Hi mortish! Hope everything is going well for you snd your loved ones! So, I've noticed something in the re-write:
Did you tone down the boys "jerkniess" in classic route? 😂
I've noticed a lot of scenes where they're deff less mean than I remember, so I'm guessing you left those to the Dark Maiden version? Hmmm that puts me in a situation... I can say with confidence I LOVE angst, i eat that for breakfest, so I was okay with with their behaviour as long as it was addressed or improved once they went "ohshit i thinl im in love" u know?
Sooo I'm not certain i should go to Dark Maiden..I'm not sure if I'm a BIG dark romance fan. I like stories that make it HURT, but there needs to be consequences, so the couple can grow from it and their love stronger.
SO, tell me, which version should I go for? 😭 The worse it hurts now the sweeter it'll be later, provided its not just the FL taking the shorter end of the stick all the time
It's definitely toned down from the original Bride of Shadows. I actually felt like the original version was pretty tame, but there were a lot of complaints, particularly when it came to misogyny.
In the current version of Classic, they're fairly tame but still douchier than standard romance fare. Valdricht is pretty manipulative, but not in an overt manner. He just says whatever he has to do to manage the MC and sleep with her. Tbh I think a lot of players don't even realize how much of a snake he is. As for Serax, his less savory impulses are curbed by Valdricht who is genuinely protective of the MC. You'll see Serax get more assertive after he's slept with her for the first time, and more abrasive as he competes with Valdricht and eventually Kerach for her attention. Where that abrasiveness is directed depends on your dynamic. The MC can also be pretty toxic in Classic, depending on how she handles Serax and Valdricht's relationship. I'm giving players the option to be a team player or jealous/territorial for either guy.
Dark Maiden is very different from Classic, a lot of players play both routes, assuming they're comfortable with the dubious nature of the DM relationship. The guys aren't very nice in Dark Maiden. They aren't cruel imo, but it's clear that the MC, at least initially, is just a body for them to use. In Dark Maiden, it's actually Serax who is clingier in the early chapters. The MC is kind of like a toy that he and Kerach are constantly fighting over, while Valdricht is like the aloof, mercurial overseer who's somewhat distrustful of the MC. I like Dark Maiden because there isn't really an early bond between the MC and the guys, it's more of a relationship born of desperation that slowly evolves into something more. When it finally does, I think it feels pretty earned, but it depends on how tolerant you are of being objectified/used for most of the first act of the story.
If you're torn between the two, read both. Even most of the dreams are different after the first couple nights, there's really little overlap between the two. The most challenging aspect for players of Dark Maiden seems to be the language barrier.