Ok, I'm hoping a more educated Starkid fan can help me out with this.
If you look back at some of my recent reblogs, you can tell, I've been getting into Starkid a lot recently, specifically the Hatchetfield trilogy. To clarify, I haven't seen NPMD or Nightmare Time yet, but I do plan on watching them.
Recently, I watched TGWDLM and Black Friday for the first time. I absolutely loved TGWDLM, but I had pretty mixed feelings about Black Friday, which confused me. Because while I've only seen two Starkid shows before Black Friday (Holy Musical B@man and TGWDLM), I loved both shows so much, and Black Friday was, objectively speaking, just as good as those two shows. It's an amazing critique of consumerism and capitalism and had emotional story beats that hit me very hard. I honestly cried more watching Black Friday than I did TGWDLM. I kept having this cognitive dissonance with the show, trying to come up with a reason for why I didn't like it as much as TGWDLM, and like feeling both it should've been its own unrelated story, not set in the same Multiverse, but also that it wouldn't work as well being a self contained story. And I didn't wanna make a post about how I was feeling about it until now, because I finally realized what it was:
Which feels like a weird critique to have about a musical with amazing music and amazing performers, but it's because it's set in the same Multiverse as TGWDLM. In The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals, being a musical is a fundamental core part of the story; there is an in-world reason for why it is a musical. Whereas in Black Friday, it's a musical because that's the genre of show it is. I don't think there's anything wrong with it on its own, but because they are established to be in the same Multiverse it feels contradictory and less thought out. Yes, I understand that I am currently missing information that can be provided in NPMD and Nightmare Time, but it still feels weird to me to establish a universe that is canonically not a musical and then have the other shows set in the same universe be a musical for the sake of being a musical. I also get that there is some weird timeline and parallel universe shenanigans going on in Black Friday and the Hatfield universe, but it still just feels weird to establish the universe as not musical and then just make everything a musical, y'know?
I'm hoping to get the thoughts of some more educated Starkid fans because I want to legitimately love Black Friday as much as I love the other two Starkid shows I've seen because Starkid is so fun and the songs are so good. Even in Black Friday, I love a lot of the songs. And I want to be able to enjoy it as much as I did with the other shows but I just feel like I'm missing something. I also feel like there has to be an answer to this because I haven't seen anyone else have this criticism so I feel a little bit like I'm going insane lol, but if you read all this, have a good day.