One of my biggest issue with Calvinism, is the vanity and callousness of the limited atonement. Calvinism is a theology that really only works (or is appealing in whatever way that people are drawn to it) if you believe that you are part of the 'persevering saints'. In his video the Redeemed Zoomer himself discussing election by saying âyou received a free gift of grace and your neighbor is just receiving what they deserveâ. In context he says that because the gift is undeserved you shouldnât boast or think you are better than others.Â
But I think the fact that he is just casually dropping that his neighbor deserves eternity hell, without really interrogating why your neighbor who lends you their hedge trimmer and brings cookies to every bake sale, deserves an eternal separation from God, is a problem.Â
Is there really a good reason for anyone to suffer if God loves everyone and is powerful enough to save them? If God created people why didnât he just create them good? I mean if God is the ultimate author why write a story with so much suffering? Why leave some zoomers unredeemed? If you knew for a fact that you were NOT one of the elect, would you think the same way?Â
It's easy to say that everyone is deserving of a fate, if you are confident you are exempt. I can joke that itâs okay to eat meat sometimes if Iâd let a shark eat me, but to be clear I really have no plans of letting a shark eat me, and donât think I would make that joke if I regularly swam in the ocean with sharks.
The fact that they would sit and argue that God is fundamentally good, while also saying God randomly choses some people to save and lets others suffer, is crazy to me. Its a level of mental gymnastics that can only be done by someone who is convinced of his own election could really argue. If you knew that you were not chosen, and that God created you and was going to send you to hell for eternity because of the way God made you, would you really still call God loving?? REALLY??
For God to truly be all loving, he must be all redeeming and Calvin can fight me about it.