#ka asks

Vengeful Pinata Warrior | {Normal}

When you play this, replace another target warrior or item's effects with "When this is destroyed, each opponent draws a card."

When this is destroyed, you draw a card.

My Own Rules Item | {Strong}

If a warrior would win a clash against another warrior, the other warrior wins instead.

It's Me, Bokey! Warrior | {Weak}

{Ace}

When you play this, you can replace target card on the field's effects with target card in a graveyard's effects.

Once per turn, when a warrior attacks a card, you can give that attack target {Underwhelm} this turn. (If it would Decide the Outcome of a Clash, it always loses.)

{Sniper} 1 (When this attacks a player directly, it deals 1 extra damage.)

Bubble Bouncing Invocation

The next card you play from your hand has {Followup}. (You can play an additional card after that one.)

The next card target opponent plays from their hand has {Overwork}. (After they play it, they can't "Play a Card from their Hand" on their next turn.)

Size Shifter Warrior | {Normal}

During your turn, this becomes {Strong}.

During your opponent's turn, this becomes {Weak}.

{Piercer} 1 (When this defeats a card, it deals 1 damage to that card's controller.)

Footwear Exchange Invocation

Swap the effects of two target cards on the field until end of turn. They also both gain your choice of {Piercer} 1, {Underwhelm}, or {Teamwork}.

"Let's walk a mile in each other's shoes!"

Null-Goo Drone Warrior | {Normal}

When you play this, another target card loses its effects as long as this remains on the field.

The Infinity Everything Sword!! Item | {Weak}

{Ace}

This has every effect from every other item on the field and in the graveyards.

Equip this to a warrior. That warrior has every effect from every other warrior on the field and in the graveyards.

-

Deck: Plushies Gimmick: Matching and {Overwhelm}ing enemy cards' strength

Itsy Bitsy Kitty Warrior | {Weak}

{Overwhelm} (If this would Decide the Outcome of a Clash, it always wins.)

{Piercer} 3 (When this defeats a card, it deals 3 damage to that card's controller.)

Crazy Color Chameleon Warrior | {Normal}

{Overwhelm} (If this would Decide the Outcome of a Clash, it always wins.)

{Blocker} (When another card is attacked, you can redirect the attack to this.)

{Inconspicuous} (This cannot be attacked if there are other possible non-player targets.)

Big Bouncy Bear Warrior | {Strong}

{Overwhelm} (If this would Decide the Outcome of a Clash, it always wins.)

Pursue the Perfect Pal Invocation

{Ace}

Search your deck and graveyard for up to two warriors and put them into your hand. You may put one of them onto the field instead if it has the same strength as an opponent's warrior.

Grub Grabbing Gorilla Warrior | {Normal}

After this clashes with a warrior of equal strength, destroy up to one target item and gain 1 life.

Cotton Craving Customers Invocation

Choose {Weak}, {Normal}, or {Strong}. Each player creates a warrior of that strength. These warriors can't attack each other.

Draw a card.

Affectionate Army Ants Warrior | {Weak}

{Pressure} 1 (You have +1 combat tension.)

After this clashes with a warrior of equal strength, if you haven't created a copy of Affectionate Army Ants this turn, create a copy of this.

Button-Eyes Plush Dragon Warrior | {Strong}

{Ace}

Once per turn, after your warrior clashes with a warrior of equal strength, your warrior can attack again this turn.

-

Deck: Gunlance Gimmick: One-time use effects

Rocket Sheller Warrior | {Normal}

{Blocker} (When another card is attacked, you can redirect the attack to this.)

When this attacks or is attacked, you can {Strengthen} it until end of turn. Use this effect only once. (It turns from {Normal} to {Strong}.)

Shrapnel Sheller Warrior | {Weak}

{Followup} (When you play this, you can play an additional card this turn.)

After this attacks or is attacked, you can destroy a card on the field. Use this effect only once.

Shield Plating Item | {Strong}

{Pressure} 1 (You have +1 combat tension.)

When a warrior you control is destroyed, you can return it to the field. Use this effect only once.

Full Reload Invocation

{Ace}

Choose one: -Shuffle your graveyard into your deck, then draw two cards. -Remove all cards you control from the game, then return them to your field. {Strengthen} each warrior you control until end of turn. ({Weak} becomes {Normal}, {Normal} becomes {Strong}, {Strong} gains {Overwhelm}.)

Incindiary Sheller Warrior | {Strong}

To play this, return a card you control to your hand.

{Piercer} 1 (When this defeats another card, deal 1 damage to its controller.)

When your opponent attacks, you can redirect the attack to this. Use this effect only once.

Minefield Wasteland Item | {Weak}

At the end of your turn, {Fumble} target opponent. (Describe an action. If the opponent does that before your next turn, you can Counter Your Opponent's Play for free.)

When this is attacked, destroy the attacking warrior. Use this effect only once.

Burst Sheller Warrior | {Normal}

{Ace}

During your turn, you can play an additional staple. Use this effect only once.

When a card you control is targeted by an opponent's effect, deal 2 damage to that opponent. Use this effect only once.

-

Deck: Money Gimmick: Creating and using {Weak} items.

Bottomless Vault Item | {Strong}

When you play this and at the beginning of your turn, create a {Weak} item.

Your {Weak} items have {Inconspicuous}. (They can't be attacked if there's another possible non-player target.)

Stressed Hoarder Warrior | {Normal}

When you play this, create a {Weak} item.

{Pressure} X, where X is the number of {Weak} items you control. (You have +X combat tension.)

Senior Banker Warrior | {Strong}

{Ace}

When you play this, create a {Weak} item.

Instead of spending advantage, you may sacrifice a {Weak} item for each 1 advantage you would spend.

Wallet Weightlifter Warrior | {Normal}

When you play this, create a {Weak} item.

{Piercer} 1 (When this defeats a card, deal 1 damage to its controller.)

As long as you control three or more {Weak} items, {Strengthen} this. (It turns from {Normal} to {Strong}.)

Bribery Invocation

Create two {Weak} items.

You can sacrifice any number of your {Weak} items. For each one sacrificed, destroy a random card controlled by target opponent.

IRS Agent Warrior | {Weak}

At the end of your turn, {Fumble} target opponent. If the opponent performs the action, you also create two {Weak} items.

{Sniper} 1 (If this attacks directly, it deals 1 extra damage.)

Eat the Riches Invocation

{Ace}

Create a {Weak} item.

Target a warrior you control. Sacrifice all your {Weak} items. For each one sacrificed, {Strengthen} that warrior and give it {Piercer} 1.

-

Deck: This card creation system is kinda fucked up?

Gimmick: Raigeki

Destroy One Invocation

Destroy target warrior your opponent controls. (This is a maximum power, perfectly balanced card according to the card creation rules.)

Destroy All Invocation

Destroy all warriors target opponent controls. (This is also a perfectly balanced card.)

Gain OR Drain Invocation

Choose one: -You gain 1 life. -Target opponent loses 1 life.

Gain AND Drain Invocation

You gain 1 life and target opponent loses 1 life.

So, card creation in Perfect Draw uses a point system with a few metrics. The relevant ones here are "powerful" and "versatile". If an effect gives you card advantage, such as destroying an opponent's card, it's an amount of "powerful" equal to the card advantage it gives. So destroying 1 monster is 1 powerful is 1 point. What about destroying all opponent's warriors? The card creation rules say to assume each player probably has 1-2 warriors on the field, so that's 2 points.

Next is "versatile". Any time a card gives you an additional option, that's 1 versatile, which is also 1 point. "Destroy target warrior" lets you choose which warrior gets destroyed, so it's versatile. 1 versatile + 1 powerful = 2 points. "Destroy all opposing warriors" doesn't give you any choices, so it's 0 versatile + 2 powerful = 2 points.

The Gain/Drain cards are the same way. The OR lets you choose (versatile 1) between effects of powerful 1, for a total of 2. The AND gives you two effects of powerful 1 with no choices, for a total of 2. Technically all these cards are worth 3 points because they're "consistent", but that doesn't change anything; they're all worth the same amount.

Obviously something's not right here. Getting choices can be powerful, yes. Getting to choose which warrior is destroyed is stronger than, for example, if it was random. But the rules treat "getting to choose between 2 effects" and "getting two effects" as equally powerful.

I feel like I MUST be missing something. This isn't some loophole or exploit, it's the basic rules of card creation, applied to dead-simple effects. They can't have messed up something so simple, right? But I can't read the rules in any way that makes "destroy all opposing warriors" as anything other than 2 points, and "destroy target warrior" is explicitly mentioned as being 2 points.

That said: This is the demo version. Maybe it's an early draft, or maybe the full version gets into more detail, or maybe I misinterpreted something. If anyone wants to read through the card creation rules and see if they can make this make sense, or if anyone reading this has the full version, please comment, I want to understand.