Thereās always so much speculation among Ghosts fans about what the Captainās name might be.
And it occurs to me that we will probably never find out his name at all. There just might never be a canon answer to this one.Ā
Sitcoms are full of permanently teased and withheld information, and if that running gag goes on long enough, any reveal would be disappointing. The glorious not-knowing is the joy, because the answer could be anything.Ā
Like, think about all those hinted-at stories that sitcoms never explore. What on earth happened on that fateful fishing trip with Uncle Bryn in Gavin & Stacey? Just what is the āspecial stuffā that causes all those nosebleeds in League of Gentlemen? Why was the money resting in Father Tedās account?Ā
Or how about the trope of the invisible character ā named but unseen. We never actually get to meet Maris in Frasier. Or the formidable Mrs Mainwaring in Dadās Army.Ā Or Beverley Macker in The Royle FamilyĀ ā yet just the mention of her name will cause conflict between Dave and Denise. Marshaās hellcat daughter Amber in Spaced only streaks across the screen ever so briefly. (āStop walking in front of the telly, your tights are strobingā is still one of my favourite line deliveries in anything.) The ridiculous mythology just builds and builds over time, until no human actor could do this impossible character justice. They canāt be revealed. Thatās the joke.
Iām not talking aboutĀ āstuff we donāt knowā. (I have so many questions about Fleabagās backstory!) I mean missing information thatās regularly dangled in front of the audience asĀ āstuff we are deliberately not telling you.ā Itās all about the tease. Itās kind of like a MacGuffin, in that the question is fascinating but the answer is not really the point. Why would any competent comedy writer chuck away a rewarding recurring gag? Especially if that gag is a lovely part of the showās world?
So for that reason, I bet he will always be just the Captain, at least until the very end. I know thereās a lot of theories about him hiding behind his military identity and how shedding that is part of his character growth, etc. The emotional and dramatic DNA of this show is so genuine, so heartfelt, that itās easy to forget that ā and I mean this with all the love in the world, Cap ā itās a sitcom. But the IdiotsĀ know what theyāre doing and I reckon theyāre going to string out this joke as long as possible. If that means we get to hypothesise about his name ad infinitum ā what a gift.
By the way, if you like nerding out about the nuts and bolts of comedy writing, the Rule of Three podcast is outstanding and has lengthy interviews with lots of your Britcom faves.