulders. Joanna’s fingers were competent but distracted. She kept her eyes a fraction too long on the door, on the hall beyond, as if counting the moments until she could leave. It was clear she had not asked for this posting. She did not want to be the woman who tended your hair and curtsied in your name. That fact, more than any whispered allegiance, told you where the small seams in this house might be.

Joanna came close then, lowering her voice until it was a private thing between you. “Sir Garling has finished his duel,” she said, the words forced into calm. “He requests to see you at luncheon. He will arrive within the hour.” Her fingers smoothed a stray curl with careless brusqueness that almost passed for tenderness. “He asked me to ensure you are presentable.”

Your heart gave a sharp jolt. Finished. The word rang with finality. You had slept through it, unconscious while the courtyard filled with steel and blood. Of course, Garling had won. The very fact that Joanna stood here, stiff as a post, meant the outcome was decided before the first strike. But what had become of Thorne? The thought gnawed at you even as you kept your face composed. Had he fallen? You wanted to ask, but the maids’ cold eyes reminded you that words would cost you all. Better to hold the hunger behind your teeth.

You let them dress you prettily. You let the pearls be fastened and the brooch rest at your throat. Each clasp and fastening felt like a lock being shut, each brushstroke a small burial of the girl who had hoped to see the fight with her own eyes. Alarm pricked through your calm, but you smothered it. Inside, you were already rearranging plans. Flashy appeals would get you watched and pinned. You needed quietness, patient favors, a string of small debts woven into loyalty.

Joanna’s stiff shoulders suggested resentment rather than devotion. Resentment could be coaxed into necessity. Necessity could be turned into an ally. You catalogued the maids’ faces in a breath, memorizing who avoided your gaze and which one lingered with curiosity disguised as duty. Somewhere among them, a whisper of discontent would surface. You only had to find the one who would break the silence.

You would go to luncheon. You would bow. You would let him measure you. Then you would begin the quieter work of knitting loyalty from the shadows. Joanna’s reluctance was a door. You would not burst through it. You would slip inside, unremarked, and close it softly behind you.

And so you let her guide you, obedient and docile. 

The great doors to the dining hall opened on cue, and you were led inside. The table stretched long and gleaming, though only the head and a single place at his right were set. Silver domes covered platters that breathed faint wisps of steam. The smell of roasted meat hung in the air, rich and heavy, like incense meant to smother the senses.

Garling sat already, lounging at the head of the table, composed as though he had not spent the morning with steel in his hand. His colorful regalia was gone, replaced with dark robes that lent him the air of a magistrate rather than a knight. He lifted his gaze as you approached, studying you without expression, and gestured to the chair beside him.

“Sit,” he said simply.

You obeyed, the scrape of the chair against the marble sharp in the hush. The lesser maids filled your cup with wine and set a dish before you, though none dared linger. Joanna alone remained at a respectful distance, stiff as ever.

For a moment, the silence held, punctuated only by the muted clatter of cutlery as Garling carved into his meal. Then, as though answering a question you had not dared ask aloud, he spoke.

“Thorne lives.” His tone was calm, not cruel, yet the words landed heavy. “I left him enough to crawl back to his rabble, though he will never stand straight again.”

He picked up his fork, turning it idly between his fingers before letting his eyes shift toward the help. With only a single glance, Joanna dipped into a stiff curtsey and withdrew to the far side of the room. The man who had been standing in silent attendance at Garling’s back also bowed out, his boots clicking against the marble as he departed. The chamber doors closed with a heavy finality that left you alone with him, the air suddenly much too large and much too quiet.

His gaze returned to you, steady and unwavering. He leaned back slightly in his chair, the fork still poised between his fingers, as though the weight of the moment were no more to him than deciding how best to cut his meal.

“Well?” he said, one brow rising. “Show me your gratitude, won’t you?”

The words were not jests, nor overt taunts. They were a command dressed as a courtesy, expectation sharpened into ritual. The pause that followed was long enough to press against your ribs, long enough to remind you that in this house, gratitude was not optional, and silence was an insult.

Your fingers tightened in your lap beneath the tablecloth, nails pressing crescents into your palms. At last, you found your voice. “What gratitude does this require?” The words left your lips quietly, but they carried enough weight to echo faintly in the cavernous hall.

Garling’s eyes narrowed—not in anger, but in focus. He set the fork down with deliberate care, the metal clicking softly against the plate. Then he lifted his hand, the motion slow and precise, curling two fingers in a beckoning gesture.

“Come here,” he said.

The command was not barked, nor cloaked in gentleness. It was a simple order, inevitable as gravity. He did not explain further. He did not need to. His gaze held yours until the space between you seemed to pull taut, until movement itself felt less like choice and more like surrender to a current you could not escape.

You hesitated, but the weight of his gaze allowed no retreat. When you rose and stepped toward him, Garling reached without ceremony, catching your wrist and drawing you down. In a single practiced motion, he pulled you onto his lap, as though you belonged there, his arm settling around your waist with proprietary ease.

He studied your face closely, the corner of his mouth curving not quite into a smile. “Not pleased with my gift?” he asked, his tone almost petulant, as if sparing Thorne’s life should have earned him your delight. “My servants are very perplexed, you know. They see me bleed an enemy only to let him crawl away, and then they see you sit here sulking. It makes them wonder what it is I value.”

Your breath caught, the scent of spiced wine clinging faintly to him, heavy and intimate. You steadied your voice, though the words came sharper than intended. “Are all your dubious gifts merely a way to pull affection from me? Is that what this is—only injuring men so that I will be forced to thank you?”

Garling’s expression softened into something crueler than mockery: amusement. “That is a benefit,” he admitted without hesitation, hand brushing lightly against your side as though to prove the point. “But not the only one. I enjoy watching the conflict in you, the way you resist and yield in the same breath. You should hate me, and yet here you sit, forced to indulge me.” His eyes gleamed, dark with satisfaction. “There is nothing sweeter than being doted on by someone who despises and desires my touch.”

You sat stiffly against him, your body refusing the pretense of ease. Every line of you was in tension, though you forced your face into the cool indifference you had practiced in mirrors.

“If this is your idea of gratitude,” you said, tone carefully even, “then you’ll find your time wasted expecting it from me.”

“Oh?” Garling’s mouth curved faintly, his gaze probing. “Then tell me something else,” he murmured, the words brushing close as if confided. “Are you untouched?”

Your heart gave a sharp beat, but you kept your eyes steady. “It’s rather early to ask that. Or too late into this game, if you desire chastity.”

His brows lifted, as though your retort entertained him. Then, without warning, his hands moved—slipping beneath the fine fall of your skirts, calloused fingers tugging at the silk of your stockings. You jolted, breath catching in your throat.

“There it is,” Garling said, satisfaction threading his voice. “The same reaction as last night. You play the part of indifference, but you betray yourself in the smallest ways.” His index finger pressed deliberately against the stocking’s edge before withdrawing, leaving your skin prickling.

“You act surprisingly pure for a woman meant to be undercover,” he went on, his voice low, almost contemplative. “That dichotomy fascinates me. They should’ve sent someone more experienced. But perhaps that is why I enjoy this—your veneer of steel, your polished restraint bleeding into your white soul. It makes every crack in the mask worth prying open.”

He leaned back, studying you as if you were both captive and experiment, his other hand resettling at your waist with proprietary ease.

His hand slid higher, deliberate and unhurried, the weight of it heavy beneath the silk. You drew in a sharp, steadying breath, forcing your expression into calm while your body betrayed you in its stillness. Your hand flew to his, stopping its ascending path through silks.

“This is unkempt.” You said, sweat building at your brow. “Uncivil and badly timed. It’s rude to touch such places, unwed, near food and people—”

Garling chuckled low in his chest, the sound carrying more satisfaction than amusement. His hand did pause a moment before brushing yours aside.

“This is my house. My servants, my time, and you are my woman. It matters not what I do, or when and how I do it.” He purred, tilting you back, forcing your hands to brace themselves rather than stave him off, lest you fall.

“Then gain some manners.” You ground out, neck straining, “Impatient bully.”

He hummed, eyes narrowing, his blonde lashes fluttering prettily.

“I will admit,” he said, voice dropping to something quieter, “I am finding this difficult. The vows are close, but not close enough. Having you in my house, beneath my roof, at my table—it presses against my patience.”

He ghosted his face closer, nose brushing your chin.

“Every day you walk these halls, you tempt the limits I have set myself. ”

His fingers grazed higher still, a promise rather than a touch, and his eyes searched your face with cold curiosity. “And after being forced to participate in a match I cannot kill, over my own woman? It’s enough to make the blood boil. You should be grateful I am a man of standards.”

 You exhaled slowly, schooling your features and allowing yourself the smallest of snide retorts. “Then perhaps you should visit a brothel and relieve your limits there.”

You hadn’t meant it as a joke. Not really. 

When you glanced up, Garling was staring at you. Not with his usual hawk-like scrutiny, but frozen, utterly still, as though his world had just cracked down the middle. Then it came: low, deep, sudden—a laugh.

Not a polite chuckle. Not the sardonic scoff you’d expect from him.

A real laugh. Rich and unguarded.

It startled you so much that you almost fell. He caught your wrist before you could, his grip firm but not cruel. His eyes shone with a sharp, nearly feverish intensity.

“You,” he said softly, reverently, “made me laugh.”

The words landed heavy, like a confession. His thumb brushed over your pulse, slow and deliberate, and for once, you didn’t see the commander or the zealot. You saw the man electrified by the shock of his own humanity.

Then, before you could process the shift, he leaned in.

The kiss was not tentative. Not cautious. It was sudden, claiming, as though your words had undone every restraint he’d wrapped around himself. His mouth was hot and demanding, his hand sliding to the back of your neck to hold you still as if terrified you’d vanish before he finished tasting you.

When he pulled back, just enough for breath, he didn’t look smug. He looked… thrilled. Like he had uncovered a secret no one else on earth would ever be allowed to touch.

“Say something else,” he murmured, breath warm against your lips. “Something only I would find funny. Make me laugh again. Call me a feathered peacock, or something just as ridiculous—”

The fear and tension were strung so high that his laughter broke like glass, sharp and startling. It jolted you into your own, sudden and unrestrained, bursting out before you could stop it.

Garling’s eyes widened, then darkened. Delight twisted instantly into hunger, and the air between you crackled. Before you could collect yourself, his hand closed around your arm—firm, insistent, not cruel.

He didn’t allow you a heartbeat to question, to think. With one sweep of his arm, the table was bare, and you were whisked atop.

Then his hands were on you. Swift, purposeful. He caught the edge of your dress and tugged it down from your shoulders, silk sliding against skin. His mouth followed immediately, pressing hot, open-mouthed kisses across the slope of your chest.

The sound of your laugh still echoed in his ears; you could feel it in the fervor of his movements, the way he growled against your skin like a man half undone.

“You don’t understand,” he said between kisses, voice roughened with thrill. “That sound… I need it. I need you.”

Every kiss landed lower, more urgent, his grip tightening at your waist as though to anchor himself. You could feel the sharp edge of his desire in the way he pressed closer, breathing you in as if your laughter had set him aflame. Somehow, a butter knife found its way into his hands, slicing through whatever was left there, and once he was done, he stabbed it into the table.

And you realized with a dizzying clarity: to Garling, this wasn’t just a victory, it was an aphrodisiac. And your own mind found it impossible to keep up with the novel sensations and heat he was bestowing upon your flesh. It should’ve been embarrassing, revolting, but with each inch you found yourself arching, keening under him. 

The silk of your dress slid lower under his hands, until the bodice pooled uselessly at your waist. His mouth descended, hot and relentless, pressing reverent, consuming kisses across the bare curve of your chest. Each touch was half-worship, half-claim, as though he couldn’t decide whether to praise you or devour you whole.

You braced against the table behind you, breath hitching with every insistent drag of his lips. He murmured against your skin, not cruel quips, not biting commands, but words that sounded dangerously like awe.

“Perfect… mine… laugh for me again…”

You knew you shouldn’t like this. Not him, not the way his control slipped into raw hunger, not the way your body arched toward every desperate kiss he trailed over you. But the heat pooled low in your stomach all the same, undeniable and damning.

Garling pressed closer, almost frantic, his hands sliding up to frame you, thumbs brushing the underside of your breasts with trembling reverence. His mouth moved higher, lips closing around the tender swell as though he meant to brand the moment into memory. The sound that escaped him was half-groan, half-prayer.

Your pulse thundered. You should have pushed him away. You should have refused. Instead, your fingers threaded into his hair, holding him there, and his answering growl vibrated against your skin.

Blond hair fell unlodged from his head, tugged and pulled, and softer than you had imagined.

Time unraveled under his mouth.

What began as frantic kisses turned into a slow, obsessive claiming. He lingered over every inch of your chest as though it were sacred, his lips marking and worshiping with a fervor you had never expected from him. Minutes bled away in gasps and shivers, his mouth tracing the same paths over and over, each press of his lips deeper, each scrape of his teeth hungrier.

Your skin burned with the heat of it, flushed and sensitive, his breath fanning across dampened trails of devotion. You clutched the table behind you, torn between pushing him away and dragging him closer.

Garling’s voice rasped against your skin, incoherent fragments slipping through his composure.

“Mine… never anyone else… laugh only for me…”

And then, a sharp shudder tore through him. His whole body went taut against you, a strangled sound breaking from his throat. He froze, his grip bruising on your waist as the realization struck.

He had lost control.

The weight of it hung between you in the dark chamber, his harsh breathing, your pounding heart, the scent of raw need filling the air. He pulled back a fraction, his lips still brushing your marked skin, and for once the ever-composed Garling Figarland looked… undone.

For a long moment, the only sound was his breathing: ragged, uneven, teeth clenched as though he could physically grind back what had just happened. He didn’t move away from you, though. His forehead pressed to your sternum, lips still hovering near the places he’d marked, as if unwilling to surrender the ground he’d claimed.

Then a low sound escaped him, not quite a laugh, not quite a growl. Something caught between amusement and irritation.

“Ten minutes,” he muttered against your skin, voice roughened with disbelief. “That’s all it took. Ten damned minutes, and I—” His hand flexed at your hip, betraying the lingering curl of desire still burning through him. “Pathetic.”

But his eyes, when he finally looked up at you, told a different story. They gleamed with contentment, a dangerous satisfaction that outweighed his self-reproach. He looked at you as if he’d fed on something more intoxicating than wine, and he wasn’t ashamed to savor it. His pupil expanded, turning black at the sight of your breasts, and he actually looked away as if he were a shark.

You swallowed, heat still thrumming in your veins. “It wasn’t… exactly nothing,” you whispered, trying to cling to composure.

That earned you a sharp smile. Irritation smoothed into pleasure. The predator in him was curling around the fact that it had been you who unraveled him. His thumb dragged lazily over one of the reddened marks he’d left, pride flickering through his touch.

“So little, so quickly,” he repeated, but this time there was no bite in it. Only wonder, and a simmering promise. “You should be terrified of how much more I intend to take from you.”

And then he kissed the words into your chest, claiming the irritation, the contentment, the hunger, all of it, as if the contradiction itself thrilled him.

His lips lingered against your chest, breathing you in like a man drowning and unwilling to surface. When he finally drew back, there was no shame in his gaze. Only a dangerous gleam, a predator tasting victory even in defeat.

“You know what I should do,” he said softly, voice curling around you like smoke. His hand slid up your side, deliberate, until his thumb brushed the edge of another mark he’d left. “If you were anything less than what you are to me, if you were not the love of my life, the only thing I will ever bend to, I’d take you right here.”

His mouth dipped closer, grazing your ear, words hot and merciless. “I’d bend you over this table. I’d ruin you in ways no silk could hide. I’d make certain every servant who walked these halls smelled you on me.”

The crude intensity of it made your knees weaken, shame, and want colliding in your chest. His hand tightened at your waist, steadying you, savoring how the threat rattled through you.

“But I won’t,” he murmured then, pulling back just enough for you to see the iron in his restraint. “Because I want everything. Not scraps stolen in a dark room.” His eyes locked on yours, a vow burning in them. “On our wedding night, I will lay you down and strip you slowly. I will taste every inch of you until you beg me to take what I already own. And then, when you are shaking and marked as mine beyond denial, I will give you what I denied myself here.”

He pressed a kiss to your temple, almost reverent. “You don’t know what mercy that is. And you don’t want to test what I would be without it.”

His hand wandered higher still until his fingers brushed against the thin fabric of your undergarments. The contact was fleeting, almost casual, but it struck through you like a blade. Your breath caught, and panic flickered in your chest, sharp and unbidden. The rigid control you had forced upon yourself slipped—your shoulders stiffened, your heart stuttered, and the cool mask you wore cracked in that instant.

Garling felt it. His chuckle came low, dark with satisfaction, but after a pause, he withdrew his hand, leaving your skin prickling in the sudden absence. He rested his palm once more against your waist, holding you with the casual ease of ownership, as though nothing untoward had occurred at all.

“Enough,” he said, his voice smooth, almost businesslike. “Our wedding will be held in one week.”

He lifted you from the table as easily as if you weighed nothing, setting you on your feet. You stumbled back a step, the sudden freedom making you all too aware of the distance you sought. Your arms crossed over your chest, shame finally returning to you at the state you had been left in.

You watched, dazed, as he went to the cords on his shoulder, loosening the tassels holding his red cape. With one motion, he removed the fabric, draping it around your shoulders to cover your disheveled state of dress. Everyone would still know, but at least your modesty was spared. 

“That is extremely unusual,” you managed, your tone airy and unsteady. “Out of tradition.”

Garling went to a far chair, sitting next to one of the few untouched dishes left. He carved a piece of meat from his plate, unbothered by the mussed state of his own being. “So is marrying a revolutionary,” he replied, the faintest curl of amusement touching his mouth. “But here I am.” He placed the bite into his mouth and chewed slowly, as though the conversation were already finished.

With a snap of his fingers, he summoned the staff back in. Joanna and the lesser maids returned, moving briskly to clear the dishes, their faces carved in the same cool masks as before. The room no longer felt private, but the weight of what had transpired lingered, a presence no servant dared acknowledge.

Garling dabbed his mouth with a napkin, then turned his gaze to you once more. “Return to your room. We will not see one another again until we are to be wed. I find I am too tempted to test my restraint otherwise.”

I believe the Gorosei possess the ability to silence knowledge of events that “never existed” and, I think they do this with Demonic Sigils.

It’s far too impractical and resource intensive for the Gorosei to kill off all rookie marines that take part in clandestine operations.

What is far more likely happening is that following these events they make low rank marines forget both what they saw, and what they did with a Sigil.

Following God Valley Garp found himself disillusioned with the marines and was forced by either, the Gods Knights, Gorsei, or Imu into a position that both solidified his place in the marines and, prevented him from acting against them.

There are two ways this would have happened and in both Garp is coerced.

1. Dragon is caught trying to save Shanks and Shamrock’s mom and is subsequently sentenced to death. Garp arrives at God Valley just in time to submit himself as a pawn of the Gorosei in exchange for Dragons life.

The Gorosei realizing how much of an influence Garp has, accept this proposal which compels his obedience to them and Seal Dragons ability to speak about God Valley.

They could also place a sigil that relays everything he sees and hears to Mariejois.

I think this would explain the tattoo on Dragon’s face, Him telling Kuma that if he continued speaking he would die, and the Reason he looks east, it would also explain his inaction toward Ginny’s kidnapping. Dragons main plan to subvert this would be to put the World Government in a situation where they can’t act on this information

The caveat to this being that Dragon would have had to somehow hide Luffy’s birth, the plans of the revolutionary army and, his current knowledge of Imu’s existence.

Because most of this would make it both exceedingly unlikely that he could outmaneuver the Gorosei and would raise far more questions then it answers they probably just used a sigil of silence.

However I don’t think this altogether rules out a Sigil which monitors its host and it most likely exists just not on Dragon.

However there is still another, and far more likely Scenario.

2. Dragon escapes God Valley. Successfully evading the World Government, he instantaneously becomes both the Worlds Most Dangerous Man and the biggest threat to Imu’s authority. He subsequently has the world’s largest bounty placed on his head and goes on to found the revolutionary army beside Ivankov in order to dismantle the current government and stop the atrocities he witnessed at God Valley from continuing to happen.

Now the World Government may be able to successfully censor the marines but that still doesn’t mean they can control them. And Garp as someone who is far too strong to be tied down will now be thinking of leaving the marines in order to protect his son.

It is because of this potential threat that the World Government feels the need to lock Garp down and they now employ a strategy they frequent, Blackmail.

Garp is now put in a precarious position where he has to protect his wife or someone else important to him, who is now being held hostage by CP0 with the threat that should he step out of line they will die

Garp is now a slave the Gorosei. His desires are no longer of concern and no matter what, Imu has the final say.

With this position comes independence from the marines. He is able to found sword, rescue Koby, and shit talk Celestial Dragons because at the end of the day he isnt impeding Imu’s plans and, he is far beyond the purview of marine oversight.

In both scenarios marines who advance passed a certain rank are required to take a “Vow of Silence” in which they are unknowingly marked with the Sigil of Silence.

I think this essentially creates 2 types of Marines, those who’ve seen the truth and those who are ignorant.

This then leads into another theory I have about Aokiji and Akainu being representative of Knowledge and Ignorance respectively. However i’ll save that for later since this is already becoming quite a lengthy post

So, What exactly am I getting at?

I believe both Dragons action and Garps Inaction are representative of the divide among those who’ve seen The Truth, I think both are bound somewhat by blackmail and, the ongoing raid at Mariejois, Garp’s capture at Hachinousu, Morgan’s impending knowledge of Imu and, the Strawhats ongoing fight with Gunko are all indicative of the future of the story.

We are coming up on the Climax of One Piece folks and it all leads back to one place.