1) The way Bon speaks to Rosemary does not come off as a romantic lover, rather someone who idolizes her. We know that Bon adores the animatronics, and that he revolves his entire (after)life to them. When Rosemary speaks about designing the animatronics, his reply comes off in a more fan matter, rather than familiarity. This is further emphasized by the fact that Rosemary avoids saying she loves him back. you also can’t claim she stopped loving Jack, since she literally JUST escaped prison and ran backstage to see him.

2) Jack did not want Rosemary to think about him anymore. It wouldn’t make sense for him to then reach out and lure her in with his memory.

3) Jack, for the most part, seems to cope by using lighthearted remarks about when Molly was a child. He does this to try to make Rosemary smile. When Rosemary deploys the same lighthearted remarks, Bon doesn’t understand

4) Jack and Bon do not share the same amount of enthusiasm about the animatronics. Bon idolizes them, calls them perfect, is implied to have KILLED himself to live as one of them, whilst Jack is… normal? Only really comments on the bowtie

5, and the most important) Jack being Chilean is a very important thing to Martin, hence why he voice acts Jack himself to give Jack a Chilean accent. Bon, on the other hand, does not have this accent. For lack of a better way of wording it, I don’t think Martin Walls would have casted Eva in order to whitewash Jack. If he wanted Jack to be Bon, he would’ve voice acted Bon himself. This is specifically about the claim that Bon “sounds” Chilean at the end. Martin would have voiced Bon from the start if he wanted to hint at this

———

2026 // 2023