Black Sheep
Rachel Harrison
Rating: 2/10
Horror Score:🫀/5
Horror type: satanism
Review: Boring and cliche with obnoxious narration.
Maybe it's my fault for not getting along with this book. After all, I read the blurb (protaganist leaves her staunchly religous community at eighteen, returns home for her cousin's wedding, exhumes a terrifying secret and has to confront her own crisis of faith) and assumed I was in for an interesting horror-based critique of religous trauma set in a Christian community. Instead, I got a predictable slog with the main fear-factor being satanism and satan just kind of being there (blah, don't care).
This book had the honestly astounding ability to make me more bored with each new obvious reveal or plot twist. There was no point in the book where I was genuinely surprised, just the slow, inexorable reveal that my high hopes were in vain and what I was reading was a bland amalgamation of milennial cringe and boomer satanic panic.
The main character, Vesper, feels bland, has no clear motive and commits the grave sin of being annoying. She's generally resentful at the world in a way that feels forced. For a few scenes, it seems like her anger and resentment are going to become a big thing, though this anger is never signalled by anything more than the words 'I'm pretty pissed off right now'. Instead, the effects of her rage are mere serendipity on the world around her instead of being a genuinely held or compelling emotion. It's dropped in two chapters anyway, so it doesn't really matter.
(more complaining and spoilers below)












