#kagerookuta

How Giran Became a Criminal: A Speculative Path

Giran's journey into the criminal underworld appears to be less about a dramatic fall from grace and more about a calculated, opportunistic ascent within the black market. Several key details point to this:

Mentorship and Early Start: The document states, "All that is known about his past is that someone he affectionately refers to as 'the old man' took him under his wing when he was an upstart." This suggests Giran wasn't born into a life of crime but was introduced to it and mentored early on. The "old man" likely taught him the intricacies of the black market, how to forge connections, source illicit goods, and, crucially, how to evade authorities. This early guidance would have been foundational to his long-standing success as an "underground broker."

Quirk and Aptitude: Giran's Quirk, "Muddied," is not a combat-oriented ability; it affects memories, making them fuzzy. This type of Quirk is far more suited to intelligence gathering, information control, or facilitating discreet dealings rather than direct confrontation. Coupled with his "Awesomeness by Analysis" and a perfect 5/5 in "Wits," Giran was naturally predisposed to a role that leveraged his intellect and connections rather than brute force. His past as a "B-rank villain" suggests he engaged in criminal activities that were significant but likely not frontline combat.

Motivation: Greed and Professionalism: Giran is explicitly described as being driven by "Greed" and being "Only in It for the Money." However, this is balanced by an almost paradoxical "Consummate Professional" ethic and "Honor Among Thieves." He views his illicit dealings as a legitimate business, adhering to strict rules of loyalty to his clients and refusing to betray them, even under torture. This unique blend of avarice and integrity would have made him a highly sought-after and trusted figure in the underworld, allowing him to build a vast network over "several decades." He likely saw the black market as a place where his skills and principles could thrive, unburdened by the legal and ethical constraints of legitimate society. He rejoiced at increased workload, indicating a workaholic nature that found satisfaction in his criminal enterprise.

In essence, Giran likely became a criminal through a combination of early mentorship, a Quirk and intellect perfectly suited for illicit brokerage, and a strong personal code that, while morally ambiguous, fostered trust and longevity in the dangerous world he inhabited.

Giran's Fate: An Uncertain Doom

The document provides a clear, yet tantalizingly ambiguous, statement regarding Giran's fate after the Paranormal Liberation War:

"In the aftermath of the Paranormal Liberation War, Giran is not shown among the 16,229 soldiers from the PLF who were arrested by the Heroes and law enforcement, including those who were defeated and captured at the Gunga Villa. Whether he was arrested or managed to escape the villa is unknown."

This explicitly leaves his fate as "Uncertain Doom," but we can speculate on the most probable outcomes based on his character and past actions:

Escape (Most Probable):

"The Ace" at Evading Authorities: Giran has "managed to evade authorities for several decades," a testament to his skill in operating under the radar.

Crazy-Prepared: He previously demonstrated this by attempting to wipe his client data before capture (though it was restored by Skeptic). This indicates a mindset geared towards self-preservation and escape.

Non-Action Guy: Giran is not a fighter and would prioritize slipping away over engaging in combat. During the Meta Liberation Army arc, he was escorted to safety by Twice's clones, showing he relies on others or his own cunning to avoid direct conflict.

Chaos of War: The Paranormal Liberation War was a massive, chaotic event. The sheer scale of the conflict and the number of combatants would have provided ample opportunity for someone as adept at subterfuge as Giran to disappear amidst the confusion, especially given he was in a bunker during the raid.

Arrest (Less Probable, but Possible):

While not explicitly shown among the arrested, it's conceivable he was apprehended but simply not highlighted among the general "soldiers." His role as a broker might mean he's a less prominent public figure than the direct combatants.

However, given his history of evasion and the explicit "unknown" status, a quiet, unmentioned arrest seems less fitting for his character.

Death (Unlikely, but Cannot be Ruled Out):

The text specifically states "unknown if he escaped or was apprehended," which typically implies he was not confirmed deceased. If he had died, it's more likely the narrative would have confirmed it, especially given his significant role in the MLA arc and his bond with Twice.

Long Analysis: Kagero Okuta (Giran) — The Shadowy Broker Who Built the League, Endured Hell, and Vanished into Vagueness

Kagero Okuta, better known by his villain alias Giran, is one of My Hero Academia's most intriguing "faceless" antagonists — a non-combatant C-rank villain whose true power lies not in Quirks or fists, but in connections, cunning, and unbreakable loyalty. He's the guy who turns dreams of chaos into reality with a cigarette, a smirk, and a black-market Rolodex. Giran isn't a frontline monster like Tomura or Dabi; he's the enabler, the oil in the League of Villains' machine. His story arc is a masterclass in Horikoshi's world-building: starting as a quirky supplier in the spin-off Vigilantes, evolving into the League's backbone during the main series, surviving torture that would break lesser men, and then... poof. Fading into narrative limbo after the Paranormal Liberation War. His ending is deliberately vague — imprisoned, but with no epilogue confirmation — leaving fans to speculate if he's rotting in Tartarus, rebuilding his empire underground, or perhaps even flipping sides in the post-war chaos.

This analysis dives deep into Giran's character, his pivotal role in escalating the League from ragtag terrorists to a national apocalypse, his unyielding code of ethics (in a series full of moral voids), and the frustrating ambiguity of his fate. Spoilers ahead for the full manga (up to Chapter 430 and epilogues).

1. Appearance & Design: The Eccentric Everyman of the Underworld

Visual Breakdown: Giran is a middle-aged (late 30s–early 40s) everyman with a sleazy charm — short gray hair parted to the right, squinted pink eyes (gray in anime for a more muted tone), a small mustache-goatee combo, and a missing front tooth that gives his grin a roguish gap. He's 5'7" with a slight build, dressed like a mid-level salaryman gone rogue: unbuttoned shirt, blazer, pants, black shoes, and a fluffy "intestine"-shaped scarf (a Horikoshi troll, evoking his black-market dealings). His golden tube-necklace and circular glasses scream "shady importer," while the bunny-eared phone case hints at his whimsical side.

Post-Torture Changes: After the Meta Liberation Army (MLA) arc, he loses all fingers on his right hand (chopped off one by one as "messages" to the League). This isn't just cosmetic — it symbolizes his sacrifice, turning a smooth operator into a scarred survivor. No prosthetic shown, implying permanent disability.

Thematic Design: Giran looks like a chain-smoking uncle who'd sell you bootleg merch at a flea market, but his design contrasts his role: unassuming exterior hiding a web of influence. The pink eyes (symbolizing "hidden depths") and cigarette (constant smoke = obfuscation) tie into his Quirk and profession. Horikoshi uses him for comic relief (lighting cigs with a gun flame) while underscoring his menace — he's the guy who arms psychos like Toga.

2. Personality: Smug Professionalism with a Code of Honor

Core Traits: Giran is the ultimate pragmatist — indifferent, profit-driven, and smugly self-confident. He scouts villains like Twice, Dabi, and Toga not out of ideology, but because "outcasts like you are more common than you think" (Ch. 57). His constant smirk screams "I've seen it all," and he delights in black-market booms (post-All Might retirement: "Requests for suits doubled!"). Eccentric tastes shine through: bunny phone case, intestine scarf, casual gunplay.

Standards & Loyalty: Unlike most villains, Giran has a rigid code: "I only make deals with people I respect. Not guys who kick the crap outta me first" (Ch. 239). Tortured by the MLA (beaten, fingers severed), he destroys his client list and refuses to snitch, mocking Re-Destro: "What kinda merchant sells out his customers?!" This isn't bravado — it's principle. He offers genuine advice (to Twice: "Find comrades who need your talents") and shows kindness to broken clients like Jin Bubaigawara, seeing potential where society sees freaks.

Affable Darkness: He's affable with allies (ribbing Tomura's immaturity: "Too young and immature," Ch. 57) but disdainful of "big business" like Detnerat encroaching on his racket. Keen intellect shines: He warns Knuckleduster about chemical fumes (Vigilantes Ch. 26) and spots Twice's identity crisis mid-call (Ch. 148). In a series of emotional wrecks, Giran's cool detachment makes him oddly relatable — a villain who'd buy you a drink after selling you a bomb.

Flaws: His neutrality backfires; he avoids PLF politics ("not wanting anything to do with the goings-on," Ch. 271), isolating him during the raid. Eccentricity borders on recklessness (e.g., taunting torturers), but it underscores his "face-to-face business" ethos.

3. Abilities & Quirk: The Memory Merchant's Toolkit

Overall Abilities: Giran is no fighter (Power/Speed: E-rank), but his real strength is intellect (Wits: A) and professionalism (A). He's a black-market savant: Scouts talent (recruiting Toga/Dabi), supplies gear (Compress' robotic arm, Ch. 148; Toga's upgraded blood-sucker, Final War), and navigates underworld trends (post-Kamino boom). Scientific savvy: Knows drug interactions, taser limits, and pheromone mixes (Vigilantes).

Quirk: Muddied (Kondaku): Touch a target's head to induce minor amnesia — blurring memories of the previous/next 5 minutes. Perfect for a broker: Erase traces of deals, escape witnesses, or cover tracks. Stats: Technique C, but high utility in espionage. Never used offensively in canon (he's non-violent), but implies he could "muddy" interrogators mid-torture.

Stats (Ultra Analysis): Power 1/6 E, Speed 1/6 E, Technique 3/6 C, Wits 5/6 A, Professionalism 5/6 A. He's a support villain — the guy who arms the apocalypse, not starts it.

Weaknesses: Physical frailty (tortured easily) and moral code (refuses "dirty" deals) limit him. Post-fingers, he's even more vulnerable.

4. Synopsis & Role in the Story: From Vigilantes Supplier to PLF Pawn

Vigilantes Era (Pre-Main Series): Giran debuts as Knuckleduster's shady supplier — painkillers, tasers, pheromones (Ch. 26). Warns about overdoses, spots fakes (no taser-AED combo). Recruits broken Jin (Twice) post-trauma: "Outcasts like you? More common than you think. Join a group that needs your talents" (Ch. 115). Sets up his "kind broker" archetype.

Vs. Hero Killer Arc (Ch. 57): Brokers Stain's influence post-arrest, predicting villain influx. Introduces Toga/Dabi to Tomura — "Hear 'em out, kid" — kickstarting the League's expansion. Amused by Tomura's immaturity, but loyal: "I'm just in it for the money... but yeah, they'll fit."

Final Exams/Provisional License (Ch. 115–148): Booms post-All Might retirement ("Suit requests doubled!"). Calls Twice (spots crisis mid-contradiction), supplies Compress' arm after Overhaul fight. Subtly builds League's infrastructure.

Shie Hassaikai/Meta Liberation Army Arcs (Ch. 148–271): Captured by MLA tracking his supplies. Tortured (fingers chopped, beaten), but destroys client list and defies Re-Destro: "No deals with guys who kick me first." Mocks their ideology ("Lack of imagination"). Twice's clones rescue him during Deika chaos (Ch. 239–240), cushioning tower collapse. Witnesses League-MLA merger into PLF (Ch. 240), but distances himself: "Not my circus."

Paranormal Liberation War (Ch. 271): In Gunga bunker with PLF (despite claiming neutrality). Twice mentions him as a "friend" who wants no part in ops. Raid hits; exits blocked, all arrested (16,229 total). Giran vanishes here — no escape shown.

Post-War Vagueness: No mentions in Dark Hero, Final War, or epilogues (Ch. 421–430). Unlike Compress (jailed, quirkless) or Re-Destro (reforming), Giran's fate is unaddressed. Implied imprisoned (with PLF masses), but no Tartarus confirmation or rehab arc.

5. Relationships: The Broker's Web of Loyalty

League of Villains: His "family." Recruited Toga/Dabi/Twice; loyal to a fault (torture silence). Twice sees him as "swell" (Ch. 271); Tomura demands his release (Ch. 219). Compress/Spinner worry during capture (Ch. 219). Dabi's indifference highlights Giran's neutrality.

Meta Liberation Army: Pure antagonism. Despises Re-Destro/Detnerat as "big business" intruders (Ch. 219). Mocks Skeptic's puppets (Ch. 232), refuses bribes/torture (Ch. 239).

Vigilantes Ties: Business-only with Knuckleduster (supplies, warnings). Kindred spirit with Twice (pre-League guidance).

Overall: Giran values "respect" over cash — won't betray clients, even for survival. In a series of disposable villains, he's the rare one with a code.

6. What Became of Him? The Vague Fate and Fan Theories

Canon Status: Last seen in Gunga bunker during PLF raid (Ch. 271). Heroes block all exits, arrest 16,229 members — Giran is explicitly "not shown among them," but logic dictates capture/imprisonment (no escape feats like Nomu flight). No Tartarus mention (unlike Compress), no post-war cameo (unlike reforming PLF like Re-Destro). Epilogues (8 years later) ignore him entirely — no rehab, no black-market return, no Twice memorial nod.

Why Vague?: Horikoshi's pruning. Giran's arc peaks in MLA torture (loyalty showcase); post-merger, he's redundant (League self-sustains). Vagueness fits his "shadowy" theme — a broker who fades when unneeded. Possible dropped plot: Early Vigilantes hints at deeper backstory (e.g., taser origins), but main series sidelines him.

Theories & Speculation:

Imprisoned & Forgotten: Most likely — low-rank C-villain, no high-threat Quirk. Tartarus overflow or standard jail; post-war reforms might rehab him quietly (like minor PLF).

Underground Return: Slips free via Muddied (blurs memories during raid). Rebuilds black market in chaotic post-war Japan, supplying "reformed" villains or even heroes undercover.

Dead?: Unlikely — Twice's clones saved him from Deika tower (Ch. 240); no raid death panel. But torture scars + age imply quiet fade-out.

Twice Tie-In: As Twice's "friend," he might appear in memorials or Toga's blood echoes, but nothing confirmed.

Fan Wishlist: Horikoshi could retcon a epilogue panel (e.g., Giran brokering peace deals in rebuilding society), but as of Ch. 430, he's a ghost.

7. Thematic Role: The Enabler Who Humanizes Villainy

Giran embodies "the system" — profiting from chaos without causing it. He arms the League but offers kindness (Twice pep-talk), questioning hero society's outcasts. His torture defiance critiques MLA's ideology (freedom via control?). Vague end mirrors real-world brokers: shadowy, disposable.

Legacy: Without Giran, no Toga/Dabi/Twice — League crumbles early. He's the unsung villain MVP, turning misfits into monsters.